Skip to content
MSP40: Questions Unanswered episode artwork

Aug 9, 2018 25 min

MSP40: Questions Unanswered

from MSP [] MATTSPLAINED [] MSPx Hosted by KULTURPOP

Today we’re going to speed through a bunch of the questions that Matt gets asked most often. What do the Facebook and Twitter share price falls mean? Should I invest in crypto currency? Where’s my ray gun? It’s time to Mattsplain. Excerpt from Transcript: Because he’s got a one track mind – a recent show on GPS being a good example – we usually tackle one topic at a time on Mattsplained. That generally means there are more things we can’t cover than we can talk about. Today we’re going speed read our way through some of the topics Kulturpop’s Matt gets asked on a daily basis. It sounds a little less depressing than what we do most weeks. It’s time to Mattsplain. Will today be less depressing than what we do most weeks? •No. Covering more topics means I can scare even more people than usual. •I’m hoping it’ll be like watching a Tony Robbins lecture backwards. •You’ll feel a lot more scared and insecure by the end. •I’m going to jump straight in and ask the first question myself, because I’ve been peppered with it this week. •Does the recent fire sale on Twitter and Facebook shock pose any great problems? Does it? •For investors, yes. They’ve lost money. And while those stocks may not dip too much further – I’m not an analyst, you’ll get better advice from the Morning Run crew than from me on that – I don’t know if they’ll soar again in quite the same way. •It doesn’t seem to be the start of a tech sector rout. Apple’s quarterly announcement was very strong, indeed. Even if Huawei now makes more phones than Apple. •But most of us aren’t Facebook or Twitter investors. That’s a really small number of people. •The majority of us, literally billions of us, as far as the markets are concerned, we’re just losers. I mean users. What do you think it means for users? •If you look at it that way round: not very much. •Our day to day use of these services will continue exactly the same. •The real question is: what does it mean to the people governing those companies? •If I was them, I would be scared. Full transcript at http://www.kulturpop.com/pods/

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

MSP40: Questions Unanswered

0:00 25:40
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This is a download from BFM 89.9, the Business Station. It's Fun Friday, my name is Jeff Sandhu. Because he's got a one-track mind, a research show on GPS being a very good example, we usually tackle one topic at a time on Matt's Play. That generally means there are more things we can't cover than we can talk about.

Today, however, we're going to speed read our way through some of the topic Sculchpop's Matt gets asked on a daily basis. It sounds a little less depressing than what we do most weeks on Matt's Play, so Matt, today will be less depressing than the usual show on the fun Friday. Well, you might think so, but no. Covering more topics means that I can scare even more people than usual.

So I'm hoping today we'll be watching Tony Robbins lecture backwards. You'll feel a lot more scared and insecure by the end of it. So I'm going to jump straight in and ask the first question myself, because I've been peppered with this this week. Does the recent fire sale on Twitter and Facebook stock pose any great problems?

Does it? For investors? Sure, they've lost lots and lots of money. And while those stocks may not dip too much further, I'm not an analyst, so you'll get better advice listening to the morning run crew than for me on that.

I don't know if they'll soar again in quite the same way, but it doesn't seem to be the start of a tech sector out. Apple's quarterly announcement this week was very strong, even if Huawei now makes more phones than Apple does. But most of us aren't Facebook or Twitter investors. That's actually a really tiny number of people who are actually actively investing in those companies.

The majority of us, which is literally billions of us, as far as the markets are concerned, we had just losers. I mean, users. So what do you think this means for users then? Well, if you look at it that way round, it doesn't mean very much.

Our day-to-day use of these services is going to continue. It's going to be exactly the same. The real question is, what does it mean to the people governing those companies? And if I was them, I would actually be really scared.

Do you think Mark Zuckerberg will miss the $17 billion US dollar C personally loss? No, because I don't think he's ever looked at those shares as being money. They're a control tool for him. They mean he gets to run the company the way he wants.

I'm guessing that that's worth more than a few billion dollars to him. And I think that's one of the things we miss. We fixate on the estimated worth of these guys. But that doesn't mean that they do.

They already have huge amounts of money. It's just kind of arbitrary numbers after a while. And besides, once you've got a super yacht and you can wear a box fresh hoodie every day of the week, what is their left to spend on? But do you think that confidence issue will worry them?

I think that's going to worry them a lot more than the market optics. In a way, it's like one of those world-breaking domino toppling attempts that come onto the TV every once in a while. The tiles started toppling last year. And they've gone up and down and in and out of obstacles in a way that would make for a really compelling, okay, go, you know, virally.

But we finally reached that endpoint where declining user confidence and trust has tipped over into the financial market. Concerning the Twitter stock fall, quite a few analysts have claimed to be surprised, they're saying things like Twitter's fundamentals are great. It's turning a corner into profitability. And that may actually be true, but those bullish sentiments overlook the user mistrust that we've been talking about this year.

Twitter has announced plans to delete an incredible 70 million fake accounts. That's more than the population of Great Britain. You know, you have to wonder were Twitter and Facebook naive, or did they not care? Or was there some kind of horrible collision of those two facts somewhere in the middle?

What we do know is that a lot of the big social media companies are struggling to maintain growth and attract new sign-ups. At the same time, they're already spreading fake news, is prompting some users to delete or retire their accounts. And potential younger customers, they're just not signing up either. And I think of all the factors that's probably the most worrying for them.

It's amazing to believe that services like Twitter and Facebook could be seen as something for old people, but they are. And although we know that younger generations are much more social, it also appears that they're really resentful of the fact that their parents share their entire childhoods publicly on their social media. So now those kids are at an age when they can get their own social media profiles. They're increasingly opting for networks where they can button down who does or doesn't see their posts.

So we're seeing the increasing importance of applications like WhatsApp, which offer a lot more privacy. The Twitter especially, the rejection of visibility and universality by an entire generation could be incredibly damaging. And I know you've made a decision to stop using Twitter. Well, that is a personal decision, so I'm not going to use the show to soak up for once.

If you're interested, I have put an article up on Medium.com that explains why I've chosen to leave the service and become a quitter. But I think that's probably more than enough about social media. What else is in my untweated questions bag? Yeah, so let's stick with the news verse we touched on this last week.

3D printed guns. Now there have been some arguments that the dangers are overblown and that the guns that's possible to print are actually unreliable, dangerous and quite limited. And all of that is true. Due to the limitations of the plastic composites that we generally 3D print with, any gun that's printed off can really only be used once, at least safely.

It's not very accurate and it probably won't be very reliable. So in a sense, it is a terrible gun. But you don't legislate by looking at the technology you have today. Designing laws and the systems that support them takes a long time.

So you have to legislate by looking at the technology that we're going to have tomorrow. You're worried that allowing these pistols today could lead to an amateur missile tomorrow? Well, yeah, I know that sounds stupid and ridiculous. But it's something that we say on the show over and over.

You think you've got time, but then suddenly the future overtakes you. Look at the data protection laws that the EU brought in this year. We should have had those a decade ago, possibly even longer. So in a very short period of time, we're going to be able to do things in our homes that still require billion dollar production facilities today.

It's been a while since we actually talked about 3D printing. Yeah, I had to stop boring people with it, but my obsession is still the same. Now this won't happen overnight and at first I think we'll see larger-scale machinery and regional staging hubs. Then it will start to move downwards and we'll see big 3D printers in every town or large community before.

Eventually, we start seeing a lot more capable equipment actually in our own homes. So soon, the only thing that will control what you can make at home will be your access to the raw materials, because you'll have all the means of production literally in your garage or the kitchen or wherever. So that means we should be able to control, say, the production of most biological weapons. But once we start being able to print off mental handguns, then there'll be nothing to stop us making guns pretty much any size or calibrate, which just depends on the size of the machine you have at home.

So unless there's a concerted effort globally, anyone, anywhere, will be able to manufacture pretty much any gun or maybe even larger ordnance. And again, I know it sounds stupid, but like heavy artillery systems. But that's assuming that they can actually get the gun powder and also the explosive as well, right? But even that might be a lot easier than it sounds with printers that will be handling the synthesis of medical drugs and other powdered goods, because it'll be very much the kind of similar processes.

We're not going to be able to stop this technology, and because there will be so many users, it's going to be very difficult to control as well. 3D printing is basically going to be like the Instagram of warfare. The only thing we can do is come up with legal frameworks that will address part of the problem and push the blueprints as far into the dark web as we can. Another common question we all get here.

Will AI or robots replace my job? There's a pretty simple answer to that. And the answer is yes. Every single one of us thinks that our role and our job is too important to be outsourced to a machine.

And every single one of us is wrong. Machines may not replace every lawyer or accountant or sales person or DJ or scientist or architect or doctor or writer or designer, marketer, laborer, technician, crafts person, baker, janitor, security guard, police officer, soldier, airline pilot, taxi driver. I think you get the point. So machines will replace most of us then?

Yes. I mean, I still do some of my day job work in the advertising industry, and I was chatting about this to a friend earlier this week. Everyone thinks that because advertising is such a theoretically creative industry, it will be immune to this kind of encroaching technology. But I don't think so.

I can certainly see AI replacing human graphic designers within a few years. Those machines can come up with hundreds or thousands of different variations in the same time that a human design team might be able to come up with half a dozen. So you may still need a creative director to choose which designs are shown to the clients, but you don't need that actual design team. And what's worrying about replacing all the junior positions with machines is that you don't have an obvious route for anyone to develop those leadership or senior management or decision-making skills.

And again, that goes across the board, architects, doctors, scientists, etc. And how clever is AI in human terms? You know, I keep trying to get AI experts to give me an equivalent in human years or an IQ level, and they all refuse. I think this is one of the reasons that we find artificial intelligence so confusing.

We have this need to compare AI to our own intelligence. That's natural. That's our default marker. The AI experts try and avoid doing that because machine intelligence is very different to our own.

It's not an equivalent to human intelligence. And that won't help anyone either. Well, you know, we all know the story about the AI that is the world go playing champion. We've talked about it enough times on the show over the last couple of years.

It can compute thousands upon thousands of variations of moves. It can look thousands of moves ahead and look at all the different combinations. But if you change the dimensions of that go board by even a single line, the machine won't be able to function. It won't be able to play at all.

The analogy I keep using on the show is the six-year-old boy who knows absolutely everything about dinosaurs. Can he make you a sandwich? No. Can he calculate the angle on a triangle?

If he's relatively normal? No. Six-year-old boys are utterly useless unless you want to know about dinosaurs. That's why cats are superior to all children.

And as bad as that analogy is, that's basically what AI is. Okay. A couple of quick ones before we hit to the break. Shall I buy a cryptocurrency?

No. Money is a really odd thing to invest in. If it's fluctuating wildly, then it's very bad at being a medium of exchange, which is its actual job. So the value it possesses is entirely arbitrary and it's driven by the belief in its value, which if you can't use it to actually buy stuff with, makes it pointless as anything except a medium of investment.

So the circle goes round until everyone wakes up and the currency eventually crashes. You may make some money in the short term if you're lucky, but it is very risky because, as a currency, it has to stabilise or be corrected by the market towards its actual value. Can you explain the blockchain? Again, no.

At least not today. I keep promising I will, and I will do a couple of shows on blockchain this next month before the end of the book. Wow, that's a promise. Anyway, when we come back, more of your random technology queries with the Cottapops and Matt's, Mats, B-A-M, B-A-M, B-A-M, B-F-M, 89.9.

And we're back. It's fun Friday together with Cottapops and Matt Amatage. Now, before the break, we rattle through an impressively quick list, quick by Matt's standard. Anyways, our responses to questions were often asked.

Sticking with the AI Matt, we were exploring before the break. Will I be able to marry a robot in the future? Well, I am hoping that's a hypothetical question. That's a good question.

Exactly. There's no specific robot. Right. Before the break, I was saying how different human and machine intelligence is, but that's not to say that machines won't develop some form of sentience or awareness of their own belongings.

So as with 3D guns, we were talking about earlier, these are issues where we should be thinking about and legislating for today, because the reality is probably going to arrive a lot sooner than we think. So we have to come up with these kind of governing frameworks for machine intelligence. Guaranteeing the equivalent of human rights. Well, exactly.

As regular listeners will know, I spent quite a lot of this year talking about sex robots, not because it's an area that I'm that interested in, but because people are asking me to comment on the subject. So in part, this goes towards answering your question about marrying a robot. If you have a sex robot that has intelligence, but it's not self-aware, then that's probably not particularly nice, but it's probably fine. If you have a sex robot that is sentient, but has no control over its own life, then basically what you've created is a slave.

So if we decide as a society that we want machines to become sentient and self-determining and self-aware, I don't see any issue with you and a consenting AI getting hitched, whether the machine has a physical body or it resides in the cloud. If the robot's dumb and it only has a program personality, then yeah, it's kind of gross. I guess we're going to stick with the man machine questioning on this next one. Should I edit my DNA?

Well, this is exactly the same argument as the 3D printing for guns. The technology is cheap and easily available. You can hack your DNA in the comfort of your own home with a few hundred dollars worth of tools. Should you do that?

No, you really shouldn't do that. We're not at the point where we understand what the consequences are. A lot of research is being done, but genetics is an enormous field. It's going to be a long time before we have a really good understanding of what the implications and the consequences of altering our DNA structure are going to be.

Yeah, but I don't think that's going to stop the backroom hackers. No, it's not going to stop them because the technology is already a reality. And again, it's something that we don't have the social framework to deal with. Another example of a place where the rules that govern our behaviour have fallen behind the advances in technology.

Over the next couple of decades, I think we're going to see thousands of people doing themselves potentially enormous harm trying to tinker with their DNA. You can see the potential for abuse in professional sports, for example, or in the increasingly competitive world of education, people hacking themselves to enhance their performance in all kinds of aspects of their lives. We talk about the baritary grown meat on the show and how that freaks people out, especially you. Well, DNA hacking freaks me out in the way that the lab meat freaks other people out.

And one of your current obsessions is screenless technology. But what a lot of people want to know is, how do you actually browse the web without a screen? Well, of course, screenless tech is a bit of a misnomer. It's really an extension of the internet of things.

So at the moment, if you have a lot of smart home devices, you're probably controlling most of them through an app on a smartphone or a tablet. So what we're seeing with systems like Amazon's Alexa, Google's various voice control systems, Siri and a bunch of others is an attempt to take those devices off our screens and control them without voices. Because we've transitioned from storing information on paper to digital screens, and this is the next step, because speaking is one of the most efficient communication tools that we have. So we won't see screens disappearing completely then?

No, what we'll be seeing is that information won't be chained to those digital screens. You're still going to have to write those office reports on Microsoft Office or Google Docs, at least until the machines take your job and write the documents themselves. A lot of the information though that we get, we don't need to see things like the time or the weather news headlines. All of those can be delivered to us by machines that speak.

And a lot of our information searches can also be vocalized with the results being spoken back to us. For listeners who don't believe me, I'll ask you a very simple question. What do I look like? You know, most of you won't know, and most of you won't care.

Speaking is why we still have radio in a world that's full of digital screens, because voices are important. Going screenless isn't so much a forward step, for me anyway, as a correction. We're bringing the machines into line with the way that humans have always communicated, which is my voice. Want it being noisy?

Well, I think that's the next point. We may have to all end up wearing Bluetooth devices or having some kind of ear implant. I don't want to confuse things further by getting into the realm of brain implants and your thoughts directly being transmitted to your communication devices. So let's pretend I haven't mentioned that.

But when you look around your office, how many people spend pretty much the entire day with headphones clamped around? There is. Oh, yeah. It's pretty much everyone.

It's radio special. It's radio special. So I don't think it's going to be a big shift. I think by and large, we've already made the behavioural adaptations that will enable voice control tech to become pretty much second nature.

I think my headphones are just attached to my head. No, really. I was really surprised when you took them off of you, because suddenly your hair's front was like, oh, yeah, Jeff has hair. Now, a long time, listen, I'll be able to be able to get back on the evening edition once you know, where's my re-gun?

Well, at risk of being sued by our drive time colleague, I will admit that he didn't really ask that question. But Jeff and I both know that he really does one. One of the Guardian's tech reporters, a guy called Dave Hall, has a really fun weekly column called They Promised Us, where he tries to figure out how close we're getting to all those must-have sci-fi technology items from our childhood. Things like hoverboards, teleporters, holograms, and of course, that 60s alien invasion staple, the re-gun.

So where is my re-gun? All right, calm down. I've taped one to the underside of your desk, there in case of alien invasion. It actually looks like the re-gun, at least in terms of being a laser weapon, may be a bit of a non-stata, as boring as it sounds conventional munitions, like the ones we can 3D print, are simply more efficient in real-world conditions.

Lasers are pretty easily distracted by smoke, fog, cloud, and all the normal things that warfare throws at weapon systems. No one's really into it, huh? Well, no, every big country's military is still trying to do stuff with the technology, but because of the amount of power that lasers require, it seems like laser weapons are more suited to stationary positions, say, on the decks of a ship, where huge power converters can supply them the energy they need. Certainly, we're not likely to see a Taser-sized laser gun anytime soon.

Laser weapons are also likely to take quite a bit of time to re-power for a second shot, and there's a really high likelihood that they're going to overheat and blow up before you can hit your target in the first place. Well, that's a parry-booburthing, that's a shame, though. Well, you might be worrying prematurely, in terms of destructiveness and high-tech, we're just kind of leap-frogging the laser and making scary progress on some truly kind of shock and all-type weapons. There are microwave weapons that work by heating the water in your skin, so those are mooted mainly for kind of crowd control use, less deadly weapons or whatever they call them, but tests are continuing to see if they cause any long-term damage.

I mean, if you put a piece of chicken in the microwave, you know, there's quite a lot of long-term damage. My favourite are the plasma weapons the US government is supposed to be working on. They literally create lightning and then fire it. Wow.

Yeah, so that uses a different kind of laser, but it excites all the stuff around it, and it fires. Yeah, so it fires lightning at you, and I guess that's the closest that any of us is ever going to get to being, you know, Thor and firing the bifrost at anyone. And of course, work continues into particle-beam weapons, but they still come with the nasty side effect of dowsing you in lethal doses of radiation when you fire them. So they're a bit of a last resort.

Could I make any of these with a tree printer? Well, worryingly, once the technology is out there in the wild, I don't see why you wouldn't be able to make some of them at home. Maybe not today, but within a few generations of the technology, especially, as I said, the microwave weapon, because you already have a microwave using that similar technology sitting there in your kitchen. So it really does make those one-shot 3D printed guns look really primitive, right?

Yeah, so you're all for these nightmarish dystopian pronouncements. Does the future really look that bad? No, I mean, I had another dystopian exchange with a friend over email this last week. A usual damnit.

Yeah, a lot of the time, you know, these futures look dystopian because we look at individual elements. It's one of the reasons, you know, I've been saying we need to find frameworks and codes of conduct for using all of this new technology. The future nearly always looks nightmarish from certain perspectives. If you go back a few hundred years, you imagine some poor peasant wandering out of the bucolic countryside and into the smoke and dirt and pollution of the industrial revolution.

That's nightmarish to that person, but we wouldn't be where we are today unless we'd gone through that. So that's why it's important to know where we're headed and make sure that ours is one of the many hands that's on the tiller that kind of directs society. One final question, and I'm sure this is a question that we get asked most often. What phone should I buy?

It always comes back to that one. How often do you get asked that question? Move. Just today I had two.

Okay. Just today. I haven't had many today because you're one of the first people I've been talking to. You know, you can maybe I should do that.

Yeah, exactly. Not talk to people. You know, you can go into great detail and map out what society might look like in 50 years. And the only thing people really want to know is should I buy the Huawei or the Samsung?

And my answer, as I'm sure yours does, doesn't change. If you buy a phone from one of the well-known manufacturers, the chances are it's not really going to be bad. Blah blah processor, blah blah ram. Really?

Yeah. I don't know what it's meaning. Exactly. Who cares, right?

Look, go into the showroom, test all of the phones they're interested in. The assistants won't like it, but you know, the economy's not great. So if you spend an hour playing with it, they're not going to kick up a fuss because the chances are you're going to be the only person in the store. So forget the specs, like Jeff said, find a phone that you like and it works for you.

The difference is, you know, a really subtle. Some manufacturers do better cameras. Some manufacturers have better screen resolution. So on the stock operating system versus the custom ones.

Find a phone and a price that makes you happy. Yeah. I can't tell you what that will be. So trust your own judgment.

All right. So we've gone quite a few questions and a lot of 3D printing. Very unusual, a little bit fun, actually not so miserable. A little bit fun, a little bit fun, a little bit fun, still dystopian, still pretty scary and future looks pretty bleak still, but better than usual.

Anyways, we'll stick around because we've got geeks go after this. Also you can check out kotrapop.com for transcripts of the shows and you can find out how to bring the dystopian mat into your company, a little bit of mat screening to your company. We'll be right back after this, give a good night. Thank you for listening to this podcast.

To find more great interviews, go to bfm.my or find us on iTunes, bfm89.9, the business station.

The MSP Show The Digital Nomad Podcast Where can you turn to speak with the movers and shakers in the IT industry? The MSP Marketing Show is your source for up-to-date business info. MSP Unplugged Paco Lebron MSP Unplugged is the weekly podcast for growing MSP owners running shops under $1M with 10 or fewer techs. Each week, our hosts sit down with MSP owners, operators, and the vendors who serve them for real, unfiltered conversations about what's actually working: growing revenue and landing better clients, cybersecurity, AI and automation, sales and marketing, and leading a team without burning out. Watch on YouTube or listen wherever you get podcasts. Business of Tech: Daily MSP News & IT Services Analysis MSP Radio, Dave Sobel, Managed Service Provider (MSP) Industry Analyst Vendors are rewriting the rules on MSPs faster than anyone can track — pricing, partner programs, liability, and now AI. Business of Tech is the daily MSP news briefing that tells you what changed and what it means for your business.Every weekday, channel veteran Dave Sobel picks the MSP and IT services news that actually moves your margins, contracts, and risk, and answers the one question that matters: Why do we care? No vendor cheerleading and no press-release rewrites — independent analysis for managed service providers, IT services leaders, and the vendors who sell to them.Short daily episodes keep you current in about 15 minutes. Longer interviews go deep with MSP owners, investors, analysts, and channel executives on where the managed services market is heading.What this MSP podcast covers:• AI for MSPs — AI pricing and consumption billing, AI liability and governance, and AI agents in the service desk• MSP pricing and profitability — per-user vs. usage-based pricing, margi SMB Community Podcast: Business Advice for Small MSP Owners Dave Sobel, Amy Babinchak, Small Biz Thoughts, James Kernan Running a small MSP means being the CEO, the sales team, the HR department, and the escalation tech — usually in the same afternoon. The SMB Community Podcast is where MSP owners get straight answers on the business side of running an MSP.Every week, Amy Babinchak, and James Kernan — MSP owners and advisors from the Small Biz Thoughts community — take on the questions small MSP owners actually ask: How should I price? When do I hire? Should I give a proposal at the first meeting? What is my MSP worth? No vendor pitches and no theory — practical advice from people who have run, grown, and sold IT businesses.What this MSP podcast covers:• MSP sales and client growth — the MSP sales process, proposals, price objections, referrals, local marketing, and choosing a CRM• MSP pricing and agreements — MSP pricing models, single plan vs. tiers, price increases, managed service contracts, margins, and cash flow• Leading an MSP team — MSP hiring, tech compensation and commissions, accountabil

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of MSP [] MATTSPLAINED [] MSPx?

This episode is 25 minutes long.

When was this MSP [] MATTSPLAINED [] MSPx episode published?

This episode was published on August 9, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this MSP [] MATTSPLAINED [] MSPx episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.