Skip to content
My AI Agent Failed at Ordering a Sandwich episode artwork

Oct 30, 2026 15 min

My AI Agent Failed at Ordering a Sandwich

from Fix My Business

Scott’s AI agent made a phone call. It lasted 11 seconds. It was a disaster. The setup: Flying from Buffalo to South Carolina, Scott ordered a sandwich online from the cafe at the FBO so he could do a quick turn. Between frequency changes and air traffic control, he hit confirm — and realized he’d ordered a cheese sandwich. No turkey. The attempt: From 8,000 feet on Starlink, he asked his AI agent to call the number on the receipt and fix the order. The agent refused the number on the receipt — not the published business number When it used the published number, its own guardrails blocked the call It finally got through and asked which voice to use The transcript: “Hello, this is Sue.” “Hi, this is Haley calling on behalf of Scott Todd. I’m transcribing our call for notes. Could you please check whether his online—” Hung up. Sue didn’t want to talk to an AI. It’s a robocall. When was the last time you stayed on the line for one? Scott ended up making a Wi-Fi call himself. Sue was happy to help — she just didn’t want to talk to a machine. The hype problem: X is full of people showcasing AI agents making outbound calls — cancel subscriptions, call the cable company, call the airline. Scott’s take: his cable company calls him every week. These are solutions to problems that don’t exist. The urban legend: Earlier this year, a client told Scott about a technologist who had AI agents making outbound calls and buying properties with no humans involved. The client felt left behind. Scott told him not to worry about it. In August, Scott sat next to that technologist at an event. He asked directly. “Yeah, no. That’s not true.” They ran thousands of calls. The results were terrible. Maybe a property or two. They killed it. From a deal or two to “this is the way forward” is a big gap. Where it does work: Scott’s land marketplace gets voicemails daily — “I’m looking for six acres in this area.” The team can’t help; they’re a marketplace, not an agency. Those calls used to be archived and forgotten. Now AI calls back, explains how the marketplace works, and points the person to the right path. The calls last about a minute and they’re well received — because it’s a response to someone who reached out, and it’s help, not a pitch. The principle: Know what tools exist. You don’t have to own the pressure washer — you just have to know there’s such a thing when the job calls for one. Then identify the real problem in your business, and bring the tool to that. Not the other way around. Link in the description to send Scott your business question.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

My AI Agent Failed at Ordering a Sandwich

0:00 15:28

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fix My Business?

This episode is 15 minutes long.

When was this Fix My Business episode published?

This episode was published on October 30, 2026.

Can I download this Fix My Business episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.