NEW - Throwback Thursday: The Music Pirates Lost. The Artists Still Lose

Everybody who built an MP3 library remembers the tools. Winamp, Napster, the slow crawl of dial-up giving way to broadband fast enough to actually steal music in bulk. This one walks through 1999, the year Napster broke open, and 2001, the year it got shut down for it, with torrents picking up right where it left off. What replaced it didn't exactly clean up its act first. Spotify spent its early years grabbing tracks from torrents before streaming rights caught up to it, paid its fines, and turned into the giant it is now. Apple sold songs for a buck twenty nine, then made that whole model worthless overnight with an $11.95 monthly price. Bandcamp comes up as the one holdout, still selling MP3s of indie tracks too weird for the auto-copyright bots. Streaming won the legal fight. The royalties argument never got resolved, it just stopped being loud enough to notice. Topics: Napster history, MP3 piracy, Spotify royalties, Bandcamp, Winamp Originally aired on 2026-06-18