Skip to content
Nine and Fairfax Merge episode artwork

Jul 26, 2018 1 hr 4 min

Nine and Fairfax Merge

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

Shock waves were felt around the country this morning with the news that Channel Nine and Fairfax are merging. To unpack what this means for journalism and for Fairfax we have a bumper edition with Darren Goodsir, Emily Watkins, Amanda Wilson, Marcus Strom, Tim Burrowes, Darren Davidson and David Skapinker.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Nine and Fairfax Merge

0:00 1:04:25
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails that keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.

That's how we protect Ontario for all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca. Pay for it by the Government of Ontario. Hello and welcome.

You're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism. Coming to you from 2CR and Sydney on Gadigal Lands of the Aurora Nation. Right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Peter Frei and I should say at the top of the hour that I am a former and very proud former employee of the Fairfax Company.

And the reason why I'm mentioning that is well, did you feel the earth move this morning? Deep and long lasting media fault lines in this country not only moved today, but two of the major lines joined and became one, well, subject to approval by the Government Regulator. With the opening of the stock market this morning came the announcement of the merger of Channel 9 and Fairfax. The new company, to be called 9, is reported to be the largest media company in the country with a combined value of $4.2 billion.

The media assets now under one umbrella are quite staggering. They are Channel 9, there's any morning herald, the age, domain, stand, 9 now, 2GB and the list goes on and on. And that's not to mention our good friends in the regions and in the bush. Well, the numbers may add up for the bean counters, clearly they do.

What does this all mean for media diversity and more importantly for journalism in this country? To discuss this, I will be joined by a smorgasbord of people to help us make sense of this rather historic day. And joining me are David Scupinger, the industry analyst with Tella Media, Emily Watkins, the media editor of kraiki.com, Marcus Strom, the Federal President of the Journalist Union, the MEAA. Darren Goodser, former City Morning Herald editor, Amanda Wilson, former City Morning Herald editor, Darren Davidson, the media editor at the Australian and Tim Burrows, Founder and Content Director of Mumbra'la.

Welcome one and all. Well, we're joined on the fourth state by Darren Goodser, a former editorial supremo of the Fairfax Group. Hello, Darren, thank you for your time. Hello, Peter, how are you?

I'm very good, I saw slightly some a day, of course. I guess not to start with some sentiment, but I think it's possible a little bit more than sentiment. One of the things that's happened today, of course, is that the name Fairfax we are told will no longer exist in the news media landscape in this country. As I say, that's a sentimental thing, there's a lot of 170 plus years of history in that name.

And it was ended with this, these words from Greg Highwood. Thank you, thanks everyone for their contribution to Fairfax. I think it was all to you and me and that as well. So Greg Highwood killed the name today.

What about the culture or the legacy or the ongoing legacy of Fairfax? Can that be killed so easily? So it is a very sad day in terms of the demise of the Fairfax name. And like you perhaps Peter, I'm dealing with a range of emotions in the wake of what is on any assessment of momentous announcement.

But I reflect on how many times people, organisations and powerful politicians and business leaders have sought to dismantle or take apart the journalistic fundamentals that have long been part of the Fairfax stable. I thought recently of the Gina Reinhardt, a people on the board and the purported takeover in various attempts to tamper with the with the substance that's in the newsroom. In the metropolitan cities and in the regional and country centres of Australia and it hasn't worked today. And I have every confidence that those fundamentals will continue under whatever ownership flows from this merger stroke takeover announced today.

What do you think it means potentially for Australian journalism? There's a lot of speculation on day like this, of course. But what do you think it means? So when thinking about this, I think about where Fairfax was when Greg Highwood assumed the leadership of the company in early 2011.

And the share price got to mid 30 cents as I recall and it really stood on the precipice of collapse. And that in itself would have had devastating consequences for the diversity and the richness of Australian journalism. So for Fairfax to have survived and got itself into a position where it is even a takeover target is a remarkable achievement in a corporate sense. And needs to be, I think, remembered amid all of the very, very emotional and understandable and legitimate commentary that comes out on an occasion like today.

So the test will be whether or not the journalism in a continue or hopefully, and perhaps this is a naive view, even be strengthened by such a consolidation. Yeah, I mean, let's not get too somber in one sense in that, I mean, Channel 9 has done some wonderful journalism, continues to do some wonderful journalism. It's not as if, I mean, some people portray this as a sort of a, the stage of thinking person's organisation called Fairfax being taken over by some crazy tabloid people. It's not that really, is it?

Like Fairfax, and like most publishers' times, obviously fairly larger, are much more than publishers today. Nine facing the chain collapsing revenues in that realm has partnered with Fairfax over the last five years to, is no bad thing. Well, I think you made a fair point there that, you know, Channel 9, you must have said that Channel 9 is most interested in stand and domain. So two questions that flow from that I think, one is to what extent do you think that the floating out of domain has played a role in this in so far as it showed that Fairfax is not just a bunch of, dead or dying, you know, silly old journalism things.

And two, that the successive stand, and the seeming success of domain shows that there is, if you like, a different culture or corporate culture in Fairfax and therefore they're not so far apart, because when you think about, you know, in the days when Packer was going to buy Fairfax, was this massive cultural clash that in large part prevented that from happening? I'm sure there's going to be lots of cultural differences between the two stables to surmount, or to reconcile. There's no doubt there are massive differences between the two houses when it comes to their approach to publishing, and perhaps even in terms of corporate disposition as well. And Fairfax in the last decade also has had to rely or find alternative revenue streams not to cross subsidise the journalism so much as to appease its shareholders who were seeking legitimate returns on their investment.

So firstly the company invested in things like Trade Me, then there were stays, and then the resurrection of domain to become a digital powerhouse in the real estate market. All of these things helped to, I suppose, keep the walls at bay over the last decade when it comes to the potential corporate collapse of Fairfax. Both you and I work at universities now, and we come face to face with those wonderful things called students. And these students, younger people, are seeing, and younger people in journalism are seeing this massive merger, and hearing people like us talk about it, how do we make them optimistic about the future of journalism in this country, in the light of things like this happening?

Well, in the University of New South Wales for a year now, and the sad part of publishing in a traditional sense is that major newsrooms are becoming smaller and therefore less able to cover with as much depth, and as comprehensively the subjects that they traditionally were able to. That's a given. I think any debate on media has to concede that. But there are also other organizations and individuals, universities among those who are also seeking to do their bit to fill the void created by the collapse in the traditional business model that has underpinned journalism for the last century or so.

So it's a different type of journalism, and I think it's still too early to tell how that's going to play out. It's just different, but certainly there needs to be strong, authoritative, independent voices to report on, to educate, to inform, and to entertain increasingly divergent audiences. I think one of the things I'm struck by in recent times, Peter in journalism is traditional newspapers had an appeal that was an inch deep and a mile wide, and I think rightly or wrongly the digitally has provided the ability to nourish audiences that are an inch wide and a mile deep. So there are incredible niches now developing in journalism to satisfy increasingly specialist needs.

Now, whether that's enough to compensate for the decline in mass media is another question altogether. Yeah, no, I think you make a really very good point, and if you like to be optimistic about the future of journalism, I think there is. There are lots of opportunities in those exploring those niches and understanding audiences in a much deeper way. Just going so finally on the Fairfax Nine merger, again speculation perhaps, but the talk already is of a $50 million saving.

Now you and I have been through plenty of cost savings at Fairfax. $50 million in a merge entity of $4.2 billion frankly doesn't seem like a lot of money. You've got any initial thoughts about that? I mean, Eric, for instance, as always speculate, it's more like $100 million.

You know, I'd say this is speculation, but these are sorts of things that people want to know because $1 equals jobs obviously. Yeah, well, the Fairfax story of the past nearly 10 years has been a reduction in the cost base of equivalent, you know, approximately 10% per year each and every year in line with the commensurate decline in revenue. Now that this merger has taken place, you would hope that the savings would predominantly come from areas that are away from the front line of reporting, at least initially. It would be fairly abrupt to see to the journalistic elements of this merger, at least, you know, in the immediate aftermath of it actually happening.

You would hope that the horrible phrase synergies is able to be realised in other areas to achieve those cost savings that have been highlighted in the announcement today. Yeah, no, let's hope so. Final question for both of us really. We can walk around and we can introduce ourselves as former Fairfax editors, but that's been a few years time.

Actually, people go, what? Fairfax, what are we going to call ourselves mate? Former HACS who were privileged to work in a fantastic organisation whose DNA will hopefully prevail proudly in this virginity. Let's hope so.

Thank you so much for your time. Thanks so much Peter. Bye bye. So joining us now, we have the wonderful Amanda Wilson, former editor of the City Morning Herald, a great friend and great colleague.

Hello, Amanda. Hello. Well, you deserve it all. And Emily Orkins, who I was about to say one for but she is wonderful.

She's from Craggy. She writes about media and she's a regular guest on the Fourth Estate. Thank you for coming in. Thanks.

It is a momentous day and so let's kind of go with a big question first. If this merger goes ahead, it will, as we all know, change the media landscape in this country forever. Simple question for it, better or worse? Amanda?

That is a, I think it's all right to change the lands of journalism options that are available to people like me who are now out there consuming, and subscribing, and reading and watching. And that's, I think, kind of making things moving on. And as everybody who has observed me, people try to survive and continue to pay for creation of content and journalism. So really the fundamental, I don't actually care that the City Morning Herald has done for years and so long as they preserve the stories that the AFR produces as opposed to what the City Morning Herald and the Aged produced.

No, and I think you're right. I think you've touched it right on the button there. Emily, what do you think? It is speculative, of course.

I mean, the country, weighing up the country commentary so far and acknowledging that journalists in particular are prone to the half glass empty kind of look at the world would point to a negative, but there could be positives in scale, surely? Well, yeah, I mean, that's something we've got to think about. What would have happened to Fairfax if it didn't scale up in some way? Last year there were talks with the two different private equity groups looking at purchasing Fairfax that didn't go ahead.

So I mean, there's always that question, what would happen if it didn't merge or be acquired by the finalist? It would be as long as Fairfax as the most. Exactly. Yeah.

And I mean, as I said, we don't really know how true it is that 9 is going to continue to invest in those mastheads. I mean, they might very well invest more and there might be a lot of benefits to the scale and the advertising money that can come in through that scale. I mean, I think any lack of diversity is always a concern. And this is the key question.

It's sort of whether these various mastheads, as you said, as well, these various masthead and entities under this one big umbrella are delivering different things to different people at different times and different ways, all those sorts of questions. You look at what top journos have to work and collaborate with, for example, the ABC, Paul Corners in order for them to resorting to travel around the country to do the investigations they're doing or to go overseas to cover stories. That kind of thing has been happening more and more. And I reckon it's one of the few reasons they're able to afford to keep people like a top person, because of these collaborations.

So you could look on the positive side and say, so combining the newsroom resources of 9 and potentially they can do some incredible work, which means the ABC won't be collaborating. Well, yes, I mean, I don't know when saying anything, but surely the ABC collaborations are over. I think that's a real loss too. If that's true.

If you think about some of those investigations, some of over the past few years have been some of the most substantial and important investigative journalism done in this country in recent years, and I think it would be a real shame if we would lose that. I mean, I can't imagine some of those reports being on 60 minutes or a current affair, for example. So I'm just looking at the results of, as we're talking as talking to the Fairfax RTS, and I quote, independence of what we do is not under threat. What do you think of that?

Live radio, all that stuff. What do I think? I think that the claims of independence at Fairfax Campaign and the Campaign. Independent, not always, not.

That's right. And I think nobody believes that it's proof that in the pudding, if you produce the goods and they're wonderful, they're independent, they're strong, they're great journalism and they win awards, and they change things. They cause royal commissions to happen. Yes, that's good.

That's independent. So he can say that as much as he likes. I don't think people like the Board of Fairfax deeply understand what we journalism are you. The Board of Fairfax is about shareholder value and their own value.

Surely it's not their own value. Their own value would be a very big thing. I'm sure some of the executives stand to profit. I understand that one executive who won't name just shares fair her blushes is going to walk out with $32 million.

We should have stayed on, Amanda. IDP, we never had the airport. No, we never. $32 million is never an option for us.

No, no, tell us. Let's talk about Greg Hywood. Greg Hywood will be remembered, rightly or wrongly, as the man who did want a Packer or a Murdoch never managed to do, and that is to kill off the name Fairfax. Do you think that's who we remembered?

Yeah, I can't imagine any other way he would be remembered if this goes through, and even if for some reason that I imagine it will go through, I think he would still be remembered for at least trying to do this. I can't imagine anything else that he would be remembered for. Which is a sad, I mean, putting aside, that's what is his slightly cold character. He has done and he has made a great contribution to Australian journalism to be remembered as the man who killed off Fairfax in name.

Possibly as a little unfair. What do you think? What do you think Emily would be better than that? Well, it's a hard world.

Yeah, I mean, most people in public life can be reduced to one or two things that they're mostly remembered for. That's what I mean. Greg Hywood will be remembered. Well, because I think journalists are the only people who are going to keep his name alive in any way, that's exactly how they will remember him.

They will describe his efforts over the years to keep the company profitable, which involved losing 5,000 staff. Well, I think since we've had this stuff, we're for it. Not that's not 5,000 journalists at that time. They're not all journalists yet.

Yeah. So, you know, flashing and burning, constant restructures, promising that this is it. We care about quality, we care about independence, and this is it. This is going to be great again.

And then six months, you know, end of financial year comes, and Bob's your uncle there, having another redundancy round. And I mean, one of the really strong parts of Fairfax, in my view, has always been their rural and community and regional news. And I think that's one of the most important parts of journalism that we city journalists often forget. And that's the important part of local news gathering at a super local level.

And I read it not so long ago that private equity company was circling around the Fairfax regional pages after they cut something like $700 million out of that business to keep it afloat in the last couple of years. So, Greg has been a champion of cutting, shrinking, downsizing, shareholder value. And as far as I'm concerned, that he's been quite successful at that. But it hasn't actually done much to preserve the true value of the company.

Yes. You think the true value of the company, i.e. the journalism, has survived despite him? Well, that'd be a way of putting it, Pete.

And I think it's because of the passion, commitment, dedication, and bloody mind of the people who not only remain at Fairfax, the journalists and the photographers and the artists and whoever. But also the young people coming up who've joined because they believe in what it stands for. And they've been desperately peddling as fast as they can to try and keep that side of the business afloat. And not always succeeding.

You can't face a whole business on Kate McInland and Del Fergusson. No, I mean, what's your take on that? I mean, you are young, young, young, you know, I say it, you know, I say it, you know, I say it, you're with Amanda. Sorry.

Up and coming, you know, ambitious journalists. When you see things like this, and for people like the students I teach, is this, when you look at this and go, gee, this journalism light really is kind of on its last legs. Yeah, I think it's really demoralising. I mean, I graduated from my degree more just over 10 years ago, I suppose.

And even then, I mean, we had very un... I won't say uninspiring, but pessimistic probably tutors and lecturers about the future of the industry. I did not change that. You know, about the future of the industry, even back then.

And I think it takes a lot of passion and ambition for a young journalist to actually want to pursue a career in this industry when, you know, those outlets that you sort of look up to and journalists that you look up to at outlets that are cutting and cutting and cutting. Can I finish on a little optimistic note? Amanda sort of gave us a hint on this. Out of this reorganisation, there may emerge new opportunities in the market.

And there was mentioned, as you mentioned a man about regional maybe being sold off. And there's talk today about the radios, of course, being sold off. So Emily, stick with you. Do you think there could come out of this new players in this news media, and therefore there might be increased diversity?

Absolutely. I mean, I wouldn't rule it out. And I mean, in recent years, there have been a lot of digital players coming onto the market in Australia, which does increase the diversity. But I think the problem with that is that you don't have the institutional knowledge and the historical knowledge of sub-itaters and those sorts of people and photographers on the desks, but then you also don't have rounds of people with good historical knowledge, which is incredibly important to not just the big massed heads, but like Amanda and you have both touched on, but the local and the regional papers as well, which their facts has a lot of.

So, I mean, sure, there might be other opportunities that come up for younger journalists that have some great ideas, but I'm still, I find it hard to be optimistic about the future of regional and local journalism. Well, my advice to everyone is subscribe to Crikey, of course. And I, well, this, do you think just on this final point, Amanda, do you think part of this whole story and not to get too retrospective about it? Because that's the easiest thing to be, you know, yesterday's editor sort of thing.

But is it, does it stem from either the way, Fairfax, gave away its content in the beginning news at the beginning of the digital revolution and be whether it's got much to do with the willingness or otherwise of people to pay for news content? Look, I know, I'm not, I'm not, um, well, blindsided by the incredible bonds of Google and Facebook, and they, no matter what you do, no matter how great your call is the advertising dollars. So, you know, if you're, if you're an organization, say you're a small arts organization, a weekend section of the Herald and the Age, if you're from that, and have an ad on Facebook, you know, you're going to do the cheaper, more successful option, and you're going to get funds on seats at your art event, right? And you can advertise all you like in Spectrum and you might get 100 readers with great hair.

So, not to do, not to do that, they're fine, they've got money. They buy drink at lunchtime. Yeah, they do, they do all of those things. So, it's, it's just happening everywhere, and I think this isn't inevitable, and we may see others of similar nature forming and then, and then, unforming or reforming.

I mean, it's just a changing world. The same way we're going to see print must, it's appearing because you think nine will pay the enormous cost of printing newspapers? Well, is this a death of print in terms of effects? Yeah, I mean, not that many people read print anyway anymore, it's like a count of a book.

Yeah. Round, I would afford. Yeah, it's a final point on that, do you think this is a death of print for effects? I really hope not, but yeah, I think we just need to wait and see.

Yeah, well, there is a lot of wait and see here, and I'd like to thank Amanda Wilson, former editor of the City Morning Herald, and for your erudite comments as ever, thank you. And I'd also like to thank Emily Watkins from Craigie, for popping along to the studio, and, and end of what is a seemingly busy day for a media editor, thank you. Thanks, Peter. Thanks, Peter.

Restless, the death of David Dungay Jr. is a new podcast from Guardian Australia and 2SCR 107.3. It explores an indigenous death in custody from the point of view of the family. They didn't have to do what they had done, they could just let him make his biscuits.

Just hours after his death, corrective services released a statement saying his death was not suspicious, but David's family has seen the footage. He's saying I can't breathe, I can't breathe, they're saying I'll get talking so you can breathe. Subscribe to Restless, wherever you get your podcasts. We're joined now by Darren Everson, the media editor from the Australian, you've had amazing day-out of measurement.

Yes, very busy indeed. This is one of the biggest media deals happening in the local enforce, some time probably since Kerry Stokes and seven that worked at their reverse takeover of Western Australian newspapers. Yes, that's right. In terms of subsides of the deal, dollar value and magnitude and potential to reschepe, I should say, the local media industry, this is the biggest one since.

And that's my first question. It's will, if it goes ahead, subject to ACC approval, but if it goes ahead, this will change the media landscape in this country forever. Will it be for better or worse? Tough question I know, a bit speculative, but what do you think?

Yeah, I mean, it depends on if you just, they would say it's a positive development because the combined entity will have more scale and will be able to better compete with Facebook, Google, only giants making very aggressive, encouraged, the local advertising market. They're not only dominating the share of our dollars, but they're taking 100% of all new investment in digital ad dollars. And actually, we'll meet your companies are moving to more into digital and that's where all the growth is. And that's why I have consumer's are consuming content, I'm sticking on smartphones.

From that point of view, advertisers are happy to either say the company will have better chance of prospering in the future. It's got more revenue there for it. It's very chance of survival, of course. Yeah, but the downside I fear will be that they'll cut jobs and they'll cut German jobs.

And I also fear for the future of print as well. I'm a Fairfax now. I mean, I was actually looking at some comments by a few months a year ago. I spoke to him on the conference call this morning about the deal.

He sort of skirted around that and said, well, you know, we're sort of made vague and it's... And he's going to see how the new entities are going to go too well. And they're going to cut print that means cutting down. Well, maybe it may be it bored down to, and again, speculation, but maybe it bored down to, in the end, Greg Highwood, who's roots are deep in print.

He could have bring himself to do whatever he said he was going to do a few times. And that was to actually kill off print and it needed a hard-nose DV guy like Marx to do it. Yeah, maybe. But I'm a student who's lost.

He's been acting in the last couple of years. He has got back behind the print newspapers. And, you know, I've got to talk a few years ago about going print-homey at weekends and digital-only during the week. And he actually wrote back from that, realized there was still a lot of profit left in print.

And it was supporting the digital side of the business, which doesn't monetize as well at the moment, particularly with Dr. Oppling, Google and Facebook and Mark. And he got back behind them and then he did the print deal last week before. Yes, that was interesting.

And I was wondering about that. What do you think? I mean, it seems to me that Fairfax has done three things in the recent past that made it actually, if you like, a more better-suited bride for nine. And they would be, you know, the deal on Stan and then the floating of domain.

And then, as you say, the last couple weeks ago, the print merger. All this sort of hard stuff. Do you think they were kind of key bits in making Fairfax the bride look that much more appealing to nine? Absolutely, it's being domain.

And I'm looking for a company on the stock market. And the print deal and the print deal, the outside from that for down on nine. So it takes a lot of cost out of the business. I think the annualized savings is $15 million.

There's no duplication on truck routes. It's called print their papers in some markets. It's mainly in the South Wales and Queensland. They're doing that.

So yeah, they were precursors too, too, too. And I did wonder when I saw the print deal, I was talking about that. Some kind of activity with him and we have been hearing rumors and writing stories over in talks. But yeah, the main is, you know, as you alluded to, it's the crown jewels.

And you can see how they'll promote promotion on nine, you know, very highly rated television panels. And what they'll do is they'll be off lots of it. And they just, you know, they'll... Yeah, well, I was wondering about that.

I mean, I know it's not necessarily a river gold so much as a silver stream. But, you know, as we heard today, the probably market in Melbourne, Sydney is going off. Isn't that a bad omen for domain? Yeah, commonly.

So what it means for a company like domain or real estate.com, which is owned by REA group owned by my company. It means that ads stay on site longer because the hardest is out. So, you know, sometimes a very hot market is not necessarily different for these big problems. It's because the ads just come off really quickly.

That's a good point. I'm going to steal that point. That's a good point. Can I ask you one final question?

Sure. So, going back to Greg Highwood. In fact, Greg Highwood will be remembered as rightly or wrongly, I think. But if he will be remembered as the man who did what a Packer or Amer.net quite managed to do.

And that is he killed off the name Fairfax. There's a lot of talk about the death of this actual word Fairfax in the values that it embodies. What do you think about that? It's the same to see that go.

I think at the same time, the market has got to retain their names. I'm going to consume a buy, a Fairfax paper. They don't buy agents. They buy Harold.

They buy the age of the buy. The AFR. Whereas with nine, I think it's probably more important for them to keep their call. You know, you switch channels to channel nine.

You buy nine and that name itself. It's a very vulnerable name in the Australian media market. So, kind of sad. But I think the newspaper in my head's have more power than the Fairfax name does in the local market.

In their local communities. But Harold, what Greg, be remembered? I don't think he's going to be remembered by staff. I mean, today, as we talk now, there's a protest about to be organized at Fairfax by the Ami Double A in the climate.

There's very well known high profile. The investigation is going to be there speaking about it. It's pretty sharp coming to that, Greg. It's nice to be done.

It's nice to be done on again as I have done in the last couple of years. But, you know, those newspapers, you know, have a, you know, just give them a longer lease of life than maybe, you know, in time, he will be looked at someone who has very tough, you know, part and past decisions. But, yeah, I don't think in the short term future he's going to be remembered in a very fun way. That's for sure.

I guess it won't worry him that much. I think it's going to be quite about this financially. Yes, he certainly could sit on an island somewhere carrying his money. All right, mate.

Thank you so much for your time. I know you had a super busy day and keep up the good work. Great speaker. All right.

So, Michael Stroll, the Federal President of the MEAA and brackets journalism section. And thank you so much for joining us on this day. Thanks for having me, Peter. This is, well, we're the start.

The end of the name Fairfax is, carries a lot of weight and sentiment. Is this the day that, in a sense, quality journalism died in this country? That's possibly another statement. Yeah, I think it is.

But it's what the name represents and what the name represents is a commitment to independent quality journalism. And that's why everyone is worried about that. Is this the beginning of an obituary for that? Or, that's really up to us.

It's up to the union. It's up to our members. It's up to the public to demand investment in independent quality journalism. And that will take pressure on the government.

It also takes people subscribing to and watching and consuming that sort of journalism as well. Yeah, I mean, we can, there'll be lots of ways of thinking about what's happened today. From your point of view, obviously you're interested in your members and as you just said, quality journalism. Have you had any assurances from any company involved in this merger?

From nine or Fairfax? No, we have not had any formal communication with them. So, so you had no forewarning? No.

Despite the fact we're in the middle of an enterprise agreement discussion with Fairfax, we had no forewarning. I think we've been told informally that's because of the market sensitivity around it. Right. So, but it was announced on the Today Show, wasn't it?

I'm not sure. First I heard of it was the lead delegate at Fairfax rang me about three minutes after even on the ASX. Yes. So, what does this get to the chase in terms of what the union wants?

What does the union want now? So, we have written to the CEO of both companies. We're seeking a number of assurances from them. The first one is if the merger goes ahead or the takeover goes ahead, we want to make sure that the charter of editorial independence applies across the merged entity.

Hugh Marks from nine, who's I think I read on the Guardian blog, has already said that he's got no problem with that. So, that's encouraging to some extent. But we want to make sure that there are no cuts to journalist jobs across the combined entity. And we want to make sure there's increased investment from any savings they make into journalism.

And we also want to make sure that our members pay in entitlements continue over into any new entity. As the first step from the union to call on the ACCC to block it? Yes. So, we're going to write to the ACCC.

We want the ACCC to knock this on the head at the moment. In December last year, Scott Morrison, the Treasurer, asked the ACCC to launch an inquiry into the impact that digital platforms are having on the media landscape. They inquiry is underway. So, we think it's premature that for the ACCC to give the nod to a merger of this scale, when it hasn't even considered the implications of what digital platforms have had on the media landscape.

So, we want that process to go through. Well, and at the same time, though, of course, on the flip side of that, really, I suppose, is that this merger was enabled by the legislation of changes to the cost of media and the 75% rule that came through last year. So, this is a merger that has a reason out of a government's legislation. Yeah, and the Prime Minister probably said that this morning that they're almost taken credit for it.

I think this is irresponsible. We did say this at the time that mergers of this nature would really limit the diversity that exists in the media, and that's dangerous for society. Given the rhetoric that is floating around the world at the moment and the way media is being manipulated, it is more important than ever to have strong, robust newsrooms. Amen to that.

I guess just to play devil's advocate for a second, you could argue, the potential, you could argue, that it is being made up of a way that is being manipulated. You could argue that it is better to have, as we're at a merge nine, fifth, even though it's just called nine, better to have one good, strong one than two weak ones. I mean, that's essentially what mergers are all about, right? Well, being the detail of the merger, whether the strength will continue in newsrooms, the fact that nine has said it's most interested in domain and sand, and journalism really didn't get a mention, is a big worry.

If journalism is not in front of mind for this merge company, it says a lot about their priorities for investment. Yeah, and I guess, as you say, the devil will be in the detail. Already they've talked about reductions in costs of about 50 million. In a $4.2 billion merger, 50 million doesn't seem like a lot of money.

And Eric Beach has already penned a quick piece for Crikey saying, don't believe 50, believe more like 100. So where does that really make savings? I mean, as you know, and as I know Fairfax has gone through multiple redundancies and cost cuttings over the last eight to ten years, in fact, for other back than that. Is there any more fat to be cut into something like Fairfax?

No, of course not. I mean, if they cut any more, it's into bone, muscle and the soul of the newsroom. And that's just on that point, and that final point maybe is, yes, the culture of nine and Fairfax. I mean, Fairfax is a proudly independent journalistic culture.

I'm not saying that nine isn't, but they are different companies. Do you think this marriage can work on that level? Well, we have to make it work wrong with nine and Fairfax having different cultures. They've got different markets, they've got different audiences, and nine has a good tradition of good journalism.

And we want the culture of the nine newsroom to continue and to be invested in, to be a player in the market with a separate culture and identity and role to play. Fairfax does something different, and periled in the age of the camp of times in all the regional papers and digital platforms that Fairfax has. They will be able to retain their independent cultures so that nine does what it does. Well, the nine newsroom as it was, we'll do what it does.

TV minutes does what it does. And the rest of it continues as well. We haven't heard yet any commitments around that, and that's what we'll be putting to the companies. Final question before I let you go, and thank you for your time.

You've had many, many clashes with Greg High. Would you be sad to see him go? I was not particularly personal for me, Peter. Okay.

And I don't think Greg's going to retire. He'll certainly have enough money to retire on when he gets his golden handshake off the board. But yeah, it's not a personal thing for me. It's about democracy.

It's about diverse media diversity and about the wages and conditions of our members. Thank you very much. Thank you. And joining me in the studio is David Scapicca from Telham Media.

Hello, David. How are you? I'm great. I'm very proud of you.

We're all like you. We're all absorbing the impact of this historic day, this merger between Channel 9 and Fairfax Media. Telham sits kind of above the industry. How's it going down in the early days, but how's it going down in the industry, do you think?

It certainly is a fascinating day. We're already seeing a lot of journeys, particularly in Fairfax. Quite concerned for what sort of the next steps are, but sort of taking it back a couple of steps. As you said, there's a long way to go.

We've all heard the Fairfax brand is disappearing pretty soon. That's a pretty momentous occasion in Australia, not necessarily in a good way. It's been around 50 years plus. And suddenly there will be no Fairfax.

That's right. I mean, you know, there clearly could have been an option to have Fairfax as a division within nine. That clearly wasn't taken. There's going to be reasons for that.

I think there's a lot of talk about how this is going to impact journalism as an industry. That's obviously where Telham sits and that's what we look at. On the one hand, you can kind of say these mergers always end up with efficiencies, which is really just code words for job losses. Exactly.

However, on the upside, you do have Channel 9, which does invest in content. You may not necessarily like that content, but they are a content driven business. More not so much journalism content. I do think.

Well, it's interesting. In the investor call after the announcement this morning, Hugh Mark, the CEO, actually said that 60% of the nine line up is using current affairs. That's on the original Freedia Wear and Linear Television as opposed to Stan and the digital channels. So that was a really interesting number.

I actually hadn't heard that before. And it is, you know, when you put all of the airtime together, that's quite a lot. The interesting thing is going to be, you know, where they can find cost saves and where they can not duplicate creating use. Early days, but where do you see or what's the talk, if you like, about where those cost savings could be?

Well, I think we all have to look very closely at the print operations of the mastheads. You mean they may not be print? Correct. It's really interesting.

In the press release that was sent out by nine, when you look at the Sydney Morning Herald masthead that they've got in the diagram of what's going to be left, it's actually only smh.com.au, non-smh. There is the age. So that's quite interesting. So we've got to look there.

The other one that was also flagged and that's been talked about for quite a while, even before this merger is the regional operations. There's actually been rumors flying around that News Corp and Fairfax will both sell their regional operations to a third party to be operated separately. Regional media is probably one of the most important media groups in Australia. It provides a really fantastic community service, so it's going to be very interesting to see what happens there.

And then New Zealand, which most Australians wouldn't consider, but actually Fairfax is quite a big media owner in New Zealand. There's already been moves to spin off their New Zealand arm. However, it was flagged this morning that they made the new plans. So if you want to keep working for Fairfax, you have to go across the bit.

Potentially. Just quickly. Thank you so much for coming in. Who do you think just talk about personalities for a second?

The talent keeps a very good and very excellent close eye on personalities. Helen McCabe, for instance, the editorial director of 9.com.au, she would strike me as a big winner in this. Potentially. What's your thought on that?

As you say, very early days. However, Helen is one of the best media operators that I've ever come across. I actually met Helen years ago just after I came out of uni and I did some work with her while she was at the Sunday Telegraph. She would be edited there.

She's one of those journalists who has managed to work across almost every type of medium. She's been a very good player in the past few years and become an expert at every single one. Everything she touches seems to turn to gold. So you're probably right.

So what do you think then on the flip side of that coin? If Helen's a big winner in the digital space in news and current affairs, Fairfax, you know, as I well know, and obviously as an ex-feflex editor, has a habit of knocking off senior editors. Do you think there's James Chessell feeling today, director? Look, I don't know specifically the individuals.

Obviously they have some phenomenal talent. They've got Lisa Davies, James Chessell, all those kind of people, Daniel Croninoff and Brisbane. You've got some phenomenal talent there. The question is going to be what does NINE already have in place and where don't they need people to do that?

And it's not just that. You take it down a couple of levels and you look at the press gallery, for example. Both operations have some fantastic talent there. Are they going to need both?

Don't know. You've seen experiments around Australia and around the world of newsrooms going multi-platform and you're having newspaper journalists trying to do television, for example. It doesn't always work that well. For lots of different reasons, very different skills, different requirements in terms of type of talent.

It's going to be interesting to see if they do go down that path of making all journalists multi-platform or if they just simply try and keep different brands and segment for their marketing or the advertiser audience. Final question. Do you think this is the end of it? We are in a converged world, as you just said.

This is the first merger that comes following the changes to the cross-media laws and the 75% rule. Is this just the beginning? 100%. This is the firing shot.

I think you're going to be seeing a lot of consolidation in the media industry. There were big questions around whether seven and nine, sorry, seven was going to take their facts or nine was going to take their facts. This is interesting. Not sure where seven is going to be looking.

Perhaps something across Osterio, for example. That's an option. It's going to be fascinating. But this certainly isn't the end.

You do also have to consider perhaps seven balance sheet might not support it, but you do have to consider whether seven would consider a counter offer at this point. It started a bit more. Interesting. On that point, we'll leave it.

Thank you so much for coming in, David. Thanks, Peter. Joining us now is Tim Burrows, the founder and content director of Mumbrella and sign up in catch Mumbrella. It's a fantastic site.

Tim, on the weekend, you wrote a very interesting piece of it, in which you said, quote, it's turned the corner. Is this what you meant? Yeah, you've got to be careful what you predict. I was having you particularly in that piece.

I also had unkind things to say about futurists as well. I think from shareholders point to view, Fairfax shareholders, this looks like pretty good news. Those who have stuck it out since the GFC, the share price come back up, of course, getting quite big bit of them from Nara. That doesn't necessarily mean it's good for the journalists.

What should take on those last two groups? I mean, perhaps too early to tell. commentary so far has been broadly negative about that, but I guess you would expect that. Is this a good moment for loyal Fairfax subscribers who really wouldn't really have that much in common with Channel 9 people, really?

Yeah, and I suppose over the years, you have to remember that Fairfax has often owned brands which I really talk very much to each other. So, for being stablemates with 2GB, 2 brands which couldn't catch up with each other in terms of how they've had it. So that's not always being a stranger to things. I think the question, generally, is because again, people might look towards West Australia where we've seen several West media who create a whole new move.

We've already had Fairfax already said that they would give me a very symbolic way. They're actually having a good time of moving into new headquarters as well. You're in for half a floor of Fairfax Jones. Yes, exactly that.

What do you make the death of the name Fairfax? To most journalists, yes, I'm sure you want to get out of the age, you're the AFR. In recent years, it's become more of a unified marketing brand, a little bit more than that, and it's always over the years. But the mastheads are at the brand.

So, therefore, yes, people like me can still call themselves an ex-signal encounter. Exactly, you know, and certainly they've got their magic for the masthead. So, look, it's absolutely a sad day that they're devising Fairfax family as well, I'm sure. But, you know, the...

That brings up my question. Is this the death of Prince? I personally sincerely hope not. It felt to me like the agreement, so I've kind of extended lots of newsmen that are shrinking at the same time, of course.

I'm sure that one of the reasons that we've seen behind the share price go down today, aren't necessarily that keen on a legacy medium like Prince. And they maybe missed the news in Umbrella that there was a print merger. Yeah, after the merger going on, we don't know what do the actual things as well. Well, indeed, indeed.

Although, I mean, this is entire speculation, but this merger, as we all know, is a child of the changes in the legislation last year. Long discuss, long help, all killing is called this merger terrible thing. But the laws of the world, of the game have changed, and so therefore, isn't this just in a sense the enactment of the spirit of those laws? Yeah, you're completely human beings.

Okay, so do you think overall, final question, overall, do you think this is a positive day for the media landscape or not? That's a very difficult, honestly. On that note, Jim Barris, thank you for your time and thank you for your invitation on this very busy day. My pleasure.

Thanks, Jim. That's it from us on Fourth Estate on this very important and somewhat historic day in the news media landscape in this country. I'd like to thank the many guests we've heard, including David Scapinka from Tella Media, Emily Watkins from Krikey, Marcus Strom, Federal President of the EMEAA, that's the Journalism Union, Darren Goodser, a former editor of the City Morning Herald, Darren Davidson, a media editor at the Australian, Tim Burrows, founder and content director on Mumbrella, and last but no means least, Amanda Wilson, a former editor of the City Morning Herald. It's been a very big day in the media landscape.

Join us next week, when Anthony Tocker will be in the host seat for another rousing edition of Fourth Estate. Make sure you subscribe to the Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app, so you can hear us talk media, politics and a few things in between at your leisure. And as I say, we'll be back next week, but in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Facebook or Twitter. Our handle is Fourth Estate, a U.

My name is Peter Frang. Thank you very, very much. Good to see you.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 1 hour and 4 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on July 26, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.