Nine-Five Percent
from Random Acts of Urbanism Hosted by Brigitte Pellerin
The podcast is carrying on! The number that frames everything: of the councillors who sought re-election, about ninety-five per cent came back. Twenty-one of twenty-two. The Ontario average is roughly two-thirds. Evan Potter’s read is that Ottawa isn’t unusually content, it’s unusually short of competitive challengers. Most registered on May 1, the opening of the official campaign, against incumbents who’d been campaigning every day for four years, with newsletters, office hours and every community event. So the conversation turns to what happens between elections: who was in the field early and did well, what Stacey Abrams built in Georgia without ever winning herself, and what Doug Jones is now attempting in Alabama. The argument is that a better-informed citizenry produces better candidates, because voters who know the issues can kick the tires. Then the row. Tim Tierney (fifth term, now president of the Federation of Canadian Municipalities) published an op-ed on election day urging Queen’s Park to ban third-party advertising in municipal campaigns. Both hosts say no, from different directions. Plus: $474 million of Elon Musk’s money and what it bought, and a call for stories from people still dealing with the July 1 floods. Sources: Evan Potter — Tim Tierney may be fighting a battle he cannot win · Democracy Now — Musk spent record $474 million on midterms · Unpublished — Tierney elected FCM president · CTV — Meet Ottawa’s new council: 21 incumbents and 3 new members Random Acts of Urbanism is a reader-supported publication. Transcript Brigitte Pellerin (00:01) Hi everyone, hi Evan. How are you? Evan Potter (00:03) Greetings. I’m feeling good. I’m feeling good because of the midterms. The midterms make me feel good. Brigitte Pellerin (00:10) A little bit tired — but man, are we happy. This was really a great result. Even I had 240 or so Democrats in the House, and maybe 53 in the Senate, and it’s been blown out of the water. I was too shy, it turns out. Evan Potter (00:28) Don’t feel guilty. Many other people couldn’t believe their eyes. Brigitte Pellerin (00:34) It was so interesting to see. I mean, this is a municipal podcast, but there are lessons from the midterms for what’s happening here. What was really interesting was just about every single demographic that was pro-Trump, or at least Trump-curious, previously — strongly backing away from him and going towards the Democrats. Except for white men. They’re the only ones. Not all white men voted for Donald Trump, but the white men who voted for Donald Trump last time still voted for him this time. And that says a lot about the state of electoral politics. So — we have decided to keep this little podcast going. Because we’re having fun. That’s the main reason. And number two, we keep hearing from folks that they appreciate it, because there aren’t a lot of people who do this kind of work, and especially not for municipal politics. I like to call this informed commentary. We don’t just do reporting, we don’t just do opinion. We try to do a little bit of in-between. And we’re going to keep it that way. You and I have our own opinions and our own biases. We try to be transparent about those, so that people watching or listening or reading can filter what we say through that lens, and make up their own minds about whether or not they want to believe us, or think that we’re full of it. So before we launch into the newer topics — exploring municipal power in Ottawa, where it is, the trends — a little bit of a review, now with the midterms in mind, of our own municipal election. You wanted to run through a couple of things, so I’ll let you go. Evan Potter (02:14) I did. And I’m really delighted to be carrying on with this podcast with you, Brigitte. I see, and many others see, a huge gap in Ottawa local journalism. The local media outlets — we know who they are, CBC, CTV, CFRA — I think they do a great job in day-to-day news reporting. But there’s almost no political journalism. Now, this is informed commentary, so this isn’t journalism. But there is very little political commentary on local politics. Brigitte Pellerin (02:55) And we try to do analysis sometimes, and context. Evan Potter (03:03) We’re not saying that the information the Ottawa public receives is insufficient in terms of committees, and what council is doing, and the results of their policy deliberations. We’re just saying we’re additive. We add some political context to what’s going on at City Hall. Brigitte Pellerin (03:23) And we welcome feedback, by the way. I get a bunch, and I think you get a bunch too. If there are stories you want us to look into, or things you want to hear more about — or criticism, that’s fine too. We’re not always right. So it’s good to know. Evan Potter (03:37) You asked me to make a few comments to get the conversation rolling. I think it’s significant — and this may distinguish Ottawa from other municipalities in Ontario — that ninety-five per cent of incumbents, so councillors who sought re-election in this cycle, were re-elected. And a shout-out to [name to confirm] Rousseau, who is Councillor Wilson Lo’s chief of staff, because he reminded me that the average for Ontario is two-thirds of incumbent councillors. So Ottawa is way above the average. Brigitte Pellerin (04:24) Interesting. So either we’re really happy with our councillors, or we’re not going out to vote, or — we don’t know what the reason is, but clearly there’s a discrepancy. Evan Potter (04:33) There’s something there that we can explore in future podcasts. But it makes you ask: either the citizenry, Ottawa residents, are very happy with their councillors — or there are not enough competitive challengers. And I suspect it is the latter. That we are not growing competitive challengers in these wards. I noticed that most of the challengers for this past municipal election only showed up as of May 1st, the start of the official campaign. I could count on two hands the number of challengers who were in the field trying to generate name recognition last year — thinking that they were going to officially join the campaign, but realising that in fact they probably needed a six-month or even a year head start to make themselves more visible in the ward they wanted to compete in. Brigitte Pellerin (05:46) In the wards that were open — I know Joanne Chianello had been out for a while. I want to say Chelsea Walton was also out for a little bit before May, but I don’t know that for sure. I think Christine Harrison in West Carleton-March also, before May. And Barbara Gandolfo. And Erin Coffin obviously, because she’d campaigned four years ago, so she’d been there for some time. And maybe that’s one lesson: you need a lot of patience. Evan Potter (06:01) You need time. Brigitte Pellerin (06:16) And persistence, and time, and stubbornness. Evan Potter (06:18) Because those incumbent politicians, councillors — they’re campaigning every day. It’s not just the mayor that’s campaigning every day. We said that in a number of past podcasts: a mayor, not just Mayor Sutcliffe — a mayor, a councillor, is campaigning every day. They’re going around, they’re being visible, they’re going to every community event, they’re talking. Brigitte Pellerin (06:40) They have newsletters and office hours, and they’re making themselves available. Evan Potter (06:44) So when they register for their official campaign, they’ve been campaigning for four years. And for somebody with much less name recognition to show up on May 1st during the election — good luck. Brigitte Pellerin (07:00) Good luck, you know? But maybe that’s one way of getting your feet wet, too. There are sometimes people who are debating it, and not sure if they want to do it — because it’s a commitment. If you want to be there for a year, how are you going to earn? Not everyone can just take a year off work, or work at night. It’s a financial commitment, it’s a family commitment. There are a lot of things to keep in mind when you decide that. An… Get full access to Random Acts of Urbanism by Brigitte Pellerin at randomactsofurbanism.substack.com/subscribe
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.