No Holds Barred #169: The Biggest Star of Every WrestleMania (1–41) Ranked

Who walked out of WrestleMania as the biggest star of the night? On this episode of No Holds Barred, JT & Aaron choose the single wrestler from each of the 41 WWE WrestleManias who left the show with the most STAR power — then rank those selections in a full tier list. From the early dominance of Hulk Hogan to the Attitude Era explosion of “Stone Cold” Steve Austin… from The Undertaker’s aura to Shawn Michaels’ show-stealing performances… from John Cena’s era to Roman Reigns, Becky Lynch, Cody Rhodes and beyond — we break down who truly owned the spotlight at WWE’s biggest annual event. This isn’t about match quality. It’s about presence. Momentum. Iconic moments. And who felt larger than life when the show ended. Which WrestleMania performances defined an era? Who was overrated? Who was undeniable? Join JT & Aaron for debate, nostalgia, rankings, and definitive tier-list chaos covering WrestleMania I through WrestleMania 41.   WrestleMania, WWE history, WrestleMania rankings, WWE tier list, best WrestleMania performers, biggest WrestleMania star, Hulk Hogan, Stone Cold Steve Austin, The Undertaker, Shawn Michaels, John Cena, Roman Reigns, Becky Lynch, Cody Rhodes, WWE podcast, wrestling history, wrestling debate, pro wrestling analysis, No Holds Barred podcast, JT and Aaron