Hello everyone and welcome back to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism. Coming to you from Twizzi Art in Sydney on Gadigal Lands of the ER Nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Tina Quinn, it's a pleasure as always to have your company. On the weekend came the announcement that Sky News had been suspended from posting any new videos on YouTube for seven days.
The reason given was for spreading disinformation about COVID and about unproven therapies including that old chestnut, hydroxychloroquine. Surely an embarrassing situation for what many see as a mainstream news outlet. Now this comes in the same week that Sky launches a new free-to-air channel for regional areas in New South Wales, Queensland, Victoria and South Australia. So it begs the question, if Sky's content is considered too dangerous for YouTube viewers, why is it not so for our more traditional platforms?
In this edition we ask some fundamental questions about the state of the Fourth Estate in Australia and where Sky News finds itself. Also, should we really be happy with YouTube censoring Australian news companies or are they just simply doing the work that our own media regulators are failing to do themselves? To help us discuss what this action from YouTube means for Sky News and our media in general, we're joined by Ariel Bogle. She works at the Australian Strategic Policy Institute doing research on propaganda.
She also worked at the ABC, the Conversation and Slates Future Tense. Ariel Bogle, welcome to Fourth Estate. Hi, thanks for having me. And Bernard Keene also joins us.
He's a Crikey's political editor. He has also been Crikey's Canberra Press Gallery correspondent and has worked in the public service as well as being a speech writer. He's also a passionate supporter of Greyhounds and adopting older dogs. Bernard Keene, welcome to Fourth Estate.
It's a pleasure to be here. So Chris Keene this week said that a multinational company is basically censoring the news and views that Australians can see. Is he right to be worried by YouTube's move? Bernard, you can go first.
Chris Keene would say that. A multinational company is censoring the news all the time. News Corp says news all the time. In fact, I was fascinated to the Australian, the newspaper that Chris Keene writes for, didn't actually mention the YouTube ban in its Monday newspaper.
So one person's censorship is another person's judicious news judgment. But as a society, we have been pressing big social media platforms and YouTube's the oldest and the biggest. Well, certainly the oldest, certainly the oldest. To put in place much, much better and certainly much stricter controls over dangerous content.
This has been a vexing issue now for a number of years. And the governments, other media companies, certainly News Corp have been complaining about the level of dangerous content that's to be found on the likes of Facebook, on Twitter. And obviously on YouTube as well, YouTube in fact, possibly the worst defend or at all given its tendency to, as it alleged by meaning, although disputed by some, to radicalize people by pushing them further and further down toward even more radical forms of particular content because of the way its algorithms were. YouTube taking a position of trying to edit this content so that it is not producing misinformation is something that everyone's been crying out for for a number of years and for everyone to suddenly turn around and say, well, this is a question, blighter for expansion multinationals should be doing this.
I think is certainly hypocritical and also undermines the value of media platforms actually trying to be a bit more responsible about how they handle dangerous content. It's an incredibly vexed issue. No one, I think outside of the ranks of the Twitter, I think this is an easy issue to solve. It's immensely complicated.
A lot of efforts make what you try to deal with it. Ariel, what do you think? Is this a measured response to disinformation? I mean, YouTube has been accused of giving rise to neo-nazis and giving a platform to flat-earthers, basically.
Is this as Chris Kenny claimed an example of cancel culture or do you think it's a measured response? Well, as I've been alluded to there, I think there's a real diversity to discussions of free speech in Australia, which maybe we can get into. So first thing I spent 2020 reporting for the ABC on all kinds of misinformation related to the COVID pandemic, two vaccines, two whole number of related issues. We asked members of the public to send in what they were seeing online.
And they certainly sent us plenty of YouTube clips. And often we would turn to YouTube and ask them, you know, why hasn't this not been taken down yet? And often they would take it down, but it did take us pointing it out to them to that to happen. And I think this latest decision to remove some videos or to block Sky News Australia from publishing videos for seven days as part of its kind of three strikes regime is a really interesting step.
Some people would call it justified and we can discuss the kind of content that Sky has in publishing. But it does show the remaining transparency issues at YouTube. I mean, we don't really know what the decision making process was here. We don't know why now.
It seems like, according to the reporting from the Guardian, some of the videos that Sky has subsequently removed from its YouTube channel, you know, came out in 2020. So why now? I've been certainly providing a lot of transparency about this kind of decision making processes can help people kind of scan the system and create workarounds. But I think we're really in the dark.
Neither Sky nor YouTube has been clear about what exactly the type of videos were that caused this all to happen. So there's our remaining issues with outsourcing these kinds of decisions about news content to multinational companies. Do you think it's important that YouTube have a policy like this at all? But those transparency and accountability issues about its content moderation remain extremely vexed.
One rumor that's going around is that, rather than being some outrageous infringement on the rights of Sky News, in fact, basically the week long suspension was an opportunity for Sky News to clear house a bit and remove a lot of the content that even people within News Corp and Sky News recognize is problematic. And it's got a week to do that. And it's been visually removing a lot of quite problematic content. And in a week's time, normal service will be resumed, normal service, of course, including a very strong commercial relationship between YouTube and YouTube.
And it can go forward without a lot of very problematic content in relation to the pandemic and in particular treatments for COVID-19. So how much credence for you that? I don't know. So there's a rumor that this is basically a backroom deal almost.
Or a character. Well, it certainly has given Sky an opportunity to cleanse the board a bit to make sure that it's not pushing the sort of content that even other, you know, the sort of the day that's like rough dropping out on Jones's even other sections of the new scope find beyond the pale. Well, Sky News's digital editor, Jack Horton, said in response to YouTube's ban that you have a right to debate Australia's COVID-19 policies. Does he have a point or is he ignoring the elephant in the room, Ariel?
Well, I mean, I couldn't quite take that column too seriously when he alluded to Auschwitz and Mao. I thought perhaps a bit too colorful for the debate at hand. You know, of course, there was room for debate about the approach to Australian government at the federal or state level has taken to the COVID outbreak. But that's a far cry from debating the efficacy of a horse tranquilizer drug like that's not the same thing as debating whether the Australian, the city lockdown is working in the right way.
But I think there's a lot of fuzziness around the edges when we're talking about the kind of content that I was sharing and what metaphors to cross the line for YouTube. So YouTube is interesting for COVID has created quite a strict policy and that's in contrast to its policies around other types of content, say political misinformation or even misinformation about climate change, which arguably will ultimately be just as harmful if not more. So YouTube doesn't allow content about COVID that poses a serious risk of egregious harm. And that is definitely content that promotes treatments that have not been proven, misinformation about tests, misinformation about how the virus is transmitted.
So I think that's pretty clear, much clearer than a lot of its other policies. So I do think this argument that we're not allowed to have debate about what's happening with COVID in Australia is fatally false because there's plenty of contradiction in the media every day on Twitter, on the broadcast channels on the radio. We can argue about whether that's working or what level of debate that is, but the argument that there's not a debate because of a YouTube decision is hardly tenable. Mm.
Sky News has been rolling out Craig Kelly repeatedly to its audience as an expert and someone who's not afraid to speak the truth as such. Chris Kenny, Alan Jones, Chris Smith and Corey Benardi are among the names to feature Kelly and his takes on vaccines. Now, look, the real problem is he's not a medical expert in any meaningful way and is in reality a failed coalition MP and I think a former furniture importer last time I checked. Should Sky News apologise to its audience for misleading them and putting their lives at risk, burner to you?
Certainly there is a real issue about what impacts very broad-based pandemic and nihilism if you like the kind of certainly on Jones and me pedaling. But more specifically commentary around the efficacy of certain treatments has on on individual viewers. I mean, I suspect given the nature of the audience of Sky News, which seems to be sort of conservative and older, there's an element of preaching to the converted anyway. But you put your finger on a really, really important issue about the role of experts.
Now, if you turn on Sky News during the day, or at least until about four o'clock when I think Chris Kenny comes on, you'll see journalists on their talking to other journalists, which is something that I'm talking about, or talking to politicians. And they're talking about their area of expertise. So what Sky News after Dark as everyone calls it consists of is a bunch of people who frequently aren't even journalists, certainly on Jones and me and Jones, a number of people who have been a political staffer. A bunch of people who have never been journalists and certainly aren't experts by pining about all sorts of issues.
Democracy should tolerate a wide range of different views and debates. Oh, look, no one's saying no one's where the free speech angle is a distraction. No one's suggesting they're not entitled to expressive views. But what Sky News after Dark is peddling is comment.
It's not peddling news. It's not peddling information. It's not however biased that might be. You can get that from Sky News during the day.
But after Dark, you get comment and opinion and purported analysis and the lack of expertise from the people who are on there undermines the whole argument that, well, we should be entitled to have some sort of debate. Sure, you can have a debate, but it should be informed by facts and it should be undertaken by people who actually know what they're talking about. And the Sky News business model really is the commentary aspect. It's not about the news.
It's not about providing information. It's about comment and opinion, which of course is pictured in a certain way. It's designed to be monetized by a relation to particular audiences. The reason Sky News can do this under the terms of its license.
It's a broadcaster. It has a license like any other broadcast in the country. There are different kinds of licenses, but they're all licensed. Under the terms of its license, it can provide as much opinion and commentary as it likes.
And there's no rules around that. There's no restrictions around that. It's only related to news and information that it's required to provide things like balance and appropriate fare coverage. When it comes to opinion, it's anything goes.
And that's the driving force behind the whole range of content that you get from Sky News after Dark. And it's the lack of expertise from people who are taken very, very seriously as authority figures by a lot of viewers. That I think has exposed a lot of people to a lot of quite poor advice that's going to influence their health decisions. Well, the Daily Telegraph has dropped Alan Jones as a columnist.
And even Fox and the US has all of a sudden really started to warm up to vaccines. Is News Corp moving on this issue, do you think? Or should we expect to see some change in Sky? Do you think?
I'd like both of you to answer. Ariel, to you first. Change. Well, it's interesting question because changing too much would undermine, I think, what strategy is for YouTube.
So separate, perhaps from the broadcast channel from even its digital content from its other social media accounts. It's YouTube strategy certainly seems to be appealing to a US market. So just before we have this conversation, I went and checked what the top videos were on its YouTube channel. The most watched videos.
The first one is about coronavirus. It's a special report. You know, China's deadly coronavirus cover-up quote unquote has more than 8 million views. But the next top videos are all US, you know, really indistinguishable from a US broadcaster.
They seem to have no particularly Australian angle to them. They are about Trump. Trump becomes a first US president to step into North Korea. That has more than 6 million views.
A real bumpy of the American, right? Biden's sort of demeanor. There's a video titled Biden's Computer Issues Can No Longer Be Ignored. That has more than 4 million views.
Another one with more than 3 million views. Joe Biden has to be taken out of circulation quote unquote after rambling about men on the moon. Quote unquote. This is the kind of content that are among its top videos.
And it's a good strategy that seems to be paying off because of course, it's going to use Australia can run ads against that content and make money. And it's interesting to have a look through the comments. So I can't definitively say that everybody watching that video is in the United States. But certainly the comments seem to suggest that people are receiving it in that way.
So one comment on the Biden's cognitive issues video was, I don't know who this news anchor is, but Australia should be proud. They have some truth and integrity in their media. And another comment, you know, it's a damn shame I'm going to have to watch news from another content to get news about my own country. So they certainly have found some sort of niche on YouTube, which must be lucrative for them to be pushing it quite so hard.
So I'm not sure the incentives will change here. And so they won't really do change in editorial policy. Bernard? I used to call some of the great work on vaccinations.
It was a Sunday telegraph, basically Sydney, which I think led a strong campaign in relation to vaccination about five years ago, which led to Scott Morrison adopting No Jab No Pay and No Jab No Play, as those policies are called, which basically withholding money from people who declined to have their children vaccinated without a good reason. Ironically, I cash incentives for people to get vaccinations, which the Prime Minister is currently railing against. That they know about now from... No, suddenly it's a bit of a back flip on that issue.
But there's no doubt that you've got a very good campaign on that and really went hard against anti-vaxxers. There is a risk of trying to come as a monolith when, of course, it has different outlets with different business models. And there are some great journalists that work there. And there's some very good journalists there.
So I think to talk about it as one big weather variant is shifting in one particular direction. It's probably not very helpful. But I think, institutionally, I'm still going to have to understand that for a paper that had actually played a really strong role in relation to vaccination, running the views of a man who was basically telling people to avoid it like the plague, Paul Pun, not intended, was damaging even within the confines of news called reputation with the readers. You're listening to Fourth Estate on the Community Radio Network and our guests are Bernard Keene and Ariel Bogle.
Before we look at ACMA and the press council's role in all of this, I want to touch on the politics that are very much the heart of this coverage. The moment COVID struck, it was identified as a health issue, but also a political one for the leaders who had to deal with it. Trump famously said it would disappear. Now, the far right has attacked COVID and those who take it seriously from the get-go.
They've also pushed cures which have proven to be at best ineffective. Hydroxylchloroquine features most prominently in the rights attack on COVID-19 measures. Ariel, from a propaganda point of view, why has Hydroxylchloroquine been a consistent touchstone for the right? Well, it's interesting to trace it back.
I did a piece last year sort of looking at where the obsession with hydroxylchloroquine really began because in the beginning of 2020, there were actually a variety of news articles, scientific papers, looking at the efficacy of hydroxylchloroquine, because of course, doctors, researchers were throwing everything at the wall to see what would work here and hydroxylchloroquine was one of many. It was really after a French researcher who since become quite controversial, did he or I will be published a study which has been very much a question for how it was carried out by other researchers, but it suggested hydroxylchloroquine was quite effective. But Trump tweeted that. And that was really it.
After that, hydroxylchloroquine no longer really became a medication of any sort. He became a plu cool symbol, a sort of touchstone. And declaring that it might work was became a kind of article of faith in Trump and in the conservative politics of the United States, which we really saw transferred into Australia by figures like Craig Kelly, who posted quite a bit of hydroxylchloroquine in last year, as well as some other drugs. So I think that it's interesting, I mean, as well, to look at how these drugs have been interpreted, because a lot of the things that we ask of Australians in combating the pandemic are collective action, you know, staying home for the benefit of others, getting vaccinated for the benefit of others, wearing masks for the benefit of a complete community.
Whereas a drug, a quick fix presents a sort of like more individualised and more, yeah, I suppose more individualised that heart approach to a disease like this. And so you might argue there's some kind of different values there too. But it's an interesting question, I think one that really bears a reflection on a year or two on since it first emerged as a quote unquote wonder drug, but never really panned out. If you live inside the ecosystem of Sky or Fox News for that matter, I mean, the pandemic is not just a health issue, but part of a much more complicated narrative.
This narrative has the great lie that Biden stole the election at the heart of it. Climate change in the UN are also part of it, as is that Lav and China and the other present threat of so-called progressives wanting to make us all live inside a totalitarian world, with vaccine passports being the first step on the road to hell, basically. Now, this conspiracy goes on and on and is also ever changing and seems to pick up different touchstones along the way, like a great big snowball in such an ecosystem and a business model for that matter. Are we expecting too much for facts and experts to rise to the surface when it comes to coverage of COVID-19, when so much of what they produce is basically a fantasy?
Bernard, to you? Yes, using straightforward to combat conspiracy theories is not particularly effective technique. At the heart of the real conspiracy theorists is a willingness to engage in what's called motivated reasoning, which means basically you do think the facts that you want, you reject the facts that you don't want, and you invent the facts that serve your narrative. So confronting conspiracy theorists with clear facts showing that, no, what they believe is not the case.
It tends to not be particularly effective. I mean, there were cases of QAnon, believers deciding after the inauguration of Biden that, in fact, they've been lied to, but that tends to be someone unusual. Conspiracy theorists have been a real surging conspiracy theorizing in recent years for a number of reasons, partly the internet, partly to do with the kind of economic situation in fact. And a lot of this is tribalism, really.
I mean, as Ariel said, I mean, the elevation of a drugsicore queen is an example of a sort of a totemic figure or symbol that people can believe in. It fits a conservative narrative. I mean, it's a parallel to the idea that we just technology will come along and fix climate change, for us, we don't have to actually engage in collective action. We'll just invent something that will fix climate change.
Well, you know, here we had the perfect invention to fix COVID-19. That sort of technological determinism, I think, plays to much better to conservatives with a worldview of disliking any sort of collective action. If I can make a small assumption here, I'd say that both of you think that propaganda and disinformation doesn't really have a place in our news media, how do we make that more of a reality? In the case of ACMA, it's received 23 complaints about skies, vaccine coverage, and it's ended up just being sent on to Sky News for review and comment.
Is that good enough, Ariel, to you? Well, it's a very fraught question, I think, about whether ACMA and the tools and resources, it has a moment to sort of digital age we're in. Certainly they have a lot of, they have something to say about television broadcast, less, I suppose, to say about what happens on Sky's YouTube channel. Earlier this year, they did launch the Australian Code of Practice on disinformation, misinformation, alongside the platforms, and they're still debating continuing about the adequacy of that code.
I think it'll be interesting to see, it seems like ACMA and Sky and a whole bunch of others will be asked to speak for the Media Diversity Committee even later this week. So I think that it is time, I think, to ask whether ACMA has the right type of powers, whether it's the right regulatory body to deal with the kind of online disinformation we're seeing, spring up via media outlets, YouTube channels, or Twitter content, Facebook content as well. It's also really interesting that this ban from YouTube has come at the same time, in the same week, basically, that Sky News regional has launched within, so it's basically it's a free-to-air channel, the New South Wales, Victoria Queensland, and South Australia in their regional areas. Why is YouTube able to step in yet?
They've decided that some of the content is dangerous, that Sky are putting out on their platform, but why is that good enough for it to be broadcast out on television, basically? To you, Bennett? There's irony in all this, which is that YouTube is doing a regulatory work that ACMA, so far as to decline to do, despite the fact that when you're online, you get the rules in relation to online content are far less strict than in relation to broadcast, and broadcasting, as I said earlier, you're licensed. You have certain license requirements, subscription television has significantly less onerous requirements than free-to-air broadcasting, but that of course doesn't apply once you start taking a subscription TV feed and putting it on a regional broadcast in that subject to terrestrial free-to-air broadcasting licenses.
The powers of ACMA, or before at the ABA, I mean, that's been a vexed issue for, ever since I can remember, about 15 years ago, I was involved in overhauling the powers of ACMA. Then to try and address some of the concerns about the perceived lack of powers that ACMA had, if I'm willing to use powers, basically the fact that you got flogged with the wet lettuce, if you stepped out of line, if you were a broadcast, the widespread perception, I think there was some justice for that. And what about the press council? I mean, they routinely take up 12 months to pass a adjudication, and then it's rulings at best, again, amount to just a snap on the wrist.
Do you think there's a better way for them as well? I think the press council is, they're literally the best, even what it really doesn't have, it's taken at best, and that's being pretty generous. There's a fundamental difference though between broadcasters and newspapers. I mean, broadcasters, I said, they're licensed by using public spectrum, and therefore there's a requirement, long accepted that they are subject to special rules that govern the kind of content that they're allowed to put out.
Newspapers, well, look, anyone can produce a newspaper. You don't need your license for using a newspaper. You can go and check out a newspaper, wherever you like them, whatever you like. So the restrictions around that are much less significant, and that's exactly how it should be.
The idea of a proper regulatory model for newspapers is another one that's been around for a long time, Stephen Conroy tried to fix it about a decade ago by proposing that it be basically a requirement that newspapers themselves put together some sort of credible body to vet their content, and they rebelled against that and declared it was an outrageous attack on free speech and freedom of press, which was anything but. Nonetheless, it's true that in terms of subscription TV and in terms of newspapers, there is even less of an ownerless regulatory requirement than there is for free web broadcasters. And I think it is significant that YouTube's done the regulation that Acma really hasn't been in a position to do. I mean, you said that it affords as complaints to the sky news, well, that's what it's required to do.
I mean, you can't, as a regulator, you can't just make a decision about someone else's complaint. You've got to give the person complaint against the opportunity to actually deal with the complaint. As soon as you start trying to extend that to his powers, they start talking about things like natural justice and they're pretty well embedded in the way we regulate. If we put the lack of diversity in media ownership in Australia to one side for a moment, do you think there is, do you think it's the problem at the full state?
It really shouldn't be controlled by the government for obvious reasons, but self-regulation is a failure as well, because basically you're putting the kids in charge of the biscuit tin. Is self-regulation ever a good idea? Do you Ariel? Self-regulation is an interesting question.
I mean, I'm much more on top of how the social platforms I regulated and I pointed to earlier that Australian code of practice on disinformation and misinformation. That's another sort of form of self-regulation. I think we need to look at two when we're talking about these incentives and how our media is structured. The way that these platforms operate and the kind of content they encourage, there is an argument here that the way YouTube works, the way it recommends videos, the way it has, I suppose, made favorites of news outlets on its platform, recommending them over other types of content, the way office of partner program to news outlets like Sky in terms of allowing them to earn revenue, and of course, the recent deal news corp has made with Google directly to help pay for some of its journalism.
These are all incentive structures that might encourage arguably the type of content Sky News Australia has been posting to its YouTube channel. I mean, you could argue too that it's broadcast, television, sort of terrestrial, television component is just a feed-off for YouTube rather than the other way around. So there's a lot of questions here, I think, we need to look at more broadly than just the University here in Australia, but also how our media outlets interact with the platforms where they now make money and where they are often finding the most eyeball. Right, Bernard, do you?
The self-regulation is never a good idea, no. I mean, money is involved because there's always been a money always outweigh the incentive to self-regulate. And we've seen that for a long, long time ago, when God-class has officially called a co-regulatory model, but it's much closer to self-regulation than to effective regulation. But I do think, I mean, I really might point about in a way, the television content that Sky produces is a feeder for its online service.
The business models that our broadcasters and our media companies are moving to are quite different to the old and long-year ones. And we're still stuck with the broadcasting services act, despite being updated routinely in the last 20 years, there's still very much an analog-based approach. I mean, it's still based on things like radio license areas, for example, which is a quite bizarre approach to regulation, but it's a foundation for our whole media ownership structure. So there's no doubt that, but not just about the change in technology.
And there's always been this idea, if we can make the broadcasting services act technology neutral, and some of this is even boasted that they've done that, it's more about the business model, but about the technology itself. And the business model, I think, has evolved rapidly compared to a replodding and old regulatory structure. But the vexing problem in all this is that governments have slightly moved our conductors, reviewers, bureaucrats, all the reviews, inquiries will be held. And by the time they actually get legislation department to address a particular issue, a suite of new issues have emerged.
So it's it's taught us in here. And that complicates the fact that these are not easy issues to deal with, how do you deal with the hybrid online broadcasting entity? The broadcasting services act really isn't structured to deal with that. And in some ways, that creation is meaningless in a regulatory sense, because it doesn't fit neatly into those categories, particularly around trying to determine what kind of requirements do you impose on its content, if any.
Over the years here on Fourth Estate, one of the solutions that's been mentioned again and again to the problems that we're regularly seeing in the media in this country is that we need more diversity within our media. Now, America has a much more diverse media than ours, but it has the same problems of disinformation and propaganda. In fact, I think you could probably argue it's far, far worse than ours. Do you think that greater media diversity would solve the problem we have when we're discussing outfits like Sky or outfits like the news corp?
Ariel, do you first? I think it would be interesting to see what a more diverse landscape in Australia would do in this on this topic. I mean, we have, of course, had a wide range of newspapers, a wide range of radio stations, et cetera, in the past. But it's not quite a good comparison because the internet, of course, was not at such a high level of penetration at that time.
I mean, certainly, there are some little startups. We might say that a lot of individuals, a lot of social media influences are playing a role in this media space. And perhaps we should start including them in the discussion of our information and news ecosystem. But what we've seen there, too, is the issue of accountability.
What happens when you do spread misinformation about COVID, whether it be deliberately or not, how do we enforce a sort of regime of correction of accountability on to this diversity of people that are speaking out and loudly? Because we can't just look at the figures like Trump, of course, as part of the problem, we can't just look at Facebook or YouTube. We also have to look at the role of media in the disinformation cycle. We also need to look at the role of influential people who basically act as their own broadcasters at this point.
I mean, I would count a lot of Australian football as a mini media empire based on the type of and size of the audience they have on platforms like Instagram, YouTube, or even TikTok. So there is a growing diversity, but perhaps it's not in a way that we're entirely comfortable with. Werner, to you? I think diversity can be overstated, funnily enough.
Diversity of outlets is not necessarily going to give you diversity of information. You can have a lot of very left wing outlets, a lot of very monotony outlets. So diversity per se is not necessarily a good policy goal. I think what we've seen overseas, certainly evidence from Europe, suggests that countries with strong public broadcasters tend to feel better, I mean, more against misinformation than others.
That's not necessarily the case of the UK, with very strong public broadcasters. That's not necessarily the case, but it does tend to be the case that strong, respectively, the public broadcasters tend to be a good bulwark against misinformation, if not certainly not the cure. In Australian recent years, of course, the coalition's been attacking the ABC, defunding it, trying to attract its credibility. And the same time they're also handing out more money to Newscorp.
And of course, the attacks on the ABC are at the behest of Newscorp. But having said that, the government has also, and this was part of the 2016 media ownership changes, it has started committing significant amounts of money to smaller and regional publishers and media outlets to support greater diversity at that level, and the full disclosure of the cracking and product media that owns, and one of the beneficiaries of that. And I think that's been a successful way of supporting media diversity, even if at the same time the government's trying to undermine public broadcasting. I think you need both.
Media diversity is good, but what we're doing is very strong media companies, well-resourced, large media companies. And I say that because if you want people to properly hold the powerful account, whether it's government, whether it's corporations, whether it's a powerful part of individuals, you need well-resourced, deep-pocketed media companies that can undertake and resist litigation by the powerful, smaller medium companies for all the YAS, we're plucky and so on. We're not having the kind of deep pockets that we need for a genuine holding of the powerful account, and that kind of mix I think is important rather than diversity per se. Well on that note, I'd like to thank both Ariel Bogle and Bernard Keene for being on For The State.
Thank you. Thank you for listening to For The State. This edition was recorded out the studios of Torsir and heard across the country on the Community Radio Network. For The State is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation, and thanks to the Foundation for their continuing support.
Make sure you subscribe to For The State on your favorite podcast app, so you can hear us talk media, politics and a lot in between. We'll be back in one next week, of course, but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Twitter, I hand all this For The State you. A big thanks as always to my executive producer, Anthony Dofril. My name is Tina Quinn.
Please do stay well and you can catch us next week on For The State.