Thanks for downloading and welcome to Take Aurelie, the podcast from Dream Queen's Medical Centre at Nottingham. In this episode we'll be discussing non-accidental injury, saying the unsayable. As ever more information is correct at the time of recording, all views and opinions of the speaker's own, any and all guidelines mentioned are correct from Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust, other trust guidelines may vary. Hello, welcome back to Take Aurelie and for our second episode on non-accidental injury, today we're going to be talking about saying the unsayable. Once again I'm joined by Dr Colin Gilhooly. Hello Colin. Hello, pleasure to be here. Good. So in the previous episode we talked about sort of red flags and how we're going to start as a clinician to think about non-accidental injury, child abuse and you.
essentially said you always think it and you always want to tick off any of the worrying features and to start being happy with yourself that this is the case. So now we're moving on and I think this is something that I think is particularly challenging without experience and we're calling it insanely unstable and I'm thinking You're thinking it in your mind, how do you even start to bring the subject up in front of a parent slash guardian slash carer? And this is a station, I think, that's used in a lot of OSCEs for this reason, I think, because it's something that comes with seniority, that comes with experience and something that has to be handled well. Yeah, it's challenging, isn't it? It's always challenging because essentially you are breaking bad news. So whether you're saying a patient has cancer, a patient's going to die, telling someone that you suspect that they or someone has hurt their child is an incredibly challenging situation. I think the first thing is to recognise that it is.
Not to share it from it, but to actually say, this is difficult, therefore, before it comes up, I need to be aware of how I'm going to manage it. And like all those situations before that I've mentioned, an open and honest approach is far more important than anything else. Skirting around the side of an object isn't helpful. If you're going to spend a lot of time talking around the edges of it, then your point gets lost very quickly. So I think being open and honest is the most important. The second thing you need to bear in mind is that actually you have a legal responsibility.
when you suspect child abuse of any type to report it. So you have to do it. So this isn't you just doing something off your own back. It is required that if you think that someone might hurt a child in any way, you must follow a set course of action. That gives you a schematic to work from. So when you go in there...
You are not calling social services because you're malicious or you want to hurt anyone or upset them. You're calling them because you're required to do so. It's what your trust requires you to do. It's what the legal system requires you to do. The GMC, whatever. Everyone, okay? You suspect a child. So you need to go in and say this, this and this, whatever they may be. So your child can't move yet and they have a bruise on their chest. Your child can't move yet and has a broken leg.
whenever that situation happens we have to think about whether someone has hurt this child and therefore in that situation we always do X Y and Z okay so there you're being very clear but you're being very open okay and you need to be clear and open about what's gonna why why you're doing what you're doing okay so I mean junior doctors listen to this podcast so I'm thinking you know you're a consultant now in pediatric emergency medicine level would you expect a doctor to start making this decision for themselves? What levels would you still expect them to come to talk to you first? So, from the point of view of child protection, I'm happy to discuss any... if I was working as a consultant in the paediatric emergency department and someone suspected that a child had been abused in any way, I want to know about it. In the same way as I want to know about a sick child.
There is no difference from that point of view, because like you just said, it needs to be handled well, and that doesn't mean that a junior doctor can't handle it well, but actually maybe having a conversation with me might allow us to make a clear plan and approach, and then to be supported through that process. Because I think the key thing is that, yes, maybe it becomes easier with experience, but there's only one way to get experience. So you have to do it, but definitely I would expect to know about it if there was a child who was suspected of child abuse. setting the scene I mean are you going to you've taken the history of examining the child are you going to mention it straight away or are you going to go away get a chaperone think to compose yourself and then go back in I think composing yourself coming out and having a clear plan for what you're going to do is incredibly important like any good communication scenario involves doing it in a focused way in the right environment okay with the right people present okay so whether you get someone like a nurse to go in with you sure making sure maybe someone's looking after the child and you take parents carers whoever's with the child into a room just sit down and just say
what your reasons are for why you suspect it, and therefore what you are required to do. Because like everything, when you think someone's very sick, you're required to give them a set treatment course. You suspect the child's been abused, you need to follow a set plan. Following the plan usually for breaking bad news, it usually follows a firing a warning shot, so this isn't good news, I'm afraid. assessing their knowledge up to that point, so what do you know, I've had a scan, you were looking for a growth, yes, and then saying it in plain English, unfortunately it looks like you have cancer. So that's usually that way. So if we use that sort of pattern of thinking about non-accentral injury and speaking to the parents' guidance and breaking that news, are you going to fire a warning shot? How are you going to approach it?
It's a bit harder to fire a workshop because you're not saying I'm going to break my news in quite the same way but I think saying there's something really important we need to talk about and that is whatever's happened to your child, in the circumstances that we've heard of, means we have to suspect that something may have happened to this child. In that situation, we, as doctors, nurses, health professionals, need to follow a set plan, and that plan is, starts with, a phone call to social services. And that is because your child cannot walk and has fractured a bone in the leg or something like that? No, as multiple linear bruises...
across their lower back in an unusual position that you can't account for whatever the situation might be that's made you suspect it lay it down while you suspect it and lay it down that when you do you have to alert and then the thought that people are going to have in their mind is then you obviously Even if you go through the most non-judgmental way possible and you're being very open, I have to do this, etc. Parents are going to think I'm being accused and they're going to react potentially in an unpredictable manner. So in your experience, I can't go into too much details obviously, but there's a general sort of summary.
How do parents react when you're starting to mention this? So they are obviously all, I would say, upset. But actually, most of them are upset. And if you are open and you explain why, most of them understand that actually you're approaching this from the same direction that they are. Most parents want the best for their children. Most doctors want the best for their patients. So actually, if you say, I need to make sure that I do the best for your child and give them the best possible care, this is part of it.
and then be very clear it's not your job to judge not your job in the emergency department to make this judgment it's just your job to make sure that you do the absolute best of the child in front of you and in the set of circumstances you've been given with this is what needs to happen okay but parents generally yes they are upset but most vast majority don't become angry okay and with a clear explanation of why you're doing it and what the next steps will be will respond in an upset but reasonable fashion. Occasionally they become upset, but that is actually the minority. So they might be shocked, they might be... But there's often a lot of understanding, that actually, yeah, I kind of get it, you've got a job to do, whatever you need to do. Have you ever been in a situation where the perpetrator might have been in that group that you're having that discussion with? Yes. And what's that like?
challenging but the important thing is at that moment in time you don't know any of that information okay and you're not there to judge okay but you may have during the course of you know so this child has injured themselves while this guardian or parent was responsible for them and it's becoming apparent as we're taking their history that that parent or guardian was off doing something else at that point so there may be so you may have one of the parents looking at the other one going you know potentially but I think in that situation it's important to stay professional remember that you are there to provide high level care for the child and regardless of what's happened to that child Most parents, well, all parents or carers love their child, okay? So even if someone has hurt or injured them, that parent is still a victim as well because they've got an injured child. And it's important not to forget that, okay? And your job is to support that child and the parents around it. And that's kind of the challenge of paediatrics. And actually, yes, you've got to look into all of this and you can do all the professional stuff like that, but you've still got to keep yourself clear, level-headed, and make sure you look after everyone. Okay. And then I suppose...
Is it a similar format, I suppose, if something is disclosed to you? So say even if it's not, you know, some young person has come in complaining of a headache and then whilst you're alone with them is disclosed that there's some form of abuse going on and actually that's the reason they're here. Are you following the same pattern again, just saying this has been disclosed? Yeah. So I think it's important to think about the age of the child and...
speak to them to ensure that you get them on side and in those circumstances with the child I will always say to them anything you say to me is in confidence because I'm your doctor unless I'm worried that someone's hurting you or anybody else because as soon as someone's hurting a child or anybody else that becomes a social care issue and it needs to be fully investigated so being upfront and honest and ensuring that you've done that early on is important to make sure you build a strong relationship with the child as well as that the other thing that's important is to guide parents, carers, child on the timeframe of these things. So when you refer to social care, that can often start quite a lengthy process. Nothing happens quickly, does it? And being upfront about that, so that they know that they're going to be in hospital for a long time or for hours or whatever, and it's not just going to be 30 minutes, is really important. Because if they know all the information upfront, then it does make it easier. Otherwise, they feel that something's been kept from them, and as soon as you get into that environment, then things can escalate quite quickly.
So what about situations? I know children and young people may not have the same perspective on things. What if they're saying, oh, don't say anything, they'll hurt me? Or you have worries about yourself? I mean, we already talked in the previous podcast about the risk of escalation. So what can we do? Oh, don't, he or she will hurt me if you mention it. Obviously, we have to mention it. So what can we do about that if we actually think about imminence danger? So at the moment, the child's in the emergency department and is around, so the child is at that moment in time safe. If the child's saying that to you, then it becomes clear that actually that child is unlikely to be safe.
to go home with those carers or the particular perpetrator of it. So therefore, that information needs to be handed over to social care so that they can provide their full assessment and make a plan that involves the child being left in a place that is safe. So whether that's in a short-term foster placement, with a family member, in an environment where the perpetrator doesn't have access to that child, whatever it might be, if that's the information you've got, then you have a responsibility to make sure that that information ensures the child is put in a safe place. And this social character, that's a 24-7? 24-7 thing, there is always a duty social worker on call, 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
There are obviously specific named doctors for safeguarding within your trust if you need advice, and in Nottingham there is a consultant on for child protection and at ours there's a paediatric registrar on call. I'd make it clear though that if you suspect it, your job is to refer it to social services, not to call the paediatrician. It's the job of the social services to then call the paediatric registrar or the paediatrician on call for safeguarding to make a plan for a full child protection medical to be done. you're the doctor in A&E, you speak to social services, you speak to the family, social services will come up with that plan, they will speak to relevant people, that is not your job. Correct. Depending on the injury, you might need other specialties. Yes, if you've got a fracture, etc. Great. What about, so we're involving social services, is there ever cause that we need to let the police know, or is that always through social services as well? Often the police can get involved through that. Obviously, depending on the type of injury and how it occurred, then the police have a role to play.
We often, with the injuries we see, it needs a full assessment and a child protection medical to make a decision on, and make a clear decision on whether it's a non-accidental injury. But there are some things in which a child will have been so severely injured, even if you don't know why, that the police need to be involved for that matter. So you think about, even in adults, a stab wound is an automatic referral to the police. Significant injury where there might be life-changing events the police would normally want to know about them. clear and obvious, you might have a history that might say that mum saw dad punch the child several times. Now, that child may need a child protection medical, but there's a clear history of someone being assaulted. Now, that's a police issue whether you're four years old or 40 years old. So I think that's a slightly different kettle of fish. Certainly in children, anyone under 18, whether it's been raised and someone has stated that someone has harmed the child, that is a police matter as well as a social care answer. Okay. And that would be through A&E, making that police call? Yeah.
Okay, great, okay. And so including in that then as well, it's not just our own patient, but with that social care referral saying there are other siblings available, not available, present, who we would also have other issues with. The patient may have said, oh yes, they also injure my brother or sister, etc. That needs to be mentioned as well, because it's not just our patient in front of us, it could be their siblings who are also there. So I think when you're referring to social care, it's incredibly important to be very clear. So this is like when we said we were talking to the parents, carers, whoever it might be. I said, be explicit. You need to be explicit with social care about what your worries are.
When you pick up the phone and you speak to them, you say, I have a child who can't walk a crawl who has a bruise. That can't be explained. I have no history of why it happened. Therefore... needs to be investigated. I have a child of fracture, I have no history of why it happened, you need to come see it. Or they're non-ambulant and they've got a fracture. Regardless of story, actually, this needs to be fully investigated. And tell them why you've called them. Sometimes you can tell them a story, but you're not actually telling them exactly why you called them. So it's important you're clear in your mind why you've called them and you get that information across. Like an ESPAR referral? Correct. They want to know the names and dates of birth of everyone who lives in the house. So before you go, make sure you're taking names and dates of birth of everyone who lives in the house. Relations and all that.
OK, so that's just some tips on making sure you've got the right information and that you're being very clear when you call them. You said it's very, very rare, but what if you encounter some hostility? What if there's some absconding? You said this is a long process. What if the patient is gone or some of the relatives have gone during this process while we're waiting to hear back from social care? Any tips? If the patient has absconded, let's start there because that's probably quite an easy one, and you're worried about whether that child has been subject to child abuse, so you're worried about them not being safe with the people who are looking after them, then that's an easy decision, then the police need to bring the child back. Cool.
I thought that'd be a simple one. Give me a description, this is where they are, this is their press. Pick them up, bring them back. The second one about if you have hostility, I think the few things to say are... I know that you want the best for your child, I want the best for your child and in these six circumstances I need to make sure that I have done my best and I am required to do this by law and to be very clear that you're not making an individual's decision out of manners but actually you are required to do this, this is a legal requirement on you so you have to do it okay because what you're trying to do is just have a clear explanation okay tell them actually parents regardless of whether they hurt their child or not generally love their kid and they want the best for them And so it's important to try and show that you actually are coming about this from the same way of wanting the best for the child. Hard to argue with that. And the next thing is to make sure that when you went in there, you went in there with some support and in a safe place. It's rare that people get that. They're angry about the whole situation. They're frustrated by the whole situation. They're in an unfamiliar environment. Trying to relate to them and give them some control back is also incredibly important. So your simple things for how they escalate are incredibly important in this situation. Give them some control. Give them options.
Would they like a drink or something to eat? Never offer them a drink because that's a yes or no question. Offer them drink or food. Then they have to choose one or the other, but they still get to make a choice. Okay. Do they want a hot drink or a cold drink? Yeah. Okay. And when you offer them a cold drink, and then automatically you give them the ability to answer three questions and have some control back. So simple de-escalating techniques for all situations are really important. Give people some control, because that's normally why they're escalating, because they feel the situation is out of their control. Sure. And I think from a legal point of view, because obviously they have parental responsibility for their child, can we ever say, I want you out of my department, you're being obstructive, you're being abusive, etc. Can we do that? So it's a last resort, isn't it? Because actually you're trying to keep, you want to try and keep your relationship with family and carers going.
because it is important you're trying to keep the child relaxed and even if you're worried about what has happened to that child generally with their parents or carers children feel more comfortable it should be a last resort okay but it is important that you consider the safety of yourself staff and all of the children within the department and if that is compromised or put a risk actually you need to restore that and make sure that safety is paramount for everyone okay so if it's a situation where safety is being compromised for anyone then you can but you've got to understand that there are implications for doing so and use it as a last resort So do you have any resources in mind anywhere we can signpost our listeners to for any further information? So mention it on the last podcast. The Royal College of Pediatrics and Child Health has a huge amount of resources on their website that you can use. There is also a lovely article. It's quite old now, I think. It was published.
I think it's the general of the American Family Physician, but it's about the approach and management of child abuse. And it goes through the different types, tells you about the risk factors, talks about the different approach. It is an American one, so it tells you how to contact children's and family services, I think, as opposed to social care that we have here. But it gives you some useful tips and tricks. And that's available online. So it's Child Abuse Approach and Management from 2010. And who wrote it? Colleen Kelly, I think. Colleen Kelly. Cool. Okay.
Thank you so much, I think this is a challenging subject but I think we've shown that you can handle it in a professional manner and hopefully people having listened to this feel more confident at least in knowing the basics. Hopefully it's made them think about it so they can think about how they would approach it and if you think about it and you practice this before you do it you'll be better because practice makes permanent. If we think of it as rare and then we don't think about it we miss it and then it becomes rarer but it's still out there. So it's that thing of you always have to have it at the front of your mind and be thinking is there anything that makes me suspicious and the majority of time there will not be. But any time that you are, you need to work hard with your history so that you work out whether it's just a suspicion, but actually things make sense, or whether actually there's something that concerns you. And if there is, speak to someone, get some help and support and advice. As I say, I'd prefer someone brought it up with me and talked to me, then they didn't. Fantastic. Thank you so much once again, Colin. Thank you.
That was the Take Orally Non-Accidental Injury Staying the Unsayable podcast. As ever, you can find the blog entry and the Take Visually for this podcast at www.takeorally.com. Remember, you can subscribe to Take Orally on both SoundCloud and iTunes. You can find Take Orally on both Facebook and Twitter. For more information about research and educational opportunities within emergency medicine and acute medicine in major trauma, you can find any way to dream on both Facebook and Twitter.