EPISODE · Sep 23, 2025 · 11 MIN
Obsession, Betrayal & Bullets: The Amy Fisher Scandal
from Unsolved & Unhinged
She was just 16. He was a married man twice her age. Their affair ended with a gunshot that shook America. This is the true story of Amy Fisher—the teenage “Long Island Lolita”—whose jealous rage nearly killed Mary Jo Buttafuoco and exposed the darkest corners of suburban life. Join us as we peel back the sensational headlines and uncover the truth: lust, betrayal, survival, and the scandal that would never be forgotten.
Embed this episode
Ready to play
Obsession, Betrayal & Bullets: The Amy Fisher Scandal
0:00
11:24
1×
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
No similar episodes found.
Similar Podcasts
Without a Trace
Laura Kite
On Without a Trace we shine a light on unknown and unsolved cases, raising awareness and drawing attention to the victims that society forgets or ignores. We provide a well-researched and honest discussion, considering the potential social, cultural and political context behind these crimes.
Nighttime Scary Tales
Horror Camp
Welcome to Nighttime Scary Tales, where nightmares come alive. We bring you a chilling blend of expertly crafted spooky fiction and meticulously researched bone-chilling true crime. Each episode is designed to haunt your thoughts long after the credits roll.Prepare for a descent into the darkest corners of human experience and imagination. Dive deep into unsettling psychological horror, supernatural encounters, and dark fantasy. At the same time, we explore infamous cold cases, unsolved mysteries, and macabre historical events that prove truth is often scarier than fiction. Nighttime Scary Tales is an immersive auditory experience perfect for your commute, late-night listening, or whenever you crave a dose of the macabre. The podcast delivers a unique twist of existential dread, prompting you to question the very nature of humanity and reality itself.If you are a fan of dark fantasy, true crime, and the truly unexplained, this is the perfect podcast for you. Sub
True Crime Arizona
Briana Whitney
Arizona’s Family journalists Briana Whitney and Serjio Hernandez take a deep dive into both unsolved and solved cases around Arizona — retracing steps, uncovering new evidence, and revealing new theories from those involved in the investigations.
Military Murder
Mama Margot Productions LLC
Do military true crime headlines leave you hungry for every detail? Dive into your next mystery with Military Murder.Every Monday, host Mama Margot - lawyer by day, storyteller by night - brings you in-depth accounts of infamous and underreported military crime cases. With over 16 years of active military service, Margot bridges the gap between the battlefield (or just basic military life) and the courtroom, so you won't have to hunt down details across countless sources - Margot does the digging for you.Since its debut in 2019, Military Murder has been the destination for 100s of gripping stories that illuminate the darker side of military service. On the show, you'll hear about cold cases, unsolved cases, and cases which received little, if any, media coverage. If you're passionate about true crime with a military twist, welcome home!Follow along and join a community of dedicated Militar
Frequently Asked Questions
How long is this episode of Unsolved & Unhinged?
This episode is 11 minutes long.
When was this Unsolved & Unhinged episode published?
This episode was published on September 23, 2025.
Can I download this Unsolved & Unhinged episode?
Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.
URL copied to clipboard!