Skip to content
Officer Bagley's Timeline Doesn't Match? Here's What We Found episode artwork

Jul 29, 2026 1 hr 10 min

Officer Bagley's Timeline Doesn't Match? Here's What We Found

from Reasonable Arguments® Hosted by Jennifer Bash

What does not add up in Officer Chris Bagley’s testimony? In the first episode of our series, **The Case Against Tyler Robinson**, Jamie and I break down Bagley’s testimony from the Tyler Robinson preliminary hearing and examine the timeline, body-camera footage, evidence handling, and investigative decisions that deserve a much closer look. Jamie had not followed the case, so he came into the testimony with fresh eyes. I had already spent hours reviewing it, and as we worked through Bagley’s answers, the questions kept piling up. Why was he vague about when his shift began but extremely specific about other times? Where did the police tape come from? Who was the unidentified armed man with a badge who accompanied him to the roof? Why did Bagley’s body-camera battery die during one of the most important parts of the investigation? And do his actions match what should have happened after a shooting on a crowded college campus? We are not simply recapping the hearing. We are examining what was said, what was not explained, and whether the testimony actually supports the case being presented against Tyler Robinson. This is Episode 1 of **The Case Against Tyler Robinson**, our ongoing series dissecting each witness from the preliminary hearing. Watch through the end and tell us what stood out to you most in Bagley’s testimony. Subscribe so you do not miss the next witness breakdown. #TylerRobinson #ChrisBagley #PreliminaryHearing #CourtTestimony #TrueCrimePodcast #LegalAnalysis #crimeinvestigation Chapters 00:00 Introduction to the case and hearing 02:06 Overview of the police testimony and key witnesses 04:01 Analysis of the police officer's observations and actions 09:51 Discussion of the evidence collection and scene preservation 14:56 Examining the timeline of events and suspect movements 20:02 Questions about the forensic evidence and interpretations 25:02 Implications of the investigation procedures and conclusions 29:50 Summary of key insights and unanswered questions 02:37 Analysis of the police officer's testimony on evidence handling 04:59 Discrepancies in body camera footage and timing 08:11 Questions about suspect custody and scene security 11:45 Implications of evidence management and procedural concerns 14:56 Summary of key findings and unresolved questions

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Officer Bagley's Timeline Doesn't Match? Here's What We Found

0:00 1:10:57

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Speaking to Politics Mike Politics shape our world. The issues being decided in the halls of government every day have real and lasting impact on all our lives, but discussing politics is extremely unpleasant. It is very difficult today to have a calm, adult conversation about politics. Are the people screaming on TV, the radio, and online really who “we” are? Are they really representative of mainstream America or are they just really aggressive and loud? I believe the adults just got tired of it and walked away, but their silence is not consent. This podcast is the test of that theory. If you see fit to tune in, I will present news of the day, analysis and commentary while doing my best to check my feelings at the door and let you, the listeners, decide what it means to you. No ominous music, no angry rants, just a relaxed conversation and positive vibe. Politics, for reasonable people. We the People National Constitution Center A weekly show from the National Constitution Center hosted by Julie Silverbrook and Tom Donnelly where listeners can hear the best arguments on all sides of the constitutional issues at the center of American life. Cases and Controversies Bloomberg Law Bloomberg Law's Cases and Controversies brings you the latest from the Supreme Court. Each week we preview oral arguments at the Court or feature in-depth interviews. We explore critical legal issues with Supreme Court advocates, judges, law professors, lawyers, and legal journalists. Departures with Robert Amsterdam Amsterdam & Partners LLP Departures is a literary podcast featuring half-hour interviews with nonfiction authors covering a diverse range of subjects, from geopolitics to law, to history, international affairs, and current events. Hosted by international lawyer Robert Amsterdam, founder of Amsterdam & Partners LLP, Departures brings listeners into casual but revealing conversations with our favorite authors, bringing light to new ideas, arguments, and issues deserving of consideration outside of the usual narratives of the news cycle.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Reasonable Arguments®?

This episode is 1 hour and 10 minutes long.

When was this Reasonable Arguments® episode published?

This episode was published on July 29, 2026.

Can I download this Reasonable Arguments® episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.