EPISODE · Apr 17, 2026 · 50 MIN
Ohio_s Most Wanted Serial Killer _ The New Detectives
from FilmRise True Crime · host FilmRise True Crime
A tree stump holding three dismembered bodies. A thirteen-year-old girl tied up in a basement. A Walmart bag that cracked the case wide open. The most wanted man in Ohio was hiding in plain sight.Matthew Hoffman did not wake up planning to become a multiple murderer. He was burglarizing a home in Knox County when the residents returned unexpectedly. Tina Herrmann, her eleven-year-old son Kody, and family friend Stephanie Sprang were all stabbed to death. Their bodies were dismembered and stuffed inside a hollow tree in the Kokosing Wildlife Preserve [citation:1]. Thirteen-year-old Sarah Maynard was held captive for days in Hoffman's basement before being rescued by a SWAT team [citation:1].The break came from a single detail. A Walmart bag containing tarps and trash bags was found in the victim's garage. Surveillance video showed Hoffman buying those items. A state database search of the car seen at Walmart returned Hoffman's name on the first page of hits [citation:1]. Prosecutor's later dropped the death penalty to secure a confession. Hoffman wrote a letter describing the murders, the weapon, his attempt to burn the house, and even killing the family dog [citation:1]. He is serving life without parole.Turn down the lights, put on your headphones, and press play because the monster asked for pictures of the tree to prove it was still alive.
What this episode covers
A tree stump holding three dismembered bodies. A thirteen-year-old girl tied up in a basement. A Walmart bag that cracked the case wide open. The most wanted man in Ohio was hiding in plain sight.Matthew Hoffman did not wake up planning to become a multiple murderer. He was burglarizing a home in Knox County when the residents returned unexpectedly. Tina Herrmann, her eleven-year-old son Kody, and family friend Stephanie Sprang were all stabbed to death. Their bodies were dismembered and stuffed inside a hollow tree in the Kokosing Wildlife Preserve [citation:1]. Thirteen-year-old Sarah Maynard was held captive for days in Hoffman's basement before being rescued by a SWAT team [citation:1].The break came from a single detail. A Walmart bag containing tarps and trash bags was found in the victim's garage. Surveillance video showed Hoffman buying those items. A state database search of the car seen at Walmart returned Hoffman's name on the first page of hits [citation:1]. Prosecutor's later dropped the death penalty to secure a confession. Hoffman wrote a letter describing the murders, the weapon, his attempt to burn the house, and even killing the family dog [citation:1]. He is serving life without parole.Turn down the lights, put on your headphones, and press play because the monster asked for pictures of the tree to prove it was still alive.
NOW PLAYING
Ohio_s Most Wanted Serial Killer _ The New Detectives
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
Jun 20, 2026 ·2m
Jun 20, 2026 ·2m
Jun 15, 2026 ·3m
Jun 15, 2026 ·3m
Jun 14, 2026 ·2m
Jun 14, 2026 ·2m