Welcome to the weekend edition of The Daily Stoic. Each weekday we bring you a meditation inspired by the ancient Stoics, something to help you live up to those four stoic virtues of courage, justice, temperance, and wisdom. And then here on the weekend we take a deeper dive into those same topics. We interview stoic philosophers, we explore at length how these stoic ideas can be applied to our actual lives and the challenging issues of our time.
Here on the weekend when you have a little bit more space when things have slowed down, be sure to take some time to think, to go for a walk, to sit with your journal, and most importantly to prepare for what the week ahead may bring. The biggest political media scandal of our time since everybody's talking about it. Journalist Olivia Nuzzi had to resign from her job at New York Magazine because it was revealed that she was having an affair with RFK Jr. Hey, it's Ryan Holiday.
Welcome to another episode of The Daily Stoic Podcast. I know a thing or two about falling under the sway of people that you look back and you go, what? That's insane. What was I thinking?
I look back on my early 20s and I'm proud of some of it and I'm not proud of other parts of it. I talk about some of it. I don't talk about some of it. You know about some of it.
Maybe you don't know about some of it. I wrote about a bunch of it and trust me, I'm mine, which came out back in 2012. It's sort of an exposé and a tell-all slash memoir about my ride through the media and marketing and PR system and the sort of mid-aute web 2.0 bloggy world. It was crazy.
I screwed up. I look back and I go, what was I doing working for some of these people? What was driving me? I mean, in retrospect, this stuff becomes clear, right?
It was clearly imprinting on some of these figures, like that were powerful and successful and controversial and they seemed competent. They seemed smart. They had like an energy that I went to like a moth to the flame. I took Charni being one.
A guy who was brilliant and provocative and creative and a genius in many ways and then tragic and flawed and dark and ultimately quite a scary figure in other ways. I remember towards the end, you know, when he was fired by the board of directors and these investigations, I remember, you know, life was threatened. I remember checking my car for bugs. It was a crazy period.
I would just go, how did I get here? What happened? What was I thinking? And, you know, it's not just like it was inexplicable.
Like it had consequences for people. I did things that I shouldn't have done. I talked about this encourages calling actually, like where I got asked to do this thing that was not just illegal, but like morally repugnant. And I didn't do it, but I didn't exactly resign in protest.
And I didn't because I was scared. I didn't because I didn't want to lose my salary. I didn't want to get fired. Like in retrospect, it's obvious.
Like, why would you want to keep a job that not doing something illegal could get you fired from? But when you're twisted up in it, when you're in the moment, when you have made compromises along the way, when you've turned your eye away from things along the way, when you've said things publicly, you get twisted up, you get upside down, you get in over your head. So do I regret that period of my life? I mean, yeah, I also obviously understand that it was formative.
It shaped me. I wouldn't be here if that hadn't happened. So I guess I'm just saying it's complicated and something I'm still dealing with and processing. My own role in it, what I did, what was done to me, what I should have done differently, what I learned, what I took out of it, which is basically all that you can do in life.
And we all have our own versions of that. It's not an excuse. It's an explanation. And I say all this to Segway, to today's guest, who I've known for a while.
I appeared in one of her stories once because someone she was writing about had read, trust me, online. And we've gone back and forth every once in a while. I'm a big fan of her writing. And you've probably read some of her pieces too.
I mean, her pieces drove the news cycle many instances over the last decade or so. When Donald Trump first met Olivia Newsy as she writes in her new book, American Contone, she says, Trump looked me up and down and said, very young, very beautiful. And then the same person, when she wrote a piece that he didn't like, tweeted that the reporter was a shaky and unattractive whack job known as tough. But dumb is a rock who actually wrote a decent story about me a long time ago.
Her name is Olivia Newsy. I guess what I'm saying, if you have no idea who this person is, is that she's been on a wild ride. Here, so I guess we don't usually talk about the events of the news. We don't break news.
We don't talk about scandal. Or, gosh, we talk about ancient philosophy. We talk about timeless lessons. We talk about being a person in the world.
If you know anything about Olivia's story, you know, well, she got herself into some trouble. In fact, she was supposed to record this like a week ago, but she was in the middle of parting ways with Vanity Fair, the second sort of shoe to drop in a series of shoes to drop in the last year or so. She talks about all of this in her book, American Contone, which I will read the first sense in the back cover. It's a mesmerizing first-hand account of the warping of American reality over the past decade as Donald Trump has risen to dominance from a participatory witness who got so far inside the distortion field that it swallowed her whole.
Olivia Newsy spent a third of her life observing those in power. She became a reporter in 2014 when the political landscape began to reconfigure itself around a singular personality whom she was uniquely primed to understand. Over the next 10 years, she used her access and eye for detail to chronicle his campaigns, trials, and government in blockbuster future stories that drove the national conversation, propelled her to the heights of her profession. Then, in 2024, her personal life collided with the public interest in a scandal that cost Newsy her job and reputation.
Amid a full-blown tabloid frenzy, Newsy went quiet, drove west, and spent the next year in self-imposed exile at the edge of the country, where she wrote this searing and astonishingly clear-eyed account of what she and we have experienced over the last decade. I will say this book is actually very good. I thought the reviews did it a complete disservice. I don't know what exactly is motivating.
Some of those reviewers and writers, I don't know what exactly people wanted, but I thought as a piece of writing, I say this as a person who has written books, written a book about media and their own role in it. And as a person who owns a bookstore and loves this genre of writing, I think it's actually a fantastic book. I think it's worth reading. Like so many of her articles are worth reading.
I'll give you a couple famous ones. I examined Donald Trump's ear and his soul at Mar-a-Lago, the conspiracy of silence to protect Joe Biden, and then the one that ultimately led to the events that we will be speaking about directly and indirectly in today's interview, the mind-bending politics of RFK Jr's spoiler campaign. So look, if you know about the story or don't know about the story, let me tell you sort of what to expect in this interview. I'm not holding their feet to the fire.
I'm not in paragating her. I'm not that interested in the specifics in the gossip or that did this happen? What about this? And why didn't you do this?
I am just interested in what it is like to be a person on one side of something like this. What happens when, what this notion called the passions, overwhelm your faculties, your values, your decision-making process, and you get yourself into real trouble? What happens when, again, another ancient term, you unleash the furies of the public's sense of injustice upon yourself, right? What would it feel like to be publicly shamed?
What does it feel like to lose your perch at the top of your profession, both deservedly and undeservedly for things you did do and things you didn't do? We talk about the difference between guilt and shame. We talk about who leans in and who leans out in situations like this, how you learn to trust yourself. When you have a pattern of behavior or thinking that does not serve you well, that gets you into trouble.
I don't know how much more I need to introduce this. I think it's a great interview. I think the book is great. As I said, she signed a bunch of copies.
We have them at the Painted Porch. You can go back and read some of her writing. She's worth following on social media, on Instagram. She's at OliviaNusiX, paradoxically, Twitter.
She's at OliviaNusi. And thank you to Olivia for coming out. She didn't have to do this interview. She didn't have to reschedule this interview when her life blew up like a second or third time.
But you came out to Austin to do it. Then we walked around the Painted Porch, the video of that bookstore walkthrough, posted up on YouTube here probably tomorrow maybe. I'm glad this happened. Seems like she's doing better than I would have expected.
So that's good to hear for people who are following very closely, who are angry or worked up about it. I would say I get it. Like I'm pretty, as I say in the interview, pretty understanding of people who get themselves into situations like this. Because I've been there at least a little bit myself.
But also there's no one who is less of a big fan of the other person involved in this than me. I mean, I think he's one of the chief villains of our time. I think he's done unimaginable harm. I shudder for young children, not just here in America, but in the developed world that's sort of just finally wrong and dangerous and deranged things.
He is done to not just like the medical system, but the public good that is public health and the public good that is our information about public health. So I am not a fan. In fact, I will say just a little inside baseball. Back in February of 2024, somebody asked me if I wanted to come to this like dinner he was at with a bunch of other podcasters and maybe he'd come on the show.
And I said thanks for the note. Hope you're doing well. I could not in good conscience attend, let alone donate money in support of someone who has spread so much utterly untrue and dangerous nonsense for so long. I wish Mr.
Kennedy nothing but failure and shame because at this point obscurity is too much to hope for. So if I can separate my feelings about that to the human being that was involved in all this and have this conversation, I think you should be able to do that as well. And I feel like I learned a lot. I enjoyed the book.
And as always, I will keep reading what Olivia is writing because she is a great writer. And I hope she keeps doing it. And she signed a bunch of copies of American Conto, which we have at the painted porch. I will link to that in today's show notes, which you can swing by the store on historic Main Street here in Pastor Texas to grab it.
I grabbed mine at the Seattle airport flying back from my talk there. I guess this was Thursday. She was going to do it on Friday. Had to cancel last minute.
We moved it to Saturday and then there's a stuff with Vanity Fair happened. So we canceled it. I wasn't honestly totally sure if it was going to get rescheduled, but I was pleasantly surprised when she popped up at the painted porch here on following Thursday. So that would be I guess two days from now, if you're listening to this on Saturday, when it comes out.
Again, grab signed copies of American Conto from the painted porch or wherever you get the book. She read the audio book, which I'm sure is great. Listen, and let's just get into it. Okay, I have a book for you.
I thought about it as I was reading the book. I'm going to walk you through the books and I'm going to pick out some. This is actually my copy, but I wonder if you read by Grand Central Station. I sat down and wept.
No, I haven't. Do you know about this book? No. Okay, so I was thinking of books that might be interesting to you.
Is it smart? No, no, not that. Elizabeth's smart. Okay, this is the one.
She's in the 40s. She falls in love with this poet. Uh huh. Did it end well?
Well, if she falls in love with this poet, a love is an understatement for this. She falls in love with his married poet. Okay. They have four kids.
Sorry. Her family disowns her. Okay. She is, I think, deported at one point for moral turpitude.
She continues the other family. She's a famous copywriter. She's like, you know, this would be like if Peggy fell in love with Don Draper. Okay.
This really happened. And then she wrote this kind of like fever dream of a novel about it. Cool. Now it's time.
Yeah, she doesn't mention the person's name. She doesn't mention the specifics of it. But it's this beautiful novel about a torrid life-loaning love affair. I can't relate to that at all.
I can't relate to that. Her parents have the book banned in Canada, where she's from. It just like at one point, I mean, she's so infatuated this person. She, he's in London.
She's in America. World War II is happening. And she crosses the Atlantic to go be with him, even though she's risking being killed by a German U-boat. I like the Jews deported.
Yes. She's either deported or it's like a violation of the Man Act like you can't travel car. It's just craziness across the board. Well, I look forward to reading about this foreign experience.
But it's a beautifully written book. It's like the source material is torrid and life-ruining. But the art that comes out of it is beautiful, but also remains totally mystifying. The reason I thought of you and then the reason I was going to ask you about it is like, she's writing what happened.
But I'm wondering as she's writing what happened, does it make any sense to her? Right. Like, do you have that experience? Like, can you look back at the events of the last couple of years and you recognize that person and there's a logic to it?
Or are you just like, it's an out-of-body experience? I wouldn't say there's a logic to it, but there's an illogic to it, I guess. Does that make sense? No.
Tell me. I mean, it's not like I think, oh boy, what happened? It's not like I, you know, fainted in a field of poppies and woke up on the wrong coast or something. But I can look back and see like the suspension of certain critical faculties.
Yeah. And that makes sense to me, but it doesn't make sense. Yes. Right.
Yes, totally. Yeah. Well, there is, I think people think that your life can be heading in the wrong direction, and then you have the sudden epiphany, and then you realize you're heading the wrong direction, and then you change everything. Right now.
And it's usually much more gradual and then even the exiting out of it is gradual, and then the coming to terms with what happened and why it happened and where it could have gone differently. That's gradual too. Well, I felt really grateful for the, I think I write at one point that I felt like the hand of God came and like, swatted me off the path that I was on. And I felt grateful for that.
Like it was abrupt and unpleasant. And, you know, it was not a smooth landing. It was like being ejected from a moving vehicle. But I was grateful for it.
I'm grateful for it now because I thought, well, if that hadn't have happened because it struck me that you don't just wake up one morning and make a huge mistake, right? Yes. Like, necessarily there are many minor or imperceptible mistakes, certainly to just like a misaligned worldview, right? Or just a misshapen path that you're on.
Yeah. And I look back and when I talk about kind of seeing the suspension of critical faculties, I see my dismissing that or dismissing discomfort in my daily life, right? Like dismissing thinking that it was possible and that there would be no penalty for like pushing aside things that I didn't want to deal with. And all of that seemed to sort of accumulate into circumstances or conditions that made an enormous mistake possible.
There's another moment in fiction that I thought of when I was reading a book and then I also thought about it in my own life because I have some experience going down a path that I'm like, what was I thinking? And I missed it. Like, I missed it when I read it in high school. I missed it when I read it a bunch of times.
But in Gatsby, there's this moment where Gatsby comes to Nick when he's trying to get in his good graces and he says like, hey, I know you don't make a ton of money doing what you do. I had maybe this business opportunity you could help me with. And Caraway says like, only later did I realize that that was potentially a pivotal moment in my life. That basically Gatsby was trying to draw him into his world.
And Caraway sort of dismisses it out of hand as he's not interested in it, but that was his chance to enter the underworld, right? And you don't like the moments where you don't do it or you do it. Don't seem significant in the moment. You're not like I'm gambling everything on this because they all feel like small little decisions.
Yeah, and I think I was like this improbable success in a straight world, right? And a lot of my success came from the fact that I didn't play by rules, right? And I was willing to walk into spaces where maybe I shouldn't have been or, you know, use my wits or whims to acclimate myself to the environments. And when you're rewarded for that over and over again, I think it kind of, I guess it created a sort of feedback loop where I write about Icarus.
And someone was asking me about it like some journalists in New York Times I think recently. And their interpretation, which I felt said more about this person as often, interpretations often do, was that I was talking about being close to like other people's power, right? They're going too close to other people's power. But to me, it was just like I had a misunderstanding of my own power, right?
And my own ability to know, I was so used to being right. Yes, and taking risks and those risks paying off rather than blowing up. And people deferring to me, right? Like I got this job at New York Magazine when I think it was like 23 or 24, and I was there for swashing in correspondent.
And I had never been a Washington correspondent, never covered in my house. And luckily the guy in the White House had never been there before either, right? And there were some great things about having a fresh perspective, but there were also perilous things about that, right? But it's a collaborative environment where there are photographers who've been there since like the Carter administration.
You could say, is that normal? Oh, yeah, this always happens or no, this has never happened before. But I was used to, you know, I'd say, what do I do about this? Like my other dirty and she even figured out, like, and I'd be like, okay.
And then I would figure it out. And I was correct most of the time, right? And I got, I think it contributed to just this incorrect view that I didn't have to police my own judgments, right? Or I didn't have to second guess myself as it related to my calculations about right and wrong, whether or not a risk was a good one or whether or not there was a, when I was acting out of ego or fear or selflessness or whatever.
And I think that kind of accumulates into this misconfigured worldview. When you're not exactly surrounded by people for whom strong black and white moral judgments and retitude is a big priority. I imagine it's destabilizing being around other people who are also not just bending the rules, but questioning why there are rules at all. Or just ignoring it's not only questioning the rules, it's just rejecting the premise of the rules, right?
Yeah. And I mean, I've said this before, but it's like Trump's lawlessness that lawlessness animates the whole spirit of the place that might be, right? And you feel like in order, it's like every company needs a criminal, you have to kind of get inside the mind and the lawlessness inspires lawlessness. And yeah, I mean, a lot of the book is about perception, right?
And it's about the distortion of reality. And I was trying to accurately reflect the fantasmic worry, right? And what it just has felt like to be here and from my vantage point, right? Yes, I had a moment like that.
So people are listening, they don't know why. And I worked for a bunch of controversial people over the years. And this was a messy, exciting period in my early and mid-20s. And like, I remember I read this book, again, another work of fiction, which I do think sometimes fiction gets to the truth of it more than nonfiction can.
But Schuylberg wrote on the waterfront of this book called The Harder They Fall, which is about a boxing promoter and a press agent. Like, so the boxing promoter is corrupt, it's affiliated with the mob. And he says, press agent is formerly a journalist now, he says, press agent. He's sort of in this morally dubious space.
And it's a spoiling ending, it's an amazing book, but it's not really spoilinging. At some point, he says, and he keeps, he's really good at what he does, you know, he's good at placing stories and creating this narrative. They're building this fighter up so he can take a fall. And he says towards the end, you know, I told myself that I could deal in filth and not become the thing that I touched.
When I look back on my own story, I feel like I read that. And that's what changed the trajectory of my life. That I was like, I got to get out of this. Right.
And then I remember I was talking to Tim Miller, who interviewed you. Love Tim. Yeah, it's great. And we were talking about this because we wrote similar sort of confessional books.
And I was like, well, let me go see when I read that book. Yeah. And I read that book in 2009. So I, like many years, like I understood the information I understood where I was playing with.
And then I didn't do anything about it. So we, we can know the information. We can even know that we're walking a tightrope or that we're playing with fire, whatever you want to use. And then it can take us a while to wake up to it.
I think you can understand something intellectually though. It takes a long time to absorb it like enerically and spiritually. But you wrote the book. You were like 25 when you wrote that book.
Yeah, 20 and a half. Right. Yeah. And I reread it when I was writing this.
And I talked to you about some of what I was writing because I was worried, she was talking about, but I was trying to sort out the puzzle of like, how do I deal without feeling like I'm shirking responsibility with things that I was a part of that were kind of just head rotten values or how do I describe those things without feeling like I'm putting blame on anybody else or your own systems or something. And it was really, it was important for me to read that book because I remember reading it years ago and thinking like, man, this guy's crazy. No. Because it's really aggressive stuff to write, but it's like, it's a machine gun of a story, right?
It's like, it's really effective because it's narrow and you're not trying to, you're not throat clearing, right? You're not, you know, it's like the opposite of how I write in some ways, right? And I just, I found it very instructive to kind of be confronted with that on the other side of my mistake. Well, I didn't have any literary abilities.
No, it's not done. It's well done. But I mean, you were like a real book about your experience. And that was, I didn't think I had the capacity then or the sense that anyone was interested in.
And I was just trying to kind of go like, this is all the things that I've seen, isn't this bucked up? Yeah, I mean, there's urgency to the style, right? I guess that's what I was trying to describe. Yeah.
Is that something you wrestled with? Like, because I know I did with the book where you're like, I'm indicting a system, which I am also a part of. And there's kind of a, that's a tricky position to be in. I wrote this profile.
It was my favorite piece I ever did at New York Magazine. It was about an anonymous Republican and one of the many anonymous Republicans who would kind of shut talked on Trump during the first Trump administration, but was a part of the system, right? And part of that story, and it was part of what informs the choices I made in this book. But part of the story was about how I think I say something to the effect of like, the press provides the alibi as it prosecutes the case, right?
Like it was selfishly in my immediate interests to rely on people such as that. Yeah. Even though every time I would rely on an anonymous person, such as that, I was further kind of cementing that system of anonymous contradiction with on the record behavior or decisions and helping to perpetuate this system that's bad for people, right? And probably bad for American society and that was getting worse.
And it's not something I wrestled with necessarily with this book, but like I wanted to make sure that none of my decisions, I had rules for myself for surviving spiritually, like a scandal in public shaming. And among the rules were just, you know, everything has to be from love, not for love, right? I could never use anyone as a human shield. I could never spare myself and harm someone else.
My first order was to have dignity amid my big, dignity or honor amid my dishonor or handle my ethics scandal ethically, right? And I wanted to make sure I wasn't making any decisions on the page that conflicted with those principles or that anything that was coming from fear or coming from ego and just, you know, like the classic showing not telling, right? I mean, that sort of was the standard the whole way through. Usually when people are thinking about supplements or training, they're thinking about recovery, they're thinking about protein, they're thinking about creatine.
But one of the most overlooked pieces is gut health. If your gut is not dialed in, everything else struggles to work the way it should. And that's where Momentous fiber plus comes in. Momentous fiber plus addresses one of the most overlooked foundations of long-term performance.
That is gut health because fiber is not just about digestion. It's the key driver of gut health, which directly impacts a bunch of things, nutrient absorption, energy stability, recovery, focus mood, and overall performance. Momentous fiber plus is a complete three in one formula with soluble fiber in soluble fiber and prebiotic resistant starch. Like everything Momentous makes fiber plus is built with a science first formulation, clean and minimal ingredients and no artificial additives or artificial flavors.
And right now, Momentous is offering our listeners up to 35% off your first order with promo code daily stoic. Head over to livemomentus.com use promo code daily stoic for up to 35% off your first order. That's livemomentus.com promo code daily stoic. I heard you say that somewhere that you were trying to get through a dishonorable thing, honorably.
What does that mean to you? I mean, I was thinking a lot about honor, right? When you're being rightfully, in that case, ridiculed, you're prompted a lot to think about what you did wrong. And to assess what you did wrong to assess what went wrong.
And I think there's something very interesting about a crisis, like a public drama, where everyone gets kind of distilled to their essential, like the lawyers are their most larry, the press people are their most press people. And I felt like my impulse to not sort of judge anyone by their worst behavior kept running to conflict with the fact that I felt like, well, it's like people who drink if you drink and you're like an angry mean drunk, that always scares me about people, because I think, oh, that's probably is revealing something essential to their character that otherwise is not accessible or that they're able to kind of keep it on. And I don't think it's a small thing, right? And I guess it's the same under the kind of external stress of a scandal or public crisis, where I just felt like I was experiencing a lot of people making selfish decisions that were dishonest and like just screwed up.
But I didn't want to do that. And I was a lot of me like having to assess really quickly, okay, I'm going to accept this short term discomfort, short term pain rather than eternal suffering, right? And it's actually easy to do that. It's interesting that you would respond that way because I think the fundamental innovation, if you want to call that of this moment in culture, is that people have figured out that if you dispense with honor or shame, it's actually a hack for getting out of scandals and triumphing over them.
Like if you just throw out any sense of personal accountability, if you refuse to cast a stone at yourself, if you just pretend it didn't happen, actually a lot of the mechanisms that we have as a society for holding people accountable for things, because most of what is a scandal is not actually illegal, you can kind of survive. And that's, I mean, there's always been shameless people, but that's kind of a new phenomenon. I mean, shamelessness like animates public life in America now in a way that I think it feels not new, but it feels like an exaggeration from how I remember it in the Bush era or something of my youth. But a lot of people told me like, just keep going basically, like these guys don't care.
You shouldn't care either. You should just take whatever assignment to go cover the end of the election. And it was an attractive thought. I was like, oh, like, can I just, I could just pretend this didn't happen.
And then like my insistence that it doesn't matter will eventually like manifest, right? And then Jeffrey Tuben columns and then your times. Well, I don't think there should be. I'm just saying like, there are people whose things happen and they just keep doing what they're doing.
But unlike with Tuben, like I did something wrong, right? Those ethics rules are really important. They exist for a reason. And I ran afoul of those rules.
And in that way, I hurt the whole industry. And I took that seriously, the kind of like public part of what I had done wrong. And then privately, like morally spiritually, I took it really seriously. It just seemed like this, it was a big deal.
Like it wasn't even if people were like, oh, who cares? And you know, a few people who were expressing something like that, I cared. I cared. I did something wrong.
And I knew better. And I didn't do better. And like that struck me as like, well, it struck me. Right?
And it just seemed like something I needed to take seriously. And I just couldn't really, I couldn't really like entertain this notion that I would just continue on and continue to, you know, for a second. I was like, okay, yeah, maybe I will go cover the end of the election for like greeting card or whatever. And I just like, it would front of all the main rule of like, I had to be able to live with myself, right?
Where does that come from? Because that, where does that sense come from? Where did you learn that? Where did you pick that up?
You think? I don't know. Do you think that I'm just, is that an innate sense? Is that something you get taught?
Is that a religious connotation? Because it is, it's something that is clearly absent. And I'm just wondering how we lost it or... I don't know what's interesting.
My brother and I were extremely different. Like he's just really, he's more type A. Like he was always in sports and he's a more disciplined person in a lot of ways, like a lot of overt ways. And are in a lot of ways our parents were not very disciplined people, right?
Like they struggle with addiction. My mother struggled with mental illness and they both died young. And they were sort of wildly irresponsible in a lot of ways, right? But they were really good people.
And they were really like, in ways that I couldn't have appreciated at the time that each of them died. Like I think most girls who were like who really valorize their father. I assume, when he died, I kind of assumed I was creating him on a curve. You know, like, I wasn't going to interrogate it too hard.
I just kind of thought like, I'm one part of my brain, very tiny voice. Like I'm probably overstating things, right? But that's okay. And I didn't really know very many people.
You know, he died when I was like 21, 22. And then as time went on, the more people I met and the more that I just like was on this planet. The more I came around to feeling like, oh, you know, he was remarkable. In all the ways that I thought, and in ways that I didn't know enough to appreciate.
And the way that they both were disciplined was like, they were both really hard workers. And they were both, there was a certain honesty to the way that they lived and the way that they tried their best to like be here, right? And I guess, so I see that with my brother too, where like for him, you know, manifesto more is just like, you know, personal responsibility and like, he doesn't like, but I think I see sort of the same quality in the both of us and like, you have to just deal with the world as it is. Yeah.
And you can't kind of, you can't wish your way out of misfortune, right? Yeah. I mean, that's what I would think. But I don't, I'd not ever want to scribe to that clearly.
No, I mean, is that your problem? No, it's not my problem. But it's just, it's an interesting, when that was a widely held societal belief, it acts as a check. And it's weirdly, that's actually the fourth estate, not journalism.
Like one's sense of shame or honor or reputation or one's ability to be like, yeah, I guess I did fuck up. That's actually what journalism was invoking because the idea that like, hey, if I get caught that will look bad and I care about whether I look bad, as opposed to I only care if people who like me like me or whatever. And so like, there's a playbook now, right? It's like, you fuck up or you're, you sense of bad stories coming.
It's like, you call this like the Russell Brand playbook, like just become a right-winger. Or conversely, if you're a right-winger, you're like, actually become a never-chumper. Like you can switch sides and then that side will forgive all your transgressions, provided you hate the other side. And this is kind of like immunity clause, you can evoke, right?
Invoke. And so what journalism used to do would be the disinfectant, but you had to care. You had to care if you looked bad in this report. Yeah.
And when that goes away, or if that isn't a thing people care about, we keep throwing the exposés and the articles and we're wondering why it's not working. And it's like, it's not working because they just decided that it doesn't work anymore. Yeah, I mean, it's not working. And it's also like, when I, you know, I found myself in this just due to my own error, right?
This completely bizarre world of like sources familiar and like, you know, narrative forming and persisting and kind of contorting just into utter delusion. And if you don't participate in that economy, you know, it's a long-force been cliche, if you're not a source of your target, right? And one of my roles is like knowing that you refuse to be a source anyway. Like, because it's like, you know, if you don't play, you can't lose, you can't win.
You really can't lose. Actually, you can definitely lose, right? You can't lose anything that didn't belong to you. Right.
You can lose the media narrative, which is not yours to control anyway, but you win whatever the sort of sense of honor or limitation standard you set for yourself. And I just had to like, one of the things I just always instill, which remind myself is like, what's fake is ephemeral? Like, I have to believe that, right? And if I don't waste this opportunity of this rapturous crack-up of my life, if I don't waste the opportunity to kind of to assess it honestly and to like figure out how to proceed better, then I will be able to correct those things with time.
Yes. But I can't. I just won't participate in the kind of 3D chess warfare that would be required to win a public narrative. And like, also, it's just in public, there's no justice in public narrative.
There's no public narrative, but there's no such thing as justice in public narrative. Yeah. And when you look at the people who quoted, who'll get away with it, I guess the moral question, did they actually get away with it? Or did they inflict some sort of greater injury upon themselves, which is they lost the opportunity to perform, to change, to understand, to correct.
That's something like suffering, right? Like that, to me, that type of suffering is way too high a price to pay to avoid the short-term pain. Yeah. What's interesting to me about all that, and I found this, I was reading the book, the book is very restrained, that's what I would say.
Like you choose not to use certain names, you don't, you have rules that you've set for yourself, right? What you would do and wouldn't do. And you're just saying. Yeah, I'm thinking.
So there's like a restrainsness to it. But it's a restrained person writing about a moment, or a person who was so fundamentally unrestrained. And that contrast is interesting, and I wonder if you've thought about that at all. Yeah.
I mean, I write about it a little bit, right? Where it's just like when your privacy is violated, their emergency expectation that you're going to further violate your privacy, right? That like, you must bear everything in order to receive some sort of that solution. But there were aspects of it.
I mean, it was, because at first I was like, I'm never going to talk about this. I'm never going to write about this. Like, I have nothing of use to share about that experience, but I'm always writing, right? And then I'm out in LA, like at the edge of the country, watching the end of the campaign, and it was just my necessary context, right?
For like the literal vantage point and the philosophical intellectual vantage point from which I'm synthesizing what became the Trump era, this tenure period, right? In which extraordinary things happen, right? He gets elected in the first place, there are two impeachments. He's never been there before.
He's booted from office. It's part of what he says is not an insurrection. Others disagree. He becomes a felon.
He's shot at, right? And then he's elected against this epic, insane story. And I felt like I have to see this thing through. I didn't know when I agreed to cover it.
I didn't know that it was never going to end, right? I was the cup reporter and he was the un-series assignment. And so when I was asked to cover it, I was thrilled because he was a familiar character and I felt like I understood something in his psychology. He's from Queens.
He's from the periphery of New York. And that kind of, to me, I was too. I grew up in Jersey. That explained a lot of the way he operated.
And then it just never ended, right? And it was like this ensemble that kept getting, you know, whenever left me ensemble, right? I kept getting bigger and bigger and more unwieldy. And I just felt like I was being crushed under the weight of it.
And a lot of people that I covered round one with were like, not doing that again. And I thought, like, I have to, you know, I actually have to do it again because I have to see this through, like, the context that I possess is important. And there's something important about people having a fresh perspective too. And I do value that.
But it's also important for people who've been here and know these characters to be here. And so I was intent on doing that. And then all of a sudden, and in some ways, I felt like I was at the height of my powers too. And I had this kind of new perspective on him.
And I felt like useful in a way I hadn't in a while. And I had a lot, I wanted to explore and report out and assess. And then I couldn't, right? Because of my own error.
And it just felt like if I was going to write about any of that, any of the last 10 years, the ways in which my personal life and personal story collided with that distortion of reality seemed like really important context for any reader. I'm not trying to let you up the hook, but I'm curious like what you think about this is something I thought of when I was reading the book. I do agree you were at the height of your powers. I loved reading your stuff and you're very, very good at it.
Like when someone is at the height of their powers, we make exceptions for not even exceptions. We have certain expectations for people who are great, whether it's sports, finance, or whatever, like music. We understand there's kind of a crazy and a chaos that follows. Like we don't expect somebody who's putting up 30 points a night in the NBA to have or selling, you know, a million records a month to be like orderly and have it all together and have this strict, like we just sort of expected like scandal and craziness follows.
And then there's something about our reaction to what you did, your story, that it's not a double standard, but it is like a, I'm just wondering if there's something about writing our journalism that we're like, no, no, no, no, talent must go hand in hand with having it together personally, that we're not as surprised when we find out an NBA player is cheating or is doing this or that. You know what I'm saying? Yeah, I mean, there just, there aren't that many rules for journalists. Yeah.
So, you know, it's like, it's not hard to not run a fellow those roles, right? And I just like did. So I understood last year, I completely understood. And I found a lot of value, frankly, like reading the criticism and absorbing the discourse around it.
And even when people were being extraordinarily untouchable or unkind, often they had something interesting to say. And sometimes I agreed, this more recent like chaos that has subsumed the publication of this book is harder for me to take because I felt like, wait, I just did that. I just did, I did the public ridicule. I fucked up and I felt like I handled that right.
And I tried really hard to not make any mistakes in how I handled my mistake. And why was this happening again? You know, and I hit this wall and then I kind of came around to as a coping mechanism thinking that, like, okay, maybe I was operating under this solution that because I had done the right thing, that I had input good, that I should like extract some sort of good, and it doesn't work that way. Of course, it doesn't work that way, right?
Like, of course, it doesn't work that way, right? Like, it's, and you must do good anyway. And it was, it was important, I think, to be reminded of that. Yeah.
And I think that's the problem, right? People are going, hey, if I don't do the right thing, I can get away with it. But if I do the right thing, it's still going to suck. And so we won't karma to be real.
And we want things to be fair and just. And the reality is like, you can do the wrong thing and get away with it that happens all the time. And you can do the right thing and still be criticized and not appreciated or not forgiven. That's just how life is.
Yeah, but I guess it's like get away with it, in what sense, so right? Because it's like, I keep your money, keep your platform. Yeah, but what costs, right? Like, like, I think the reason why I'm not crushed is because I don't have, I'm not carrying a shame about like, my efforts to wriggle out of, like.
Is there a difference between guilt and shame? Like, do you feel, do you feel guilt about what happened? You clearly are holding yourself responsible. You've got to talk about this.
I thought about the distinction between shame and embarrassment. Like, I think shame is really important. And I know that shocking for like, I think shame is really important. But I think shame is important.
I think embarrassment is about ego. Because that's, you want people to think about you a certain way. And you think, and it's about public perception, right? Shame to me is an interior experience.
And embarrassment is more about an exterior experience. And I think shame can be really important if you have done something shameful. Like, you should feel shame. You should, you know, sip at that and figure that out.
But embarrassment to me, like none of this has been embarrassing to me because my value for this book or for myself as even being is not derived from the public perception, right? But in terms of guilt and shame, I don't know. That's interesting. What do you think?
I don't know. I mean, in the sense you're using shame, which is like, here are my standards and I feel X because I felt short of those standards or I feel proud because I lived up to those standards then maybe we're using the words interchangeably. Maybe, yeah. Yeah.
It's like, it's good to be hard on yourself. I guess guilt implies fault. Like, right? You found guilt, you're not found shamed.
Yes. Right. You experienced shame. You think, anyway, that maybe you don't experience guilt, right?
But it's funny that we call it a public shaming. Not a public guilt. You're a public embarrassment. But like, so you're saying it's good.
But then obviously the thing we do to other people is not good. No, no, certainly not. And like the, is it John Ronson? The such a good book.
But that's a totally different thing, right? Like that. I think I consider that more public humiliation than public shame. But I guess it's private shame, public shame or different things.
Well, it's hard because we talk about cancel culture as this thing went too far with. It's obviously bad. And I would agree with that. At the same time, society does need some mechanism other than the law to say like, this is not what we do.
And there's consequences for doing the thing we don't do. Like I think that's been the remarkable feature of the Trump age that it's like, hey, you can hit your wife on camera and still run a, you know, a professional fighting league. And the irony of also like you run a sport where people just slap each other back and forth. It's like a remarkable thing, right?
Like, or you can say horrible racist things in a chat and then not lose your job over it. Like there has to be some kind of accountability for it. It's not that you should be eternally damned or sent to prison or into exile, but that society does have to have some mechanism in which we go like, here's the line. When you go over the line, there's consequences for doing that, I think.
Yeah. I mean, I think like it just happens in a slower invisible way in social situations, right? Where it's like, if you're just, if you're unpleasant on balance, eventually you're not going to be invited to a gathering, right? Like your social circle, but it does seem like just the attention economy, the kind of rotten values of that, or that people who are loud and simplistic, that wins, nuance, loses, right?
But I always just feel like, okay, the loudest people are probably not who I'm trying to talk to anyway, right? Like, I'm trying to talk to the smartest person in the room. And to me, that's the most open-minded person, the person most interested in and capable of holding nuance and just the most curious person, right? Someone who matches my curiosity, like I always think about Michael Pollan, who for me is like the North Star and what he, so among things that he's still remarkable at, he's a great, he's a hospitable guide, right?
Like he, as a narrator, you take his hand and you're reading and he's bringing you on this journey, whether it's, you know, through his garden or, you know, into the poppy plant and into a consciousness, he's got this book about consciousness coming out next year that I'm so excited for. I don't know him, by the way, I'm just like, a huge fan of the work, but I like that. I always think about that where it's like he is not condescending. He's assuming, he's assuming that you're here for good faith reasons and that you, that he has something to tell you that you're going to find valuable and like that it's the gold standard for me, right?
So, yeah, I just, it's like you live in a world where you can get caught on camera accepting a bag of cash, whether that's legal or not, whether they're legally, who's the, who's the, like the immigrations are, whatever, yeah, yeah, and like the legal system will catch up with that at some point or not, but that should, hopefully, but the point is, like, I think we're, we're grappling with the society in which the public revelation of that fact does not end anything. It has just zero effect. It's like, doctors are prescribing antibiotics and they're just not working. Yeah.
And we're just wrestling with antibiotic resistance at a cultural level. Right. And then the question is like, what's incumbent on those doctors to stop and think, well, wait, are we over prescribing antibiotics, or should we be more thoughtful in our prescriptions for whatever is ailing patients that way we avoid a situation where everyone is antibiotic resistant? Like, right?
Right. And so I think when the answer to everything is public shame and cancellation, I mean, our whole system has been set up with a, in a consensus reality where there was a definition of value or there's shared understanding of value when there were authorities and there was public trust, right? And even as the institutions were being built, there was like a good faith that they were being built in good faith, right? And then like, it's, what is a high crime and misdemeanor?
Right? It's open to interpretation. But you know, why is there no law preventing the bulldozing of the East Wing? It's like, well, they didn't think about that.
Right. Nobody thought about that. But there was no East Wing that, you know, it's like, Yes. Well, the founders believe that the system, that the system, the final check on the system was the idea of person over to, right?
Like, I think Adam says something like, they'll go through the system like a whale through a net. And so we had, it's interesting that they knew that, that we were vulnerable to the superbugs or the antibiotic resistant man on horseback, speak, and that, but they just expected that would never happen. I mean, if you can keep it part of the a republic, it's overlooked, I think, right? And like, it's, it's sort of to grandiously, like, tie it back to my personal error.
It's goes back to the, maybe noticing on one level, the suspension of certain critical faculties or letting things slide with myself and thinking that I didn't need to judge myself in real time for minor things, right? And then that creates a situation where you make a big mistake. And I feel like in general, there's a kind of, I don't know, part of it's like, we just don't have a, we don't have a formal mechanisms for, maybe it's like the collapsed institutions and the collapse of the family, right? The rural institutions, the family unit, are in theory, like the midpoint before we get to law enforcement, justice departments involved, right?
Like, and if those checks are in place broadly speaking, you can't count on them. Then I guess it's like what you're talking about where there's no penalty in real time for misbehavior. If I was talking to you in 21 or 22, could you have articulated these sort of values very clearly? And then there's a period where you sort of, you override them or forget them, or is it more like you've come to understand them in the wreckage of what happened?
That's interesting. But I mean, I don't think I was consciously thinking about it, right? So maybe on, I could have had some sort of like, I had an intellectual conversation about it. But also in that period, it's like, it was, everything was sort of hazy, you know, still covering Donald Trump was covering the pandemic in the end of that first term.
And then it didn't really end. And right, there are all these challenges and trying to kind of make sense of like, what that even was. And then it, it's like this lithium fire that like the embers of it just spark up again, right? And like, it, I was thinking really very little about my own behavior where I fit in, and my character fit in, in this kind of broad corruption of character.
I use in the intro of Trust Me I'm lying, I was fooling around with that word disintegrated. Like, we feel like it disintegrated in the air, like it fell apart. But like, if you think about disintegrating meaning, not integrated, I was like, that's what I had my beliefs, I had my values, I was studying this philosophy, which now, like, I sort of dedicate my life to, and then I had my sort of day-to-day work behavior. And those two things were not integrated.
They were compartmentalized. They were just not, they were operating independently of each other. And like, the reason they were not integrated is that there's a lot of cognitive dissonance between the two. If they were integrated, then you have to wrestle with a contradiction between what you think your character is and your day-to-day actions.
And so you keep them apart from each other. And you just, I mean, being busy is a wonderful way to keep them from integrating with each other. Right. And like, that's one of the things I write about a little bit about being a reporter is like, I'm someone who really only has a fight instinct.
And you can just almost anything. And as a political reporter, the stakes are built, and you never have to wonder, like, am I? It's what I'm doing. It doesn't matter, right?
It matters in a really overt way, even in like small little episodes. And the gift of that is tremendous. Like, a few times I've ever been assigned a story about something else. I've always hit this point where I'm like, wait, I need this story to be about the universe.
And mankind. And I need it to be life or death here. And this, you know, actor, or this is not immediately high stakes in a way that I'm used to. And that is sort of like a gift in the same way that like, the great engine for these characters running for office, that's a gift too for a writer.
And there's something too about maybe this is what drew you to in the first place by looking and judging other people. You don't have as that you're putting energy outwards that might otherwise go inwards. Totally. Yeah.
And I mean, I write about it's like, when I started writing, it was really like the height of the personal essay boom for young women writers. It was like the, maybe it was like the tail end of the era of like exo Jane, but there was just a lot of that diaristic writing about young female experience and sexuality. I just could not have care less about that stuff. Like, I just thought the stinks are so low.
And I don't care. I care about things that are going to affect other people, the arrogance of the arrogance of thinking that you want to be in charge of anyone else's existence at like a scale up greater than like a dinner party. I should be the most powerful man in the world. Right.
I should affect your life or the lives of people that you love. And I got it. Right. That to me was just an astonishing premise for anything.
I couldn't believe that anyone could think that way. And it was endlessly interesting to me. It allowed me to just completely turn away. That seems like there's a sickness to that, right?
And then but how often does the artist go like, isn't there a sickness in going, the world wants to hear what I have to say, right? And they are similar impulses of different scales and whatever. But yeah, it's more like, I think it's like immediate effect or like less perceptible or just less overt, maybe slower burn effect, right? But I do, I mean, I think that's part of why it's been interesting how all right, I've been with like really negative assessments of this book.
And on the one hand, it's just I anticipated, you know, that there just might be unpleasant reaction, just the premise alone, right? But the other part is just like it's a choice to be a public facing person. It's a choice to create work and submit it for like public consideration. And so you really can't be all that broken up when like the public faces slapped, right?
Yeah, you control what you write, you don't control what people think about what you write. But that's still nice. It's still nicer. I mean, like, one day I hope to experience that, Dan.
But it's like you've assumed the risk that it's going to be unpleasant. And it's still a privilege to do it, right? And it's not a great tragedy. Okay, so I have a question.
So you have there's a section in here which you've talked about before, but let me as I wrote a note on it, I'm curious what you think. You said it was a term of the only way for me to survive such a public relations crisis, tell all spare no detail, spare my job my life as it was. This was the offer on the table. You can write your way out of it.
The man for whom I worked told me I did not consider this. Have you read Molly Blum's book? You know what that is? Aaron's working there to move you better.
But she was that famous. She ran those underground poker games in LA in New York City that all these famous and important people. So Kevin Spacey movie? No, that's a different family movie.
But she's an Olympic level skier. She loses, she blows out her knee and plies her skills to doing something that you're not supposed to do, right? It's illegal. No one's dying, but it's not right.
And she becomes quite wealthy and successful running these underground poker games. And eventually she gets caught as everyone eventually does. And basically the FBI comes to her and says, look, you can keep your illicit gains if you tell us who was involved in what you did. And she famously gives up the money rather than tell people what you did.
Now, one argument is like you're not doing it because you don't want those people to come after you. But in both the book and the movie, and I've gotten to know her a little bit, she just felt like it was the wrong thing to do. I did the crime all the time. That was my view of it.
Now, I'm always interested when people take certain moral stands that I don't totally understand. Yeah. You might go, hey, you're all criminals. Yeah.
Or all committing a crime. And why wouldn't you say it? And I think people might say to you, I thought that's interesting. This is a central argument of the book is that you can see the book, which is that you don't spare yourself, but you don't really talk about anyone.
You talk about other people, you don't name other people, and you don't... It's obvious who they are. I'm sure you have receipts that you did not show, right? And that's a moral choice you're making.