Hey, I'm Chad Abumrad. This is More Perfect. Final episode of Season 2, long overdue. Today, I'm going to fulfill a promise that I made to myself at the very beginning of More Perfect, several years ago. When I started the show, it was out of a very basic desire to understand some things that I knew nothing about, to be able to talk about some things I knew nothing about. And one of the very first questions that I bumped into as a Supreme Court idiot.
Was it, why does everybody keep talking about this thing called? The Commerce Clause. Commerce Clause. Commerce Clause. The Commerce Clause, what the hell is it? Well, it's Article 1, Section 8, Clause 3 of the Constitution. 16 words, two commas. Congress shall have the power to regulate commerce with foreign nations and among the several states and with the Indian tribes. The power to regulate commerce with foreign nations and among the several states and with the Indian tribes. There are no more sexier words in the English language. Yes, better words for wooing were never written. That's Jamie Floyd and Ari Savitsky. We'll meet them properly in just a second. Okay, so it turns out the definition isn't that hard. It's written right there in the Constitution. Those 16 words have something to do with commerce going across state lines. Fine, but...
When you start to stare at those words and really track how they've been read across time, you realize that within that shell of boring is a cosmic power. Like, for me, the experience I had learning about the Commerce Clause was a little bit like watching the X-Men movies. Like, initially, I was like, My name is Magneto. Why is Magneto the head of the bad guys? Will you join my brotherhood and fight? Like, why would they follow him? He has the most boring power. Who will you stand with? I mean, he can control metal. Okay, well, like, Mystique can shift into any shapes you want. Storm can control lightning. Initially, his powers seemed like, you have the worst one. But then...
You see these scenes where he's like being attacked by a thousand policemen and he just kind of makes their bullets freeze in midair. Or he picks up a whole bridge by just pointing at it. And then hits you. Oh, he has the best power. Because the whole world is made of metal. He can control the world. If we built the world a different way, maybe not. But in this world... Let's just say I'm Frankenstein's monster. Today, I want to tell you the story of that monster.
It's a story that contains everything we fight about as Americans. States rights, civil rights, equal rights, race, big government, small government, all of it. Wrapped up in those 16 words with two commas. To even explain why something like the Commerce Clause exists, just pull out a dollar bill. Go ahead and pull it out, right? It's issued by a central bank. Are you looking at a dollar bill right now? I'm looking at a dollar bill. It's a Federal Reserve note, United States of America. That is James Chen, professor of law at Michigan State University. Now, the thing about a dollar bill, the awesome, obvious thing, is that you can take that dollar bill and buy some Sour Patch Kids or whatever dollar buys these days anywhere in America. Right. But in the late 18th century, in fact, all the way through to the 20th century. It wasn't like that. No, no, no, no, no. All the states had their own banks.
And their own bills. Different sizes, colors. For example, there's a moment when South Carolina has this pretty little green South Carolina bill. Same time, Rhode Island has this giant pink square thing. And if you are a South Carolinian in Rhode Island trying to buy some...
carrots and potatoes, let's say. Let's say that. And you've got to make payments somehow. What do you do? Well, you hand them your South Carolina bill. Well, the Rhode Islanders would look at that and say, well, I don't know what this is. Who's to trust this bank, right? And so they would discount the note based on the distance from their own home. They would discount the note based on how it looks, how professionally drawn up it was. They might look at that $10 and say, that's only worth eight to me. That's a horrible, horrible way to do business. That sucks for the person holding the note, right? And so what the government decided to do is to say, hey, we're just gonna use one bill. Just one bill. It's gonna be so much easier.
This is one of the ways the government was going to pull all these different states together. They were going to regulate the currency. And not just the currency itself. They were going to regulate the flow of that currency. And this is where the Commerce Clause comes in. This is Jamie Floyd, journalist. Sometimes legal analyst. Host of All Things Considered. Here at WNYC. It's early in the republic. Now we're at 1820s. Now, just to hit pause for one second. So the Commerce Clause was a pre-existing thing? Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. It's in the U.S. Constitution. It's in the Constitution, but it's never been really, like, thought about? Or where is it in the minds of people at 1820? Nowhere. Nowhere. Pretty much where it is right now. It's nowhere in the minds of people.
Which says 1824, two steamboat operators get into a thing. It's a business dispute. They're each going back and forth between New York and New Jersey. They each think they should be the only one allowed to do that. And it makes its way, as we say, all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. And who's sitting up there? Well, a big bad dude named John Marshall. Marshall is the sort of Rambo of the court.
He looks at those 16 words, Congress shall have the power to regulate commerce with foreign nations and among the several states. He looks at those 16 words and a couple of commas in a period. And he decides, pretty much for the first time, that those words give Congress the power to regulate commerce between and among states. This vote is going from one state to the other. The only way to resolve that is for the federal government to come in and control it. Again, the idea is that this is the only way for the country to function as a unified thing.
And John Marshall, when he writes his decision, he says, look, we have a United States of America. We don't have a divided states of America or independent states of America or New Jersey and New York existing separately. We decided to organize as a United States. And so what John Marshall says is because of that, there has to be a power to regulate trade between those states and amongst those states when there are disputes. Otherwise, it's all going to fall apart. It was at that point that the Commerce Clause began to glow very faintly.
For the next hundred years, the government would experiment with the Commerce Clause in cases involving trade, with the Native American tribes or navigation. But if you want to talk about power, the real power of the Commerce Clause got unleashed in about 1941 in a wheat field. My father was a farmer, I'd like to say, all of his life. Took pride in the fact that he never worked for another man. He would tell me that. Can you introduce yourself? Well, my name is the same as my father. It's Roscoe Curtis Philbrunn. I'm a junior. Roscoe Philburn, as he was known at the time. He was a fifth-generation farmer. In Montgomery, Ohio. Our farm was just right next to Dayton, Ohio. Roscoe is about a 40-year-old man at this point. Again, we're talking about 1941, 42. Good-looking, sturdy.
Fiercely independent. I never worked for another man in my life. Apparently, that was his motto. He would tell me that many times over the years. If you had to put, like, Captain America with a pitchfork, this is him.
So, Roscoe's got this farm, more than 100 cows on it. He would milk cows until both of his arms went practically numb. Had chickens? 2,000 chickens. And we had a very big garden. He would plant things, you know, like string beans, lima bean peas, sweet corn, potatoes, carrots, radishes. A couple different kinds of fruit trees. Apples, cherry trees, peach trees, pears, strawberries, and raspberries. Oh, and of course they had crops. We would grow corn, a couple different kinds of hay, oats, and of course wheat. Wheat. Okay, set up out of the way. Here's what happened.
It's 1941. Roscoe Sr. My dad was out in the field, I think, on his tractor. That day he was plowing the weed or something. And there apparently must have been some guy from the Department of Agriculture locally, I guess going around to various farmers in our community, wanting the farmers to answer several pages, I think, of questions. And this particular day, this government gentleman came out into the field. He looked around.
And he said, Roscoe, by my calculations, you've got 22 acres of wheat on this farm. You're over your quota. He was 11.1 acres over what was permitted. Roughly. And so the guy tells him, you have to pay a fine. A really big fine. My dad looked over and he was just as sober as a judge in a courtroom on a murder case. And what happened next would change the country forever in ways that we are still literally living with. But let me just sort of fill in the gaps here. Tell you what you need to know about why they were even having this conversation.
And to help me with that, my name is Ari Savitsky, and I'm an attorney. Let me bring in a friend of the show, man of the law. You know, an important thing to understand is that, you know, when our story starts with Roscoe Filburn, agriculture is a huge percentage of the economy. The Great Depression is happening. Our financial panic grips the world. And the dust bowl. The great dust storms of the mid-1930s. Has happened, too. Which happened to America's great plans. And so you have a lot of people who rely on selling crops and buying crops, and so wheat prices. It's a matter of life and death. For millions of Americans. This nation is asking for action, and action now. So look, so...
In 1938, Congress enacts what's called the Agricultural Adjustment Act to reboot the economy. So the 1938 Agricultural Adjustment Act got the federal government into the business of regulating wheat. Basically what the government did was they said to the Farmers of America, we are going to give you essentially a loan. We're going to guarantee you a certain minimum price for wheat. We're going to give you X number of dollars per bushel or whatever it is, and that will help lift you out of poverty. In exchange for that, you have to promise us to only grow a certain amount. So the big fear was that if they grew too much, there'd be this...
flood of supply on the wheat market, prices would crash, and that would be bad for everyone. You know, wheat is sort of a collective action problem, right? Everyone's going to sell as much wheat as they can, but that means prices go down and everyone makes less. So what the government decided to do, in addition to giving out loans, is that they placed a cap on how much wheat a person could grow. So quota, straight up quota. That way you ensure that the supply of wheat is steady. And you ensure that the prices don't crash. And the whole reason the government could do this, regulate the entire wheat market, was by hinging it on the Commerce Clause. Those 16 words that basically said that when something like wheat is bought and sold and moved from one place to another, one state to another, cross state lines.
Well, that's interstate commerce, and that's something that Congress can regulate. And this brings us back to Roscoe Filburn with that inspector on his farm. Inspector says, look, Roscoe, you've grown too much wheat. My dad looked over, and he was just as sober as a judge in a courtroom on a murder case. And what do you think he says back? He says, wait a minute. I'm going to tell you just exactly how I feel about that. No, that's how I feel. No, you government. I don't know. He might have been a family guy. He says, I don't get it. I have nothing to do with interstate commerce. And this is the key.
He explains to the inspector that yes, according to the government quota, I'm only supposed to grow about 11 acres of wheat and I am growing 23. Get that extra 12. But Big Brother does not leave him alone. The inspector says, We're the government. That's the law. Please uphold it.
Pay the fine. 50 cents for every excess bushel, I think it is. He had 239 excess bushels of wheat, for which he was fined about 117 bucks. In today's dollars, it's about two grand. Two grand. My father, apparently he wasn't real crazy about that, and I guess he didn't like that too much. If I'd have been 20 or 25 years old, I would have probably advised my father not to do what he did, but I guess he sued the federal government. Huh.
His argument was like, look, I'm just trying to feed my cows. Come on. I guess it went to our court in Dayton, Ohio. That was the first stop. And I believe that he won. Round one to Roscoe. The Ohio court agreed. There's no commerce of any kind going on here, unlike the original case with the boat. I believe I even remember him, my sister, telling me that he came home and he was just delighted that he did win. But then the government appeals the case. And of course, when it got to the Supreme Court of the United States, he lost.
He lost in a decision that I think it's fair to say still drives conservatives and libertarians bonkers. And I'm neither one of those things, but I get it. What the Supreme Court said is that Roscoe Filburn growing that extra wheat and not selling it still counts as interstate commerce. Because having that extra wheat causes him to not buy it on the market. He needs less wheat from the market. And if all the farmers of America did that...
then that would be really bad for the market. The idea is that if you need more wheat than the quota, you go on the market and buy it. Even though you can grow it yourself, you gotta buy it. Because if everyone can produce their quota and then whatever extra they need, I mean, pretty soon the regulation breaks down. Which means that the government intervention in the wheat market will have failed. You will have defeated our attempt to regulate this market. Therefore, we have to regulate even the things you don't do. See, that is so weird. It's such a mind, frankly. It's like, he's not doing anything. This is literally non-behavior. This is Obamacare. It's very much like the healthcare case.
It's getting heated over healthcare. Today's issue, the individual mandate. Just to explain, that's a reference to Barack Obama's healthcare plan. It was hotly debated a couple years ago, still hotly debated. One of the key ideas of that plan is that in order for healthcare to be affordable for everyone, everyone should have to buy it. So we're going to require people to buy insurance or else you pay a penalty. Which made a lot of people mad because they're like, hey, the government's forcing me to buy something I don't want. My decision not to get healthcare is not...
participation in interstate commerce. It's not even economic activity. I'm sitting here on my couch not buying health care. I'm just sitting here. From the individual perspective, that makes perfect sense. But if you pan out, and Justice Kagan said this in court, it's not so simple. In the aggregate of all these uninsured people are increasing the normal family premium, Congress says, by $1,000 a year. Those people are in commerce. They're making decisions that are affecting the price that everybody pays for this service.
Obamacare makes sense to me in some spiritual way. But getting back to Roscoe, we're regulating the things you're not doing. Because no farmer is an island. This is the case in which Congress receives a tremendous amount of power from the U.S. Supreme Court. Essentially, this case says that Congress can regulate almost anything. And that is the single most significant precedent in the area of the Commerce Clause. The Big Bang.
Did anyone sort of raise their hand in the middle of this and be like, whoa, if you can regulate the non-behavior of this American farmer, then that's not even a slippery slope. That's like a cliff that goes right down. Like, there's no slope to that. A New York Times editorial from November 13, 1942 said, If the farmer who grows feed for consumption on his own farm competes with commerce, would not the housewife who makes herself address do so equally? The net of the ruling, in short, seems to be that Congress can regulate every form of economic activity if it so decides. Would not the housewife who makes herself address...
do so. Yeah, it's like if you make something, like shoot, my wife and I with our kids made these little like miniature stuffed animals for them to play with the other day. Are we then in violation of some? Oh my gosh, if you made your kids do it and now you violate some child labor laws even. After the Roscoe Philbrin case, those 16 words and the whole definition of commerce expanded because now commerce wasn't just the buying and selling of things. It was the not buying and selling of things. And that expansion, that would go way beyond weed. It would go into realms much, much deeper. Much deeper in us. That's after the break. I'm Jad Abumrad. This is More Perfect. We'll continue in a moment.
This is More Perfect. I'm Chad Abumrad. So you had the big bang of the Commerce Clause in that wheat field where commerce gets redefined as not just what you're buying and selling, but also what you're not buying and selling, your negative commerce. But at this point, you know, 1941, we're still talking about markets. We're still talking about commodities. There comes a point when the use of the Commerce Clause goes way beyond that, where it gets into matters of the heart. You might say this is the moment when the Commerce Clause gets weaponized.
Hello? Hey, can you hear me? Yes. This is Jad from Radio Lab in More Perfect in New York. Jack. Jad, J-A-D. Jad, J-A-D. Okay, well, Andrew is here and he's recording. To really understand what I mean, you have to meet this guy. Can you introduce yourself? Tell me who you are, your name? Yes, it's Ollie McClung Jr. And how old are you? 77. And where are you speaking to us from right now? I'm in Birmingham, Alabama. You were born in Birmingham? Yes.
Aside from some time at college in Florida and a stint in the Coast Guard, Ollie Jr. has lived in Birmingham his entire life. And the reason we called him up is that for 75 years, his family ran a famous barbecue joint named Ollie's. So this is your dad's business, from what I understand, right? Yes, my grandfather actually had founded it. Oh, really? When was that? 1926. So this was passed to your dad, who passed it to you? Yes. But we were in business together until he died. Ollie's Barbecue was located on Birmingham's south side. The building we were in at the time you're talking about, from 1949 until 68, it was a concrete block. Big sign outside said, World's Best Barbecue. Pretty good for its day.
Apparently during lunch, the line would stretch out the door. Ollie's was famous for its slow-cooked pork and chicken and for its spicy vinegar barbecue sauce. And the pie baking. Chocolate pies. We always did a lot of pies. But Ollie's was also famous or would become famous for something else entirely. Well, because of the times and the way things were at that time, of course, throughout the South in Birmingham, we had a carryout business as well as sit-down business.
Those of our black customers came in and ordered from the carryout counter and took their food out. And truth, fact, history, they would take it on with them to eat as opposed to sitting down and eating. What he's saying is that Ollie's Barbecue was segregated. If you were white, you could eat inside. If you were black, you couldn't. I mean, that was the way it worked. So what does this have to do with the Commerce Clause? Okay, so the federal government at the time, this would be the Kennedy administration, then LBJ, they wanted to come down on places like Ollie's Barbecue. But their hands were sort of tied.
I mean, we have this thing called the 14th Amendment, which says no state shall deprive any person of life, liberty or property without the oppressive of law, nor shall any state deny equal protection of the laws to any person. James Chen again, those words, he says, which were ratified right after the Civil War, were written to basically outlaw things like segregation. Of course, it didn't work. We have another 80 plus years of Jim Crow. And the reason for that.
is that the Supreme Court, shortly after the 14th Amendment was passed, kind of neutered it. Well, not kind of, they did. And one of the ways they did was by insisting that we read the 14th Amendment as being targeted only at states. If you look at that sentence, the second sentence of the 14th Amendment says no state, no state shall deprive any person of life, liberty, or property without depressive. The problem is, is when a restaurant owner like Ollie McClung denies service to black patrons, it's not Alabama doing the damage.
Just private business. It's not as if Alabama ordered the McClung family to discriminate against black patrons. They just did it. So if the 14th Amendment can only get to states, here it has no reach. Because there's no state action. There is nothing to regulate at the state level. So, what the feds decided to do in a fascinating bit of legal gymnastics is they decided to use...
The Commerce Clause. Congress passes the most sweeping civil rights bill ever to be written into the law. Giving all Americans the right to be served in facilities which are open to the public. July 2nd, 1964, Congress passes a sweeping civil rights bill that was hinged on those 16 words. And I will explain to you how, because it's kind of fascinating in just a second. But first, just to get us to that point. So 1964 Civil Rights Act is passed. Did you desegregate right away? No. No. We were not happy with it, obviously. I want to read to you something that you said in 1964. I believe this is sort of your account of something that happened in...
in your restaurant. The day after the Civil Rights Act was passed, a black man comes into the restaurant asking to be served, and you turn him away. Forty-five minutes later, he comes back with a young girl, four other black people. They sit down at the counter. They want to know why Ollie's wouldn't serve them, and they were taking notes, and you're quoted as saying they seem like agitators. Yeah, in fact, they were. They were folks that came and went around several places just to test the law, basically, yeah. And you were turning those folks away? Yes. You kicked them out? Mm-hmm. And why?
I mean, just because that's the way we had always done, that's the way until the law got adjudicated, we weren't going to unilaterally change things. But, you know, from their perspective, they're there because the law's been changed. Yeah. Yes. Ollie says right after the Civil Rights Act was passed, sort of an emergency meeting was called of the Birmingham Restaurants Association, and he and his dad went. We discussed with them and with the executive of it that this was going to be such a potentially harmful to the restaurant businesses. Like you would lose all your white customers? Is that what you worried about? I mean, that was a possibility, and somebody ought to do something, and so we kind of ended up being the ones to do something, i.e. file the suit.
So they filed the suit, basically saying to the federal government, you have no right to barge into our small, independent, local business. The thought was, they can't really tell us what to do because we're not an interstate business, and that's all that the federal government regulates. And up until that point, that was all they had regulated. The case went to the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Alabama. At the lower court level, the three-judge special panel, we had a unanimous decision in our favor. The Alabama court agreed that there was no interstate commerce happening here, and that Ollie's did not have to desegregate. They could sell their ribs to whoever they wanted.
optimistic about that. The government then appeals, and the case, as they say, goes all the way to the Supreme Court. Alright, let me now explain to you how the government made this argument, because they made it in court. October 5th, 1964. Solicitor General Archibald Cox gets up there and lays it out. Why the government should be allowed to use the Commerce Clause of all things to desegregate all these barbecues.
He says this is a business that sells and buys a lot of meat. In the 12-month period prior to July 1, 1964, the athletes purchased about $70,000 worth of meat. $69,683 to be exact. And where do you think all that meat came from? It was purchased from the Hormel Company at its Birmingham, Alabama plant. All the meat sold at that plant came from other states so that it moved to an interstate company.
In other words, you think you're a local business, but you're not. The meat is sourced from places other than Alabama. And what about your ketchup? Hypothetically. Do you grow all your tomatoes in Alabama? No. Salt. Salt. Not mine in Alabama. So even though we bought it from a local vendor. That local vendor probably bought it from somebody who bought it from somebody that got it from out of state. They were reaching beyond what had ever been done before, basically. Government was basically telling the McClungs the same thing they told Roscoe Fulbright. You are not an island. And that was only the government's first argument. They had another argument. Now there's a second and still more directly. That was even more radical. Between racial discrimination in rest and interstate commerce.
which is caused by the artificial narrowing of the consumer market, resulting from the exclusion of Negro patrons. So here's the argument. If you deny black people access to restaurants and hotels, you are effectively shutting down interstate travel by them in parts of the country where this practice is commonplace, the entire Deep South. You're limiting their ability to cross state lines and travel. The essential argument, says James Chan, is that when you discriminate against someone...
You create downstream negative commercial effects like like you create a chilling effect because the person you're discriminating against is then less likely to travel across state lines and spend money. So in effect, you are depressing their future interstate commerce. If you ask black people with this experience from this time period, they will universally say we never left home unless every tire was triple checked. Every belt was triple checked in the car. Because we did not want to have the car break down in a hostile southern town and get lynched. Right, right. It is an entire system of travel and commerce that's at stake here. Essentially, the argument was discrimination is bad for business. It's expensive. And ultimately, in a unanimous decision, the Supreme Court, the same court that 100 years earlier had basically gutted the 14th Amendment, the Supreme Court agreed that discrimination in restaurants pose significant burdens on the, quote, interstate flow of food and upon the movement of products generally.
Do you remember that decision coming down? Oh, certainly. Where were you? I was at work. Can you tell me a little bit about how you and your dad processed that decision? We simply served anyone who came in after that, no problem. And there were. The very next day, there was a group of local civil rights leaders who came in and ate lunch. I knew some of them by having seen them in the news, that sort of thing. They were not our regular customers before then, nor after, frankly, but they celebrated or whatever you want to say, tested. I don't know what their motive was, but they came in and ate lunch. They got served just like anybody else.
They came in and it was fine? Sure. The law was decided, so that was it. Was it tense? No. Other than the waitress who was waiting on them, she was a little antsy about it. And this waitress, was she a black woman? Yes. I forget who it was now, but she was, like most of our employees, been there a very long time and had never served other black folks in a sit-down situation. And, of course, it was a little bit...
I won't say upsetting, but different. She was a little hesitant at first. I told her, just go right ahead and serve them. And she did, and we did, and that was not a problem. After the ruling, it's not as if a lot of black customers suddenly started coming into Ollie's Barbecue. They didn't. Here's how a guy named Nathan Turner Jr. put it in 2014. He was interviewed for an NPR piece. He grew up nearby Ollie's. Just the fact that Ollie's pushed it that far to take it to the Supreme Court, it left a bad taste, pun intended, in the mouths of a lot of black people in Birmingham. Now 53 years later, how do you think about that Supreme Court decision?
Well, if you're asking about segregation, that's one thing. If you're asking about the Supreme Court and the decision in the Commerce Clause, I still disagree with... Let me put it real succinctly. I think what you had in that decision was that rather than... And I think my civics is correct, but I don't know. Rather than three-quarters of the Congress...
and three-fifths of the states, I believe it is, having to, or maybe two-thirds of Congress, whichever it is, having to vote to repeal an amendment to the Constitution, you had basically nine appointees who repealed the Tenth Amendment to the Constitution. The Tenth Amendment basically says that the powers not given to the feds are reserved for the states and for the people. And that's about as succinct as I can say it. But do you understand how this is going to sound to a lot of our listeners? I mean, that you are making a states' rights argument as a not-so-veiled way to continue to discriminate. That really, in the end, this is not about states' rights. I think that's how it's going to sound to a lot of people. Well, it may very well, but it's not the case.
Was there segregation? Yes. Were we going to voluntarily end that? Probably not. Would we go back and reinstate if we could? No, absolutely not. But the issue that you're talking about with the Commerce Clause and the constitutional issue is still just what I said. So you still believe 53 years later that the Supreme Court got it wrong, that they should have never used the Commerce Clause to make you desegregate ollies? Yeah, that is correct.
But don't hear me say that I don't want to go back and have segregation again. That's a separate issue. But is it separate? This is my question. I grant you, if you think of it in the abstract, a federal government being able to regulate commerce across all boundaries is an enormous power. And it could be a scary power. So I grant you that. At the same time, you have a Civil Rights Act that speaks to a different amendment in the Constitution and that you and your father were not willing to follow. So how is the government going to get you to pay attention and to get in line? They've got to use the Commerce Clause. So on some level, isn't the power present?
Because the other principles that would otherwise regulate your behavior just aren't working. Well, that's the point. You choose which is the priority, basically. I don't understand. Which is the priority? Well, which is the priority of those amendments? And so for you, the 10th Amendment that grants states' rights for everything non-enumerated outweighs the dignity of black people? No, no. No. So say it to me differently then. Well, the 10th Amendment left that to the states.
The Fourth Amendment, yes, gives people rights, everyone rights. But here's the thing about rights. It's kind of like the first law of thermodynamics. There's only a, and people don't realize this a lot of times, there are only so many rights. There are only a finite number of rights. If you take some, give some to someone, they come from someone else or somewhere else. Now, it's very well to say that the end of segregation was a higher right, a more important right, than...
the misuse of the Commerce Clause or whatever you want to say. But there's still a balance in just which one you think is most important. Today's Parliament, we call it zero sum. Ali's basic point, and we talked about this for another hour, was that in achieving desegregation that way, and by the way, the Civil Rights Act of 64 dramatically altered the South. It desegregated huge parts of the South. But by doing it that way, he says, with the Commerce Clause, something was sacrificed. He calls it a zero sum. I wouldn't call it that. I don't think most people would call it that.
Treating people with dignity and equality is a net win, period. But it is legitimately strange that the government had to take such a roundabout, ass-backward way to fix this, to fix this grave injustice. What you would think would be the obvious, that you would go right to those civil rights parts of the Constitution, but it wasn't. It was the Commerce Clause. That's what's weird, is it? We have the 14th Amendment, and yet we go to the Commerce Clause for something that is so clearly stated in one of the amendments. Well, lawyers are very tricky.
This is Jamie Floyd again, by the way. And the lawyers in those cases, they wanted to win. They wanted to win more than they wanted to make a social statement about equal justice, equal rights, the 14th Amendment. I mean, those things mattered. But most of all, they wanted to win. They wanted to shut down discrimination at those lunch counters. And if Congress could shut them down or require them to open their doors to all Americans using those 16 words, I'm okay with that. Yeah, yeah. No, I mean, obviously, the ends do justify the means in that case. But it does make you, if you sort of put that case and the weak case in your mind as a kind of split screen.
And it's a little strange because I do think, okay, we have, I mean, hopefully we're Americans with principles that matter, you know, that we believe in equality, we believe in racial justice, but really we just believe in money. And we can do all the other stuff by bootstrapping it to commerce. But somehow, as pure principles, they what, don't have teeth? Well, it's deeply troubling that we have to use commerce to achieve our higher values. That is weird to me. That is fundamentally weird to me. And it's kind of cynical. Well, yeah. I mean, you are right. We are, at least in large part, about commerce in this country. But if that's who we are, then we should embrace it and use it to our advantage.
And if we can use it to our advantage, perhaps it does take us to our higher principles. That's an interesting way of looking at it. Yeah, it's not all bad. One of Jamie's points, which I hadn't actually thought of, was that legislating morality, legislating what is good and what is bad, doesn't always go well. Because we very often don't agree. I mean, obviously, there have been times where people kept slaves and thought that was just fine. But that was right. And for 100 years, you had the 14th Amendment in place, but it couldn't solve Ollie's barbecue. And here was a way for the government, without going at the moral questions head on,
government could reach its hand all the way into the barbecue joints and the hotels and the restaurants and the houses and now the cake shops of America, reach its hand all the way down into the local. And it was because of this increasingly expansive idea of commerce that was now no longer the buying and selling of things or the not buying and selling of things. It was now any behavior that could create a kind of butterfly effect that might one day, many steps downstream, have a future effect on the buying and selling of things. So in that sense, Ali McClung was right. His case, that was a massive shift.
It shifted totally the federal government's role, beyond business even. If you think it's good, then that's fine, and it's for the better. But it just has to be realized that it was a massive shift from the way that the country had been up before that time. After the McClung case, James Chen says the government's use of the Commerce Clause pretty much went wild. Yeah, there's just no real limit.
They began to wave those 16 words sort of like a magic wand. To pass laws on everything from fair labor standards to... Marijuana is a Schedule I. Drugs. Gun Control Act of 1968. Guns. The Justice for Victims of Trafficking Act. Sex trafficking. 19,000 African lions in the wild. Endangered species. 1992, professional and amateur sports. Sports Protection Act, which forbids state-authorized sports gambling. All kinds of things. And in fact, the only question was whether the government even had to make the argument itself. Whether the government even has to defend itself.
James Chen says there were times when the government would pass a law, it'd get taken to court, and the government would basically not show up. And they would still win. That's where we were. So we were arguing whether the government even has to argue. So you can see the McClung case as sort of a second Big Bang. But then you get to the mid-90s. At this point, 1994, you have a Democratic president, Bill Clinton, Democratic majorities in both houses of Congress. And together they pass the Violence Against Women Act. Today is the first day of spring. And I think it's appropriate that we begin a new season of hope in the fight against domestic violence.
I thank you all for being here. This is an important day. The act was sort of a sweeping rethink of the federal government's role in trying to prevent violence against women. It beefed up investigations of violent crimes against women, prosecutions. It allowed women to sue their alleged attackers in federal court. We had to take responsibility. Domestic violence is now the number one health risk for women between the ages of 15 and 44 in our country. And the law was hinged on the Commerce Clause. Same essential argument as in the barbecue case.
That same fall. My name is Christy Broncala. I'm 19 years old and I have lived in Fairfax, Virginia most of my life. A woman named Christy Broncala starts her freshman year at Virginia Tech and just weeks in. In mid-September 1994, I was raped by two football players in my own dorm. I had met them for the first time just 15 minutes before they assaulted me. These two football players, she alleged, had raped her repeatedly. On a single night in 1994, I was raped three times. She went to the local campus authorities. She told her story. College held her own hearings, didn't go to the police. They suspended one of the two students. He appealed, won. And when he returned, Christy Broncala dropped out of school.
Christy Broncala ultimately decides to sue her alleged attackers and the school under this new law, the Violence Against Women Act. And the case ultimately makes it to the Supreme Court. We'll hear argument now, number 99.5, Christy Broncala versus Antonio Morrison. When Christy's case got to the Supreme Court, her lawyer, Mr. Chief Justice, may it please the court, made the same argument about women that the government had made in the Ali's Barbecue case about black people. That discrimination, or in this case, outright violence.
has a huge downstream effect on the economy. A bipartisan Congress concluded that gender-based violence substantially affects the national economy. Gender-based violence and the fear of that discriminatory violence deters women's travel interstate, restricts women's choice of jobs and ability to perform those jobs, reduces national productivity, and increases medical and other costs. And again, the court was given tons of evidence about the economic effects. For example, Congress heard from women whose batterers kept their partners from working. They're showing data that every year this costs the country billions of dollars, and that economic downstream effect was not hard to prove in this case.
She dropped out. Well, especially if you aggregate it, right? It's not just her. It's everyone else who's similarly situated. But in this case... As I understand it, this law doesn't apply to any... The argument was happening at a very different time in the country, very different mood, and in front of an increasingly conservative Supreme Court that just wasn't buying it anymore. Petitioner Berzancala's complaint alleges that she was the victim of a brutal assault. This is Chief Justice Rehnquist reading the majority opinion. If the allegations are true, no civilized system of justice could fail to provide her a remedy for Morrison's conduct. But gender-motivated crimes of violence are not in any sense of the phrase economic activity.
In other words, we're very sorry for what may have happened to Christine Brancala, but this is not commerce. This is violence. The suggestion was, at least in the Ollie's case, there was something being bought and sold. Here, they felt like the link to commerce was too thin. We accordingly reject the argument that Congress may regulate non-economic violent criminal conduct based solely on that conduct's remote effect on interstate commerce. Chief Justice Rehnquist got his majority to start to chip away at the commerce power. Just a tiny, teeny, teeny, weeny little bit. And Jamie Floyd says that attempt to roll it back.
Continues. It's rolling back. It is rolling back. Still pretty powerful. Don't get us wrong. But where we're left at the end of the day is in a really confusing place. Ali McClung, excluding black people from his dining room. Yeah, it's a commercial act. We consider it reprehensible. But I would like to think that raping Christine would be at least as bad. Totally. I mean, you see, this is what this kind of absurd abstraction gets us to. And in a coherent ideal world, can't be right.
But maybe that's just the inevitable thing that happens when you try and make it all about money. This episode was produced by Sarah Kari. More Perfect is produced by me, Jadon Imran, and an amazing team, Susie Leftenberg, Jenny Lawton, Julia Longoria, Kelly Prime, Alex Overington, and Sarah Kari, with Ellie Mistal, Christian Farias, Linda Hirschman, David Gable, and Michelle Harris. We had production help from Derek John and Louis Mitchell. Supreme Court audio is from Oye, a free law project in collaboration with Legal Information Institute at Cornell. Leadership support from More Perfect is provided by the Joyce Foundation. Additional funding is provided by the Charles Evans Hughes Memorial Foundation.
And on behalf of the entire More Perfect team, thank you guys for listening, spreading the word. You'll hear from us again very soon.