Skip to content
One Species, Barely Holding Together episode artwork

Mar 25, 2026 22 min

One Species, Barely Holding Together

from Evolutionary Insights by Anthropology.net Hosted by Anthropology.net

The bone fragment pulled from Denisova Cave is 2.5 centimeters long. It was dug out of Layer 12 of the East Chamber, a vaulted space in the Altai Mountains of southern Siberia where the light changes color in the afternoon and winter can kill you if you’re unprepared. The fragment was identified as hominin through ancient protein analysis, not morphology — it looks like nothing in particular. Then researchers drilled into it and extracted DNA from the powder, and what came out was one of the better-preserved Neandertal genomes ever sequenced: 37-fold average coverage from a single library, better than most ancient genomes require five to twenty libraries to achieve. The individual was male. He was probably about 110,000 years old. He had never been named or catalogued as a skeleton. He was, effectively, nobody — until he became one of the most informative people from the Pleistocene. Two studies published this week in PNAS, both drawing on new Neandertal genomic data, arrive at a picture of Homo neanderthalensis that is striking for how fragile it makes them look. Not just at the end, in the final few thousand years before their disappearance, but throughout their entire existence across Eurasia. They were a species running on fumes. The Fracture Lines The Denisova Cave individual — referred to in the Massilani et al. paper as Neandertal D17 — belonged to a population of Eastern Neanderthals more closely related to another individual from the same cave, roughly 120,000 years old and female, than to any Neandertal from Western Europe. This isn’t surprising on its face: they came from the same place. What is surprising is the degree of genetic separation between these eastern Altai Neanderthals and the western populations in Europe. The standard measure for comparing population differentiation is FST, which runs from 0 (identical) to 1 (completely separated). Among living humans, the most genetically distant populations on earth — Central African forest-dwelling groups like the Mbuti compared to Papuan Highlanders — reach an FST of around 0.27. These are populations that diverged somewhere between 130,000 and 220,000 years ago and have been largely separate ever since. The gap between Eastern Neanderthals (D5 and D17 from Denisova Cave) and Western Neanderthals (represented by individuals from Vindija Cave in Croatia and a newly sequenced genome from Belgium) comes out at FST = 0.30. That is larger than the most differentiated living human populations. The Eastern and Western Neandertal lineages diverged only about 115,000 years ago, compared to 260,000 to 440,000 years of separate drift between Mbuti and Papuans. Neanderthals were differentiating faster. The Massilani team attributes this to smaller effective population sizes, which amplify genetic drift: when groups are small and isolated, allele frequencies shift quickly just by chance, without any particular selective pressure driving them. How small were these groups? The genome of D17 shows that about 24 percent of his DNA sits in long homozygous runs — stretches where both copies of a chromosome are identical, a signature of recent inbreeding. In D5, the older female from the same cave, the figure is 20 percent. The Denisovan individual from the same site sits at 4 percent. Early modern humans come in between 1 and 6 percent. Population modeling using the length and distribution of these homozygous tracts suggests that the Altai Neanderthals — both the older Eastern ones and a later, Western-derived individual named Chag8 from a different cave in the same region — were living in groups of fewer than 50 individuals under realistic migration scenarios. The later Western Neanderthals in Europe appear to have lived in somewhat larger groups, but not dramatically so. Princeton geneticist Joshua Akey, who was not involved in either study, put it plainly: the global Neandertal population was probably only a few thousand breeding individuals, spread across most of Eurasia. There is something almost incomprehensible about that. Modern humans, for all the times we almost went extinct, have never been that reduced on a global scale while simultaneously occupying that much space. The Bottleneck You Can See Coming The second study, led by Charoula Fotiadou and Cosimo Posth at the University of Tübingen, approaches Neandertal demography from the other direction: not nuclear genomes from individuals, but mitochondrial DNA from dozens of specimens spanning the last 130,000 years of Neandertal history in Europe. Mitochondrial DNA is maternally inherited and present in large quantities in ancient bone, which makes it tractable even from fragmentary material. The team generated ten new mtDNA sequences from six sites in Belgium, France, Germany, and Serbia, and analyzed them against 49 previously published sequences. The pattern they found is stark. Before about 75,000 years ago, European Neanderthals showed multiple distinct mtDNA lineages. Individuals from different sites across the continent sat on different branches of the phylogenetic tree. There was genetic diversity — not a lot by modern human standards, but genuine regional variation. Then it collapses. The vast majority of Late Neanderthals, those living after about 57,000 years ago, cluster within a single mtDNA lineage. From Iberia to the Caucasus, across the whole surviving range of European Neanderthals, almost everyone is descended in the maternal line from the same ancestral population. The analysis places the origin of that lineage at around 65,000 years ago, with a 95 percent confidence interval running from 56,000 to 76,000 years ago. And it pinpoints the likely geographic source: southwestern France. What happened in between is not hard to guess. Marine Isotope Stage 4 — the glacial period peaking roughly 73,000 to 60,000 years ago — was cold and dry across Europe. The Fotiadou team’s analysis of the archaeological record, drawing on the ROCEEH Out of Africa Database (ROAD), shows Neandertal sites becoming dramatically concentrated in southwestern Europe during this period. The hotspot visible in the data through the 70,000 to 60,000 year window sits in southern France. Structured statistical tests on the spatial data show this cannot be explained by research bias or uneven sampling. Something pulled Neanderthals into that corner of the continent. The genetic and archaeological evidence converge on the same scenario: a population that had been distributed across most of Eurasia contracted into a refugium. Most of the earlier diversity was lost. Whatever lineages existed outside that southwestern European core either died out or were so reduced as to leave no detectable genetic trace in later populations. The only exceptions are two individuals in France — one from Les Cottés, one from Grotte Mandrin — whose mtDNA sits outside the main Late Neandertal lineage, suggesting the refugium itself preserved at least some of the older variation. When the ice retreated, sometime after 65,000 years ago, the survivors spread out again. Neanderthals reappeared at sites across Europe and into the Caucasus. But they were now, in the maternal genetic record, essentially one people. University of Tübingen paleogeneticist Cosimo Posth, a co-author on the Fotiadou study, described it directly: all the genetic diversity visible in the mitochondrial record before 60,000 years ago disappears, and a single lineage survives. This is not extinction followed by replacement from somewhere outside. There is no external source population arriving from Asia or Africa. The Neanderthals who recolonized Europe after the glacial maximum were the descendants of the ones who had sheltered in southwestern France. What the bottleneck destroyed, you cannot get back. 42,000 Years Ago The Bayesian skyline analysis in the Fotiadou study tracks effective population size throu… This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.anthropology.net/subscribe

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

One Species, Barely Holding Together

0:00 22:20

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Evolutionary Insights by Anthropology.net?

This episode is 22 minutes long.

When was this Evolutionary Insights by Anthropology.net episode published?

This episode was published on March 25, 2026.

Can I download this Evolutionary Insights by Anthropology.net episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.