Welcome to Primas 2024 podcast series. My name is Shonda Ragland. I am the senior director of Education and Training at Prima. On this Prima podcast, Daniel Litten will discuss optimizing the total cost of risk.
Daniel is the senior consulting actuary of Pinnacle Actuary Resources, Inc. We will also be joined by Primas education coordinator, Taequan Gilbert. Taequan will moderate the discussion. Enjoy the podcast.
Thank you for joining us today, Daniel. Yeah, happy to be here. Thank you. Very welcome.
So can you explain the concept of risk retention and how it relates to its resources policies? Yeah, of course. So risk retention involves an organization taking on a portion of insurance risk rather than transferring it to an insurance company. It's a idea that you retain it yourself.
And candidly, we do this all the time. You see this with your auto policy. We make insurance companies offer deductibles for your collision and comprehensive. And depending on what type of risk you think you are, you may choose a higher or lower deductible.
So, you know, risk retention, particularly for those who think that their good risks tend to take on a little bit more risk in the risk management portfolio. So it's really a key element of risk management. It requires coffee holders to bear a certain level of potential losses themselves. And this can vary.
And the way you retain risk varies. You can either do it through deductibles or through self-insurance. And the nuance is very small. Deductible of self-insurance from an actuarial standpoint are virtually identical.
So when you take on a deductible, you know, if you're unable to make good on your claims, on your retained portion, ultimately the insurance carrier is on the hook for the deductible layer. But if you retain risk through self-insurance, then the insurance carrier is unable to or is not required to make good on that self-insured layer. And if you're not able to pay your claims, then then they go to a state guarantee fund or some other residual fund to cover those losses. But really, the main motivation is retaining risk.
You can have greater control over your costs, right? It's sort of a cost-effective strategy in managing your risk. You get to get into the game. You know that you're liable for a claim to your deductible layer, and you tend to spend more time focusing on risk.
What are the key factors that influence an organization's decision to retain more risk rather than transferring the insurance? Yeah, absolutely. You know, one of the primary factors is balance deep strength. You know, you may be the best risk in the world with very little claim activity.
But if you don't have any financial wear with all its management volatility, whether it's through having some capital on your balance sheet or some other means of covering the claims, you can find yourself in some trouble fairly quickly if a significant claim were to arise. You know, it's closely tied to that as a level of risk tolerance, right? So how much volatility are you willing to accept in your financial statements? You may decide a $250,000 current current deductible is right for you, but are you willing to take a $250,000 charge to your income statement just due to one claim?
Or do you feel it would be more comfortable from a risk tolerance standpoint to lower that current's limit to $100,000? The other is cash flow. You want to be able to have that liquidity to be able to pay claims as they come due. Interestingly enough, retaining risk improves your cash flow position on set because you're not paying premium on day one to the insurance barrier for that deductible layer.
You're keeping those funds at the organizational level until they come due to pay the claim. However, with paying premiums, you've got a set number that is quantifiable and are no surprises. With retaining risk, you want to be able to have that cash flow to be able to pay whether it's a hundred or $250,000 claim when it comes due. So having that liquidity in that cash flow ability to pay claims is paramount to successful risk retention strategy.
From a mathematical standpoint, one of my favorite elements of a key decision is what kind of break are you going to get from the market? You may go to your insurance payer and say, hey, I want to take on a $100,000 deductible. The market says, okay, we're going to give you up $50,000 break on your premium, but your actuary tells you that your expected loss is at the organizational level. The maintain level are going to increase $100,000.
All of a sudden, there's a mismatch here. The market's not giving you back as much as you had hoped. It may not be a good deal and you make the side, hey, it's worth just. The source is still using the insurance market capital until that decision makes better sense.
On the other hand, I've seen it with some of my clients where they're looking to raise a deductible and we say, yeah, your expected losses are only going to increase $20,000 and they're like, great, the market's giving me $100,000 premium relief. Let's go ahead and do it. In those cases, one, it makes a good business decision just from a financial impact, but two, they know that they have a financial stability to absorb larger losses and have the cash flow to do so. So larger organizations with very good risk management strategies, strong balance sheets, tend to be better candidates for risk retention, smaller organizations, smaller balance sheets where there's a lot less predictability and loss experience tend not to be good fit for taking on high levels of risk through deductible self-insurance.
How can changing policy limits impact in organizations overall risk management strategy? So in this regard, you really want to think about the total cost of risk because when you're changing your policy limits, you got to think about it from a deductible level, but also from what the insurance company is giving you, right? So you may want to increase or decrease your general liability policy limits to some particular level to get some premium relief, but you may be taking on more volatility and same as your deductible self-insurance. You want to be able to quantify what your total cost of risk is as you're trying to manage your risk management strategy.
And some of these decisions factors involve a thorough risk assessment. You really want to evaluate your potential risks and their impacts. You really want to have a conversation with key stakeholders and say, what's on the horizon? What keeps us up at night?
What can really impact our balance sheet if we take on more risk or move our policy limits? You want to really consider that financial impact. How much volatility are you going to take in your financials, get any changes in your policy limits or deductibles? Because if you lower your policy limits, you are increasing your exposure on the top end rather than the bottom end and you want to make sure that you consider that financial impact.
So really that guiding principle of what you want to do in terms of policy limits just stand from a comprehensive risk assessment, a clear understanding of the potential risk of loss. And it really just comes down to decision making throughout the organization. How involved and how collaborative is the organization? Do the risk management live in a silo or are they able to have conversations and collaborate with other departments in the organization?
And that's paramount against a solid risk management strategy where everybody has a say in safety and control all the way from the C-suite out that risk is important and risk should be considered in everyone's job description. What are some common challenges that public entities face when adjusting their policy limits? So when you are adjusting your policy limits, there's a lot of considerations that should go into this decision. The first is really that's difficult in actually measuring your risk exposure.
So really precisely gauging potential risks. For example, it's important to stay ahead of any legislative changes on the horizon. So you may have decided to take on some risk but down the road, you know, if they legislate your rate, say, hey, we are increasing the potential of limitations for law enforcement liability, something that you have not considered in your risk management strategy. Now you've got this exposure to some positive catastrophic claims that have been lingering out there and someone sees that special limitations has an increase and goes ahead while the claim.
You know, another challenge is really balancing that cost and coverage. Again, finding that optimal equilibrium between expenses and protection. So the more risk you take on, the lower your expenses are on the front end but the more volatility you take on. And where is that sweet spot?
Where is that equilibrium? Really, it comes down against, you know, communication and alignment stakeholders. It's important to have proactive discussions and securing buy-in from key stakeholders within the organization. And it's also important really to align your risk management goals.
So ensuring that change in the line of the organization's risk management strategy and objectives, so really getting a sense of what does the organization's feel is the level of risk tolerance, is it in compliance with what the board thinks, what others think, what can at least what public energy standpoint, what are the constituents thinking, how much risk are they, you know, it's part of getting a pull on it, you can think of in terms of risk retention. But are you doing right by the taxpayers by taking on more risk and taking on more volatility for a public entity? What should public entities consider when determining the appropriate level of risk retention for the specific needs and circumstances? So to some extent, we've discussed some of this, right?
So really risk-powered. How much volatility are you willing to accept? If you've got a strong balance sheet and you want to save on your insurance premium and you're willing to take on that volatility because you have a strong sense of loss control, that's a big consideration. So thinking about your financial resources and your risk-powered is really important.
What is going on in the industry standards? And when I say industry, this can cover multiple industries. One, of course, what's going on with your peers, what other public entities are doing. But also, what's going on in the self-insurance industry?
You know, what requirements are changing around the horizon in terms of self-insurance? When you're taking on a deductible, you know, the insurance carrier may act, is going to ask you to collateralize that deductible layer. Do you have the financial wherewithal too? Put in the collateral to fund the deductible layer.
And then you've also just got to consider regulatory requirements. You know, what are you going to stay in compliance with relevant laws and regulations that you decide to change your risk management strategy? So to all of this, it's important to have that thorough assessment, identifying your correct, identifying your vulnerabilities, making sure you're consulting experts, consulting risk management professionals, looking at what actually they're saying is the total cost of risk, both the deductible layer and the insured layer, and making sure that you have a full understanding of your entire risk profile. From the holistic, let's say enterprise risk management's position of what the whole organization looks like, when you're taking on risk, you just really got to think about what risk you're exposed to, and how others can be impacted, and how key stakeholders can be impacted, how your constituents can be impacted.
And once you've done that, if you've evaluated risk from so many different angles, and you realize that risk retention is for you, you've done like your risk management strategy. What are the potential financial implications of increasing or decreasing policy limits for company? Well, this goes back to what we're talking about, right? So you've got changes in your policy limits, where you're increasing your cost by increasing your policy limits, you're decreasing your cost by decreasing your policy limits, you're taking on retention.
So the financial implications come down to you, what do you think your level of risk tolerance is going to be, how strong is your balance sheet, and how much capital are you willing to put up, to manage that these exposed layers for which you now have liability for a claim which can be incurred. So you want it to be very careful of what your exposure is when you're taking on risk, or moving your policy limits around, because if you're not, you may find yourself unaware that you had exposure to a some set of claims that you had not considered throughout your due diligence process for retaining risk. So it really is important to continue to have those discussions with key stakeholders with risk management professionals so that you really understand what that exposure looks like as you develop this risk management, this risk retention policy. Are there any emerging trends or innovative approaches in the field of risk retention and policy adjustments that public entity should be aware of?
Absolutely. So what we think here with our public entity clients is it's important to get ahead of rapidly changing exposures. So I'm thinking like cyber exposure, environmental exposures, law enforcement liability, standard exposure, sexual abuse and molestation, and really getting a sense of the quantitative analysis behind that, understanding what changes are on the horizon, maybe there's going to be changes and there's an impact to TorCAPs and how does that impact your risk management strategy. So the first thing is to get ahead and always be thinking ahead of what could be changing in the environment in terms of the exposures and the claims that could come in the door.
But then also, particularly for larger public entities, getting involved in predictive analytics and seeing what emerging trends are out there in terms of changes of frequency and severity and legislative changes, everything that could be out there, a good robust predictive analytics team could really help you see what's on the horizon and what changes in the environment to impact your organization. But then what we're seeing also, what's really interesting in terms of innovation and risk retention is we're seeing more and more public entities explore CAPs as an opportunity to retain risk. Back in the 80s and 90s, pulling was that innovative opportunity for public entities to get together and help manage their risk profile. And to some extent, pulling is still a very innovative means to manage your overall total cost of risk.
The CAPs have been making some noise in the public entity space and it's going to be interesting to see where that goes. Some of my public entity clients have said it's a convenient way to have funds that are earmarked for risk. And that other departments do not have access to those funds because it's now contained enough at a regulated insurance company. And so that gives public entities a little bit more flexibility to manage their total cost of risk.
So it's going to be interesting to see the see where these things go with CAPs and insurance companies and public entities. We've reached the end of our podcast. Thanks for tuning in. Please visit the Prima website to hear other Prima podcasts, view upcoming Prima webinars, read Prima blocks and learn about other Prima educational resources.
Be sure to check us out on Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter, and our very own Prima talk. Have an amazing day.