Welcome to FutureFile, your weekly podcast exploring all the technology that changes the way we live, the way we work and the way we play. This week we will be discussing parenting and specifically how technology can influence parenting, the benefits, the drawbacks and a couple of guests with me who are going to help me dive into this. First up is Mr. JC Sutton from our Mirrors Community Team who is, you may remember from the gaming podcast a couple of weeks back, he joins us for a second appearance on Future File.
Thanks JC and also for first time on Future File, Mr. Steve Mile who is our features editor and also a host of the first time Dad's podcast which we will be putting a link to. Hello. So thanks a lot guys for joining us both of which both of our, my guests obviously are new parents, I myself am not a parent yet so I will be learning hopefully as much as you guys will.
But I want to get into this because it's a very very interesting topic. There's a lot of statistics around at the moment about how technology is influencing children, what kind of usage children are having and young adults teenagers as well. All about what kind of use they are getting out of the technology. So for example, we had a report from off-con towards the end of last year entitled Media, Asian Attitudes Report looking specifically at parents and children and they found that from ages three to four, 1% of children have smartphones but 21% have a tablet, 53% of children age three to four go online for nearly eight hours a week, 48% use YouTube.
You put that up a little bit to 12 to 15 year olds and the numbers jump massively. We've got 83% of 12 to 15 year olds own a smartphone, 55% own tablets and a massive 99% go online for nearly 12 hours a week. So those are just a few stats to kind of crunch some of the numbers but how is it in the real world? I'm going to turn it over to my two parents, guests to kind of give their thoughts on what they think about the current side of consumer technology and how it impacts parenthood.
So guys, over to you, Jason, do you want to kind of start how are you finding technology and parenthood being a new dad yourself? It's a bit terrifying really because it's obviously adds a lot of convenience to life and it's not that another avenue for fun and entertainment but it's also a way for potential dangers to come in as well. And so my stomach is only nine months old and he's already been reaching for my wife's mobile phones and screens and things like that and we've had to block off the Xbox because he was a very good guy on the front. Right.
And it sort of made me kind of reassess my relationship with technology and how I used it and how I grew up with it and trying to balance my bias towards the way I grew up with technology towards myself and I was a parent and seeing it from the other side. So it's a bit of an interesting way to be on the other side of that thing now. Yeah. Steve.
I think there's a new parent and my little boy just said too, you approached technology when you were a parent the same way you probably viewed it when you weren't a parent. So if you're someone that wants every gadget and you have every gadget in your house before you become a parent, then when you're probably going to get every parenting, electric gadget, as a electric gadget. Yeah. So you can get monitors which connect to the internet so you can watch your child in its cup while you're at work on your phone.
You can get a matte switch, a motion sensitive so if your child doesn't move during the night and alarm goes off on your phone. My wife and I, we didn't go for any of that. We went for a very conventional just a monitor where you can hear him. Yeah.
And if you're in the next room, so not because otherwise it amplifies it to such a degree that you need, I don't think you need it. We survive without this kind of technology. Tools I think when kids are small, they don't need screens. Right.
So you can entertain yourself with like trains and cars and it makes him look up at the world when he's going around in his buggy. He's observing cars going past, looking at diggers, looking out for fire engines, space cars. He's not got head down on the tablet. Yeah.
And we've only got to get on the tube to see how we behave with tablets. Yeah. Everyone's looking at their phone on the train. Yeah.
No one's looking out the window at the world going by. No one's looking at other people's faces. And I think, you know, we haven't deliberately, my wife and I try to keep him off the screens, but we just don't think he needs it. Doesn't he?
At this point in his life, he's only been on planet Earth out of his mother's womb for two years. He hasn't seen enough of the world to want to find an alternative world. That said, we're expecting baby number two during the month's time. And I'm on this tour of us spending all of that time looking after him.
When that tension is split, we may be calling what we call the extra parent, which is perhaps TV. And you hear of, you know, you're talking a little bit about the parents and putting kids down in front of TV screen just to buy themselves 15 minutes so they can look after the small baby because, you know, they're entertained. Yeah. But I think it will be very cautious when we introduce that into his life because we've seen when we've gone to friends' houses, kids, when they've had the iPad or whatever, take them, other tablets, I might be able to take them off of them.
Kick off. Really? Start screaming, you know, like, what, more, more pad, more pad. Oh my God.
We've got friends that, when they had a second child, the present to the first child, because you're told to give a present to the child. Yeah. And the sipping off. What was an iPad?
I just, you know, wasn't that long ago? You know, I'm 40. Where the idea of having a smartphone put to us was like this amazing, incredible technology. When the iPhone came out, it was like, we even went like, you know, iPod's coming out.
And then again, when tablets start coming, available with colour, you know, we want your own life. Oh, yes. It's a real sort of more as a law type thing where how quickly you go back even 10 or 15 years and when I was growing up and, you know, the speed at which the technology has changed, as you said, as you both said, we were on our phones, we just think how quickly we're on our phones. And we have all seen that change kind of come about, but your kids will, you know, they won't be a world before social networks.
They won't be a world before smartphones for them. Yeah. That's, that's tick does make it easier in some respects. I mean, you can run out of nappies and you can be, we're walking down the stairs, you can be on your, your, your, your app, ordering nappies to be delivered the next day, which you don't have to go out and fight around a supermarket with a screaming child.
You can get to park with your child because it allows you to do. It seems to me there is this, there's this sort of two pronged kind of argument here. There is tech that enables, it makes it easier to be a parent and it's helpful. But there's also the tech that the child actually uses, which, which you have to be a bit wary of.
Yeah. So Jackson, at the moment, is on the cusp of saying Alexa play bar bar because we've got an echo in our house. And that's a bit freaky. That he's having a conversation with AI, you know, in our house.
And what's also, you know, worth noting of that conversation is it's Alexa play bar bar not Alexa, please play bar. There's no, there's no manners. Yeah. It's a demand.
It's an order. Yeah, exactly. It's an order and we're constantly told by Amazon and some of it's great that you can do all these things with it. It's on heating up, you can all shopping, you can kind of take direct, you can get directions, you can all the pizza or whatever.
And how long before we're having to put parental controls on smart home, your key to ordering like, you know, a lot of stuff does have parental controls in it already. It's just maybe it's not made. It's not. Yeah.
Yeah. I mean, you can go into these apps and you can find the settings, but I mean, I've written a number of features about how to do exactly that because it's not often spelled out or maybe it's not, maybe parents don't understand how to get in and change these things or actually looking forward a little bit when the kids get a little bit older and have been so used to it and they find ways around it. I mean, that was, I mean, that was, I mean, when I was in my, you know, teens, and the internet was coming around file sharing was starting to kind of thing and stuff like, you'd find ways around it. And then your parents who had jobs and mortgages and all the other stuff, they didn't always have the time to be as up to speed on what's going on.
I certainly agree with that nowadays, compared to our parents generation, that we as parents now have to be as literate or more literate with it on to children have to. I mean, my mother bless her. She couldn't really operate my grave very well. And if she knew that I was up till 4 a.m.
and I was a teenager down at the mp3s or playing 964, she'd probably be crazy. But now we don't have that. We can't do that anymore. We have to, they've heard of everything that's changing.
So, all the online games that are coming out, all the new features of our technologies that are coming out, we have to know what these games are capable of. And very specific language that they kind of use in the features and we have to constantly become. Which, coming out of it from a point of view of particular type of parenting where we want to be engaged with that. And we are journalists.
So, we're naturally slightly concerned, cynical looking like that we think there might be a problem there. So, we should be ahead of it. I'm sure it was loads of parents who just don't even consider it. It's like we wrote both things on a Darkland.
And a birthday cake for two y'all came up and it was white, sugar, frosty gysing with, God knows how much sugar in it. And you can see there was half the parents as this cake came out and it's not being dulled out. We're looking at each other. What do we give that to our kids?
And the other parents who didn't care, didn't even think that actually the sugar was an issue. And I think it's made the same as technology. Some of us think there's things to be cautious of. And the rest of us think, why doesn't matter?
You flagged before we came on about Steve Jobs. That's true, yes. It does. So just for a bit of context, back in 2010, Steve Jobs, the legendary co-founder of Raffle, was interviewed by a New York Times reporter called Nick Bilton.
And at that point, the iPad was a relatively new invention. And he was asked, Steve Jobs was asked, if his kids enjoy playing with it, to which his response was, and I quote, they haven't used it much. We limit how much technology our kids use at home. So that's from Steve Jobs.
Bill Gates also has reportedly limited the screen time of his children when they were younger, because they know and are aware of the way in which these technologies are designed to dominate your attention. So if they're doing it, that speaks volumes about how we as sort of even relatively non-techy people should be aware of it. Yeah, I wonder how many CEOs of cigarette companies like there smoke or, you know, bottles of drop-in companies have cupboards full of chocolate. You know, I think it's that principle.
I mean, let me tell you what I have to hear from it though. Surely, if we give our children a tech at a younger age, they'll become, we'll find out how they use it and why they use it. We always seem to be in a bit of a guinea pig environment, but sure, that's a good thing for making it better, safer, as we go on, or is it always open to be exploited? I don't know, what do you think?
I think it's the way technology works and the way we use it affects how we interact with people in the real world, apart from it as well. Once we're at World War and War and War from Tech, I think that's a really heavy influence. And I, when we see we're talking about that, is trying to talk to Alexa and I'm using please. And thank you, that's a kind of a worrying step that children might care about out into the real world and not being able to manage, not being stimulated constantly and I think it's important for the kids to feel ball occasionally.
So I kind of have to come up with their own interactions or to be a bit more internal and not necessarily have to be put in constant contact with other people or be connected. Even I kind of, when I get home from work, I like to just switch off and just kind of be present in the room with my family. And I kind of want to impress that on my son as well. And there's an interruption that takes place, you know, when you've gone by music and with CDs in all of us.
Right, Alex. And you don't have to know. You can operate entirely from your house. You can get your food, you can get music.
And if kids grow up in that environment, where's the interaction? Where's that human empathy come from seeing another person? And I'm not talking about over a screen, you know, a shared game, you know, computer game. But an actual person that, you know, is flesh and blood.
And I think there is, I mean, I'm anecdotally you're putting stats, but there is some discussion about knife crime in relation to computer games because on computer games, if you get stabbed, a person survives combatter life and in life crime amongst young men, they go up in that environment where either violence is a fake violence. They don't necessarily have to understanding that it's, you know, you stab someone, listen. OK, I'm going to come in on there again and play the sort of devil's advocate. What if, I mean, you're children of both young, but let's say getting on a little bit.
And they find that games or chat rooms or messaging apps or social networks and that allow them to maybe make friends with other children with similar interests, but maybe they don't find in the real world at school. Now, isn't sure that's a good thing. It makes the world smaller. It allows you to see other things.
But I think this is a, why has this technology been created? Who's behind it and what's the purpose of it? I think there are some definite educational benefits to it. Like computers and schools and stuff.
I mean, my other half is it's a teacher. And it's obviously, it's been a long time since the university of school, but it's all moved on so much from one of the kids get a homework sim. But when they're all school sick, they get their homework sent to them on Bay Remetal or something. And they kind of can confidence in and things like that.
And even the writing boards, all digital now. So it's all written in that sort of level. When I was at school, there was one classroom that had a digital board. It was a geography thing.
You could pull up the globe and sort of do things and annotate and stuff on it. It was one board in the entire school. The computers are most equal. Acorn computers.
They're black screen with green text on it. There's no graphics. Like the old Amstrad. Yeah, that's just that sort of stuff.
I'm really aging myself. I'm a university without email address. I don't have an email address after I've seen university. And I don't necessarily think I'm less than anan.
Because of that, I've probably caught up with my email. I mean, obviously, when you talk to your kids about that, I don't have any email. They'll be like, what's an email address right now? Because there'll be something else.
Why did you text? Why did you just like use your... You have to call up the whole graph. It's about the future too, where Marty goes into the diner in the future and plays the arcade machine.
I think it's a larger word to the young actor. So you have to use your hands. That's right. Like a baby's toy.
That's going to happen to us. Anyway, before that, I was going to say about your last night at school. Yeah, so there's obviously a whole range of benefits, especially in the educational sphere. When I think of when I was doing a school project back in the day, I'd just go around to a friend's house and he had in Carter, 95.
And everyone's home work looks exactly what's especially silly worded to in class 95. Then you'd take the tricks to a library. But now you can just access all that information immediately. And I think it helps expand that world.
It helps introduce concepts and ideas and the exchange of information to children at a younger age. I think that's fantastic. You can broaden their horizons. But you want them to have broadened horizons without losing focus or what's directly in front of them and how to apply that knowledge, the stuff they've learned online in the real world to get that.
That's important as what they do. And I trust in whatever it is that they're using that it's for good, rather than, if I can use me, a robotic. You want them to go so it's like a pre-peditanical website, and have it to get their information, rather there's an obscure kind of... Yeah, that's right.
There's always sort of side-effects. I'd say we might move from a society where the children are learning, exploring, putting Lego blocks in the physical world on top of each other, to drag and drop Minecraft-esque games, and that's just a sort of movement that's taking place. But what you know for an absolute fact that when a child is sitting playing with Lego blocks in your front room, they're not getting served ads. They're not getting their data the way they move the blocks isn't being recorded and sort of metadata anywhere else.
I can play there was a bit of a back at you Jeff as a childless. A man, would it matter to you if when you had children that they didn't use a pen and paper? How do you sit there with a pen? Well, absolutely.
I go nowhere without a note pad and a pen. I just don't. It's always in my back. It's like your journal is doing this background.
Not being able to write their name, does it matter if they have a signature they have a retinor ice can or they don't have... I think the stuff I get, kids go to school without enough strength in their finger and thumb to write a pen because they just swipe. It matters to me. It still matters to me.
Probably because I'm in that generation of I remember the time before the internet and before we all have phones. If you'd asked me in 10 years' time, I'd probably say, well, no. It's an out-of-the-skill. If you can get through with your fingerprints and your...
You'd have to make fire skill. You'd have to make fire skill. We don't know how to make fire. We don't need to make fire any matter.
We don't have to come together because we don't need to anymore. I don't know. It's something that I think when I can do come along at some point, I'd be really keen to make sure that they understand some of the parts of the... How website is created, how a server works, what a packet of data is.
That sort of stuff, which is kind of the nuts and bolts of computing and technology a little bit, rather than just how to go on YouTube and find keywords. It's like anything. There's depth to the knowledge and there's useful parts to the knowledge. And there's sort of the shiny surface level stuff that you maybe don't need to know as a lunch.
I think that's really interesting because I think that I don't know those nuts and bolts. I use all the technology and take the grants. I don't know the website. I don't know the product side of things and how...
Well, I can drive a car but I can take an engine apart. But then I totally appreciate how parents these days... You know, there's so much... Just go back to what you were saying earlier, Jayce, about you're expected to know all this stuff before your children do.
You know, there's so much that you have to know. I mean, I'm amazed that people can really turn out functioning children and hold down jobs and marriages. And all the rest of it. So hats off to you guys.
Thank you. Thank you. I'm sure that Jackson will have screens in front of him at some point on a more regular basis. But hopefully we'll still have some element of kind of him understanding that that's an addition to your life.
Not a replacement to your life. I don't know, Sam Cornie, but you want to remind them that technology is the tool that they are using rather than it kind of dominating and using them and kind of getting them into the messaging stuff you want it to be at all and not using them. That needs to be quite nice to actually say if you were going to give some advice to the listeners who maybe are using tech themselves and either new parents or all the parents or even people like me who have not got children yet. If you could think of a couple of really useful piece of advice that you found in your early experiences of parenting that you kind of wish someone had told you before you started about technology and how it works.
Oh, that's a tricky question. Yeah, we do post a tricky question here on this podcast. I think that less is more was not something that I wish I'd known because that's the approach I've taken. But I think that is the approach to take with regards to parents and tech.
Just because things are marketed at you as being when your parents are pressure on you to get all the bits and pieces and somehow that makes you a better parent by owning this stuff. I don't think that is. I think that's certainly to start with the first two years. The simpler it is, the more you understand the fundamentals of parenting and what it takes to feed.
In a microwave, it's useful for you to be in maybe, of course. And you know, it's useful to have hands free technology when you're pushing a buggy to call up music and that kind of stuff. And it's useful, but you don't necessarily need the Wi-Fi super duper, you know, 80 quid, 90 quid one. Right.
So, I agree with that, definitely. Yeah. And I think also think about what purpose the technology you're using is serving. What is it replacing?
What is it providing? If it's buying you like five minutes to go and do something very important very quickly or just to calm the child down briefly, that's fine, but enough. But if it's kind of replacing a core parenting role, if you're kind of, if you give them a title for an hour and they're not really getting any engagement from you or anything like that, I think that's an important question to ask. What is technology swapping out, replacing?
What are the benefits? Yes. You find that you're using other technology to allow you to use technology. So, you're sticking them in front of a TV screen so you can look at your phone.
I don't think that's a great thing. You can all probably do with being spending less time on our smartphones, looking at each other in the iPad. Absolutely. Yeah.
We do try and sort of, people talk to me a lot about technology. I try and sort of say this thing. It should be, well, it goes back to sort of what you're saying should be enhancing your life rather than kind of the reason for doing it. So, if you can use it to, say, make it a fantastic, easier or learn something, or take a valuable skill away from it.
Don't just let it, because technically, and the minds behind these products, these services, it's almost psychology and how adept it is at taking your attention away, because that's how they make money. That's not to say that it's not really useful to use them in your quiz, but it's a balancing act, isn't it? Really? Yes.
I feel we come back to saying that. We can, we can. Also, as a gamer, that if your child is playing a game or there's a hot new title that's out and it's on the play when everyone's talking about it, sit down and play it with them and watch them play it. Find out all the features that there are.
Go through all the menus. Read up as much as you can about the game because there might be parental control functions that are hidden slightly. There are things you can do to kind of control it, but be aware of everything the game can do because that's very, very important, because there are a lot of parents who kind of are unaware of being able to control screen time, but they're in the app itself, being able to set it to cut off, so control muting chat options or various private lobbies and things like that, so be able to do that and being aware of what a game can and can't do, and your ability to manage that is very, very important. So it might be a bit boring, so we're going through all the options and reading up, but it's very, very important.
That doesn't make me think of an interesting point. Some of the tech companies are actually putting out, you know, kids-specific products. I'll give you three off the bat, so Facebook has a Facebook messenger for kids, which is where the parents can fully control the contact list. It's a voice video chat app and you can draw and send stickers and things like that, but it's fully controlled by the parents and they prove it through their own Facebook account, so that's one.
YouTube Kids is trying to lock down YouTube as best it can, and lastly, Amazon, they offer a sort of Fire, it's a Fire tablet Kids Edition, but it also comes with a year's subscription of Amazon Prime, but Kids-specific content. So now, there are, it's such a murky topic and we could spend so on talking about it, because what these services are, effectively, is there are world gardens that can give kids a safe space digitally speaking to engage with, but also what you're doing is it's a sort of Trojan horse approach because you're automatically giving these children- It's like always happening all day. Exactly, exactly, exactly. So, again- You can do it and then you're still going to do it.
Exactly, and then you're going to put a drug analogy, isn't there? Lashing, or something. Yeah, I mean, it's, on one hand, as someone who's very pro-technology, I can certainly see the benefits of it, but again, yes, as a journalist, as a cynical journalist, I can say- It's a very parenting. I mean, we talk about it a lot of first-time dads.
The more time you can spend with your kids at that time. And I think if you don't spend time with your kids, where is your kids spending that time? And if you're kids spending that time doing something that you're not aware of, because you're not there, then that can't be a good thing, I don't think, for your relationship, because if you're somewhere wrong with your kids life and we hear about cyberbullying and stuff like that, then you're not there and you don't know what they're doing. How will you know, until perhaps critical point, that something's going awry?
I just think more time with kids is hard, but then- Is it easier if you find something that you can do to get a lot of what you're saying about gaming? If you're interested in that, or interested in football or something going out and playing football with the kids in the back, you can find that kind of avenue, then you're doing well. Plus, on a sentimental note, I find that there are times when my son and I are here, we'll be playing around with his toys and whatnot, and I might have the Xbox on, and I'll be playing a really small, quite simple game, or he'll be asleep on me, and I'll be trying to play games honestly. And then I pause for a second, and I think back to when I'm full-seal, 50, or 60, or whatever, and other than that, some Tommy that arrives is you wish you could get all that time back.
No one ever wishes they spent less time with their kids when they were growing up. So it makes you put it down, I'm going to be older, I'm going to miss him being asleep on me or being cute, and playing, and I'm going to miss that instead of considering the screen, so I'm just going to take that back and- Sometimes when you're running around trying to do stuff like that, I wish they weren't here, but I wish they could just let me do this, but then if you think, I'm actually not going to do that, what I'm going to do is lie in my stomach and play Brio Train with Jackson for half an hour. You know, it's got for instance, it's a little world, and it's like, when they're a teenager, locked in their bedroom with a VR headset on, and you can't, you just see plates of food vanish, sleeping all day, and you don't even know who their friends are. You were long, I'm pretty sure, as an early, for those early parent years.
That is quite a wonderful little note too, I think, in the show, and I mean, Steve, do you want to just go quick, plug out some of your podcast? For some bad podcast, you have fun and iTunes, and Spotify, and all the other places, it's basically two new dads talking about the madness of being first-time dads. All right, stuff, well, that's all from us this week, we've kind of run out of time, but thank you both very much for joining me. Really appreciate it, really good to talk, really enjoyed it, and hopefully really useful for the listeners as well.
As I say, this is your future file podcast, we do this every week, we're talking about all the tech that's in your life and affecting your life, so please do listen to us, subscribe, leave a comment, and we'll be back with another one soon. All right, thanks for listening.