Skip to content
Parsha Talk Ki Tavo 5785 2025 episode artwork

Sep 12, 2025 33 min

Parsha Talk Ki Tavo 5785 2025

from Kol Ramah Hosted by Camp Ramah in the Berkshires

Parashat Ki Tavo [Deuteronomy 26:1-29:8] features, among other things, the lengthy curses [Deuteronomy 28:15-68] known as the tokhehah [Warning]for Israel’s failure to follow the terms of the covenant. There is a parallel text in Leviticus 26 as well. There are blessings, too, but these are much fewer, perhaps reflecting the human tendency to gloss over our good fortune but itemize our bad fortune. It is to redress this, perhaps, that Rabbi Meir says that one must recite 100 blessings every day, in order to truly appreciate God’s gifts to us. The parashah also has the famous passage Arami Oved Avi [My faterhs was a fugitive Aramean, Deuteronomy 26: 5-11]. In the Torah, this passage is associated with the holiday of Shavuot, the holiday of first-fruits, whereas the rabbis make it the heart of the Passover Haggadah. We take up this interplay between the rabbis and the Bible in our discussion. We also discuss the difference between comings and goings, and goings and comings. We have now passed the 700-day mark of the captivity of the hostages. We continue to be mindful of them, the living and the dead, and insist that they be speedily returned to their loved ones. We also keep in mind the soldiers defending Israel as members of the Israel Defense Forces, may they be removed from harm’s way. This Saturday night marks the beginning of the recitation Selihot, penitential prayers, as we move closer and closer to the High Holy Days. May the coming year of 5786 be a year where dreams are fulfilled and peace is established. Shabbat Shalom.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Parsha Talk Ki Tavo 5785 2025

0:00 33:47
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Thank you. Shalom, and welcome to another edition of Talks Talk. I'm Rabbi Elliot Malik. I'm a kind of part to be talking about congregation on church. But joining me... But you're not in a concert. You're not in a concert. I'm at Anshei Chesed Synagogue. Anshei Chesed. Anshei Chesed. I changed it. I'll tell you a little funny story. We were always, it was always congregation on Anshei Chesed in any alphabetical list of synagogues in New York. It was always B'nai Jashren and then congregation on Anshei Chesed. We're like drop congregation. And now we're Anshei Chesed and we're the first then. We're the first. Any alphabetical list. Here we go. So we are in Anshei Chesed. I happen to be in the city today. And it's great always to pop in on Rabbi Jeremy Kalmanowski on Anshei Chesed.

And our long-lost friend in Long Island, Barry J. Chesler. Salam Sheikh, the day school of Long Island. We're recording this on day 706 of the war. The news is just anguishing day after day. We are a day after the attack in Qatar, and the literal fallout of that is still... It's just unbelievable. And a day of violence in the United States. A crazy day of violence in the United States that always has a little bit of the... Today, as we're recording this, a sort of right-wing political activist was assassinated.

You know, and you just fear that we go down the spiral of madness and increasing attacks. We're in a very difficult time. And, you know, we are also counting down literally, you know, less than two weeks before Rosh Hashanah. And that brings us to Kittavo. Kittavo is always during this time. It's so interesting, you know, thinking about this Parsha, we're also thinking about, you know, concluding themes and themes of renewal. So I want to turn to the opening parts of this Parsha, namely the Bikurim, the first fruits. I want to ask about the...

the experience of the first fruit and get your take on it. So Barry, explain to Wes, what do you think? The first fruits come at the beginning of the wheat harvest, probably in early June. It's identified with the holiday of Shavuot, which is referred to as Yom Bikurim in one of the biblical books, I think, by Yippurah. And the farmer not only brings his first fruits in a basket to the local priest, is the plain meaning of the text, not the one that the rabbis necessarily went by, and makes a declaration declaring that his ancestor was a wandering Aramean.

who went down into Egypt few in number, became a great nation, was enslaved and embittered, and God heard the outcry of the people, and God miraculously took the people out of Egypt and to the land that he had promised their ancestors, Abraham, Nitzchak, and Yaakov, and... the first fruits then are a sign of God fulfilling his promise. And what struck me this year in reading the passage is that the farmer makes his declaration when he brings the first fruits, not at the harvest in the fall, which might make more sense because I think embedded in the ritual is this idea of longing, that the first fruits are a kind of guarantee, a promise that there will be a successful fall harvest. So I just want to finish by saying that I think an important part of life is longing.

working towards something. In the words of the late great Harry Chapin, it's not the getting there, but the going that must be good. And this is kind of the biblical going. I have a slightly different take on it because my reaction to the Pilgrim's Bikurim is what a great sense of accomplishment. It's not that I'm a farmer. I think I've shared in the past that my closest experience is growing basil in my garden. That's heavy lifting. The experience of cutting a leaf of basil and then putting it in your whatever tomatoes. What an experience. But I can anticipate that. There's tremendous joy.

in seeing that something pops out. Look, I live not far from, you know, several New Jersey farms. I go to the farm stands during the season. We're in a wonderful season where tomatoes, they're just, I mean, New Jersey tomatoes, that's what it is. And there's beautiful corn and everything. And, you know, I interact with the people at the farm center, our local farm market at Highland Park every Friday, go make sure I buy, you know, a few things. And there's just a sense of joy that people have. There is, except the first roots are not enough to sustain you. Okay.

And I think it's important to keep that in mind. It's sort of like when you run a marathon, which I've yet to do and probably will not make it this lifetime, but I'm hopeful in the next world, that when you get to the first mile, that's a great sense of accomplishment, but you still have a long way to go. And I think the first fruits is kind of a similar process. You're celebrating, of course, and you are joyful because you do have something to show for your work to date. But so much hard work remains. And the question is, what is your attitude going to be? Because there are going to be bumps along the road. No farmer has every day a good day throughout the season. And you need something to sustain you.

during those difficult summer days when things might not look so promising. And I think that's what the first fruits are designed to do, to sustain you through the dark days of the summer, which will inevitably come. The rabbinic imagination about bringing Bikurim... What you said is certainly correct, and my experience with farming is even less. I was on kibbutz for five and a half months. Oh, wow. Good for you. I do go to the grocery store. There you go. It's practically a farm. But my experience is none. And so I think that what you said makes perfect sense. But the Mishnah in the third chapter of Bikurim, of bringing the first fruits. Good evening and welcome to Schechter School of Long Island. All ninth grade parents, please begin moving into the gym.

You don't have the ninth grade? No. Okay. So in the third chapter in Bikurim is a fabulous description of a celebration and a party. How does one set aside Bikurim? You go into the field and you see, for example, a fig. Now they're not imagining the wheat, which I think is the natural meaning of the text, but you see the first cluster of grapes or the first figs and you tie a little ribbon on it and say, I hereby declare these are my Bikurim. And then you go up to Jerusalem and you, there was a system that was called Ma'amadot in those days, Kohanim in different regions would take turns.

serving in the temple, and whatever, they went to their local, I guess you'd call it a county seat or something like that, and there's singing and dancing all night long in the streets, and they say, let us arise and go up to Zion in the house of the Lord our God, and then they come in, and they would bring fresh, those who live near Jerusalem would bring fresh fruits and grapes, those who live far away would bring dried fruit and grapes, and an ox would go before them, his horns bedecked with gold, and a crown of olive branches on his head, and they would play the flute, and when they would get to Jerusalem, they would send messengers, and everybody would greet them, and they would say, We're so glad that you are here in peace. It is, but I think we can agree as modern critical readers of the Mishnah that this is an imagined Bikurim procession. Because the reality for the rabbis is this passage about Bikurim is not about the first harvest at Shavuot, it's about the redemption of Pesach. This is the heart of the Haggadah. And I think that...

When we think about the shift of Bikarim, the reading of Armeel Vedavi from Shavuot to Pesach, is Pesach also is a beginning that comes with the promise, because now Shavuot is going to be the holiday of revelation, and what's going to complete the redemption from Egypt is going to be the redemption, is going to be the revelation. And again, I think that there's a sense of longing, which is expressed by our counting of the Omer, quite differently than the Torah imagines it to be. And it just seems to me that... sometimes perhaps we need to pay attention to this dimension of life. I think we, sitting in the diaspora, are missing one essential point of this passage, which is the land. The land. The pilgrim is standing on this land. He brought us to this place. He gave us this land. And so we, living in the diaspora, we, as part of a minority, we, who are not necessarily tied to land, although we have connection and we have all sorts of associations to landscape and surroundings, etc., but we are...

as Jews deeply aware of our transience. So what it suggests to me your answer, I don't know if you intended it, is that revelation becomes a defining moment of Judaism once there's a broken attachment to the land. Of course. Because in the land and in our ritual of Bikrim, there's no mention of giving of the Torah. We go straight from Egypt to the entrance into the land. And maybe, you know, and again, there's that shift which is expressed in a kind of longing because we long now for the second redemption, the great redemption.

because we are transient in this world. I feel that your observation that you just made about the sundering of the connection to the land, you can see how so many of the... We've always had an unbroken Jewish community since the time of Abraham living in Eretz Yisrael, but it is fair to say that... For the vast, vast, vast majority of Jews, whether they lived in, you know, Baghdad and Aleppo or, you know, Cairo and Casablanca or, you know, Lodz and Warsaw. It was an entirely emotional and imagined thing, not practical thing. And so revelation in the portable homeland of the book, it makes so much sense. And let's be honest and say that.

The relationship that we have since the massive return to the land has sometimes been pretty screwed up. It's a complicated relation, but it's the land. And Deuteronomy's program, Devarim, is a nation on the land. And it's overwhelming as the theme. You are coming into Lakitavot, Ela Aretz. Sofasu, you can stop the whole... Yes, Nachmanides, Nachmanides, and he said this in Baikra, although it's even more true in Devarim, that the whole point is exactly that learning all the means to vote is for when you get to the land. Nachmanides actually thinks that outside the land of Israel, all the means to vote are basically kind of DeRabanan. Yeah.

Exactly. All right, let's move to another one. It's a favorite pasuk. I'm sure we've talked about it again, but I want to see it in a different set of eyes. This is chapter 27, verse 9 through 10. So Moses and the Kohanim, the Levitical priests, speak to all of Israel, saying,

Quiet, silence. Here, Israel, today, you have become a people. To God. Listen to his voice. So that I command you this day. My first reaction on this reading is like, you know, we're so connected to Shema Yisrael Adonai. And I try to kind of do a thought experiment. If we change...

the liturgy, to put, and say, imagine that's what the liturgical statement is. It's coming at the end of the whole Torah. So you say, today you are a people. So leaving aside the silence, it's, I'm struck by, and here I have my thinking for the holidays, but it's, today you are a... A fountain pen, exactly. But it sounds like this is a graduation statement. It's saying, here you are, people of Israel, you are standing at the Jordan, you're going to graduate, and now you are a people. And there's so many types of becoming in life. This is the one moment that they are a people. And it's worth pausing on. But what is it? And what do you think is being, it's just poetic exaggeration to say,

today you've become a people, but you haven't been a people at Sinai, and you haven't been a people at, I mean, because the graduation thing, of course it is real, and this is a covenant, this is a covenantal assertion, both in the, both in the, you know, passage, and in the blessings and curses that will be given here on, and it is a foreshadowing of the covenant renewal ceremony that Joshua will make at the end of that book, but, It is, I think, poetic exaggeration to say, because they were people at Sinai. How about when Bilam says, you know, yeah, this is, I'm in Israel. So it just strikes me as a little odd. I think what supports Eliot's point of view, though, is that the covenant here is distinguished from the covenant at Horeb. I can't remember, I think it was Rashi who mentions it in one of his comments. And so there is a sense that what's happening now in Debarim, on the east side of the Jordan, is not just a continuation of what happened at Sinai, but something different.

And so it could be a graduation. And Sinai, perhaps, is kind of like a middle school graduation, perhaps. Or an entrance into kindergarten. I'll tell you why I'm focused on this. Because, you know, I spent some time in Israel this summer in the Harmon Institute. And the question that kept coming up was, what are we going to become? And I find that, I'm thinking about that certainly as we come into the new year. I'll probably make a sermon on it or not. Who knows? Because we're only 14 days away. Why would you have to worry about that now? Seriously. It's not until 12 hours before that. So the question was, what are you becoming? What are you going to become?

You know, I'm thinking of the Shlomer, a person woke up in the morning and he felt like he was a people, and that's the Zionist story, that you are a people now. And what does that mean, and what's profound about it? But let me get to the second one, which is, You'll hear, Okay, Jeremy Kamenowski, Rabbi Jeremy. Sounds a lot like... Okay, so...

Right, you don't have to be rabbis. I didn't see that until... So it's an echo of Sinai here. And maybe that's what you're saying, Barry, which is this is a covenantal moment and the people are becoming a people simply by their echoing of their commitment in the sense, you have to do this. And perhaps the emphasis on the becoming, which will continue. That in other words, you're not ever a people forever. You are always becoming a people. This is very attractive because, you know, this is...

In Western thought, the distinction between becoming and being is profound. And it reminds me of a... I think it's attributed to the Kuska Rebbe, let's assume. Why is it we call Shavuot Matan Torah and not Kabbalah Torah? Because Matan Torah, the gift of Torah, the revelation of Torah, the gift of Torah happened once. But Kabbalah Torah happens every day. Every day you have to accept it. So perhaps it is something like this. It's not that the juridical status, the covenantal partnership, all that has been going on throughout. I mean, the Exodus 19 through 24 really makes no sense.

if that is not the covenantal moment. But it is also true that even in an enduring covenant, it requires active affirmation all the time. And so this rhetoric, which I'm not inclined to think that this is a, you know, kind of a different juridical status, I'm just inclined to think it's poetic oomph, that, you know what, guys? Commit yourselves, and that's what makes you a people. And it's a good statement to end your valedictory speech here, you know, your speech in front of the people. It's like, today, it's it. And, you know, tomorrow, today is it. Yeah, tomorrow is also today. All right. So let's turn to the last third of our talk, which is blessings and curses. And I want to focus on blessings because, let's face it. They're more fun. We've actually spent a ton more time talking about curses this week. Exactly. So here's what happens.

if you do the mitzvot, if you listen to them, all the blessings shall come upon you, chapter 28, verse 2, and then take effect, they'll catch up to you. I love that idea that the blessings are following you and they catch up to you. If you obey the word of the Lord, you're God. Fine, okay? I mean, fine, yeah, of course. Then I want to sing it almost like,

your basket and your kneading bowl, blessed shall you be in your comings, blessed shall you be in your goings. Okay, so that's lovely. That's beautiful. It's a little less, it is beautiful. Maybe a little less beautiful than Shirah Shirim. You are a living of the valley. The calving of your flock and the lambing of your... Your sheep, the lambing of your flock, the lambing of your flock, the lambing of your flock, calving of your herd and lambing of your flock. Who heard a word like lambing? The lambing, it's your lambing.

I'm moved by it. I think that any time we give blessing or receive blessing, it's profoundly moving. And I want to suggest here, I guess the obvious, which is not a suggestion, which is this is the totality of your life. The city, the field. Everything, your productivity, namely your personal fertility and the fertility of your animals and your basket. Blessed shall be your basket and your kneading bowl. And then the last line, which I'm very drawn to in terms of homiletics, which is blessed are you when you come in and blessed are you when you go out. And the reason why I'm drawn to it homiletically is because I hear in my biblical ear the inverse of this.

Which is, clarify what you think the more important is. I'm not sure what the more important is, and this is what I need, I'm working this through. Okay, so this is what strikes me. I want to show you, on the inverse is, is what it says here, coming and going. or entering and leaving, and then there's leaving and entering, which is at the end of Psalm 121, which we've been reciting the whole year, or two years since the war, God guards you going out and coming forth for now and all eternity. And I'm struck by the fact that these are two very similar things, but one is an inversion of the other, and what that means is that maybe there's something different, okay? So my pitch to you is as follows.

Entry and exit is speaking about space, the internal space, and using, as broadly speaking, home as the idea. I come into a space and I leave a space, I usually think about that as home. You know, blessed where you come in, I welcome you. Blessed where you go out, you're going out. Is journey. May you be blessed, may God guard you, when you leave and when you return. So I'm thinking about this as follows, okay, which is...

All of us have had the experience of standing at the gate as your kid goes on the airplane, okay? Or standing at the door as your kid leaves home. Or being yourself the kid who leaves home and says goodbye to your parents, okay? And that moment of departure is a moment, back to longing, of longing. And it's, the one anxiety that you have is, you're coming back. I hope you're coming back. I know you're coming back. I want to see you when you come back, okay? That's seichal wecha. That's life as a journey, okay? It may not be, by the way, the parent does worry that I hope you come back, or I want you to come back. But it may also be...

I hope you make it back, because this is all in a package, the blessings of abundance. It's just really, really hard for us to imagine what ancient people put in. What kind of vulnerability about food sources or their animals or whatever. It's very hard for us to imagine. When I get paid, I open up the app and I see that somebody has made the numbers in my bank account. They had to, as Barry was describing, work incredibly hard under incredibly, you know, iffy conditions. And so if you have that journey thing, it's like, go out there.

And I really hope you make it back. Yeah, I hope you make it back. And I think they're two fundamentally different metaphors or stories that we have in our lives. One story in our lives is we live in our homes, we live in our cities, we live in our spaces, and we want to be blessed in our spaces. And the other one is we want to be protected on our journeys, and we live our lives really as a journey. So the master arc of the Jewish people is Yitziat Mitzrayim v'Hevetah. It's in the first passage that we recited, right? It's, you took me out of Egypt, back to the Aramea Oved.

It says, you took us out, you brought us. So that's the same, it's so commonplace, but we take it for granted. You went out and you brought us. That's the master story of the Torah. You took us out of Egypt, you brought us into the land. However, so it's, and it's, you see the verbs in Avraham, and you see the verbs in many other places. The inverse is Noah. Noah, God says to Noah, and then he's cupped up in the Teva, in the Ark, and then God says,

Get out of there. And what happens on the ark? Well, what's also, by the way, when Moses says, you know, I got to retire. Yeah. Exactly. He uses it in that way. So that tells me another thing. Let's say it is about living in life. So I want to offer a slightly different interpretation. And that is that is a kind of a prayer about our lives. We want to be blessed when we're brought into the world and we want to be blessed when we leave the world. Yeah. And that is a journey that we make once.

The tsetcha hu b'o'echa is the metaphor of return. It's about coming home. What's important about the Exodus is we're not going to someplace new. We're going to the great line in Rocky Mountain High about being born in the 27th year to a place I've never been, going home to a place I've never been before. And that's what this journey is about, that when we come to the land, we are actually coming to an old land, not a new land. There's a mature theme. This is for mature listeners only. And one of them is Shimon, baruch atah b'o'echa.

So for the sake of Torah here, we will express this. It says, may your wife not be in the state of Nida as you return home. Because for our Hebrew, our listeners were a little bit less into the idiom of Hebrew. and it's different than English, la voe, to come to, not putting too fine a point on that one, is a sexual metaphor. To engage in sexual conjugation. So it's the, in the most literal interpretation, may your wife be sexually available to you as you return from your journey, okay? Now, I'm not sure, you know, I've read this over and over, and I'm thinking, like, is he being serious here? Is it a little joke? Is it humor? Or should we take it as Torah, which is any way you want to?

I think I would characterize most of the Midrashic stuff like that as they're playing, but they're serious. In other words, they're not joking, but they are playing with the space that exists in these words. You know, it also reminds me, by the way, let's say, it reminds me a little bit of the Jacob in the dream, because the angels are going up and down. We don't say going down and up, even though that kind of fits the context of the narrative. They're better in Genesis. But let's say, yeah. So you're saying it's the idiom, but I'm saying the idiom...

exists for a fine purpose. And I've been very, very captivated by the idea that we use a lot of metaphors in the way we speak and, of course, in the way we teach Torah. And, of course, the Torah itself and the metaphor of home versus the metaphor of journey are two very, very powerful metaphors that are metaphors for life. So now, here, I'm doing the homily, okay? The sermon is, you're coming home, right? So Rosh Hashanah's coming, and for many of our people, it is about coming home. I had a lovely conversation with a Jew who said, you know, as this person became aware that I was a rabbi, and I said, yeah, I'm worried about the holidays I'm preparing. And she said, you're prepared.

preparation and my preparation are different. Your preparation is about sermons. My preparation is who is coming home? You know, in that moment, it was so profound because it's like so true. Most of the world, the Jewish world, they're experiencing these moments as Baruch Atah B'vuecha. Yeah, you're coming home. So maybe the existential question of the high holidays is do I have a home to come to? Okay. And then it's also, am I going on a journey after this? You know, it's not only, you know,

your your exit from this this place but it's like you're going into life now and you know i say it emotionally i feel very emotional about it i want you back i say i feel it the same way that i feel standing in saying goodbye to your kid and saying i i'm saying goodbye but and i'm saying with joy may you go with all the love and blessings but i'd like to see you back here right because when you want to see someone back it means they've been there already once before and that's an important thing to remember Because not everyone feels at home when they come to Shul and Rosh Hashanah people wear. And our task as rabbis is to make everyone feel at home. And we hope people feel at home with us here. Absolutely. Absolutely. So we're going to do the sign-off now. Yes. Thank you. It's been a pleasure. We've got one more before Rosh Hashanah. We're going to get one more in it. Good. Until then, everyone, shabbat shalom. Shabbat shalom. See you next week on the next edition.

Kol Deracheha Rachel Leshaw Welcome to Kol Deracheha, a podcast about women and mitzvot, from deracheha.org, a Yeshivat Har Etzion Initiative. Our name comes from the pasuk in Mishlei 3:10, which says "be-chol derachecha da'ehu." "In all your ways, know God." We've changed that to Kol Deracheha, which means "all her ways," and also "the voice of Deracheha."Our goal is that Kol Deracheha will inspire you wherever you walk on the pathways of Torah.Season 1 of Kol Deracheha is dedicated in memory of Mrs. Anita Hirsch Silverman, Yehudit Raizel bat Eliezer v'Esther, zichrona livracha. towrah yahwh shuwb nephesh Dabar Torah Channel Shemoth 9:14 zo'th pa'am shalach kol maggephah leb 'ebed 'am yada' 'ayin kemow kol 'erets Bible (Reina Valera) 09: El Primer Libro de Samuel by Reina-Valera ciesse El Primer y Segundo libros Samuel originalmente eran un volumen en la Biblia hebrea, que proporciona la biografía histórica de Israel desde la era de los jueces hasta David, el segundo rey de la nación. Las escrituras dan cuenta de los tratos de Dios con la nación, incluido el propio Samuel, el vínculo de conexión entre los jueces, y los reyes. Ramah, a unos diez kilómetros al norte de Jerusalén, era la localidad del ministerio de Samuel. Era su lugar de nacimiento, residencia judicial y lugar donde fue sepultado. La oficina norte de Samuel estaba ubicada a cinco millas al norte de Ramah en Bethel, donde 800 años antes Jacob había visto la escalera al cielo. La oficina occidental de Samuel era Mizpeh, tres millas al oeste de Ramá, donde colocó la piedra "Ebenezer". En su vertiente norte estaba Gabaón, el lugar donde estuvo Josué cuando el "sol se detuvo". Ramah se localizaba en un área central esencial para el ministerio de Samuel. La casa d An Intro to God Volume 2 - Mitswah (Instructions) Yada Yahowah Mitswah • Instructions To understand the Mitswah | Instructions, we must turn to Yahowah’s Towrah | Teaching, where Moseh revealed the value of observing them… “You should observe (wa shamar) His clearly communicated prescriptions of what we should do to be cut into the relationship (choq huw’) in addition to the instructive conditions regarding what He is offering and what He expects in return (mitswah huw’) which, to enjoy the benefits (’asher), I have provided as instructions and directions for you (’anoky tsawah ’atah) this day (ha yowm). Then, as a result of the relationship (’asher), He will be good to you and accepting of you (yatab la ’atah), and of your children (wa la beny ’atah) after you (’achar ‘atah), while also (wa la ma’an) elongating your days (’arak yowmym) on the earth (’al ha ’adamah) which (’asher) Yahowah (Yahowah), your God (’elohym ’atah), is giving to you (nathan la ’atah) for all time (kol ha yowmym).“ (Dabarym / Words / Deuteronomy 4:4

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Kol Ramah?

This episode is 33 minutes long.

When was this Kol Ramah episode published?

This episode was published on September 12, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Kol Ramah episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.