Skip to content
Parsha Talk Lekh Lekha 2025 5786 episode artwork

Oct 31, 2025 33 min

Parsha Talk Lekh Lekha 2025 5786

from Kol Ramah Hosted by Camp Ramah in the Berkshires

Parashat Lech L’cha [Genesis 12:1-17:27] is the third of the parashiyot in Sefer Bereshit [Book of Genesis]. It has long been recognized as the beginning of our Jewish journey, though Abram [who is renamed Abraham in the parashah] is never identified as a Jew. He is Abram the Ivri, the Hebrew, which might be understood as Abram, the descendant of Eber, or Abram, the one who stood over and against the world with his proclamation of monotheism in a world of pagan worship. Our conversation focused on the opening verses, with God’s charge to Abraham. What is the force of the phrase ve’h’yeh b’rakha, be a blessing [12:2]? What is Abraham’s mission? We also compared him with Sarah, about both of whom the Torah records that they laughed in response to the news about an impending pregnancy. What kind of laughter was it? What does it teach us about Sarah and Abraham, not only as individuals, but as marriage partners? This is a particularly rich parashah [which probably could be said about all the parashiyot in Genesis], but what distinguioshes this, perhaps, is the number of discrete scenes. We continue to keep in mind the hostages whose remains are still in Gaza. May they be returned swiftly to their families for a final, dignified, funeral. We are also mindful of the men and women defending Israel as part of the Israel Defense Forces, may they be removed from harm’s way. Shabbat Shalom.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Parsha Talk Lekh Lekha 2025 5786

0:00 33:37
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Shalom and welcome to another edition of Marshall Talk. I'm Rabbi Elliot Malavitz in Highland Park, New Jersey, at the Highland Park Consortium. Highland Park Consortium.

Joining me with good friends, Rabbi Jeremy Kominovsky, Banjai Chesed, New York City, Rabbi Barry Chesler, Assamantik, the Day School of Long Island. And first, we want to say Mazel Tov, Rabbi Jeremy Kominovsky, Rabbi Amy Kominovsky. Beautiful, beautiful wedding this past Sunday, Dasi to Greg. And what a lovely, lovely, beautiful simchat it was that these two lovely young people are joined together, creating their own home now. And it was beautiful, fantastic, and just spellbinding. I'm still on cloud 10. Yeah, exactly.

And we begin noting today 756, while the hostages have been released, 11 bodies still remain in Gaza, and we pray that they are found and returned as soon as they can be returned, that the ceasefire holds, and that whatever the next chapter is, we will be in the next chapter, knowing, of course, that it's not going to be simple, even as we record this today. Lots and lots of very complicated and difficult things are taking place in Israel, but we'll leave that for another conversation. We want to talk about Lech Lecha. And it's true that Lech Lecha, this parasha, is the parasha that begins the Jewish story. And even saying it's the Jewish story is almost an anachronism because Abraham, always spoken of as the first Jew, is not technically the first Jew. And he is Ivri, he is a Hebrew. Of course, the term Jew doesn't come into the vocabulary until way, way, way into the biblical.

after the biblical era. But for all intents and purposes, he's our ancestor. And our story begins with Abraham. And our story begins with God saying to him, and the immortal words that you shall be a blessing. We didn't talk about this to begin, but I just want to get your vote on this, which is, it's go forth from your land, your birthplace, your father's household to the land that I will show you. I will make you a great nation. I will bless you. I will make your name great. So the Vav in V'yei Bracha could be,

And you shall be a blessing. Okay. Which is the imperative. And that's, that's been our traditional interpretation. What about, I'm just going to float this as a pocket reaction. What about so that you will be a blessing? I think that's what makes the most sense. Actually. It's sequential. You do this and this will happen. And therefore you will be a blessing and therefore you will be a blessing. So, so it's, it's the blessing. The blessing is a consequence of all of the things that, that happened to you, including this transition. Right. But there's also a counter story here because this is all very passive, right? God's making the great nation.

And he's going to bless him. And Abraham will not bless, but will be a blessing. Right. And so while we've always kind of looked at this as an imperative, the final clause in this little introduction could be understood the same way. And therefore, all of the families of the earth shall be blessed through you. And there you have it. That's the main goal, which is here, I want to establish something, a relationship with you. I want you to have this journey. And therefore, you will be a blessing because of all the things I give you, because of the blessing I give to you. And therefore, because of all this, there will be something about you that will bring blessing through the whole.

world through all the families of the earth through you all of the world will be blessed and and which means through you the blessing power that because of you and because of my relationship with you the blessing power will radiate from you to the rest of the world. And that's what I want. God wants blessing into the world. God wants life in the world. God wants that kind of direct connection. And through Abraham, blessing will come into the world. And if you like Abraham, you'll get it. If you don't, you won't get it.

Right, and there seems to be an implication that the nations of the world will recognize in Abraham this blessing quality. Right, and so that they won't necessarily have to be part of his family, but by simply admiring Abraham and by emulating him and by certainly taking the wisdom or the idea of God, they will themselves become a blessing as well. So what do we make of it today? How many Jews do you think see themselves as a blessing? And how many non-Jews look to Jews as a source of blessing?

So I think this is one of the reasons why we spent so much time at Camp Ramon and the Berkshires talking about this, because I think that this idea is so, it's not misunderstood, but not known. I mean, it's almost like saying, do Jews know what it means to be Jewish? Well, most Jews would say, well, I'm Jewish. It's like asking someone about their breath. I breathe. So I don't need to really think about it. But if we peg the identity of Jews on this formative moment, then...

A Jew has to reconcile or to recognize that as a descendant of Abraham, your presence here is to bring blessing into the world. That's what we said. And that's what you said at the wedding too, Jeremy. I really feel like, you know, this is a little bit on a knife's edge here because this can and should be taken as an imperative to live in a way which confers blessing to the world. That's a heavy responsibility. It's a great power. And that means that when you look at your being Jewish, you kind of should say to yourself,

How is it that I am a blessing to not only my own nation, which I hope that's true too, but to the other people too, right? And I think in the... you know, 20th century, when different iterations of Zionism, like some Zionisms have been, you know, that we hope that we are a luminous nation, which brings lights to the world. And then some versions of Zionism, you know, famously said, well, we should be a state like all the other states. You know, I think Ben-Gurion said, you know, when a Jewish cop arrests a Jewish burglar, then we'll know we're a state like all the other states. I don't find that latter one, you know, that let's be a nation like all the other nations. Let's be a state like any other state.

I find that, you know, really unworthy of Jewish history and the mission quality of the destiny quality of the Jewish people. So I want our people to say. You know, I really, I have to try to be a blessing. And because we do have so many enemies, and Barry, you sort of said, like, you think the other nations, actually, I think the other nations, for the most part, have not seen us as a source of blessing for all kinds of reasons of competition and rivalry and... Delacy, envy, shame, fear. Religious, you know, anti-Judaism, not, you know, the Christian story of anti-Judaism. All those things are replaced. They have tended to think that we're, in fact, a malevolent influence. And all too often, I think that Jews have said to themselves, okay, well, we should just worry about ourselves then. I certainly think...

You know, there are different iterations of this. This takes different guises. But some of the most extreme nationalisms that one sees in Israel are the opposite of... Right. So and, you know, not to be too sympathetic to that, but it arises out of a tremendous cynicism and the real experience of Jews who have suffered terribly at the hands of the nations of the world that have not known you. And that this line that really is the...

The summative line about those who bless you will be blessed and those who curse you will be cursed. There's a truism to that. The truism is that the nations that have cursed us and invade against us and try to exterminate us are themselves loathsome and reprehensible cursed nations. And those that are of the admirers of the Jewish people, they end up sharing a lot of the values and they are blessed nations. The question then is, how does one become a blessing? Because God is blessing you, therefore you will bring that to the rest of the world. In other words, it's almost like saying, and I'll use you as an example, you bless your children under the chuppah, and you give them this tremendous feeling of aura, this light, this tremendous love. And it's with the hope that they're going to take that with them into the world, and that will be shared to everyone.

Doggone it, that's exactly what happens. We stand at our tables on Friday nights and bless our families, and we convey that great sense of love. And you know what? We hope that that will be shared into the world, that they will go out as vessels of love into the world. They will radiate something, to use the radiation metaphor, the nuclear metaphor. They're radioactive with blessing. God is making Abraham radioactive. And so everyone that Abraham is going to touch is going to get a little bit of that radioactivity.

Does that work? That's what I want to be. That's what I want to be. Okay. All right. I want to fast forward to the end of the story, okay? Because I'm troubled by what happens at the end of the story. And I want your help in understanding this moment. The moment is where...

Ishmael is already born in the family. And Ishmael is born into the family because Sarah is frustrated. She wants a child. She has Hagar become a surrogate for her. And Abraham acquiesces to what Sarah wants. Ishmael is born. And then God comes into the picture and says, no, you're going to have a child. And you're going to have a child through Sarah. And this is in the passage where Abraham gets his name Avraham.

And Sarai gets her name as Sarah. This is chapter 17, verse 15. Her name will not be called Sarah anymore. I'm going to bless her in the same way that, by the way, the blessing of the beginning of the parasha. And I'm also going to give her through you, to you, a son.

And I will bless her. And it will be for nations and kings and kings of nations. They will ensue from her. And it's at that point, verse 17, that Abraham, he falls on his face, and he laughs. And he says in his heart, Is a hundred-year-old man going to bring forth a child? And Sarah too. A nine-year-old woman going to have a child? So I want to get the intonation of this, and I want to understand.

what the laughter is because I am confused that the whole tradition sees in this laughter, you know, joy, he's, he's, he's happy about this. And I don't see the glee here as much as I see the, the really, the, the irony and maybe the sarcasm or maybe the cynicism and even worse, the sardonic quality of this laughter, huh? You know, and I don't know which, which. tone to give it i mean i often think you know in reading this one of the exercises i like to do in studying and teaching is like okay so you're directing this play and you have the abraham actor here and so you tell the abraham actor okay you got this line here and figure out your emotion here is it well you should ask him what kind of laugh it is well that's the quality of the laugh itself so what i would suggest is that with abraham it's the laughter of wonder of a kind of amazement and with sarah it's a nervous laughter because i think one of the things that might distinguish abraham from sarah is that things may have happened too late for sarah and if i remember correctly she never speaks isaac right after he's winged there's no interchange between sarah and isaac abraham at least takes a son to go kill him um but

You know, like Abraham seems to have aged better than Sarah. Like I sometimes imagine Sarah thinking this should have happened years ago when I could enjoy it. Now it's wonderful, but I can't really enjoy it the way I would like to enjoy it. And not only that, I mean, there is that, the weaning is about taking Isaac out of the world of women and putting him into the world of men, you know, and really, I think quite rightly, as you said, it's really separating him from his mother and putting him under the orbit of his father. Jeremy, I mean, if you're going to direct Abraham in this play here.

Joy? Happiness? Laughter? Giddiness? Bellini? Truffaut? Bellini. Definitely Bellini. Well, you know, because this story is going to be, you know, paralleled in the next Parsha, and Isaac, obviously, it's an etiology story. Why is it called Isaac? Because when Abraham heard he laughed, Isaac, when Sarah laughs, that seems to be valence negatively. And then when he's finally born, Sarah says, Abraham laughs Billy Bo. Sarah laughs Bakir Ba. He laughs at his heart. She laughs.

you know, inwardly, although Bikir Ba, the Midrash, reads it as she laughed at her inner organs, like that internal organs, that is to say, you know, like that's going to happen. But then when the baby's finally born, she says, Everyone who hears about it will laugh. And I wonder if there's a... you know, so why Sarah's laughter veils negatively when the words are almost the same and Abraham's laughter veils positively, you know, one can ask oneself whether the stories are just, you know, a little overdetermined that they're always going to reflect well on the patriarch and more ambivalently on the matriarch. But that phrase, might it mean, God played a joke on me, everyone who hears will laugh at me. Is she feeling, when it comes up next week, that she's being mocked?

And Abraham, who has been getting these promises, now sees the promise fulfilled. She's been at this for 25 years. She only did the little surrogacy arrangement after 10 years of childlessness. So this is already now another 15 years on from that. I think that her laughter might be, you know, a little bit frustrated, like, what does the person got to do here? You know, I've been doing my best, and you're just yanking me around, and then finally, in this kind of almost ridiculous way, you finally give me the big prize at the end, whereas Abraham, I think, you know, I think, I'll go a little bit closer, like Barry said, wonder that the promise is at long last fulfilled.

I'm thinking about, and I tried to do a little research on this. I haven't, you know, been as successful as I wanted. There are people who study laughter and that laughter is a mechanism which, you know, we take it for granted. But laughter is an equalizer in some way. Laughter is a way to express what, you know, in one experience of laughter, it's an experience of, you know, discomfort. Or it's the, there's a sense that you are establishing an equality between people. When we have our conversations and we laugh with each other, it's because we recognize things, we are building the relationship among the three of us, let's say, in our conversations. It's not because we're genuinely funny, although, you know.

some of us we are genuinely funny um but you know this is not a this is not a funny moment although whenever i you know get up and talk about this and and you know the there are some elder women in the shul and i say you know think about this you know uh god is saying to a 90 year old woman that you're gonna have a child and they they actually get a lot of joy out of that they get a lot of humor out of that they go that's hysterical you know and and in a way it's like I'm troubled by it, but I shouldn't be troubled by it. The Torah is always going to be filled with, you know, different ways to look at this. In one way I look at this, I actually think that, that Abraham is the one that's being quite negative here. But he pull Abraham al-Panav is, to me, it's like, it's such a frustration for him. He has had nothing but frustration with God from the very beginning, from Lech Lecha alone. If you read carefully, he goes to all these different places. And then, you know, when he's in the land, he goes to, he has to go to Egypt.

Why does he have to go to Egypt? Because the land can't sustain him. And so it's like, wait a minute, God, you told me to go to this land, you told me it would be a blessing, you told me all these wonderful things, and now I'm going to die. But ironically, he's sustained by the Egyptian handmaid. So it is ironic. It's like, I'm choosing to survive, and I'm going to go against what you want in order to survive. I'm choosing to have a child, and it's going against what you want because you wanted the child to be originally from me and Sarah, but we're not waiting for you. There's no...

There's nothing in the Bible and nothing in the Judaism that descends from the Bible. The thought that you should just, I mean, okay, there's not nothing good. The Red Sea is probably the example. We should just wait and let God do his thing. In fact, you're always supposed to be a partner. And so Abraham, God says, have a child. You get busy. And so, of course, he got busy and this was necessary. I mean, Abraham, you know, there's a major moral episode in this part, which is when they do go down to Egypt and all this in that.

Genesis 13, I guess it's still chapter 12. scene in which they go down to Egypt is prefiguring what's going to happen in the Exodus. Because they go down to Egypt, and they get held in slavery, and Sarah's in the Pharaoh's palace, and he says, you know, they will kill me and keep you alive, which is exactly what happens with the boys and the girls in the Egyptian episode in Shemot. And it's very clear, by the way, that unlike the episode with Avimelech, where the Torah explicitly says that God protected Sarah from sexual violation, in this case it says she was taken in the Pharaoh's palace, and you'll see the translations where she's taken into Pharaoh's palace, but...

don't be fooled she is taken in pharaoh's palace but then afterwards they leave they leave with great wealth and so this is all prefiguring what's going to happen then. But Abraham, you know, Nachmanides says in the great comments, you know, this is, Abraham did a terrible, terrible sin in surrendering Sarah to Pharaoh. And that's why exile is decreed on the people. And that's perhaps why in the Torah's narration, perhaps that's having to do, has something to do with the childlessness. Maybe she wasn't so quick to try again after what he did. Maybe, maybe there was a divine punishment for what he did that extended out the, extended out the barrenness period. I think that the negativity that, you know, the frustration may have a number of sources and not all of them are really to be laid at God's.

feet i think that abraham has plenty to blame himself for again going back to to you know the the complexity of the scene and the it's it's um you know so many so many vectors of their lives flowing into this, including the frustration, including the relationship with God, including the relationship with Sarah, including the relationship with Hagar. And really, I think also a relationship with himself, his own self-understanding. Think about it. He has been childless himself for, well, at least 86 years. He becomes a father at 86. So his own self-understanding is, I'm alone in the world, or I won't have any project. And it's a real struggle with him. And you see his moral pain, well, you'll see it next week when...

God basically says you have to listen to Sarah and eject Hagar and Ishmael from the household. Because here Abraham is tremendously loyal to the people that he has around him, notwithstanding the difficulty that he has with all of them. So we have just a minute left or two. Characterize Abraham and his relationship with God here, if you will. And he is the person who trusts in God. And what does God really want from him?

Is there anything you could add to a portrait of Abraham as it's emerging here by the end of the Parsha? What kind of man is this man? Well, you know, not that long ago, I had a conversion candidate have a full circumcision. And he did it with such commitment. I mean, going through the mikvah, you know, it can be awkward or foreign. Adult male circumcision. That's, you mean it. That's the real deal. You mean it.

And so the end of the parcher, I mean, this was Shai's Bar Mitzvah portion, and I remember it was really quite nice. It's, you know, Lech Lecha, God says to Abraham, go. God appears to Abraham at the Brit Bein Habitarim, goes from auditory to visual to signed in, that is sealed in his body. So I feel like the intensification of the divine, according to Shai Komarovsky on this one, the intensification of his relationship, and then it's going to be even more intense next week with the binding of Isaac. I feel like this guy has reached Like I said, I think the early part of this parasha is morally very difficult. Maybe next week will be too, but I feel like this guy has reached a very intense, intimate level of commitment. Very. What I would say is that Abraham has a certain confidence in God, which allows him to listen to God's voice, but also to challenge him when he thinks that the voice is less than clear.

And the interesting thing about Abraham, I think, is that he never abandons God. And, you know, there are times when you would think in this Parsha next week for sure, when you might say to yourself, well, it's time to leave. And he doesn't. And I think he, in this sense, he provides a model to us because you have to keep the conversation going. That's the job of Abraham, to continue the dialogue with God into the future.

So interesting. You know, it all speaks to the depth of his humanity. There's a tremendous humanity that's emerging through this, despite all of the challenging situations, the awkwardness, and really the impossibilities that he is being challenged with, including parenthood at this late stage. And of course, you know, next week's Parsha, the sacrifice of Isaac. But what you see here, and I think we're reading between the lines, is his humanity. So what you've helped me do is understand the word Vayitzchak.

as a kind of portal into his soul, a portal into his humanity. And no matter how we see that, whether it's a sardonic laughter or just a kind of ironic laughter or just even a ha, this kind of very plaintive laughter, what we have here is a human being whose the shades of his humanity are emerging for us more and more as we get to know him. Look, we've said in the past, Abraham is really one of the great... characters of the Bible, there's not much to not like about him, although there are things that, you know, are...

are puzzling. Like you said, Jeremy, at the beginning of the Parsha, there are things in his relationship with Sarah there that are quite problematic. But we'll have to leave it where we are bringing this to a conclusion, where the Parsha brings it to a conclusion. He's being promised that he's going to have a child. And spoiler alert, it happens. Okay. In the meantime, we thank you for joining us for this Parsha discussion, our Parsha talk. We so value your attention and your commitment to us. It's such an honor that we have...

So many, we have hundreds of viewers and listeners all over the world. And we really appreciate it. Thank you for joining us. Have a wonderful Shabbat, everyone. Shabbat shalom. We'll see you in the next edition of Shabbat Shalom. Bye.

Kol Deracheha Rachel Leshaw Welcome to Kol Deracheha, a podcast about women and mitzvot, from deracheha.org, a Yeshivat Har Etzion Initiative. Our name comes from the pasuk in Mishlei 3:10, which says "be-chol derachecha da'ehu." "In all your ways, know God." We've changed that to Kol Deracheha, which means "all her ways," and also "the voice of Deracheha."Our goal is that Kol Deracheha will inspire you wherever you walk on the pathways of Torah.Season 1 of Kol Deracheha is dedicated in memory of Mrs. Anita Hirsch Silverman, Yehudit Raizel bat Eliezer v'Esther, zichrona livracha. towrah yahwh shuwb nephesh Dabar Torah Channel Shemoth 9:14 zo'th pa'am shalach kol maggephah leb 'ebed 'am yada' 'ayin kemow kol 'erets Bible (Reina Valera) 09: El Primer Libro de Samuel by Reina-Valera ciesse El Primer y Segundo libros Samuel originalmente eran un volumen en la Biblia hebrea, que proporciona la biografía histórica de Israel desde la era de los jueces hasta David, el segundo rey de la nación. Las escrituras dan cuenta de los tratos de Dios con la nación, incluido el propio Samuel, el vínculo de conexión entre los jueces, y los reyes. Ramah, a unos diez kilómetros al norte de Jerusalén, era la localidad del ministerio de Samuel. Era su lugar de nacimiento, residencia judicial y lugar donde fue sepultado. La oficina norte de Samuel estaba ubicada a cinco millas al norte de Ramah en Bethel, donde 800 años antes Jacob había visto la escalera al cielo. La oficina occidental de Samuel era Mizpeh, tres millas al oeste de Ramá, donde colocó la piedra "Ebenezer". En su vertiente norte estaba Gabaón, el lugar donde estuvo Josué cuando el "sol se detuvo". Ramah se localizaba en un área central esencial para el ministerio de Samuel. La casa d An Intro to God Volume 2 - Mitswah (Instructions) Yada Yahowah Mitswah • Instructions To understand the Mitswah | Instructions, we must turn to Yahowah’s Towrah | Teaching, where Moseh revealed the value of observing them… “You should observe (wa shamar) His clearly communicated prescriptions of what we should do to be cut into the relationship (choq huw’) in addition to the instructive conditions regarding what He is offering and what He expects in return (mitswah huw’) which, to enjoy the benefits (’asher), I have provided as instructions and directions for you (’anoky tsawah ’atah) this day (ha yowm). Then, as a result of the relationship (’asher), He will be good to you and accepting of you (yatab la ’atah), and of your children (wa la beny ’atah) after you (’achar ‘atah), while also (wa la ma’an) elongating your days (’arak yowmym) on the earth (’al ha ’adamah) which (’asher) Yahowah (Yahowah), your God (’elohym ’atah), is giving to you (nathan la ’atah) for all time (kol ha yowmym).“ (Dabarym / Words / Deuteronomy 4:4

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Kol Ramah?

This episode is 33 minutes long.

When was this Kol Ramah episode published?

This episode was published on October 31, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Kol Ramah episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.