. . . . I'm talking to you from Tel Aviv, in Israel. Joining me by good friends, Rabbi Barry Chesler, Salam Shreem, the Big School of Long Island, and Rabbi Jeremy Kalman, I'm Shachet Chesed in New York City. We are recording this. It is already New Year's in Israel. There is a bit of a celebration going on in the streets of Tel Aviv. I was out a little earlier just to pick up some provisions, like an orange and a banana and things for breakfast. I think that orange is a designated fruit for the New Year. That's right. Tel Aviv is called the Big Orange. I don't know really why, although it's not hard to figure out. Tel Aviv was...
near a lot of orange groves. This might be a little shorter because we're going to get bumped for my shul's minion. We are recording this, New Year's, and wishing everyone, our loyal audience, a happy secular New Year. We're going to complete the book of Breshit, and we're unrehearsed here. We did not have a chance to talk about this since there's a big time difference between me and my colleagues here. So we're going to go jump right into it. V'ayechi, last parasha in the book of Breshit.
First thing that I want to point out, 17 years, brackets, the life of Jacob. Sorry to point out something very interesting, and that is the same thing that happens with Avraham, who leaves where Kasim is 75, and Yitzchak is 75 when he dies. So we have Avraham having 75, bracketing the beginning and end of his life, and 17 with Yaakov. Oh, Joseph is 17, he gets sold into slavery. Right, and then they're reunited for 17 years. Yeah, okay, cool. You know, the ages of the patriarchs are somewhat large, and we've talked about this in the past, that they have a certain kind of formula to them. I think we should leave that. You know, what I'm troubled by or want to start with is what Jacob says to Joseph at the very, very beginning of the Parsha. He's giving him a bit of a history. If you want to look carefully at chapter 48, I'm just going to jump in. Verse 3.
God spoke to me in Luz. He said to me, I'm going to make you large, numerous. I'm going to make you into numerous nations. I'm going to give you this land to your seed. Your two sons who were born to you in Eretz Yisraim, they will be to me like Reuven and Shimon. It goes down. Verse 7 is the real verse of puzzle for me. When I came from Paddan, Rachel died upon me. In the land of Canaan. She died on me. Yeah, exactly. As we were making our way to Efrat, and I buried her there. And, you know,
Of all the things that he could say, he is choosing this one. So I'm asking you this question really, you know, kind of out of left field, which is he doesn't talk about Joseph. He doesn't talk about, you know, Dina. He doesn't talk about his time with Levine. He doesn't talk about anything else. But he talks about the death of Rachel. And I'm struck by that. And on the other hand, maybe I shouldn't be struck by that. Maybe that's been the center of his life. Maybe that's what he wants. You weren't struck by it. We would have nothing to talk about. So I think it's good. We have plenty to talk about. There's plenty of the partnership. He's beyond this. So what do you make of this? So sorry to point out something.
You know, I have, I must say, mixed feelings about Sarna's commentary. It's entirely too psychological for me. He does great things with the numbers, though. I like that. But his comment here is that, noting that traditional commentators have by and large understood this verse to be an apology for Jacob for troubling his son with the arduous task of burying him in the cave of Machpelah, when basically he dumped his mother at the side of the road. So in other words, what sets it off is the request to take me back at great expense, time, money, to Eretz Canaan, even though I did not perhaps treat your mother with a cup of that she deserved.
You know, that is exactly Rashi's claim on this. He said it was traditional. And Rashi is. Pretty traditional. For a French guy. Yeah, for a French guy. But...
But first of all, I just want to point out the importance in biblical Israel of Ephraim as the, you know, kind of apotheosis of the northern tribes and the use of the word lehafrot throughout this. You know, God spoke to me and said, and that's Ephraim's name, and she dies in Ephrat. And I just think that the Ephraim connotation of this whole passage is a strong one. And I think that the importance of burying him in Eretz Yisrael, the importance of Joseph also wanting to be buried in Eretz Yisrael. And Rachel's tomb, all of these things are so important to Breshit. And with respect to Rachel's tomb and with respect to Joseph's tomb, the stories, I think, I'm just intuiting here, but it seems obvious to me, make sense because even in biblical times, those places were venerate. You know, Keber Rachel, as the Midrash has it, you know, that Keber Rachel was by the road so that when the Babylonians were driving the Jews into exile, they would pass by Rachel's tomb and she would pray for them.
In rabbinic times, Rachel's tomb was a place. I'm going to guess that Bible time was a well-known place, too. And so maybe there's an apology. Listen, I'm making you take me to Hebron, and I was not so nice to Rachel. But I'm inclined to read it more positively, as we have important burial sites, Machpelah, Shechem, and Ephrat, that are really important to us. Right, but what's interesting is that, if I remember correctly, Machpelah is designated an Ahuza. It's some kind of...
holding in the land. And it is, in fact, the first piece of property that belongs to Abraham. That's not said about the other burial sites. But what struck me when listening to you talk about the connection of Ephraim to the story is that, in effect, what Jacob does when he reverses the blessing is he tells Joseph that he's not the oldest son. He's actually the youngest son.
And I think that's incredibly important, because I think part of the psychology of Joseph is he wanted to be a Bahor. He was the Bahor of his mother, of course, but Nebuchadnezzar was 11 out of 12. You know, not so great. And by wanting Menasheh to be blessed first, I think Joseph is trying to establish his claim as an older son. And Jacob, you know, says, no, that's not the way we do things here. You are the younger son, and that's where your greatness is going to be. And that's why Ephraim is going to be the main son from you. But he is, this is quite correct, and it is the...
the elevation of the latter-born son. But what effectively happens here is exactly what Devarim says should not happen here, which is that the son of the more beloved wife gets what is the sign of behorship, which is to say a double inheritance. So Ephraim and Menasheh each get their own inheritance. So, you know, Ruben and Shimon... And Ephraim and Menasheh have equal inheritance. That is to say, Joseph gets the double portion. Right, but also there's a financial thing, too, because he gives Joseph a gift. It's not just a double tribe, it's a monetary doubling as well that Joseph gives. Well, I think the tribal part, because it's also a land halukah, a land distribution, is also very strongly an economic benefit. You know, this is exactly what, I mean, it's so interesting in Parshat Kitei say, the divine says, listen, you've got two wives, one beloved, one last beloved, and one hated. You cannot treat the son of the beloved wife as the bachor if he's not the physical bachor.
And that's Genesis' most favorite topic, is to do precisely that. So why is that, do you think? What strikes me is that the law tends to present itself as being very neat, but real life is very messy. And Genesis is a mess. It's kind of tohu bavohu. Maybe that's really why the story begins with tohu bavohu. And the rest of the Torah and subsequent Israelite and Jewish history on the land is an attempt to wrest order out of that primal chaos.
Well, I like the theme of order out of primal chaos. I think that's really profound. And I like the theme that the regularity of the law can't account for every detail. I also think that... Despite the fact that the Bible clearly comes from a place, a society, which treats birth order as really important and the inheritance things that attend upon that, and it's suspicious of so much hierarchy, and it likes the suburb hierarchy, and it likes the thing that you think is least likely to be good turns out to be the best thing. And so all these second-born children, morally or charismatically gifted, outwitting the...
older kind of dupacy, in Reuvene's case, not so nice, resectually, in Shimon's case, not so nice violently. You know, Joseph is the one chosen by God, and God can choose the stone which the builders despised. So you mentioned, you know, the scene that is going to happen here where the brothers are going to be around Jacob's, you know, deathbed. And, you know, as I read this now, I'm struck by the differentiation that already takes place. He has a kind of private moment with Joseph. The adoption of Ephraim and Hashem is constituted as a moment that is separate from his time with the whole family. And death, the deathbed scene, it's...
a fairly intimate moment. He still has his wits about him, Jacob. And wouldn't you think that this would be another cause of envy and enmity between the brothers and Jacob that you've got the precious last moments. You know, you have your own private moment with him. That's not fair. I don't know. So what's interesting to me is that the adoption of Ephraim and Menasha is a private moment. Yeah. So how did the brothers find out about it? And then one of the things that your comment suggested to me is that there are two ways that the end of the book could go. One could be the way that it is, which is a kind of a living will where the patriarch gathers his...
his children about him and gives them his blessing or message. And the other thing could be a reading of the will, where this is, you know, the patriarch is dead, and now we're reading his last will and testament. I just wonder what would make a better impression on the children, given the actual terms of chapter 49, to hear it in the presence of Yaakov or to hear it after his death? This is so much more dramatic, so much more poignant. You have the individual saying these things, you know, himself, and then he pulls his legs back into the bed and dies. It's just perfect theater, I think. You know, I mean, and it's one of the best. What I'm saying is, you know, that maybe a will.
Well, I don't know what's worse. I mean, he does say terrible things to Ruvane. Well, I think this is actually better, what happens, because for two reasons. First of all, if he's dead, then people say, oh, you know, he was already gone before he died. And with Jacob there, they have to take it. And if they're going to learn from it, it's easier to learn from hearing it directly from Jacob than to hear about it afterwards. You know, I had an experience like that where, you know, a person read the will of their deceased parent. It was such a poison pen letter.
It was horrible. And they came in to see me and it was filled with just wretched emotion. And I can't believe my mother said this to me. And I said, she's dead. There's not much you can do about that. And you know what? You didn't deserve it. And so I gave the only Hasidic advice I ever gave in my life, which was take a letter to her grave and burn it and then bury it in the grave. And that way you will burn the memory of this letter and it will remain buried with her.
And he did it. And did it work? And you know what? Yes and no. Obviously, something like that is not going to go away. But I think having a symbolic way of exercising that. No, it's a great suggestion. Yeah. What I was thinking, the flip side of that is when you're the one who's alive and you have not made peace with the deceased. So you go to the grave and beg for forgiveness, which is also a powerful statement. You know, is it powerful or is it just a charade? Oh, it's not just a charade. Because then you don't go.
If you can't invest meaning in it, then you simply stay home. I can't believe that you would take the trouble to go to, that a person would take the trouble to go to a kebber and not be moved by it. You have to go with a minion. You have to go with 10 people, according to the Shulchan Aram, I think. I can't understand, like, the scenario that you just described. I mean, the unresolved emotion that people have. Like, I read this book, Sam Heilman, who's the sociology professor, and he wrote a book about Hasidic dynasties in the post-war period.
And I forget who this person was, but there was some guy and he left Europe and he went to South America and then he ultimately came back to Israel and he entered the rabbinic establishment. He was like the chief rabbi of Apula or something like that. And because he Zionized, his Hasidim turned on him and they basically stole his children and raised them to replace him. And he, in the end, instructed them, you are not to say Kaddish for me, you are not to mourn for me. And just the anger, I don't remember many more details, but the anger and the rage.
from a parent towards a child. I just cannot even conceive of it. It's just blown my mind. And Jacob Avinu, Ruben, you're my firstborn child. I love you so much. You're such a jerk. I cannot believe you slept with Bilhah. And Shimon and Levi, you got some passion, guys, but you're just like, you're terrible people. What in the world is going on in these things?
So I see my minion is coming on here. Just a final line, because you are in Eretz Yisrael right now. And I feel very, very strongly as I have it conveyed to my children that I want to be buried in Israel. I really don't, you know, it doesn't bother me to think that no one will come to visit the grave or something like that. Do you have a place in mind? I do not. But I figure at some point in the next, you know, bunch of years when I can still pay for it, you know, I'd like to arrange it. So, and that sense of homeland is so pretty. This book is about, we discussed this in the past.
The Torah in general, but Genesis in particular, is very exile-focused. Abraham is always having to go away, and Jacob's having to go away, and Isaac is the one guy who doesn't go away, but that sense of lostness, exile, the desire to return, just comes through so, even though the book does end in exile, and the book ends as diaspora Jews longing for that homeland, it is just such a strong thing in this book that I have to be part of this land, and it's been true in Jewish history. You know, the Gemara in Ketubot has an extended zugia about burial in the land of Israel, including the statement that y'all should have come when you were alive, not horizontally, y'all should have come vertically. So a little bit of a dig. But I feel that this is an emotional center to the conclusion of Genesis. It is. And, you know, we have different views on burial. And I haven't really...
you know, considered what you are considering as a practical plan in my own life, notwithstanding the fact that, you know, I'm deeply connected here. I feel much more pragmatic about these things altogether. And, you know, what I want to take out of what you're saying is there's a need for a kind of return, a primal return or a mythical return. is a very strong theme. Well, what I would add, it's not just that what sometimes we overlook when we think about the return is it's also making a statement about our beginning. And, you know, when we go back to Adam, who's told that you came from dust and you will return to dust, you know, the riff here is that because you're going to be buried in Israel, there's a sense that you think that's where you came from originally as well. And I think that's quite powerful. Yeah. You know, it...
I always like to point out that Rishi doesn't end on a high note. It's on a sad note. It ends with embalmment. With embalmment. It ends with Joseph in a box. You know, Joseph being the first slave. Hang on. And we're going to see that. We're going to end it there.
We're going to say Shabbat Shalom to everyone. And we wish a wonderful evening to the, to the good people of, uh, Okay. Shabbat Shalom. Shabbat Shalom. This is Barsha Talk Live with everybody. Have a great show. Have a great show for the rest of your time in Israel. Go see your children and love your grandchildren. Thank you so much. Take care. All right. Be well. Bye-bye. Bye-bye.