Thank you. Shalom and welcome to another edition of Parcher Talk. Rabbi Elliot Malvin here. Hi, I'm Parcher. I'm Parcher. I'm Parcher. I'm Parcher. I'm Parcher. I'm Parcher. I'm Parcher. I'm Parcher. I'm Parcher.
Eversley from Maryland and wedding is taking place in Tel Aviv. And this is going to be spectacular. We're celebrating a simcha, you know, in the midst of such complicated emotional elasticity in our people with hostages coming out. And of course, we're remembering those who are still not out at this point. And by the time that this goes on YouTube, we hope that more hostages will have returned to their families. And we pray as we do fervently for them all to return as soon as possible. We're talking about Parshat Yitro. Yitro, the...
Yitro has the revelation at Mount Sinai, Ten Commandments. But before we get to all of that, there's this individual, Yitro. So I'm going to turn to you, Barry. What do you make of this individual, Yitro? And let's talk about him. Who is he? Well, obviously, he's a good guy. He provides a safe haven for Moses when he's fleeing Egypt. Has him marry into the family.
The part of him that strikes me the most is the account in the beginning of our Parsha this week, Yitro, where Yitro proposes the justice system for the Israelite people to relieve the burden from Moses. When we get the account into Barim, Moses is going to take credit for it. And I think that what we see here is that Jethro is indispensable. The Israelites need him in order to succeed. And it's not a view that has traveled well in Jewish history.
Would you consider him an archetype of the ally, the outsider, the person watching out for us? I think he's basically a good guy. And I'd like to say the world is filled with good guys, but that would be an overstatement. But there are any number of good people within any number of different traditions, faith-based or otherwise. And they have much to teach us, and we have things that we can teach them.
with the exception of Chayes Sarah are rarely named after people. I mean, I suppose you could stretch it a little bit. This is the blessing of Moses. But we've got three partial yod named after Gentiles. Noah, Balak and Yitro. Noah is pretty much an admirable character. I mean, we have a way of reading and want to know why is it that Noah didn't fight back for the rest of the world? Why did he just save his own family? It's a good question, spare question. But Noah is seen as being an excellent human being. Yitro is seen as being an excellent human being. Balak is seen as being a bad human being, but under a lot of pressure. We can cut him a break about that. He did feel that his people were about to be overrun, so he does what he can do to curse the Israelites.
But what I think is really interesting about this is because of our history of being a small, often beleaguered people, The vast majority of Jewish history has grown up as a small resident people in a great big religious empire, and in both cases of Islam and Christianity, an empire that thinks, why are you still hanging on to this rejected faith? We are the majority. We've got lots more people. We've got lots of good monotheism over here. Why are you so stubbornly insisting on your own difference? And so, unsurprisingly, because we do love our own uniqueness, we do love our own history and our texts and our teachings, we do dig in and we do say, thank you, we're not choosing to join your club. But the consequence of that may be...
a view of, you know, a kind of latent hostility and condescension to like, there can't possibly be anything good in those religions, right? So I think that Yitro comes to remind us that one of the greatnesses of Moshe is he didn't think that all the answers were already located within our group. And he could hear some good ideas from this outsider figure, outsider vis-a-vis the Jewish people and his traditions, not a follower, not one of the descendants of Abraham Yitzhak B'yakov. And so let's build on this. I, you know, there's a line in Vayqorav, which I think is awesome, which I do try to live by. It says,
If they say to you that there is Torah among the nations, don't believe them. If they say to you that there is wisdom among the nations, believe them. I think it's actually the opposite order. And so that's what I try to live by. I think that to think that there's a lot of wisdom in other nations, that's a good path. And the Torah, our own religious uniqueness, that has to be local for us.
So it's clear that Yitro has wisdom, because he provides Moshe with a lot of wisdom in terms of how to manage the people. But what makes Yitro different is that he experiences solidarity with Israel, and he shares in the joy of their redemption. I'm referring to the verse that is verse 9, it's chapter 18, verse 9, where it says, It's a very strange... form of rejoicing. And it has, for those of us who have a kind of ear to the Hebrew, yachad in there, there's a bit of that, and it's...
It means, you know, he rejoices, but we also hear he has a sense of solidarity. He's with us. For all the good that God did for Israel. So he shares that, he shares their comment, like, way to go, like, this is a great thing for you. And as you were speaking, I was thinking, you know, there are other archetypes of people who, let's say, have sons-in-law who married their daughters, right? And they're not particularly nice to their sons-in-law. I'm thinking of Laban, for example. Laban is not, so.
You know, we use the word Gentile when it comes to Yitro. And Levan, I mean, I don't know if the word applies because it's anachronistic in a certain way. Yitro is from family stock. And you could argue, I'm sorry, Levan is family stock. Yitro, as a Midianite, you know, there's some distant relationship there as well. But they're not the stock of Israel, that's for sure. Levan is not a nice guy to Jacob, our ancestor. Yitro, nice guy to Moses. Well, it's interesting, Elliot, because I think Levan is most often referred to as the Aramean.
Yes. So even though he's family stock, we left that family behind. But also in the Aramean, there's the hint of Mirma. Of being conniver, a cheat. Yeah. So he never quite gets away from that either. But I was thinking that maybe, you know, he didn't have anything against his son's-in-law. He just didn't like his nephew. Right. Okay. So I want to ask you this question. You know, we have a brief discussion on this, which is, you know, how do we get more utros in the world? And is it...
I mean, can we do something for that? Should we do something for that? Or are we relying on the world to produce Yitros? And maybe it's too much of an open question, or a vague question, but, you know, I think we both enjoy, we all enjoy, you know, relationships with non-Jewish people, non-Jewish clergy, non-Jewish, you know, people in our communities, and some of whom have been quite righteous for us, stand with us. And they don't have a need to...
join the Jewish people in any other way. You know, there's a debate among the rabbis as to whether or not Yitro actually, you know, joins and becomes a member of the people of Israel. Does Yitro convert to Judaism? Or is Yitro happy being Yitro? And I would say that, you know, in this scene here, Yitro rejoices. He shares wisdom with Moshe. He celebrates with Moshe. There's a big feast, lots of, you know, there's a big mangal, you know, barbecue with Yitro. And then he goes his own way. And he's leaving his daughter with Moses.
And his grandchildren. And his grandchildren. So he sees his responsibility with his people. He's okay with that. He's okay. I just glanced over here at Numbers chapter 10, which is the scene that you mentioned, that at one point Moses says to... Yitro famously is... There seem to be at least four names. Yeter, Yitro, Chobab, and Re'uel. And they all are described as being Moses' father-in-law. Here in chapter 10, in Numbers, we have Le'chobab ben Re'uel.
and then Reuel is supposed to be his father. So whatever. But it's the same basic character, the Midianite father-in-law of Moses. And Moses says to him, listen, we're going to this destiny place that Hashem has told us that we're going to go there. Come with us and be part of this. And it'll be great for you. We'll do well with you. I'm not going. I have my own family in my own land. And I want to be part of that. I mean, I think that that is quite touching. Moses implores him and says, don't abandon us. Moses really wants him. I mean, it's like...
very trusted advisor, very, very helpful. Because you know all of the places where we successfully camped. And you have been our scout, guide, wide open eyes kind of person. And if you will walk with us, if you will go with us, and Hashem will do what God has promised and will benefit you too. And then it doesn't say his further response. But I think that we, I'm inclined to think.
that he said, listen, I have my own journey to make, which I like this. Again, it fits in with what I think a healthy relationship with other religious or with other ethnic communities. You have to be supportive, collegial, allies, and recognize that people have their own paths. You know, you said, how do we see that there are more Yitros? I mean, I think...
I think that one thing is like to be the Yitros for other people, right? To actually, to actively wish them well and try to help them succeed and be the best versions of themselves and not feel a constant, you know, constant sense that really, I got to tell you something, there's one right religion in the world and it's Judaism and all y'all are just barking up the wrong idolatrous trees. You're barking up the wrong Asherot. And no, listen, I think we should hope that Christianity flourishes. We should hope that Islam flourishes. We should hope that other religions and other ethnic groups flourish and it'll come back our way too.
Right, because they tell a story that's part of human civilization. And, you know, both of those religions, you know, obviously have billions and billions of adherents. Which is something. I mean, good for them, right? Good for them, yes. You know, we hope they don't hate us. But, you know, it's chauvinistic of us to say that we have the monopoly on righteousness. And here, the Bible presents us with a number of people who have righteousness. So I think what might distinguish, in one way, Yitro from Laban is that Yitro is not transactional.
He does not seem to be motivated by any self-interest. He's able to lend a helping hand because he listens and he advises. That's who he is. He's not looking for anything. He's not looking for a reward. Levine, on the other hand, is all about the transaction. He is, to use one of the great phrases from the Godfather, a businessman. And I think, to answer your earlier question, we have to be open to the intros of the world. We can't close ourselves off from the get-go from people who might have something to say to us, to teach us.
Do they come with a posture towards us or is it an authenticity of just being God-fearing? I'm thinking of, you know, you go to Israel and you go to the Yad Vashem and there's the Avenue of the Righteous Gentiles and, you know, each story is amazing. These are people that either sacrificed their lives or knew that what they were doing by saving Jews was going to put them in peril, and many of them paid with their lives for it. And when you ask them or their families why they did it, they say, we just did it because we knew that this was the right thing to do. So there's an authenticity that comes out of their humanity. Nobody is saying that this is not available to you. I'm thinking of that in connection with something that's said at the beginning of the Torah to Abraham, which we...
Turn to all the time, which I'll bless those who bless you and curse those who curse you. It's a refrain that is found at several points in the Torah, and it's key. If you understand, if you see something that's blessing, if you see blessing within the people of the stock of Abraham, that itself is worthy of blessing. But if you only come to them with envy or animosity, that puts your ugliness. That is a cursed thing. And it is remarkable. I'm always amazed by this. It was remarkable, especially in our experience in the last year and a half.
When people have reached out to us, that people have said, no, we support you. We understand what you're going through. And, you know, we're not you. We don't need to become Jewish. We don't need to join. You know, it's like that poster. You don't need to be Jewish to appreciate. Leavey's right bread. Exactly. But it helps. No, it's, you don't need to be, it's, we're happy. And I'm saying Yitro's happy being who he is. I get that sense from him. He's like, if we use the Hebrew term for he's happy with his lot. I'm okay. This is what God chose me to be. I'm okay being in this role. I'm okay having this.
place, this zone, this territory. You have your life. I have mine. I appreciate you. I honor you. And in that way, you become honored. Well, he anticipated Dylan. You go your way and I'll go mine. And there's something to be said for that. All right. So let's turn the page. We've got to talk about the Ten Commandments. And I've often thought, and I don't know if we put this on a previous edition, but I want to return to it. You know, the Ten Commandments, it's a long text. The heart of the Ten Commandments is not...
commandment five to commandment six. You know, if you read the commandments with symmetry, you want one to five and six to 10. And that's great. That's a great, it's a great frame. But if you put it all in a text and you put it, you know, did the word count, halfway mark would come in commandment four.
And that's Shabbat. And, you know, the irony of, and I'm going to quote you, Barry, the irony of many advocates of posting the Ten Commandments in public is they want so much for us to see the Ten Commandments, and yet Commandment 4, maybe other commandments too, let's face it, doesn't apply. And we need Commandment 4. And Commandment 4, which is Shabbat, look, Shabbat is sustained as Jewish people. We need all 10. We need all 10, okay? But there's something unique about Shabbat. Shabbat is the longest of the commandments. That's also important. And I'm thinking, you know, in our media, social media, technological era, nothing has been more important than Shabbat. So I would offer a slightly different take. Martin Buber paired four and five.
Those are the two positive commandments. There are actually five negative commandments before war, even though traditionally we divide them into three. And there are five negative commandments if we make allowances for the 10th commandment, being one commandment, even though there are two negative commands in it. So then we have five commandments leading up to Shabbat. And then the commandment about honoring our parents, which Buber emphasizes, is really about the land, about sacred space, because it comes with the promise of long life on the land if it's observed. And then the five so-called secular commandments. So if we observe the first five commandments, we can...
appreciate and sustain a sense of sacred time. And if we have a concept of sacred space, that will organize the way that we live socially. If I understand this correctly, if I'm missing it, I'm sure many of our viewers and listeners are also. So we typically understand it as five and five, but you're saying, Buber, the last five are, quote unquote, the more secular of the commandments. Right, from do not murder to do not covet. Okay, right. Four and five, which is Shabbat and...
and honoring your parents with the promise of long life in the land. There are actually five negative statements or commandments before that, but they only appear, we number them as three instead of five. We combine low, top name, and low, whatever. And so, and Buber being the person that he was also removed some of the fourth commandment. There's some interpolations in it. Anyway, the point, because he believes.
as I remember it, something more terse, which I think also makes sense. And the idea then is that this is what makes it such a foundational document, because its center is sacred space and sacred time. And that is the task of the Holy Community, which is what the people are called in Chapter 19, right before the Ten Commandments. I get the comment that you're making about space, because it does, it'll lengthen your days on the land. But I would say that it seems to be something of an exaggeration to say it is about the social space, even though it does hold out that as a reward and a consequence. I think, you know, it's often said that you've got your first four, which are theologically oriented. Although, well, we count them as I am the Lord your God as the first, a positive assertion of God's existence. That's how Maimonides reads it. The second one, no other gods before me and no idols and no worshiping. As Barry said, that could be split off. Christians tend to read I am the Lord your God not as a commandment, but as like a preamble. And you have to say that that's kind of true. I am is not really a...
a commandment, even though Rambam takes it to be, and then there's no name in vain, then there's Shabbos, all of which are clearly theologically oriented, although in Deuteronomy, Shabbat is not about God's creation of the world, it's God's liberation of the slaves, and so you have to give rest to the people who work for you, that makes it more social. Then we get the one that is the nexus point, because honoring your human parents, as the Talmud says, there are three partners in every human creation, two human parents and the divine who is involved. Honoring your parents is, in some respects, goes both ways to your human relationships. But your human relationships, that you have gratitude for them, that you feel the benefit, you be the beneficiary of a gift you did not earn to be created, to revere your parents, is, in a sense, to revere the whole chain of your existence back to God. And one of the things I like about the next bunch that are clearly, Ben Adam Lechavero, they're clearly in the human community.
As an appreciator of good writing, I love the punch. After all the somewhat wordy part of the beginning, these are so unambiguous. These are so direct and forceful. It's like, honor God, don't worship idols, have Shabbat, be grateful for your life, and don't kill anybody, and don't violate your marriage, and don't steal or kidnap. I think that's just great punchy. Right, so I'll agree. And my argument here for Shabbat at the center is that that's the most accessible to people.
Arguably, yes, living in your home and having a relationship with your parents is also accessible. But I read in the Fourth Commandment an inclusion of a family unit. There's a whole circle around you. There's a presupposition that you are with people, you are with your relationships within a certain zone, a zone of time. The reason why I say it's more accessible is because most people don't commit murder, despite the fact that some people would like to. But most people don't commit murder. They don't steal. They don't commit adultery. They don't bear false witness. These are things that stand in opposition to human behaviors. They're there as signposts for people.
It's interesting that you say this, because since we started off talking about our relationship to the Yitros of the world and their relationship to us, I mean, what I'm about to say is a straight-up Jewish text, or it was originally created as a straight-up Jewish text that just joined a Bible in that other religion, Matthew chapter 5, which is the Sermon on the Mount, which in its original context is a Jewish text speaking to Jews. in the Christian scriptures, Jesus says, you know, speaking of the recently deceased Jimmy Carter, who will always go down in a little bit of infamy for having quoted this pasuk, which you would have thought Christians would have all known. Jesus says, you've heard it said, do not murder. I say that if you hate someone in your heart, you are committing murder. And you've heard it said, do not commit adultery. And if you've lusted in your heart, I say you have committed adultery. It's an almost Haredi, because it is true what you said, Elliot, murder is rare. And adultery, we assume, is pretty rare. And actual thieving and kidnapping is probably pretty rare. And Jesus, in that passage,
wants to say, actually, everybody does all these things a little bit. So don't just don't do the big things, but also don't do the small steps on your way. And maybe we can listen to a Yitrolic figure about not only not killing, but not being violent, not being hateful, and all the other steps along the way. We have to... just dial back before that and just, you know, it requires so much to examine this. But let's end this with just the way that the commandments are introduced.
a kingdom of priests and a holy nation. That's what you should say to the people. I just want to say, you know, this is the covenantal statement. One of my Bar Mitzvah kids said, that the wings, we translate it as the wings of eagles, but it's a vulture. They're vultures. Much less poetic. Much less poetic, but the vulture cares for its young in a different way than the eagles do. And eagles were not endemic to the ancient Near East. Not having said that, we are saying...
You know, as are possibilities of taglines for the Jewish people. Discuss. Well, we'll find out on Sunday how the wings of eagles fare. We're recording this the week before you, Charles. By the time anyone hears it, they will know what happened in the Super Bowl. Oh my God, yes, of course. I don't know if you have seen any of this hysterical show called What We Do in the Shadows. It's basically the office with vampires and the vampires, they were sent to North America, to Ganga, North America. They set up a small place on Staten Island.
And they get invited to a party for the greatest football game, and they think they were invited to a superb owl party. All right. Well, that's our attempt to be a holy nation and a kingdom of priests. We're trying to add sanctity into the world and Torah into the world. And we're glad you joined us for a little half hour of discussion and joy and simcha that I'm drawing from the two of you as I embark on a trip to Israel. Gigantic mazel tov. Gigantic mazel tov. A huge mazel tov to Nama and Jacob, to the other Yaakov and his wife and baby. Baby Amalia.
And you got a Chevy there. You got my aunt also. My mom, who's a big fan of partial talk, Diana Malamud. Big shout out to my mom. We'll see you next week on the next edition of partial talk. Thanks for watching.