Peggy Carr

An episode of the Forensic Tales podcast, hosted by Rockefeller Audio, titled "Peggy Carr" was published on November 17, 2025 and runs 39 minutes.

November 17, 2025 ·39m · Forensic Tales

0:00 / 0:00

Summary

When 41-year-old Peggy Carr suddenly fell gravely ill, doctors were stumped. Her symptoms made no sense—burning limbs, hair loss, and paralysis with no clear cause. But when her teenage son and stepson became sick too, investigators uncovered a chilling truth: the Carr family had been poisoned. The substance was thallium—a deadly, nearly undetectable metal once used in rat poison. The discovery launched a full-scale forensic investigation that led detectives to a single suspect: a brilliant but disturbed neighbor with a background in chemistry and a fascination with murder. This is the story of how science, persistence, and an undercover operation exposed one of Florida’s most shocking poison cases. For a complete list of sources used in this episode, visit ForensicTales.com. Support the show and get early, ad-free access to episodes by joining us on Patreon. Forensic Tales is a Rockefeller Audio production. Hosted and produced by Courtney Fretwell. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Episode Description

When 41-year-old Peggy Carr suddenly fell gravely ill, doctors were stumped. Her symptoms made no sense—burning limbs, hair loss, and paralysis with no clear cause. But when her teenage son and stepson became sick too, investigators uncovered a chilling truth: the Carr family had been poisoned. The substance was thallium—a deadly, nearly undetectable metal once used in rat poison. The discovery launched a full-scale forensic investigation that led detectives to a single suspect: a brilliant but disturbed neighbor with a background in chemistry and a fascination with murder. This is the story of how science, persistence, and an undercover operation exposed one of Florida’s most shocking poison cases. For a complete list of sources used in this episode, visit ForensicTales.com. Support the show and get early, ad-free access to episodes by joining us on Patreon. Forensic Tales is a Rockefeller Audio production. Hosted and produced by Courtney Fretwell. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Share this episode

Similar Episodes

Case #33: Phoebe

Dec 23, 2025 ·41m

Case #32: Michelle

Dec 16, 2025 ·38m

Case #31: Kristen

Dec 9, 2025 ·43m

Case #30: Rose & Casey

Dec 2, 2025 ·40m

Case #29: Cienna

Nov 25, 2025 ·41m

Nov 18, 2025 ·47m

Similar Podcasts

Get Out Alive Ashley Bray Hosted by forensic wildlife biologist Ashley Bray, Get Out Alive aims to have honest conversations about intense human-wildlife conflicts, especially those resulting in attacks. She is often joined by friends, experts, authors, and even attack survivors themselves. Join her every other week as she tells stories of animal attacks, why they happen, and how we can all avoid them. Explicit Murderie Podcast Alyssa & Taylor Two Friends that went to school for Criminal Justice and Forensic Science talking about Murder and other True Crime Cases. Explicit This & That Lindsay Gross I am a registered nurse in the emergency department and trauma. I am currently undergoing my certification in forensic nursing. I am in school to obtain my BSN. I plan on becoming an NP and getting an additional master's in Public Health. I originally thought about creating a podcast for school projects. Then someone suggested I include medical content. So here I am...We will have guests!I will probably talk about things that interest me other than science topics on occasion. I will probably also talk about current events at times as well. https://linktr.ee/ThisandThatPodcast Explicit Murder in Illinois iHeartPodcasts In 2007, Chris Vaughn was arrested during a funeral for his wife and three children. He would be tried and convicted of their murders. To this day he maintains no memory of what occurred that tragic day 20 years ago. Murder in Illinois follows the complicated circumstances that led to Vaughn’s conviction, as well as the forensic evidence his supporters believe proves his innocence- in attempt to answer one question: Who killed the Vaughn family? Explicit

URL copied to clipboard!