Hello and welcome. You're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalists are coming to you from Tursiara in Sydney on the Gallegal lands of the Orrin nation right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the go via podcast. My name is Peter Frey and I'm the co-director of the Centre for Media Transition at UTS and my producer today is Anthony Dockrell. Coming up, it's been a monumental week in the media, firstly with the lifting of the suppression order on Tuesday morning allowing the media to tell the country that something the journalists have known since December, that being the cardinal pal was ventility on the child sex charges.
And of course you may have known it yourself because if you had read overseas websites like The Wash Post and The Daily Beast and probably even your own Twitter stream back then, you would have got the news. So tonight we're going to discuss the media's coverage of pal's conviction, the suppression order and the threats by the court to take action over local news outlets who referred to the conviction in December without actually naming pal. So from a four letter word to a three letter one, Ita. News this week that the ABC's board will have a new chair and her name will be Ida Butros and that wasn't a name on anyone else's radar and it certainly wasn't a name that was put forward by the selection process.
So is Ita wise choice or is the government still messing with the ABC and its processes? It's a kind of tricky time to be a journalist at the moment but it seems to be a brilliant time to be a defamation lawyer and for the couple of guests we have who used to be lawyers it's not too late. Anyway it's a tricky time to be a journalist at the moment but yes as I say it's a good time to be a defamation lawyer. Tonight we ask is defamation law impacting too much on the media's role to hold the powerful two account?
All that plus the breaking news story about an unnamed journalist at the H.U. has successfully claimed in court that covering crime and court reporting gave her PTSD. To help us make sense of all this we have a glorious panel, a glorious panel. We have Margot Saville who is a journalist with extensive career in the likes of the Australian and John 9, the time of the ABC, the City of Wurghand and she currently freelances and you can read her work at Craggy.
Hello Margot. Hello Peter. We have Deidre Mackin, a journalist, a witty columnist, very rare breed, the witty columnist for the Australian at the weekend and she's been a senior writer for the City of Wurghand, the AFR, the EH. Anything else?
Hello Deidre. Hello Peter. Matt Peacock who's a journalist with a long and distinguished career at the ABC. He's also been the staff elected director of the ABC board.
Hello Peter. Hello Peter. And then Davies. What can I say about you and Davies?
Walk through a winner, investigative journalist, Wash Pose, Washington correspondent for the Fairfax and then where's the Guardian? And where's the lawyer? Yes. Indeed.
So we have two lawyers who have yourself and Margot, you were a lawyer for a little while weren't you? Only one year. Yeah. One year.
One glorious year. So you don't regret being a journalist? No. Sure.
Okay. This week we were allowed to tell everybody that the world's third most senior Catholic and the most senior Catholic character in Australia was Van Guillsey of Charles Sext's charges back in December. Now if you're anywhere near a courtroom or on social media, you will know that there's been an outpouring of anger and emotion that had been held in check with the suppression order. That order was doing necessary because Pell was facing a second trial on similar abuse charges.
Those charges would drop yesterday and hence the suppression order was lifted. So tonight we look at the media coverage of the guilty verdict and ask was the suppression order necessarily in the modern age. And before we turn to how journalists have been stopped from reporting on this story, let's turn to yesterday. By the nature of the suppression order, everyone in the media that needed to know that Pell had been found guilty, had time to prepare.
This also means that when we look at how the media covered the news on Tuesday, this wasn't a normal breaking news story. So just generally initially, what was your take on the coverage? Did we start with you? There's a lot of it.
The coverage since it's been lifted. Yeah, the last three days. Yeah, my impression by this morning was it was overkill. But then the more I thought about it, the more I thought, well, this has such long ramifications and not just for child abuse survivors and not just for Pell.
It's got ramifications for anyone who goes to church every Sunday, anyone who's ever been to church on Sunday, anyone who works in Catholic organisations. What are they all thinking? I think they've had their trust and indeed probably their faith undermined by this whole process. So the more and it's happened at the time when the Vatican is has just looked at it and the time is incredible.
Yeah, that's right. So it couldn't have come at a more timely moment. And the fact that it was such an unlikely case to get up according to all the lawyers and yet it's undone the third most senior man in the church. It's got sort of it's a remarkable story.
It really is. So I don't think it's been overdone now. Okay, let's turn to some of the more specific pieces. And that's one of the one on Twitter that was getting a lot of coverage was David Mars piece in the Guardian, which was a withering takedown.
I'm David, I would probably appreciate it. It's been waiting a long time to write that. And in particular, the final paragraph, which I will quote, the world can now know that a little over 20 years ago in Pell's first month as a Archbishop of Melbourne, this scourge of sex was forcing choir boys to suck his penis. Was that one of his finest works or a little bit too much?
Well, this is an interesting question and one that's being debated internally at the Guardian. Personally, I thought it was a fitting end to what was a very hard column and a forensic column that looked at all the things that Pell had said about sexual behaviour and sexual norms in this country. And he has been, as people have pointed out, a warrior for a right wing view from the church. So, you know, I think it was a tough piece, but it was fair, in my view.
What do you think? I thought it was entirely appropriate. I think that if you read so much legal coverage, you know, there's so much obfuscation and euphemism around what happens in these types of cases and the legales can kind of overtake normal patterns of speech. And I think it's good for people to know exactly what the crime was, especially in cases of child sexual abuse.
Most of us are inclined to turn our eyes away from it and try not to think about what actually happens. And David brought it home. I thought it was really good. And in fact, you yourself had a little twig of moments by painting a picture for us of someone kissing Colonel Pell's ring in the backstage of the ABC.
I got a lot of twidda fiends, so who part on as well? Never drink and tweet after dinner. But that's a lesson. That's a lesson.
Yeah, that's right. And I think that seeing those men like that who profess to be chased and profess to hate homosexuality and who fight against it with every fiber of their being to see them as these sexual predators, I don't know what they do. I think that's really vitally important. Not all sections of the media reacted like David Meyer.
I mean, some sections were completely the opposite in a way. Some of Pell's thorn just defenders continued to stick with him, Andrew Bould, Miranda Devine, being the most prominent, but not just those two. It was quite a lot of commentary and Skye on that line, the telegraph, the Herald Sun. And even the New York Post, a long way away in New York, I had a piece of yesterday saying that it's basically in defense of Pell.
I'm not sure about this because there was a lot of different types of commentary. But do you think, David, we should read anything in that? I saw this pushback coming a bit from News Limited. I think it would be wrong of anyone to say that the jury or the court process got it wrong.
That's the part that shouldn't be up for debate amongst us or anyone else. What can be debated is the reaction to it, is the lead up to it, is the ramifications. But I don't think anyone in their right mind can say, well, they got it wrong because they went in court. They didn't see the evidence.
No, I saw all the evidence. I don't want to say they got it wrong. Well, I just don't think that's a debating point. It's not a debating point.
And maybe, you know, I know, what do you think? Well, you know, this is our system. We hand the decision-making to 12 people. And that's how we come up with whether someone's guilty or innocent.
And then people can appeal. So the only people who can challenge the process, whether the jury was directed, etc, is going to be the court of appeal and no doubt they will be an appeal. So people make mistakes. But this is our best effort at having a system where we get people to judge who's guilty and innocent.
And what's the other alternative? We could have had a judge. Oh, well, we'll get to judges in a second. Yes indeed.
Just as a passing question, really, on the way out of this one. But is it, I get the impression sometimes that news limited is a very Catholic kind of, I mean, I don't know, I don't want to be too sectarian about this. What Richard Ecklund does call it the Catholic Boys Weekly. Yeah, but is that justified?
I mean, that's just another way of criticizing, if you like, the right of the media rather than the left, isn't it? Or not? Is there a sectarian divide in Australian media, do you think? Well, I'm a sort of strong believer in free speech.
And I feel as a principle, we have to allow the free speech to people we disagree with. And I disagree with everything that they wrote about PIL and everything that they write about most things, actually. But you know, they've got the right to make their point. And if we go around closing down, media organizations we don't agree with, then we're left with, I don't know, the Philippines.
Yeah, or Hungary or? Yes. Okay, let's turn to the legal issues that come out of this, the suppression order. So the Australian Law Council's called for review into house suppression orders in this country.
What do you think, most of you, does the panel think that the suppression order worked and should have been used here? Because it kind of didn't really work, did it? Well, I sort of look at it in two parts. One, there's the principle of the suppression order, which I think is correct.
And I think if any one of us was charged with a crime, you would want to know that principles of open justice applied to you and that you were able to be judged by a jury who hadn't been prejudiced by earlier hearings against you. So I think, you know, if we want it to apply to us, we have to allow that it applies to PIL and anybody else. So that's the principle. And I think that should be upheld.
But in practice, I think it's absolutely impossible and ludicrous for the judge to go around threatening to charge people. When, you know, with a click on Twitter, anybody could have read that in December. So in the internet age, this concept of suppression or this kind of knowledge could be contained has been proved to be a rather fanciful notion around the jury. Yeah.
And also, as one of the commentators pointed out, if you suppress the established or old media in Australia and let it go viral on the digital media, then perhaps you're not getting the sort of coverage that you'd want. It'll be, what is fake news or, you know? We don't utter those words in the studio. But it'll be reported with perhaps less rigor than it would have if you'd allowed Australian journalists to be in the media.
So I guess the question then is two things. One is the alternative because, I mean, we're all right on the same, you know, PIL or anyone could be asked about the right to a fair trial, not to purchase the potentially purchased the jury against us. So there is a need for some form of control. But at the same time, this isn't working.
So is there an alternative in secondly, and these letters have gone out from the court to the Herald Sun and other places? And the Guardian reported it very well yesterday. I mean, is that where we're getting to with that? I mean, for a start, what are they going to do?
I mean, so the Herald Sun ran a headline saying censor, there's a prominent Australian who's been famous guilty, there's a lot of prominent Australians over there. What do you think about all that? What is the alternative to this? Is there an alternative or?
Okay, so the underlying principle is, you know, convictions, prior convictions are really prejudicial when you're facing trial. And that's what this would have amounted to if we'd published that you've been convicted. So there is a really big principle at stake. But what are the alternatives?
One is you hear all the trials together and you do it all at once. Now the courts didn't do that. And that's another principle that applies to people who can choose to have, defendants can choose to have their trial split. So that was one way around it.
What else could they have done? They could, in New South Wales, they could have had a judge alone trial for the second trial on the basis that judges will be able to separate in their minds the earlier trial from the current trial unlike jurors. But it's going to be a problem over and over with the internet. I mean, it's just people are going to know what happened.
So I think before the courts start throwing the book at the media, maybe they need to think about what are the alternative structures that the court can come up with. Now, having said that, judge alone trial, I kept thinking of a very British scandal where the judge at the end gave, there was a jury in that case, but he gave such biased directions that the politician was acquitted. And I thought, well, maybe that would undermine the confidence in the system if you had a judge judging an archbishop. So, you know, that's just the counter-perfect.
What you're saying is nothing's perfect. Nothing's perfect. But I think we're going to have to look at how the courts handle this because it's a problem that won't go away. You know, there will be leaks all the time around the global media network.
And it does seem to be a legal problem. It's not a media problem. And the fact that they've launched all those proceedings against the media is a bit tougher, I think, because it's a legal, it's a media problem now. Well, they've made it a media problem.
But I think that's a real stretch what they've done there, including some journalists who didn't have any part in it. It seems like a scattergun approach. And it's going to consume yet more money from the, you know, the beleaguered media companies to defend. Well, yes, we'll get to defamation.
I mean, the judge was clearly livid at the media for what happened back in December. And this is a very, you know, there seems to be a payback time. Yeah, it does seem to be payback. You have the question, is it going to work?
Is it going to be effective? Is it going to change the way people cover trials not in the least? So, what do you think of Anza? You know, maybe you have the jury trial on trial one and then you have a, have a judge only on trial two.
There might be an option. Well, that's kind of been part of the Jeffrey Rush case. Hasn't it? In fact, that it's a judge standing alone.
And he's already said that he's not going to include extra evidence that was offered up by the defence because he didn't feel so, you know, that's always going to be an issue with the judge alone as well. Yep. I don't know. I guess the courts are so bogged down at the moment.
Anything that streams lines a case and saves the public money would potentially be a good idea. Okay. But if the principle is you don't want the jury to know once before the court. You don't have a jury.
Then you don't have a jury or you hear it all at once with one jury and you deal with it that way. And maybe the courts have to adapt a little bit. Yeah, that's true. They're living in the internet age too, right?
Yeah. All right. We're going to get to a definition in a second. Let's talk about the ABC.
Let's talk about the new chairperson of the board. Ida Bhattros, you were surprised? I think probably I was surprised everybody else. One thing I wasn't entirely surprised about is the fact that the nomination panel that's supposed to choose the candidates for chair was completely ignored as more or less.
It has been historically since its inception really. But why is that? I mean, how does the system work? Okay.
This is crazy, right? So you have this panel that puts forward foreblocks. It doesn't even think about Ida Bhattros who pops out of nowhere and gets the prize. That's right.
And the last time, of course, they would probably wouldn't have thought about Justin Milne unless the minister rang him up and said, Hey, why don't you apply? So it's all a bit of a joke. And of course, then there's this question of consultation with the prime with the leader of the opposition, the ABC being an important publicly owned institution. We all own it.
We all have a stake in it. And it should be removed from party political pressures, I think, over things like the appointment of chair. And yet this consultation is what is it? A quick text?
Is it a fun call? So your point is a lot of these processes are a bit of a joke. So what? In comes Ida?
Well, we'll talk about the process a little bit longer. What needs to happen? Well, I think I'd be interested to hear what others say about this. But certainly I think that we need to have a process of selection of the chair and also members of the board that has various criteria attached to it, one of which, of course, importantly is the knowledge of public media, public broadcasting, for want of a better word, and also a proven track record of being able to stand up to political pressure and some dedication to the concept of independence and free and fearless media.
So all of those criteria are, I think, a part and parcel of- And they're not explicit in the process now? No, they're not even mentioned, really. And it needs to be a collaborative process. I mean, why shouldn't the Australian public have more of a say in this process?
Or certainly it'd be more transparent and up for grabs more? I should have a president. Well, you know, there needs to be much more engagement of the process. It needs to be removed from- I mean, it's easy to say it needs to be removed from party politics, but look at party politics now, and you know, you would want it to be removed from party politics.
And so would most normal people. Okay, all right, interesting. Well, let's open it up. Well, what do you think about it?
Well, let's talk about the process. Rather than the process. I've never met, I've never met, but she's got an amazing track record in media, and she's certainly run and being the chair and being board members of many, many organisations with both public and private. So I think a large part of being the chairman is process.
She'll be across that about the process of running a board. The issue, I think for me, is that that board in particular the chair will get to choose the next MD. And, you know, at a time where I think, you know, I mean, obviously we're not in the caretaker period, but we're so close to an election, I think it's outrageous for the government to make an appointment like that, and not to leave it to the next government. Yeah, well, that's a good point.
And are we going to get- we will get a new MD of the ABC before the election. Probably. The job is advertised. And in a way, the MD's job is probably more important in terms of shaping what you see and here on the ABC.
That person is the front line to standing up to pressure from the government. You know, that's where the calls come. The chairman has a role, which is to advocate for the ABC and, you know, arguably back up their MD. And they're also responsible for enforcing the charter.
Now, the charter is a really important document. It's not- the chairman of the ABC is not the same as the chairman of a normal board. They're not answerable to the shareholder, because the shareholder is the government. They actually have interposed in that this charter, which is incredibly broad.
And you need someone with real strength and backbone to push back against all the pressure that will come from the government. So is either that person? Can you agree? I think she might surprise.
Yeah, I think she probably should. I'm just going back to the process. I sort of thought that Scott Morrison might appoint Tina Arena. He was so keen to get her number from Julie Bishop.
But maybe she'll be next. Maybe. But if it is a captain's call, there aren't terribly many good examples of Captain Call. But on one level, I think, I just a refreshing choice, because older women generally don't get a chance to get into positions of power, and that sends a powerful message.
My main concern, and this may sound to be dangerous, but I think it applies to any director or chairman in Australia at the moment, is how across the digital landscape she is, because she does come from a strong media background, but it's an old media background. And the ABC, like every other organisation in Australia, needs to cope with digital disruption and the new generation. So moving through with a completely different mindset and usability of media. So my main concern is how across will she be of that, because she's not a native to the digital landscape.
And like most all directors of that age, and most of them are that age, a lot of them struggle with technology, not just calling up an Uber, but understanding how it plays out in their industry. So Matt, go and match you on that, because Dave Anderson, the current acting manager, is a very techy type of guy. In fact, the criticism of Dave would be his editorial sort of guy. Yeah, well, you know, so was Michelle Guthrie with her qualifications, one would say.
And so was Justin Milne with his techy qualifications. So I think the more important criteria here, I mean, really, if you look at some of the criteria for a managing director, for example, you'd have to say, I have major criticisms of Mark Scott, but a lot of people don't share those criticisms. Many of the faults that Michelle Guthrie was attacked for were things well under Mark Scott. The difference with Mark Scott is that he tweeted the tweet.
He walked the walk, he talked the talk. And people loved him. He duchessed. So really, a big factor in sharing all being the MD of the ABC is to spruk, to have good PR and to inspire people and to deal with synodestimates and to play the media game.
So now, I don't have no problem with that. Yeah, so therefore, is this a, are we heading to a perfect result in so far as I don't hear, you know, she's all great at the front front of house with I don't know, and then you have Dave Anderson assuming they were the ABC person, you know, who's, and Dave would have to be the front runner at the moment. He was number two to Michelle Guthrie if she got hit by a bus while it turned out she did. And now you've got Dave Anderson.
What do you think is doing that? I think staff would support the idea of him getting the job. Do you think that for the job, you think he's good, he's the right candidate? That's my view, but I don't know who else is out there.
But then I was on the board that chose Michelle Guthrie. So he'd listened to me, you know, she looked like quite a good candidate then too, and had a lot of faults, which became apparent. But, you know, I think still we'll only know in about the end of the year what her legacy probably is. But, did you support Michelle Guthrie?
Board confidentiality, but put it this way, the process was smoothly run, you know. There were other candidates obviously, but at the end of the day the board, I think, had a uniform view about what they did. But look, the thing about the point about this board is that it does appoint the next managing director and if I'd have buttroses on it, you have others on it that really have no media background whatsoever, and have been put through the mill, I guess you could say, in this traumatic period where they've lost both the MD and the chairman, I mean, they're doing, but nonetheless. So what is that board going to do now?
Is the question in terms of appointing and managing director? Well, and also just for you and Margot Andi Adri, you know, does, how do we have any inkling to know how I says appointment, how I do think about the next managing director? Well, I've got to say, I sat in a green room with her a while back when the dramatic week was happening when Michelle Guthrie got the flick. And the comments, the conversation that we had, I was struck by her general support for the ABC for her sensitivity to the difficult time that it was going through.
It hucks back to what Didry was referring to that the greatest challenge is digital. Now, I'm sure one of the factors over the appointment of Michelle Guthrie was we need somebody that's digital savvy. That was a major. We don't want to have another Fred Hilmer, you know, kind of thing.
Well, whatever. So that's the big specter that's on everybody's brain. Now, Ida is alive to these things. And I remember her listening carefully to points.
She was sort of saying, but you know, she wasn't a great speaker, but it seemed to me that Michelle Guthrie was doing blah, blah, blah. So I was struck by the fact that Ida was interested and sensitive to the huge problems that are facing the ABC. It's not, we all know about the problems that have been facing commercial media and stuff like that, but what's not widely discussed is the challenges within that ABC. So just finally on the ABC, putting on what aside the personas is that one of the problems, the charter and that it's not fully robust enough, as we've shown in the last year for these times and for an interfering government.
I don't think it is the charter. I think it's the government. That's the problem. I think the government's malevolent against the ABC, the current government.
I don't think there's any argument about that. But it's not just the liberal. And I don't. I think the charter, you know, there are things that should be changed in the charter, but I'm not an advocate of wholesale change unless you really know what the political landscape is, because you might end up with some nasty things in there that pull in handsome ones.
So, you know, let's sleep in Dog's Lie is my suggestion at the moment. It's not the charter. It's the way governments are punitive overfunding that is the real problem. Well, so, okay.
Superstar like Ida, back to the person, I guess. But is she going to be greater getting funds out of the government? I mean, we don't really know. Do we?
No, we don't know. But she has got charm and Pinesh. She'll be able to get into anybody's, any politician's office. You know, I just here to see you.
That'll be a calling. No problem. Name. I think that she's got media experience.
She's got television experience, which none of the other people did. And just remember, this is where all the money gets spent. Like the lion's share of the budget is consumed by TV. So, I think she'll bring a lot to the board.
The thing I the question mark I have about her is, I haven't ever seen a stand up on a big media issue and fight for it. Now, maybe that's my ignorance. I'm hoping that she will prove to be a charming, solid advocate for the ABC who's not afraid of taking the long term. She has had fights.
She has on the missing issues. And fighting for the rights of the aged. So, even back in the 70s, she was paid to fight. Did I mention her father?
Is that a minus? No, no, I'm just saying. To a point, I think she's possibly more pragmatic than someone who would make a grandstand. Peter, I don't think I mentioned her father.
Did I? Let's mention her father. Yes. Well, according to something I was speaking to last night, I'd sort of had a vague memory of this, but her father Charles was actually a senior executive in ABC News for quite some time.
And according to somebody who knew the family, I grew up with that in a blood, basically. It was actually the time of duck man's illness. Well, yeah, well, that's right. Well, duck man was there for how many years.
That was the last thing. But anyway, the point is she may not have worked at the ABC herself, but it was in her family history, for sure. Okay. Well, a time will tell.
I mean, I think it is a strange term of answer that the chair is not part of the selection of the panel. I mean, that's the thing putting aside the personas. I spoke to a former board member yesterday who said that selection process is enshrined in the act that they have to have the process. But the act doesn't say they have to abide by the result, which seems ridiculous.
And that the whole process would have cost more than $200,000, which is when you add in the amount of money they're about to pay out to Michelle Guthrie, is a big whack-a-man. It's a few journals worth. Yeah. And you can go back to these search firms and say, we want you to look a bit broader, or we want to tweak the search.
A lot of it would depend on what public servant wrote the qualities of the chair that they wanted. If it was very restrictive, then that's a sort of list they get. But you can go back and say, give us some more people. You don't like it.
Well, the answer wasn't Greg Highwood anyway, was it? No. No. Well, we'll go there.
We'll go there another show. Another time when Greg Fox's hit up. Let's go back to the law. So this journal is in Cape Verra.
It seems a bit hard. It's not the golden age of journalism in terms of how much money we're making, what have you. But it is the golden age of defamation, also it seems. That's the place to make plenty of dough.
Steady work. Everyone's a winner. So I don't want to get too big and joined us about it. And there are many high profile cases, so we're not going to talk about so much we can.
And one of them, when we can talk about it, is the last week's decision of charge outwing against the same money and the age, which is going to cost $280,000 plus costs, although it'll be appealed. So I think that brought up a really interesting question around the defensive qualified privilege. So we're going to get a bit lawyerly here, but fortunately, we have multiple lawyers in the room. So it's a good.
So just this week, we rejected the house defense of qualified privilege, relating to publications in the public interest to get that defense. The publishers had to prove that Guano to resource steps to establish the story was right and in the public interest. But we said that journalists had adopted a quote, sneering and deprecating tone, and basically did him in. And so now the age and the estimates are standing by Guano and will be appealing.
And in the statement, they said that John Guano was a careform and sickless walker, a war-winning journalist who was globally recognized for his Chinese expertise, and quote, we source and check all our stories, we're going to take a great pride in our role to inform the community debate. So there's a few facts on the wrong end of this, losing battle. And is there something terribly wrong with this way we're approaching defamation in this country again in the digital age? Okay, well having fallen foul of the qualified privilege defense myself, it's a very hard defense to get up.
And the idea behind it is that you do everything you possibly can, you act reasonably, but you still might have some have fallen short of being able to prove the truth of something. So in this case, the weird thing is that the judge agreed that the unindicted co-conspirator in the UN bribery case was probably Chow Chuck Wing. That was probably who they were referring to. But what he said was, well, Guano painted it as if he was actually convicted, not it was the conspirator, not that he was alleged to be the constituent.
So it was over written? Is that basically what he said? Yeah, he just went a bit too far now. I haven't done a lot about this case because I worked at the ABC when we did the same program on Chinese influence.
They're coming up this week or next week anyway. Anyway, we'll go to some of the questions. So I know a little bit about it. And the problem everybody has is how do you, I mean, short of going and actually doing the same investigation as the cops did in America.
How do you get beyond what they've got in their indictment? And so I think John really tried to do that, but it's an imperfect science. And I know everybody checked everything thoroughly as they could, but you just can't prove the truth of him being the person who paid the right. That's what the FBI is trying to do.
Sure. So the show was broadcast knowing that the defense of the show was going to have to be qualified privilege. That would have been conscious when you went to and I don't think anyone has succeeded on the qualified privilege defense for many, many years. So that brings, so in the UK, it's a bit simpler, right?
I mean, I'm not the super expert on the UK law, but as I understand it, it's basically you'd have to show that it was in the public interest in the public benefit to get qualified privilege. So is that what needs to happen here? And it's certainly simpler in the US as well, where they have a public interest, a public figure defense. So that, you know, something like this would probably be okay in the US, but it's not okay here.
So I don't know enough about the British law to say whether we need to revise our laws, but we certainly, you'd be a very brave journalist to rely on the country. So let's boil this down, Dedri. Is R.R. deformation laws hindering the search for truth?
Well, I think they are because they were drawn up at a time when the media was powerful and wealthy. There weren't many of them, and they were the chief disseminators of the information in the community. So they had a lot of weight to throw around, and I think the defamation laws were aimed at protecting people against that might. Now we have a situation where the media is more and more impoverished, it's more diffuse.
Each of them has a smaller share of the community's mind. And at the same time, you've got very powerful forces coming up, whether they're billionaires or industries or powerful companies, who know that they can take out an action, not just on behalf of themselves, but perhaps as a cautioning trail on behalf of the industry or the community or whoever. So well, you guys are going to talk about this. We're going to slap you with a writ and then we'll do another one and another one.
And you can see it already in the media. They're going, well, we can't take on this person. Or if we're going to take him on, let's make sure we're loyed up to the gannals. Can't do this job.
Marga, Peter Grestner and others, Peter Grestner has been the front of it, and saying we need a new freedom of speech law, in effect, to protect the right of journalists to do their job. Is that where we're at? Absolutely. I know there's been a sense of inquiry into the future of public interest journalism and they're making a lot of recommendations about defamation law reform, and if you speak to journalists like Kate McLimonte, you hear that it's almost impossible to get stories like me too up in Australia.
We've had one and that's gone to court. And in America, there's a ludicrous situation where someone in America was able to write a story about someone who's been applying to the Australian courts for defamation, and that's been allowable, but in Australia it's not, which is absolutely ridiculous. And I think Anne's point about the public figure defense is right, because under that defense, I mean, obviously it's enshrined in the US Constitution, the freedom of speech. We don't have that.
And we should. You can't get damages for defammetry falsehood, unless it's made with malice. And malice is if you knew something was wrong, or you should have known it was wrong. And I think, you know, the Judge Act win case, obviously, that there's no malice there.
That was an accident. And that was a tiny error in an otherwise correct case, it seems to me. And I think that really, they should be able to defend it on those grounds. Well, the judge bringing you back to a great exception to the tone of the story, which is a very subjective thing.
I mean, you know, I mean, to an point that maybe it was a written a tad, maybe a little too definitive, maybe one might say, but nonetheless. When I was going to, the judge should talk about the tone. One does get the impression that judges have their opinions about the media too. And occasionally, their views intrude into their judgments more than they might.
Well, indeed. They're not the paragons of wisdom and virtue that perhaps. No, to go back to the, you know, the old media when it was powerful and now it isn't. But it's always been a historical truth that the judges have despised the media by and large, because they've regarded it as a, well, I mean, I'm generalising wildly here, but it's still seen as an anti-conservative force.
I guess you should add that Justice Michael Wigny is a fine person and we're not defaming him. No, that's right. I wasn't talking personally about the judge. No, of course not.
No, no, no, no, no. Okay, let's move on. News today, in fact, the age has been ordered to pay $180,000 in damages to one of its former journalists for psychological injuries incurred while working as a crime reporter. Now, the journalist hasn't been named, but she worked for the age from 2003 to 2013.
So I probably can all guess who she is. But she covered the gang wars that grip Melbourne and she went to numerous crime scenes, she won many awards, and apparently she went to 32 murder scenes. So this is a really interesting turn of events. I mean, I'm going to two minds about it.
But clearly if she's got PTSD, then that's a terrible thing. But now she sort of, she successfully sued the age. What do you think due to? Well, the implications of the damages is that the age did something wrong there.
Well, it failed to look after the journal. Yeah. But I would suppose that if you're a war correspondent or a crime reporter to do your job, you're going to be exposed to that stuff. And there's no way to protect someone if they're going to be doing that job.
And you put up your hand to do that job. It's not that she ran into it when she was training on a regular training thing that you have to do to be a journalist. She put up a hand for the job or she accepted the job. Therefore, I don't see how you could go through that job and not or any job in journalism probably and not be traumatised on the odd occasion.
She's obviously been traumatised a lot. Well, it's a tricky one because we haven't read the judgment. And so it does seem according to the Dye Center, which has been very active in this country and some of us have to do with it over the years, this is the first of its kind. And so this is potentially a precedent.
But there was the first of its kind with that, you know, a while back over post-traumatic stress after covering wars. So you don't know. People do experience a lot of a lot of ill effects from being exposed to things that you don't really know about. I suspect, Peter, you would find if you started digging that there would be various journalists who've been paid out quietly not having had to take it to court.
Because they... I'm sure that's true. So I'm thinking about, you know, war correspondents who've gone or, you know, they've been given a soft job somewhere. Whatever.
That's how the media's handled it. To talk about that, too, the point is, and it probably does apply in this case, who knows, but it's how people's employer deals with it in this day and age. So they may well have been pleased for help and, you know, there might have been all sorts of circumstances that the employer didn't react to. We don't really know what the incidents were.
Margot, one of the ways of looking at this, of course, is that as we all know, journalists are doing more work, more, you know, turning up stories more frequently, you know, now in the digital age to feed the beast. Maybe this is just a sign of things to come. Maybe it is. I've just finished reading the biography of Marie Colvin.
She clearly had PTSD, but she's... She was addicted to it, though. Yeah, yeah. She was addicted to it and she medicated with alcohol and goes, what?
Yeah. So, yeah, I think, you know, it just goes with the job and, you know, it's a workplace health and safety issue. And it's just maybe it's just going to be a cost that's going to be built into media organisations or their insurance contracts. But the point that we're all making, really, is that it's, you know, being a journalist is bad for your health.
Being a journalist is bad for your health, but I mean, that's why we have journalists, right? So what has to go and be a witness? Yeah. But that's what I mean.
Yeah. But it doesn't mean that your employer can just sort of absolve themselves from taking responsibility for you. So when I was at Fairfax, we all went off to the tsunami and I went having no experience covering those sort of things. When we got back, we were sent off to the psychiatrist, the psychologist.
We had to go to two or three sessions. They sort of checked up that we were OK. I probably wasn't at that great risk because it was like a one-off thing and I tended to do business and, you know, have people yell at me down the phone from investigations. Well, that is traumatic.
Not as traumatic as seeing dead boys. And I really don't think Fairfax had a very good system for dealing with the people who were day-to-day exposed to it. They got better because everyone's really aware of it. But in the old days, people were just sent off and, you know, it was a badge of honour that you've been to 47 men.
Indeed. And went to the pub afterwards and tracked us off stupid. Yeah. One other element to this, I think, is I think this came out in this case was the journalist was concerned about saying too much about it because everyone else was getting made redundant and she didn't want to be made redundant.
So she was concerned about complaining. That is another factor, right? Employees aren't mind readers. No.
You have to speak up. Well, I think she did. But anyway, I don't say I'm read the ins and outs of this case. But also with PTSD, one incident can do it for you.
So you can have an occupation of health and safety programme of checking on people. But it's something that it's almost virtually impossible to stop. And Ambo's and police go through the same thing. So maybe we should, they haven't got too big systems in place either.
But maybe we should be included in those sort of industries, looking at ways of helping people cope with terrible events. Anyway, on balance, you'd have to say it's probably a good result because it puts a lot more weight now in the employers' hands. They are going to treat it seriously because they're going to have lawyers clambering all over them if they don't. Well, if Justice Michael Wigny don't get your attention in the previous case, will.
Fair enough. Fair enough. Fair enough. And I should say, this is about all time we've had for this week.
But if any of this discussion we've just had causes anyone stress the lifelike. Sue. Don't want that to. Sue Matt Peek up.
The lifeline number is 131114. It's been a great decision. I could probably speak for another two hours. My parking need is in the middle.
You've got parking need. So I'd like to thank you. Did you reckon? Thank you.
Thank you. And I hope you don't get a parking ticket. Margo Sivin. Thank you so much.
Thanks, Veda. And Davis. Thank you. And slightly later, rival.
But nonetheless, made a contribution. Thank you. Thank you. Make sure you're subscribed to The Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app.
So you can hear us talk about media and politics and a few things in between. Actual leisure. We'll be back with more next week. But in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Facebook or Twitter, where our handle is Fourth Estate AU.
My name is Peter Fran. Thank you so much for listening. A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars.
And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer. That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us.
Learn how at Ontario.ca.