Skip to content
Pete Hegseth and the Signal leak episode artwork

Mar 25, 2025 29 min

Pete Hegseth and the Signal leak

from Sidebar Hosted by The Washington Post

On this episode, The Washington Post's Libby Casey, Rhonda Colvin and James Hohmann break down the Trump administration's leak of national security information to a magazine editor – and how Congress reacted to it in a fiery hearing on Tuesday. Plus, is the Trump administration transparent – or just claiming to be?

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Pete Hegseth and the Signal leak

0:00 29:58
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

If you got in this group chat like Jeffrey Goldberg did, would you have believed it? You're at the grocery store. You're at, you know, wherever you might be. And you get this. That probably would also make me think that this was not real. I personally would have reported it to our security team here at the Washington Post who investigate email scams. He's phishing me. And yeah. Look what happened is this crazy. We stand on the verge of the four greatest years in the history. Make America great. How can you be against it?

It's the group chat heard round the world. Top Trump administration officials planned a military attack in a foreign country via the messaging app Signal and accidentally included a journalist. This is Sidebar from The Washington Post. I'm Libby Casey, joined by my journalistic colleagues, Rhonda Coleman and James Homan, who are in all of my group chats, but you guys know that you're there. Okay, so Democrats are apoplectic about this. Republicans are saying we all make mistakes. The German news outlet, Der Spiegel, described it as an airstrike planned like a teenage party. And in an extraordinary hearing today that Rhonda was at, top national security officials went before senators to talk about worldwide threats, and the Democrats were like,

The call is coming from inside the house. Like, you guys are the threat. So today on Sybar, we'll talk about that. We'll also look at the Trump administration's claims of being open and transparent. They just released last week some previously redacted files about JFK's assassination. But just how transparent is this administration, really? Let's start with what we know about the most infamous group chat, like, ever, which is saying something. James, dive in to what happened to Jeffrey Goldberg. So he's the editor-in-chief of The Atlantic, a pretty outspoken critic of Trump and the administration. And he, all of a sudden, is looking at his phone, and he gets invited by someone named Michael Waltz, which is the national security advisor, to connect on.

signal and he thinks it's a scam, maybe accepts it. And then all of a sudden he gets added into this group. And the name is PC for principles committee on the Houthi strikes. The Houthis have been blocking shipping lanes in Yemen. And all of a sudden, Walt sends out this message and Goldberg doesn't know whether it's real or fake. But he says to the CIA director and the secretary of state and defense and the head of the CIA and the director of national intelligence, we're organizing this. Please tell me who on your team is going to be sort of your point person. And so all these people start responding with the names of their deputies. And Goldberg is intrigued. And then it just keeps going from there. And over the course of several days, eventually Pete Hegseth sends.

out some what apparently was like detailed targeting information minute by minute who they're going to strike where how using what weapons and then afterwards they're all congratulating each other and sending around emojis saying great job it is one of those holy cow stories where you read it and you think how can this be real life it feels like if it was on veep it wouldn't be believable because it's just like too dumb right it's like too simplistic of a storyline who would ever do this now a spokesman for the white house national security council has said the message threat appears to be authentic and the administration officials were reviewing how an inadvertent number was added to the chain um ronda what did jeffrey goldberg do Well, he removed himself from the chain. And that was something that I think is a part of a journalistic ethical decision, knowing that he didn't belong there. Also, he may not have wanted to see what was coming next. But, you know, I think it was made out of a decision of journalistic integrity, making sure that he was not opening himself up to any further information that he was not supposed to see. I know one lawmaker pointed out yesterday that imagine if someone.

else was accidentally added to it who didn't have those same type of ethical questions that they were asking themselves and decided to just release the whole thing, stay on there until anyone noticed. You raise a good point because Goldberg did not release all the information about that chat. He specifically says in the Atlantic article that he's not revealing some things because he feels that it is in his mind sort of classified intelligence or information that's sensitive. And not in the public interest. So John Ratcliffe, the CIA director, named someone who's an undercover current spy, and there's no news value in outing that person as a spy. And so Goldberg showed a lot more sensitivity and care than the people on the chain. Why do you think he left the group chat?

I don't know. I mean, I think that there obviously was a lot of sensitivity to potential legal issues. The administration has made a big deal about targeting journalists for violating the Espionage Act of 1917. And if you're in possession of classified material, I assume that he made that decision after consulting with his lawyers, but I can't be sure. And also when he was, when he realized, I mean, it is remarkable to read the article and I do encourage people to check it out because he's like going about his life, getting this string of signal messages. And then he realizes that it is legitimate and real because he, at first he thought it might just be phishing or maybe a scam, somebody trying to trap a journalist. And then once.

the attack begins, he realizes this is real. He literally is in the supermarket parking lot and opens Twitter on his phone a little afternoon and types in Yemen. And there's all these tweets about airstrikes in Sanaa. So there are a couple of problems here. All right. There's accidentally putting a journalist on a group chat. But then there's this question about chatting over Signal, military plans, plans of an operation. Is Signal supposed to be used in this capacity? From what we know, no.

However, John Ratcliffe, who was in front of senators today during a previously scheduled hearing where the intelligence chiefs come in front of Congress to tell them of threat assessments, he said that this was approved for the use the way he was using it and that no classified information was passed through it. Now, from having covered Congress and different things involving the intelligence community, I know as a reporter that much of these decisions are supposed to be or discussions are supposed to be had in SCIFs, certainly not cell phones. And I'll also add this. Remember when. Obama, in his first term, there was all of this chatter about him using a cell phone, his Blackberry at the time because it could be a national security risk. I mean, just think about that and now where we're at. So yes, people who have access to classified documents, materials, they are not supposed to be using this in some sort of casual way as this text thread.

appears to be. There are two issues. There's a legal issue and there's a privacy national security issue. The legal issue is that they are actually required to keep these records for the presidential records act purposes for future historians. And indeed, this chat was set to auto delete after a week. So that is certainly violating transparency rules. The second thing is Signal itself is believed to be, we have caveats, secure. But former CIA employees received a message just last week telling them that they should be really careful using Signal because foreign actors have a...

shockingly, discomfortingly easy time getting into your phone and hacking into your phone. They can use malware, including no click sort of things. You don't even have to click on a phishing email. This is for sophisticated foreign governments, China, Russia, Iran. And once they're into your phone, and ostensibly they would be for all these.

people, they can read anything you can read on your phone. So they may not be able to hack into the signal traffic between you and I, but if they're on my phone, they can see everything I'm seeing on signal. And so one of the people who was on this chain was Steve Whitcoff, who's the president's emissary to Russia. And he was actually in Moscow when these texts were being exchanged in the Kremlin meeting with Putin. And you can be reasonably certain that the Kremlin made an effort to get into his personal phone while he was in Russia, using Russian networks, using Russian Wi-Fi. And so in that case, theoretically, the Russians could then...

have read all of this in real time. So that's, I think that, you know, it's why people are like, oh, signals are safe, but it's not necessarily safe. It's also human error. Everything from leaving your phone sitting out somewhere where someone sees it to putting the wrong person on the group chat. And it seems like Ronda Republicans have been focused on the question of like Jeffrey Goldberg getting into the group chat and not being like the drop ball there. They seem less fussed about the use of signal at this point. Is that fair to say? It is fair to say, but that's also a hard argument to make because he, as we were just saying, he did voluntarily leave. The National Security Council has also said this was, appears to have been this credible text thread among these folks. So.

To say that it was Goldberg's fault or he somehow got into it, that doesn't appear to be true. Or even just that it was a mistake to add him in and they'll look into that. But that's getting distracted about who's been included in the group chat and not focused on the... function of having the group chat up. Yeah, exactly. Kind of diverting attention to that part of it. But I'll also add this, because I think this is a point that you're going to hear a lot from Democrats. Other than the security concern, there's just how it appears to the U.S. adversaries, to even your allies, that this kind of looks like amateur hour a bit. That this is just, it's not a good look to have had this happen, and also to have Republicans try to sweep it under the rug and say, you know, well...

Mistakes happen or any other claims. This doesn't look serious. Well, it is serious, but it doesn't look like the people who are involved in international security and making war plans are going about it in ways that previous administrations have. Didn't we all learn something about lax operational security from one Hillary Clinton and the question over the private email server? These are the same people who are really condemning that. Yeah, same people. And remember, there was a congressional investigation. I mean, it went on for years. Remember, Trump had the lock her up, you know, motto that he would say at his rallies. So that was a real thing. Everyone was upset about it.

And now we're saying this. I'll also add this. I know I'm going back in time here, but I was thinking about how the Obama tan suit gave. Remember that? Everybody talks about it and how it was, you know, we covered things that were easier at that time. But if you remember why Republicans were mad that he wore a tan suit, it was because they said he did not appear serious when he was talking about war policy when they had to deal with ISIS and Syria. And I went back and looked at some of the things Republicans said about the tan suit. You think about that, and then you also think about how, again, adversaries of the U.S. will be looking at the fact that war plans are being discussed on a cell phone.

You know, I'm glad you said that, Rhonda, because my memory of the tan suit was like the media was frothing over it. But you're right. It was like Republicans were frothing. Oh, yeah. Republicans on the Hill. Yeah. We're saying things like people will not take us seriously if our leader is wearing a tan suit. And now you have this. So you're saying it's like a like a bunch of teenagers, basically. James, who is in the doghouse? Mike Waltz. And it's interesting because.

There are frustrations with Waltz inside. Inevitably, this happens with the National Security Advisor because they play the coordinating role where they are basically supposed to be an honest broker who's bringing in the Secretaries of State and Defense and CIA. And they're sort of taking all their views and coordinating it and bringing it to the president. And so Mike Waltz has rubbed some people the wrong way. He's been seen as a little imperious by these people. I'm not saying he has been. And he also is more of the traditional internationalist wing of the party. And so I think that kind of the isolationist types, the Vance world types, they see an opportunity to.

fell or sidelined mike waltz obviously it was a huge screw up by him he appears to be the one or his team his spokesperson uh brian hughes putting this together initiating the chat initiating the chat but then hegseth is the one who yeah let's talk about i think hegseth is the one who obviously puts the really really sensitive material in there yes and that uh is bad because it just makes him look unserious he's the word that i think is totally right uh and so trump has come out and said mike waltz has learned his lesson he expressed confidence in him so he's going to keep his job it doesn't appear any immediate heads are going to roll uh but i do think this really sort of makes hegseth look bad especially because hegseth is on a trip he went to hawaii now he's going to guam today and he lands in hawaii he was in the air when the story comes out and like he basically like lies and i see what he says so here's what pete hegseth had to say when asked about the group chat you're talking about a deceitful and highly discredited so-called journalist who's made a profession of peddling hoaxes time and time again to include the, I don't know, the hoaxes of Russia, Russia, Russia, or the fine people on both sides hoax, or suckers and losers hoax. So this is a guy that peddles in garbage. Nobody was texting war plans, and that's all I have to say about that. Thank you.

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth directly contradicting what the White House has said about the veracity of these messages and attacking Jeffrey Goldberg. And it just, frankly, it underscores the reporting that he was criticizing. You know, Jeff Goldberg has had a lot of great reporting and cover stories in the Atlantic about Trump calling veterans suckers losers. And Trump has always denied it. And so when you have someone coming out and flatly deny something that other people in the administration have confirmed to be true, it does give credence to the other reporting that they're going after. We also heard Trump say fine people on both sides. That's in reference to Charlottesville, Virginia. So what happens to Hegseth? Anything?

Eyes in silence. I mean, they've been standing behind him at this point fully. Right. I think it's actually one of those questions that people were asking when he was confirmed, because he was confirmed basically in a tie where J.D. Vance had to come in and break the tie in order for him to get the job. So he went into this not being a very popular candidate for this job. And Republicans as well as Democrats have said that he is perhaps not the person for this role. So I think there's always been question marks about headset, his future, if he will last the entire four years. I don't know the answer yet. I think we'll also.

perhaps learn more. If you hear more outcry about this, if you, if there are deeper investigations, if something else happens that's similar to this, you know, we'll have to see. When it comes to the big questions, who you ask matters. From breaking news to politics that impact your life, to advice you can trust. Get answers you don't have to question with Ask the Post AI. Trained exclusively on post journalism with clear sourcing. And if we don't know the answer, we'll tell you. Ask the Post AI. Find it on WashingtonPost.com or in the app. Back to the doghouse, J.D. Vance, vice president, in the chat, seems to critique or have a different opinion than President Trump. It is really interesting because that, you know, one of the news...

value elements of this is, you see the conversation sort of surface level, it is surprising, you'd like to think that there's more grand strategy, or any discussion over whether bombing the Houthis would actually help or anything like that. But instead, what you have JD Vance saying is, This is Europe free riding off of us. Very little US trade goes through the Suez Canal. I don't think that this is consistent with what the president is saying he wants on Europe. And basically everyone else saying, no, the president, including Stephen Miller in a meeting, this is, he greenlighted this. This is the direction that he wants to go. And then Vance basically saying, well, if Pete to Hegseth, if you think this is the right thing, let's do it. But also try to protect the Saudi oil fields in advance if you can. So it's a window into Vance being privately pretty similar to what he is publicly. He's not sort of broken with the president that way, but being very, very skeptical of foreign intervention, but also.

kind of breathtakingly negative toward Europe and our allies, which Hegseth is too, saying, I hate the Europeans just as much as you do, and we're going to find a way to make them pay for this. I mean, they really trash talk Europe and show this great disdain. And one thing that our colleagues pointed out, reporting led by Alan Francis and a team, that experts said to them, this shows that that disdain for Europe isn't just posturing, it's not just a negotiating tactic, that the private messages reveal these people actually feel this way, which is really interesting. It's hugely at odds with... You know, the whole post-war era. I mean, it is a pretty dramatic break. And you're right, it's not just, oh, pay more for your defense. They really do want to actually sort of make Europe defend itself. That is a dramatic change in statecraft. So, Rhonda, you were at this hearing today on worldwide threats. Did it feel partisan? How were Democrats approaching it versus Republicans? Yeah, I've covered this, you know, several times. It's an annual hearing. The intelligence community puts together a report. Anyone can read it. You can go on the committee's site and see the report. Usually it's very bipartisan. You see similar questions on both sides of the aisle on, you know, threats that are coming from China or Russia.

This time, it does feel as if Republicans may have added some of the talking points that they ran on in the last election and often talk about for the first time. added to the report was mentioned that the opioid crisis and drug cartels are an emerging threat to national security. And that's something that Senator Cotton, who is the chair of this committee, a Republican, he said that he made that his focus in his opening remarks and his questions. But then you had Democrats, they were already with questions about this text group. I mean, the timing is remarkable. Yeah, and I should, and I believe I've said it, but I should say that this was scheduled prior to our awareness of this text group. And Jeffrey Goldberg published his article based on when the strikes happened in Yemen. So it wasn't like this guy, this is just how it has all proceeded. And the timing is remarkable. Yeah.

The other thing, you're right about fentanyl and overdoses, that was notable, and they took out all the references to climate change that have been in the document in the past. This is the 12th report of the threat assessment. The 11 before mentioned climate change and migration due to climate change as a worldwide threat. This did not. So that also shows you, even in other administrations, Republican administrations, as well as Democrats, that that was an issue, and now it's not. So Democrats asked these questions of these intelligence leaders about the...

signal text messaging chain. Let's listen to an exchange between Tulsi Gabbard, head of DNI, and Virginia Democrat, Senator Mark Warner. There was no classified material that was shared in that. So if there was no classified material, share it with the committee. You can't have it both ways. These are important jobs. This is our national security. So they were saying in there that the text string did not have classified information, James? It's wild. It's possible it's been declassified and that they got, but it's totally absurd that pre-decisional material about strikes and targets, you know, you heard that in the Hegseth clip we watched too, where he says we didn't discuss war plans. If those aren't war plans, I don't know what would be.

And of course, this is classified material. But this gets at the trying to be too cute by half. And I think Warner really called their hand. Warner is in cycle. He's up for reelection next year in Virginia, which has more federal workers than any other state. And I think that this is one of the very few places where like politically, I think a lot of people are like, whatever, a group chat, this doesn't affect the...

pocketbook issues that I care about. But in Virginia, home of the CIA, a lot of other, the biggest naval base in the world, I think this does resonate. When he first asked Gabbard about the text thread, and she said immediately, I'm not going to answer any questions. This is being investigated. So we can't say anything. John Ratcliffe tried to come in and say his views on it. But I noticed that Gabbard was not, she wasn't playing ball here. But that clip that you just played was later on in the hearing showing that

When pressed, they're going to have to answer for what's going on. So if Democrats on the Hill keep pressing, if you see any sort of public outcry that this is, you know, dangerous and it looks very concerning for the U.S., you may see that this becomes a bigger issue and isn't that easy to, you know, sweep under the rug. Well, here's one of those narrative shifting moments releasing the JFK files. We'll talk about transparency and the Trump administration when we come back. This is Sidebar from The Washington Post.

This is Sidebar from The Washington Post. Listen to us on your favorite podcast app or watch along with us on YouTube. Just look for The Washington Post. So let's talk about openness and transparency. James, what efforts is the Trump administration doing to become open and transparent?

Donald Trump wants to call himself the most transparent president ever when they're sharing war plans with reporters. Maybe that is a sign of transparency. Maybe there is such a thing as too much transparency. But there are three things that they're doing to, I think Trump is trying to basically show that he's taking on the so-called deep state of the government. The first is the JFK files, just putting them all out, 80,000 pages. And we frankly saw why last week a lot of this had been held onto. A lot of what had been redacted was people's social security numbers, including many people who were alive. The Post had a great story on Sunday about a guy who discovered his grandfather had been helping the CIA and he had had no idea. One of the documents was about a CIA.

officer provisioning a prostitute for the king of Jordan's father during a visit to the US decades ago, awkward stuff. And also ended up in this dragnet of files related to JFK. The next two things are Trump really wants to put out all of the Martin Luther King Jr. files. So they collected, I mean, it's one of the darkest chapters in FBI history. They did all these illegal wiretaps and they have recordings of him having extramarital affairs. And Trump wants to just put it all out there. The King family is fighting this. And so civil rights group saying this will really embarrass and undermine Dr. King's legacy. And Trump says, I don't care, put it all out there. And then the third thing is the so-called Epstein files.

Pam Bondi, the attorney general, when she came in, she put out some stuff that had already been out there a decade ago, and they handed out these binders to influencers, and it was a nothing burger. And so the result of that was that people on the right were actually pissed at Pam Bondi, the attorney general. So now what she's doing to overcompensate is they've literally... they've reassigned hundreds of FBI agents to go through all these files, anything that was part of the investigation. And they're trying to come up with stuff that they can release. And it's just, it's part of an effort to basically save face. And so I think they're going to play out a bunch more. So all of that is happening and it creates this impression like, wow, Trump is being really transparent. But in other ways, he's the least transparent president of modern times. He ended the, what Biden had done and what Obama had done before. He's not releasing White House visitor logs. He obviously hasn't released tax returns. He hasn't released medical records. There's a lot that's being done in secret. This is actually Sunshine Week. And a lot of the transparency groups are saying Trump actually.

is trying to make it harder to get Freedom of Information Act requests for stuff that is embarrassing to him. So there is some transparency. I would argue it's not the right kind of transparency. We have to just also say the word Doge because there's been such a lack of transparency over what Doge is doing, what they're targeting, who they're going after, which agencies and organizations within the government they're trying to shut down. And then their claims of where money is being saved are clearly are constantly having to be fixed and repaired because they have not been accurate. I'm so glad you mentioned Doge because there's been some great reporting about how they were initially putting all these so-called savings online. And then people were like, these aren't actually savings. This is a contract that ended 20 years ago. And so they've really stopped doing a lot of that because it was showing that their claims weren't being backed up by reality. I have to ask about one more thing happening this week.

The vice president's wife, Usha Vance, is going to Greenland. Rhonda, why is she going and what is this all about? Well, she, in her statement, says it's for learning the culture. She is taking one of her children with her. I believe they will be viewing the dog sled. Should we listen to some of what she put out on Instagram? Okay, let's listen to the second lady of the United States. Hello. I'm so excited to share that I'll be visiting Kalalutina, Greenland, next weekend. I'm particularly thrilled to visit during our national dog sled race, which our country is proud to support as a sponsor. I've been reading all about it with my children, and I'm amazed by the incredible skill and teamwork that it takes to participate in this race.

I'm also coming to celebrate the long history of mutual respect and cooperation between our nations and to express hope that our relationship will only grow stronger in the coming years. I look forward to meeting many of you soon and to learning from you about your beautiful land, culture, and traditions. See you soon. Okay, Usha Vance. It's an awkward video. I'm not going to lie. But she's trying to be warm and communicate to the people of Greenland. They are not happy, Rhonda. They aren't. And I think we heard some of the most direct statements that we've heard from the prime minister and other government officials with Greenland. He's saying, you know, in fact, I have the quote here that stood out to me. We are now at a level where this cannot in any way be characterized as a harmless visit from a politician's wife. The only purpose is to demonstrate power over us. And he had other statements to say that this is an aggressive move. Mike Waltz, as we talked about him earlier, he is also scheduled to go. Mike Waltz is in the dog.

house, what do you do? You send him to Greenland. A nice vacation off the grid, right? Yeah. So it appears that the administration is downplaying this as, oh, we're just sending some folks to learn a little bit about the culture. But Greenland is getting a little bit more concerned. Yeah, when you have a national security advisor go, it's not just a vacation trip. I mean, it's clearly being done for strategy. And Donald Trump has said that he wants to take over Greenland one way or the other. Now, Trump is saying this is friendliness, not provocation. But when you're having to defend the trip, James, it raises a lot of eyebrows. Yeah, it's really interesting to send you to advance. So what people don't really realize about Greenland is that 90% of the very small population, but 90% of the population is indigenous. One of the reasons...

the White House chose to send Usha Vance is because it's the daughter of Indian immigrants. They thought that she might be able to connect better with the local population. Obviously, that hasn't worked as planned, but it will be fascinating to see how this plays out. And I think the Danes are quite nervous. Denmark controls Greenland. The Danes are honestly freaking out about what Trump wants and what are they going to do to try to...

fix this. The people of Greenland have a saying, nothing about us without us. And the idea is Denmark shouldn't be doing things about us without consulting us and involving us. And certainly the United States, half the world away, should not be making decisions that don't involve us. So we'll be watching what could be a really joyful educational trip for Usha Vance and one of their children. It may turn out to be a lot more electric and people focusing on it and watching it very closely in a way that usually second lady trips aren't probably focused on so much, James. All right, well, we'll be focusing on that as well as everything else happening. It's been such a week and it's only Tuesday, but luckily we have another episode of Cyber coming up in just two days. So we'll catch you up on everything else that happens in the next 48 hours.

James Homan, Rhonda Colvin, I'm Libby Casey. Thank you for joining us. We'll talk to you in a couple days. Did you know you can play the Washington Post's games for free? Find the crossword, keyword, ridges, and on the record in the Washington Post app or at washingtonpost.com slash games. No subscription required.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Sidebar?

This episode is 29 minutes long.

When was this Sidebar episode published?

This episode was published on March 25, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Sidebar episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.