Skip to content
Piltdown Man episode artwork

Dec 18, 2012 9 min

Piltdown Man

from Witness History: Archive 2012 Hosted by BBC World Service

In 1912, Britain's top paleontologists were tricked by one of the biggest hoaxes in scientific history - a skull thought to be the "missing link" in human evolution. The remains were discovered in a gravel pit in rural Sussex and became known as Piltdown Man. Witness tells the story of the hoax using contemporary accounts of what happened. The programme also hears from Dr Miles Russell of Bournemouth University, author of 'Piltdown Man: Case Closed'. Presented and produced by Simon Watts. First broadcast on BBC World Service December 2012.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Piltdown Man

0:00 9:00
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and thank you for downloading Witness from the BBC World Service. Today we're going back exactly 100 years to the biggest hoax in scientific history, the discovery in rural England of an apparently ancient fossil, which became known as Piltdown Man. Using contemporary accounts, Simon Watts describes what happened. It's December the 18th, 1912, and at the Royal Geological Society in London, scientists unveil an amazing discovery, a fossil that makes headlines around the world.

An English ape-man, Paleolithic skull is missing link. The earliest man, remarkable discovery in Sussex, a skull millions of years old. The most ancient inhabitant of England, the Unifound Sussex Man. The fossil was soon nicknamed the Piltdown Man, after the village in rural Sussex where it was found.

The discoverers were Arthur Smith Woodward, a leading paleontologist at the Natural History Museum, and his friend, Charles Dawson, a Sussex lawyer and amateur fossil hunter. Dawson had found what looked like part of a very ancient skull in a gravel pit near a golf course, and asked Woodward to come and have a look. Mr Dawson brought his discoveries to me to talk about them and to learn whether his conclusions were justifiable. We decided to work together in the gravel pit at Piltdown and to try to find the remaining pieces of the human skull.

On different days, we picked up three undoubted flint implements and fragments of a tooth of an elephant, and one much-rolled bit of the tooth of a mastodon. Finally, on a warm evening after an afternoon's vain search, Mr Dawson was exploring some untouched remnants of the original gravel at the bottom of the pit, when we both saw half of the human lower jaw fly out in front of the pick-shaped end of the hammer he was using. Thus was recovered the most remarkable portion of the fossil we were collecting. Woodward concluded that the fragments of skull and jaw found by Dawson were not just any old fossil, they were the holy grail of paleontology.

It was exciting because it appeared to be the missing link between apes and humans. It was final conclusive proof that showed that Charles Darwin and all the others' theory of evolution was correct. Dr Miles Russell, author of The Piltdown Man Hoax, case closed. Essentially, what they presented was a large section of a human skull and what appeared to be an ape-like jaw, which seemed to comprise both of the human and simian characteristics, which suggested that here indeed was somebody who was in mid-stage evolution.

And it was an exciting find because it had come from the southern counties of England. It proved that England was the cradle of humanity. So it was almost a matter of national pride? It certainly was.

It was a sense that Britain and England are where civilisation began. A lot of experts who were excited by the find were blinded by the fact that it was what they'd all been looking for for so long. And the hoax isn't a particularly clever one. There are certain aspects of it which close detection would have seen.

It was clever only in the sense that it's what people wanted. So how was it faked then? What had actually been done to make this thing? It really comprised of two distinct segments.

We've got an extremely thickened human cranium. Of course, that fits into the idea that this was a primitive individual. But it suggests it was enclosing quite a large, developed, human-like brain. There's also an orangutan jaw.

They then removed a large number of teeth and the two they'd left, they filed down. Which suggests there's a rotary chewing motion more akin to humans than apes. Somebody had abraded the teeth, probably with sandpaper and with a metal filer. Anyone using a microscope and looking at those teeth should have spotted that.

But the thing is, no one did. They then stained the orangutan jaw and they've stained the human skull. They looked broadly similar. They were the same colour.

Finding the missing link gave Arthur Smith Woodward enormous prestige. Some of his colleagues at the Natural History Museum had doubts. But it was not until after his death that his conclusions were rigorously tested. The problem of the Piltdown remains was brought sharply before the world in November 1953.

When modern scientists proved that the Piltdown man was a hoax, the BBC invited the researchers to explain their results in a special programme. The jaw bones and teeth were found to contain no more fluorine than modern bones and teeth. That being so, their organic or protein content should have been high. Yes, that is so, and we checked that too.

And as a matter of fact, we've been able to show that it had been coloured artificially with iron and chromium to match the brain case bones. This new work leaves no doubt that the Piltdown jaw is a bogus fossil. But who was the hoaxer? Many suspects have been suggested, including Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, the author of Sherlock Holmes, who lived near Piltdown.

But most experts think the evidence points to the amateur fossil hunter Charles Dawson himself. He wrote several different and often contradictory accounts of finding Piltdown man. This is just one of them. Several years ago, I was walking along a farm road close to Piltdown Common, Sussex, when I noticed that the road had been mended with some peculiar brown flints not used in the district.

On inquiry, I was astonished to learn that they were dug from a gravel bed on the farm. Upon one of my subsequent visits to the pit, one of the men handed me a small portion of an unusually thick human palliator bone. It was not until some years later that I picked up another and larger piece belonging to the frontal region of the same skull. Charles Dawson is one of those really enigmatic characters.

Everyone who knew him described as quite a jovial, outlandish character. He's a solicitor. But he spent a lot of his time walking across the South Downs collecting things. And most of these things that he found were of an exceptional nature and really made him a celebrity.

He was known as the Wizard of Sussex for these finds. So I suppose if you were the Wizard of Sussex, the ultimate thing to find would be the missing link in Sussex. Well, indeed, he's called the Wizard of Sussex. You never know whether that's a jokey phrase, but certainly a lot of people were amazed at all these incredible discoveries that he was making really all within about a 20-mile radius of his home.

So he finds evidence of some of the earliest blast furnace activity, a Roman carcine statue. In the 1890s, he was elected a Fellow of the Society of Antiquaries based on his archaeological finds, of which at least 16 can now be shown to be foked. So Dawson has a track record of fakes and hoaxes. Will you have the opportunity and the means to do the hoax?

Oh, absolutely. He certainly had the means. He acquired material for Hastings Museum. In his legal side, he managed to get people to sign off in their wills and again, a whole series of antiquarian and archaeological collections.

He's got a wealth of historical artefacts which are passing through his hands. His office was quite unlike any other solicitors. It's full of scientific equipment. He's got a stove.

He's got saucepans. He's got petri dishes. He's got all kinds of tubes. He's boiling things up.

He's testing chemicals all the time. He's certainly got the means. He's got the opportunity. He's the only constant at every point.

Every time a find is made at Piltdown, he is there. He either finds it himself or he's standing next to the person who finds it. Of course, when he dies in 1916, Piltdown man dies with him. I think Woodward's biggest fault was he was friends with Dawson.

And Woodward, as far as we can tell, trusted Dawson implicitly. So he never questioned any aspects of the find he should have done, but he didn't. And we know that when Dawson died, Woodward carried on work at Piltdown. When he retired in 1920s, he moved very close to the site.

And so the rather sad postscript to the whole story is he spent the last 21 years of his life digging in the gravels at Piltdown, searching desperately for more evidence to support the things that he and Dawson found together. And of course, he found nothing. Dr. Miles Russell, ending witness from Simon Watts.

For details of our complete range of downloads and our terms of use, go to bbcworldservice.com slash podcasts.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Witness History: Archive 2012?

This episode is 9 minutes long.

When was this Witness History: Archive 2012 episode published?

This episode was published on December 18, 2012.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Witness History: Archive 2012 episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.