Hello and welcome. You're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism, coming to you from Tursiara and Sydney, on Gadigal lands of the Ora nation, right across Australia, on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Peter Frey and I'm the co-director of the Centre for Media Transition at the University of Technology Sydney and my producer of today is Anthony Dockrok. If you are a regular listener to this show, I might owe you an apology.
We've been doing a lot of one-on-ones recently, rather than panels, and many of them have been with blokes. We'll get back to the panels very soon and I guess we will re-balance the genomics. But this week, I simply can't go past the opportunity to talk at length with a very special Distinguished Journalist, Media Executive and Educator who also is a bloke. Welcome to the show, Steve Cole.
Thank you. I'm glad to be here, Peter. Steve Cole is the Dean of the Graduate School of Journalism at Columbia University in New York. He's a staff writer for The New Yorker.
He's one of Pulitzer Prize, former managing editor of The Washington Post, and many other things in journalism. Not to mention, or just to mention, the author of several books mainly about national security and intelligence. I'm quite exhausted just saying it. How do you find all the time?
I just love my work, actually. You're just a work-holic. Not well, possibly, but I don't feel abused by all of the effort I put in I enjoyed immensely. Well, I have to say, it's a wonderful body of work and congratulations on that.
That's the fandom. So you're here to perform? Yes, sing for my playing ticket. You're going to be at the Sydney Opera House at the Antidote Festival on a panel about press freedom with the equally wonderful Maria Ressa from the Philippines, who's I think one of the world's most courageous journalists, and our very own Peter Gresser, who as we all know, has spent 400 days in Egyptian prison self or whose troubles of being a journalist without a zero.
I'll be there for sure, but can I just ask this? Is there a danger that everyone, the panel, the audience, are going to be in sort of a furious agreement? I suppose journalists do like to talk about journalism with one another, and there is a little bit of that setup here. But I think what's interesting is not the debate about whether or not journalists should be imprisoned, which I would hope most people in an open society would be an agreement about that.
But why are things becoming so much more dangerous around the world, and what are the forces that are creating this jeopardy for what used to be a profession that didn't enjoy total immunity, nor should it be accountable. But it wasn't subject to this kind of pressure, and how the forces of populism and the kind of delegitimization of journalism has moved from the emerging world now to the White House. Well, we get to him in a minute. He does demand attention.
He does. I mean, it's amazing if we can go on and show that I mentioned the T-wood. But no, we will not be able to. Just on that point of, I agree with you, I think this is an inflection point in this whole debate, and we just had a press freedom summit in Sydney.
Very important subject. We also have, interestingly, I'm interested in your take on this, but in this country, at the very least, we seem to have the attention of the policymakers. You may have a couple of inquiries happening into press freedom following these raids in Australia. Do you feel like the, which do you think that we are in the cycle?
Is it turning our way at all, or is it the wrong way? I think in the US it's inseparable from the departures from norms represented by the Trump administration. And at the same time, the problem of kind of creeping assertion of government power over journalism predates Trump during the Obama administration, there was a record number of prosecutions of journalists sources compared to the previous administrations going right back to Nixon. And toward the end of the Obama administration, they kind of straightened themselves out a little bit and made some declarations that they were going to go back to a more liberal approach to these things.
But this has been going on before Trump, and I don't think it's going in the right direction, because there are two things. There's the black letter law. What does the government empower to do? What do judges decide in particular cases?
But then there's the politics. There's the environment of public opinion. What do you think you can get away with? And I think a lot of what's troubling now is really more in the second category, that politicians, national leaders, populists feel that they can get away with things that their predecessors wouldn't have thought to dare to do, even if it crossed their minds.
So where do we fix that? Because we can sit around and all our peers and colleagues can talk around the importance of free press and for democracy and such like. But if it's not resonating with the politicians and all their voter base, how do we get change? How do we stop it?
Well, I think elect enlightened leaders would be one strategy. But it's a complicated picture in the US. We sit on the Pulitzer board, whoever has my jobs, it's on that board. And so you see all the journalism that's coming forward from around the country.
And the paradox is that in the US, there's a renaissance of investigative reporting that really makes a difference in red states, in Trump land. For example, the whole need to movement in the United States wouldn't have happened without investigative reporting. The institutions, the prosecutors who always say, trust us, we got it, we don't need an investigative press. They failed all of those victim survivors of these institutions, individuals.
And there's a recognition across the country that investigative reporting was absolutely vital to bring some of these serial predators to justice. And in Louisiana, which is as Trumpias, there was an investigation done by the advocate in Baton Rouge about a peculiar practice of allowing majority jury verdicts rather than unanimous jury verdicts in felony murder cases. And they demonstrated how much injustice had arisen from this. And as a result, a Republican governor and a Republican legislature responded to this investigation and changed the law.
It's a huge thing. So there's still a recognition that investigative journalism matters. You're on the, so you've been brought here by the Judith Nielsen Institute for Journalism and Ideas and you're on the international advisory. And we've had the Institute's boss might run on the show recently.
And I did ask him one slightly pointy question, which was whether Rupert Murdoch needed money from a philanthropist like Judith Nielsen. So as you probably aware, the first round of grants went out to mainly mainstream news organizations, not only but mainly, including to Rupert's newspaper, the Australian. So I mean, really, does Rupert need a leg up? Well, this is our first meeting.
So I haven't really, yeah. I'm putting a brief in. But I think I recognize the instinct to try to launch an institution like this in such a polarized climate with some sense that there is a kind of a range of credible journalism that you need to be including and you're thinking about how to strengthen journalism. Whether you make this grant or that grant, that's not for advisory board member judge.
But I think in the US, it's particularly difficult to find a way to defend journalism without stepping into some kind of hyper-partisan polarized conversation. And Rupert Murdoch's properties like Fox News are part of the problem. So I don't, I wouldn't recommend grant making to Fox News, for example, as part of a nice strategy or bright part. But you have to recognize that, you know, there is, for example, there's a conservative press in the United States that is quite skeptical of Trump and that doesn't get the attention in sort of media circles that it deserves.
And I read it, I find it actually quite valuable because it's a way of thinking about change in the Republican Party in the era of politics. Because of his values and in efforts to them. Yeah, I mean, they're genuinely conservative. They're not populist.
They're also internationalist. They're not America First. They believe in trade. All that sort of thing.
They're not just a transactional politician. Yeah. Yeah. One of the ways we want, I suspect, to look at Trump is that he's good for journalism, which is kind of what you've just been saying, right?
So we talked endlessly about the Trump bump, you know, increases subs for the New York Times, watch posts, New Yorkers, etc. We, we, you know, I brought a political fact here in 2013, and the fact checkers are doing an amazing job. So every time Trump talks, but fact news, you get fact checked and reaffirms the role of journalism. So that's the positive, right?
I mean, we're doing the job. Is it just a question of volume? It's just a question not to be able to keep up with him because he's remarkable. The speed and the use of Twitter and all that.
I mean, well, he's quite, quite skillful really at doing what he does, which is to own the conversation, to disrupt the institutions that are opposed to him to counter attack against any criticism, whether it's journalism or from another source. He's a counter puncher and an extraordinary media magnet. And the paradox with him and the press, of course, which everybody recognizes, except perhaps himself, though, you know, maybe he's more self-aware than than he seems. Yeah.
But is that he needs the media desperately? He lives for the media. He's a much more kind of affirmative media consumer and media player than prior presidents who found it just, you know, a burden on their work. He's in the way.
Yeah, he's inside the bubble. And you can see, as we go into 2020, he's, you know, he's reverting to his natural instinct, which is to be available to everybody who wants to interview him all the time. So he's, he stopped locking out the major networks, especially on television. He just wants to be on television all the time.
He's letting the major networks back in to interview him. And so, you know, it's a, it's cynical, it's damaging. It is, it is, it is creating, I think, long term damage to the fabric of the American democratic system. But, you know, it's not all what it seems to be because he is himself a creature of the press as much as an opponent of the press.
You wrote recently about the Mueller report in, in the New Yorker. And there was two, two great points I thought were the other more discussion. The, the one point was that the reams of accurate reporting about Mueller's investigation and the allegations of Russian interference may have created an outside expectation. You know, so, I mean, I'm not sure what the antidote to that is, but nonetheless, I think it's an interesting point that the, the journalist, in a way he created this sense, oh, he's going to be impeached or something.
And obviously that hasn't happened. I mean, where does journalism talk about that, with that kind of basically shooting itself in the foot? Yeah. I mean, I think there was, I guess the distinction I was trying to draw was between the professional reporting about what Mueller's team was actually doing.
What were they investigating? What were they discovering? What could journalists independently uncover in parallel to the investigators' work to describe the facts about Russian involvement in the election and whether or not the Trump campaign was complicit with a Russian propaganda or, you know, sort of active measures campaign. And so that, that reporting was turned out to be almost entirely verified by the Mueller findings once they were published.
But then you had something else going on, which was not reporting. It was talking. All of the news networks with their panels, hyper-partisan panels just blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And that's where the expectations built up.
And, you know, you have these news networks that are increasingly identified with, you know, political points of view and especially in, in, on the networks that were identified with the opposition to Trump. You know, there was this, this almost emotional, deep spiritual need for this investigation to lead to the end of the Trump presidency, which was entirely unrealistic throughout, because even if Mueller had found impeachable offenses that he regarded as impeachable offenses described as such and referred them to the House, they would never have been able to convict him in the Senate until 2020. The only way you're going to ever remove Trump realistically was by defeating him in election. And smart people on these networks should have understood.
That should have tempered the chat, chat, chat about impeachment with these facts, but they didn't. Why? Because engagement makes money. You know, we're in an age where, you know, you're not looking for broad audiences.
You're looking for deeply engaged audiences and where you can touch people where their political convictions lie, then that's a form of business strategy, frankly, to drive ratings, to drive subscriptions. And it's not good, I think, for journalism. No, it's not good. And one of the foundation quotes of journalism is attributed to Charles Presswick from the Manchester Guardian in the 19th century to see the, so it's a sea life steady.
The journalist's job is to see life steady and to see it whole. Yeah. Are we not doing that? I mean, it seems to me, what you're talking about is a lot of us are writing privileging opinion of effects and not seeing the life steady or nor seeing it whole.
We're losing our sense of proportion. I agree with that. And I think it's, I'd see it as a function of business problems as much as anything else, at least in the US, because in newspapers, the loss of advertising to Google and Facebook, the broken advertising markets, even the digital advertising markets are just not functioning in a way that could sustain journalism. And so the alternative is subscription.
You mentioned it before. In order to drive subscription, you really need readers who are engaged. Yeah, you need your base. And what they're finding is that readers who are willing to pay for journalism want opinion.
They want more and more opinion. And so if you pull up your app on your, on your phone, if you're a subscriber to the New York Times or Washington Post, you'll find quite a lot of opinion headlines. They're often labeled as opinion, but they're, they're right, they're ahead of the news headlines. And how can you expect people to distinguish between opinion and fact based reporting, especially when much of the reporting is itself couched in analytical framings and so forth, which can be helpful, can be appropriate.
But you know, the idea that we expect readers to understand the bright line between fact based reporting and opinion and to justify ourselves as, you know, scientific method driven in different evidence based reporters. It's a fantasy. No wonder they're confused. So it's, I hope that we will find a way around this corner so that audiences are willing to pay for news.
But what they really want is reporting. Yeah, because you ask audiences, of course, they will often say, you know, they will turn it, they'll say, Oh, yeah, what facts and what evidence? Yes. And as you say, even though really they're basically picking their facts, you know, what's happening.
So what we need a new business model or models. Where do you see hope that reaffirms the role of reporting and evidence based, you know, factual reporting? Well, I think today the view is that the only way forward is through subscription. And there are some, you know, subscription services that do privilege fact based reporting and a kind of impartiality or fairness over opinion.
And they are succeeding. I think where the problem lies in the US is at the regional level and the local level, you know, the national media, there's diverse national media that are thriving in a business sense. They have large newsrooms. Some of them, I think, are drifting towards kind of partisan strategies, but they're still highly professional and impactful.
But you know, around the country, you know, in Des Moines or Detroit or Nashville or Dallas, the decline of local newspapers has not been reversed. And subscription is the strategy now, but it's nascent and it hasn't been proven out yet. It really hurts the fabric of those communities to lose locally based reporting. And we're seeing a similar trend here, not that extent yet, but we generally lag two or three years behind the US.
But we do see the same trend here. I mean, I think regional and local is where we have to spend a lot of attention. I don't have a simple answer either. And it goes to this question of credibility too, I think, because when you're living in Indianapolis and you're reading challenging stories about corruption or about abuse of power, but they're done by reporters and editors that send their kids to the same school, that go to church on Sunday that you can see in the supermarket that it comes from the community.
The evidence is, social science evidence, that that journalism is more trusted. But if you have someone parachuting in from the New York Times or your only take on the news is coming from the two coasts, you know, of course you're going to be alienated from that in some respects. So we need to put more journals in the community and spread to cover it. And there are some sort of projects around that sort of idea.
Yeah, there are some nonprofits, but you know, sometimes you feel like you're just throwing pebbles in the ocean. In nonprofit journalism, I mean, is that, I mean, there's a lot of it in the US and there is here. Is that the cause for hope? It's definitely a problem again.
It's a scale issue, but it's becoming significant now. It has crossed the kind of threshold from being a sort of seed experiment to being a significant force in American journalism. There are national outlets like Republica that are very impactful and very well-resourced at this point. And a lot of these regional nonprofits that have started up have proved to be sustainable and influential.
There's one in Texas that Texas is very significant. And they've proven that they can make it work, too, over a period of years. So I think that's going to be part of the landscape for an indefinite time. And I'm glad that it is.
You know, there's no reason why philanthropy in the United States is tax advantaged in a way that isn't in many places in the world. And so there's always a fair amount of philanthropy that's being directed at one thing or another. But why not journalism a healthy public square in addition to symphonies and opera companies and that sort of thing? Yeah.
Well, that's a debate we're sort of trying to have here. I don't know, to what extent you called out with the ACCC report, where there was the competition watchdog here, a massive study of the influence of Google and Facebook in essence on the news media. It came up with some recommendations, one, which goes to the heart, I think, of what a lot of journalists are concerned about, which is the money that's gone out of the industry and ended up with Google and Facebook because they're more efficient at advertising than say news media industry. Let's face it.
But one of the ones essentially that they've given the platforms, one of the recommendations was that the platforms now have nine months to work out with the news media industry how, quote unquote, it treats the news media industry fairly. And if it doesn't, there's going to be a big stick in the Google and Facebook and it knocked over the head. What do you think of that idea? Well, I listened on the radio while I've been here to, I think the leader of the ACCC talking about this.
And he sounded a bit cautious about what the standard would be. And so it sort of sounded a little bit like maybe he was just trying to create some space for the companies to do the right thing. But in the US, our experience is that the companies manage these problems like public relations problems and that they engage, they throw a little money at it to try to buy goodwill, but structural reform that would really change the equation between publishers and platforms has been elusive. And it's not really in their corporate interest to restructure in the ways that would really make a difference.
And so I think it's unrealistic to expect that they will. And the kind of window dressing that they've been doing, we tend to interpret it as just image management because they are under pressure. And it's PR and they're trying to stay, it's more than PR, they're trying to stave off regulation. And the only place where they really have been hit with regulation that hurts is in Europe.
And so as the European regime evolves, then perhaps there will be models that can be imported from that into the US. We're not as privacy focused as the Europeans are, but we are certainly interested in restructuring. And I think now there's a bit of a movement on any trust in the US that had been absent during the Obama years. And the first amendment that was interesting, I was spent quite a bit of time with Google a few months ago.
And of course, at the heart of what they do say in terms of say YouTube and spreading things that people will find to say. So if not hateful, it's a sort of argument that well, the first amendment gives everyone the power to say what they like. Yeah, I mean, that's one way to advocate responsibility for being a publisher. I mean, the problem is that they want it both ways.
They want to be a neutral platform where everyone can say what they want and at the same time, they don't want any regulation. And so... Do you think of them as publishers? I do.
Yeah, I think they are publishers. They don't believe that they are. They don't want to be publishers because being a publisher would come with responsibilities that would require them to curate and edit material on their platforms to an extent that they've been unwilling to do. But one of the arguments against not making them publishers but making them something else, like a third category is in this country and yours, as a publisher, you get certain rights.
You get responses, yes, but you also get certain rights. So rights around the defamation and such like and privacy and one thing, and I guess the argument is do we really actually want to give Facebook and Google the same rights as journalism? No, it's a fair question. I mean, watch what you wish for.
You don't want Facebook and Google deciding what constitutes acceptable speech and already as they've tried to address the very real problems of hate speech and incitement to violence and other pollution on their platforms, they're engineers. And so their solution is almost always another algorithm. And then the algorithm picks up things that shouldn't and repress the speech and there's really no redress for those who are hurt by that. But as a First Amendment problem, Google and Facebook are peculiar because First Amendment protects Americans from government repression of speech.
It doesn't really speak to corporate control. And this is a kind of quasi-public entity. These networks have become like a public square, but they're not a government. So asking them to cease and desist or asking them to take responsibilities just to be complicated compared to if the prosecutors were coming around saying, sorry, you can't publish that article tomorrow.
So is one answer to all that some sort of form greater transparency around the algorithms? Yes, that would be a very good place to start, absolutely. And none of these companies has been, especially for coming, but Facebook has been particularly difficult around that. And it was one of the earlier, the ACCC put out a draft report and where it suggested a kind of algorithm cancel.
That's what some sort of thing. Bring your algorithm and then we'll have a poke around. That didn't actually make it to the final report because I think transparency of the algorithm would be obviously a great benefit to the news media industry. Yeah.
And the idea of being warned when they were going to change the algorithm, I mean, that has caused all sorts of problems as you know. But how practical is this? I don't know. Maybe I'm not an expert.
I worry that we're kind of, I think these are all the right ideas, but I worry that we're nibbling around the edges of a structural monopoly problem. The publishers and news organizations have lost control of their distribution and they've lost it to a monopoly that isn't really aligned with the promotion of the interests of these publishers. And although they willingly gave that over, well, they did in desperation and confusion after the digital revolution. And of course, you know, the companies aren't responsible for the fact that there was a technological revolution.
We sort of invite that and we organize our society. Yeah. We should have been in Facebook. I mean, that's the thing is well, that's true.
That would have fixed it. We wouldn't be talking about this. That's true. Anyway, we didn't.
Let's talk about your day job because you do run one of the most prestigious journalism colleges in the world. I'm assuming demand Colombia is holding up pretty well. It's holding up. It's holding up just fine.
And we have a full employment economy that we compete with, but we're doing just fine. I think the thing about students arriving, we're just a graduate school. So if you come here, you know, you're you're choosing this as a profession. And the change that I've seen, this is I'm starting my seventh year now.
And the change that I've seen is really more about attitude, which is has benefited from the Trump effect prior to 2016 in this kind of new digital journalism universe and social media universe. I found that's not most, but a significant number of young people coming to graduate school were kind of confused about what journalism was anymore. And very sort of involved with themselves. Sometimes you'd have a student with say a scholarship donor and donor would ask, why did you come to Columbia?
They'd say, because I wanted to tell my story and I would just die a little bit inside. Unless you swam here from Guyana, I'm not interested in your story. We're interested in everyone else's stories. And that's all gone.
You know, Trump has cleaned all that up. Really? If you know, now everyone's sitting up paying attention, they know what kind of a world they're in. And they have questions.
If you know, I'm a journalist of color and I'm supposed to go cover a white racist rally, how do I stay? Say, who do I interview? Okay, that's a good question. We can we have answers to that question.
But it's a different environment and people are purposeful, I think, in a way that I find inspiring. Yeah, that's that's a wonderful thing to hear. How many students do you take? About 170 of them in programming.
It's small. It's elite. Yes. Well, it's, you know, we have a network of alumni that numbers I think something like 12,000 and they basically are in every newsroom in the world.
And if you know, there's a there's a big fire and a bunch of journalists gathered outside of it waiting to go on the air to write up a story. You'll find there's five or six Columbia grads there from different classes. It's quite a powerful network and very important one. You ever thought about opening up a branch in this country?
You know, we have partnerships with other universities. So maybe after a podcast we can talk about it. That's usually the way we do things globally. We have a relationship with Cinco's Poe that's very good.
And you know, the journalism education in the US is a little bit different from the way it's typically organized around the world even in Europe. I don't know so much about Australia. But you know, and then there's the calendar and all of that. But yeah, I mean, we're a global institution.
A third of our students come from outside the United States. Oh, you have many Australian students. I know. Yeah.
It strengthens our program to have those kind of partnerships. Yeah. Yeah. Okay.
Well, let's get off the air and go that breakfast. I think we can talk forever. What's your advice to anyone considering studying journalism? Well, I think it's valuable in today's world because there isn't the mentoring and the stability in long careers that there used to be.
And so journalism education was always a way to get launched and to learn how to go out and do the work you really want to do. But now I think it's relatively more valuable because the kinds of internship programs and the 30-year careers at stable institutions, that's just not the landscape in media. It's not the landscape in a lot of industries. But to me, the main thing that I tell the students to come to Columbia is you're never going to have an opportunity to work closely with so many passionate diverse experience journalists to develop your own methodologies.
And one of the things that's so great about journalism is that it's a profession you can succeed from so many starting places if you're willing to put the work in. It's not like you need a surgeon's hands or a mathematician's brain or something. If you put the work in, if you don't mind talking to strangers and you're determined, you can get there. But it does take some learning.
And so really, it's like everything else, just put the work in, take advantage of the time. And you'll find that it is something that you can learn pretty quickly within a year or so. You can be pretty fully equipped as an entry-level journalist. No, I agree.
Grad's very wise words. Steve Cole, thank you so much for your time. Ian of Columbia, Grad School Journalism, New York, a writer, and so much more. Thank you so much for your time.
Have a great day in Australia. I'd like to be here. Thanks for having me. And thank you all for listening to The Fourth Estate.
This edition was recorded at the studios of Twircea and heard across the country on the community radio network or your own time and your own leisure on your podcast app of your choosing. Make sure you're subscribed to The Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app. So you can hear us talk about media and politics and all sorts of things in between. We'll be back with more next week.
But in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter where our handle is Fourth Estate AU. And thank you very much to my producer, Anthony Dochrall. My name is Peter Frey. Thank you very much for listening.