A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails that keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.
That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca. Pay for by the Government of Ontario.
Hello and welcome. You are listening to Fourth Estate, coming to you from the Sydney studios of 2SER on the Galigal lands of the Orr Nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network, around the world on a podcast listing device of your choosing. My name is Peter Frey and I'm the co-director of the Centre for Media Transition at UTS and my producer tonight is Anthony Dockro. And tonight we have a special podcast event with Catherine Murphy, the political editor of The Guardian Australia, who has produced a magnificent tone called On Disruption, all about disruption in the news media sector.
Thanks for coming Catherine. Thanks for having me Peter. And why on earth are we talking to you? Well that is the question, isn't it?
We are talking to Catherine Murphy, who I must say I've known as Merff for about 30 years or whatever however, however long. Yes, 300 years. Because she's written what is perhaps a deceptively slight tone, but I am here to assure you that it's a very powerful tone. It's kind of an essay obviously, it's Catherine Murphy on disruption, it's part of an MUP series of ons.
Ons, ons, ons, ons. Small and perfectly formed. This one is purple and as Evie McGuire has just said, it reminds us a little bit of the little book of calm, but it is not calm. Definitely there's a dystopian side.
There is, that's your dystopian warning. It's sort of part memoir, part confession and I think in part are called to arms. So the simple question first, Merff is did you enjoy writing it? I did.
Why? Because I really needed to say it and it's sort of the sum of many thoughts I've had over the last few years. I've had this little book more or less in my head in various forms. So it's always hard to write something even though it is a modest time, it's only 15,000 words, something like that.
It's always, the act of writing is never stress free, but I wrote it fairly quickly because as I said, I had a very clear idea about what I wanted to say and broadly how I wanted to say it. And I really wanted, I suppose, to take the conversation that you and I have about what's happening in our industry to a wider audience. And the call to arms, I think, as you said, is absolutely right in my mind. I want to have a conversation with news consumers that we would normally really just indulge amongst ourselves.
I think you achieved that. So congratulations. Thank you. We're going to get around to some of those issues very soon.
You'll listen to the Fourth Estate special with Katherine Murphy, the author of a new essay in a book form called On Disruption Part of a Series by MUP. I don't necessarily wish to do this interview as a chronology to keep pace with the book, but let's go back to where more or less you start. So not the image of you turning up to work on your first day in a sports craft suit, tempting as that maybe, but at the juncture of two things, in a sense, the start of the death of the print era of journalism and that's seminal change in Australian politics, the end of the whole Keating governments and the election of John Howard. So let's do the politics first.
You paint a picture at the end of the Keating era as a journalist crying on election night, which I think if you were a consumer, that is a bit of a confronting issue of the image. But you make the point that the journalist, the unnamed journalist, is not crying out of partisanship, not crying because Labour's lost, but in the knowledge that much of their working life and how they iterate that working life was about to end. A lovely quote. When a government changes, a small universe explodes.
So that dynamic, that symbiosis, especially in the press gallery is very little understood from the outside and not often discussed with such candor. So praise to you for writing about it. Tell me, is that relationship a good or bad thing or just the way things have to be? The proximity of it you may know.
Well, the nature. So here's someone who's, you know, I think it's summed it up beautifully. There's someone who's crying on election night because, all those ministers, all those contacts have been washed out to see. Well, it's sort of, it's a big thing when a government changes.
If I understand that because obviously when there is a change of government, it is a big event in the country. It's not just a big event in my little ecosystem, but everywhere. That, yes, it's such a good question. I don't know why that woman was crying.
You didn't stop laughing. I didn't stop laughing. I was busy. I was busy when I ran.
But it is, there is this sense of dislocation. There is this sense that because governments in Australia generally last more than one term, two terms, three terms, four terms sometimes, there is this whole investment in storytelling and working life, connections with people and understanding of a government's rhythm, tempo, all of that. That's a big investment. That's a very big investment you make.
And then all of a sudden it's broken and all of that investment has to start again and you have to find your own level, your own tempo, new relationships, all of that sort of things. So it's quite a visceral thing to happen. And me describing it in that way was sort of setting readers up for a big technological change that was coming at us down the pipe. We couldn't even see them, Peter.
We didn't even know what was happening. We thought it would never end. The party would go on forever. We thought it was so much of a party.
But we didn't know it was a party until we got back and saw the party. Exactly. And we didn't know what was coming. But in terms of the relationship between political journalists and politicians, well, does it have to be the way it is?
Well, no. No, it is changing. It is changing. Yes, it is changing in a lot of different ways.
I had a conversation with Michelle Gratton last week, actually, around some of these issues. And obviously, long-standing political journalists for folks who don't know. No, no, no, no. If folks who don't know, Michelle can't imagine anyone, but just in case you don't know Michelle, she's a press gallery news paper journalist of many decades.
And we end quite. And we sort of I think came to a mutual position that in a funny way, the relationship between political journalists and politicians has been drawn a bit in the digital age. In some respects, we're closer because we monitor each other in the digital sphere in a way that we didn't do quite intensely. We might sort of track son of age digital footprints on a beach.
We watch each other very closely. But we're not thrown together quite as organically as we were in the old days. So we're closer yet more distant, which is a funny sort of concept to try and explain, but it is nonetheless true. For example, I was remembering that one of the tricks Michelle taught me when I was very young in the sports craft suit in the IFR Bureau was that if a minister wasn't returning your call, that you would literally go down to the ministerial office, sit in the foyer until such a time as a minister came out.
And that was retained. We did that all the time. No, I would do that now. It's a shame in the way, isn't it?
It's a good thought. I mean, I'd agree that again, you're too carried away with the misty eyes sort of nature that is actually getting the job done. No, no, exactly. It was an ideal way to get the job because literally the minister couldn't walk past you without obviously being there.
But that's a combination of different things. They're busier. We're busier. The security in the building is different.
The building is locked down more than it used to be. And the way we communicate with one another has been redrawn by technology just as the way the way journalists and readers communicate with each other is being redrawn. No, absolutely. Just before we leave the sports craft suit, then we will leave it right now.
In my head is to be the health of everyone. It's green, but I suspect it's not green. No, it's green, it's green. It's what?
Green. Forest green. Forest green. I don't even say blue.
And much of the book is about lifting the hood. I suppose lifting the hood and you use a great card analogy later on in the book or middle on in the book and explaining about what goes on and why. And why is it so interesting? Why you thought it was so important to have this kind of confessional element?
Is confession, if you like, a prerequisite for understanding disruption? No, it's not. And I had actually wanted in the first instance to do a companion piece to an essay that I wrote last year for a publication called Me Engine Quarterly, which was about political life. And I interviewed former Cabinet Minister Greg Convey, a long-term liberal backbench of Mel washer, a long-term Labor staffer, and I sort of did almost like a documentary about their life to try and explain to people why politics seems to have gone off the rails.
Rather than standing outside that phenomenon and throwing rocks at it, which is what we do, justifiably, that's our job, when you talk about lifting up the hood, I wanted with that piece to try and interrogate what was going on behind the scenes in order to better explain why politics is manifesting in the way that it did. So I wanted to- There's that kind of concept in your head. I had it in my head. Yes.
So that's what I wanted to do. And I wanted to actually approach us in the same way, because I always knew I was coming back to us and by us, I'm in journalists. So in my head, I was going to do a similar exercise. I was going to decant the contents of various people's heads and have a sort of more reported piece.
But a lot of people, well, a lot of people, people I asked weren't all that keen, really, to be interviewed on the record. And not so much because they felt there was some great secret they had to keep, but more their feeling was we're stealing transition. We're stealing flux. I'm not certain that I would have much sort of cut through value to share at this point.
We will be in transition possibly forever. Well, possibly for at least for another decade and probably beyond that. And that was reasonable. So then I thought, oh, OK, well, rather than drop it, I thought, well, my experience of this is as valid as anybody else's.
And I was a sort of early adopter in digital. And I would, I couldn't rate my own perspective. So I thought, well, I'll do it that way. It wasn't actually my first choice.
It was my second choice. But there's a bit of power, I think, though, in narrating your own story, because when I build up to various propositions in this essay, where I really do want to grab the reader by the lapels and say, look, listen up, there's some really big things going on here that would be really good if you grappled with or started to think about. There's a power in telling your own story as well as telling the story of others. So I sort of adjusted into it, if that makes sense.
It works. It works. Just one of the big things, one of those lapel grabbing moments is really when we get to Trump, who, as you say, is a leader who absolutely understands and exploits the digital news media cycles, need for constant crisis and incessant conflict. So Trump is playing journos at their own game, right?
I mean, there's Karl Palpen, who quoted him in the book, says, who's from the Colombian journalist, and who says, you know, Trump has turned up to be the assignment editor for reporters. So is this this moment where, or do those journalism in a way, is journalism in suck it in? And are we by being suck it in kind of complicit in, if you like, the Trump madness? And I guess the question is, is there an alternative to this?
Well, the answer to the first two questions is yes to both. Yes, absolutely yes. Is there an alternative? There's not an easy alternative.
This is the difficulty. We've got, with the Trump phenomenon, and we could translate this experience to Australian politics as well, but it's not as visceral. It's a tug of war. But let's just say it was Trump because that's kind of easy.
And he's an outlier. He is. But he's a good case study to work these things through. So he basically, the genius of Trump in the disruptive media environment is that he plays journalists at our own game.
He basically picks up the fact that our craft is about bearing witness, observing, reporting what important people say. And fundamentally news is about conflict, particularly political news, which is basically the battle of ideas, rendered in journalistic form. So he's very, very masterful at understanding those dynamics and turning them back on ourselves. Now, is there an easy answer?
Well, no, it's the problem because you get into a position as a journalist where, you know, do you play sensor? Do you not report what somebody says because you know you're being played? Well, well, sometimes sometimes, yes, but you can't do it all the time. And if we sort of seek to set ourselves up as an omniscient type figure with perfect wisdom on when we will censor and when we won't, I think that's the time for news consumers to worry about us, right?
So that's a genuinely vexed and difficult question. When do you turn the volume down on an important person? Well, I think the answer is you have to do it. I don't think we can shy away from doing it.
I think you do have to do it. I think you have to be or we have to be as practitioners in this age, enormously self-aware of our own craft and also of self-aware about the capacity for gaming of our own craft. And as you say, Trump is the master of gaming, the gaming, everyone here. I mean, just talk about our own country for a second.
Well, two things. One is a broader question. So the conflict model of journalism, the kind of he said she said the battering of the ball across the net all the time, which is kind of in a way that's still a life-stocking trade. Do you think that that's wearing a bit thin with people?
I think it's fatiguing audiences in a big way. I think two things that I'm very conscious of in the current environment is the bombardment of the new with the audience that literally people are drowning in content and it's shooting at them at an enormous velocity. And when that happens, one of the things I'm most worried about in the current environment is this equal and opposite reaction among readers to switch down switch off. Get out of there, fall back to resting predispositions rather than facts.
I feel this might be the case and it's too complicated and the landscape is too cluttered to work through that factually in an evidence-based way. So that's a really troubling phenomenon. But yeah, I think we've got to be incredibly attentive about burnout of not only ourselves but our audiences that we are literally throwing too much at people. And I think we've seen actually in the more recent manifestations of digital, this sort of more consolidating phase.
I think things are turning down ever so slightly in terms of, I think, I think. I mean, one of the things you get to in the book is quite a dark spot and you kind of take a sound and you open the door and you go, oh my God, it's so dark. And there's a couple of months in the book that are quite dark. And then I won't be in the plot line forever but you do pull this back a little bit.
But there is a dark moment in the book where you kind of raise the question is kind of journalism and political journalism in particular at risk of kind of losing its position, its value. Right? So this is a really scary moment. It is.
It's about as existential as it is. It's about as existential as it is. It's about as existential as it is. The Pack of Christ called full-down.
Yeah, it is. So again, and there are no easy answers and you sort of help us through a point of story of you in the book but what can we do? I mean, if you were talking to your younger self or my younger self, what would you tell you? Well, I would tell you that there are no easy answers and I can't give you fake reassurance that somehow we'll get through this intact serving the public interest, doing everything will be marvellous somehow at the end of this line.
I can't tell you that because I don't know whether that's true or not and I wouldn't insult your intelligence by giving you false comfort. But one thing I suppose, what enables me to pull back from my own existential terror is that fundamentally I still believe in what we do. I think it's important and I think at its best it changes things. It makes things better.
I still believe that there is truth even in an age where it's harder and harder to determine what the truth is. But I believe truth exists. I believe it exists. Well, I think we have to believe that.
Well, I think it's true. And I think journalism fundamentally is the art of serving the truth. It helps, yes, seeking the truth. Seeking the truth.
Exactly. So I think the only way to get through is trying to project those enduring values into the new environment. And if the old values clash with the new environment, the problem might be the new environment. It might not be the projection of the old values.
So then it's a matter of experimenting in new forms in order to find a level where those values work in the new environment. I mean, that's the fundamental driver of the trans... The positive driver in the transition, right? To use the harness technology but remain true to the eternal values.
Yes. Well, I think so. And it's not easy. And I'm not saying that anybody does it perfectly.
I don't know anyone who does it perfectly. I certainly don't. But I do shy up every day with that intention. And as long as we shy up every day with that intention and we do more good than harm, then we're holding our own in a very, very difficult and challenging period, I think.
Again, I wish I could cure cancer for everyone here this evening, but I can't. So it's... Very later. Maybe after dinner.
After dinner. So just while we're talking about Trump, and I'm not going to think this is my last mention, but I'm interested in Trump and his manipulation. Or his understanding means very, very clear understanding of what makes us a lot tick. Is there anyone not talking about political ideology so much as technique in our body, political bodies?
Is there anyone who comes anywhere near that? Well, we have echoes of it. I think sort of... And you'd never say Trump or a Trumpian character wouldn't work in the Australian political society, but you would never have that confidence.
There are material differences, obviously, between... I'm talking about the kind of understanding of the media, so not so much as... Yes, as the conditions that create the demagogue. Yeah, no, it's different.
Yeah, I think we see experiments with it a lot. Certainly that sort of post-truth politics, the high conflict politics. I mean, this might be a silly example, but the story that dominated the political week last year, last year, last week. Last week, I don't even know what century.
I mean, David Leanhelm. Right. And the handsome young thing is, in a way it's a perfect case study of the disrupted major environment, what works and what doesn't. In that instance, we are reporting a real thing, it's their hands and young and workplace harassment.
We're reporting a cultural moment, which is quite profound. Women, you know, having a gutful of this crap and sort of saying, well, once in very loud and forceful terms, we've really had a gutful of this crap. That's an important cultural moment that you need to market. But in terms of this death match that then ensued between the two protagonists, David Leanhelm was kind of narrow casting for all he was worse.
You know, there are votes, there are votes in thinking that you can say whatever you like to women and not apologiseing for it. And we, in the news media, amplified that. Yeah, absolutely. And then of course, this guy knew this thing as well.
Absolutely. And then we can get out-raged about the amplification. Exactly. And see, this is the thing.
I suppose, okay, now we've reached the threshold here because it's sort of the, there is a point of extremism in this kind of media market where it's heads we win, tails we win, right? You can know that this is a massive kind of media moment, which it was. I mean, the traffic, I know, on the Guardian for these stories was massive and I think for every organisation, right? Because everybody's interested, it's a water cooler story.
So you can, actually, if you're really uber-cinecal in the modern media environment, have a little bit of this at every stage, you can cover the opening, you can cover the high conflict thing, then you can do the end cycle, basically criticising everybody for covering it, right? Like if you uber-cinecal. As you say. Well, heads we win tails, we win tails, but who loses is the consumer of news.
And tell me about them. And did you, but that's a great example, even though it's, you know, it's a stupid story, but in a way, did you get, or do you get the sense from the audience? Because a lot of the book, actually, when you start pondering the positives, is that the relationship between journalists and the audience has changed completely, you're relatively, will never be the same, will never be this distant thing we had in the past. So when you get a handsome young Leonholm spat like that, do you get the feedback from the readers that say, hang on, enough already?
Yes. And yet we continue. Well, it's sort of, it's a funny thing because there's this proliferation in live coverage because people want things called live. That's why it happens, because there's a massive audience for it.
In a story like that, you get massive traffic for it. Everybody's reading about it, talking about it, wants to know the next iteration of it. Yet, for, I suppose, media consumers that are more attentive to the dynamics in the environment, you also get pushback from those readers and consumers. I don't want to hear any more about this.
You're just amplifying conflict. You're just feeling the circus. I had to do with the square that circle. Well, it's hard.
Yeah. I mean, one of the very personal parts in the book is where you talk about exactly what we're talking about now, which is, you know, the rise of the flimsy, intraday, insight, badge, is exclusive. You know, it's February, it's shouty, it's superficial, it's shallow. Yeah.
And, you know, as you say, some days you basically have to go and take a walk up and chat to the winds because it's unbearable. Yeah, it is unbearable. So it's unbearable what you're doing. Yeah.
Only sometimes. No, no, it can be. Right. Yeah.
OK, so isn't there a bunch of signals saying, yeah, let's not do it anymore? No, thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
Thank you for not taking any. Thank you. Yes, we're getting signals that we need to think about how we do it differently and how I suppose we've had this big, big technological disruption. We've had where we basically had to relearn our jobs in front of a live audience.
That's what's happened. We've just had to be entirely different kind of news commodifiers for one of a better term in full public view. Now, I think we are genuinely in a settling phase with all of this. Obviously, the technology is going to keep coming.
It's going to keep challenging us. It's going to keep challenging our business models. It's going to keep challenging the very fundamentals of our craft, whether or not people can believe that something is true or not true and all of that sort of stuff. Right?
All of that's going to keep coming at us. I don't think that it's the world suddenly going to stop. But I think we do have an opportunity in this consolidation phase to think through what works about the environment, what doesn't work about the environment, and also have already eye to the fact that we are potentially burning ourselves out and potentially burning our audiences out. Yes.
And it's an opportunity to think about how we go forward. Absolutely. And one of the things I think, you don't actually say this in the book, but it runs through it, I think, is this tendency for the news media for journalists to be perhaps a little bit too sentimental. Yeah.
Right? It was so great when. Yeah. It was so good when we didn't have Google and Facebook, see it in the right way.
It's not that much argument by that one way. But it's kind of like this idea of looking for already the villain in the piece. Yeah. When possibly the victim in the villain in the piece might be asked.
Well, definitely. It's, yeah, look, I don't look at the digital environment as a light. I don't want to smash my computer or my mobile phone or go back to newspapers. I'm sort of in my own practice.
I'm so beyond newspapers that I don't think I could ever go back to that static world. I just don't think I could. And I don't think I romanticize it in sort of documenting the last 10 years of it because I was sort of post-golden age. I believe journalism had a golden age, but I was only briefly there.
I was only briefly there. I was only very briefly there. I was only there. I was only there.
I was only there. Anyway, so it's not a matter of sentimentalising and that is stupid. It's more benchmarking what we did then versus what we did now and working out whether those differences are material and working out whether there is any merit in considering how we did things in the past and trying to do it in a similar fashion. Okay.
Well, let's go to a couple of those specifics. You're talking in the book about the idea of the general sense of voice of God being somewhat redundant, Morgan Freeman-esque moment. Thank God. Thank God if she's listening.
And the other one is that this questions that swirl around the word objectivity. Yes. But you don't actually use objectivity in the book management. You kind of get, you swirl around it.
And this whole concept which you cite Jay Rosen and others who talked about which is objectivity is a becoming a redundant concept because if I read it as nowhere we're coming from, why don't we just say, hey, we're journalists, we've done the best we can, but we think because we think this, we think this is how we should be reported. In other words, subjectivity, rather than objectivity because objectivity is becoming a bit of a useless thing to hang around our neck. So those two very specific things, voice of God and objectivity. If you correct me if I'm wrong, I think you're happy to kill off the voice of God.
Yep. But you want to hang on to objectivity. Well, not in some sort of, not in a false balance form. The only thing that's worse than voice of God in my head, which is the worst, as we've both identified, I'm not, I was never a fan and I'm glad to see the back of it.
In terms of objectivity, I prefer to think about verification rather than objectivity. It's a subtle distinction. But anyway, I don't want false balance. I do not, all things are created equal or stupid arguments can be lined up against sensible arguments and that's just the word of the law.
No, that's done. Leader on the ABC charter. How dare you say the false balance, factory? How dare you say that?
No, I don't. No, I really don't. You don't want to make a job? No, I absolutely respect the ABC.
No, I don't want that. I don't think it's helpful. But false subjectivity of the type that Rose and others talk about where it's just based on basically, confess your biases so everybody knows where you're coming from and then just get on with things. I don't think it works because there's a sort of, there's like a discipline in it.
Everybody's got values. Everybody's got a point of view. Everyone's got a world view to be ridiculous to suggest otherwise. Of course.
Right? But the discipline of journalism as a facts and evidence based craft is that you can get out of your own road. You can make the facts more important. Indeed, indeed.
And I think we would both, you know, we're going to both come from that strength of thought. Yeah. But Rose and this sort of saying, well, A, can you, but B, why should you? Because it's important.
Right. It's important to, it's more important to seek facts than anything is what we're really saying. It's, it's, it's, you've got to, it's all I can construct in my own mind is it's a mental discipline. I'm not saying that you, I mean, everybody approaches the facts and sort of refracts them through their values prism.
Right? So it's sort of in a way, we're kind of being a bit excessively binary here, obviously. We are. Obviously.
Obviously you bring your own values to it. Yes. Totally. Totally.
Totally. But I think, no, I do think there isn't really vital discipline in journalism, which is I don't think it's enough to say to the reader, look, I think my worldview is X. So I will just tell you what I think through the prism of my worldview. I don't think that's enough.
I don't think that serves the reader. I think what serves the reader is to try and put down your predispositions, walk into a situation, determine the facts based on the evidence and follow the facts and follow the evidence, whether or not that clashes with your worldview or whether or not it does. I still think that's important. And why I don't like objectivity as much as verification, it sort of comes back to that, right?
It's a process of go out to try to the best of your ability to determine what is true and share that with the reader. I mean, objectivity is in a way a deeper and broader concept than verification. And I think verification is a very handy concept for us. I mean, they've got to trust us for something right now.
Yeah. One thing that you talk about, one of the things we talk about a little bit here is this idea. You saw the internet age as a place to build a kind of campfire. You could have a conversation, a letter fire also ran up chat.
And in the book, you kind of extend that a little bit and suggest that, and then possibly the next step is for us to become, if you like, river guides in white water. You're a nice quote. So that left me feeling a little bit optimistic. What did you mean to do that?
Yeah, I did. Well, I'm not, at this stage, I'm not planning myself to go off and work in a dress shop. At this stage, when certainly not a sports rough shop, at this stage, I am planning to plow on in my own profession. And I'm not intending through this essay to compound a loss of faith in our institution.
That's really not my purpose. My purpose is to acknowledge the difficulties that we are currently going through in an honest and open way with the reader, with an objective of seeking a community of interest with the reader, which is, you know, that's the upside of digital for me, is that it creates this opportunity for journalism to renew its mandate in a community. You literally can go to a community in technology allows you to do that and to build a constituency with an audience in a way that we couldn't have done with prints because it's too remote. It's too remote from an audience.
I mean, audiences loved mastheads, you know, when you ran the City Morning Herald, I mean, how passionate is that audience? And when I worked for the age, how amazing are we passionate is that audience? I'm not saying that readers weren't connected to newspapers. Of course they were, absolutely.
But this is a more hands-on thing. This is more a bond that you can see. What's more personal things than that? I mean, you know the brands, as much as the website you went for the Guardian Australia?
Well, I think there's downsides to that. The upside of it is that you are there, you are accessible, you are open, you are accountable to your audience, and you are on a journey with your audience. And I don't say that in some sort of, you know, praise the unicorn sense. I mean, this is a hard job.
And knowing that you're not alone when you do it is incredibly consoling, actually, and important. And knowing that there are people out there who you annoy the crap out of, but also people who really support and encourage you in your mission is great. That's one of the upsides of digital. We should be a little bit upside on the digital.
Upside on the digital, yes. That's a good way to almost finish this wonderful interview. I wanted to touch before we left on the role of the platforms, and in particular, we have a nature of seeing where we're going on into the platforms, looking at their impact on journalism. And last week we had a special time with Henry Ergas, who's written a report commissioned by Google about the platforms impact on public interest journalism.
He uses a definition of public interest journalism to say in essence that there is no, you can't link the actual number of journalists working at any one time in this country with the output of public interest journalism. I was interested in what your thoughts were on that. He uses public interest journalism to mean journalism where the cost of doing it is not compensated by the public good it receives on the other side. So it's an essence of public good.
So he really talks a lot about investigative journalism. Now obviously you don't never get compensated for the investigative journalism. It is a public good. But he's also making this point.
It's interesting because you've written this essay on disruption. And part of that you cite the numbers that have been lost on journalists in this country. Henry doesn't worry about that. He thinks it's perfectly fine.
I'm interested in whether you think that there's less good journalism around as it were because we have fewer journalists. Well, it's not, I suppose Henry is correct to say that it's not. He's an economist, yes. Exactly.
Right. So just because there are more journalists around, if so fact I don't mean that there is better journalism around like that's a reasonable proposition to make. But no, the job losses and the character of the people who we lost in the transition, these are according to that new beat study for average age 49, two decades worth of experience on the job. And as someone who watched all of those people go with massive amounts of personal grief and anxiety, I know what we've lost.
I know what we've lost. So I don't really need someone to give me an abstract proposition about what we've lost doesn't mean anything because that's wrong. We've lost depth. And what also what I would really like people listening to be attentive to, because not many people think about this outside the industry.
But we really need news organisations to be able to operate at scale in order to protect our investigative function because just a simple economic proposition. The subjects of investigative journalism sue, they sue journalists. Those defamation suits are enormously expensive. The costs of the investigative journalism.
And in this country where we have very flimsy free speech protections in this country, people get sued all the time. If we do not have organisations that are able to operate at scale and defend their work and defend their own journalists, we will not have investigative journalism in this country. Do you get on that point and maybe to finish this one for a new view? Do you get the sense that the federal government is willing, I don't know what you just said, and be maybe willing to act to protect journalism in this country?
The difficulty I think that is facing governments now is because their own landscape as politicians has become so hyperpolar and also the media landscape has been cluttered with culture war and tribalism. I think it's increasingly difficult for governments to stand up for a basic principle that they would regard not even the industry as having unanimity upon, if that makes sense. I think it is difficult. I think it really is difficult for journalists to stand up for a principle about journalism in the modern age.
I think they should. I think they should. I do think that politicians, because they have been on the front line of the same disruption, we have lived through, I think they get it because they have lived it themselves. I am complicit in it.
Well, absolutely. But we do not need to explain to them because they themselves have been through it. I do think that I am sort of reassured that a lot of senior people in politics do think about these issues and not superficially and they think about what might be able to be done in all of the circumstances. But the whole landscape is the badlands.
Yeah, it's all badlands out there. As a Prime Minister of Metro book? He told me you bought it actually. He bought it.
Oh, I suspect it's a funny. Yes, yes, yes. I don't know. Getting on the line of finance.
Getting to the point is on the line of finance is with the book. You've been listening to the fourth estate, a very special podcast with Catherine Murphy, the essayist. I think we can call you an essayist now. It's a political editor of the Guardian and who's written a wonderful book called On Disruption, part of an MUP series of Ons.
And before we go off, in a few words, why should the general public buy this book? Because I would really like the general public to understand that our disruption is their disruption. I don't want people to think that this is a memoir of a journalist who has endured a transition. It is that, but it isn't that.
What I want to achieve with this project is grabbing people by the lapels and saying, look, there's some really big things, big consequential things going on here that may not be able to put all these pieces of your puzzle together because they're not obvious from the outside. But they are critical. What's happening is critical to how society conducts itself, to how politics is conducted, to whether journalism even happens anymore, to whether or not people can believe the output of journalism is being real verifiable or fake. These are not small things.
These are things in a democracy that's kind of the kind of access point on which a democracy turns. And I don't think we need to be sleepwalking into this set of circumstances. I think we need to be awake, attentive and engaged. That's already.
Thank you so much for your time. It's been my pleasure. It's been my pleasure.