Skip to content
Podcast Extra - Reporting on China episode artwork

May 14, 2019 31 min

Podcast Extra - Reporting on China

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

From 2SER's the Middle we talk about media coverage of China, with the journalists who report on it. What are the realities of reporting from China, and does Australia's media get it right?

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Podcast Extra - Reporting on China

0:00 31:30
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Visit BetMDM Casino and check out the newest exclusive! The price is right, Fortune Pick! BetMDM and GameSense remind you to play responsibly, 19 plus the wager, Ontario only, please play responsibly. If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you, please contact the next Ontario at 1-866-531-2600 to speak to an advisor.

Be of charge. BetMDM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with iGamingOntario. This Friday, the ocean shows you to save us all. The stories are true.

The story has just begun. From Disney, I want to know daughter of the chief. Let's save her up. Let's save her up.

It's my we time. I'm going to eat whatever that is. His name is Hay Hay. Oh, it's no!

Disney's Moana. In theatres by A. Get tickets now. You're listening to The Middle, the show about the Australia-China connection, web-bringing greater balance and broad expertise to all aspects of the Australia-China relationship.

Hello and welcome. You're listening to The Middle, the show about Australia's relationship with China. Coming to you from Tursiara and Sydney on Gadigal lands of your nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device, across the globe via podcast. My name is Peter Frey and my co-host is Oneing Sun.

And our producer today is the wonderful Kayla Makoo. I'm Oneing and I come to you from the University of Technology, Sydney. The middle is inspired by the simple desire to shed more light than heat on Australian-China relations. To do that every week, we explore one aspect of the relationship with two subject-area experts.

And if you'd like to catch up with previous episodes in either English or Mandarin, please go to themiddleau.com. And you can even see what we look like if you fancy that. So, Oneing, perhaps you should tell us what this week's episode is all about. Yes, thanks Peter.

This week we're talking about Australia's media coverage of China. No, we are asking some questions here. Are Australian journalists doing an okay job in covering China? Are there any problems in the Australian's media coverage of China?

Does the media deal in feelings more than facts when it comes to China? And how do news organizations create quality reporting on China as a newsroom but continue to dwindle? Today we have two guests who are very, very well qualified to answer these questions. Glenda Kopera is joining us from Beijing.

Glenda is a senior financial journalist from the Australian with more than 30 years' experience reporting on business and finance around the world. And in the studio we have Sulyn Tan and Sulyn is a journalist at the Australian Financial Review reporting on a wide range of things but most recently on Asia, China and politics. And Sulyn, you've been doing quite a lot of real estate reporting as well. Yes, absolutely.

In the last probably five years watching the market go up in town. I'm really pleased it's going down because I'm in the market. So we'll get some advice later. It seems that we can look at China-related content.

Journalism in Australia is belonging to sort of one of three areas. There's reporting about China. There's reporting on Australia-China relations. And then there's reporting on Chinese influence.

I mean you might dispute those three characterizations but how would you, let's start with you Sulyn. How would you assess the media's performance in those three areas? Poor. Extremely poor.

I'm not going to hold back here. I've spent the last few years watching the coverage go from reasonably curious to absolutely radicalised and one-sided. It just seems that certain journalists particularly, even ones who are very experienced have a certain agenda. They've set in their minds that there is some kind of a conspiracy theory and they're going down every possible path looking for something.

And almost always without evidence and almost always without a voice from the other side. So in that sense- I'm sure we're going to come back to that scene. What about you, Glenda? I mean those three years reporting about China, reporting on Australia-China relations and then reporting on China influence.

Because perhaps what Sulyn's getting at is more prevalent in reporting on China influence questions. But you know she might dispute that. What do you think, Glenda? Well there has been an enormous increase in reporting on China influence, security, being China as a threat.

Just on the basis of all I can do is follow online. But it's not so much adjusting. Like almost every story or story after story is looking to have China as a read under every beat. I mean it's interesting with the story on the hacking of the email in Parliament House.

Now the Prime Minister announced that it could have been a fake actor or whatever. And maybe they'll agree with what I don't know. The General's been briefed in Canberra by various interests. Because General's after General has been just said China.

China wasn't named but the assumption was it was China. Yeah. And the question is maybe I mean maybe the General's been briefed by someone or security interests or whatever it is there. This kind of reporting is as you come on, that's a prevalent reporting.

When in fact there's a heck of other stuff going on. I mean you've got students coming out. You've got tourists. You've got business.

It's a very broad relationship. You've got art, art, you've got artists coming and going. And yet it almost the front page or the early page stories are all with a security flavour. And certainly very you know painting China is in a quite a negative way.

And it's something I, there must be given it's more than one General. Maybe you know people are there with disabilities going on. I mean I have made it. I can only think that there's a bit more to it.

Somebody is briefing these General's on something which I'm not aware of. Well Glenda, just having you talk about that in that way. And it seems to me that some China scholars or media scholars like you know in universities also argue that the reporting on China has gone a bit too far in the direction of China bashing if you like or anti-China as a kind of knee-jerk kind of reaction. So are they being too sensitive about this or do they actually have a point?

I guess I sense from what you're saying that you think they might have a point. I think I back to the days when the industry China came from the Wigglem government and then it came from the whole government and there was huge at the top levels of government. You had a quote all our life on China has been a communist country and it's still you know people do. I think one happens to people, new people come to China and they say well it's just like us.

Well it's a communist country and I thought it had a B1. What do you aren't having? I think one of the vaccines is at the top of the government. You know the opening up and the connections with China were done by you know the Wigglem board and they're feeding.

It seems at the top level of the government now there's not a you know there's an ambivalence about China and I think that's the route into journalism thinking. But clearly with its Huawei story it seems to intelligence and security and clearly all around the world. Generals are being briefed or fed or whatever story by various sources and it's really through the recovery. Well let's ask Julian the same question.

Do you think journalists might have been briefed somehow? I think so. I think there's a fair amount of behind the scenes kind of political maneuver here instead of actually coming out and saying what they need to say or even standing out for what they're right. So absolutely no wrong defending Israelis national interests or security but they don't they do in a clandestine fashion you know just going around the back and dropping it with certain you know journalists we have a certain agenda or have already been radicalised thinking that there is a you know China's taking over the world.

Isn't it something to do with a kind of innate fear of you know China's powerful and when it was a big country full of peasants that was one thing but now it's actually a big country full of people with lots of money who come to Sydney and by Harvard mansion. So that's not the model that we expected right that's not the China that we could understand we wanted the China that would take our wheat and wool and you know but we wouldn't get too bulky there we have China rising as a superpower. And therefore it reflects a narrow mindedness of the Australian people and particularly Australian leaders and government because it's their job to educate and guide in that the world's changing is China's changing and instead of looking to reach that relationship. It was like recording on the ground from China.

I mean are there pressures on you in terms of what you can and can't do the influences on you do you feel that you're you know what you do is being watched and all that sort of stuff. Or do you have relative freedom. Yes well that in the like the Australian government I know what is what I write as well. So and the Chinese government will be down in the Chinese and that's like being a girl in some way you know there's a lot more open in the sense that you've got internet control but really you've got so what the kind of conflict.

So I'm going to go to the website for it there updating it there is the first comments they're reporting from it and I can get that fairly instant but now it's probably not being reported in the way a critical journalist would do but there's a foreign minister post conference at three o'clock every afternoon on three to go and anyone every end of the phone journalist any registered is pretty darn after questions and that you can get the next day on on this time. So in some ways and if I want to get on a plane and theory apart from the bed I could probably go somewhere countering that is a change in tone of the government really controlling more putting more pressure on Chinese people about what they can say. And certainly my assistant who's been working for the place for some time it's much much harder to get academics to come out or people to speak and just make a comment. The pressures on them are quite great and there are a lot of people now that you could have grown up five years ago have the economy going down the Australia China going in more cautious.

So in a funny way you know things are more open than they were in the past I mean twenty-seven years ago or perhaps even ten years ago you'd have the journalist who would like to come in and take away the China daily. Now you know there's a quite a lot of information is active but they're at that concern of people having their name in the paper. I had one story and I like to name the person that's the first person I made a extremely innocuous comment about this cold situation and it just rebounded on that person so much and on the business. All the people in the business they just don't make any waves and so there's this increasing phenomenon of people being very cautious about speaking and time after time when you do want to speak to someone or you can't use their name or identify them so well.

Are you conscious of? I think one of the narratives is gets transposed on China these days is a kind of Russian cold war narrative. Then we just replace the word Russia with China and so the idea is that the journalists get followed home after work and all this sort of stuff. I think this dark cars falling around is there anything like that going on?

Look honestly they can probably monitor your weak chat or they could do it all electronically if they wanted to. I have only been here since July. The special recognition here is that the Western District anyway, so your obvious special recognition is quite high. I was told by another colleague who was not reporting on identity and just talking to people who were from the country who come to protest and she was both a given to the policeman who already knew who she was and she suspected they had got her detailed by a special recognition.

I think the old age when they followed the time it starts, the electronic stuff is very, it is probably quite sophisticated if they want to use it. I think you have to assume that you could be monitored. I can't imagine somebody wanting money, wanting to be all day in my life. Well Glenda, it's interesting you were talking about Australian journalists' relationship with the local Chinese government there.

I would also want to go to the other direction and asking a question about Australian media's relationship with the government and foreign affairs ministry in Australia. For instance, when Julia Bishop, when she was the minister, she criticized the media a number of times saying the media was informing the public about Australian-China relationships. So clearly there is a tension between the government's foreign affairs agenda and journalists' desire to tell the stories in a certain way. So do you experience this kind of tension?

Well, we are told, and I think the foreign government works all around the world. You have to have a good relationship if you can with the industry for various reasons. You have to know what people are coming through and all this. The rule is, and it was felt out clearly, you can't quote any of us, you, every comment has to come from being fat in Canberra.

And that's the rule they have to live with. So in a way, if I want to end statement about anything, I have to email them fat in Canberra the same way as anyone else. And that's a constraint there as well. And I think that the default thing is probably the government would prefer things that were not, if there's tensions, I think they probably would like to play them down.

I did hear there was a company, especially Why In A State, which changed pin-folds. They had some problems getting blown in about last May. They decided to disclose that to the stock exchange. And I heard like informally that the government would prefer they didn't speak out about that.

But I've been here directly by a certain way that on a way fine. So I think they, if there's problems they'd prefer we weren't covering it. I'd like to ask that Selena question, as she's the person who is actually reporting on this, basically in Australia, how do you see this tension being played out in every day? Between media and government?

Yes, I think because journalists are quite vain. And they're all after an award. They're looking for a witch hunting. They're wiggly.

They're wiggly. They're looking for a walklier. We all know how that plays out. So they're after an award and they're looking for something that is sensational and it rides on the trend, it plays into emotions which are unfounded and not necessarily backed by evidence.

And you can see all the defamation cases that are late that point to that. Again, journalism has lost its footing when it comes to reporting in China. We are still the father state. We have a responsibility to the public.

Governments may have games to play. They have votes to win. But we have to report both sides of the story. And both voices, the current discourse at the moment is completely one-sided.

It's about Australia's view of China, Australia's view of China buying up Australia and all that stuff that you can actually control. So we've lost our middle voice of balance, where we were supposed to look after the people of Australia. And the ones that actually do do balance stories, they're not actually out there being read widely because they're behind a pay wall. The blogs, the newspaper, the online, they pick up everything they can find for a headline, for an award.

And that's a problem. Just on that. Do you think the more partisan media, so the global times, obviously most of the PRC, and there are certain partisan, maybe more pro-government news organizations in this country. Catherine Murphy recently noted that that had been described as sort of a megaphone diplomacy, that media is being used as a tool of furthering foreign policy.

Do you see that? Yeah, absolutely. I mean, Global Times, we all know, is the mouthpiece, right? As is all of the national papers in China.

But they don't report to be a democracy. They don't go out and say, right, we're a balanced democracy, we fair balance commentary and write solidly founded stories. They don't report to do that. That's not their business model.

They're propagandists. Exactly. But we talk about being a democracy, and we're doing exactly the thing that is not democratic. We are doing exactly the things one sided, and it's actually, in fact, doing exactly what these Global Times of the world are doing.

You're speaking one side of the story. So we've all gone to both sides of the fence. You and that Cameron, I'm in this cap. Glen, what do you think about that seems?

I think there are real issues of trying to now growing up and becoming a world power, becoming more, you know, playing a bigger role and being more confident and a little bit more aggressive. It seems to be turning into hating every Chinese or critical of every Chinese. And we don't do that with America. We don't blame, we don't like Putin.

We don't somehow turn into a mass criticism of every Russian. And people are who are in the Australian China business, being affected by this constant barrage of negative comment. We somehow complain, complain, complain, ordinary Chinese people with what the government might be doing. Do you think the Australian media is then being complicit in that?

Again, that's a broad statement, the Australian media. Are the sections of the Australian media that are buying into that more than others? I think there's certainly journalists who are reporting on it. I mean, I think if you look at, I mean, I've got to be honest, the business journalist, and that's the way I follow China.

If you look at the business section, whether we're daily reporting, actually business deals with China, blackmores or what-or-or. So there are other screens and there are other screens of the paper. Again, I think it does come down to a sort of a gap at the top in government. And I think the future is going to be much more complicated as well.

And we need to be able to walk into government sort of thing. We need to realise that the future world is much more complicated with superpowers, offering up against each other and a much more competent China. And the government hasn't worked out how really to deal with that. It'd be interesting to see how Penny Wong's world will do.

So there's not a leadership coming from the government, or in fact, this term has revealed that having the speech he's made, he's made by just with on the security issues or perceived security issues. So look around other screens of reporting as well that are there to be found, but I suppose the main thing that's getting in the paper at the moment is somehow this security issue and it's done by and attacking and all these other unmade, affordable, affordable countries. So I guess in some ways the media has been criticised for its coverage on issues in terms of China influence. For instance, Peter Manning, who is a former ABC person, he described this kind of trend of journalism to move from investigation to what he called access journalism.

And also James Lawrence and the UTS also produced a report which aims to debunk a whole range of myths, if you like about China's power and influence. So obviously from what you're saying, there is a problem with Australian media reporting on China. So you think this criticism are justified? I think it is because I think the people who are running the paper often lies in the hands of several journalists and several editors who are, you know, for one of the better with friends and in power for a very long time.

They already have a set view and they're not easily influenced by other new journalists or journalists with, you know, ethnic backgrounds like us, you know, who have a knowledge of how things work and cultural transparency. So they're not open to that in that sense. So I think, and even the national broadcaster I feel is leaning towards that as well, which is very disappointing if you're a national broadcaster. And putting out a lot of programs off late, especially on four corners, there are just so sway to one direction.

It's stunning that I am gobsnacked as a taxpayer and a Australian citizen to see this happening, knowing that there is definitely another side of the story as a journalist. Well, do you think that these kind of stories tend to play more on emotion rather than fact when it comes to coverage of the problem? What the problem is? Oh, absolutely.

People love emotional story, don't they? They love the drama. So the more, I mean, that is why things like Meredith First Sight is exciting on TV because they love the drama. They don't want to know the hard facts or having to understand something that's difficult.

And to Peter's point, maybe it's just easy to see China as a village full of peasants and people making shoes in factories and all that. And suddenly their views change and it's really hard to see something else. And they can't get their head around it. And our leaders are not teaching or guiding us towards being a flexible thinker rather than, you know, one dimensional.

And just a quick question on this. Do you think that this, if you like polarity stems from or is a product of the industry, the journalism industry and the kind of tough times we face and therefore there's fewer resources around to do in-depth reporting and it's easier to cut the corners and go with the kind of dominant narrative? Yes, you know, cosplay, it's definitely got people do all day. You know, there's like a place I wanted to have to go out into the real part of China and spend a week with you.

I don't know if that would be justified financially or not. And this kind of thing where people think there's alleged things without actually saying things to be prevalent. I think we're only changing cons. I mean, it's not just Australia.

You look at the stuff that Trump has been saying, you look at my pen, he's done a stack of the package. This worldwide debate about why I am trying to think for. And so I think we have to look at the debate in Australia in a broader thing. And the future, I mean, all speaking and others actually, the other thing is if I'm the future will the Australia have to learn that the future is about dealing with people that might not look like us, what about us?

They might not have the same government as us. They might not have the same religious as us again, you know, speaking of like, what percation person back. It's only have to engage with Asia and that could be grown up and we have to realize that all the governments are very, very different. We have to not just jump up and down and say, well, this is not a democracy.

Right. I think that complexity is missing. And my theory is that Australia will lose opportunity because there's plenty of other countries who are in here trying to do business and have a relationship. And you have to constantly engage with China to change it very quickly.

And now it's a very proud country. So I'm not defending everything it does. But I think we make a big engagement in a more creative way. If we just, if I walk from the outside, well, you know, we'll just live in that little island and we won't be part of this sort of Asian growth story which is happening.

Well, Glenda, you just talk about the need to look at the complex picture and the need to avoid simplistic, which I think is absolutely crucial here. So here is a question I want to put to you and, as soon as you first, that is, if you ask to come up with some recommendations for say Australian journalists reporting on China, let's call them best practices in reporting China. What would you recommend? Well, I think the more journalists that come here the better and try and understand it.

If some China side, they get a bit thinking. Like sometimes I talk to the Chinese side and they say, well, you could have tried to make it. I think perhaps the more, you know, I think perhaps the more, you know, that come here and try and realize it's very complicated, interesting about complicated country for better. Maybe getting, you know, editors up here a bit more as well, you know, seeing people in the paper to understand what, what, what, like about.

And again, you know, leadership, perhaps that's a political level of taking it forward in a complicated world. And again, very interesting to see the labor. And later, traditionally, it's engaged with China in a better way than the liberals in a way, but, you know, we're in a new world. I think about the more coverage, the more people we can get to come up here and see what's going on.

And just engagement is constant. Rather than perhaps sitting and just sort of throwing rocks, which is easy to do. So that kind of exposure and immersion is really crucial to getting a sense of what's happening on the ground. I get the sense from you, Glenda.

That's the message you want to get through, right? What's happening is moving here is how important China is to Australia, of course, and to the world. I mean, it's growing, I mean, it's growing enormously. And yet it's going to show up coming up government.

But it's saying we're going to do it in our way. And how do you engage with that? How do you, how do you report the policies and negatives of that? It's very complicated.

And we need more, we need to be able to try and, you know, conflict-wise. Yeah, increasingly, China is reported both from people like you who are based in China and people like Sulu who are based in Australia. So I would ask Sulu in the same question. If you are asked to come up with a list of recommendations in best practices covering China, what would you recommend?

I'd say that, you know, I'll even break it down from immersion. Just very simply, if you're in Australia, go and spend some time with your Chinese friends. Go and have lunch and dinner with Chinese students. Go and speak with new migrants.

Go to the neighbourhoods where they live. You know, actually, if you don't speak Mandarin, that's okay. Bring a friend. Bring a translator.

Actually, turning up at places that make you uncomfortable. If you were never there in the first place and you've never had any exposure to a friend or a community, actually turn up. That is what we have time for this week on the middle. You can find previous episodes, as I mentioned, online at themiddleau.com, and subscribe to us for whatever podcast app you might use.

And until next week, it's goodbye from me, Peter Frank. And goodbye from me, when in yourself. And thank you both to our guests. A Safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my card doesn't get stolen.

It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer. That's how we protect Ontario.

For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca. Pay for it by the Government of Ontario.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 31 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on May 14, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.