The opinions expressed in this podcast do not necessarily reflect those of ACMI. political documentary in a post-truth world. And I'm very pleased to welcome to the stage Nicola Harvey, Managing Editor of BuzzFeed Australia, Dr Anna Bronowski, filmmaker and maker of the fascinating documentary about Pauline Hanson that we will see a little bit of later on. Basically, I think the purpose of this session is for...
Anna and Nicola to get into a really serious fight between long form and short form. And that's basically what I will be. I'm sort of like the opposite of a moderator. I'll be a new moderator. I'll be trying to whip up that division. And at some point, Matt Davies may have to step in in the middle in a way that sort of reflects his role. Matt's a journalist and filmmaker. He's worked on shows like Foreign Correspondent in particular and has had some fascinating experiences bringing together.
long-form documentary and also you know bolt out of the blue uh lightning viral videos uh and that's really what one of the things that we're going to talk about in today's session um you may have seen from the the outline that one of the questions we're going to answer is how do we ensure the integrity of storytelling in our post-truth world probably spent about three or four minutes on that once we've got that knocked off um we'll move on to other things like the uh the connection between social media and political documentary and i suppose the way that this um omnipresent phrase viral video can work uh and perhaps against short and long-form video journalism. The session goes for an hour. There will be a sort of block of questions at the end, but we're going to try and stop throughout after the panel has had a chat on each particular topic. And so if you'd like to ask a question at that point, please feel free. We'll sort of signal that someone will come to you with a microphone. Please keep your questions. We don't really need the full biographical history and the details of your thesis and all those sorts of things before the question, but questions are most welcome and we're really keen to open up the discussion. So with that in mind, let's plough on. And I thought...
We should begin with a little bit of definitional work because we're talking about political documentary. And I wanted to ask everyone on the panel, what's your understanding of that phrase? What is a political documentary? And also, can you tell us about some of the works that stand out to you as the best examples of whatever it is political documentary is? Anna, do you want to start off there? Yeah, sure. Well...
To me, and I might as well just get the boxing gloves on and running, why not? Political documentary is propaganda. There's three types of propaganda. There's grey propaganda. There's propaganda for the good. And I'm sure most people in this room would like to feel they're on that side. And then there's propaganda for power, manipulative propaganda. Look at the First World War, Second World War, and Trump's banning of the press from the White House press briefing lately and what's happening there. So for me, if...
political documentary is a form of propaganda in that it's trying to persuade your viewers to come to a point of view that the filmmaker believes in and thereby somehow insight change then there are many ways to do it and the ones that stand out for me perhaps don't work now but they did then and the key one for me is Michael Moore's Fahrenheit 9-11 which basically at the time brought feature docs back into the cinema and was a blockbuster and then on the other side you have propaganda against Michael Moore that came out at the same time from the right because they realised how powerful this medium is and that was Michael Moore as a big fat stupid white man. Yeah, that'll get it rolling. Great answer, yeah, absolutely. And so inherently you believe that political documentary is not just about agenda setting, but it is pushing an agenda. Absolutely. I mean, filmmaking is manipulative. You can't avoid that, and you're dishonest if you don't think it is. It is. And so if you're making a political documentary, use these tools, humour, seduction, entertainment, to persuade your audience to a point of view, as long as it's truthful.
Okay, and so what was your agenda in making the Hanson documentary? Oh, look, it failed dismally. I mean, we wanted to make a film that would attract Pauline's supporters as much as her detractors, and that worked. I mean, SBS, it beat all time slot expectations for SBS that night, and in fact put SBS up against the commercials, which was rare. So that worked. But unfortunately, even though we tried really hard, and I think this is worth unpicking, to show her supporters and detractors all sides of what it was that had made her change Australia and come back again with a vengeance, there were very few people we converted.
over either side so her supporters watched it tuning into sbs for the first time many of them and filled the screen with emoticons we love you pauline marry me pauline god you rock um and her detractors said i can't believe i'm watching this it's like a train wreck so um that's still a work in progress julian like how the hell do we convert people that don't agree with us and that's interesting um Is that something that you feel is the case more today than in the past, that it's harder to convert people? Absolutely, because we're living in a world now where Daniel Patrick Moynihan's statement, everyone's entitled to their own opinions but not to their own facts, no longer applies. People treat their opinions as facts. How the hell do you convert that kind of audience? And, you know, I'm sure that Nicola and Matt have ideas about that too. Yeah, please do. I'm kind of curious about that idea of converting. What we are interested in.
How's that? Better. I just want to go back to that idea of converting via political documentary because we at Buzzfeed obviously make short video and we make short video for the social networks, particularly Facebook at the moment. And what we are trying to do is find a space where there is a civil conversation. Civil as in civil duty, but also maintaining some kind of decorum. And so it's less for us about persuasion and more about just opening up conversation. And I think...
For us, that is a way to engage with our younger audience, especially. BuzzFeed has, you know, bulk of our audience in Australia is 18 to 24. They are young. They are really politically engaged. They want to know more. They want to have a conversation. So what we're trying to do with video is actually find the space for civil conversation. And, you know, it's not working, really, very often. Because what we see in social media, as everyone knows, is this polar opposite debate of, you know, the extreme left and right going at each other without much understanding of a common ground or much desire to find it. By politically engaged, the BuzzFeed audience is politically engaged. Do you mean that already left wing?
No, quite seriously. That's a really interesting point, though. No, I think in Australia, especially, we've seen a really robust group of followers in our BuzzFeed Oz poll page. And that's off the back of two very big personalities. Our political editor and our political reporter, Mark Stefano and Alice Workman, have brought with them a very, very fiery young liberal base. Not because they're friends with them, they just, you know, people love to take pot shots at Mark. And I think he's a closet Tory. And so that sort of brought in an audience who feel very much at home to debate and unpack some what we would consider perhaps right wing.
ideology. In general BuzzFeed is a progressive media company and we're not going to shy from that. We are objective in what we do as much as possible. We uphold some very high journalistic standards but we take some positions and we're not shy about coming out in our support for LGBT rights, trans rights especially and that's where we're seeing the political engagement. We have a lot of supporters being very vocal about trans rights at the moment. And do you have any metrics on whether you do actually manage to change people's minds from these sorts of videos? Is that something you can track?
No. What we can track, though, is how a story gains traction. And I'm sort of leapfrogging ahead because we might get to this a little bit later. But what we did see was a really deep investment in the Standing Rock story in Dakota. And for the first time that I can remember, a really deep interest in what was happening in terms of First Nations people's struggle against government. And we saw that over time of three months gain traction. Every single week we were going back with another story and it was ballooning.
Interesting, interesting. Okay, well, let's go back to you, Matt. You've heard Anna say that political documentary is propaganda. The propaganda that you've made for our independent national broadcaster at Foreign Correspondents. For the good, for the good. For the good, yeah. But do you endorse that view that political documentary is inherently propagandistic? I guess where I sit with my work is slightly different in that I am working with the ABC and we've got our charter editorial policies and so on. We have to pretend that's what it is. But my take on it is that foreign is a unique beast in its various formats over the years.
What I feel, and those who have come forward to agree, is that we're taking a news cycle issue, perhaps, or an issue that is not necessarily getting a lot of their time and trying to take it on and give people a deeper understanding of what that is. It might be something, maternal deaths in Papua New Guinea, that no one's covering, that we've decided that's worth doing a half an hour program on because we're next door to Papua New Guinea and people should be made aware that that is an issue. Australian aid funding goes there. Women are dying at one of the highest rates in the world in childbirth. In Australia, it's one of the safest countries. But I guess perhaps one of the stories that continues to resonate is how coverage of the Black Lives Matter issue, which we'll get to a bit later as well.
Roots is an extremely viral social media, video, iPhone-driven kind of political movement. But if you left it at that, it was a very polarising news issue, depending on who you tune into. So our idea, our role there as a political documentary maker was to go there and to hear from all sides of that story and present a piece, a body of work that, you know, was relevant. It's important. My work is all internationally based at this point, and we try to find a hook.
For those international issues that are relevant here in Australia, we have issues here with police and Indigenous Australians and others and incarceration. So there are often crossovers with what I do, and I think that's part of it is that continuing to show Australian audiences that there are issues that are relevant to us, they're also occurring in other parts of the world, and we can all learn by watching political documentary in its various lengths. So in that sense, the way that political documentary can change minds is just by raising topics. Bringing it into the service, making it a conversation. And Nicola just mentioned Standing Rock. Our characters from our program met on that process through that filming and they organised the Standing Rock, the veteran stand, a couple of months later. So it's a curious beast when you're out there in this political space. You're asking people to give their views on issues. You're going to people's lives, often challenging desperate people. They're sharing things with you. And, yeah, if I can bring that into someone's lounge room and that stirs some kind of debate about Australian politics while internationally speaking, then I feel like that is adding to that discourse. It's a political documentary. Maybe that goes some way to answer your first question, which is what we consider a political documentary at the moment. And while Michael Moore's films were...
And, you know, we have these amazing characters like Pauline Hanson and the Wiener documentary. That was fabulous. What we are seeing is political documentary being driven by characters who are not on the world stage, who are not the big personalities. Yeah, and it's curious to keep in mind this post-truth phenomenon, which is where we started on this conversation. Because I've just come out of Venezuela, and that's particularly interesting. I mean, that's a popular story. It's a la Trump. But one grab in the interview is that Latin America's wrote the playbook on what Trump's doing now. And there is this, if we subscribe to the idea of post-truth as filmmakers, then I think we're losing it. We're out there with our cameras and we're talking to real people. That's our role. It is to find that truth, despite that.
the madness and the amount of oxygen that Trump gets on those sort of issues. I completely agree with that. I think for us to all jump onto this post-truth phase is incredibly dangerous. The status quo, the leaders, the people in power want it to be a post-truth phase. All the more reason for us to stick by the truth. And I have to say that the act of... Look, I know you won't be persuaded, but I believe that you are both using propagandistic tools for the good. You, by avoiding censorship by omission, you are giving airspace and mainstream airspace to voices that are not heard, and that in itself is a political act. And you are using BuzzFeed brilliantly, I might add, humour.
which is a very persuasive tool to get young audiences to engage with serious issues. So the top 10 what the fuck moments of the Hanson doco that you guys ran. added to the ripple effect, this kind of postmodern digital eco-chamber that happened around that film. And you know what? We're just not going to have a fight because they really helped us. I'm really disappointed. With our film, I'm sorry, but they were brilliant. Like BuzzFeed brought a whole new level of engagement to the Hanson doc on top of the, I don't know, 450, I can't remember how many people watched it, 450,000 or whatever, plus the 180,000 people that tuned in not into the film, but to Pauline Hanson sitting in a chair doing nothing for 72 minutes, live streaming herself on Facebook. It's like Racist Gogglebox. Watching the film, exactly. Racist Gogglebox, but in mime. Like she didn't...
really say anything yeah actually should we have a quick look at that this is this is about as meta as you can get this is Pauline Hanson watching Anna's Pauline Hanson documentary and I really hope Anna that you will live stream this event watching all this happen so So let's go into a little bit more detail on the role of social media then. I mean, in the old days, I'm sure Michael Moore had promos running in other cinemas with the select grabs of his doco as a way of trying to get people to buy tickets. Is that fundamentally what you guys in particular use social media for? Is it just basically a new technology of promo? Can it be something different? Should it be something different?
I was going to talk a little bit more on the way we're confronting that digital with freedom on it, surely. But I will say that social media, I mean, look, if an issue is popping in the BuzzFeed space and the short-form space that we can latch onto and drive the audience from that, and that's an absolute bonus. So you're saying that when you put excerpts of your content out, or you're saying you look at what's happening in social media and go, let's do... Yeah, issues that are already out there, we harness that social conversation in a longer-form version. It does drive people to our programming. I mean, at the moment, foreign correspondence is mostly a broadcast...
delivery um but increasingly the move is to the digital frontier and increasingly where you know i'm we're creating content that is specifically for social and distributing that in a very unorthodox ABC approach, that is to digital platforms and third-party platforms. Do the foreign correspondents that rate the highest on free-to-wear television also go the best on social? No. What's the difference? Probably the audience age demographic, I would say. So our traditional broadcast audience is a lot older and the digital space is obviously a lot younger, so we're talking about quite different. And one of my challenges has been to work out how the style and the flavour of the rhythm of the program to attract.
what is the brief to find this, you know, miracle audience that exists out there but are hard to tap into. In some way that is the challenge for the ABCs and it's sort of cradle and grave, not cradle to grave and what to do in the middle. In the middle, yeah. But I mean, look, taking an issue like Black Lives Matter is like something like, again, I'll go on about that one because it's a good case. That's an issue that is very relevant to the 20, 30-year-olds. You know, they're the ones fighting. That civil rights movement has been fought many times but it's now in the hands of younger millennials with iPhones. So that drew a youthful audience that interested in that story. So by choosing that as a subject. So there we have an hour and a bit to go about, well.
arising from a hashtag. Just tell us a little bit about the experience of making that film and how you used the long form and short form differently. Arriving on the south side of Chicago with three Australians walking into some fairly interesting neighbourhoods was rather curious for the locals. But I think we came in with... You know, we're not American. We're looking at it from an outside perspective. We're welcomed in. You know, it was a very tricky neighbourhood in many ways, extremely violent. But, look, people wanted to share that story because they felt they trusted us, and I think that's a very important part of political documentary. I mean, your relationship with Pauline must be rather peculiar, you know, but whatever our role is, whether we're in a South Sudanese refugee camp or in a community in Chicago or in Washington, D.C., interviewing a senator about those issues, I mean, it's just a very big part of it. There's no camera involved. It's actually just developing the rapport, the relationship. You are...
asking people to open up about extremely challenging and issues that are close to the heart and the mind. Filming that was a real sense of, you know, America, it's really fractured and there's a lot of trauma. And I can see how off the back of filming something like that a year ago, that the Trump phenomenon has grown and, you know, they all play into each other. Curiously, one of the young lads there, the photographer, he was up there. That is the way social media has been played with political documentary. He's from Baltimore. He was there with the riots after Freddie Gray died. He was just taking photos on his phone, putting it on Instagram. Time magazine picked up one of his images and ran it as the front cover, which went on to become, you know, he's now one of the most influential African-American photographers in the country. But, you know, it was interesting. That whole story has been laced with social media elements from its birth and continues to be. And that's, I guess, with political documentary, the presence of social media, the relentlessness of it can keep that conversation.
going a lot longer than when it was once screened on television. It was on Ivy for a couple of weeks and then just disappeared. Matt, can I just ask you something? The nature of social media, obviously, it's global, so anyone can kind of weigh in on this. And so it's interesting that you guys took this subject up as Australian filmmakers going into America. Can you talk a little bit about what role Sarah played in this as a reporter and how that would have been different? Because we saw a clip this morning from Ava Devonais' 13th.
film and you know similar subject matter yes i mean look we are in the current first place and traditionally it has it's you know the program is fine corresponding it does have a reporter leading the um the narrative uh i think in the future there are there are opportunities and we're constantly asking questions about this about how to do that maybe differently sometimes it is curious if you haven't seen 13th if you haven't seen this one watch this one first then watch 13th you'll notice there's quite a bit of talent that we share we did it first um and the uh but it's an amazing film but that's the beauty of i think uh a feature doc there is the time and the resources not necessarily highly budgeted for but the time is able to get the talent without the reporter reporter in some ways in my role is very useful at times because we're on extremely tight turnaround we might have eight weeks to go and make a one-hour program that is filming and editing and putting it together so the reporter role in that space does can help connect the dots looking ahead perhaps with the younger generations maybe some of that structure is open for renegotiation just because young ones are able to consume it slightly differently they didn't grow up with George Negus on the television
in a pineapple shirt, but, you know. I just want to dive in on what you said before, like the micro-docs that are lifted from our films act as kind of accidental trailers. And, in fact, they do. And I think we're a lot, as long-form political doco-makers, I think we're in a much more exciting position in terms of reaching broader audiences than the more conventional Michael Moore was back in 2001 with Fahrenheit. The micro-doc is an art form in its own right, and to me it's very exciting. For our Pauline Hanson film, I worked with SBS Online, we came up with ten kind of mini-docs, not necessarily drawn from the film, or everything from what kind of clothes does Hanson like compared to pants down.
and the fact that they found their outfits at the same budget discount Delina store to a clip that was lifted from the film that went viral in a way that I as a filmmaker could not have possibly dreamed. It reached, within three days, 1.8 million viewers. And it kind of, well, it excited me because one, it was reaching a new audience, a younger audience that perhaps didn't have time or the habit of engaging with long-form political doc, hadn't been raised on it. But two, it... encapsulated everything that we find wrong and troubling about Hanson in the same way that paintings used to tell a thousand words compared to the book. Microdocs.
do that for the long form doc. I think that they can coexist, but they're radically different. One's a poem, one's a novel. And yeah, that's what was exciting. If there's a way of then using those 1.8 million suddenly engaged viewers to either kickstart a new kind of debate that you as the filmmaker hadn't even imagined was possible, or encourage them to then log on and watch your film, that can only be a great thing. I don't want to get too semantic about it, but yeah, in a sense, that's a micro doc. It's a clip that encapsulates a whole lot of things incredibly...
quickly and is almost it almost works as a metaphor for what what handsome represents which is this profound ignorance this tendency to generalize and the fact that the person that's normally not put on the mainstream airwaves is right there with her and we're rooting for him and what was interesting to me about that clip was not just a sort of arty farty interest that I might have as a filmmaker but that clip was the one thing that actually did get Hansen offside. So that had gone viral by 24 hours before we were meant to go to air on Sunday night. And Hansen and Ashby, James Slippergate Ashby, her helicopter driving come political advisor dude, you'd know all about Ashby, they were worried because what they were seeing on their comments page and their avid users of Facebook, in fact Facebook is how Hansen got in, they were seeing their supporters.
writing in saying, Pauline, you can't say that. We're withdrawing our support. We don't like One Nation. So it was the first time that we'd achieved something we wanted to achieve with the long form, which is persuade people to think about Pauline again. So they rang us. It was 8 p.m. on a Saturday night. We'd all had a few wines. Ashby rings and says, pull that clip or something very, very nasty will happen. And I thought nothing of it, but I thought I'd better ring Joseph Maxwell. Get your travel notes immediately. Exactly. Just remember what Ashby's got a track record of doing. Yeah, yeah. And Joseph immediately rang the lawyers because he decided to treat it as it.
possibly was a serious threat, and the top defamation lawyer, I think it's Tom Blackburn QC, came back and said, they're right, it is defamatory. Hanson's defaming herself, leave it up. Has she taken action against herself? No, no. She probably would, though. I'm interested to ask, firstly, I got the impression that you think that that's not a micro-doc, and please give us your comments on the issue more generally. Look, I think, I mean, Anna said it herself, there has been a tendency for long-form filmmakers and broadcasters to clip and then put...
sort of segments of the film out as teasers or trailers in advance and I think that certainly you know serves a particular purpose but it's promo the intent is to ultimately draw eyeballs back into the main broadcast and even though you say Anna now that that clip and its virality reaching 1.5 million was satisfying in itself one of the things that we have kind of grappled with and we've talked about is this idea of what constitutes documentary in terms of context so you had two lines exchanged in that clip and I think the virality probably came out of the fact that people were hate sharing it we have a algorithm at that we look at in terms of engagement, and we look less at number of viewers and more at number of shares, how many people are actually putting it out further into the world, either in support or in opposition. And that one line or two lines from Hanson proved to left-wing Australia.
everything that they thought they knew about her. And the intent of your documentary was to offer more than that. Is that not right? Well, I mean, first of all, I don't think it was hate sharing necessarily because if it was just hate sharing, then one of the lines in the film that never went viral, for example, I believe we're being swamped by Asians or when she slams Muslim people, that would have been more likely to be shared if the only agenda in sharing that clip was a left-wing one to show how evil she is. I suspect that that clip, unlike all the other clips we uploaded, went viral perhaps because, and it's coming back to what BuzzFeed does so well.
it used humour to get to the bottom of a very potentially ugly and fraught issue. And so it was a piece of entertainment as well as a provocative clip. I mean, we, obviously, when we filmed it, we knew it was gold, but we had no idea that that's what would cut through. So I'm really interested to hear that Left Wing has shared it, but it's quite clear from Hanson and Ashby's reaction that a lot of One Nation supporters did too. That's interesting. Yeah. So perhaps, can we throw to one of my clips? Sure, yeah. I just wanted to show the first excerpt on... So this is the Australia Day one? Yeah, Australia Day. Just the first excerpt. Yeah, just the first. And just a little bit of context before we start. It had the same kind of reach as Anna's viral clip. No humour involved. Similar kind of topic, but we were trying to switch the lens around and provide an alternative perspective. So this went out just before Australia Day 2016 and won an umbrella award last year.
So that was just a really short excerpt of a three-minute video that was made by Tanya Safi. And I wanted to just unpack that a little bit because when that video went out into social media, it received a huge volume of nasty, horrible... Yeah, there was. Which is interesting, and it goes back to what we were talking about earlier of how do we open up a space for civic conversation. And we're trying to do it by telling other people's perspectives, putting stories out that are really heard in mainstream media. But we're getting a...
barrage back at us every single day or every single time we do a video like that but we keep going. So do you think then that the purpose of creating a space for there to be a certain type of conversation is actually working? I think it is. I mean Matt said earlier if you keep going documentaries can have impact if we talk about the Standing Rock and I'm going to keep banging on about this because for me it was a really formative moment to see First Nations people and their politics and their causes. covered in a really robust and deep way by the American media, and actually finally get up into CNN when one of their anchors sort of had a bit of a rant on air, saying it's about time we heard these stories. And it was a way for the world to have a look at how First Nations people in America are surviving. But mostly it was just that change of language around how they talked about the land and their political struggle. And the one thing that really encapsulated it for me was...
an interview that one of our video producers did with a young woman, where they were just being accused of being protesters, and her response to that was, no, I'm a water protector. And then all of a sudden, that shifted the conversation. And it snowballed from there. And BuzzFeed ended up doing, over three months, I think, 15 different short videos. Some of them were news. Some of them saw more mini-docs. This is BuzzFeed Australia or BuzzFeed? All of it. So BuzzFeed US did the bulk of it. But what happened, we saw, I don't know if you'll remember, a check-in function on Facebook where people very casually were able to support the protest by...
checking into the reservation in North Dakota on Facebook, and it was a way to apparently try and distract police who were tracking people. Anyway, that was beside the point. What we saw was a show of support from First Nations people in New Zealand. There was Natiparo, who did a beautiful moving haka on the beach in Gisborne, and that was filmed. Joe Williams, who's an indigenous guy who lives out in Dubbo now. He was a footy player and a boxer. He actually travelled over there with messages of support from Aboriginal Australians. So there was a groundswell, and I don't recall having seen that before, and so we tried to capture it.
Matt, do you agree that micro-docs or these short-form grabs are the most effective way of raising that consciousness? Or is it just a way? Does it lead people simply to longer form content? Is that the purpose of it? It's both. It is both. One thing I've been grappling with in my mid-range length political documentary. Get off the fence, Matt. Come on. Is actually how to find the audience. So where is the audience? And are we able to just rely on the phone or on the broadcast? There is a new phenomenon of obviously the idea that we should take content to people and almost identify the audience sometimes before you.
Shoot the film. I guess Freedom Riders is a story I did on trauma therapy through surfing in Cape Town, South Africa last year. It was a curious experiment where we distributed that internationally on a digital. It was a bit of an ABC kind of first, perhaps, for current affairs. It went out digital. It also was broadcast on a regular time slot, so it had a traditional audience. But in sending it out digitally, it was picked up. And this was the experiment that we did by third parties who...
saw value in that and they other media organizations the new yorker and others like this we'd spoken with they were hosting it on their site well because it was a surfing related story i identified you know and nick fanning at the time was returning to jeffrey's bay where he'd been attacked by the shark the year before it was a very big popular moment and that that industry latched onto this story we were telling which is a political documentary about young south africans whose parents weren't allowed on the beach because of apartheid learning to surf and dealing with various violence and drug-related traumas that they're encountering in their townships so that surfing body actually took that and ran that so we were actually distributing this story outside of the traditional abcs um push that is iview and broadcast and the results are astounding it actually went it just continues continues this day people from brazil write to inquire about showing and hosting and we were able to those analytics of course were owned by us that all came back to us and i don't know the numbers on the top of my head my digital producer would know but basically it was it was an idea that can sort of a quasi long form with short form elements that were pushing towards it actually generate a broader audience than just here in australia now before everyone jumps in and says well how do you monetize i'm in the position where it's a public broadcaster and that money was
telling a good story and it was pushing the ABC as a content, you know, as a current affairs machine, able to do stories internationally with the best of them. So I think that was really that idea of going out to the audience, taking it to the audience, we were rewarded for that and that is, I guess it's almost a blend of what, you know, how BuzzFeed go out to their audience and how Anna's film would release and how we are coming into a time in platform land where it's really interesting but at the end of the day the point of doing political documentaries is that as many people see it as possible and that this course of conversation evolves and that was just one example of something that we've been able to experiment with and yeah. Do you want to play that clip? Sure, just the opening little bit. And it brought people in as well because we actually put a lot of emphasis into the cinematography for this one. Important. It's my favourite place. Being in the water, it makes me feel free. Even for stress, the water can make you feel better. Catching wave, it gives you something strong. The next day, something big is going to happen. Your dreams are going to come true. For 19-year-old Nonnetto Mabunu, every day is a mission to stay positive.
I'm a strong woman. And I'm glad that I'm a strong woman because I don't give up easy in a lot of things. The love of surfing helps to guide her through. The township of Massey-Pumalele is full of dangers and disappointments. We've got gangsterism, drugs, alcohol abuse, teenage pregnancy.
That's the opening lead-in. So we follow that young lady and she's got some extremely traumatic tales that unfold. But again, the way it was shot in the style and the identifying our audience, it actually did just really pop out there in the world. I want to come back to the question form in a second, but I just do want to be true to my promise to open it up to questions. So is there anyone who would like to ask a question at this point? If you do, just let us know and we'll get a microphone to you. And if there isn't, I am very happy to say that there's still a ton of stuff we can talk about here. Yes, okay. Madam, up there.
Isn't the other thing in this post-truth world, though, also the amount of scrutiny that makers are now under? I mean, everybody can make a film virtually on their microphone, so it's more than just the content and the platforms. I'm just throwing it out there. Oh, well, God, yeah, scrutiny. I mean...
Not just by hostile forces who don't like the message you're promoting, but also within the organisations you're making your political film for. So not just on Pauline Hanson, but on my last one more so, which was actually trying to humanise North Korean propaganda filmmakers. I found myself in floors at the SBS and ABC that I didn't know existed. They were kind of like being inside... a labyrinth in the tax department where strange people emerged called fact checkers. And I had to sit there for 10 hours at a time going through every single source and corroborating it. Now, that's fantastic. I mean, that's what great journalists should do. But it struck me as... I mean, that's never happened before. This is... These were not the first times I've made contentious films. And it struck me that...
Our public broadcasters are under threat and threatened, and they were nervous, and understandably, and the government is holding, and I'm just going to let you guys leap in here, but it feels to me like they are operating under threat of having their funding removed if they put forward messages that the current government doesn't like. Anna, can I jump in on that as well? I think one of the, perhaps to your question, but also to follow on from that point, I think TV news bulletins are increasingly under pressure, not only because the audiences are shrinking, we know that, but... because everyone is questioning whether whatever is going out on the news bulletin is accurate or not. And I think there is an even greater role to play for documentary makers, like The Foreign Correspondent, to dig in a little bit more and to provide a lot more depth, which admittedly we don't do in BuzzFeed. Our clips are very short. We can't do it. We seem to be saying that that's a bad thing, or implying that, but it's not. Isn't it just about... Isn't it just much more scrutiny of accuracy and facts now? Because I must say, I do think that that is the case. And people get caught up on it more, but that's...
Because errors have got through in the past, in my view. Maybe. But when the ABC's attacked for having a green agenda because they're critical of coal-fired power plants, I mean, this is where the scrutiny to me is intensely critical and worrying. That's definitely a factor, but I think a different thing. And I think the ABC's done a pretty good job of working out how to draw that line. I was just going to say more, all of politics aside, the actual reality of filming now on the ground in a lot of places, maybe not so much in Australia.
In the past six months alone, I mean, I've been fortunate to shoot in Turkey and Venezuela and South Sudan and lots of very curious places where stories need to be told. And that's what traditionally, that's where you get a lot of this great political documentary from. But journalists are actually now, and filmmakers are increasingly physically threatened, whether that's with imprisonment or physical assault or in the cases of many deaths. So stepping into the arena of political documentary does come if you, depending on which way you cut it. I mean, there are stories to be told about coal-fired plants in Australia, which are equally important, but also those, I'm sure there are some in the room here who are interested or do that for their living. And it is, you know, it's tricky.
It's a really difficult environment and that's governments around the world are clamping down on that every day. It's getting out of control, to be honest. So Matt, do you think they'll get to a point where it will be too risky for you? Yeah, you do. There does come a point where things get to a point where you really just got to get out of there. This is actually probably where the phone and the short form...
formats are going to become increasingly important in getting messages out of oppressive states. They aren't just North Korea. These are places that you were backpacking in six months ago but just in recent times have radically enhanced their security or intimidation of journalists, media, filmmakers and bloggers. So there's a question over here. If we could bring the mic down this way. What was that? The hand's gone. Okay, if we could just come over. Okay, we'll go to this one here and then over to later on. So I think we've got two now. We're going to go here first and then I'll go to you, Madam. Hi. That's right, no, we heard.
I think there's a really big distinction to be made between news and current affairs, which is meant to be objective filmmaking and meant to be showing different sides, and between the feature-length political documentary made by the likes of D.A. Penny Baker, Kim Longinotto, Sean McAllister, where there's a real polemic going on and they are taking a side, which is what you were talking about, Anna. And there's a big distinction, and I think it's important to make that distinction because that's what the broadcasters are there for, and there's another forum for those long-form... And a lot of those filmmakers who have made, I think, some of the best political documentaries going way back, they've got a lifetime commitment to politics and to getting a story out there. And can I ask you, what's the most recent film you've seen in that model with a polemic? Well, I mean, it's really interesting because the Wiener film was made by the guy's campaign manager. He was, at one point, the guy's campaign manager and I saw him at Sheffield. And because I sat there watching that doco thinking, how the fuck did he get the access to that guy and how did that guy... I mean, he's a bit of an idiot as well. But also...
It's because he had a really close relationship with him and that is where the model has changed, the kinds of people who are making these films and we're all in the game. I think the most interesting... We've just got to make sure that everyone has a chance to have it. The ones where hunters are having documentaries where it's a whole lot of mobile phones and the documentary is made up of a whole lot of people's records of events, like the sinking of that Italian boat. Can I ask the panel, do you agree that there is and there needs to be this firm distinction between news and current affairs?
which doesn't have a perspective, and then the longer form. is allowed to happen. I imagine, Anna, you wouldn't. Absolutely. I mean, long-form political documentary and long-form documentary tends to be made by filmmakers with a very strong message that they want to communicate and tools that they use to communicate it. You need to sustain an audience's engagement, for one. But I think where the meeting point here is is that although we're all involved in different forms of factual, we are all intent on reaching broad audiences. And what I'm fascinated by in watching the clips that have been shown is that all of us and all of the clips and the people behind them are using similar tools, persuasive tools. They're using humour.
They're using beauty. They're using music. They're using vernacular. They're using authenticity. These are all things that have helped these smaller docs go viral. It's not just because certain voices we've never heard from before are up there. It's also the filmmaking that make these films work for audiences and why some tend to be picked up and some don't because ultimately it's still about entertainment. So, yes, of course, political doco, if you want to do it well, you need to know your subject backwards. But, yeah, anyway, that's...
Can I jump in? Yeah, I just want to hear Maz as well. It might be foolish to pick a fight with Mandy on documentaries. She knows quite a bit about them. But I am curious as to whether the lines are blurring around definitions of documentary because, you know, Penny Baker is an extraordinary filmmaker. But...
We've got new technology now. We've got new platforms. Our audiences are demanding new forms and styles of storytelling from us. And I don't see as clear a distinction between documentary and the type of work that Matt is doing today as perhaps there was 15 years ago. I don't think there is either, yeah. I think the tools are similar now. I think everyone's being driven by similar things. Absolutely, Manny. There's a complete distinction. But I think what we're seeing is aspiration of documentary aesthetic, perhaps. Current Affairs has evolved and continues to evolve in its look and feel.
All of our stories are still in that classic current affairs model where we're not able to be just with Pauline Hanson on her journey. There is for every story, there's always both of those sides. And we are covering them in depth. It's just that, yeah, me personally and other colleagues and contemporaries of mine are trying to push the fold in terms of its look and feel because I feel that younger audiences are just so much more conversational in filmmaking and general aesthetics now. You can't just put the person up and talk your heads as much anymore. So I guess that's where some of that confusion is. But nowhere in my mind is there a confusion that we're making a documentary.
like what Anna has made. I think whoever's got the microphone up there? Yes. If you've got a microphone in your hand, you're the ones talking. Hi.
I am an indigenous filmmaker from the Americas. I'm Bolivian. I also have an Australian passport. I'm Inca descendant. And I don't agree, and I think it's a very dangerous path to say that documentaries, political documentaries, are a propaganda tool because I believe with all my heart that everything that I do is very political, yet I do not have the answers, and I'm not making propaganda for a government. I'm exploring the truth and telling stories of people that I believe in their fights. I don't think they're perfect, and I think complexity is something that we have to discuss, but I would be very dangerous path to call...
political documentary propaganda. I think that there is a wrong word, a wrong connotation to political. We are all political beings. It's my human right to be political today as an indigenous filmmaker. And I think that there is a confusion all over the world. I just came back from shooting a film in Bolivia for The Guardian, I'm sure. And they were trying to scare us, calling us political. They're trying to scare the government, calling everyone political. And by calling you political, it's like they're trying to undermine your argument because you shouldn't be involved in politics. And I think that's wrong. So I think that it's very dangerous to call political documentaries a propaganda tool. It's even more dangerous because we don't have an agenda.
Our agenda is to push the story that we've seen and the truth at that moment in time. Yeah, look, I completely agree. The word propaganda was a provocation at the beginning of this discussion, and I was using it in a very old-fashioned sense in that it is a tool to manipulate or persuade. But absolutely, I agree. Yeah.
I think if you go backwards, actually, it's probably quicker. The shortest distance between three points. Just a quick hook. Yeah, that's right. I'm also worried what you just said, that political's a dirty word, that people use you are political as a way of putting you down. That's really interesting and worrying, as if anyone who is not a politician hasn't the right to be political.
And when you were saying your only agenda is to put out the truth, your truth is seen as political because it contradicts that agenda you just said, which is run by a minority. Yeah, just along a sort of similar line, but on a local, on a national scale, I made a documentary last year that was a political documentary following a character in an election race. And we had... The opposition, the person who was running against him, didn't want to participate. In fact, as first-time filmmakers for ABC got legal letters and things that were quite intimidating. So I wanted to ask the panel their experience because going back to that discussion before, there were some of the news media that we were trying to get help from to help tell the story because we were kind of getting blocked at a few angles to try to make a balanced documentary. And now since then, the newspaper that did cooperate with us and help us tell our story by allowing us access to film certain aspects, they are now owned.
by just one media conglomerate in that state. So, yeah, just how do you guys keep pushing through against, like, when you do feel intimidated? Because essentially the buck stocks with the filmmaker, but ABC is very supportive, et cetera. Yeah, just looking for that. I admire the bravery you guys must go year after year, this kind of thing. So, yeah. Can we have a comment from you guys about responding to threats and pressure? Look, I don't encounter it so much in the Australian space. I mean, I have spent a lot of my career working in the Australian space, but not so much as extreme as some of the recent work I've done. Yeah, I mean, look, there is...
I just play by, I normally am travelling in a group of three and we play by our little rule of thirds. If one person feels like something's really not fitting, doesn't feel right, I'm more than happy to pull out, pull back, just change the way we're trying to capture it. I mean, that's kind of an extreme example of perhaps, but that's the reality. When working in other spaces, I'm a Australian passport holder, so I have certain rights and I'm in another place. If I cross a line, I don't even think about the other side of what happens. So for me, it's just more about common sense and making sure safety is a thing in terms of threats. My threats are more so physical than they are.
defamation letters and things that perhaps you've you encounter my only thing would be is if you believe in what you're trying to say you'll find a way through um but it's hard and you have to find a way through that will take the gatekeepers with you because you can't do it without them so there's a really interesting discussion out there to be had about who the gatekeepers are and are they the right gatekeepers as well and that applies to all sorts of minorities um yeah nicola's buzzfeed ever got political pressure to remove a story Yes, a lot. Are there a range of responses to that? We have editorial policies that very clearly stipulate that we don't remove a story, full stop, unless it's contempt of court.
That's been the only example where a story was published whilst the case was going on. Which one? I can't remember what it was, 18 months ago. But obviously the most recent example for us was actually out of the US. Our global editor-in-chief, Ben Smith, made a decision to publish quite a controversial piece of intelligence and it wasn't a decision taken lightly. It pushed...
pushed the boundaries, I think, of contemporary journalism quite a lot. And we certainly didn't have a lot of allies in doing that. It was publishing a dossier on Trump and his Russian connections, alleged Russian connections. It's still there. It wasn't removed, despite all the pressures. But what I would say to that is that we had someone at the top and he had the support of our CEO and president. And when you have that level of engagement at the very top of your organisation, it makes it easier to do the risky things.
So that doesn't help you necessarily, but that's how it came about for us. I can't believe that, unfortunately, I have to say this, that that is all the time that we have. But I do think that note of the importance of benevolent proprietors and good lawyers is not a bad one to end on because God knows you need them. Ladies and gentlemen, can you please thank our panellists today, Matt, Anna, of course. And also, can we thank Screen New South Wales and AIDC for everything that they've done in this session? And, of course, if you wanted to come around and chat to anyone now, you're more than welcome to, as long as you have a lawyer with you at all times. Can I just also say thanks to Linda? Yes, thanks for the huge amount of preparation, Linda. Thank you, Linda, and Screen New South Wales for making this happen. Thank you, Linda. That was great. Thank you. And thanks, Nicola, of course, as well. Great. Thanks, everyone. You have been listening to an ACMI podcast. For more recordings, go to soundcloud.com slash ACMI online or the ACMI website.