Skip to content
Political tipping points episode artwork

Oct 25, 2025 16 min

Political tipping points

from Pairodocs' Podcasts Hosted by Pairodocs

I’m a slow thinker. It’s why I don’t do Twitter. It takes me a long time to come up with an opinion. I have to keep turning over an issue and looking at it from different angles. I read both sides of an argument. I often find some book on philosophy, poli sci or history that is relevant. And finally after all of that I (might) have an opinion on the subject. So it took me a while to write about the Canadian election, which happened 6 months ago. It was obviously time for a change There is a saying that government is like underwear. After a while it gets dirty and you have to change it. Over time the problems of the day rub off on the once fresh government until it accumulates a stink, and people eventually want something that smells better. The fact that the Liberal government under Trudeau the Younger was 10 years old in 2025 was a strong predictor that it was the Conservatives’ time for electoral success, even if the Libs had been doing a reasonable job. But by any measure, they weren’t. They gave us many reasons to give them the boot. The Libs massively violated civil liberties during COVID. They made it a human rights violation to refuse to call a man who says he is a woman a man. They filled high positions with geniuses like Theresa “Gloryhole” Tam who made us an international laughing stock. They flooded the country with immigrants by increasing immigration rates 15-fold. They massively increased the debt and deficit and rubbed salt into that wound by doing things like paying friends of the party 750 times the original budget for the ArriveCan app. They were debatably the most scandal-ridden government in our history, with so many examples to pick from that Trudeau’s multiple blackface appearances don’t even make the top 10. Obviously there was no way they could win. Right? In the run-up to the election there was a lot of fighting over which poll was more accurate. Conservatives disbelieved polls that pointed Liberal, and vice versa. What was initially a clear lead for the Conservatives shrank and then disappeared under the influence of a clever Liberal campaign which tapped into the most central part of Canadian identity: anti-Americanism. When the Liberals won, many of my conservative friends were surprised and disappointed. I was not surprised. A long socialist slide Western society’s slide towards socialism - including the 2025 Canadian election result - is a predictable outcome of a gradual but inexorable transformation of our collective vision of government’s role in society. Politics - and thus our choice of government - is downstream from culture. Historically, a centralized authority was seen as being a necessary evil, there to prevent your neighbour from killing you and/or stealing your stuff. Food, clothing, and shelter were your own problem. But over generations the Overton window through which we view government’s role has shifted inexorably leftward. As we expect more of government, it has grown to occupy a much larger place in our economy and our day-to-day lives, as I have previously written about: This shift in politics has developed as the belief in positive “rights” has become entrenched in our collective psyche. (You can flip back to another previous Substack for more on positive versus negative rights.) If we have a “right” to an always expanding wish list of services, then government must necessarily take more from productive citizens to provide these things to citizens who are less productive and responsible. A major leftward shift A simple but controversial example. Is it the duty of the state (and therefore the taxpayer) to support a woman who gets pregnant and cannot support her baby? A hundred years ago, even the most extremely progressive politicians would not have thought so. Such a duty was thought to lie with the mother herself, the father, the families involved, and the local community and church. Benevolent societies might help, but were run by volunteers, and contributed to voluntarily. Generations ago, not even the most progressive politician would have suggested the government take on this moral and financial responsibility. In 2025, even the most “far-right” politician would not DARE suggest that such support is not the duty of the government. That is how much the Overton window has shifted. Similar changes have occurred in most realms - housing, education, addictions, healthcare, dental care, child care, and now school lunch programs. There are few areas where we do not now see the government as responsible for providing the needs (and sometimes the wants) of the populace. The mindset that one is responsible for taking care of himself - let alone his family or community - is less and less common, even amongst the more conservative demographic. “Free” stuff is not really free, but rather quite expensive Even some of my conservative friends, after ~1/3 of their taxes went towards healthcare for several decades, were thankful that they “didn’t have to pay” for their healthcare when they finally access the system. Wow, what a bargain! Lucky! The word “free”, when used in place of “taxpayer-funded” is a politician’s trick. When Big Government runs a service, we pay a huge administrative premium on top of the price of the service. Someone must collect taxes. Someone must dole them back to organizations and individuals. Someone needs to be in charge of gender and racial equity. Someone must do an environmental impact assessment. Someone must manage the service delivery. And of course someone still has to actually perform the service. All the extra steps require bureaucrats and functionaries, who have well-paid positions with pensions and benefits. Would you rather pay someone to dig a hole for you, or pay a government administrator to arrange it for you? Does it become “free” if you pay taxes to have it dug? I’ll vote for you if you give me stuff Although politics has always attracted graft and corruption, I do think that we once expected our politicians to be wise. Perhaps I’m over-romanticizing the past (I certainly know that politics has always been dirty) but it seems that we have devolved into pure “pothole politics”: we simply vote for people who promise us the most stuff. “Stuff” paid for with productive citizens’ taxes. Voters who expect the government to give them free stuff vote for politicians who promise free stuff. And this means voting for politicians who are considered good “constituency men”. If you haven’t heard the term, here is an AI summary: My take on the term is less generous. To me, a constituency man is simply someone who people think will get them free stuff. In my former home in industrial Cape Breton - a hyper-unionized and hyper-entitled place with very high rates of “disability”, welfare, and seasonal EI - we constantly vote in good constituency men who will “do anything for ya”. Just as one example: Want support in insisting that your sore back really means you are disabled? No problem! I can’t tell you how many times I have seen this done by “good constituency men”. A colleague’s patient who was later caught building decks under-the-table while collecting compensation for a back too sore to work at the local call centre got a very supportive letter from his MLA when fighting for compensation payments. The politician helped get his constituent free stuff, guaranteeing that vote next election, as well as more votes from family and friends of the happily disabled man who knew the constituency man was someone they could count on. One of Cape Breton’s most prominent/notorious politicians - Dave Dingwall - was famous for stating that he was “entitled to his entitlements” even though it was clear he was pork-barrelling. Despite this he is still beloved, and prominent in our comm… Get full access to Pairodocs’ Collection of Heresy at pairodocs.substack.com/subscribe

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Political tipping points

0:00 16:31

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Pairodocs' Podcasts?

This episode is 16 minutes long.

When was this Pairodocs' Podcasts episode published?

This episode was published on October 25, 2025.

Can I download this Pairodocs' Podcasts episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.