Post Preseason 2025 Rookie Tier List/ Top 12 In & Out

With the preseason behind us, we are going to take what we learned about the 2025 rookie class and revisit our 2025 RDR Rookie Tier list. Who has moved up or down? Join us to find out. After that, we pick players projected in the top 12 of their positions that we think might disappoint and replace them with someone who we expect to perform better than their projected spot.  If you would like to create your version of our rookie tier list, you can do so at this link: https://tiermaker.com/create/rdr-2025-dynasty-rookie-tier-list-18366530.