Poverty isn’t invisible
from On the Commons Podcast Hosted by Antonia Malchik
Where did August go? Into wildfire smoke and the heat of exhausted ecosystems. “What do you notice?” “A lot of grief. And there’s something like . . . an internal flinch. Not a physical flinch, almost a psychological one.” The clinician raised his eyebrows and wrote something down but said nothing. “Okay. Ready?” No. “Yes.” I picked up the little plastic paddles again. This exchange, from a recent therapeutic session, is indicative of my experience of EMDR: a murky, weird journey into my own mind and memories during which I’m encouraged not to force anything or narrate, but simply observe what’s going on, note it, and keep going. EMDR, which stands for “eye movement desensitization and reprocessing therapy,” is a therapeutic treatment that relies on bilateral stimulation and is used primarily to treat trauma. When I first started EMDR, the clinician tipped two fingers back and forth while I followed their movement and let my mind wander where it willed, prompted first by whatever painful memory we’d chosen from the list I’d brought in. Now we do it with small handheld paddles that alternately pulse or vibrate; even with my eyes closed I notice they’re still following the movement back and forth, like a metronome. EMDR was discovered accidentally by Dr. Francine Shapiro in 1987, who was walking in a park when she noticed the effect her own eye movement had on difficult memories. She developed it to treat PTSD in war veterans, and later trained clinicians treating people who’d survived horrific traumas like genocide or mass rape. It’s been shown to be extremely effective for PTSD but, as Stephanie Foo related in her memoir What My Bones Know, it wasn’t intended for the chronic, long-term trauma that’s known as complex trauma or C-PTSD, the kind that can develop from an abusive childhood or relationship. EMDR often doesn’t work in those cases. It didn’t for her, nor for many other people I know with childhood experiences similar to mine. For some reason, it has for me. For the past two years I’ve been doing it almost weekly, with months off now and then because, while EMDR is a surprisingly effective tool for trauma, it’s also exhausting. Many sessions feel almost brutal, a surreal word to use because neither the person being treated nor the clinician is really doing anything. I sit there letting my mind wander—“stop trying to control where it goes,” the clinician has had to constantly remind me—through memories, that day’s stresses, visualizations that have become familiar places in my years of half-assed meditation, dreams both recent and old, worries about my kids, and, reliably, “What am I doing? Is this working? Am I ever going to get ‘better?’ Is the therapist bored?” That last one comes up a lot. A couple months ago I asked if we could try EMDR for what I described as financial fear: all the outsized worries of poverty, of finding myself even more poor than I had been growing up, of the invisibility and dehumanization that accompany poverty. Specifically of living on the streets with my teeth falling out because for some reason that’s what I’m most consistently worried about. My teeth. Maybe that will happen; maybe it won’t. I’d just like to stop being so overrun by fear of it that I find it hard to get my work done, perhaps turning poverty into a self-fulfilling prophecy. The EMDR process aims to take strong emotions like fear and underlying beliefs like “I am unsafe” or “I am unworthy” (there’s a whole list that I keep in the back of my planner, and I can’t say I enjoy tracking down what my frightened inner two- or twelve-year-old is feeling that day) and reframing them into positive cognitions. Nobody knows quite why it’s so effective for PTSD but dozens of clinical trials have shown that it is. All my previous sessions had been focused on single events, specific scenes of violence or abandonment or other cruelty and the associated emotions. My reactions to those sessions are intense. After my very first one I had a splitting headache for two days, and on the third I hid in the cupboard under the stairs to sob for two solid hours. I f*****g hate EMDR. It’s probably saved me from spending the rest of my life lost in a dark labyrinth of disconnected emotions and avoided memories, but it’s painful as hell and it’s hard to see when or how you’ll ever be free of all the grief, fear, and other emotions it brings up. Like you might just be stuck wandering those dark paths forever. It’s worked for me but I hesitate to recommend it to anyone. It’s painful in almost all the ways humans can experience pain. At one point I wondered if facing one’s shadow simply isn’t something most people could or even should handle. The sessions on financial fear have been different from the others. Less intense for one thing. I’ve done several now, and they all seem to lead nowhere except toward an increasingly large, dark mass in the center of my being, a mass that would rather stay hidden. Interestingly, I had a brief conversation just this week with a friend going through a similar process, and she also described coming across some enormous mass. I keep wandering in mental circles, or spirals, or maybe just turning around and around in one spot, opening doors to just about every difficult issue I have ever carried. When I walk away from these sessions, desperate for sleep but needing to get home to make dinner, it’s almost always with the same question: how do variations on these same fears show up in humanity’s worst habits and most destructive societal structures? Which aspects of my own fears are universal? The fear of poverty is inherent in but not exclusive to capitalism—the Soviet Union under communism had poverty. Despite rhetoric about fair and equal distribution, Party leaders had access to privileges and resources not available to anyone else, most of whom, like my father and his family, stood in line for hours for bread or the occasional sausage or fruit. Without wealth inequality and the theft of shared resources for the profit of a few, there would be no poverty, or at least not poverty as we currently conceive of it. No world where a medical emergency or loss of a home or job could mean bankruptcy. Like all words, “poverty” carries its own historical weight. It is a measure of worth in a society designed to be unequal. Scarcity is another story. Fear of starving or freezing to death is primal. I don’t think you could go back far enough in time anywhere on this planet and find people who didn’t face scarcity at one point or another. A winter harsher and longer than usual, a summer scant in berries, a season when the animals were hard to find. In lands like Russia, where my father and stepmother are from, people lived on berries and mushrooms and sometimes meat, the country’s soil being what historians have called agriculturally marginal. Ukraine’s rich, fertile “black earth” soil and access to the Black Sea are two of the reasons Russia’s leaders have persistently tried to take over and control the country. My fears of poverty are informed by a hungry childhood. It’s a fear that threads through my days even though, for now, I have a home and work I love and can feed my kids. It threads just as much through the days of a billionaire who cannot let go of his wealth because anything less might be not enough. Poking at those fears during EMDR sessions have started to convince me that there’s something ancient in them, too, something, yes, universal. When the commons of England were stolen and privatized, and the same damage later inflicted on Scotland and Ireland, it threw people into deeper poverty by taking their homes and means of survival while at the same time making their homelessness and destitution illegal. Many of those same people, both the thieves and the people they stole the commons from, went on to e… Get full access to TRESPASSING at antonia.substack.com/subscribe
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.