Skip to content
Practicing Enterprise Risk Management in CHIPS Manufacturing episode artwork

Jan 6, 2025 26 min

Practicing Enterprise Risk Management in CHIPS Manufacturing

from FLIP THIS RISK® Podcast Hosted by Dr. Karen Hardy

Dr. Karen Hardy speaks with Clio Grillakis about the practice of Enterprise Risk Management within the CHiPs Semiconductor Manufacturing Program at the National Institutes of Standards and Technology (NIST). *An interview clarification: "the United States produces 10% of all semiconductors, not just leading-edge semi-conductors."

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Practicing Enterprise Risk Management in CHIPS Manufacturing

0:00 26:52
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

You're listening to Flip This Risk, where it's time for a new conversation about risk management. From the boardroom, all the way to the barber shop down the street, you can overcome fear of risk and thrive. Join your host, Dr. Karen Hardy, for candid conversations with industry leaders from across the globe.

Dr. Karen brings her experience as an industry thought leader, best-selling author, and apex award winner to each episode. On the forefront of today's risk management strategies, helping leaders from small and large businesses overcome risk and feel confident in their choices. Let's start the show.

Hi, I'm Dr. Karen Hardy, and welcome to Flip This Risk podcast. We'll be interviewing high-achievers about their relationship with risk-taking in their profession and in their careers. You can find out more at flipthisriskpodcast.com.

Today, I'm very excited to have with me Cleo Brilakis. She is the senior advisor with the CHIPS program office. Welcome, Cleo. Thank you, Karen.

It's great to have you here. Listen, could you tell us a little bit about who you are and what you do in your role within your program? Yes, so my name is Cleo. I work for the CHIPS office.

The CHIPS office is under the National Institute of Standards and Technology, or NIST, which is a bureau under the Department of Commerce. And like you said, my title is senior advisor for risk policy, which means that I work directly for the CHIPS professor or CRO of the CHIPS program office. And as part of my role, I lead the enterprise risk management function for the CHIPS program office. Excellent.

You know, one of the things we do here on this podcast, we always want to look at what risk management looks like across various industries. And one of the industries that CHIPS office and program focuses on is manufacturing. What is the state of the manufacturing industry? Yeah, so first I wanted to start off just by explaining what CHIPS are.

So CHIPS or semiconductors are these tiny devices that are in basically all of electronics, like any technology that we use from computers to smartphones, to cars, planes, even an LED light bulb will have a chip in it. So I think that the story of the semiconductor manufacturing industry is honestly similar to a lot of other stories of American manufacturing. The semiconductor was actually invented here in the United States, and we used to be a global leader of semiconductor manufacturing. However, over time, over the years that manufacturing has shifted over to other countries.

We are still the global leader in design and research and development of CHIPS, but actually manufacturing commercially at scale of like the most leading edge logic memory chips. That doesn't happen in the US anymore. We only produce 10% of these types of these leading edge chips. And this is a real problem because, probably because of supply chain issues, you know, during the COVID-19 pandemic, there was a global shortage of CHIPS.

The way that the supply chain works, it's very complicated. And if there's any choke points through the supply chain, it creates these impacts throughout. And that is one of the problems that the CHIPS Act is trying to solve is making sure that one of those supply chain issues doesn't happen again. I'm glad you said that because I think a lot of people heard of CHIPS or acronym, but wasn't really sure what it stood for.

So you did a great job explaining in terms of what the status of the chips were and why it's so important to be your work is so important right now. So you touch briefly on the goals, objectives and benefits. Is there any specific benefit that stands out for you within CHIPS? Yeah, I mean, I think that the overall, so I mean, in short, the goal of the CHIPS Act is to bring manufacturing back to the US.

And ultimately, the goal is to ensure US economic and national security. And that, you know, I mentioned that CHIPS are used in things like cars and computers and stuff, but they're also essential in the defense sector. So making sure that we are securing our national security is a really important goal of the CHIPS Act and again, ensuring economic competitiveness worldwide. So could you explain to us what the organizational structure of the CHIPS program is?

Yes. So the CHIPS office is split into two offices. There is the CHIPS R&D office or research and development. And their goal is really to boost the R&D ecosystem in the US.

And then there's the CHIPS program office or CPO where I sit. And our role is to provide financial incentives in the form of grants and or loans to companies to incentivize them to build CHIPS fabrication facilities or fabs here in the US. That is awesome. The type of work that you're actually involved in structurally as well.

But what about, I think you have mentioned early on in our discussion about an incentive program for manufacturers. Could you tell us more details about what their program is all about? Yeah. So the way it works is that the Department of Commerce releases what are called notice of funding opportunities or NOFOs.

So these NOFOs will be released and they'll include specific eligibility requirements for projects to receive funding. So for example, companies can look at those and see, okay, what type of project do I have to submit in order to be eligible for funding. It also includes the like amount of funding that would be available in relation to the size of the project. Something I should mention is that the CHIPS Act isn't meant to fund the entirety of a fabrication facility.

Chip fabs are billions and billions of dollars. Sometimes they can reach like 10 or $20 billion, which is a huge amount of money. And the goal of the CHIPS program is really to sort of provide enough funding to incentivize private investment incentivize companies to build their fabs here in the US. So commerce will release the NOFOs then companies will apply for funding.

Then there's a process of there's pre-application and then there's application review where the CHIPS program office assesses whether the application has merit based on a variety of eligibility requirements. Essentially, the biggest hurdle that they have to clear is is this project going to ensure the economic and national security of the US. And then there's a process of drafting preliminary terms. If those are signed with the company, then we move on to the due diligence stage.

And after that, assuming that everything is clear and looks good, there's the drafting of the final award documents. And after that, the awards are kind of like signed finalized and we move into post award monitoring and disbursement. And I think another critical part of the program too is that a lot of the way the awards are structured is their milestone based. So the companies actually get money based on achieving milestones, like for example, certain stages of construction completion and or something like equipment installation.

So they're not really getting the money in a lump sound like they have to prove like they've made progress on their construction facilities. Wow. I mean, that's amazing. The type of amount of work and how significant your work is for the USA.

I can only imagine also that manufacturing has common risks, right? Just the industry itself. What are some of the specific risks that you have to be mindful of in your day to day operations? Yeah.

So I'll start. I'll start by first of all explaining our kind of like overarching risk framework here at ZPO. So we think of risk as a sort of pyramid and on the bottom of the pyramid are transaction level risks. So that's sort of the bread and butter of our program, like with each deal or transaction, we're assessing the risks to awarding that money to the applicant, right?

Like to the company, like if we give them this funding, are they going to actually produce this technology? Are there people who are going to be buying their products? Like is the project itself going to be successful? So that's like something that we do.

That's kind of like this little lowest level of the pyramid. Then on top of that is the enterprise level risk or program level risk. That is, these are the risks that threaten achievement of our overarching goals that I mentioned, like chips being able to secure our economic and national security. Are we going to be able to achieve these really like lofty goals that we've put in place?

And then the top of the pyramid is we call like systemic or national risk. These are external risks that we might not have control of, but we are still monitoring and reporting on them. So to go into a little bit more detail on the types of risks in each of those categories. So for transaction level risk, we have sort of a sub framework in that framework where we look at financial risk.

We also assess strategic risk, execution risk, as well as like portfolio and program risk. So we'll look at when we assess financial risk, we'll look at the financial strength of the applicant. We'll also look at the financial strength of the project itself. And if there's a loan, we'll assess credit risk.

And then for strategic risk, we'll look at things like geopolitical risk or supply chain risk. And for execution risk, we assess construction risk and technology risk. Like, are they going to be able to, is this a current technology that already exists? Is this a new technology that doesn't exist that they have to like produce in the future?

And, or like, for example, transfer, transferring technology because building semiconductors is so complicated. There's so many steps involved that even if they're transferring the technology from another country to the US, there is actually a lot of risk in that a lot of times. So many variables that they have to control. So we look at those, we look at program requirement risks, you know, if they're going to be able to meet those requirements.

And like I said, just overall, like is this project, what's the likelihood of this project being successful? Like, do we want to fund it? So that's in this transaction level category. On top of that, we look at enterprise level or program level risks.

And these are risks that include things like process integrity and quality control, making sure that we're applying the same standards across the entire program for every applicant. You know, we're very fast moving program people think of us. We think of ourselves as sort of like the startup of government. But in that, you know, we obviously have logic goals and accelerated timelines, but we want to make sure that we're being really thoughtful and consistent.

And then we look at other things like, you know, the risk of having these accelerated timelines. Are we going to be able to meet the goals, like on the timeframe that we've established for ourselves? Things like that. Like, are we going to be able to close the deals in time?

So those are some examples of those types of risks. And then these systemic or national level risks, those are things like, you know, macroeconomic risk that applies to the entirety of the semiconductor manufacturing industry. Things that, you know, we have to monitor to see how it impacts the portfolio over time, which might not have, you know, we might not have like our controls in place for risks like that. But it is something that we do want to document and monitor.

You're listening to Flip This Risk Podcast with Dr. Karen Hardy. And we'll be right back with more great conversation after this. Do you want to write a book, but don't know where to start?

No worries. We've got you covered. Become a published risk management author with Flip This Risk Books. Flip This Risk Books is an international award-winning book series written by industry subject matter experts and practitioners.

Just like you want to build your professional brand and authority in the field. Write a chapter for our next book series. Visit FlipThisRiskBooks.com You know, you speak a bit about managing different types of risks. Have you found that the implementation of enterprise risk management as a method?

Has that made a difference? Because you're looking at so many risks at each of the different levels. Has the implementation or adoption of enterprise risk management made a difference in your effectiveness for managing so many risks within chips? Oh, definitely.

So I think that, I mean, obviously, assessing transaction risks is essential. But having that wider perspective of enterprise risk management is, you know, you need that perspective in order to make sure that we're on track to achieve our goals. So we have an enterprise risk committee or ERC that meets actually every two months. So it's a pretty like, you know, the cadence is pretty frequent.

And senior leadership is thoughtfully thinking about the risks to the program, you know, continually and thinking about what are the risks to achieve our goals? Like, what are we doing to manage them? And so there's this constant, like, zooming in to, like, specific risks. Like I said, like technology risk is like really specific, but then zooming out to the program level, enterprise level risks.

And it has made a difference because we just wouldn't be able to get to where we're at without that zooming out. We've awarded $25 billion to date. So, I mean, that's just a huge achievement, right? Like being able to get to preliminary terms or final terms with these companies is an incredible amount of work.

And so it needs to be a constant, like, a thoughtfulness on the part of leadership to say, like, are we going to be able to achieve those goals? What obstacles do we need to move out of our way in order to get there? Where your stakeholders, where they easily bought into the practice of enterprise risk management, they automatically see the value of enterprise risk management. When you introduced it to the organization, how was that experience for you?

You know, that's a really good question because I think that a lot of times when introducing ERM into a agency or a program that has existed for a long time, there can be sort of like putting a pet, sort of like a culture class of sorts. But I think, and this is like a kind of success story for the CHIP's program office, the leadership has always wanted to know what the risks are. A goal early on in the program was to go in with this phrase that is repeated often, eyes wide open, to make sure that leadership is taking thoughtful risk and forum decisions. And I think there is just a knowledge, like, throughout the leadership team that, like, they would rather know the risks instead of, you know, ignoring them and praying for the best.

So there was kind of a knowledge that risk management was essential. They wanted to be informed. And yeah, there's a real appetite for for ERM and for risk taking. And I think a good example of that is, you know, I think that risk appetite discussions can often be challenging.

But like we have a risk appetite statement and we refreshed our risk appetite earlier this year. And there was a great discussion of, you know, what types of risks were taking, like the types and amount of risks that were taking as a program and thinking about like, you know, is this the type of risk that we want to be taking? Like, yes, no, like, is this going to get to our goals? Well, your risk appetite statement design around a survey question that you asked senior leadership in terms of, you know, what's within our risk appetite was outside of our risk appetite.

So originally, yes, when the program was very new, it assess senior leaders appetite based on these different categories. And then over time we got data on, since we scored the risks for transaction level risks across the program, we actually have data on, you know, high, medium or low risk taking across the program for these different, like some risks, like supply chain risk, construction risk, things like that. So we were able to aggregate that and present that to management. And even though, like, early on, they said, okay, like, yes, we want to be, we have a high risk appetite for like this type of risk.

We were actually able to kind of like take information of the actual risk taking across a program and present that to leadership and show, you know, you said you wanted to do this, but this is what we're actually doing. Like, do we need to pivot? Like, are you are we comfortable with this? Is there somewhere where we actually need to be taking more risk less risk?

Excellent. And as we come to a close, what about frameworks? I mean, there's many frameworks out here that you can actually follow or model for your organization, something that fits your organization and the culture, the several out here ISO 31,000 is the co so is anyone that your office prescribes to and what has been your experience with that. So we definitely, we look heavily to one VA 123, we want to make sure that we're complying with federal guidance.

And, you know, part of that is, like I mentioned before, we have our enterprise risk committee, which means regular regularly to discuss risks. We have our risk profile with our top list of short term risks, as well as medium and long term risk that we also report out to the RC. We also have our risk register that we manage as well as our risk policy that's documented, you know, the framework that I described that's documented in our policy. And we also have an internal controls program.

So that's kind of like the base of like, okay, we want to make sure that we're complying with federal guidance. On top of that, we also do look to 31 ISO 31,000 just for the best practices of following a standardized risk process to make sure that we're establishing the context, identifying risk, assessing them, prioritizing them, and you know, you know, like, what is the appropriate response? Do we need to mitigate it? Do we need to accept it?

And then, you know, afterwards monitoring and reporting with constant communication. I think that it's important to kind of pick through like a lot of different standards and frameworks. And of course, the RM is sort of like one size fits all it needs to be tailored to that specific program. So I think that once you comply with the federal best practices, it's always good to look to these other areas to see kind of like how to improve and mature.

So let's say like what are the top three success factors for you now you've been doing this for a while and adding in doing enterprise management within your program what is one of two success factors you want to leave with people. Yeah, I mean I think that, you know, this program is, it's very ambitious right. I think that's something to, I think that like you're not going to get to wherever you want to go unless you are ambitious. The chips act has like dedicated has 50 billion dollars dedicated to it right.

And it has this like very ambitious goal of bringing chip production manufacturing back to the US. And I think having, even though it's very challenging and I think a lot of people here at the chips program office have been working really hard over the past few years. And so I think that we could get to where we're at now without that level of kind of like lofty ambitious goals. And then secondly, I think that this concept of going in eyes wide open.

I feel like that's a really important success factor, knowing the amount and types of risks that you want to take in order to achieve your goals. That is essential for all levels of the program and then most importantly, you know, leadership to make sure that they're guiding the program in the right direction. And so, I think that's something I want to mention is, or like leave people with is the, this idea of the program being sort of like long term. The, these fabrication facilities can often take like years to construct years to reduce chips.

And, you know, we're doing a lot of work now, a lot of really important work on ordering the funds is sometimes can take what feels like a long time to do this sort of like thoughtful due diligence. And ultimately, we might not see the impacts or the successes for years to come. And that's really in this like next phase of the program of project and award monitoring. But I think that's good to keep in mind because, you know, this isn't going to be completed in like the next one year, the next two years, it's going to take a long time to see the ultimate benefits, hopefully positive benefits of the program.

I wouldn't think anything less. Listen, we all want to thank you so much for joining us today to talk about chips and how you manage risk and enterprise risk management in a program within a manufacturing sector really appreciate your time. Thank you so much, Karen. And I want to thank everyone for joining us today.

I'm Dr. Karen Hardy and I'll catch you next time.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of FLIP THIS RISK® Podcast?

This episode is 26 minutes long.

When was this FLIP THIS RISK® Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on January 6, 2025.

Can I download this FLIP THIS RISK® Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.