Hello and welcome to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from 2SCR in Sydney on the Gadigal lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast, I'm Monica Atter. This week we're talking about the difficulties of working as a journalist in exile, and many journalists are at the moment as war and conflict swirls the world. This interview was where another podcast called Double Take, produced by the Centre I Work at the Centre for Media Transition.
The abrupt fall of Kabul to the Taliban on August 15, 2021 marked a devastating blow to civil liberties and human rights in Afghanistan, and indeed over the past two years, the Taliban have systematically reintroduced restrictions reminiscent of the 1990s, with journalism as one of the most affected professions. There's been a mass exodus of journalists from both the profession and the country, of approximately 12,000 journalists, both male and female, present in Afghanistan in 2021, over two-thirds have abandoned their profession. Alarmingly, more than 80% of the country's women journalists have been compelled to stop work. Reporters without borders also report a grim scenario.
More than half of the country's media outlets have vanished. Surveillance and censorship of journalists has reached unprecedented levels and so have threats to their lives. Amongst those journalists who fled Afghanistan is Zara Nada, founder of Zand Times, a Canadian-based news website offering opportunities for Afghan women journalists both within and outside Afghanistan to continue reporting on the Taliban regime. In this interview, CMT postdoctoral research fellow Aisha Jahangir speaks with Zhaqar about Zara Times, the challenges of practicing journalism in exile and the safety concerns faced by women journalists.
Thank you so much, Zara, for giving us your time. I would like to start by asking you if you can introduce yourself briefly and share a bit about your background as a journalist in Afghanistan and the reasons that led to your exile. Thank you so much for giving me the time and opportunity to speak. My name is Zhaqar Nada.
I am editor-in-chief of Zand Times. Zand Times is an Afghan woman-led media that covers human rights relations in Afghanistan. They started this organization last in the early lunch this in August 2022, one year after the Taliban takeover of Afghanistan. And that's what that the reason behind creation of this news website was we wanted to be able as Afghan women journalists tell our own stories and be able to inform an audience outside Afghanistan about the situation of women in the worst country to be women.
About my background, I have been a journalist in Afghanistan. Mostly I started my work as a journalist in 2011, late 2010, and worked mostly with the local media in Afghanistan. And later on I joined the New York Times Bureau in Kabul. Of course, during my time in Afghanistan, I experienced discrimination on the base of gender and the base of ethnic.
And that was something that I do talk a lot about. But then I moved to Canada in 2017. I moved to Canada. The situation in Afghanistan was not good in terms of security and everything.
And I had a son. So I wanted to be able to give the chances that I didn't have in life to my son. So he would be able to go to school. My husband was in Canada.
So we moved to Canada. I'm here right now based. And when I came to Canada, I started my school. I did a master in communication and culture.
And right now I'm a PhD student, although technically I'm in a year off. But yeah, I'm a PhD student studying on women and gender studies. With this definition of journalism evolving, you know, to fit and reflect the contemporary reporting practices, how would you define the type of journalism that sometimes does? Or in other words, where would you place sometimes on this broad spectrum of journalism?
I would say that this is a kind of journalism that comes from our heart. It is start with our sense of responsibility that first we start this work knowing that we have been a journalist in Afghanistan. We know the challenge is the problem that we use to face before the Taliban take over. But then the Taliban take over.
One thing that's clear for us that there is, we know who the Taliban are and we know how they treat women. So we know women will be the first group of people in Afghanistan who will be subject to oppression, to discrimination. And as right now, we can see their subject to systematic erasure from social and public life. And we felt that it was a responsibility to be there and to help women in Afghanistan raise their voice and ensure that their voice is heard to, you know, like through the work that we are doing, our focus is to cover the lives of the most marginalized in Afghanistan, but particularly women.
And the way we do it is we work with a group of women journalists in Afghanistan. To answer your question, I would just say that this is where work is mostly fact-checked. So we go and we report about women's lives, we are connected with women in the communities, women who are working in different provinces in Afghanistan. And they are able to keep us informed about the situation of women.
We don't know about what the Taliban are saying because if you can see some of the media saying, hey, the Taliban are saying that they're going to do this, they're going to do that. We stick with the fact of what has happened when the Taliban are doing and how the people, the population of Afghanistan are experiencing those policies. So would it be right if I say from looking at stories that the Zung Times has covered since its launch that you focus mostly on humanitarian and peace journalism? Would that be right?
I would just say, yes, this is an organization that will be specifically covered human rights issues in Afghanistan, but of course, our lenses that we try to cover the issues that are most and they're reported in Afghanistan, mostly about women and LGBTQ rights, and of course, about the environment that we don't even talk about. So that's the lens we use. Peace, of course, is something to be engaged with. But as far as I can remember, when I was born, there was a war in Afghanistan and I'm living in the world is still going on.
So people, something that is hard for us as Afghans to think about it and to just really feel what it really means, you have to have an understanding. For us, it's hard to understand it, to grasp it, because we don't know, when we were born, there was a war and we don't know it's through meaning right now. It's surely heartbreaking. I was looking at the website and I noticed that there are options in English language and the very language, which is one of the national languages of Afghanistan, is excluding the Pashto language, which is also one of the national languages, a deliberate choice, or was it a result of challenges in finding Pashtoon women reporters to work for some time?
No, actually, it's interesting because we do have a lot of Pashtoon women working for us, working with us. I have a great colleague, her name is Pashto Gani, she is from Pashtoon ethnicity, she's a writer and one of her book has been published, some of her stories have been published in a book called My Pen is the Bing of a Bird, it's a collection of stories written by Afghan woman. So my colleague has been published there and she's been a longtime writer, so she is one of our editors working for us and we do have female journalists who speak Pashtoon, who themselves are Pashtoon, and they're working in different provinces due to security, on to name, in which province they are, but they are working with us. This is a very good question of asking why we don't have a Pashto website.
We are very interested to have a Pashto website, however, due to the financial restrictions that we have, we started this organization without own savings, so we didn't start this with the funding with the project. So we didn't have the money to be able to pay, you know, like to expand the work, because you need more resources, more people to come and work on the team, we didn't have that and still we don't have it. So as soon as we are able to have the resources, the means we would love to have our Pashto website lunch, this is in our plan for the future that we have the funding for it. It's not an intentional decision to not have a Pashto website.
Well, that would be very interesting to see a Pashto page as well. Speaking of funding, you mentioned that you started this initiative from yours and your colleagues, the spent day person savings. So how are you now financially sustaining this project? Do you have funding from other organizations to keep this going on?
Yes, we, unfortunately, for us, once we started our work and showed that what we already capable of, we started applying for grants here and there, mostly through the organization that are supporting media organization. So we have some small funding from organizations like InterNews, IWML organizations like the PortEsc but we still need funding in terms of being able to cover the cost of the entire cost of our operation. One of the things we struggle to cover is for example, legal fees and also to be able to have insurance for our team that are working, especially in Afghanistan, we would love to be able to have health insurance, possibly life insurance. Those are the things that is not in our reach because we started this work with our own savings and slowly we are getting this funding which is help us to survive to continue the work that we are doing, but this is not enough.
So we don't have the funding that we would love to have in order to deliver what we really want to deliver. So this is the best we can do with the means we have right now. So I understand that you talked about the challenges of being a journalist in Afghanistan and it's no hidden fact of the challenges that journalists and specifically women journalists have been facing since the Taliban took over. What challenges you faced as a journalist in exile and specifically now that you've started an initiative that also engages around women journalists to report from their homeland?
Thank you for that question. I think my problem is like I can categorize it in two fields. So I started this work as a journalist so I didn't have prior experience of leadership or media management. So to manage a team this was my first experience and this was very difficult and challenging because the work was online mostly.
My colleagues are inside Afghanistan and also in exactly different countries. So it's hard to manage in the first place at task force that's working online and secondly we are working in an environment like we are basically a woman going out and on is problematic for the ruling regime. They would be subject to of course many many policies many many misogynist rules that the Taliban have created. So this was of course a big challenge for our team that's mostly women journalists working Afghanistan.
So we have to come up with base to enable them to continue their work while trying to minimize the risk. So minimizing risk is not something easy. So it's something that we negotiate every day of like do we publish this information? Do we not publish?
And when we are talking about the safe farting we are talking about two groups one is our journalist how do we keep them safe and then also people that we are covering the PD stories that our colleagues are collecting on the ground and telling those stories how can we ensure that those people remain safe. This has been the biggest challenge for me and also beside that like the issue of raising money is like I don't have any experience in fundraising. So it's very difficult to think about okay how do I keep them safe and then how do I pay them at the end of the month. This has been to my biggest challenge so far and yeah yeah and so what about your ability to report on events in Afghanistan has living in exile impacted your ability to reach your network or report on an issue or an event for that matter.
I think not very much in some cases it has been even good because when I call from outside of Afghanistan I tell people hey I'm calling you from Canada and like this is who I am and I try to establish trust with them. Of course it's very hard for the people in Afghanistan because they're scared especially the people who are subject to rights violations and their family member have been killed they have been themselves targeted so it's very very hard for them to come and speak out about these violations knowing that anytime the Taliban might be able to access them and retaliate for speaking to the media so it's very difficult for them and sometimes in some cases like when my colleagues are not able to talk to people inside of Afghanistan they share their number so some of us from outside the country would call to ensure that first they understand that we are not in the hands of the Taliban you know that's very scary to think that okay if I am willing to talk to the journalists within side of Afghanistan and but if this journalist is being arrested by the Taliban so of course the interview all the information will be you know at the hands of the Taliban so that even scary so but for us sometimes when I call I first tell them who I am we are I'm calling from and sometimes it's a good thing because they are able to you know like I saw every leaf that yeah like okay thanks god she's not in Afghanistan so if I talk to her I know that she will not be arrested by the Taliban and this information will not get in the hands of the Taliban so sometimes that have been a way for me that's enabled me to continue and do my work and of course building a rapport is a very important thing especially when you're reporting on issues that are very sensitive that issues that can people put people's lives in risk yeah for me I think it has been it enabled me to do this work for the sake of my listeners specifically those who are not very well aware of the challenges of journalists in Afghanistan specifically another Taliban regime what safety concerns do you have for them what can the Taliban do to them well like I can't even talk about that because that's my worst nightmare is that if one of my colleagues is being caught by the Taliban that's gonna happen to them so I try most of the time avoid thinking about that because it's worst scenarios we are seeing like a journalist who have been in prison for months without the Taliban even stating like what is their crime but they have done to be imprisoned and so we have seen we know the risk is there it's up to as of how can we negotiate this risk in a way that our colleagues can continue their work while not being caught by the Taliban so we started one of the policy that we have is all of our team members and the fathers should be using their pen name or so the name and wish they will be writing and that's the name that even they contacted people they will be using their own so the name and as a way to establish connection with the people that they will be interviewing because if they use their real name it's very easy to get caught you know like somebody can tell to the Taliban yes this is the person who interviewed me this is the information so the first thing is about their name and also we ask them to not talk about their work with us to anybody and to their friends so we don't want anybody to know that they're associated with us because being associated with the media like sometimes that advocates for women's rights for LGBT rights is not something easy the Taliban particularly despises because of the issue that we cover so it's very important that we keep our colleagues safe one of the missions that we have taken is also our team doesn't know each other inside Afghanistan they are connected individually with editors outside the country this is also because of their safety because if they're in a same group it's very easy to chat with another colleague that's in another province asking no talking and then eventually you know who they are so we don't even take this chance we put them in a one single group here they can identify or talk or see each other's one number so they're going to make a bit of a denial and beside that also one of the requirement is that we do not want them to speak with the Taliban so if we need to get a comment from the Taliban officials it is some of us from outside Afghanistan that we'll call and speak with the Taliban in order to minimize the interaction that some of our colleagues in Afghanistan might have with the Taliban these are some of the ways that you're trying to keep ourselves safe but I think to just say like it's easy to be generous in Afghanistan it's not and especially for women's very difficult because they cannot go outside alone most of our women colleagues either go out with their father their brother or their husband in order to be able to continue their work and of course it's it's very very difficult for them especially in Afghanistan we understand that safety is very important and from your response I can see that you are keeping your journalists safe and I know that there are some cons to the fact that when you don't know your team members but I think safety concerns are really important I would you talked about keeping them safe and and that they report and they do not even know each other when they're voting I was thinking how what's the frequency of reports that they need to file in are they required a specific set a number of reports for a month how does that flow goals do you assign them do they pick stories how does that work so the picking of the story is mostly between the journalists and editors so if the journalists have any idea they would share the idea with the editor and then the editor will bring it to a editorial team here five of us will say that we talk the idea of is there a good story for us can we work on it in terms of risk what risk this story has is it even possible to think about working on this and if yes who's gonna who would be able to do this work who should we reach out to sort a question like that but sometimes when our colleagues and friends and they don't they say like I don't know what to work on you know like I don't have any story idea it's me suggest them okay we think maybe this story is a good one to work on and we give them the idea and they will go and work on it we don't have a category or code out to per se say that this is like we want you to work this many stories each month and if you didn't bring it there is an app punishment for you because we understand the security risk is there so we first of all we make our colleagues to make that judgment whether this is story something that they can work on it or not if they did this is too risky for them this is something that they cannot go and interview people about or get covered the story they would just say you know like I can do this so we will rework that story or assign it to somebody else who is able to work or like keep it for sometimes if you understand that none of our colleagues are able to work on this so we keep that aside and see maybe in the future we might be able to work on but this is very much our colleagues make the judgment and this is also up to like you know in the times that they are so we tell them so most of the way that we work is that we don't cover one story in one province we have like in a way that we pay attention to one issue in different provinces so this way even when we work in one topic we ask several of our colleagues who are in different province to collect information about that particular story yeah that just raised a question about collaborations and partnerships and I understand that sometimes did the collaboration with the Guardian and I think the full-on project I would like you I would like to know about any collaborations that you have been able to do with other media organizations or joint lists or even other institutions to enhance the reach and impact of fear-boarding we have been very interested in partnering with other organizations we have done as you said we have done this with the Guardian and Fuller project and we have had the help of women in use they reproduce some of their stories that they have published and also impact news later in France they also did translate it actually to three media in France did retranslated our work into French and published this so we have done some of those works but I think the main point for us is that we just started a page that's called like if you want to partner contact us because we do have the means the general is on the ground and if any media outside Afghanistan is interested to cover some of the issues and the topics that we cover they can come to us it's going to be working two ways sometimes they have the story idea they just don't have the reporters on the ground to cover it so they can come with the idea with us we will discuss that idea whether that's feasible for our team can we do that investigation or not and then if we can do that so we can publish that story together and hopefully that media can also help as with the cost of producing that story and at the same time for the other one is like we are working and we are all the time working on different stories and this is stories that we are working we can share them like the ideas we can share them with any media organization that's interested and to publish so they can come and ask that like okay what ideas are you working so we can share a little bit of the ideas and if they're interested we can partner together yeah great can you tell our listeners a bit more about the project that you did with the Guardian and the Fuller project yes so this is story but we look into the race of suicide in Afghanistan because even initially when Taliban takeover we were seeing a lot of news about how women are killing themselves individually in this province that province and of course we noticed that these women were very young and so we discussed and decided to work this as a investigation we are we would be able to get us some data in terms of putting some numbers of like how many women are trying to kill themselves or how many women are actually have killed themselves since the Taliban takeover we find this to be very very difficult because before the Taliban we would go to health officials and they would have been able to share some data with us if they collected them but now we know that the Taliban the official are actually the one that prevented us from accessing such a data so we had no hope that we would be able to access any data going through the Taliban officials so what we did is that we used a very grassroots approach we are we contacted and speak with health workers themselves in different provinces in different clinics mental health wards the event and we interviewed different sources in order to make sure that's what's the data and first one of the things that most of the doctors told us was that the Taliban issued a verbal directive telling them that you're not allowed to share any information with the media that the Taliban do not know about so the any media that wants to speak with the health workers they should go to first the Taliban ministry information and culture get a letter from them and then go to the hospital and talk with them that's how they told us that they've been told and some of them asked us to do the same thing but of course that was not possible for us what we did was to since some of these health workers already knew us most of our journalists in Afghanistan that we were working and some of the sources already knew us and trusted us so we had not any we didn't have a lot of problem convincing them to share the data with us but for some of them who didn't have any connections so it took us a while to be able to establish a trust with them and ensure that they can trust us and also he can trust them you know like to ensure that they're not going to go report us in the Taliban so we were able to gather some data from 11 provinces of Afghanistan. We had it shows in 10 out of 11 provinces women were outnumbering many actual suicide and attempted suicide so it took a big investigation for us and it took us eight months but eventually we were happy with the result that it brings some attention to the situation of women in Afghanistan and show that what the Taliban policies actually meaning on the ground for these women for example because we have also hearing that most of the suicide cases came to the hospital and that some of the doctors been told that if the issue is related to a family issue you get the reason for this it's like you know a family issue so they don't usually report this you know as a suicide and also the society is very conservative so they're not easily saying that yes this woman has been killed herself because of the you know like suicide is being seen as a taboo and people are and islamic so people are not going to go out and speak about it oh there's a lot of stigma around it yeah definitely it's there is but then that would also prevent people so if you if somebody died in the house with suicide there that is not registered anywhere that we can go and fight actually even if you go and speak to the family and ask why this woman she was very young she was not sick why she's dead they would come up with some idea they're not going to tell you that yes she can be the suicide so that's the situation and the environment and of course if we were able to get the truth is much like you know like the number the scale is much higher than we can be higher yeah i would like to talk a little bit about your audience engagement how do you engage with your audience particularly the of Han women whether they're in anistan or as ds where i know the past of the world and what kind of a bad view hope to have on these women so we are reporting hmm first of i think about the relationship i think i'm very fortunate to say that in the past two years that i'm working and covering women's issues particularly women's issues in afghanistan many women have reached out to me from you know in different countries in diaspora and some of them offered of course offered help some of them are struggling themselves some write their own stories and send it to us and say like this is what happened to me for example today we had a story this young woman actually messaged me on facebook and she said this is my story this is this is what happened to me and i need help and i want to be able to tell my story so like i connected with my team and i said like write your story we will eat it we will translate it and we will publish this for you so this is the kind of you know like they would come and also like we have email address so sometimes they would send send message to our email address sometimes they would reach out to social media of zentimes and send your story and what's happening and we had many women also asking for work they're saying do you have they not job for me i want to work and i really really need the work fortunately for most of them we have to say no because we don't have the means to offer them a job but if we're here and there we can offer them you know like just a piece of writing that they can do for us definitely we would ask them to help us outside that i would just say that it's very difficult even especially for the women who were able to fully afghanistan for the woman just they ended up somewhere that most of them doesn't know the language of the country they're in they don't know the culture so they have a whole new life in front of them and they are heartbroken that what they have worked for like for example if they were in journalism they build a carrier for themselves in a pond that's not that carriers gone and they most of them they have to start from scratch and they are often forced to do very precarious jobs i would like to know about technology in reporting as well as as we understand that your team is dispersed across a vinistan and the avantias were across the world so technology must play a very important role so can you share how technology has played a role in facilitating or even hindering for that matter your ability to to report from exile what i mean to ask is how do you adapt to new technological developments such as open source intelligence tools for example oh i think fundamentally in like this technology social media and internet have a lot to do with our work because initially as i told you our work is online entirely so if we don't have internet we don't have technology that means that ever working not possible so the one thing that made ever possible was availability to use this technology and internet and be able to connect with each other to talk with each other to share materials and also work and also that's how also a college from afghanistan send the material so of course this is very important for us and it enabled us to do our work and of course there might be a lot of challenge the challenge with technology because we know there's lots of hacking phishing that are of course very new for us and we are trying to learn so how do you balance advocacy for the cause and then objective journalism is that challenging is this is this even possible to navigate this balance especially when you're reporting on issues related to one of the most oppressed communities in the vinistan with charl women i think i also said this earlier that for us we are one of the media organizations that we cover the facts that are on the ground so we don't speak about you know like this is what the Taliban are saying we cover what the Taliban policies actually mean on the ground for the people who are leaving those policies for example when the Taliban ban woman from visiting outside like without the mahram of course the policies stated that 72 kilometers if i'm not mistaken 72 kilometers they have to go as far as 72 kilometers to be needing a male shepherd with themselves but we know from working on the ground that that's not true many women have to have a male shepherd with them when they leave their house even to go and visit a doctor and particularly a doctor there are many clinics who have been told by the Taliban that they should not be visiting any woman or treating any woman who come alone who doesn't have them so i have personally reported on those issues so it's different from how you know like the Taliban issue at the degree but then how it comes to be applied to the lives of this woman and they cover this population because they don't have a they don't have really voice in the public sphere to make their own opinion to just share their suffering of what's happening and how they are experiencing these days this policy that the Taliban go and just issue issue especially targeting women but what that really means in the lives of women that's what we're interested in and i would end to say that yes our work is advocacy but i really hope that this is what we do i believe it's journalism because we stay with the facts of what's happening around not what we said about what's happening and also but i will hope that our work can lead eventually to advocacy where people can see what's happening and take action so our step that we hope to reach is to raise awareness and from there we empower people to take action to change the situation on a last note i'm loving this conversation and i can go on and on with this era but i you are living in in a western society and so am i and so we understand that there is a difference in how people non-avans or people who've never been to a vinaigvan is not very well aware of the culture and the politics they understand the situation a bit differently so on the last note i would like to ask you how do you perceive the international communities understanding of the situation in an Afghanistan and what role can journalists whether in an in a vinaigvan or specifically like you are in exile play in shaping these perspectives international communities perspectives and understanding thank you so much for that question the way i perceive the international community's response to the crisis in a faunestan is unfortunately a combination of the Taliban the way i see that is when the Taliban take over they did not immediately ban all the areas of or all human rights for afghan women they started slowly that in their second week in power they banned women from working in public sector in their first month they banned women they banned girls from going to school and in four months you know they banned women from going out without the male chaperon so you see the slowly the Taliban were creating their gender apartheid in afghanistan what happened was that international community did not have a solid collective response to this violation of human rights in afghanistan and that in a way accommodated the Taliban allowed them to implement their policies because when the Taliban issued one policies that districts women drive in afghanistan this international community would come and issue a statement different countries different organizations that they think that all like is awful what the Taliban are doing is bad and they should be reversing but they never did reverse nothing happened there was only words exchanged this country said that this should not be happening but it had happened and there was no action to punish the Taliban or to force them to reverse their policies otherwise they will not be doing so we know that the Taliban are the kind of group who came and talk about things but they do as they wish they want to build Afghanistan is not a human society in that society to state the least women have no role women have no rights and i think this should be seen as a crisis as a global crisis for human rights for women's otherwise if you only look at this issue about oh it's about afghanistan i think that's not the correct way to look at the issue because what happens to women in afonesan it has consequences for women's right globally it brings the born law of what could be denied to women and there will be no consequences as we can see with the Taliban so that's what i see the response of international community and i think the Taliban it's not as it seems that oh there is no way to pressure the Taliban the Taliban wants to engage with the world the Taliban wants the money to be able to run their regime there's a lot of things take and i think the international community if they can come together and make decisions collective decisions to you know face the Taliban and in a way that they would just say this is not tolerable and we will not be tolerating this and i think there should be ways to change this and that has not happened yet in the past two years and then we are hoping to be able to do that and for your second question i think we all have responsibility for me personally i grew up in Kabul i had rights i was able to go to school i went to university and i became a journalist in afonesan that right is now denied to millions of women in afonesan and this is why responsibility to fight for their rights to ensure they have the rights that i at least i had of course i'm pushing for more rights but that didn't happen but this is our responsibility to make sure that they have at least the rights that we had and i think we don't need to do anything you know like very big to be able to bring we are ever we are with whatever we have we can start from there and of course at least for ourselves we feel good that we did what we could and at this difficult time and to contribute to our society and to deliver on our promises and our commitment to our country and definitely your dedication to journalism and responsible journalism that you do and and of course indeed your bravery as well is and is an example to all aspiring journalists in Afghanistan and in other conflict zones so thank you so much zara for taking your precious time and talking to double take here today of course thank you alisha for having me zara nade from the zan times for taking part and to aishu jahangi from the cnt and thanks for listening to the program this edition was recorded at the studios of two sia and heard across the country on the community radio network for the state is produced with the assistance of the community broadcasting foundation thanks for the foundation for their continuing support make sure you subscribe to for the state on your favorite podcast app so that you can hear us talk about media politics and of course everything in between we're back next week with more in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on twitter and handle their instagrams.com.au and we're also on threads unlike atard thank you for listening