EPISODE · Mar 18, 2026 · 36 MIN
Pre-Internet Lies We All Believed
from Hoot’n & Holler’n With Matt Mitchell · host Matt Mitchell
Before Google, before smartphones, before you could fact-check anything in 2 seconds… we just believed stuff. In this episode, the guys dive into the wild world of pre-internet urban legends—the rumors, myths, and straight-up lies that somehow spread across the country with zero proof and 100% confidence. From Marilyn Manson being that kid from The Wonder Years, to Pop Rocks and Coke “killing you,” to every town having a Crybaby Bridge, we break down the stories we all heard growing up—and why we believed every single one of them. We also get into: The Satanic Panic and the stuff people thought was “evil” The rumor that Procter & Gamble was secretly sinister Small-town legends like hitman capital of the world And the weird ways these stories spread before the internet even existed If you grew up in the 80s, 90s, or early 2000s, there’s a very good chance you believed at least one of these… and probably repeated it like it was fact. Subscribe for more episodes of Hoot’n & Holler’n every week.
What this episode covers
Before Google, before smartphones, before you could fact-check anything in 2 seconds… we just believed stuff. In this episode, the guys dive into the wild world of pre-internet urban legends—the rumors, myths, and straight-up lies that somehow spread across the country with zero proof and 100% confidence. From Marilyn Manson being that kid from The Wonder Years, to Pop Rocks and Coke “killing you,” to every town having a Crybaby Bridge, we break down the stories we all heard growing up—and why we believed every single one of them. We also get into: The Satanic Panic and the stuff people thought was “evil” The rumor that Procter & Gamble was secretly sinister Small-town legends like hitman capital of the world And the weird ways these stories spread before the internet even existed If you grew up in the 80s, 90s, or early 2000s, there’s a very good chance you believed at least one of these… and probably repeated it like it was fact. Subscribe for more episodes of Hoot’n & Holler’n every week.
NOW PLAYING
Pre-Internet Lies We All Believed
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
Mar 26, 2026 ·1m
Jan 2, 2026 ·47m
Dec 21, 2025 ·46m