This episode is brought to you by Octavia. You might already be eating yogurt, but not all yogurts are created equal. Octavia contains over 1 billion probiotics per serving to survive and reach the gut alive. When it comes to gut health, Octavia is the number one family doctor recommended probiotic yogurt brand.
Choose Octavia. Feel good from the inside out. Visit Octavia.ca for more details. Hello and welcome.
You're listening to Fourth Estate, where the show where journalists talk journalism coming to you from Twixiara and Sydney on the Gadigal lands of your nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device, across the globe via podcast. My name is Peter Fray, and I'm the co-director of the Centre for Media Transition at the University of Technology Sydney, and my producers are at the doctoral and junior car, Katsal. Today's show is all about shining some light on a dark and chilling week in Australian journalism. As you probably know, not one but two media organisations, news corporations and the ABC, have been targeted by raids by the Federal Police, who were searching for documents and other evidence.
In a separate manner, a commercial radio presenter, Ben Fordham, was warned off of simply reporting that up to six new boatloads of asylum seekers were on their way to Australia. But the raids, the raids were long and invasive. In the case of the news, news, corp, journal, and Nikka Smith, the cops turned out to be at her home and spent the day basically going through her home computer and other places where they might find some evidence. And in the other matter, several plane closed offices visited the Ultramill office of the ABC, again spending up to about eight hours, sifting through data and documents and computers.
Both cases involved the leaking of sensitive national security secrets. And the AFP says the raids were not directed by the government, and they were not intended to intimidate journals. But in both cases, the police were looking to chase down the leakers, the whistle blowers, and they may also be looking rather chilling to the journalists involved. That's not yet clear, but it is possible.
So the AFP says it's basically doing its job to protect the national security. Well, I would say, and I'm sure our panel will say, that journals were simply doing their job of holding the powerful to account and publishing secrets. In the News Corp case, the secrets were plans to allow the defense by agency the DSD to use its surveillance powers against us, against Australian citizens. And in the ABC's case, the allegations were involving the activities of Australian Special Soldiers, Special Service Soldiers serving in Afghanistan more than a minute.
Both stories were undoubtedly in the national interest, embarrassing as they may have been for the government and its agencies. So let's just briefly put in a bit of context here. There is nothing new about cops raiding journals, about cops tracking down the source of leaks, and pursuing editors, publishers, and reporters. What's unprecedented here is the concentrated nature of the action, two or three, in a short space of time.
The all-encompassing nature of the search warrants, especially in the ABC case, where the police had the power to not only search for information, but also delete, yes, delete information. And the outrage prompted by the raids across the news and media industry, and anyone else committed to press freedom. There is a palpable sense of shock. There is a real sense of unity among journals and their supporters.
So today I want to explore what next, whether the outrage lasts, and if so, to what end? Is this a watershed moment for press freedom in this country, or will, as when journal with first-hand experience of being raided told me earlier today, the outrage will be over by Sunday? His point is that both the main parties, the coalition and the labor, passed tough security legislation last year. So there is another unity ticket going on, if you like, and that is politicians sticking together and only paying lip service to press freedom, it matters involving national security.
So who knew that Peter doesn't be such a persuasive guy? I can explore these and other questions with the fabulous panel in a minute or two, but first I canvas a few of the views of journalists working at the Colface and a media scholar with some expertise in the area. Damien Cave, the head of the New York Times's Bureau in Australia, has suggested that Australia may be the world's most secretive democracy as a result of these raids. Damien joins me on the line now.
Hello, Damien. Hi. So maybe you can expand on that a bit, because that's quite a claim. Yeah, I mean, this isn't my claim.
This is a claim of experts who know Australian law and democracy even better than me. And they're argument that you just have to look at the evidence. I mean, these raids are just the latest example of a trend that's been going on for a long time, but especially since 9-11, where laws have been added and amended to make secrecy, the dominant law of the land. It's all based on many of this stuff on a law from 1914, which was used for the war in the A.B.C.
And it basically says that no one can share anything with their bosses' permission, right? That's what the law says. And if you take that and then you add to that all these layers of new laws, more than 60, since 9-11, go to any other democracy in the world, you end up with a country that is arguably the most secretive democracy in the world. I don't think that actually is surprising or shocking to those who really look at this stuff with international perspective.
But when you were sent, when you came here a few years ago, at no point would you have thought, hey, I'm going off to the world's most secretive democracy, right? No, I'm not. I mean, the image that Australia sends out to the world is look at how open and want we are. And I think that's very much a part of the national character, but the divide between the way government works and the way the culture works is enormous.
And a lot of Australians maybe haven't even recognized themselves. This power grab, this degree of overreach the government has been engaged in for really quite a long time. A final question. Do you think this is the events of the last few days are a sort of watershed?
I'm really curious to see if that's the case. I think it's really interesting that these rates of government is targeting a wide range of journalists from news Corp to the ABC, and they're targeting stories that are kind of quite clearly in the public interest. So this has the potential to really change the game, at least in terms of media in terms of momentum. Many of us have been talking privately, frankly, about these issues of transparency and secrecy for a long time.
Behind the themes, there's a lot of outrage in the level of journalism in Australia that has been building for a very long time. But at the end of the day, it's only works if the public is behind us. The media is not very well trusted. We could all do a better job of doing our jobs and explaining why things like transparency matter.
And so no matter how many outrage we all get, part of our little tribe, it can only go so far if the public behind us. Joining me now is Johanna Leigberg, a journalist and scholar and an expert in press freedom from Monash University, whose most recent book is called In the Name of Security, Secrecy, Surveillance, and Journalism. It's a very fine book, and we've done a whole episode on it on the Fourth Estate. Johanna, thanks for coming on the show.
Just to deal with this, what's really been going on behind the scenes in terms of legislation. The amendments to security law last year, supported by both the government and the labor opposition, means that journalists could be charged with committing a crime if they publish information regardless of intent to endanger national security. So Australia doesn't have a charter of rights or a first amendment like the US. So is it time we have in our laws an explicit right to freedom of the press in our democracy?
And if so, what does that look like? Absolutely. I mean, we have been discussing a bill of rights or a charter, whatever you want to call it, but decades now in Australia. But I think we have to be realistic and just admit that we're not going to get a bill of rights because Australians really like changing constitution and so on.
So I think the most, uh, quickest and reasonable thing to do is to come up with some sort of media for either Mac. I know Peter Gresley has suggested one in his organization, come up with a white paper. And I think that would be the most doable thing. I mean, at the moment, with the reasons amendments that you were talking about, it's impossible to keep crackle-balling, you know, from a working journalist's point of view, how can you ask of anyone to be able to keep crackle-these 64 plus amendments and changes and new laws that have been passed in 2001?
So instead of sends the message of, say, away from reporting national security and terrorism issues, because it's just too hard. Yeah, Mr. Chilling effect, right? Absolutely.
Absolutely. So this act would somehow need to bring together everything that is now sort of floating around. So we've got sealed laws for journalists that are protecting their sources, which is in all jurisdictions, but one now in Australia, but we don't really know how they're going to work because it's up to each presiding judge to apply them and two or three test taters. But will they really work?
That needs to be brought in. We need to have this act to need to somehow deal with this huge blanket that has been created by all these new laws and acts that have come. So it needs to test out, I suppose, the ground playing rule, the baseline between journalists. Well, so I guess the central question here is how do we, very broadly, journalism academics, the news media industry, supporters of democracy, freedom of the press, how does this happen?
Statement was put out by Giro, which is the Journalism Education Association, and you were part of that, which describes the problem. I think we're very good at describing the problem. The question really is how do we galvanize this moment in turn into action? Because frankly, I think the press freedom act that Peter Grestle is talking about was far more likely to happen if we had a change of government a few weeks ago.
I'm wrong, but it doesn't seem that the coalition government is particularly going to be up for it. How do we change that? I think you're right there. It's pretty safe to say that the current government has got very little interest in this.
The opposition needs to step up. I mean, the Labour Party has clearly been very much part of creating the current national security climate that we're in in this way. They need to somehow step up and really take this to the government now, and take this time off actually meaningfully re-growing the base playing rules for media and journalism in this country in relation to national security. I think the way forward is to engage with the opposition on this and by them try to engage the government.
But in the current climate, it's hard to see how it would actually happen. Joining me now is Leo Shenhan, the newly minted media editor of the AUS, and as a job on Sky News. Congratulations on the new job. What's the part of Sky News again?
I'm co-host of Business Weekend at the Kiki Jordan Law Sky. What an interesting pairing. Let's go to the chase here. What impact do you think these raids will have on the news media industry?
I don't think anything quite galvanised in the media like an attack on the idea of their freedom and their ability to report. I think it is this with we've seen that. The images themselves are confronting in the AFI officers leaving out of Anakinika Smith as well as the ABC yesterday. But it's the power behind these raids, I think, which is disturbing.
The breadth of these warrants that the police carry with them. The warrant in the ABC matter enabled them to delete information. I've never heard of that before. And seemingly, these are national security issues involved.
I think the point to make here is that this happens a lot more often than perhaps people realise the journalists. These two cases being so close together and I suppose that the public nature of them has attracted a lot of publicity. I mean, for example, and I tell this story not to talk myself up, I need to show that this happens quite regularly. A couple years ago, the ICAC came up with my office, and you and my editor back there, and took notebooks and recordings of an interview I did with the OBs.
I then being asked to cooperate in the trial in evidence against them. There's another case where I've been a subject of my interviews and now being charged under an actual security act as an issue to do with ACES. I could be called up into that anytime soon. I'd like to talk about that.
That's all covered by an actual security legislation. Now, the point is that this actually happens a fair bit. And to most journalists, I know this has happened in some way or another. And the question is what are our capacity to do about it?
Is it kind of more united front? And do we just get that capacity a lot of terms to maintain the rate? Yeah, well, that's the key thing. And I think, I mean, I'm not sure what your view is, but it seems to me that the news media industry can't necessarily do this one on its own.
I mean, we've had the right to know coalition for quite some time. It's done some great work, but we still had Labor and the coalition joining together last year to pass these new laws. So what needs to happen is a really interesting question. I'm not a constitutional expert, but I do understand that within our constitution, it's only a red notion of freedom of press by a couple of big court cases in a high court.
It's not actually explicit in the First Amendment, so other much more in the US for journalists. And I think as a body, there's nothing more powerful than the media companies who can agree on an issue of pressure on governments. They're extremely powerful for the best of times individually. And if that is, if they do possess that capacity to ban together, I would imagine governments would be pretty low to put up much with a sense.
Leo, before I let you go, I believe there's going to be more raises. Is that your understanding? Look, I can't comment too much on that, but what I could say is that we, the Australian reported this morning with an expectation further rate of news court, and those did not eventuate. It's not clear why the AFP has taken so long to get around to knocking on the door, and the government has been a pains to distance itself from the timing.
In other words, it's got nothing to do with the fact the election is over and the coalition is back in power. I personally am not so sure about that, but maybe I'm just a cynical journalist. I am reliably told though that Smith has knew that something like this would happen immediately after she published her piece, because one of the parts of that story was that they published a picture of the actual document, and that was primarily facing evidence that the secret document had been passed to a journal, and that was very much covered by this new legislation. Just before we get to the panel, I wanted to explore how we got to this point.
Last year, just to be clear, the government with Labor's aid passed new security laws, creating a new offense, the offense of, quote, dealing in classified information, especially in an information relating to national security. And in that word, dealing includes the words handling, communicating, and retaining classified information. And in that word, communication or communicating takes in what journalists do, i.e. publishing.
So up to them, publishing itself was not an offense. So now the new laws do include a public interest test, and that's kind of the soft journalism, but that public interest test has not yet been tested. And as publishers only know too well, defending a publication, I'll get on national security grounds, it's going to cost a lot of money, a lot of time, a lot of effort. So there's a real danger here that there will be a chilling effect on the actions of journalists and whistleblowers.
In short, press freedom in Australia and the world, but in Australia, is threatened. Let's turn to our panel. We've got a lot to discuss, so we've recruited just the right panel to do so. We have, in no particular order, but I'm going to introduce Marcus Rong first, who is the president of the General's Union, the MEAA.
He is a former Fairfax journalist, of some note, a great science reporter, among other things. Fantastic. Oh, and now you're at University of Sydney. Hello, Marcus.
Hi, Peter. Thanks for having me on. Great pleasure. Yara Boo-Mell is a walker with winning video journalist.
Her reporting has taken all over the world. She's just got back from Berlin. She looks a little bit jet-like. She's been to Syria, Libya, you know, but she's done that.
And most recently, or really interesting, she's been doing some fantastic work about press freedom in our region, in particular, for the Philippines. Hello. Great to be here. Great.
Thanks for coming on. And there's Gopinco, who has revealed to me just a few minutes ago that he was one of the original driving forces, one of the Right to Know Coalition, which is a public Right to Know Coalition, which has previously unified the media industry around these issues. He is currently the head of Teller Media, where he specializes in media and corporate affairs. And you've had a lot of experience in Australia and the UK.
I'm interestingly in Teller, because why, why, apart from many other reasons I have you on the show, David, is that Teller has a helicopter view of what's going on in the industry. That's right. Thank you, Dr. Hone.
I think my boss would say she was probably the driving force of the Right to Know campaign, but it was a lot of fun to work on it. It's super interesting. So let's start with this unity ticket in news media. The country's news media spoken, the likes of the R's, the city went here, the Guardian's Sky News and Telegraph.
They've all this story has led all their bulletins, websites and websites. There's been a lot of outrage. Really interesting, I think, was the ABC during the raids in Ultima, with the head of Investigations, John Lyons, documented the raids with Twitter, copying the first two pages of the warrant. And it was great work by John, if you're listening.
He was witnessed in nine hours of, you know, worth of warrant documents, data uploads, coffee, John tweeted the entire process saying, I've never seen an assault on the media as savage as this. I've never seen a warrant this comprehensive. And I'd say scary. The chilling message is not so much for journalists, but there's also for the public.
Marcus, how did we get to this point? Did this come out of a blue sky or has this been building up? This has been building up for years, if not decades, probably since 9-11, 2001, that there's been, I think, at least 13 or 14 iterations of reviews of national security laws since then that has ratcheted up the ability for the police and the government to censor what is done in the media in the interests of so-called national security, which of course is a legitimate concern for governments. But it's been a game of brinkmanship and bluff by both major parties, neither of which wants to open a fight with the other on national security or be seen to be weak on national security.
So, oppositions have just let these so-called reforms pass through. It's become a bit like the asylum security, isn't it? No, one party wants to blink. Yeah, so we've ended up with a bunch of laws that allow the AFP to do what they did.
So in that sense, it's not really the AFP's fault. It is a political legislative climate that the major political parties were allowed to grow and what government, eventually, or what police force, eventually doesn't use the powers that it can use. No, that's right. I mean, almost it's compelled to do so.
We spoke to Damian Cave from the New York Times earlier and he knows a piece talking about Australia in the most secretive democracy in the world. Yeah, how does that make you feel? Oh, well, as a realist. When you travel over the world.
Yeah, no, exactly. I travel all over the world and I cover issues relating to journalists, journalists coming under the wrong side of the law or under the hammer by authoritarian regimes. And I suppose what I found really poignant about the raids is when Gavin Morris, the director of news and current affairs at the ABC, who was named in the warrant, came outside and said, journalism is not a crime, which is the same sort of line that you hear from embattled journalists in mostly authoritarian, regime-run countries. And here we have the director of news and current affairs at the ABC, the public broadcaster, saying journalism is not a crime because now journalists in Australia are heavily under assault.
And so this is something that's concerning not just for journalists, but anyone who cares about upholding the public's right to know about certain things and also keeping power accountable because that is what our job is essentially. That's what we do. Let's go back to a point that I think Marcus made. And that is, so there is a balance here.
I mean, I want to shed some light here. There is a balance between if you like the limits of the public interest or national interest and this right to know concept. So how do we, David, I mean, this is a tricky question, but how do we go about balancing that? Right?
How do we keep secrets but actually do our job? I think you've, I mean, that is the crux of the issue entirely. I think, you know, Peter Kreadlin had a segment on Sky last night talking about exactly this. You know, she came out on the side of government, on the side of the current set of laws, basically saying that, you know, Cabinet needs the opportunity to discuss and come up with proposals in private.
I mean, you know, that's her point of view, you know, to come up with proposals in private. The process in this particular instance, you know, talking about Anika Smith, that's the case, was that the Cabinet shot down the proposals point blank. But even if it had gone through to, you know, be debated in Parliament, it would have been done so in open light. Now, you know, we don't know that.
But in order to change legislation, it would have had to have been debated in Parliament. And therefore, people would have known about it. And therefore, it wasn't a whistleblower. It was simply a leaker.
So I take the point, however, what I think is really disturbing is that you've got a situation where government is regulating media. You know, we, you know, whether you agree that Julian Assange is a journalist or not, the Australian media kind of came out and said, look, we take an American media, Western media came out very strongly and said, the media takes a lot of care to make sure that what is released is, you know, okay for informants, it's not going to hurt them. It's not going to hurt national security, et cetera, et cetera. And yet, now we're in a situation where government seems to be regulating that exact point.
So editorial process seems to be taken away or being taken away from the newsroom. Yeah, okay. That's a very point. So Marcus, good point from David.
What needs to happen? I mean, you know, we have an inflection point here, right? I do think it's a watershed. So what we've got an opportunity is there's a crisis, never waste of good crisis.
So what's been revealed is the complete inadequacy of the laws that govern these matters. And we need a positive defence and a positive protection in the laws for whistleblowers and journalists. At the moment, all that exists is a right to defend yourself, given a national public interest test. So it's in the breach, in other words?
Yes, it's in the breach where it should be a positive protection. That's what actually needs to happen. And also, the government is driven with hypocrisy. This was a politically motivated attack on journalism designed to intimidate whistleblowers and journalists.
The government, government ministers leak sensitive information constantly to their pet newspapers and then front them days later and say, Oh, yes, I can confirm that story is actually true. They fly up the flag. Yeah. And does the AFP investigate those?
No, they do not. That is a political decision. That is it's not an operational decision. That's a political decision.
There are breach cabinet breaches constantly in Parliament. And if it's leaked, promote a policy by the government, it's ignored. We should also say that all governments are the same. Absolutely.
It's the political process. Yes. It's very cynical. They want it both ways.
They want to control the message. I mean, if government had its way, all the newspapers would do was published, would be published press releases, put out by ministers. And so just to explain on this a bit, what needs to happen, Peter Grassner and others have put up this media freedom bill, this kind of omnibus idea that essentially that media freedom will be enshrined as a sort of central tenant in all legislation. This is kind of a checkness.
Or does this impingent media freedom? Is that where we should be going on? Yes. Something along that.
So if you read every year, our union puts out its annual press freedom report. And we've been saying year after year that there needs to be a positive protection for journalists and whistleblowers enshrined in law. This is not a new call, but I'm glad that it's crystallising. And it looks, yes, there's a crisis.
And I'm hoping that the media companies, the publishers, the law reform organisations can come together and put maximum pressure on the parliament to try and put their money where their mouth is, which is they say they're in favour of press freedom. Okay, let's see it. Let's see it in practice. Change the law.
There were one of the reasons we were actually going to talk about the state of the jobs in the industry. I don't think that the week's events will take us beyond that, but we will get back to that. But you have a helicopter view of the industry. How do you see events like this shaping the way forward for journalism, in particular young journalists who are thinking about going into the industry?
I think when journalists who want to be investigative journalists and who imagine winning a walkley and want to get on the front page into the industry, that's a huge number of those journalists. I think the challenge of something like this is that we're moving away from journalism into content. So people are no longer going into the industry to be journalists. That's true that the reporting is becoming far more infrequent and harder.
There are pockets of growth there. What's happening down at Crikey is really interesting. Nine is hiring some great people, but it's really small pockets of exciting new things. So I think the definition of what is journalism is changing for exactly these reasons.
People ask, I'm not going to say that the people I speak to are scared, but I've certainly heard stories of seasoned journalists going through their houses in the last couple of days and throwing things away or clearing them to the office, not destroying evidence like that, but just moving them. Of course the I've been in search of Anika's office at all. That's a straight to the house. That's an interesting thing.
You have to be through your own way. They went to the house, not to the press gallery. I know nothing in particular, but I've worked with big organizations where left hand doesn't talk to right hand and you release things publicly in order that's probably not great. But one raid on a journalist is a big deal.
Two in two days is either deliberate or a serious stuff up somewhere along the way in terms of public perception or its intent. Well, it's intentional. It does seem like journalists and whistleblowers from putting out an information. Well, we spoke to Leo Shenan from the Australian and the new media that are there and they were expecting a raid today.
I've heard that a few places I don't know where. But to have two, and the AFP pains to say that these cases are not connected whatsoever. So the only thing that connects them is their timing. So their timing is deliberate and it is a clear attempt to intimidate whistleblowers and journalists.
And if it is true that there was a third one being planned and that they pulled out of it, they did not expect the backlash. And that gives me hope, gives me confidence. And journalists and you know, people who dare I say freedom lovers, people who approach democracy should take heart from that. We can fight back against draconian attacks on a free press.
And that is what this is. And if they've been beaten back to only have two out of three raids, great, they're threatening more in the press conference they've just given. But we should put maximum pressure on them and we should put maximum pressure on politicians to change the law and to stop police raids on journalists. How empathetic, I mean, this is for you, Yaren, and the rest of the panel.
You know, no one in my view goes into journalism to be loved. It's not that game, right? We don't do it to be loved by the citizens. But and so yet really for this to happen, for this movement to really take hold, we have to gather public support as well.
How do we go about that? For journalism? Yeah, yeah. Well, I think there needs to be some sort of education, I suppose, for the public to understand that journalism, the role of journalism has always been to act as the fourth estate to be, a check on the balances.
Okay. Okay. Okay. Marcus, you got any plans that the union is for this?
I think we need to go. I actually don't think this is about journalism. You're being a democracy. This is about democracy.
This is about decisions being able to have access to information. This is about a government that wants to make decisions in secret without transparency. This is a culture of keep people ignorant and make decisions behind their back. It is about democracy.
Journalism is is the messenger. And also, yes, we are the fourth estate that holds people to account. So we need to reach out to the public. And if it's about journalism or journalists, yeah, the public will go, who cares?
Right. It has to be about them. It has to be about democracy. It's about their right to know.
It's about their democratic access to information. And we are the conduits for that information. Well, David, you've got a marketing brain among your journalistic brain. How would you go about sending that to the public?
Well, that's a big question. I know. I'm trying to make us all lots of money. Yeah.
Well, Marcus, lots of money. You know, I think it's, first of all, it's not an overnight thing. You don't just put out a campaign or a billboard or a nice YouTube ad. It doesn't just happen that quickly.
I think the greatest thing that probably needs to happen is the media needs to continue and enhance its reporting that it's currently doing to show its value. I mean, you've seen, for example, in the US, the New York Times, who has kind of been pretty fearless and Washington Post as well and others, who've been fearless in reporting in the face of a lot of backlash from administration. People now appreciate this kind of voice. They appreciate that they're freedoms and they're right to know things.
Well, certain people do, right? I think this is the issue, isn't it? Certainly. I mean, you know, I mean, you know, I don't think America is Australia is America.
I don't think there's a division quite the same way that there is here, there is there. Well, they have press freedom protections. They certainly, they certainly don't. So I think, I mean, in the last two decades, we've seen the weakening of newsrooms.
And I think we've seen governments, the world over trying to take advantage of that. I mean, for me, it was typified by Scott Morrison trapping all the gallery journalists on a bus while he did a walk about in the shopping center and he didn't allow the press gallery to go with them. It is, it is a cynical attempt to take advantage of a somewhat weakened news culture given the loss of funding and so on. And it's not just from governments, from corporates as well.
I mean, from media watch this week, revealing the Adani tooling up to intimidate the ABC or intimidate other news organizations to get its message across. And I think what we have to do as journalists, and this is what the union is about, is about not just building alliances with publishers, but empowering our members to be confident to fight back. I mean, as we've been talking, I've had a text message from the head of the House Committee at the City Morning Herald saying they've just met, they've had photos, they've passed a solidarity motion with the ABC and News Corp. And we're putting out a call this afternoon across all newsrooms, calling similar actions across the country to stand up and say, we won't be intimidated.
Journalism is not a crime. We're going to be on a unity ticket with Marcus Traum and Miranda Devine. Absolutely. That's my dream.
Miranda Devine, David Ma, together campaigning. I think it will happen. I do really think it will happen. It's just, we were running out of time.
I did want to touch on the Adani story. Well, I'm still unclear about it. If anyone has got any insights. So the Adani calls up and says, hey, you know, we've been asking these questions, which indicate you don't understand the story.
Now, there's nothing new in that whatsoever. What seems to be remarkable about what happened next is that then the story doesn't get run, not just in some AM, where it was due to be run on the ABC, but not at all. So Adani appears to have won in this matter. You only thought it was that, yeah?
I don't know if they've won. Now, it's sort of been... Now we're just talking about all the time. Maybe they have.
Yeah, I mean, now it's sort of been revealed that they have this sort of machinery in place to silence journalism and silence journalism and criticism. So I think that makes them look really bad. It's a very NRA lobby style tactic that they're using here, where they're just going to bark and bite as many journalists as they can or as many critics as they can. But as David said, you know, we in a shifting space in terms of journalists.
We have lots of people who still believe in the mission as it were, but there's a lot of people going into the industry, possibly not to take it to the man, so does we. Right? Yeah, I think that's absolutely fair. I mean, when you look at...
So tell them how to basically have a database of every journalist in Australia. Not exactly. That's kind of the idea is so that, you know, people know who's doing what in the industry. And when you look at it, I mean, yes, general news is still the largest sector by far in Australia, but then very close behind is lifestyle and entertainment and sport.
You know, I mean, it's not investing in journalists. Is that become more prevalent in the same way? Definitely. I mean, the lifestyle space, the entertainment space, you know, the softer stuff that gets the clicks and gets the views, that certainly growing.
I don't think that's a problem. I mean, journalism doesn't need to make money. It needs to have a sustainable world. And that stuff can fund the investigative reporting.
And I don't think that people were doing the lifestyle content, you know, clickbait sort of thing, are going to go after the Adani's of the world. That will be the investigative reporters. And that's the way this space... The same question is whether that, where the money is going from to do investigation, say for us.
Well, that's why you have the lifestyle entertainment clickbait. Well, yeah, I mean, I guess, is it being spent as a journalism? It needs to be that balance. I mean, the fight we used to have in Fairfax all the time, we would say to Greg Highwood, you're making schoolings of dollars in domain.
Why don't you use that? And we know what happened to Subson and Pete. Why don't you use that to subsidise investigative journalism? And he was saying, oh, no, news has to wash its own face.
I learned all these accounting McKinsey type. Actually, what happened was that they ended up separating domain from the rest of the, you know, the journalist body and then it's worth anything. What we originally talked about, I think there is a bit of confidence returning to newsrooms. The ABC, I mean, I had lunch with John Lion the other day and he was saying he's overseeing one of the largest investigative teams in the world.
There were 30 people at the ABC who just do investigation. Yeah, that's what you're doing. It's one of the biggest teams in the world. You've got investment in Crikey.
I think you've got some editors coming back to this and you want to hear all the age and the fin reviews. So membership of the union is, you know, had flatline and it's going up a little bit. So I think there are there are springs of, you know, buzz springs. So final question, bring it back to what we've been talking about mainly is will this help or hinder that trend?
Do you think more people want to be a journalist because they can get raided by the FB? Oh, no, definitely not. I don't think more, more. I think young journalists wanting to come into the industry will get this and be like, oh, do I really want to have that sort of life?
It's not glamorous. Journalism is by no means glamorous unless you take the softer approach to things. Okay. Well, I guess what do you think about that?
I'm not so sure about that. I think the romance of the romance of journalism could have got a bit of a resuscitation from this, that it's reminded people of what our mission is. Handling classified information is what journalists do and it's seen as the sort of the pinnacle, the peak, the most romantic and romantic notion or not. I think people who I think it will certainly re-infigrate people and just from a talent perspective, what I can tell you is that over the last few years, we haven't seen the number of journalists in Australia decrease.
We've actually seen that increase. Right. As I say, that was what we're going to talk about. Yeah.
We'll talk about it very soon. No, but I think, you know, just to sort of finish that off, I think, you know, people aren't exiting the industry in droves. We're talking about graduates, we're talking about working speaking. Generally speaking, the whole industry is growing.
That's what we see. Now, it's changing in shape, but you know, certainly the actual number of people creating news, you know, what we would consider to be news and content in that sense is growing. Well, maybe this will create increase both, right? We'll have more lifestyle journalists, which is what you, with that growth is, I'm assuming.
It's all over the show. Okay. And we're going to have more investors too, which is perhaps a happy note to end this show. And members for the union.
Happy Marcus Strong. Okay. Well, we've been talking to Marcus Strong, the federal president of the MEAA, the journalist union, to the horrible Mellon, who's a walk in the World War winning freelance video maker, a journalist extraordinaire, investigative journalist extraordinaire, and David Scapinca, the head of telomere and many other things. Thank you so much all three of you for coming along.
Thanks for your time. And thanks everyone for listening to The Fourth Estate. This edition was recorded at the studios of 2SCR and heard across the country on the Community Radio Network. Make sure you're subscribed to The Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk media, politics and a few things in between at your leisure.
And we'll be back with more next week, but in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter, where our handle is Fourth Estate AU. Many thanks to my producers, Anthony Dockrell and Julia Carcadsell. My name is Peter Fray. Thanks very much for listening.
A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.
That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca. Safer Ontario paid for by the Government of Ontario.