Skip to content
Probable Claus episode artwork

Dec 1, 2018 10 min

Probable Claus

from Barjory Buffet: The Cruise Detective Hosted by Dame Drewzel Scream

Send us Fan Mail Barjory spends her holiday on the Santa Cruz Santa Cruise, where some kinda mean ole Scrooge is killing Santas! Everyone learns a lesson that giving is better than getting (getting killed, that is!!!!!), in this sort of interactive mini mystery! Edited by Brad Beideman Rachel Crowe as: Barjory Buffet Pablo Escobosa as: Junior Inspector Santa Will Stryker as: Mean Santa Magi Calcagne as: Narrator

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Probable Claus

0:00 10:59
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to a Bargery Buffet mini-mystery, starring Bargery Buffet, the cruise detective. Put your deduction skills to the test with this week's case, Probable Clause, based on the short story, Clausable Deniability. No matter the murder by weapon or hands, they never will fit to my holiday plans. It's the best time of year when my mailbox is packed with gifts that I get for the cases I've cracked. I had just lit the Yule log when Yule never guessed. My phone interrupted with calls of distress, for that's how it goes for the best in the biz. There's no break no matter what season it is.

I was chauffeured towards trouble, wherever it dwells, on a jet ski that jingled with tinsel and bells. To the Santa Cruz Santa Cruz where I'd stick out because I'd be the sole soul not dressed to be claws. This Santa convention jingles with cheer from the West Coast up to the North Pole every year. Bombarded by beards as I boarded the boat, I tried to spot bloodstains on already red coats. Was tall Santa hiding in his Santa disguise? Do twin Santas hold secrets in their rosy twin eyes? And was Chef Santa lying? Did Doc Santa do harm? And was Tree Santa really at the Christmas tree farm? As I wandered through this wonderful time of year, I found just the Santa who invited me here.

Miss Buffet! Call me Bidge, Santa. Call me Junior Inspector Santa, Bidge. That's my thing. Why not Regular Inspector Santa? I haven't solved a cold case yet. Cold cases are what we call any case around Christmas. Okay, yeah. Because it's cold. That's why I need you. We have a serial Santa killer, and Captain Santa refuses to do anything about it. Just walk me through the facts.

To date, eight Santas have died in a little over a week. Is the cause of death consistent? Sort of. The first victim, rude Santa, was found in the kitchen. He opened the pantry and a rabid bird jumped out. It pecked his eyes out. Can birds get rabies? This one did. This was one crazy bird. I found feathers and peck scars on five other bodies, but the beak marks are inconsistent. I haven't seen a bird killer since the case of the ostrich who got onto a riverboat and started kicking people overboard. The killer hides the birds in his victims' rooms, but I can't track that because every night, all of the Santas sneak into each other's rooms and leave presents. Every single night. So it could be any of them. A Santa with an army of attack birds. And brass knuckles. The fifth victim was beaten to death with brass knuckles.

Jeez. Yeah. Who are the other victims? Let's see. Greed Santa. Lust Santa. Sloth Santa.

Jared Leto says. So the killer believes only the naughty Santas deserve to be punished, making a hit list. And checking it twice, yes. But the eighth Santa, ableist Santa, he was drowned in goat milk. Hmm, birds and goat milk and brass knuckles? Is there an Amish rapper Santa? Yes, but he's one of the victims. Bidge, we need to figure this pattern out before he strikes again. Probably tonight. I know it's not much to go on, but... Hey, carolers Santas! You know Joy to the World? Because I just figured this out. You don't? That is so weird. Did they cut funding to your training? Just leasing something, because I know the killer's pattern.

How did Bargery know? Do you know the answer? Prove it. Say it out loud. Come on. Just say it. Say it. Say it or I don't believe you. Did you say something? Well, nope. That's wrong. Here's the answer. Okay. This Kringle killer got a little too clever. I don't know how he smuggled crazy birds onto a boat, but he used a different species each time. So if you arrange them in a certain order, plus his other two weapons, you get...

Eight maids a-milking, seven swans a-swimming, six geese a-laying. But five golden rings? One for each finger of brass knuckles, plus the misshapen one that goes on your palm. Back to the birds. Four calling birds, three French hens, two turtle doves, and... A partridge in a pantry. Again, he had to work with what he had. What song is that? You're terrible carolers. Anyway, next up is nine ladies dancing. Give me nine girl Santas and meet me in the boiler room. On it. Do you have a weapon? Maybe like a sharpened candy cane or... All Inspector Santas are issued a gun. Okay, wow. You've had that this whole time? Yeah. In your little hat? Yeah. Yeah, that's why your hat is straight up. I thought you...

which is happy to see me. That's a gun in your hat. Okay, sure. Let's do this. Okay. What song is that? I loaded the weapon he shouldn't have had and went with nine ladies in Santa skirts clad down to the furnace, a room of strange shape with only one door, no means of escape. And so with our trap, we will disallow a bad Santa dying from dancing somehow. Hi, I'm never responds to texts, but is always texting when we hang out, Santa. I was told to come down here. That's the victim. So where's the...

And then with a clatter and feeling of sternness, the killer was suddenly there by the furnace. He stepped towards the victim, but somehow I'm sure this Santa could not have come through the door. Everyone out! The junior inspector fled with the dancers as the bad Santa stared as if waiting for answers. Texting Santa, cover your eyes and run! Don't you look back, not even if you hear screaming! But where did that Santa go? Just go! Despite all the fire, I broke a cold sweat as I gazed at the killer in dark silhouette. He was classic claw shape, from belly to cheek, but my blood turned to snow as he started to speak.

Oh, Marjorie. It's not nice to point a gun at old Santa. It's way less nice to kill eight other Santa. So which one are you? Murder Santa? Krampus Santa? Oh, come now, little girl. It's me, the real Santa. Sure it is. Come with me or you'll go visit the Tooth Fairy in hell. The Tooth Fairy isn't dead. Well, you can tell that to the dead Easter Bunny because... And then with a wink that distressed me a lot, he flew up the furnace like a chimney it's not. Oh, my God.

He shot out the smokestack and dropped down to grip the reins of his reindeer on the bow of the ship. But as his sleigh turned to fly off to Venus, I had him at gunpoint. Eight reindeer between us. How bottery! Quit that! Do you know what happens if you shoot the real Santa? Big Santa, stop dying. There's no more Christmas! And you love Christmas! You tried to celebrate it?

Six times in third grade to get more presents. Fuck your Santa. I am. But what's a few dead Santas if it means everyone still gets presents? Especially you. The Santa Cruz Santa Cruz. It's just a charade to bring you victims every year. It saves me a lot of trips to the mall. Where the worst Santas are. But why, Santa? I can usually figure it out. But this time, it's so weird. Why? Twelve Santas must die every Yule time so that one may live forever. And Captain Santa leaves them out for me like cookies. Because he understands it's a sacrifice for the greater night.

Please give yourself up. I really don't want to do this. Then don't, and I will be on my way. On Dasher, on Dancer, on Prencer, and Vixen, on Comet, and Cupid, on Donner, and... Vixen! Oh, shit!

It got me in the arm. The bullet skimmed Santa. He would have been dead. Had Blitzen not jumped to take it instead. Blitzen! Oh shit, we are dragging a dead reindeer. Well, I know one hoofed freak who's going to be excited. And I heard him exclaim as he soared over sea. Merry Christmas, you fuck. You'll never catch me. What happened? What was that noise?

Here's your gun, if you want to put that back in your hat. It shot Santa. I mean, I shot Santa. And Blitzen. They both got away. Are you okay? Um, don't worry. Yeah, I've seen way weirder cases than this. That's so impossible. Besides, it's the holidays. It's the best time for mental health. I'll be just fine.

But I said that I'm fine, for there's no way I'm not. I didn't get trauma from that Santa I shot. And sure, every moment since that terrible crime, I can't stop my brain from thinking a rhyme. And a lot of the doctors whom I had to see called it a Christmassy PTSD. But no way I have that. That's way past extremes. Despite that, each night I shoot Santa in dreams. I know I'll forget it. The reason is this. How did Barjorie know she won't be haunted forever by shooting Santa? Do you know the answer? Ha ha. No, you don't. And neither does she. Because I, uh, wrote it down on my Christmas list. Jesus Christ.

Anyway, happy Christmas and holidays, everyone. Join us next week for Bargery Buffet in Return of the Ostrich Who Got Onto a Riverboat and Started Kicking People Overboard.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Barjory Buffet: The Cruise Detective?

This episode is 10 minutes long.

When was this Barjory Buffet: The Cruise Detective episode published?

This episode was published on December 1, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Barjory Buffet: The Cruise Detective episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.