PodParley PodParley
PodParley
Prom Night Massacre - The Pelley Family Murders episode artwork

EPISODE · Apr 28, 2026 · 52 MIN

Prom Night Massacre - The Pelley Family Murders

from True Crimecast · host Stove Leg Media

On April 29, 1989, 17-year-old Jeffrey Pelley put on his tuxedo and headed to his high school prom in Lakeville, Indiana. But the next morning, when his father, Pastor Robert Pelley, didn't show up for Sunday service, a horrifying discovery was made next door at the parsonage. Robert, his wife Dawn, and their two young daughters had been gunned down with a shotgun. The front door was locked, the curtains were drawn, and the primary suspect was the son who had supposedly spent the night dancing. --For early, ad free episodes and monthly exclusive bonus content, join our Patreon!   Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

What this episode covers

On April 29, 1989, 17-year-old Jeffrey Pelley put on his tuxedo and headed to his high school prom in Lakeville, Indiana. But the next morning, when his father, Pastor Robert Pelley, didn't show up for Sunday service, a horrifying discovery was made next door at the parsonage. Robert, his wife Dawn, and their two young daughters had been gunned down with a shotgun. The front door was locked, the curtains were drawn, and the primary suspect was the son who had supposedly spent the night dancing.

NOW PLAYING

Prom Night Massacre - The Pelley Family Murders

0:00 52:17

No transcript for this episode yet

We transcribe on demand. Request one and we'll notify you when it's ready — usually under 10 minutes.

Share this episode

Similar Episodes

Corrupt Cop EXPOSED Database Leak Linked to Daylight Shooting Full Interrogation

Apr 29, 2026 ·80m

Husband Thinks He Got Away With Killing His Wife (He Didn’t) Full Interrogation

Apr 29, 2026 ·91m

Online Predator Caught in Texas Sting Full Police Interrogation

Apr 29, 2026 ·48m

Full Police Interrogation Officer Who Shot and Killed Man at Walmart

Apr 29, 2026 ·106m

Mom Realizes Her 13-Year-Old Son Is A Murderer

Apr 29, 2026 ·55m

Evil Mom Thinks She Got Away With Murder (She Did…Not)

Apr 29, 2026 ·74m

Similar Podcasts

DIOSA. Carolina Sanper This podcast is a sacred space created by Carolina Sanper where you connect with your inner wisdom and embody your magnetic feminine power.It is the realization that the mystical realm is where you plant the seeds of your desired reality.It is a portal to your true essence: awareness, presence, and receiving with ease. Welcome home, DIOSA. 🖤 Gear Tasting Radio Radio ITS Have you ever analyzed why you've chosen the gear you have? Was it based on recommendations, or a true look into the skills to consider when making your selections? Look no further, Gear Tasting Radio is here with an in-depth look into the usage and philosophy behind the equipment in our lives. Celebration of Life Church Bozeman COLC It is our desire at Celebration of Life Church to reach into Bozeman and the entire Gallatin Valley with the Gospel of Jesus Christ and impact it for the Kingdom of God; to go beyond the four walls of the church and touch people in our community with the love of God; and to share the goodness of God in such a way that it will draw all men into a loving relationship with the One True Living God. We also desire to train up in the Word of God and encourage them to take the Gospel message to our community through various outreaches and evangelism. Enjoy our podcast and feel free to visit us. Wisdom's Proof JesusLifeTogether In a world of religion, ritual, hierarchy, control, money, marketing, and more flavors than 10,000 Baskin Robbins — how can we know what is Right and True? Some just give up. Bad move. JESUS LIVES and REIGNS! Some simply "go along to get along" to conform to culture and biological family. Really bad move, unless you are a lemming and don't care about the destiny someone else has chosen for you. But then JESUS, knowing this day would come, said, "By their fruit you shall know them" and "Wisdom is PROVED RIGHT by all her CHILDREN." Luke 7:35 Find some random offspring from whatever you wish you knew more about, look carefully at the second generation, and see if the gates of Hell are prevailing — as they would in a "mere words" and "mere ceremonies" attendance-based religious organization. OR, is satan getting busted in the mouth by that second generation? What is the fruit and the quality of LIVES of the children - once they can make their own choices? Then you'll Know. Wisdom is PROVED

Frequently Asked Questions

How long is this episode of True Crimecast?

This episode is 52 minutes long.

When was this True Crimecast episode published?

This episode was published on April 28, 2026.

What is this episode about?

On April 29, 1989, 17-year-old Jeffrey Pelley put on his tuxedo and headed to his high school prom in Lakeville, Indiana. But the next morning, when his father, Pastor Robert Pelley, didn't show up for Sunday service, a horrifying discovery was made...

Can I download this True Crimecast episode?

Yes, you can download this episode by clicking the download button on the episode player, or subscribe to the podcast in your preferred podcast app for automatic downloads.
URL copied to clipboard!