Pud Galvin, Forgotten Ace & Rush's Geddy Lee's Book 72 Stories

Send us Fan MailListen to Jerry, along with producer Brooke, to hear about a forgotten record holder Pud Galvin. Our first pitch is on Geddy Lee's baseball book.A coffee table book opened a door: from Geddy Lee’s unlikely baseball shrine and a donation to the Negro Leagues Baseball Museum to a web of autographs that includes Ruth, Eisenhower, Sinatra, Fidel Castro, and all four Beatles. That curiosity trail led us to a bigger fixation—how stories survive—and straight into the life of Pud Galvin, the nineteenth-century workhorse who helped build the record book but slipped out of memory. See Dan Rather interview at 22:30 for Geddy talking baseball. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GP_JvHFiNpoWe trace Galvin’s path from St. Louis to Buffalo to Pittsburgh, unpacking a résumé that still startles: two no-hitters, 646 complete games, the first to 300 wins, and 20-plus victories in ten seasons without a pennant. The backdrop matters. Walks shrank from eight balls to four in a single decade, rotations ran two deep, and ERA didn’t even exist until historians backfilled it in the twentieth century. Through it all, Galvin thrived on control, guile, and a pickoff move so sharp SABR chronicles him loading the bases only to erase every runner and taunting Cap Anson by walking a batter just to nab him at first.We also reckon with a headline that feels modern: performance enhancement. Before an 1889 game, Galvin tried Brown-Séquard’s animal-extract “elixir,” tossed a two-hit shutout, and drew praise rather than outrage. Science later dismissed the tonic, but the episode exposes an old truth—athletes probe edges, and culture decides where the lines are. Finally, we follow the long road to recognition, where Buffalo historian Joseph M. Overfield’s advocacy helped pry open the Hall of Fame door in 1965, decades after Galvin died poor and largely forgotten. Join us for a brisk, story-rich tour that reframes early baseball, honors the researchers who rescue lost legends, and asks how we choose which heroes to remember.If this kind of baseball time travel hits your sweet spot, follow the show, share it with a fellow fan, and drop a review so more listeners can discover these stories.Email us at [email protected]