'Puppet master' theory in Nancy Guthrie case | Katie Pavlich Tonight Full Show

Tonight on “Katie Pavlich Tonight”: There's breaking news out of the Middle East as the U.S. launches "self-defense" strikes on Iran, while the world awaits Tehran's response to the latest peace proposal. NewsNation’s Kellie Meyer joins live from the White House to discuss how the trading of strikes could impact the ceasefire. And a political panel joins to discuss Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s Vatican visit and attempt to mend ties with the pope. Then, we dive into a bombshell new theory in the Nancy Guthrie case as top profilers suggest the suspect seen at her door is already dead, leaving a "puppet master" in charge. Finally, we explore the unexplained with former U.S. Marine Michael Herrera, who joins Dr. Steven Greer to detail his harrowing 2009 encounter with a massive, apparently non-human craft in the Indonesian jungle and the surveillance from superiors that followed.This episode of “Katie Pavlich Tonight” originally aired on Thursday, May 7, 2026. "Katie Pavlich Tonight" offers a conservative take on the day`s events while welcoming all viewpoints. The goal: cutting through left-right bias in pursuit of plain facts and honest analysis. Weeknights at 10p/9C.NewsNation is your source for fact-based, unbiased news for all Americans. More from NewsNation: https://www.newsnationnow.com/Get our app: https://trib.al/TBXgYppFind us on cable: https://trib.al/YDOpGyGHow to watch on TV or streaming: https://trib.al/Vu0Ikij