Welcome to the Play Development Project podcast. My name is Dave White, co-founder and editor of Play Development Project. PDP is a website for coaches who are committed to land and we provide a huge library of resources which consists of cutting edge insights from the world's most innovative play developers, coach educators and researchers. If you want to learn from the best and join a community of like-minded coaches then check out Play Development Project.com.
On this week's Play Development Project podcast we answer a question from our community. Hi everyone, welcome to another Play Development Project Q&A. Please be joined once again by PDP technical advisor Dan Wright. Dan, how are you going?
Really good, thank you. How are you, Matt? Good, Madam, good, and this is an absolute beauty of a question this week. It's coming from Spence via Twitter and the question goes along the lines of, I've started my captain and top goalscorer on the bench for the last three weeks as she's missed training.
This isn't punishment but it's been done due to the commitment of other players at training. Am I wrong? Dan, yours please. Yeah, I saw this tweet and this interaction between you and Spence and thought, oh, I don't answer that question.
It's such a mind field, it's such a mind field of a question. I think we need to start with understanding why they're not attending training because these are children, so it might not be her decision. So she could be unable to get a lift from my mum and dad. She could be doing extra homework.
She could be playing another sport, which is really, really good. So that's complex. Also, I think you've got to understand what were the expectations of the team when they start the season. Did they say you missed training, you don't play?
Do we as a group value commitment so we play the players that always come? Controversial one, do we value winning over commitment so we play the best players no matter what, which would probably be against some of our messages? And then is the player in the right team? Are you, if we're always expected to be at training, it's quite a serious commitment level.
Maybe serious isn't the right word, but you know, quite a high commitment level and that player is unable to meet that commitment. Maybe she's in the wrong team. So that was all swimming around as I saw you answer the tweet and I thought, please, this is a key, a bit of a key, but it is a great question. What are your thoughts?
Yeah, look, I don't think there is a right or wrong. I think context is key and I know that can be flaky to a lot of people, but I think it's really important to understand some of those things that you've just mentioned. So I think there's an upside here in accountability, but I think there's an opportunity here around player ownership. So I've worked in a group at under 16 age and we don't have the age of the players in this instance.
So again, I think that's really important to acknowledge. I worked with a group of under 16, so at the start of the season, I said to them, I want you guys to map out what your expectations are and what you'd like to achieve from the season now, most of them came back. So we want to win the league and we want to play the players that are committed the most. So they created their own guidelines around what was expected in terms of commitment to training and so on.
Now, as you say, the kids, they can't always get there, other things get in the way, life sports score, all of these influences. So I think there's an opportunity there to sort of hand that ownership to the team and say, look, how do we want to deal with this if they're old enough and able to have that conversation? I think that really would teach them some good life skills. I think there's also the idea of teaching accountability.
Now, if the player is just mistraining, again, there may be factors that have influenced that could be burnout, could be homework, could be whatever, then there is that idea of saying, look, to earn something, you've got to work for it. And that's not a bad message to send to kids sometimes. And I think we sometimes get into this environment in modern ages where things can be a little bit fluffy and we can be a little bit go too far the other way, where we're handing out participation medals and so on. Now, we want participation, we want youth players to stay in sport and we want kids to have a positive sporting experience.
But accountability is a really important thing to teach players through sport in life because we've all got to be accountable for what we do. So there's a real balancing act here. I'm sort of rambling on a little bit, but again, some of you have lots of ideas going on in my head. And the other one I think here is communication.
What communication lines are open between the parents, the player and obviously, the coach and the other teammates. So is there an opportunity to speak with the parents and look at how this can be addressed if it's not going down well, for example? I mean, lots to discuss the inmate. Yeah, lots to think what you're explaining in terms of the expectations and what we do at this club is the idea of social construction.
So it's a set of guidelines and rules that in our environment, we do this. So we will expect you to set up to every training session. And when you talk about communication, we might say, we expect if you can't come to training, you'd use drop us a text saying, well, you can't come. And that might be enough for you to still play on the weekend because there might be enough context or other constraints around education, other sports, transport, life in general.
That might be appropriate. But I think there are some, although you and I probably have slightly different views on this, I think there are some kind of consistency, consistent messages around expectations of what we, as coaches, but maybe even as a team. Because if you put this to the team, they should probably have one answer. They should say, no, we do this.
So it's not even a decision. It's similar to able players five minutes like what you do. It shouldn't just be the coaches opinion and the coaches rules. It should be, no, we're a team, we're a group, and this is what we do.
And that has to be consistent and frequent and agreed. It can't be just, well, this is my emotional opinion on this day because you didn't come last week. If a player is constantly like the training, it can be ready for strength or constantly not turning up. But then if you found out the context behind that, your emotions and opinions will completely change.
So I think having lived this situation and having heard some of the stories or some of the reasons why players can't always get to training, that could put you that side of the fence. But like you said, I think you can also correct probably an unfair or artificial environment where it's really, really non-committal and really flaky of people to help anyone. And that doesn't produce good teams. It produces a bit of a mess and people probably feeling like they've been harshly treated or feeling that it's unfair.
And then, you know, that's not a nice place to train or not a nice place to coach. So a really good, really good question. What have you got in terms of content that might support some of this? Well, there's a fair bit on the side, particularly around leadership.
And I think from coaching perspective, there's a leadership challenge here and obviously team culture that can be managed by the players and it's a very dynamic fluid thing that's constantly changing. So highly recommend the work of John Alder. John's actually just prepared another article, which is going to be released later in the year. But previously, he's done a webinar with us on leadership and culture in the Master's Class discussion library there.
He's also written in the magazine, The Shadow of Team Values. Highly recommend that a really good read. And there's also an article on the story of Claudia Renieri called The Art of Leadership, which I'd recommend just as a really nice anecdotal article on some of the successes during the magnificent run of Leicester in 2016. So there's certainly some content there.
And obviously, you can search the topic leadership on the site. You can create that in your feed as well. If you remember on the site, so certainly lots to consider. And I think, is he wrong?
Bottom line, I don't think there's a question right or wrong here. I think we've got to just say, look, understand the context. And I'd go out on a limb here and suggest, potentially Captain, Top Goldscorer, it's being suggested this is the best team. This is highly likely it's a young person with multiple sporting commitments.
So my gut feeling when I saw the question was it's likely that this player is potentially running around a lot, maybe committed to different teams, different codes. I certainly am working with players in that situation at the moment who are having to pull from school club, state level competition and so on. And that can be pretty stressful on young players. So I think the communication is the first place to start.
And then looking at the accountability and ownership. Any sort of final thoughts from you on this one, mate? No, I just wanted to congratulate you on a whole Q&A around cultural leadership without mentioning legacy in the All Blacks. Because I think that would have been appropriate to talk about the book Legacy and how that team drives their own kind of rules and standards.
So you did really well as an dimensional. Look, across my mind, I'll be honest, it popped into the head about 16 times. What a book, by the way. I don't know if you've heard about it.
So really, really recommend that one. Obviously, some great content. But head to the PDP website first and check those out. Dan, thanks for your time, Spence.
Thank you for your challenging question. And we will look forward to another PDP Q&A very soon.