Skip to content
Q&A: How do I develop individual learning plans for my players? episode artwork

Oct 20, 2017 21 min

Q&A: How do I develop individual learning plans for my players?

from Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching Hosted by Player Development Project

The question this week comes from Jody, via PDP Facebook page: “How do you develop individual learning plans, and then evaluate them?” Exclusive offer for Podcast listeners: 30 Days Free Active Membership. Visit www.playerdevelopmentproject.com/podcast

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Q&A: How do I develop individual learning plans for my players?

0:00 21:06
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to the Play Development Project podcast. My name is Dave Ryan, co-founder and editor of the Play Development Project. PDP is a website for coaches who are committed to learning and we provide a huge library of resources which consists of cutting edge insights from the world's most innovative play developers, coach educators and researchers. If you want to learn from the best and join a community of like minded coaches at the Hiccup Play Development Project.com.

On this week's Play Development Project podcast, we answer questions from our community and try to offer up advice and practical problems faced by coaches around the world. Hi everyone, welcome to another Play Development Project Q&A. Please be joined as per usual by my colleague PDP Technical Advisor Dan Wright. Dan, how are you going?

I'm good, thank you. I've got a bit of mantelos, apologies if I cough and splutter during this one. That is less than ideal. We'll hopefully get a sultry sort of dulce at voice from you as a consequence of that.

So we'll battle through, mate. And we've got a very interesting question this week. It comes in from Jodi via the PDP Facebook page. And the question is, how do you develop individual learning plans and then evaluate them?

So really good question from Jodi. Dan, what are your initial thoughts on this one? Yeah, I think this is something we break down into three parts. First of all, how would you go about doing an individual learning plan?

What does the individual learning plan look like that maybe part two? And then part three would be how we evaluate them? If we should, I know you've got quite an opinion on that. So if we sort of break those down into three parts of the first part would be, how do we sort of start the process of the learning plan?

For me, we'd have to go about understanding the plan. So I noticed something I've written about, sort of you've written about on the website. Perhaps just understanding everything that goes on all around the player. Is that something you want to try and explain?

Yeah, couldn't agree more. So obviously we've talked about the idea of socio-cultural constraints in the past and how they are basically environmental factors that influence the player on any given day. So that might be the age of the player, whether they're a Q1 birth or a Q4 birth, as well as the age effect to play. It might be their family environment.

It might be their context on the day. So we're going to be able to innovate a tough day at school. What is their school environment like? Do they have any medical conditions?

So knowing this kind of thing about your players on an individual level is going to help you understand what their needs are at a certain time. So I think when you talk about those socio-cultural constraints, you've got to account for those in what you're trying to get your players to work on or what you're trying to get them to achieve over the course of a season. What are your thoughts around those ideas? Yeah, I suppose it just goes sort of back to understanding people, doesn't it?

And so all the sort of the complexity that humans have, whether that's struggling at school, struggling in their family life, or it could be the flip that everything's great. But those sort of give you the platform, don't they, to understand how much the player can learn or whether they want to learn or whether they are in their journey. Because this also could depend on how much experience they have if that is the right word. So if you're talking about young players, if they're 10, they could have five years of organised football in them, or they could have 18 months.

So then you are assessing and judging perhaps just with your eyes. These two players look very similar, but actually they're completely different. So that's a good example of just understanding all of the context around the player. So socio-cultural is probably the language, but just understanding everything that goes around the player is how I put it in layman's terms.

Go on. Sorry mate, I was just going to say, and on that note, I think the other thing to consider is the culture that's around that. So we've talked a lot about complex systems and player development through many of our contributors. And the idea that obviously that player is at the centre of it and they've potentially got a family culture around them, but then you've got the team culture, the club's culture, and then you've got the national sporting culture, even the broader national culture.

And how do those things affect the way the players sort of expressed themselves on the pitch or the way football was viewed? So obviously I've just made a transition from London to Melbourne, and that the two locations are very different in terms of how football was ingrained in each city, what was the cultural history and background of the sporters, and I guess how they looked at it. So it's been a really interesting observation for me, and I think again, go to account for these things when you're starting to make some targets and make some plans for your players. Yeah, they definitely influenced that layman, and they definitely play a part in how much the player can learn or whether players are in that sort of non-linear journey.

So jumping onto the second part of the conversation, so how would you actually do the layman what would it look like? So this is something that we could probably spend four hours talking about. So it could be influenced by exactly what the player needs, and you could just pick one thing for them to absolutely hammer. Or it could be that you use the FA4 corner model and try and do maybe a strength in an area for improvement across those four corners, or it could be linked to your own club's philosophy.

So if you've got a club that's got four or five or ten targets, it could pick one of each thing. I think you've got to be careful that you don't overkill this. So the kids have got 15 targets. They could be playing the game, and they're going to have to spin around them by which target they're concentrating on.

I think less is more sometimes with these things. What's your view on that? Yeah, look, I think it's something that as I've evolved in my own coaching journey, I've come to appreciate the idea of less is more. I really like that as a term in coaching.

I think sometimes we can be over the top of the way we deliver or the way we speak, or the amount of work or expectation we put into players. So I do like the idea of taking a simple approach. So one example might just be setting a player one technical target on game day or one psychological target on game day just to focus on. And that might be a target that runs for six, twelve, maybe even longer weeks that you might say to the player, right?

If you are say using the FA4 corner model, it might be a technical, tactical, psych, and then a physical kind of outcome that you're looking at. And that may run for a period of time. And then what you're looking for is how much ownership you can give the player. So obviously with very young players, they're probably not going to have the knowledge to just come up with their own ideas in terms of technical stuff, but you can guide them there.

And you'd be surprised what young players can come out with in terms of being in tune with their own learning and their own progress and what they need to work on. So I think as much as you can relative to the age of the player, you've got to give them some kind of ownership as to what they want to achieve. So what they want to achieve is then driven by their own motivation and they're going to be very want to take some ownership of that if they sit their own targets. And I think then if you can have that conversation with the player, maybe the parents involved as well, and that way you as a group of things got clarity over what this player is trying to achieve.

So that's not just about the scoreboard or league tables or results. It's actually well, we were working on Johnny's left foot today and he failed three or four times, but in failing, he learned three or four really good things about what decision to make or how to execute technically. So there's loads of outcomes that can happen. Would you do it in a shared sense or would you sort of take control or how would you look at it into sitting these targets up?

Yeah, I mean, go back to where we started. I think it depends on the individual. If you've got somebody who's quite self-aware and perhaps some of you understand where they're at and where they want to be in that gap, that's normally quite straightforward conversation. So you can sit down and say, what are you good at?

What would you like to be better at? And they can usually from sort of maybe 10 to 11 give you quite a good answer of, well, you know, I'm good at scoring, but my left foot is not as good as my right foot or, you know, I'm good at defending, but I struggle in one being one's, I'm much better in a unit. And then I suppose that's the skill of the culture, maybe guide the conversation a little bit where you want to go. That does really depend individual to individual because there will be some kids that say, well, I don't need to work on anything.

And so that can be a challenge. And then there's some that maybe all this 25 weaknesses and then perhaps you know, become the opposite outcome of what you want. Quite a negative effect if you look at that. So I like the idea of the less is more like the idea of the kids having maybe two or three maximum targets or things to work on and using that fork on a model is quite a safe way of doing it and also gives you more of a 360 degree view of the player because I think as countries we tend to look in that technical and tactical and maybe even physical side of the diagram rather than the social and psychological one.

So this is something we've talked about in a Q&A before, but challenging kids in a psychological and social box has probably got more long-term outcomes than the other side. I think if you could say, can you show resilience by when the team or you make a mistake reacting positively or something, more product-child-friendly language? But a way of quickly getting them to refocus and say, that's not going to matter on to the next thing. And that's going to drive the technical anyway.

So looking back to your example of crossing with my left foot, that is dealing with adversity, it's resiliency, it's confidence. And you can dial into any of those and say, keep practicing on your left foot and when it goes wrong, don't be scared to do it again, something like that. And then in the social box, have you got the examples of social side that you could give people? Yeah, look, I think you can look at leadership, you can look at teamwork, ownership, responsibility around the changing rooms.

There's lots of social outcomes. It might be one that we leave the place better than we found it, which again, you can tie into concepts like Sweet the Sheds, which have been made famous through the book Legacy, which we speak about a lot. You've also got ideas about leadership in terms of taking ownership of warm-ups. It might just be something as simple as saying to the players, right?

You're responsible for the first 15, 20 minutes of the warm-up. The coach is only going to run the last five to 10 minutes, or it might be the players do the whole thing. It depends on the context and the situation. And I think going back to the technical side of things as well, we've spoken previously when talking about stretching players who might be at the top of the group.

It's important to make sure that you're encouraging kids to work on their strengths as opposed to always their weaknesses. It's easy, I think, to be critical and find problems or flaws with players, but I think it takes bravery as a coach to say to a player who's a 1v1 specialist, go 1v1 every time. Make the right decision to go 1v1 and back yourself, or set them a target. Can you beat somebody 12 times 1v1 in this game and really get them doing what they do best?

I think working on strengths in terms of setting these targets means that players are going to have a sense of confidence around what they're trying to achieve. And whilst we're working on those strengths in the background, we can be tidying up things that might be areas of weakness, but making sure that they're not just a focal point. So from a positive psychology point, I think that's quite an important idea. Yeah, I love the term super strength.

So what are you good at? Can you turn into a super strength? And then probably wouldn't use this with the kids, but in terms of assessment, if that is the right term, it's unacceptable weaknesses. So things that are actually going to hold us back.

So we've all got things that we could be better at, but it's about perhaps rounding off those things that are going to stop us competing at the level we'd like to. So we talked about before, I don't think you can be a 10 out of 10 and everything. So if you're already a 5 or 6 and something, can you turn that into a super strength? So I always use the example of I and Robin's finishing.

Everyone knows what he's going to do, but he still does it because he's practiced that kind of shooting left foot. He's been doing that for 20 years and still managed to do it twice against Arsenal and Champions League. This isn't just gone. But one of the things that he was not so good at that he had to get to a standard, it could mean he wasn't an elite player.

So that's a quite simple model of what is your super strength, what will make you super strength, what are your areas for improvement and what's your unacceptable weakness or something? You might have to think about the language that's sort of coaches' language, rather than kids' language. What are the things that are going to hold you back? Yeah, so now that we've sort of gone through the idea of how we select those areas to work on, the strengths, we get to the third element that you mentioned.

What are your views around how we assess it, how we evaluate it, what are these words mean, and how we actually sit and reflect with the player, how much of that is led by them, how much is led by the coach, and what role would the parents have? What's your experience and ideas on this? What a big question there. Sorry, I'm not supposed to get there.

I would start with thinking about where does the valuation come from. So it's kind of linked for me to do with school, and it's kind of linked with process and having output of numbers. So X amount of people can do A amount of things. But that isn't really why we coach, and that isn't really what it's about for me.

I suppose in an elite environment it's all about a productivity of producing players to play at whatever level you're aiming to do. And then perhaps from a district or a county or a representative side, it might be how many players go on to the next level of maybe national, and if you're coaching a school team, how many players could go on to play. Then there's so many other outcomes in terms of developing people, which is what sport is a great vehicle, a great tool to do to develop people to make better players and better individuals. So it's quite messy.

I think one of the things that I know you agree on is the comparison between players. So we should be talking maybe about, Dave, this is where you were six months ago and this is where you are now. That's the most powerful thing, and where do you want to get to? Not Dave, you're here and Billy's here, because it doesn't really matter.

And you're working in a grassroots environment. You could do all of this individual stuff, so get to another player, get to another social, cultural environment around the player, and then just check up with the kids to check how you're getting on. I don't know if you need the next bit. I don't know if you need your A, your a B, your a C, your a D, because we're then judging the player over 25 things.

I'm like, you've got world class players. If you had Neymar, what's Neymar's defensive heading like? Well, it's not an A, is it? So his super strength is this.

Does that mean we've graded on all these other things? No, no, no, all your thoughts on this was that, they're dead messing with me, my answer. Yeah, look, I think, I think the best way of referring to it is going back to Al Smith, who spoke in a number of times with PDP, and he's written for us, he's been on webinars and Al talks about the machine metaphor. So yeah, in a performance environment, we might be looking at hard data and statistics to define what success is on a game day and so on, but when it comes to youth development and children's sport, I think it's important to keep in mind that human element first.

So I think you've nailed it with the danger of social comparison. I think evaluation can be a risky thing. I think we all want to know which we were at, but the fact is we've got to be comparing it with ourselves and that kind of, that process and that progress and that journey that we're on. So if you can see that the player is making progress and putting a work in, then you can obviously give them that message and say, look, we've seen this, we've observed this.

If they're struggling, for example, it might be around the idea of resilience or emotional control, maybe they drop in their head and they're reacting poorly, then what are you going to do as a coach to actually address that? You can't just say, well, your attitude is not good enough because there might be reasons going around that you're going to work with the player. So I think it's about constant reflection. I think the more we can encourage players to drive that process in terms of reflecting whether it's after the game, the day after maybe when the emotion settled a bit, or just during the week around these targets.

It's important that they're in tune with what are the goals? And going back to another interview we've done with Dan Machitche around his work with you in another 16 set up, which is an issue 11 and 12 of the magazine, Dan referred to the idea that five targets might be enough for five years for some players. That might be all they can cope with and all they need, again, depending on the individual. So I think it's one of these things where evaluation is driven by tradition.

I think having to have metrics to decide how we're going is driven by adults and driven by marginal gains and high-end performance sport. And that doesn't necessarily correlate to children's sport. So I think it's got to be managed, but I would definitely advocate for self-reflection. And we've got some content around this.

We've got an article from Sean Douglas, the Art of Self-reflection, an issue one of the magazine, a number of articles with different player interviews. And I think when we have spoken to players in the past whether it's Harry Kiel, Wesley Schneider, the late Johan Crowe, Brad Gusan, you say you're different players who have made it to the level. A lot of the lines are questioning there was about understanding the journey and they're very in tune with the ups and downs that they had. So highly recommend those magazine articles with some top players.

And also there's seven different research reviews around motivation in the PDP research review library. Great content there. Any final thoughts on the sort of process from you, mate? Yeah, I had two things that I just popped in while she was talking.

The first one is, would you be more comfortable with that evaluation or assessment being comparing them to an elite player? So if you said, Dave, this is where you're at now, this is where we'd like to get to, and this is what it looks like for you to make the grade, I suppose. So that's the only time I'm more comfortable with it personally. Rather than comparing Dave the bit, I'm saying Dave to get to scholarship level, it's going to have to look like this.

Because there is more of an necessity and a need. So if the chat's going in the right direction and you're going forwards, that's great. Actually, the chat needs to be two steps higher up. And I think that in my mind that tends to be okay because I'm saying, for your left foot to not hold your back, it's going to have to get to this.

Are you comfortable with that? I think it depends on your environment. I definitely advocate for young players having mentors and role models. And I think there's a lot to be said for that aspiration or sort of ambition.

And so I want to dribble like Missy. I want to strike up all that right now. How do they do it and how hard do they work to get there? I think your context, the context has to be relevant to the level of players you're working with.

So if you're in a very entry level grassroots environment where kids are learning the game, then perhaps comparing them to one of the top players might not be the best example. But I think in terms of aspiration, 100%. I think kids have got to aspire to their idols and to their mentors and I think that gives them something to strive for. And there's nothing wrong with having that goal to be the best you can possibly be.

I mean, that's going to develop a winning mentality. One of the most powerful things to do when you're coaching is to say, this is really good. This is great. What would it look like if Buss would do it?

What would it look like if Buss would do it? And then the kids would just say, well, we'll go over that statue. We'll go over it. So that was what sort of jumped into my mind in terms of an individual learning plan.

Because it's great being where you are and going forwards. But if we're trying to aspire to a level, then what does that level look like? And I understand what you're saying with maybe beginners and grassroots. It could be more harm than health.

But perhaps with players that are performing and are achieving, you know, winning every week or if we're finding the game counter. So this is great. But actually, if we want to go to this next platform or level, if that does exist, what does that look like? And how would that look in our training and that sort of drive your plan?

Does that make sense? Yeah, definitely. It's about that improvement and that journey of just constantly striving to get better whether you're a player or a coach. So hopefully we've helped Jodie with that question and shared some ideas there.

We'd love to hear from the PDP community as to what you think. Dan, thanks so much for your time and expertise once again. And we will look forward to another PDP Q&A very soon. Thanks for joining us on the Play Development Project Podcast.

You can follow us on Twitter and Instagram, our Play at DP or find us on Facebook. Don't forget to head over to Play at developmentproject.com where you can sign up for our progressive coaching community and gain access to our wide variety of resources to help you and your coaching.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching?

This episode is 21 minutes long.

When was this Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching episode published?

This episode was published on October 20, 2017.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.