Skip to content
Q&A: How do we develop a style of play? episode artwork

Sep 8, 2017 13 min

Q&A: How do we develop a style of play?

from Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching Hosted by Player Development Project

The question this week comes from Chris, via the PDP Innovation Space: "What is the best way to identify and develop a style of play for our club?" Exclusive offer for Podcast listeners: 30 Days Free Active Membership. Visit www.playerdevelopmentproject.com/podcast

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Q&A: How do we develop a style of play?

0:00 13:09
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to the Play Development Project Podcast. My name is Dave Ryan, co-founder and editor of the Play Development Project. PDP is a website for coaches who are committed to learning and we provide a huge library of resources which consists of cutting edge insights from the world's most innovative play developers, coach educators and researchers. If you want to learn from the best and join a community of like minded coaches at the Hiccup Play Development Project.com.

On this week's Play Development Project Podcast, we answer questions from our community and try to offer up advice and practical problems faced by coaches around the world. Hi everyone, welcome to another Play Development Project Q&A. Please be joined once again by my colleague PDP Technical Advisor Dan Wright. Dan, how are you this week?

I'm really good. How are you? I'm good. I'm good.

As you can see, we're on different time zones here and I've just made the move to Melbourne from London. So very excited to meet a few people down here in the world of football in the last few days. It's been very interesting. It's a very pretty bad thing.

Is that real life or is that just a massive TV screen? It is. In fact, we've invested in a bigger banner and it's a fake city. So that is Melbourne by me.

It's so great to be here, mate, and obviously on different time zones, but we've got a fantastic question to kick off the Q&A this week. It comes from Chris via the PDP Innovation Space, which is for the members of our website. And the question is, what is the best way to identify and develop a style of play for our club? I coach under nine boys and we're getting to the point where I feel we need to have a style of play to work towards.

Interesting question. Mate, what are your thoughts to kick things off on this one? Yeah, I suppose we need to start with, you know, why would you think about implementing a style of play into a large club? And I suppose the key message is probably consistency.

So you've got consistency throughout the age groups. You might have consistency through your coach philosophy. And I suppose that gives the players the best opportunity of progressing through the age groups and then gives you an opportunity to move those players through those age groups. And then also, you know, you could build in the levels of technical detail, tactical detail throughout those age groups.

So what does it look like under seven? What does it look like under 10? What does it look like into those teenage years? And then as we get nearer to the first team, you know, doing mirror the first team style.

So yeah, I'd say consistency is probably the main sort of advantage of implementing a style of play. How about you? Yeah, look, I think in terms of breaking the game into moments, it can be a nice way to create, I guess, your body of work or the philosophy around how you train and then what you're looking for on game day in terms of knowledge transfer. So obviously we've both worked in Academy environments and it's fairly common place now for clubs to have their own playing style of philosophy as to what they're looking for.

And that may be variations on the game, whether it's position football and playing out or whether it's being a bit more direct. And I think from a learning perspective, breaking the game down into those moments is really important, whether it's in position out of position or the transition moments. So I think that gives the players some clarity around what you're looking for week to week or month to month, however you drive you on syllabus as such. But I know on the flip side, we've spoken a new refer to a lot about the player being a syllabus.

So do you think there's any sort of disadvantages to having a fixed style of play curriculum or any other sort of term you use for it? Yeah, I think that probably one of the only limitations I could think of is that, you know, if you haven't got the players to play in a certain way, so if you're part of your style of play is having a formation and then you haven't got the group, we haven't got players in the group to deliver that. Are you given the players in that group the best opportunity or best platform to succeed? So, you know, for example, if you played three up front or four, three, three and you've got a group with two or three exceptional number nine's, you have to think about what you'd be better playing two up top or one behind it too, because for a large portion of that player's time, he's going to have to play out of position.

And you know, if we truly play it centered and we've got two boys in the group or three boys in the group that we know are going to be number nine's and strikers, perhaps we need to be adaptable. So I think there's then perhaps a balancing point between what you're talking about in four moments of the game or what are probably the principles of play. And then how much of that is determined by shapes? So we could still have a style of play, but playing different shapes.

So, you know, even if you look at Barcelona, they play out at four, three, three, but they can also play three, four, three, and then that that are four different opportunities, I guess. Does that make sense? Yeah, it does. And I think it's probably, I think if you look at the progression of the way a lot of philosophies have evolved in the last few years around that Academy football scene or within clubs who are implementing that kind of proactive approach.

I think there are certain clubs that are quite rigid in the way they look at formations, but I think the more we learn to understand about a playing philosophy, it's not necessarily designed to tie in directly with the formations more about how you play the game. So whether it's building and playing through the thirds, that can obviously be done in loads of different formations. So I think it's important that if Chris is looking to really put a structural philosophy around the club, that maybe there's some fluidity and some flexibility within that framework around how coaches can go and deliver that, because if he's in a position, he might be coaching the undernines, but you assume based on the question that he's in a position where he can make some decisions around how the club's going to play, that he's going to have to trust his coaches to go and deliver that. And as you say, they may have to make a judgment on what sort of players they've got on their squad, what their level is, what their positions are, and where's best for them at that moment in time.

And give them some freedom to go and play in different shapes whilst trying to maintain that approach. So if it is playing out from the back, you know, maybe you're under 14 teams, you're playing a living side can do that in a three, five, two. If you've got three centerbacks, you need to be getting exposure at playing central defensive and really trying to play out from the back in a three, because that's what's going to suit their individual needs. So that's literally, I think, really important.

Yeah, and it always goes back to the game itself, doesn't it? So the principles of play, which we discussed before, or you know, essentially, you want to call it the moments, whether that's, you know, we retain and build, we're correct and scoring, we're pressing high. So what you do in and out of possession for me is more of your style of play than just a shape. So, you know, what does a team look like out of possession?

So the team's always going to press high and try and win the ball back, you know, like a Liverpool, try and win it high and get the reward, or rather going to try and build a block and win it more like, you know, let's go or lesser. So that for me would be the advantages of implementing a style of play, because then if you've got age groups doing similar things, then the language might be quite similar through those training sessions and players might actually have years and years of similar sort of coaching or similar sort of ideas, which is only going to help them. I think part of the challenge of working in grassroots or in clubs that don't have a style of play is that every year that the players get a new coach and every year they're getting a new idea and new set of values and a new, you know, what's important to us or the point might be to get in behind straight away. It might be important to keep the ball.

So the player might be taking, you know, a third of the season to work out actually, how are we trying to play football before I can get on to get better. So I'm going to learn to do this. So it's probably worth talking about who owns this direction, who's in charge of leading where we're going and I suppose in different clubs that would be different people. Yeah, definitely.

Obviously, you know, as a refer to a Christian, maybe in a position where he can make some decisions, but I think this has got to be a shared decision or a shared vision, if you like. And that can involve the players as well. Perhaps it's going to be a little bit more difficult under Nines to say to the kids, you know, do you want to build a playing philosophy? But they may have some ideas and there might be some interesting ideas from young players of all ages as to how they think the game should be played and why.

So whether that's going to be a binding thing, it might just be nice to engage in that conversation to get them thinking about the game. But I think it's got to be shared amongst people within the club. And first of all, you know, why are we doing it? Well, we're doing it because we believe the game should be played in this particular way.

We're doing it because we'd love to see our players play a certain style. We want to develop this type of player, whether it's creating exciting and attacking players, whether it's really intelligent defenders. So I think just having a sort of group discussion within the club is going to be one of the first steps as to why we're doing it, what that looks like and then how we're going to put that methodology together. So maybe breaking it down into five or six moments of the game, which a lot of clubs do.

And it may be saying, right, we're going to work on something for two weeks at a time or four weeks at a time and just hone in on that area. And that's one way to go about actually delivering it. What are your thoughts in terms of who should be taking ownership and any thoughts on those ideas? Yeah, I think it's got to be like a collective collective conversation.

It's got to be the people that are involved in delivering it. I think you might have a challenge if you're top of the tree and it's going to be a challenge. This is what we're doing because there's going to be so much knowledge in the room, if you're in a room with 20 coaches. So you might have some loose principles about width and depth and what we want to do with the ball and how we're going to create chances and set plays and stuff like that.

But as you were speaking, then I was thinking one of the main challenges here, one of the main things you need to think about is tearing this apart occasionally. So maybe at Christmas time or maybe the end of the season, you've got to be brave enough to reflect and say, first of all, are we living this style of play? Are we living it every single week or is it just a document that we build? It looks great.

It looks great. We're going to see it in the show. Parents are all. We're actually living it day to day.

And then is it actually working? So if we're doing what we're doing, is it producing players or other players having fun? Or whatever your value list is? Because if we just produce a document and it sits on our computers and we roll it out every season, but over five years, we can never adapt to it.

I don't think that can be the answer easier. Yeah, and I think just on that as well, I think the real test is going to be game day. So we've talked a lot in previous discussions about knowledge transfer and actually seeing whether coaching is effective or whether players are taking concepts on. But it's going to be that moment where you're two one down with 15 minutes to play.

And are you still going to stay true to that philosophy? Are your players relentlessly going to play out? If that's what you want them to do? Or are they going to find ways to try and get a result if that's what you're after?

Whilst sticking to the philosophy, or is it going to be let's shell it and go away from what we're trying to do just to make a win? Yeah, well, perhaps if we could be, we played out, we'll shape the find ways to win games. I don't think it's always important to say, oh, we lost but our philosophy was great. Yeah, great.

Like, quite the philosophy could be, we're going to change our shape to be effective against what the team would be. That's still a learning outcome. I suppose it's the challenge is not being too convenient and changing every single week and saying that's your philosophy because then I'm not really sure you've got one. Do you think we've got any content on the website that they could have with this question?

Yeah, we certainly do. There's a couple of fantastic webinars with different coaches. So the first one I recommend for listeners and viewers would be Idu Rubio, who's the Android team's coach and head coaching up at NK Don's there, developing forward thinking players, a really interesting webinar with him. And also Jose Figuero, who's the head coach at Team Wellington over there in New Zealand.

Great Masterclass video with him on the principles of play development. So really sort of taps into that. And also just on the idea of playing style, obviously, Esev Asalone is one of the best examples of being really true to the playing style. Highly recommend Jimmy Borne's work, both written and his video webinar series around his PhD where he was in Basa for a year around Llamassee.

So some good examples there. In terms of written content, issue 14 of the magazine was our Real Academy special. Great article with Christian Speakman, who's doing fantastic things up there at Birmingham City. And of course, a really good insight with Glenn Vandercray and over at Fine Order Academy.

So plenty there for Chris to have a look at on the website. Dan, any final thoughts from you on this one? Yeah, I think the Barcelona Masterclass discussion is a really good example of philosophy that's evolved over time. And the influences on the outside and how that sort of philosophy is what we see today.

So when we were talking earlier about building the best PowerPoint display and saying this is our philosophy and leading it alone, that's why it's about to learn as a living example of something that's evolved and got to a point where it's successful, but occasionally they won't have to go and buy this sort of play because that isn't the play that they can produce it. So, you know, a perfect example to look at, I guess. Excellent. Well, hopefully a few ideas there for Chris.

And Dan, thank you so much once again for your time. We'll look forward to another PDP Q&A very soon. Thanks for joining us on the Play Development Project podcast. You can follow us on Twitter and Instagram at Play at EP or find us on Facebook.

Don't forget to head over to Play at Devolve and Project.com, where you can sign up for our Progressive Coaching community and gain access to our wide variety of resources to help you in your coaching.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching?

This episode is 13 minutes long.

When was this Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching episode published?

This episode was published on September 8, 2017.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.