Skip to content
Q&A: Is there value in a pattern of play? episode artwork

Sep 24, 2018 23 min

Q&A: Is there value in a pattern of play?

from Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching Hosted by Player Development Project

The question this week comes from Pete, via the PDP Facebook Page: “Is there value in a pattern of play?” Exclusive offer for Podcast listeners: 30 Days Free Active Membership. Visit www.playerdevelopmentproject.com/podcast

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Q&A: Is there value in a pattern of play?

0:00 23:35
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to the Play Development Project Podcast. My name is Dave Wright, co-founder and editor of Play Development Project. PDP is a website for coaches who are committed to their, and we provide a huge library of resources which consists of cutting edge insights from the world's most innovative Play developers, coach educators and researchers. If you want to learn from the best and join a community of like-minded coaches, then check out Play Development Project.com.

On this week's Play Development Project Podcast, we answer a question from our community. Hi everyone, my name is Dave Wright and once again welcome to another Play Development Project Q&A. As always, I'm joined by PDP Technical Advisor Dan Wright. Dan, how are you mate?

Really well, thank you. Looking forward to this question. I think it could be a good chat. It's a pretty interesting one and it's coming from PDP by the PDP Facebook page.

PDP said, I see a lot of passing patterns online. What do you think of them? Quite a broad question and obviously something that polarises opinion in terms of oppose versus unopposed is the debate even relevant? Is it worthwhile?

We've had contributors like being Bartlett say that the reductionist argument in coaching is somewhat redundant and we can't really break things up. But there is a spectrum in coaching. This is a really interesting one to tackle. Dan, what are your thoughts to kick things off?

I think you just started this one because I think you've got a strong opinion around perhaps going back by seeing stuff online and then sticking it straight out to underlines what he thought was on that one. I think it's something I see a lot in particular on social media groups with a lot of coaching content being shared. I think one of the key things with PDP is that we will provide session plans but they're adaptable practices and you need to very much tweak them so they're relevant to your players whether that's the age, the ability, the stage on their own journey and I think having a framework is fine and a lot of practice can be adapted. It's very unrealistic to see, you know, semi-only putting on a practice of athletic over dread and then say, I'm going to do that with my under-thirteen's.

I think it's very different youth development to the professional game and a lot of the content you see online in terms of video sessions with professional clubs is not necessarily relevant to those kind of younger ages. So whilst there's bits you can take, a Rondo is a good example, you know, 4B4 plus 3, I think that is a session that does have relevance for young players in terms of receiving skills, releasing skills, positional understanding, rotation, moving on different lines. There's lots of stuff you can get out in those kind of positional play practices again as long as they're relevant to your players but just taking a session you see on film on the web and then putting it into your environment. It can be a risk to that so I think it's important to put some context around what you see on the web and then what's relevant to your players.

Do you sort of agree with that? I think we come back to a lot of the same messages on these Q&A's. I think the why of the practice is important. So when you see these first-in practices whether it's Chelsea, Barcelona, and the top top teams, those practices are for those players and there's loads of context around it.

So the first thing is that I think those players are elite, they are the top 0.1% of people in the world and they're not the same as under-nines that are learning the game. So watching a Gero finish is not the same as watching an under-nine finish and they will get different returns and they'll need different things at different times. I also think that a lot of the footage that these guys put out are practices that they want you to see so they don't show you perhaps to be only doing a face of play but how they're going to stop real Madrid because they don't want people to see that. So some of the sessions are kind of maintenance, tick over sessions, they could be playing two or three games in eight days and it could just be to get the guys out on the pitch and so that's not the same as an under-nine session.

So there's so much context around that. Isn't it the learning versus performance that what's the session for? These guys will be that their kind of physical returns will be really monitored and so how intense the sessions are means to the coaches who put on certain things. I know that Guardiola, a lot of his kind of fitness sessions look like football as well so they're very keen on kind of how he mannequins and hurdles and then it's to a finish and the people say that's a finishing practice but my understanding is that he does those more for kind of a motivational things so that the guys are doing that they're running and jumping and landing stuff with a little bit more enthusiasm.

And Guardiola or his fitness coach I think is going to invent a lot of the tend to do in areas of the pitch that match as well. I think Guardiola is a big fan of that so it's kind of like full backs with working certain areas and other nine's working certain areas but is that valid and is it important for under 10's probably not. So yeah so I think we can move on now. I think that's the rent over I think we've massively qualified our sort of perspective on this but I think we're getting a question here which really could be debated as drills versus patents is they're different so maybe we should start there in terms of your thoughts on the difference between a drill and a patent and where there is value and a patent of like.

I mean it's semantics isn't it because some people I know use drill for everything so a rondo is a drill, a finishing practice is a drill so they have drills and games like and some people kind of probably more like you and I'm a bit more pedantic would say no this is a drill this is a patent this is so a drill in my opinion would be no decision making so it would be purely for repetition of technique it would be predetermined so it would be you go from here to here or you run from here to here or you pass to A to B and you run there so zero decision making for the players but lots of repetition and people could argue about technical returns or honing technique which again is a separate. A patent for me would be something that looks like the game and it's unappable very kind of overloaded with a tactical return that's how I've kind of described a patent so the idea of you know plan from the back or switching play or working a crossing situation but the ball doesn't always have to be predetermined so it could be you know we want to get the return of switching play so we know that it needs to go from this side to this side but it doesn't have to do it A to B to C it completely switching along ball we can switch it to passes we can go back and then switch that would be the difference between a patent and drill if I've made any sense there. Yeah I think so and I think I think there's you know you can as you said within a patent it doesn't have to be 11 players passing the ball unopposed and sort of a traditional shake work or it could be that there's a couple of centre backs and play it could be that there's a nine and a couple of other players pressing I know before matches in the past it's something that I've used where you'll take the players who are starting maybe it's a nine side game the nine go in and they just try and keep position in their shape whilst perhaps four or five players who are starting on the sideline go in and just work as a pressing thing. Now that may only be for five or six minutes obviously you don't want to run players into the ground full distances before the game but maybe just to give the team who's starting a little opportunity to say okay we're playing in a 3-2-3 today let's go out there and move the ball around our shape and the team that's pressing works for short rotations and gets the chance to score if they win the ball and they get to attack under loaded so there is that sort of place to put players in there but I think the ability to use a pattern for tactical understanding and I think the key here is allowing the decision so whilst you may use equipment whether that's mannequins or whether that's putting cones in certain areas or whatever is at your disposal you may say like we want to try and get the ball into this area and then we want to try and get a finish.

Now the movement around that may be entirely decided by the players but you just lay the framework down or perhaps the shape that you play as the framework to do so and as you say the idea of a drill I couldn't agree more predetermined ideas where you're saying a place you must pass this distance move to this place I think that's something that personally I would avoid but patterns you know these are things that I've used for players in all ages both in the past and in the last few years as well where there is a place for that kind of exposure to a little bit of positional play and a little bit of okay let's use the whip for the pitch and to get that repetition in you're sacrificing the realism. An example I can think of from a couple of years ago was another 99 setting where we had just the front three in a midfield at number eight just looking to wake balls between areas for players to receive on the move so basic receiving skills and deliver basically into a striker in an opposite winger so they could look at aerial finishing different types of finishing so you're working on technical things like receiving on the move finishing on the move different types of scoring and they're getting a lot of opportunity to do that because you're removing that the finder now there was there was freedom within that so that for me has been a fit with young players. I think the difference between the predetermined drill and a pattern of play is there is still an element decision making so the decisions are probably narrowed but you know if I'm a wide player I think that's an easy example the wide player might be crossing first time he might be dribbling and crossing he might be waiting for an overlap but in a drill you would the coach would make that decision for them I think in a pattern you can you can still use a constraint load approach as you could say we need to switch to our seven how you do that is up to you and then you need to cross how you do that is up to you and then there is a bit of variability then for that guy but also for the maybe the finishes in the box this practice I've got in my mind all goes wide then how did the nine and ten get into the box well if you cross this first time it will have to quickly if you take a little dribble I might have to make a double movement and so there is still that element decision making and I like to think of it as like rehearsal so it's a rehearsal and I use them as like a lead into something more opposed so for example if you're doing a switch you play to cross to kind of stand the same theme you could do that unopposed with mannequins with spaces I'm not a fan of players standing on cones because I think you make decisions for them so I use a lot kind of zones and pitch geography of like you guys starting this area and trying to get into this area but then I would take it into a face of play or even 11 and then you know can you do what you were doing can you now stick this on the opposition so the rehearsal and there is a lot of tactical benefit I think I think the argument we're talking about with kids is aguero knows where to stand where knows where sign they will be do players or young players know that do they need a rehearsal of the spaces especially if you train in court of rasheter and when you go to game then you sometimes need to say no actually the width is there is there and like your triangle in the midfield three needs to look this big it's hard for kids to transfer that learning if they have never it's almost like you're asking them to build a platform on something but then they haven't got foundations absolutely so that's the skill of the culture can move it up and down that spectrum that we talked about before and I think you're just kind of tuning the dials down in the UK that was the phrase he used in the in the masterclass around those three eyes that the relevance excuse me the relevance and the repetition I think will be different for those players want it and sometimes you do have to sacrifice that realism and I think the other thing on this is that when you're working on individuals and I think coaches really need to be taking individualised approach to play development across the board you can use these kind of sessions to get those individual targets and there is a practice in the session playing library called pockets and passing and it's an example of an individual practice which the players have worked with in the past and essentially you know we had a right sided player who was playing in the seven for that period of the season and he was working on releasing so all I said to him was you're under the constraint of you must play the ball from anywhere between one and four touches so whilst he was on a pose he still couldn't have forever to go and dribble and just score he had to either try and release the ball one touch if he was in the correct position to do so or take the appropriate number of touches but he needed to get the feet sorted out to get the ball in the right position and you know work on a variety of crosses or longer distance passing which was part of his plan. Meantime back in the number ten position you've got somebody who's working on weight of past and shape of past so whether there's a mannequin there or whether there's a defender there it may just be shaping the ball around that it may be looking to weight the ball sets in front of the wing and to run on so that you can play off his first touch so there are different sort of individual constraints that you can put in a practice and I would recommend that coaches have a look at that one in the session playing library because it does outline how you can work on that then if you go back into the number nine who's on the inside perhaps they're working on first time finish so for them it's going to be timing and shape of movement to get on the end of the cross that comes in whether it's on the floor or whether it's in the year and there's a lot of opportunity there for those players to get success and try different things without the pressure of a defender.

That session in particular actually did have a center back in there to cause some problems for the nine in the opposite winger and that means that there is a little bit of realism and this is pressure and that defender is getting to work on something that was positioned specific to them so you know there's ways that you can ramp it up and I think a pattern of play also has tactical benefit so do you want to sort of dig into that a little bit around how the where the tactical side comes out as opposed to the technical. Yeah I think in an opposed pattern I've got chance to focus on or tune to what I want so if you use the example of a nine in the game they're going to have to think about whether defenders are where the space is where I'm going to take my touch where my two mates are and I'm planning a four feet is a lot going on which is good like that's the game that's what they need to be able to do but at times it might be too complex a picture to ask them to focus on all those things and expect them to arrive at the right time in the right space and then apply the right finish that's quite a lot for any player to deal with so by moving up and down this spectrum and I think it's important that we're talking about using the whole spectrum not saying that game the game be the teacher is the best and the left drills be you know chucked in the bin more vice versa I don't think that one is better than the other I think it has to be a balanced kind of diet and different players that you talked about need different things but that's the question if I was a number nine and I'm doing an unopposed pattern I can just focus on a couple of things and I need to worry about the defenders I can just focus on my timing to get into the box the seven to get in it the seven to get in it every single time I'm running into the box so then you might get to really zoom in on details of when they get to the ball and he opens up with his first touch that's the moment to go and it could be like milliseconds between the ball shall be today but I'm making a movement away with David taking his touch I'm getting into the box and to get that much repetition in an opposed practice is difficult so you might have to if you think about how many returns or how many opportunities or action that that player is going to get in an unopposed practice say that number nine gets 25 crosses well you have to play for a long time for a number seven to cross the ball 25 times with a fall back against him and so it's just what is the intention of the session what do you want the people to do you want loads of crossing and finishing then make it easy for people to cross the ball and you could have like you said a five and six in there against the nine and that would be really hard or you could have one defender against the nine and that would be slightly easier or you could have another defender that would be really easy and so it's just about where you are on that spectrum and where do you want the players to kind of find that pinch point and where's the challenge I wouldn't exclusively do these I think that's important I don't think I would say we do this every single week and we do this and then that's it I often use them as a lead into something else so we're using a big space practice whether it's a 11 to 11 and 99 or a phase of play these are the kind of pictures that I think we're going to see we might see and then it's a skill of the culture whether you're saying these are the kind of three or four things that I think will generally happen of course the games random so you can't say exactly these things will happen but you're then giving the guys some competency and some frameworks to work on rather than play a phase of play what is it that they want me to go for an idea I'm right I think that's the kind of very basic tactical understanding and you can do that with a jersey culture doing it with a drill where they they're exactly telling the guys what the move will be and then you try and run it and again but when we're talking about skill skill needs to be adaptable and to be adaptable you need loads and loads of solutions to a problem like and that that's another argument of whether there are you know four or five set patterns and there are a million possibilities and so it's kind of given the players opportunity but I don't know whether you can expect the players to have the answers if they've never had an opportunity to discover the answers they could get there if you did everything opposed all the time but it might take a long long time and so it's okay for a coach to say no these are some of the ways you could cross the ball yeah and then then have a little search and discover I think this comes down to us well hey you define a pattern so traditionally a pattern of play may be seen as well we play this certain way so there must be this combination to go through here this combination you're almost scripted movements now I would I would look at a pattern personally so there's a structure there and as I said earlier there's a little bit of freedom within that framework to then go and okay we'll find a solution so the ball's been played into this area I need to speed up my run I need to take my touch here so that that sort of framework and that guideline as opposed to a strict you must pass from A to B to C that's how I would see and I think we were lucky enough a couple of years ago to spend the day up at Liverpool when Mick Beall was there he's obviously now up at Rangers with the first team and we watched him work with the 21s at the time and he did an interference base pattern didn't he where it was all about quick play through midfield and they were switching from fall back to opposite wing but it had to go through the midfielders so little combinations and zinging the ball out to the opposite wing for across the finish the focal point for him was those players centrally and how they combined where they took up positions and obviously their effective passing and receiving technique to move the ball quickly whilst there was some interference because there was a pattern going in the opposite direction so there was some chaos there it was the challenge for the players in terms of having to put their passing areas to break down and there was a desire to do it with quality and speed and obviously players at that age and with that experience had the ability to perform at a certain level if you're going to go and try this with under 12s then perhaps they're not going to have the technical ability or move the ball as quick as players of 10 years older but so that's where there's got to be a degree of patience as well yeah and Mick moved through that kind of spectrum didn't he started with two kind of groups I think they were ten aside so one group played and the other group played it was alternating and then he said that the defenders could try and get in the way so they were playing through the defenders but the defenders kind of stood there so if your cross or pass was rubbish it was rubbish and then he moved on to interceptions only so as the ball came in the center backs could try and head it or clear it but they couldn't actually tackle and then it went on for maybe ten minutes and then he went right just play they turned it straight into a game and so that was quite a nice way of them this is some of the ways you can switch play and you're right he didn't tell the center mid-town to do it it's still going to play the full backtop of the winger but interference to full game and that's quite a nice quite a nice way to do it and I think this kind of links into a whole part hold as well you could with kids start with the phase or the game do something where the coaches more in control or you're narrowing those options and then zooming in on different things and then go back to the game and you know if you use the example of a number nine that would be play a game trying to score against these center backs okay here's some crossing and finishing for you to get loads of repetition of movement and finish you know okay you're doing different things you're going to have to adapt here he comes high the space behind he drops off you might come to feet like I think that's they're giving the kids a nice kind of barrier to the jump from something that's really random to something simple to back to random complex yeah and I think the last couple thoughts from I perspective this is also way to almost periodize your work as well in the sense of um by going unopposed or slightly opposed you're actually reducing the sort of impact and you might be slowing down the physical exertion so whether that's managing the size of the session and relative to the time of the week it may be a way just to say look tonight we're going to do a technical sort of later session and then you know in a couple of days we're going to do a heavier session where it's going to be more opposed so if you are managing players load and we don't know the age of the team that Pete's working with but if you are looking to take that into account particularly through that youth development phase or those teenage years and on it's important to just be aware that this is an opportunity to use the coaching spectrum to say well dial down the physical exertion tonight but you know we want to see the technical quality so let's make sure the details good so I think there's certainly a lot to consider there for Pete any final thoughts on this one for you yeah my kind of two main focuses would be that ball speed is really important in these so as a card you might have to drive standards you might have to say you know that isn't quick enough or that is a realistic so you know you said you couldn't do that with touches but I tend to refer to ball speed so like the even if the defenders passing out to fall back it's all slowly slow and we're going to invite a press then you know is that going to transfer to the game so that's a good way to not make the practice opposed but to make it demanding if you've been in the ball into the number seven quickly he's got to run quickly and cross weekly it looks like the game and then the other takeaway is context is king isn't it when we're seeing all these videos or little snippets on Twitter or Facebook okay what does that mean for my 12 not to mean something or does it mean nothing at all absolutely well then thank you for your thoughts hopefully we've helped Pete out with that one and and make awesome discussion or debate around that I hope so thanks for your time and we will look forward to another play development project Q&A very soon thanks for joining us on the play development project podcast you can follow us on Twitter and Instagram at playa.db or find us on Facebook don't forget to head over to playa development project.com where you can sign up to our progressive coaching community to gain access to a wide variety of resources to help you in your coaching

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching?

This episode is 23 minutes long.

When was this Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching episode published?

This episode was published on September 24, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.