Hi everyone, this is Dave Wright and welcome to the Play Development Project podcast. It's great to be back online for 2021 and we hope you're staying safe and well with the world you're tuning in. In exciting news, the PDP team has already been working hard on more great resources and initiatives for our community and we're looking forward to bringing those to you this year. We'll also be announcing our first webinar guest of the year very soon as well, so watch this space.
Now today's podcast is a Q&A discussion that I enjoyed putting together with PDP technical advisor Dan Wright and the video version is now available on the website. The question is, should I have a theme to my training sessions? Dan and I really enjoyed this question as it throws up a lot of considerations for coaches. We dive into the pros and cons of having a theme or topic in mind and what the benefits or risks of this approach can be.
So hopefully the conversation promotes a bit of thought. We always value your thoughts, so if you've got an opinion on this topic, contact us via our social channels or connect with us on the PDP Slack community. Now if you haven't joined Play Development Project yet, you can sign up as a PDP member at Play Development Project.com. Our free 30-day trial is still available so you can explore the platform and all members resources and join the content for up to a month with no charge.
Head to Play Development Project.com, select a monthly or annual membership and dive into the library of learning content. Thanks for joining us today. I really hope you enjoy the conversation. Hi everyone, my name is Dave Wright and welcome to another Play Development Project Q&A discussion.
As per usual, I'm delighted to be joined by PDP technical advisor Dan Wright. Dan, how are you this week? I'm very well, thank you. How are you, Matt?
Good, good. Now looking forward to another great community question. This time it's come in via the PDP Slack community and the question's coming from Gev and it is, should I have a theme for my session? It's a really interesting one because I guess it's one that comes up a lot with the coaching community and we all love to plan and so on.
So why don't you sort of start us off with your first thoughts, mate? Yeah, so this was something that was mentioned on the Slack group and we kind of bounced it around a bit, didn't we between us two and a few of the members. So it's difficult to always give the nuance and the detail on those kind of platforms so we're going to try and pick up a bit in the Q&A. So I thought maybe that the first place to start would be kind of season plans and curriculums, maybe versus agent stage, what the kids need and maybe what's emerging from the game.
So we're definitely going to go down a few rabbit holes and put it a few, it depends on this and depends on this. So I think quite a few coaches really like to have the whole season or whole block of work mapped out. So we eight will do this, we nine will do this or a curriculum or a kind of cycle of possession or whatever kind of that game model might be. And I wonder like this is probably a good place for us to start.
The constraints or the restrictions that that gives you versus like the team are really struggling with this or individuals in our group need this. So when the curriculum says we're working on one thing but the group or the individuals in the group need to work on another thing, what'd you do then? That was kind of one of the first points we kind of answered around, wasn't it? Certainly was and I think this takes me back to the Masterclass discussion years ago with Ben Bartlett when we first filmed our first Masterclass with him around non-linear pedagogy and constraints based coaching.
And you know, he talked about reductionist approaches to coaching. And I think it's one of those where at times we want to just, I guess, organize everything and put things into categories. And yeah, there's moments within the game, but I guess my view's changed a little bit on this over time in the sense that I would have been probably quite an advocate for curriculum, particularly when I was in the academy system versus now where I think it is mainly around what are the individual needs for developing players and then there's obviously going to be some team tasks and team focus around that. So I think there is a desire to organize things and put things into a linear fashion when they don't necessarily evolve that way.
I would have put the caveat on it that I think having a plan is helpful and you'd know that better than anyone, Dan, given how much we work together, that having a plan is helpful and there needs to be some sort of structure around a program or whether that program is just to get players in and then create total chaos. There's still a structure there, right? There's still some organization. So I think we've got to avoid going down this kind of strict curriculum and we must do this topic in this session every time and have some trust that we can create practices that look like the game where there's attack, defense and transition and as coaches, we're learning all the time about what we're observing, what we're listening to, understanding the individuals and the environment and all of those moving parts and that we can actually make decisions with our eyes and ears on the run.
So that's sort of an initial thought around the linear nature of that planning piece. Yeah, I think the idea that some people might argue learning in general but learning to sort or maybe learning skills to play a sport that we go almost like a reading age, we start with one and then we move to three and then we get to four. When we coach a group of players, people are going to learn different stuff at different times and people are going to learn something quicker than somebody else. So the idea that the curriculum is kind of moved down the road but player is right at the beginning, what do we do then?
So I think we've got to get more comfortable with that. One of the things we kind of spoke about was that maybe having a theme of the practice, but like you said, the theme looks like the game or the practices design looks like the game that gives us a bit more wriggle room to coach things that might emerge. So maybe again, that's kind of fueling our bias about a game's based approach or more opposed sessions versus less technical isolated sessions. So if our game kind of has direction and opposition and maybe some goals and generally looks like football, then we might start with the intention of coaching X, actually something else might emerge and it gives us opportunity to maybe go slightly off-piece or if we're working on one aspect of the defenders are really struggling with defending as a pair, then we might be able to talk about that within the practice.
Is that something that kind of resonates with you? If we've got a game or a design that looks a bit like a game, then we'll probably have to coach more than one thing at a time, I guess. And also if you've number four on the list, it becomes more important than the number one on our plan, then we're happy to kind of flip around a bit. Yeah, there's one that sort of pops in the mind.
It's the old attacker who's a defense session, right? We've been there as a player, we've probably coached it. We've just got four team players and I'm going to do a tactical defense and that might involve a back four and midfield three up against the front three and midfield three. Maybe there's a center back sitting behind on halfway and you may be constrained by the fact you only got half a pitch to train on in your environment.
So that's one where I think, well, actually, within that framework of a 7v7 and half a pitch, how many different things could you work on? You could go playing out from the back and then you've also got to think, well, actually that's conducive to working on pressing because if you've got opposition in place and perhaps they're focused on pressing while the other team plays out or maybe they're focused on blocking. Now maybe as a coach, you don't have to sit that thing. You can see what emerges and what we need to work on.
So if we're constantly getting popped in the press, then maybe there's an opportunity to go and coach and ask the questions. And so actually, how can we prevent this team playing out from the back? And I like the term head in learning. It's one that I heard a lot when I was working in Australia around, I guess, one outcome in itself to another.
So there may be a main theme, but there's going to be something else emerging on the pitch for the opposition or individuals around it. So that's kind of a simple example there where I think actually you don't get one without the other. And that's kind of how I see it in some ways. And didn't talk about it from the Slack group, but it's kind of just popped into my head now.
It's probably the space around having two coaches or a coaching assistant. So the theme might be playing out from the back, but I can't stretch and challenge or show loads of different pictures of how you might play out for the back. Like you said, if the team aren't pressing appropriately. So it might be that you and I sit down and design a practice, whether it's a player function or small-site, a game or whatever.
My primary focus is by the imposition and your primary focus is that possession. And we might just have to know each other really well and know the kids really well to know actually your turn to step in and maybe have them or can you rev them up a bit to get a bit of press or we get loads of success, so can you stop that. And then I think between coaches, it's again, like how much of that is explicit, like I'm going to work on this, then you work on this, then I work on this, or you set your team a challenge and make it really difficult. And my group has to try and find a solution to work it out.
I think again, that is what all for me, that is like kind of tactical battle or game intelligence or game craft or whatever people want to call it. I think we could be comfortable that we've got some broad ideas and some broad principles of what good looks like, but what will actually come out in the session might not be controlled, might not be an ass-wrenchy. I think I'm getting more comfortable with that. Yeah, and I think the other thing is, so it is a luxury to have two coaches and there'll be certain coaches out there that have that.
But one of the things that was quite big through the A-license process around realism was about managing the opposition. You might be going out there to coach a 10v10 scenario on two thirds of a pitch, for example. You're being observed and you're getting some feedback as part of that process. And if the opposition aren't playing in a realistic way, so maybe you're working on playing out from the back and maybe they're not pressing or maybe it's playing out against the low block, so we need them to be in a low block.
If you're not managing that to create the scenario that you're working on, then that's not necessarily going to lend itself to helping either team, because there's a lack of realism through either potentially laziness or players not being switched on, or maybe we have an articulated the task clearly. There's all these kind of variables that I guess we can have some control on. It was interesting to go through that process, reflecting on a number of years later. And actually, that was one of the things that we all had to work on was ensuring we've got all this focus on what we want to work on with our team.
But if the opposition's suddenly not coming to the party, then that's going to affect them. So if we're preparing for a game against a team that plays a high press, but our team and training who sit up to replicate that isn't putting in the effort or delivering on that, then that's going to create some challenges. So I think that's another one. We're managing the opposition as something to have in the back of your mind.
And again, using your eyes and ears, what are you seeing in front of you and what's starting to emerge? So that's another thing to think about, I guess. Yeah, and on the cohort that we were on, there were people maybe reflecting on their sessions and they only saw their team. So it was like, I was struggling to coach this or struggling to find the opportunity for the players to practice this.
And I was like, well, that wasn't the problem. The problem was there was no space behind or the problem was they were playing with the back five and you want them to be in the back three. So you've got to find a way to meet with that whether it's implicit through clever session designs, they've got to get to a certain recovery position or they've got to get out of a certain space when the ball goes backwards or whatever. Or you've got to be more commenced out and tell them that when the ball goes here, I need you to hear up your come.
And again, that was an interesting learning, like you said for us. I think so I feel like a bit more of a radical point of view. I'm moving towards a space where we've got a style or how we want to play, whether that's kind of moments of the game or team targets or just an identity of how we want to play football, then we've got players that have got individual needs, super strength, things they want to work on. And then we've maybe got in a high performance setting or in a setting where we may be thinking about players going on a journey on a pathway, got an idea of what the players might need at the end of that or for that next step.
So we've got those three things, style of playing individual needs and maybe what we're trying to have the players to look like in terms of a skill base. Then the curriculum is probably all the themes or the sessions or whatever words you want to use. It's probably like the glue between those things. So if we've got a consistent style of play in a possession base that we want to tackle whatever, we want to play in a high density and then we know that Dave and Dan and these kids work on these things, then your sessions will kind of get designed between those two things.
And then it's maybe the last bit is if we want them to be able to do X, Y, Z, or they need to understand how to press in a 4, 3, 3 or whatever, maybe the first team manager or the next step in our journey is requiring. Then we know that we need to have them get there. So those kind of three bubbles for me, I think the curriculum is probably the gap between those rather than the curriculum is everything. And then we kind of push and mold the kids into this spreadsheet.
If those things should be the rocks, we want to dominate the ball, we want to attack in great players that can take risks or whatever that language is. And then we know Dave's working on his left foot, Dan's working on his recovery runs, session probably could look a bit like this. And then we're giving repetition of those things. That's kind of where I've got to.
I think I had two questions here. What do you think of that as an idea? And then do you think you have to go through some years of curriculum and session plans and reflecting and maybe getting that itch of like, I want to coach that and the curriculum says this, you're going to get to that space. What do you think it's very individual and some people will really like structure and process and some people will be a bit more comfortable with what emerges from the game.
A merge from the game might be box for like it might be mental model or does that go into individuals and start a play again? It's all kind of, yeah. There's a lot to consider this. I think first of all, there's risks.
So I think we can talk about that. So if we focus our attention on one area, what are the risks? But if we say that we've got a style of play and the game is always the same in terms of scoring goals and stopping goals, is there a risk that we're trying to stuff players into a style of play who maybe that style of play doesn't lend itself towards. So I think that's something always the way up is throughout the season, mixing up the way we play.
And I'm not saying you have to go away from a philosophy, we still want to play out of the back, but maybe we're going to do that in different shapes or different ways. So that's just an example. So I think there's a risk of saying, well, you know, we've got this individual focus and to go on and play as a footballer, maybe you need to experience running in behind or maybe you need to experience playing in a different shape. And I've seen this with teams where you go, okay, for the next six weeks, we're going to work in a three, five, two and you've got kids putting a hand up.
I've never done that before. And you think, and that might be a double three in my crazy mental model. I've like, we expect kids to be able to play in a few different shapes. So that might jump ahead of style of play because you want them to be flexible and uncomfortable, whatever.
It's a really good topic to answer. I'm sorry. I think often it is. I think the second part of your question is around, do you need to experience those things?
So the resistance, like I'll put my hand up and say, if somebody comes to me and says, I need you to deliver this session, I really struggle with that. Because that's somebody else's session. And I think, well, actually, I can see the framework and I can see what they're trying to see, but I'd like to put a twist on it here. And maybe I'll do it this way.
And that's something that over time I've got more confident with because I don't think that that's necessarily conducive. So one of the things we've always advocated for with the PDP session plans is take them. They're adaptable. They're a framework.
So here's a structure. Here's some ideas. Here's options for different numbers of players and just mess about with it. Because I think just ending people working here's an exact solution to a topic.
Here's your session plan going to deliver it. I think as coaches, we've got to be more skilled than that. The other part to that is that working environments where perhaps there's whether it's values or whether it's the approach or whether it's the philosophy that doesn't quite align, there's pros and cons to that too, because that can be really beneficial because it puts you out of your comfort zone. It can also be really conflicting because it doesn't necessarily sit well with you.
So I think you've got to put yourself into environments from a coach's development perspective to say, actually, I'm going to work in a environment which is quite rigid and then I'm going to go over to this place, which is quite loose and there's a lot of freedom. And you kind of find yourself in terms of where that sits for you on the spectrum of how you'd like to deliver. I think there's a few things there to consider, but the risk with a strong theme for me if we go down this rabbit hole as such is that maybe we take our eye off the ball as something we're looking on controlling position or switching play. So we put that idea into the players head and suddenly they're moving the ball side to side, but perhaps as a result they're missing opportunities to exploit space centrally, which is emerging in the game.
So what are your thoughts around this? Because I think it's a challenging thought and we all love to play it, but it can sort of direct the players in one to one area because we're talking about it versus actually what do you see in the game? Yeah, this is like inception, isn't it? This question is the question.
I think if you're really explicit with today, we're going to work on switch your play, the practice looks like this, what we want you to do is XYZ. We can be really drawing their attention to certain things in the practice. It can be a bit false, it can be a bit artificial because they're maybe missing opportunities to penetrate in a different way. So I suppose first bit of my brain would be like, are we always explicit with the theme or what we're looking to achieve the session with the kids?
I would say not always. There's times where I'll put on a practice and I'd say it'll look great if it looks like this or say to the kids, what will look great in this kind of practice and they'll have some of the answers. Other times we're just explaining the practice and they crack on a nice step away and then we might say, what's the practice about what we're trying to work on or what we're working on in possession and how to have a session? So check in understanding and making sure the practice is real.
I think if we have a really narrow focus, I'm thinking of switching play game four goals where we have to go wide and we have to score. The pros of that is they're going to get loads of repetition of maybe checking their shoulders, opening up, receiving in a certain way, switching maybe short passes, switching with long passes, we're going to have loads of width. We're going to have all the things that perhaps we want to switch play but we're going to miss maybe putting it down the middle of the pitch, maybe paying over the top, maybe have all the combinations in the centre to go through, maybe shooting at goalkeeper, maybe forward runs in behind because we only need to go wide, you'll get defence spreading out which you won't want, you'll get people defending the four goals and not the centre of the pitch. So I think you've got to keep switching that lens, so we do a switching play again that might be four goals and then we do a phase of play where we're trying to go to the middle because the idea of switching play in the 11 billion game is to switch to get inside, like you always have to come inside to score a goal whether it's across or a combination of the goals are out there.
So know that by putting on that practice it's good because of X-YZ but it's poor because it doesn't look like the bit that they need to do on Saturday and Sunday. So I don't know that's sent you to your question but you need to think about if the practice focus is really tight or the theme is really tight, we do 90 minutes of one thing, by doing that one thing, we're doing A on the other 25 letters that we've missed. And the more narrow the focus would be the less context that you have in the game. That makes sense.
It's trade-offs, right? So if we think about like we put our curriculum in place, we put our plan in place, we say right over the season we're going to do this and we're ticking those boxes as we go because that's the program we, through evidence and through experience we believe is going to get players to maximise their potential. Then at times there's a risk there that perhaps there's something that actually needs addressing whether that's on an individual level or whether that's on a team level that maybe they're really struggling in any area right now for any number of reasons. So do we actually shift the program to one side and it's actually for the next two weeks we're going to focus here because we can see what's emerged.
So I think that's a little bit of a balance there and I think the other big one that you touched on was does it look like the game? Now that for me applies from a 1v1 right through to 11v11. That was that moment that you're trying to create whether it's a 1v1 where the balls turned over and the player has to react and suddenly it's a duel from the front, whether it's a ball put down the side and it's a duel side to side or from behind or a different angle. Are you creating moments where the new session design looks like the game?
And if the theme is there and it's strong in this narrow focus, the benefit may be as you said that level of repetition. So we're working on our four goal game, we're opening up getting into good receiving shapes, scanning different range of pass, all of the things that potentially you need to play in central areas longer term. So we're going high repetition narrow focus and again this is manipulating the practice spectrum versus a game with perhaps as you said earlier, it may be that players just have to get to a certain point when the play restarts which therefore creates some space in behind so we can start working on forward runs and defending long balls which would be conducive as two topics again with one theme and one head and learning. So there are trade offs, I think it's a really fascinating question.
I feel like this particular discussion has been a really good ramble in terms of throwing some ideas around and exploring those trade offs and those pros and cons. I think it's an interesting one. We certainly haven't had the answer but when the question came up on Slack it was one that I think is really challenging and really confronting for coaches. What are the final thoughts to wrap this one up then?
Yeah I think we touched on it briefly around what do the individuals in the group need. I think it might be worth just for two or three minutes again like unpicking what we mean by players having individual plans or players having individual focus. So ideally what we want is a piece where we've sat down with the player and we've co-corrected a plan of what you really do, what are the two things you think will help you be better in the game. So broadly maybe a super strength and an area of development depending on the age and stage of your players.
You might have one focus, you might have three, you might have a really kind of bright and invested teenage that could come with four or five times but each kid having some areas of focus. Maybe when we talk about these Q&A's and webinars and stuff people think about individual development being maybe just me and my board or one or a very small practice which is true like that can be individual development. But we can also coach the individual through team practices. So if we're doing a positional game or doing a possession practice or a directional practice or a small set of game there might be this overarching curricular focus of penetration forward passes to credit goals.
But then we might be really focusing on one player maybe our number four and he's working on his body shape to receive. So the individual focus might be like I'm coaching the team this and the practice design is this and we want to get these returns where we want to create these moments to paint these pictures. But when I'm working on this individual I'm going to work on when the goalkeeper gets the ball can the number four correct that back diamond with the two set of acts to help us play out to help us play through 360 to really brave to receive all those things that coaches maybe not. But I'm only going to look at that individual practice.
I'll still coach the practice and I'll still help people in the practice and try and keep my eyes open for other things. I'm just going to look at this individual. These two individuals that might have the same target. That would be how I would see an individual focus in youth football with players to get better rather than maybe just isolate practice or 1v1s or 2v2s where they get with the individual but I do think that's possible but we can also coach the individual in the context.
And again that might be a way where you've got your curriculum theme on topic X but I'm working with Dave around this little thing that's on his IDP or on his individual development plan to try and get success. I think we've bounced that around quite a few times and people get maybe not sure what that might look like. So that's a really clear way. And then if you have got a body of work as you go through those blocks you can go which are the kids that we would china like on.
So when we're playing out for the back it's probably going to be our goalkeeper on two centre backs. When we're switching play it's going to be our three midfield fielders. I'm going to avoid using numbers because it always gets to the field which is what is it's like attacking in wide areas we're going to work with our fall backs and wingers. So that might be a really good way to maybe keep the foot in both camps.
We're doing a great course we follow the plan. But actually the individuals in that plan might become the real kind of area of super focus. Does that make sense? Yeah it does.
I think it's an excellent summary around how to develop those individuals. I go back to the interview we did with Dema Cheechie years ago when he was working with England under 16s and he spoke about flexible frameworks. I think a big takeaway here is we've got to have something in place particularly when players are coming into systems and whether that's at a grass roots or an academy level or otherwise there's got to be something in place in form of a structure and an a belief around what we believe to be true, what our philosophy potentially is. But I don't think we should get bogged down with weak to weak curriculum topics and always been chained to that.
But there are those trade offs we've talked about with themes and with a focus and we've just got to understand how we find that balance. So Dan I think it's fantastic insight, really good thoughts from you and hopefully we've shared some ideas here which help give and other people tuning in to this particular conversation. As always thank you so much for your time. No worries then let's continue the conversation right?
There's so much to consider. So you can go back on the slack and maybe revisit this Q&A and another six weeks or so. Absolutely and we will look forward to another Play Development Project Q&A very soon.