Skip to content
Q&A: When should I play a player up or down a level? episode artwork

Oct 27, 2017 10 min

Q&A: When should I play a player up or down a level?

from Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching Hosted by Player Development Project

The question this week comes from Ryan, via Twitter: “What are the main criteria when considering playing a player down? My son is Q4 and physically small, but I wonder where ability fits in?” Exclusive offer for Podcast listeners: 30 Days Free Active Membership. Visit www.playerdevelopmentproject.com/podcast

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Q&A: When should I play a player up or down a level?

0:00 10:22
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to the Play Development Project podcast. My name is Dave Rite, co-founder and editor of Play Development Project. PDP is a website for coaches who are committed to learning and we provide a huge library of resources which consists of cutting edge insights from the world's most innovative play developers, coach educators and researchers. If you want to learn from the best and join a community of like-minded coaches at the JAKA Play Development Project.com.

On this week's Play Development Project podcast, we answer questions from our community and try to offer up advice and practical problems faced by coaches around the world. Hi everyone, welcome to another Play Development Project Q&A. I'm pleased to be joined once again by my colleague, UEFA A-licensed coach and PDP technical advisor Dan Wright. Dan, how are you this week, mate?

I'm very good. How are you today? I'm good. I'm good.

Looking forward to another interesting conversation and the question we are going to tackle first is what are the main criteria when considering playing a player down? My son is Q4 and physically small but I wonder where ability fits in and this has come in from Ryan via Twitter. I think he's implying that his son's going quite well technically there but obviously he is a Q4 and for those who may not be familiar with that term that means he's born late in the school year or the final quarter. What are your thoughts initially around this one, mate?

This is quite a complex one, isn't it? We've both got experience of... For me there's quite a few different factors that I think you've got to consider whether that's technically tactically, whether it's physical and what that's going to look like right now versus what it will look like when he's 16, 17, 18. But I think I'd probably start with the player and where he's out and how he's feeling and how his football's going because the Manchester just might be part of the struggle that we have to go through and end in a couple of years it could be fine but if the player is super unhappy I think that would be the starting point for me.

Yeah, I think first and foremost it's always good just to ask the player. Obviously we don't know the age of this particular individual but it can help just to ask the player about if you were to play down. How would you feel about it and if that's a really difficult decision or difficult scenario for the player to deal with then it would probably be one that you might really have to heavily consider before actually doing it. We've both worked with a player in the past who's still doing very well as far as we understand and was physically very small for a while there during that kind of under 12 age group.

And it was something that we looked at and we did do for a period of time. I mean, I look at it and I go, you really have to consider it quite seriously because it can have big social implications. So the player could take it personally, the player could see it as, although I'm not good enough, I'm not able to play with my friends that I'm already at the same age of. But if the player is really physically struggling, it could be a reason to do so or socially struggling if it's not working because maybe socially they found themselves down the picking order because of that immaturity or an experience.

But I would look at it more in the sense that keeping them in that group where if they're going to be physically small as you suggested, how are they going to be when they're 17, 18 or fully maturated. I would look at it as one of those things where being around the land of the giants or bigger fast or stronger can actually breed technical attributes such as better scanning, better awareness, quicker decisions, a lot of things that we might look for. So I think it's a really tough one. It does depend on how the player feels about it, what the reasons are.

But given that this is a Q4 child who's obviously very young, if they're technically competent, I'd be inclined to say stay where you are. I think it can also depend on the environment that you're in. If the club has a philosophy of making sure that you start 50% of the games or equal playing time or 50% playing time, I think there can be positives of staying in the environment. There are also some sort of horror stories of parents and players going two hours down the road and then playing eight minutes and that's just not beneficial.

So it might be a conversation for the players saying, in this environment, you'll play for this long, but in that environment, you could play three or four times longer. I think that could be a no-brainer. The social issues that you've touched on are huge because it can have long-term effects. If you say it's a play, you're going to play down for this six weeks or even six months.

I think that's a long time where they're not with their mates and this might be people they're going to score with. It might be people they're training with regularly. So removing them from that circle could be quite uncomfortable. And then you've also got to think about when you reintroduce them, what does that look like because they would have been away.

So they'll miss out on all the sort of the in jokes and the training sessions and just a general throw practice. So that can have a long-term understanding. But equally, I suppose there are some advantages of that. I think somebody that's character is probably less dominant when you play them down in each group.

They sometimes can become that leader and feel a little bit more confident, competent, and so this is what we're going to do. And so you could go from being a bit part player to being the main man, which could have some really good implications in that psychological corner. I think you have to look at the game for me and look at how many repetitions they're getting of what their action is. So there are a wide-blade saying they need to cross the ball and beat people.

And they're just physically not able to do it right now and they're not getting those crosses and they're not being able to get repetitions of taking people on then how beneficial is that. And then probably some of the experience of the coach is this going to last for half a season, or two or three seasons? I think that would influence my decision of whether you're giving a spell going down. And in that environment, whether you've got opportunity to do it periodically so it goes down for two weeks, it goes back or goes down for six weeks and comes back.

And whether that's all of training sessions, some of training sessions, I think you can find happy blend in there somewhere as well. Definitely. I couldn't agree more regarding the risks around the social side, but also the upside of being a leader going down. I think it very much comes down to the age of the player as well.

This may be very different. And I was actually asked this question by a contact recently regarding their son and this was a player who's now going into under 18 football, where it's a two-year age bracket, so they're playing 17s or 18s, but was a Q4 and had the opportunity to stay with the 16 age group. Now for me, there's a huge advantage in having another year there in youth football as such before pushing on to what's getting close to the men's game and being a leader and having that success. If it's been a tough season and the player needs success because, as you say, they might not be getting it if they're a 1v1 player and just physically can't do it, then there may be some upside.

So that player could develop in confidence if they do need success. But as I said earlier, this is one that I think you've really got to consider around, well, does the player want to do it first and foremost because it's about their experience and their enjoyment? And assuming this is a grassroots environment, making sure they're with their friends and having a good sporting experience has to be paramount. But if there are some upsides that are sort of tangible or able to be tracked in, and there's an open dialogue, and a real honesty with the player as to why we're doing this, and we think this will benefit you, then it's worth considering.

But based on the implication that the player seems to be technically coping, I would be inclined at this stage to stay put and then see how things go. If the player is really struggling to be thrown in the deep end and swim at all, then it's a case of managing that entirely. And we've actually got some pretty interesting content on the side around this. We've got a couple of articles from Steve Lawrence in issue 10 and issue 11 of the magazine, one around relative age effect, which is obviously the area that we're kind of talking about here, as well as biobanding, which is one way of perhaps looking at this issue and looking at how we can place kids together physically and look at their biological age as opposed to the other sort of factors that go with that.

But that's also got to be done with the grain of salt and a lot of consideration and knowledge of the player at the center of it. Paul McGinnis' recent masterclass discussion, he spoke heavily about the advantages of mixed age groups and trying to recreate street for also recommending that masterclass. And later this year, we've got a fantastic conversation with Nick Leiber at the FA around talent ID. And we recorded that one very recently, a really good discussion, which goes into these kind of ideas.

So some good content there, both on the site now and coming up shortly to look forward to. Any final thoughts on this one out there from your perspective, Dan? Yeah, I think it just sort of links into that non-linear journey. It's not going to be the same for every single kid in your group.

And having some ideas of what the player's going to look like in the future. So if both parents are six, one, and the player's undersized, I'd probably just stick with it because he's going to be fine. This just might be part of the struggle. And then you look at some players that were physically never super.

And I look at someone like Iniesta, it would be very interesting to see what he would look like at 12, 13, 14. And if he played him down in age group or two, will he still have that creative mind to adapt what he's playing against the pod? But, you know, I think you sometimes don't let the guy struggling that environment as long as they're not drowning, as long as they're not drowning, as long as they're constantly against it and constantly not having good performances and struggling to get those repetitions off those actions. And I think it would be time to look at it.

But always good to sort of consider the whole picture, I think. Certainly plenty to think about in this scenario. Dan, thank you for your time. Hopefully we've helped Ryan out with a half-decent answer there this week.

And we will look forward to another PDP Q&A very soon. Thanks for joining us on the Play It or VELV project podcast. You can follow us on Twitter and Instagram, at PlayItDP or find us on Facebook. Don't forget to head over to PlayIt or VELVARProject.com, where you can sign up throughout the press and coaching community and gain access to our wide variety of resources to help you in your coaching.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching?

This episode is 10 minutes long.

When was this Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching episode published?

This episode was published on October 27, 2017.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.