Skip to content
Rankning Superman Films episode artwork

May 23, 2025 2 hr 14 min

Rankning Superman Films

from Krypton Report: All things Superman & DC Comics Podcast Hosted by Jonathan Tyler Patrick, James Cole

Send us Fan Mail Tyler, James, Levi & Brad sit down with a list of 21 #Superman films and rank their favorites. The rankings might surprise you. #Supermanmovie @DCOfficial @Superman, #LookUp For all things Krypton Report: https://linktr.ee/Kryptonreport Help keep Krypton from Exploding join the $1 a month Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/kryptonreportpod https://open.spotify.com/show/3lRY203nlgk9EhPzwW1r7D?si=St6d4kC1RW-9zaVOI1nf9g https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/krypton-report-all-things-superman-dc-comics-podcast/id1009559471 Support the show

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Rankning Superman Films

0:00 2:14:39
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This is Dan Jurgens, and if you want to have a good time, keep listening to The Krypton Report. Jason J. Lewis, the voice of Superman on Justice League Action, and you're listening to The Krypton Report. Hi, this is David Patrick Wilson. I played Superman, Clark Kent, in the television production of It's a Bird, It's a Plane, during every minute of being right here on The Krypton Report. Look up in the sky, it's a bird, it's a plane. Welcome to The Krypton Report podcast. I'm Tyler, the Superman Blue, and I've assembled a team, because today we are going to rank Superman films.

As we prepare for Superman 2025, we're looking back on all the stuff that Man of Steelers has done and accomplished, and with me today, I've assembled the great and powerful Mr. James Cole. You've assembled me? I didn't know I came in pieces. Yeah, I had to order, like, you know, some came from China, some came from Taiwan, some came from Canada, and I just had to... Oh, so it cost you, like, 45% more to assemble me. Yep, but you're worth every dime, buddy. All right. Appreciate it. We also got Levi back.

Hey, hey. And we got Brad, and I'll let him introduce himself. Yes, otherwise not. Yeah, I can't do it justice like he can, so I have to let him do it. But today's, so what we've done is I made a list of Superman films, both live action and animated, okay? And the guidelines were Superman has to be like the main protagonist. So there's no Justice League films in this, sorry. And I avoided pretty much like...

I debate it. It's like BVS isn't in here. I debated it, but I feel like that's more of a Batman movie and Superman really got pushed back. So I've assembled, I can't remember how many, 21 films. Okay. And I made this little, so we'll run through this first. This is just kind of random order. It started being chronological, but I think I just ended up just throwing stuff together. But our film lists include Superman in the moment. I did not include the, I know I love your shirt. Appropriate for this episode. I have my super dad shirt on. Okay. And my new Superman hat. Looks like Levi has black Adam.

Yes. And James, you're just wearing green. I am just wearing green. Kryptonite, James. James Kryptonite coming at us. I did not include the movie serials because they're a different breed and they're not really like a movie and they're not easy to get a hold of if you don't already own them. So we have Superman and the Mole Men. Now we have Superman the movie, but we're not ranking the individual cuts. But when you do add the movie, I want you to tell me what cut is your preferred cut. Theatrical, the extended director's cut or the three hour extended cut.

We have Superman 2. Superman 2, the Richard Donner cut. I did make it its own movie. We have Superman 3. Superman 4. Superman Returns. Man of Steel. The Lois and Clark pilot. Because technically it was a made-for-TV movie. They shot it on film. It was designed to be a made-for-TV movie. And it's longer than a regular episode. And then the season kind of started after that. Because if you watch the second episode, there's some slight changes and adjustments to things. So it kind of stands on its own.

We are going to rank where we predict that James Gunn's film will be in our list. And then after the movie comes out, we'll kind of see how close we were. Superman Brainiac Attacks. Superman Doomsday. Superman vs. The Elite. Also known as James on a Friday night. The Death of Superman. Reign of the Superman. And yes, I did include Reign of the Superman because Superman is a very big part of it. In fact, there are four Superman. Yes. And I did split The Death of Superman and The Reign of Superman as separate films because they truly are, even though they did put one together. Superman Red Son.

Superman, Man of Tomorrow, All-Star Superman, Superman Unbound, Superman The Last Stone of Krypton, which was a full-length animated feature when it came out on VHS the first three episodes, because that's how I had it. I have It's a Bird Disappointed Superman, because technically it's a TV movie. And then our honorable mention is Superman Shazam, The Return of Black Adam. I put that as honorable mention because it's great, but technically it's a short. So that is our films, my friends. So that is our reference guide. We will now kick our reference guide off, and we will begin with our bottom, number 21. And we'll do it. We'll go Levi, Brad, James, me. So Levi, what is your number 21? So down here, it's the stuff that I'm familiar with but haven't seen in a very long time. I've only seen brief glimpses of. So I went with It's a Bird, It's a Plane.

All right. And I'm not like this. There will be no argument. I think what's really gonna be fun is when we get into our top five. See how far apart or how similar we are going up the scale.

Levi, I just noticed you got a nice little goatee going on, man. Let's try it. I am clean-shaven, fellas, because... Oh, you are? Sunday, we were doing an event at work, and even my hair is re-dyed black because I'm playing Superman. I'm dressing up for the kids. It's a kid's palooza, so all the kids that are in foster care and stuff come out for a big event. It's open to the public, so I will be dressed up as Superman. So I started clean-shaven for a little bit so that it wasn't such a drastic look when I did it. So after Sunday, I'll slowly start to grow some stuff back.

and let it come back in there is no wrong answers this is purely our personal opinions so we're just gonna have fun with it all right brad your number 21 all right so like a bunch of these i had tied so instead of 21 i got like 15 places in total should i just like start 15th or just wait for you guys to catch up So you just have 1 through 15? Yep. All right. I hear you. I'll make a note. Brad sucks. I'm just playing. Yeah, no, I mean, even there, you can use your 15s and just break them down. You know what I mean? I'm pretty sure that most of these on our lists, we all like to some degree or another. I doubt that there are many that you really actually hate. Yeah, there was like the ones like, oh, I know this will be on the bottom, but where? And then there's the ones like, oh, I know this will be on the top, but where? But there's none on here that I hate. Same here.

all right james what's your 21 um so well the bottom three to start are actually just three that i haven't even seen or watched yet so i can't even rank them on there um so i'm just gonna have to drop you know it's a bird it's a plane i haven't gotten to watch that yet it's understandable and that's what i told you guys uh my number 21 is superman brainiac attacks i to me this just doesn't work for me because it's like, it's got some different voices. It looks like the animated series, but it's really not. It just felt like lower quality, not as good. And I remember I have it. I own it. And I just watched it. It just wasn't, it wasn't doing it for me. So number 20, Levi. 20. We'll go with the other one that I'm just, I haven't had much exposure to Superman and the moment. All right. James 20. James.

Showing off that beard. Oh, 20? Okay, sorry. I've stopped for one second. So my 20 is going to just have to be Brainiac Attacks. I haven't seen it, so... See? And this is where I said we're going to have some stuff that's kind of flowing here. My 20 is it's a bird, it's a plane, and Superman. And I have watched it, so... But it was, I mean, it has its moments of enjoyability, but it was made on the cheap. And it's, you know, the quality's not great because they haven't actually given it a good release. Alright, number 19, Levi. Brainiac Attacks. It's the last one that I haven't actually seen. Okay. James.

Um, so y'all might hate me for this. There's no, I haven't watched the Richard Donner cut yet. I have not watched that one yet. So I know that I can't really comment. I want to get, I know you'll get this December cause we're going to watch it together in December. Yeah. I, I, I didn't own it before I got the, um, the, the five movie Blu-ray set. So I never, I never had it before now. So I've only actually had the opportunity to be able to watch it within like what the last six months since I bought it, since I bought that Blu-ray set.

So that whole conversation we had before we started recording, Mr. Director's cut. Oh, no, that's a big one. He put you in your place. Ten points for Levi. It's like, whose line is it anyways? But the points don't matter. All right. My number 19 is Red Son. It's just not one I go back to. You know, it's not a bad story. I don't hate the story, even though there's different from the book. Yeah. A lot of liberties, you know, but it's just it's not like the to me, like true Superman. So it's my number 19.

All right, 18, Levi. Okay, yeah, mine is, so this is the first one of the stuff I have seen. It has been a very long time since I have seen it, but it's the Lois and Clark pilot because we don't know how I feel about Dean Cain. All right, yeah, we do. All right, James, your number 18. So my number 18 is actually Superman IV. I haven't watched that movie that often. I've only seen it a couple of times.

I just know it's pretty campy, pretty cheesy, and that's what I remember from it. Like I said, there's no wrong answers. No, I know. My number 18 is Superman in the moment. I like George in it. He's got some good parts, but as a movie and everything, it just doesn't hold up. It works better as the two episodes at the end of season one. Number 17, Levi. This is where I go, Red Son, for what you already said. It just doesn't feel like Superman. It's a cool alt-world take, but...

I'll pass on it most times. Yeah, I don't think I've watched it. I think I watched it when I bought it, and then I watched it one more time shortly later because James and I were reviewing it. So I think I've only watched it twice when it first came out, and that's been it. But I have it. All right, James, you're 17. My 17 is Superman and the Mole Man. I mean, George Reeves, that's what really sells it on that one. He does a really great job. I mean, he does. It's one of those that's worth watching once just because he does a good job. His speech,

And the message of that is really strong and so applicable even today. 70 years later. And that's why I say it works so much better as a special two episode at the end of season one of the show than it does as a standalone movie. My number 17 is one that James and I watched recently, but it's Superman Doomsday. I like the first part of that movie, but once Superman dies, I don't really like where the movie goes. I also don't really like the relationship between him and Lois in that movie. I think it's really weird and seems very awkward. So, yeah.

All right, Levi, 16. I went with The Last Son of Krypton. I have watched these. It's the first three episodes, isn't it? Yeah. My son is very recently asking to watch Superman. So we're putting on the animated series a lot. So I've seen it a lot in the last few months. And it definitely works better as three episodes. And I think it's like a sit down and watch a movie type thing. Levi, you're raising them right. Bringing up good parenting. He's asking for Superman. It's one of those things when your kid actually likes the things that you like. You're like, oh my God, you just spend a bunch of money and give them stuff. Here, here, here.

All right, James, your number 16. Is Superman Doomsday. I mean, for just about everything that you said. I mean, beyond the first 23 minutes of the change of that movie, it takes a weird bit of a turn. The relationship primarily, like Superman is living a double life with Lois. Yeah. Beyond the Doomsday stuff in that movie, that's why it's down. All right. My number 16 is Superman 3. I have only watched Superman 3.

I think three times. Nice little pun there. Superman 3? Three times. There is a good movie in there. There's stuff I like in the movie, but as a whole, I don't go back to it because there's a lot I don't like. That's why I like Superman Redeemed, but that's another story. Alright, now Brad will be joining us. Number 15, Levi.

This is where I had Superman Doomsday. And you guys made me rethink. I've got my letterboxd open. That's what I have everything ranked on right now. Nice. And I had forgot. It's been probably six or seven years since I'd watched it. And I forgot how weird the relationship got. And I had it a bit higher because I'm a whore for a good Doomsday movie. But that dropped it back down. You know, that whole part where he's like, I don't even know your real name. It's Kal-El. You know, like, it just feels weird that she's dating Superman. And he hasn't told her he's Clark. And, like, it just feels weird. You know? Yep.

All right, Brad, 15. All right, number 15. Before I do that, however, one big thing for you guys, as well as all of our viewers, tomorrow's free comic book day. Yes, it is. My girlfriend got me this poster a few days ago. I absolutely love it. It's amazing. Oh, yeah. But as for number 15, my 15th place would be Superman 3. Superman 3, I like to compare to basically the Batman Robin of the...

Christopher Reeve films. It's too much of a comedy rather than, you know, a Superman film. That and, like, outside, like, the fights with evil Superman, there's really no good fight scene or anything like that. And Richard Pryor, I love. He's hilarious. Especially the one joke that can't stand the show. What you talking about? But I know he regretted making it. And, like, he's just so goofy and over the top and everything. He wanted to be, like, a serious actor in a movie. It just doesn't work. And it's the closest thing we get to a Bizarro fight outside of a later film again.

But yeah, just three. There's parts of it I do like, but I've only seen it once. That was it. He takes the cake from me. Like I said, I know I watched it the first time I watched it, and then I think I watched it one more time, but then the last time I watched it is when we did our commentary, which was a few years ago. So I know I've seen it at least twice, but I think three times. James, your number 15. My number 15 here is Red Sun. You know, the book is...

Superior to the film. But the film is pretty decent. I've watched it a couple of times. But it's definitely just your Elseworlds tale. They kind of yada yada through the third act. Oh yeah. Makes sense. Even though James is a huge fan of Svetlana. Svetlana.

First time I ever heard that name, I had a lady come in to pay her cable bill, and she was talking, it was a daughter talking for her mom, and her mom was Svetlana. Oh, that's pretty sweet. Someone in my old job was actually named Svetlana when I was in Illinois. That's sweet. We call her Svetlana. I can see that. It makes sense. Cool. My number 15 is Reign of the Superman. Really? I enjoy the movie, and there's parts I really like in it, but there's just something about, like, and I think part of it could be...

The past few times I've watched it, I've watched it as the complete story, because I have that on digital as well as on Blu-ray. And I just feel like the pacing and the writing, because it's a different writer for Reign of the Superman than it was for Death of Superman. And I just feel like there's something in the writing beats and stuff, but it's still good, but it's just not one I go to. Even though I really love Superboy the way they did him in that movie, I wish we would have got more of him in the animated universe. Agreed. Alright, number 14.

Levi? My turn to beat a dead horse, Superman 3. With that one, I remember seeing it as a kid on PBS or something like that, one of the free over-the-air networks. And the only thing I remember about it, it was the scene with Richard Pryor using the computer to redirect the missile or whatever it was. He had Superman chasing around and the facial expression she was making and being like, this is not a Superman movie. And this was before I was a big Superman fan.

You could feel it. Yeah, that was my impression of it. I don't think I've watched it since. If I have, it wasn't on purpose and it wasn't memorable. All right, Brad. It's a bird. It's a plane. It's Superman. This is like one of the two films on this list I have not seen. All I remember seeing is a clip I think you shared a few episodes back as a part of, as well as that brief, brief section of the documentary they did on the...

in 2006 when superman returns came out that huge like retrospective of superman from like a documentary documentary was it it's a great documentary oh yeah and i love it that they uploaded on youtube um the only thing i can remember is just that bit and then a whole song where it's like sweet dreams something something planned it's like i'm super man that's that's all i know but um it's probably better than three that's that's all i can really say all right james Number 14 is Superman 3. I got nostalgia for it. I'll watch it. I've seen it more than Superman 4. Big fan of Richard Pryor growing up. My number 14 is Last Son of Krypton from the animated series. I enjoy it. I kind of wish they had done a little bit more Smallville in there. Maybe a little less Krypton at the beginning. I had that VHS I got as a kid.

All right, number 13, Levi. This one's Superman 4 for me. I know I've seen it. I don't remember anything about it other than when I see the clips on social media or something, but it's definitely a movie that came out. He's like, it's a movie? Has it been getting a middle and an end? Three-act structure?

All right, Brad. All right, funny how you mentioned it. 13th place for me is also Superman 4 The Quest for Peace. I've only seen the movie once, much like Superman 3. And I did like it, though I will admit, it's a very flawed film. But there are some good ideas in there. Plus, I actually like The New Clear Man. I think it's cool. And Tom McFarlane, before you lose the license to the DC, make that into a figure. I mean, yeah. But yeah, also like the one thing I remember the most from that film, y'all are probably one thing of two, is that one shot of Superman flying being used over and over and over again. Yes.

And then come this year, we get a rematch of this at the box office. Only says Superman fighting Nuclear Man. It's the Sentry. My friend Jesse, before I saw Superman 4, he said, like, yeah, Nuclear Man's a lot like Sentry. I'm like, no, he's not. No, he's not. I'm a big fan of Sentry, too. And then when I finally watched him, I'm like, okay, Jesse, you're right. I had yet to put that together, but you're right. In fact, I'm going to be a really cool fan of that, too. That makes sense. All right, James. Number 13. Number 13 is Last Son of Krypton. All right. So.

it's just funny changes like just taking like we're just like worn off right pretty close my number 13 is all-star superman i think the film is really good but there's things in it that are same thing with like things in the books i'm not a huge fan of it's just not one i go back to you that often so i'd like if i it's like if i was gonna throw in a superman film it's just not one i would reach for um that's right there kind of in the middle there is some good to it and we're gonna re-watch it here soon because i have one to revisit it so All right, lucky number 12, Levi. This is All-Star Superman for me. If I'm reaching for, if I want All-Star Superman, I'm just going to read the graphic novel because it works better as a graphic novel than it does as a movie with how episodic the original story. And that's part of the, yeah, that's part of the issue is it is episodic. I am glad, though, the film cut out the Pizarro stuff because that would draw me crazy. We all know how much I love and not love Pizarro. All right, Levi says, All-Star Superman for number 12. Brad, what do you got? For my 12th pick, it is Scrant and the Mole Man.

I've only seen it once, and the best way I could describe it is Superman in a sci-fi B-movie. It's got a good message, like you said before, about how not to judge others based upon their appearances and whatnot, as that is very true to Superman. In fact, one of my favorite Golden Age images is that one poster where Superman's like, hey, no matter what race, religion, gender, etc., etc., etc., you are, we're all American. We should all be good to each other. Man, that's something we should, you know, bring back. But one thing, though, I find funny about the movie, besides that one scene where, like, one of the B-molemen falls down, it's just like this really horrible looking puppet that George catches.

Um, the moment kind of like Gargamel from Smurfs. He was a mutant. It's true. Someone brought that up to me once. I'm like, there's no way. And I watch it like, Oh my God, you were right. Yeah. Like this totally is Gargamel. Maybe that's where he came from. Are these your people Gargamel? Can't catch us. Can't catch us the Smurfs. They get some radiation. All right, James 12. Uh, 12 is all star Superman. 12 is all star. What's that? Anything to add? Um,

I mean, it's, you know, the, what they boiled it down to, to make the movie with, they took, you know, most of the most important chapters to create the film as it were. And I mean, it's done really well. It's, it's so, it's pretty good. I feel like it's missing stuff because the book was so good with so many different beats throughout that got skipped over, but you know, it's, it's been. I'm trying to think when you and I did that episode where we did our all-star Superman episode was basically we did the book and the movie and then we talked about each and everything. It's been at least five years, maybe six since we did that. It's crazy. I think we've been doing this that long. All right. My number 12 is Superman 4. I've talked about this many times, but I swear this movie was always on WGN at my grandparents' house. I saw it so much more than I saw Superman.

one or two because I feel like they weren't on TV as much but I feel like this movie just must have been like cheap as heck to broadcast so it's always on and I just thought Superman Fighting Nuclear Man you know it was awesome as a kid it wasn't so much later I learned that it was cheap but I have just a there's good stuff I like in Superman 4 like I like him back on the farm we see him as Clark and you know him being sick and the crystal and stuff like that I think is neat Lex is back with you know future Lex Luthor Lenny Luthor So there's a lot I like in Superman 4, but I have a lot of nostalgia love for it too. Speaking of which, what do you think the comic book adaptation is for Superman 4, Tyler? I've never read it. I want to because I need to find it. It's not that hard. I found like, you know, half-priced book years ago for like two bucks, I think. The ending's different. It makes more sense. There's no whatever the other love interest was flying into space and how somehow she survived in space. But I will say one thing I forgot to mention. It's funny how they made nuclear now canon to the DCU.

Yeah. It's like a cave, though, right? Yeah. Superman flies out into the Phantom Zone during the Bendis run, and the nuclear man's there, and he just punches him. And that's pretty much it. It's when he was enraged by... It was part of that whole story, I think. Because it was right after John came back. Yeah, when he got eached up. Yeah, and Superman was pissed. And I think it was also when the world was being pushed into the Phantom Zone, and they didn't realize. It's back in that Bendis run. Yeah. But yeah, he's just like in a page. And I was like, you could have done more with him, because he's not a horrible character. Oh, yeah, definitely.

All right. We're about to hit the top 10 here soon, but first we get to number 11, Levi. I went with Superman versus the elite. That's why I want to revisit it. Cause I remember liking it, but I also remember in a lot of ways, it doesn't feel like a Superman story. It almost, I know it's one issue in the comics and it almost feels like a, not quite an alternate world take on them, but like, Hey, this is definitely like a standalone do it something. Superman story.

I'm not ready to talk about this movie yet. Oh, wait. Brad. All right, number 11. The one I just watched before we started doing this episode, Superman Brainiac Attacks. First time I've ever seen it. I liked it. There's some stuff that's fun about it, but it doesn't have the same quality as the later DC animated films that come out. Oh, the other original ones, as well as the ones in the shared universe and whatnot. But it's nice to see some of the voice actors return. I like Lance Henderson as a Brainiac. I thought he was cool. No idea why they didn't get Clancy Brown to do Lex Luthor. No, it's weird. What really got him was weird. It was Powers Booth.

I don't remember him. The voice I do, I just can't think of his face. But, um, it's fun and entertaining for what it is. But, like, there's something missing to it. Like, I don't want to say, like, the soul of, like, the Superman anime series. No, I get what you're saying. Like, I completely understand. It's like, you can't quite put your finger on it. Exactly. But it did make me want to re-watch the Superman anime series. But, um, yeah, other than that, it's an entertaining film for what it is. But it's lacking the soul, or maybe it's just lacking that Bruce Timm quality because he wasn't on it.

Could be. And the animation style looks a little bit... While adapting the Bruce Timm art style, the budget for the animation doesn't feel like it's a part of that. I gotcha. Alright, James. Number 11, right? Yep. I went with Superman Man of Tomorrow. Hey, me too! Me too! Superman Man of Tomorrow is pretty good. It's one of the better Tomorrowverse films out of the lot.

The biggest thing that's a little weird for me is the kaiju parasite in the end of the movie. Otherwise, I think it's okay. We get the introduction to Lex Luthor, Martian Manhunter, Lobo, and a version of Parasite. And kind of an origin story of that Superman. There's a lot I like in this. I like that he's an intern. I like the villain choice of being Parasite in this.

i like how it ends you know the third act but i don't like the kaiju parasite even like the way they did martian manhunter uh lobo and superman i've heard you know the writer talk about this each representing like a different part of the psyche the id um super ego and ego and then each represent that they're the last survivor of their alien race um but there's just something on about it that i can't quite put my finger on that doesn't make me love it it's almost like it's a little stiff and sterile, but I like the voice cast. There's a lot I like in it, but it's just something there that just doesn't tip it over for me. I'm saving my thoughts. All right, Levi, we're in the top 10, fellas. Levi, number 10. Top 10, I've got Superman Unbound here. This one, I have a lot of fun with it. It's one of the first DC animated ones I watched because it was right around the time I was getting heavily into Superman. Is it the best Superman movie? Absolutely not, but it does a pretty good job with Brainiac. It's got Supergirl, and I enjoy it. I'm not ready to talk about this one just yet. All right, Brad, number 10.

All right, my 10th place pick is the Lois and Clark pilot. I barely remember anything from this pilot because it's been like years since I watched it off the DVD set. All I remember was liking Dean Cain. I remember the joke his mom made about like, oh, well, that's why you call him tights. I remember there being a murderer. I think it was like some kind of comedian who played the guy who got murdered. And I remember Terry Hatcher doing like a Chun-Lady spinning kick. But I remember it being entertaining and it being like my first introduction to Lois and Clark, the new Avengers Superman and becoming a fan of it from the same time. All right, James, number 10.

uh lois and clark yeah this is hilarious continue james um just a lot of nostalgia for for that uh i i've seen it the pilot plenty of times um you know i owned just the first season for a long time so when i would when i'd watch it start right there at the beginning you know um so yeah it's just it's i grew up watching lois and clark i always enjoyed it you know Real life and all that aside. I watched that long before all that ever happened. Here's hoping we get a Blu-ray set. Have you guys watched Lois and Clark on HBO Max? I watched it a few weeks ago. I texted you this too, Tyler. I was like, wow, this video quality is really crisp. Was this like this on the DVDs? No, it's not. My number 10 is Superman Unbound.

And that's what I thought was funny is me and Levi got this one the same and James and Brad got theirs the same. Same things that Levi said. I like this. I like the Brainiac attack story. I have a pitch that I think the sequel to James Gunn's Superman should be based off this story and it should be a Superman Supergirl film. Like with them two crossing over, you know, with having Supergirl next year, I think it would be great that the second film be Brainiac and be based off this story. And we could finally have Brainiac in the movies. Exactly. I don't particularly like the way they drew Superman's face. Like his chin looks a little elongated. I just recorded an episode of Michael Bailey talking about this. That'll be out sometime in June.

But for the most part, I really like this movie. I really like John Noble's voice for Brainiac. Oh, yeah. I really like Matt Bomer as Superman, too. If this is the only time we ever get him as Superman, because he would have made a really good Superman in live action, too. We got those Japanese commercials, man. But he does a great job with the voice of it. And if this is all we ever get is him as Superman, then I'm okay with that. All right. We're now at the single digits, fellas, number nine. Levi. I got the theatrical cut of Superman 2 here.

I prefer the Donner cut. It's as simple as that. Superman 2, the theatrical cut, is a perfectly fine movie other than the memory-wiping kiss, but Donner cut's superior in my opinion. I'm going to wait to comment on this. Brad? Alright, my ninth pick is Superman Returns. I haven't watched this movie in over 20 years. Oof, feeling old just by saying that. But from what I remember, I liked it. I watched it numerous times and stuff. But the problems I feel like I'd have now with it pre-visiting is one, the lack of action sequences, even though as much as I love Superman the movie.

with a modern-day superhero film, you need a good action sequence. You need a good fight between, like, a superhero or something like that. But the other problem is the length. Because, like, didn't it clock in, like, two and a half, nearly three hours or something like that? And there's, like, a lot of boring parts that I remember. But, I will say this, I absolutely love the imagery when they recreated the, um, they made a homage to the cover of Action Comics number one. Two hours and 34. Just checking for you. Was it? Two hours and 34. Yeah, that's long. Hmm.

I'd watch it, just out of curiosity. But Brendan Routh, I thought, was a good Superman, though I don't remember much about him. However, looking back at some of the photos and everything, he doesn't look that bulked up. He's kind of a little bit wimpy. He's a very slender Superman. They had him doing a lot of swimming. Yeah, he had smooth, lean muscle. Even though in Crisis, he'd bulk up. He looked a lot better as a Superman there. But I also do feel bad for Brendan because, much like someone else later on this list...

He got screwed over, man. He got really screwed over. And I really wish those rumors about there being a Superman Max show featuring Brandon Routh's Kingdom Come Superman would have been true, but we're at now. But make him McFarlane. Oh, I totally want to make Farland. Brandon Routh. Nice. As of this recording, today we dropped our episode that's all about the Brandon Routh Superman that James and I just recently recorded. Okay. My number nine. Superman 2 The Theatrical Cut.

Skip me. Oh, my bad, James. I was excited. My bad. I got excited, okay? You're good. No, go ahead. What's your number nine? It's Superman 2, the theatrical cut. I know the generally scared to step outside line is not in the Donner cut, but there's more that I like in the Donner cut. The thing with the Donner cut we'll talk about more later.

yeah i just we just recently rewatched this and there's parts in it i like and there's some parts i'm like no and a lot of it's like the editing order with superman and lois the fact that i don't like the storyline okay i'll be honest with you boys i do not like the superman and lois with margo and chris because margo likes superman she never really likes clark doesn't treat clark right right and then he gives up his powers i'm like bro she loves you for the guy you are with your powers not for who you are as a person she don't even know you as a person So, yeah, all right, I'm done ranting. Superman 2 Theatrical, my number nine. Now, James, you go, buddy. My number nine is Superman vs. Steely. So, I mean, I really, you know, it's the first movie we talked on this podcast. First time I joined you here. And it's a really good story. It's a really interesting adaptation of, like you said, one issue of a comic. But George Newbern does a really great job.

Yeah, George Newbern is my favorite voice for Superman because he's done different things, but he's delivered some of my best favorite Superman lines. Roll the cardboard, man. All right, we're down to number eight, starting with Levi. All right, here's the one that'll probably get me canceled as a Superman fan. This is where I have Superman the movie and just the theatrical cut. Wow. Is it iconic? Yes. Do I enjoy it a lot? Yes. But I didn't really watch a lot of Superman movies until I was in my teens and 20s, so I don't have quite the nostalgia.

for Chris's Superman than a lot of other people do. No, I agree. And we'll talk about when we get there. As Tyler's writing down the hashtag cancel. No, I get it. And I'll expand on things more when I get around to my part when I talk about it. Brad, number eight. Before I go to number eight, one quick question for you, Tyler. With your Returns episode you just did, did you ever talk about why you don't consider a sequel to Superman 1-2? Yes. I have a whole theory in there.

Breakdown, and I'll send you my notes. Yes, I'm looking forward to reading that. After you listen to it, I'll send you my notes of how part of the episode is me proving that Brandon Routh is his own Superman. All right. For my eighth pick, even though it was an honorable mention, and I just watched it last night, Superman Chazam. It's a short. Can't do much of it. But it's great. Oh, yeah. It's only like 22 minutes long, but it was a lot of fun. Seeing Superman finally fight Black Adam in animation, to which, to my knowledge, never happened to that point. That's cool. Black Adam was cool. Seeing everyone return from Justice League Unlimited, you know, George Newbern, whoever voiced.

I prefer to call him Captain Marvel, but most people are like, now it's Suzanne. It's now the captain. The real Captain Marvel, I should say. I thought his voice actor was really good. It was just a fun, entertaining film. It's just short. The graphic novel is pretty great, too. What is it based on? Oh, I know what you're talking about. Anytime we can see Superman chew out the wizard. Yeah, I wish they added that. Or adapted that into an animated movie. The speech that Clark gives about being good to Billy and stuff.

I've actually used that with Solomon before and everything just talking about sometimes it's really hard just to be good. All right, James, James, James. Don't want to skip James. Number eight. Number eight is Superman 2. Which one? Which one?

The theatrical. I already said I didn't see the Donner movie. I know. I mean, because I've seen it, obviously. I hope you've seen it in the top ten. Yeah, it's in the top ten. I hope I've seen it. Yeah, it's Superman 2. It's the one...

one of the most iconic movies for Superman, Christopher Reeve, just some, yeah, just some weird stuff, you know, that we've discussed over and over and over again about those movies. Yeah, that's it. I mean, I'm not going to keep doing that. It's just, I mean, I love the movie, but that's where, that's where it lands. All right. My turn. My number eight is Superman two, the Richard Donner cut. I do enjoy this movie. I like this edit. It is one that when you watch it, understand that it starts with the ending of Superman, the movie.

before superman 2 the richard johnny cut actually starts so it's it starts weird because it's trying to show you where he would have ended superman the movie right and then like yes uh they have to use a screen test in it and you know there's some stuff that i wish he would have got to actually film and some people say it doesn't feel like a full movie i don't feel that way um but i do like it better than the theatrical cut because i feel like the theatrical does have some hokey stuff in there so That's my number eight. Number seven, Levi. This is where I have the Donner Cut. It's, you know, like I said, it's my preferred cut of Superman 2. I remember I was working in a video entertainment type store when they finally released the Donner Cut, and I think I bought the only copy that came in before we even put it on the shelves. Just purely based off the fact, like we were talking before we started recording, I, unlike James, I absolutely love director's cuts. I saw director's cut of Superman 2 and snagged that real fast.

Everything you just said, the screen test makes it feel a bit out of place. But I think if you know the history of the Donner cut and you understand that, yes, there's a screen test in this. Yes, some of this stuff is reused from the first movie. And he didn't get to film everything that he wanted to film. If you can get over those few things, I think it's the superior cut. Yeah, I agree. I agree. All right, Brad, you're number seven. All right, before we get to seven, I forgot to mention Superman Shazam. If James Gunn ever does Shazam again, probably not with Secretary Levi because...

Stuff he said recently. I would love to see him adapt Superman Shazam vs. Thunder. That'd be so great. And then you get to see that scene like I mentioned before about Superman Essential 2 and now The Wizard. But yes, number seven. That is Superman Red Sun. The other movie I watched yesterday. First time I've ever seen a movie. Superman Red Sun is one of my all-time favorite Superman stories. I finished rereading it like sometime last year or year before.

Now, the movie, I do have some art with it, mainly because of the Liberty's takes. Like, for one, what happened with Stalin, how Wonder Woman was kind of handled, and then, like, the ending not really being, like, how the book ends and stuff. Plus, I kind of miss, like, you know, the whole Brainiac, Epiphanianicum, Lex Luthor releasing, like, all of his, like, scrimmage detergents, like, Parasite, A Virgin of Doomsday, The Talos, etc., etc. But with those irks aside, I had a lot of fun with it. Whoever was voicing Superman, I thought he did a good job. I like the way the art style is and animation is. Lex Luthor's voice kind of took some getting used to it because I kept on thinking of the Brave and the Bold Batman. But outside of those minor irks and the liberties it took, the only other problem is this is like a story that should have been adapted in a longer movie because he had to cut out a bit too much, in my opinion, or like you needed to flesh out a few more things. But I did like the body horror with Superman.

I kind of wish he had the weird deformed look in the comics, but still, for a first viewing of Superman Red Son, I enjoyed it. Okay. James. The never we forget. James. You know, make sure you try not to forget me now, huh? You're coming for me. Number seven is... I do know where you are. Number seven is Superman Shazam.

You know, that is a great short. It is a really awesome short. The dynamic, George Newbern playing Superman, the speech he gets to give to Shazam, to Billy, and I actually really like the art in that short and the coloring of the suit. I think it looks really good. I think the animation style in that is just great. It's just a shame we never got to see all three clash with each other in live action. Darn you, Dwayne the Rock Johnson!

I've talked about that before about what should have been Shazam 2. I'll let that be. My number 7 is the Lois and Clark TV pilot. Like I said before, it was filmed on film. It's longer. It's kind of nostalgic too for being a kid. I don't know if they ever released it on VHS alone back in the day that they would do some things. I tried to find it, but it has a different feel to it. I like the story. If they had never made the series, you still would have felt like you got a story out of it.

And I liked it. It's got the great line about Lex Luthor looking up. It's the first time we get a post-crisis Lex Luthor. Yeah. I think John Shay is often forgot as Lex because when he returns in season two, it's kind of awkward and stuff, but he did a great job. Huh? Thanks for not spoiling because I'm actually on season two right now. So I feel like Terry Hatcher was a great Lois Lane and just, it works. And Lois and Clark, best Perry White ever. Best Perry White. I mean, he does have a great Perry White. So that is my number seven. All right.

Number six, Levi. I've got Reign of the Superman here. I really enjoy this one. I think it works a lot better when you pair it directly with Death of Superman. But I really enjoy, like you said earlier, the stuff of Superboy is fantastic. And I like Lois being the driving force of this story. She's really the one pushing the plot forward at a lot of points. And I'm a sucker for Superman in a black suit. Yeah, I agree with everything you just said.

All right, Brad. All right, for my sixth place, it's the beginning of a new dawn, of a new universe even, Superman, Man of Tomorrow. I've seen the film only once. I think it was just when it came out on Blu-ray during the pandemic and everything. And I just got done reading Superman, was it American Alien, right? Superman, American Alien? Yeah. And then I watched the movie and I could definitely see a lot of the inspirations from that book, especially with like when Superman had the whole aviator outfit. Which I like that look too. Yeah, so do I.

But yeah, I thought the film was a lot of fun. I was happy to see Parasite in there because Parasite is one of my full-time favorite Superman villains. While you guys might be complaining about it, I didn't mind him being a giant kaiju at all. I thought that was cool. I thought the guy who played Lex Luthor was awesome. Zach... Quinto. Yeah, Spock from the new Star Trek movies. The animation art style was interesting. It was different, but it had a certain flaring style to it. Also, I've seen Lobo. Whoever played Lobo was great. Right, right. It crushes it. Yeah, I would argue he beats the guy from the Superman anime series.

But I liked him. I liked the fact that he actually had a kryptonite ring before Lex, too, mind you. And, yeah, I just... Also, I love the fact that the red trunks came back. I love the fact that the red trunks came back. Because if anyone knows anything about me, I love the fact that Superman has red trunks. Super duper happy he's having it. No pun intended. But, yeah. Also, I thought it was a great start to this new universe, even if some of the films were varying in quality. That Green Lantern movie. It held dirty. Excuse me. Something in my throat or something. But, yeah. Superman Man Tomorrow, sixth place. All right.

James. So here, like we're, we're getting into the top five and I kind of see that notice that none of us have talked about the new movie coming in yet either. Yeah. It's hard to really, you know, like give it a place in the top five. So, I mean, I'm going to have to just drop it here at number six. I feel like from what I've seen that it's probably going to crack into that top five, you know, maybe even top three, because it's got some really cool, interesting bits that we have never seen on screen for Superman outside of animation.

so um i have a feeling it will get higher once we get there but i mean i gotta i gotta drop superman 2025 right now just because all we've seen is a sneak peek in a teaser trailer yeah all right my number six is superman versus the elite I really like this movie. I love George Newburn's delivery. I like the plot. I like the concept. It is my favorite out of the animated films. My negative towards it is I don't like the animation style for Superman himself. Yeah, his head's weird. If they would have done, say, the way he looks in Unbound...

You know what would be better? I feel like this is a serious story and I feel like it needed more of a serious looking Superman. He's got a big like American dad looking chin. Good morning, USA. Exactly. And he's hulkingly big as Clark and everything. I feel like that just looks weird. Like the cover art is completely nothing like the animation. Right. And I really hate when they did that. That's my biggest negative to it. So, all right, here we go. You're right. Everybody getting ready for the top five.

Top five. Checking my list twice here. So, all right. Are we cool? I hope I'm cool. Are we cool? Okay, number five. Levi. All right, so James brought up a great point, and he just made me slide it back a few spots on my list. Dropping Superman 2025. I think it will be top five. I did have it before James started talking at three, because...

everything we're seeing from it looks pretty incredible so far, but he is right. It should not be that high on the list as of yet. Although the rumor is the next trailer drops on May 18th. So, I mean, we know we have to get it this month because they're not going to drop the trailer in June because I figured it'll be something like the trailer will drop and the tickets on sale. It's weird how 10 years ago this marketing campaign feels, so far. What were you talking about, Tyler? Them dropping a trailer that late? Could you imagine if they did that with Jonah Hex or something? They released that trailer a month or two before the movie comes out? Could you imagine? I don't even know what that movie is you're talking about. But, yeah. Continue, Levi. Just the marketing for this looks good, but it feels very like a...

early MCU to me where it was like teaser trailer and then months without anything. And then a final trailer a couple months before the movie comes out. And that's it. I mean, I just want to, I think they want to focus the marketing, like bombard it the last month. You know what I mean? Not, not do this extended. They've already, we've already known about this movie for like a year and a half. You know, they don't want to do the crap that they pulled for the last 10 years of talking about a movie movie and try, just trying to say something to keep it in the consciousness.

For months and months and months on end. I think they're just like, let's keep it going, keep hinting at it. But when it's that last, like, 60 to 45 days before that movie comes out, you're going to see it all over the place. I mean, we all complained about how they oversaturated the marketing for BVS. I mean, we were hyped for that movie in 2013, you know, when they announced it. And they trailer after trailer giving stuff away. Who made those trailers? Sony? And then, I mean, more recently, look at the marketing of the Flash. I mean...

Gosh, if they would have not given out free tickets for that movie, how much money could they have made? What was the point of that marketing? Alright, Brad. Number five. Number five. This is where the beginning of my list is nothing but ties. So, for fifth place, I have a tie between Superman Unbound and Superman Doomsday. A Superman Unbound I was really interested in because of Brainiac. Plus, I like the storyline from Jeff Johns and Gary Frank. Superman Brainiac.

And Brainiac's one of my all-time favorite Superman films in everything. And the film was a lot of fun. But one of the things that really, really, really sold it for me was the guy who played Brainiac. He had such a great voice. I'm pretty sure he did some kind of filter to his voice, too. But, like, it sounds so great. And there's this one line I think of every time now when I think of Brainiac. When he says, I've got the knowledge of a thousand, thousand worlds. I was like, man, it's so cool. Still disappointed we haven't gotten live action in a movie yet.

And no, Superman 3, you don't count. Go away. I know. We got it on TV, though, but not in the movie. But no, Superman Doomsday. Superman Doomsday, I got on DVD sometime in 2008. Was that number 5 or number 4 for Superman Doomsday? Oh, it's a tie. It's a tie. Got it on DVD sometime in 2008. I watched it through certain needs. I'm not going to say it. Maybe it was on YouTube at one point. I'm not going to say it. But when I got my portable DVD player, too, I watched the movie in numerous, numerous times. And also, Superman Doomsday is inspired, not based.

They stay in the trailer. And on the back of the DVD case here, it's inspired by one of my all-time favorite Superman stories lines. That was Superman. And, you know, the return of Superman, the world without Superman. And, yes, you know, being an inspiration, you know, cut out a lot of stuff, you make stuff too fast and everything, like, not really properly developed and everything, but I still managed to enjoy it. I thought the fights with Doomsday was good. I actually liked the idea that you'd do, like, an amalgamation of various Superman for the clone. Everything from, like, Superboy to Hank Henshaw to Eradicator to even, you could say, to an extent, Steel, because, remember, he had the soul of Superman.

Plus, you know, I love the fact that it's in the art style of Superman the anime series. And teenage Brad, who is trying to convince himself so hard, he was in canon with DCAU, but in reality, it doesn't sync up. Yeah, Superman Doomsday, great movie, except they kill the dog. John Wick would not be happy. My fifth pick. Alright, James, your fifth pick. My number five is Superman Returns. So, I mean...

We were just talking about Brandon Routh recently. The episode just dropped as of recording this. He did a great job as Clark and as Superman. The movie is gorgeous. I have a lot of nostalgia for it because it was my first big screen Superman. We talked all about that in our episode. We're all too young, I believe, to see any other Superman on the big screen before Brandon Routh hit it. James, you and I are the oldest two here. I thought that might be the case.

all right my number five and my number four and five i think can flip back and forth depending on how i feel um like i can kind of argue with them and they kind of they these two films have a symbiotic bond and uh we'll talk about more that next month when levi joins us but my number five is also superman returns uh i do really enjoy it there's a lot i like in it i'm not gonna keep plugging my episode but i explained a lot of it in that episode i did see it like five times in theaters and it was my first superman on the screen i really enjoyed it but there are things in it that i don't like there are choices made in it i don't like um and i wish it did have some more action and more superman things but i it's it's one i haven't watched in a while and i've been kind of itching to so i'm looking forward to when we do it here soon yeah i mean it's got some great talent and they did a good job with it i've always liked the cinematography for it too so yeah oh i love how we all wave in sync um all right number four

Levi. I am over here adjusting my list as we talk because I think this top four for me, or at least the next three, are pretty interchangeable, but I'm going to lock it in at Man of Tomorrow right here. I think it's a damn good origin story for Superman. It doesn't focus too much on... the bits we every superman every casual person acquainted with superman knows like you don't spend a lot of time on krypton dealing with all that i think uh it also is a really good amalgamation of a lot of superman stuff kind of like superman and lois's i think they borrow from the the wider superman universe to take the bits of things they like the superman martian manhunter relationship reminds me of what is that season eight nine ten of smallville with the relationship clark and martian manhunter having that i think I think he rescues or finds him and gives them his powers back in season eight. But that sort of gateway relationship is nice. And Ryan Hurst as Lobo is... If Jason Momoa wasn't playing Lobo in the Supergirl movie, it should be Ryan Hurst. I agree. I think it's kind of 1A, 1B right there. I think either of them would absolutely kill the role.

And I know James said he thought the animation in it was a bit flat, but I actually felt the same when it first came out, and then the more I've rewatched Man of Tomorrow, the more I really appreciate the animation in it. And I'm a fan of Kaiju Parasite, so. Yeah! I really hated how they didn't give me feet. like the bigger he gets he doesn't have feet he just has like oh it's actually one thing we forgot to talk about with uh tomorrow too he doesn't defeat parasite through action he threw just just through talking trying to calm down everything that's that's actually my friend richard one of his favorite superman moments too i love that and i like that you know it's a smaller scale like i get you know i get tired of like the third act superman movies like big alien invasion type thing huge in a lot of stories but i like how this is a little bit smaller and um That's one thing. I recently reread Superman Secret Origin, and at the end, I like that it's a smaller... It's him versus Metallica on the streets. And I think sometimes that can really work with a first Superman movie. I did a whole pitch on my YouTube of if I did a Superman trilogy.

how i would do it and pulling from this kind of my first film with that smaller scale so yeah like in the animation it's not that it was flat i like the tomorrow verse animation um i just preferred the animation from the previous universe oh yeah that we had before so that was a step down but otherwise i mean like i said man of tomorrow was still one of the better movies in the tomorrow verse yes it was also some of these i judged by uh how much my wife liked them and this was one she she enjoyed quite a bit when we watched it the first time. And that could be because it came out during the pandemic and, you know, new movies weren't really a thing, but we watched it and she's like, that was actually a really good movie. And Darren Criss did a great job voicing Superman. It did. All right.

James. My number four. Oh, I guess I got skipped this time. No, Brad, I thought you gave yours. No, he gave a two-part part five. That's right, you gave a two-part part five. All right, Brad, you're number four. All right, number four, the rare three-way tie. That's going to be, yeah, I know that. It's going to be a lot of ties, remember that. It's going to be All-Star Superman, Last Son of Krypton, and Superman versus three weeks. All-Star Superman, Tyler knows this, one of my greatest Superman sins is, I haven't finished reading All-Star Superman.

I started reading it back in two years ago, 23, but I never finished it. But from what I was reading, I was loving it. I love how crazy, like, it's like, it is embracing the crazy and the silliness of the silver age, but doing it well for the modern age. In fact, I know I have to trade when James Gunn announced that they're going to use All-Star Superman as inspiration for the new Superman movie. I just managed to stumble across at my then local comic book shop in Illinois. They had all 12 issues of All-Star Superman. Oh, wow. For 50 bucks, yeah. And because I had a full list discount, I got for 45.

But I imagine when I eventually watch All-Star Superman after reading the comic book, I'll enjoy it immensely. But Last Song of Skrypton, I never watched it as it was edited into a film. I just watched it as single episodes. I remember enjoying it a lot as a kid. It's been a while since I've watched it, but I remember liking it. But Superman vs. The Elite. This, I'm pretty sure, was the first Blu-ray I ever bought. And because of that, it also comes with, as you guys can see,

A digital copy and ultraviolet copy, too, as well. And I watched it so many times. Like, ironically enough, I haven't read the actual comic book that often. I may have read it once. But the movie itself, I really enjoyed it. I liked a lot of the dialogue. George Newbern, returning as Superman. Great. And I just love that ending of it, too, where, like, we see Superman being, like, scary and brutal and everything. And everyone's scared and terrified, especially the villains. But after that, he reveals, like, hey, it's all a show.

Just to show you, like, hey, I'm not that bad. Or how sicker I could be. But I have my morals and uproarings to prove to you that I'm a better person than that. The only bad thing I can say about the film, other than, like, dark style being a little wonky, like me and Tyler said, his head, Superman's head, looks weird. The only bad thing I can say is they killed a dog. But, yeah, four things. Those three. All right. All right. All right. So, my number four is Superman the movie. Superman 1978. And my preferred...

version that I've watched the most is the extended director's cut. The three-hour cut, I've only ever seen it probably on television. I don't have the three-hour cut currently. I've seen the theatrical cut, but since I've owned them on DVD and then Blu-ray, I've watched the extended director's cut. Alright, makes sense. So my number four, and like I said, my five, four, and three could probably just...

play around with each other. But my number four is actually Man of Steel. I really like Man of Steel a lot. I do feel that it gets a little inflated. You know, the scene where he fights the thing by himself, I like. But it also just makes it feel like it elongates a lot of that third act, or second act, technically, I think. Because I don't think I'd count the third act of starting until, like, when he fights Zod. I had no idea it's not the thing from Fantastic Four. I really like the movie a lot, but there's just, like, that. But there's...

the structure for it. I wish we didn't always have to start on Krypton. It has the best Krypton. Oh, it does. And Krypton the TV series. I was going to say, except for maybe the Krypton TV series. They blended. Yeah, I know. They did a lot of good stuff on that show. But like I said, 4, 5, and 3 can kind of flip around, but it just depends on my mood and where I'm at. But I do really enjoy the mood. I mean, there's a lot, too, and we'll talk about more of that next month. All right. Back to Levi.

We're at number three, right? All right. I've locked it in finally. We're going to put Superman Returns right here. A lot of the same reasons for Superman on the big screen. I am one of those people who went through a phase of liking this movie when it first came out and then hating it for a lot of years. And then I'm back to really loving it again. And I think a lot of it is strictly just Brandon Routh and appreciating.

It doesn't feel like he was given a lot to do in the movie in terms of acting and acting range, but what he is given to do, I think he does a really good job with. And I think it has some of the best Superman iconography that we get in live action. It does have some beautiful shots in it. All right, Brad, you're like quadruple tie for number three. What is it? Well, for a third place, you could argue it's a tie or it's been edited to one movie, The Death and Return of Superman. I had to grab this off the shelf just a few seconds ago.

The Death of Superman, as I previously mentioned, is one of my all-time favorite Superman stories. In fact, it's actually one of the stories that got me into reading Superman. Though, ironically enough, I didn't read it until years later. No, like a few months later, because Mr. Teenage Brad was like, hey, there's this big omnipost that says Superman Doomsday. That must have the Death of Superman in it. It's got everything in everybody. But yeah, the Death of Superman, it features my all-time favorite villain, Doomsday. He's one of those villains that lives up to his name, Doomsday. He is doomed. He will bring an end to pretty much everything. And when it comes to animation and everything, I always want to see more Doomsday.

and when they brought it to the what's the name of this universe again like dc animated original universe whatever yeah whatever it's called the flash the plus flashpoint movie um at the time i was soured on this universe you know like i watched just a second more didn't really care for that much i watched uh superman i'm sorry batman son of batman didn't really care for it and then i watched throwing atlantis again it was just okay and then when i found out they were doing like that superman i was like oh sweet and i saw still like oh it's part of that shared universe again But then when I watched it, something changed with my attitude towards the universe. I liked it. I really enjoyed it. Not only did I like and enjoyed it, in some ways, it actually improved on the original story. I mean, yes, they cut out some things I like with, like, the one teenage son who lives in Ohio.

I missed that, and the whole speech story I mean, was having 14 years and stuff on television on the Cat Grant show. But at the same time, it has a way better lineup with Justice League. That is the one thing I was lacking from that story. It didn't have Batman, Flash, Green Lantern, fighting everyone, but this animated movie. It did, and it was glorious. Kind of which, you know, Shadam was an echo, hey? But also with Doomsday in there, like...

They made, like, a real force of nature. And, like, they really pushed that PG-13 rating, too. Because, remember, he crashed land in the ocean, and some Atlanteans were unfortunate to come across him, and he just tore him apart. Like, good God. It's, like, shocking they could do that. Also, I like the little, like, homage to slasher movies when he was in the forest. Yeah. But, absolutely loved it after Superman. Then we went to The Return of Superman, or Reign of Superman. I actually watched that for the first time when it was in theaters, because they did that one day showing where they had the two films into one movie. It was also, like, the one time I went to see a movie that had an intermission to it.

Really enjoyed the story. Again, I'm also a Return of Superman, one of my all-time favorite stories as well. And they did make some alterations that irked me a little bit. Like, I wish they had the destruction of Coast City. I wish that would have led to an Emerald Twilight movie. Or, yeah, Emerald Twilight, and then eventually a Zero Hour movie. But we can see why it didn't end up like that. So, Parallax and Darkseid teaming up would have been cool.

But I did enjoy what they did. I thought the guy who played Superboy, who I believe was Jerome in Gotham, did a phenomenal job. Like Tyler here, wish they did more with Superboy in the universe. I thought Steel was cool. I thought Eradicator was cool. Big, big, big fan of the Return of Superman suit, the black suit. Thought that was great. The only other thing I could think I did not like, though, was Cyborg Superman's design. It looked ugly. I do mean ugly in that art style. Like, I don't know what happened, but it just did not look great. But outside of that, I love the movie. It's actually my favorite animated Superman movie.

Plus, when I went to see that showing, I met a friend that day, too. Nice. I actually, I had tickets for, I won tickets for when they did that showing, too, like in Columbus, and I couldn't get to it because I couldn't get off work. I was pissed. I thought you said it was some kind of winter storm or something like that. I thought it was work. I don't know. It's been too long. Yeah. It's been five, six years. It was a busy time. But yeah, third place, The Death and Return of Superman. I'll comment on that later. All right, James, third place. My third place is Superman Unbound. I mean, you know, Matt Bomer.

Why am I blanking? You said his name earlier. John Noble. Yeah, John Noble. Did the voice of Brainiac. You know, I think they did a really good job with the story. I love that version of Brainiac. Matt Bomer did a really good job. Just a bunch of the little things. You know, when the drone hits him and he's, I actually felt that. The time with Supergirl, her part in the story, giving us the history.

It's a really great Superman animated movie, and I like watching it. Alright, alright. So it's my turn. My number three, like I said, my three, four, and five can just be kind of a shuffle, is Superman the movie, the director's cut. This cut puts back in the fact that you get to see Kirk Allen and Noel Neal on the train with the little Lois. It also puts the gauntlet in when Superman goes down to go to Lex's hideout.

I love this movie. I mean, it's mythic. It's legend. It's huge. The music. But what gets me is after Superman's first night out, I start to lose interest in it. And that's when Lex steps in. I've never been a big Gene Hackman Lex fan because he's the pre-crisis. I enjoy him. I respect it more now. But I feel like some of his stuff with Otis is hokier.

And then I like when Superman goes to stop the missiles and stuff too. But I feel like the movie kind of loses me a little bit after Superman's first night out. And like I said, I'm not a huge fan of the relationship dynamic between Superman and Lois in that movie. But it's got John Williams' music. So that definitely elevates because I love John Williams, period. Solomon and I were doing a quiz on YouTube of themes from movies and stuff. I guess that theme from a couple of notes. And it was like, John Williams, John Williams, John Williams. We had Indiana Jones, Star Wars, Jaws, Harry Potter, Superman, Malone, Jurassic Park.

the guy who wrote the music to my childhood so that holds a lot of that holds a lot of weight too um but yeah i uh i do very much enjoy it but i think depending on the mood i'm in it could fall but like i said three four and five and just kind of shuffle you know it's funny like we've got we've got Superman, the movie like up on our list here. And then we've had like Superman two, like closer to 10. And I swear to God growing up, I, it was Superman two was the better of them. You know what I mean? And I think it's just because we got Zod, we got the action, those kinds of things and stuff. And so growing up, you're like, no, Superman two is better, you know? And then we've got, and on our list here, we've got Superman, the movie up here, but we've only got different movies in between. It's not like it's, it's different Christopher Reeve movies. So it's funny how that, even though.

say superman 2 is like number eight and superman is the movie is number four you know sometimes you might just want to watch superman 2 instead i'd rather watch superman 2 instead of superman the movie and you know it even might be your preferred christopher reeve movie but which one is better which one is better ranked on our lists it's funny i mean it's true One thing I'm kind of surprised you didn't mention about, Tyler, when you were talking about Superman's first night out after that, I'm surprised you did not mention that whole conversation Superman had with Jor-El and the whole conversation about vanity and everything. Because, like, when I saw that with the three-hour cut, I was like, why did they even cut this scene? It's beautiful. I mean, it is a good scene. That's why, like, the...

There are some good stuff that Jor-El has, but then there's stuff that doesn't make sense. Like, you know, the idea of him intervening in human history and stuff like that. Yeah, that's weird. Bro, just him showing up intervenes with human history. Aliens exist now. Earth is forever altered. Okay? So, it's kind of... And plus, you know, I don't really like Marlon Brando as Jor-El. I don't like that he says Krypton. I don't like the white hair. And I hate that they have tried to make people go back to that in comics and stuff and the look of Jor-El like that, to me.

Jor-El should look a lot like Clark, not be the same person. Smallville in their flashback. And then they gave us Julian Sands as Jor-El. There's never been a Jor-El that I love. Russell Crowe's probably my favorite. I think the best. But there's never been one I'm like, that's it right there. You nailed it. No, for his two scenes. No, I did not. But he wasn't bad. I just feel like it's a character that has just... In the Superman canon, it is a character that has yet to make

definitive version. Okay. We're at our top two, boys. I got Death of Superman here. I think I have said it before. I'm a sucker for a good Doomsday story. I'm like Brad. For me, he's top three Superman. I don't even want to call him a villain. He's a force of nature. This movie does a really good job making him a force of nature. He lives up to his name. He is Doomsday. There's a few scenes in this that I think are just...

I think you only pull off an animation, him being wrapped in the cable bridge cables. Oh, I love that look. And then I just pulled it up because I wanted to get the quote right. There's the lowest of supporting Superman during the fight, physically holding him up. And you get the wild-eyed shot of Doomsday sprinting down the street and Superman turns to her and says, I've got a job to do. Or I've got to get back to work. And I think that's like just...

It's becoming a version of Superman I really like. I heard Grant Morrison talk about it in an interview recently that Superman's primary word shouldn't be hope, it should be action, that he inspires hope through his actions. And I think Death of Superman does a really good job of illustrating that. Ooh, I like that. I concur. It's a great...

showing of superman uh i think that we all love the sense that he does what needs to be done when it needs to be done even if it's at the cost of his own life and the stuff with him and lois in this movie is really quite touching and i think one of the better superman and lois clark and lois relationships we've ever seen but animated or live action i can't talk about this one yet We'll save the rest for you, Tyler. You can talk about all you want. That's fine. All right, Brad. What tie do you have for number two? All right. In second place, I got two there tied. And it's Superman 2 and Superman 2025. Is that enough two puns for you right there? That's a lot of good twos. Superman 2 was the very first live-action Superman movie I've seen. Oh, sorry. The very first Christopher Reeve movie I've seen. I remember as a child seeing the very ending of it on unless you were HBO or HBO Family.

It was like the part where Superman has Zod and friends and just throws them into the pit and dies, unless you watch a different cut of it. But then one day in 2008, my older sister went to my local library. We got a VHS copy of Superman 2. This is when I was in my infancy of my big Superman. The infancy of who I am today when it comes to Superman.

I watched the movie and I was never the same again. I absolutely love that movie. Yes, there's some weird things in it, like the weird powers and everything they never had in the comic books, the cellophane ass and everything. And then if I watch it again, I could probably have a better eagle eye with like, hey, that's not Gene Hackman. Who's that? But watching that movie, it just like had a big impact on me. Plus it gave me something I want to see in live action for the longest time, a Superman fight where he battles a number of his equals in terms of power and everything.

And yes, Todd McFarlane, you're not hearing this and we know we keep on talking about you, but hey, could you make us a figure of Zod in here? That'd be great. But then we get to... Hello. She's wearing her new Superman shirt she got, but you can't tell because she actually put it inside out. Good job, kid. But then we get to Superman 2025. Oh, nice. You guys are going to give me some crap for this one. I know Tyler will. I still haven't seen the trailer yet. I let it go. I let it go. I'm hoping this weekend I can do that reactionary video. I've been putting it out for way too long because I'm keen to putting stuff on.

But, going off by all the stills and images I've seen, from what friends have been telling me, and what really solidified this, it was that one behind-the-scenes theme they released on Superman Day, and gave me my sort of glimpse into that. It hit me differently, unlike any other film I could think of. And seeing that and everything we've been seeing lately, like recently the whole Superman robots, which appeared in All-Star Superman, and I think they appeared in the Silver Age, right? Yeah, they appeared in Superman vs. the Elite, too. In Superman and the Elite, too. Seeing all that, it's making me think James Gunn is essentially doing a blend of everything we like into Superman. Something new, but familiar. Kind of like how IDW did their Ninja Turtles comic book series. Something familiar, but different.

And obviously, Superman 2025 is my most anticipated movie of this year, superhero movie of this year, probably this decade. And the more I see it, and also, yeah, they brought back the red shrubs, and that makes me happy, because I love the red shrubs of Superman. I don't care what people say, it looks great. I don't care how silly it looks, it looks great. Plus, I like what David Korset, is it Korswet or Korswet? Korswet. Korswet.

what he said about the trunks too he said something to the effect like it's something for children to see so they're not afraid of him or something it's he taught he equated to being like a wrestler it's something that kind of makes it his costume kind of stand out and it makes it like a little funny too because it helps you not fear him yes and uh david i actually have seen a little bit on i have uh hazy memories of it but like was that one netflix show he was on hollywood land or hollywood he was on hollywood and he was on the uh politician and what was funny is jenny and i watched hollywood And it has Darren Criss in it too. So I was like, ah, two Superman in one show. I love that. But yeah, so I'm in Hollywood. And as I told Tyler before, when they were filming it last year in Cleveland, I just went to see him shoot it. I just pretty much got to see like the end of the day of it, but I got to see it. And I'm pretty sure I saw David because I saw someone walking around in a big row and they had red boots. Yeah. Lucky bread. Oh yeah. No, yeah, definitely. And then there's one other thing I was going to say about it. Okay. I'm disappointed. We're doing Lex again.

But I feel like we're going to get the battle armor. I feel like Lex is the villain you should always do because he doesn't have to be your main protagonist. He just needs to be part of the world. True, true. I actually like that idea. I like that idea. And yes, I do have my qualms to the fact this is a number reboot and poor, poor Henry Cavill got done dirty again. But I'm so excited and hyped for this movie, Beyond Belief. And I would not be surprised after I see this movie, it's in my top one spot. First, the number one spot. All right. All right. James, I bet you and Levi have the same number ones and two.

I think it sounds like it. My number two is The Death of Superman. Best animated Superman film. One of the best Superman movies. I really liked Jerry O'Connell as Superman. I think he did a great job in that universe as the voice. Getting his wife, Rebecca Romijn, to be Lois in that was really great as well. I think they did a good job.

doomsday kind of coming out almost out of nowhere seemingly in this universe like he did originally kind of just coming out of nowhere um we kind of theorized exactly what what happened and how he uh arrived on earth and everything and how he became to be in that but also the the justice league lineup getting the primary justice league going up against doomsday as opposed to what was done in the comic books with like a c-tier justice league um but getting to you know getting to have them go up and then the Wonder Woman fight between Doomsday was so good. It was really, really good. And yeah, just the extended battle between Superman and Doomsday was so good. And they did so much with Superman in that time. Not only was he in a fight for his life, but he was saving people along the way. You know, they did a really great job with the death of Superman. And it is one of the best Superman movies, period. Animated live action is one of the best. All right. My number two.

i put superman 2025 it's my prediction like i said i'll probably my ethers but i had this conversation recently it's like no superman film has really done what i wanted to do every superman film after i watch it there's always something i feel like okay something's missing um i have very high hopes with this because i feel like so far everything's looked like they've drawn straight from the comics um my only hesitancy is really is like making sure that it doesn't feel like an ensemble film, that the other heroes that are in it are less in the movie, that it is focused on Superman. I do have a film that's kind of like the best of everything kind of mixed together. I choose to be optimistic and hopeful. And as I've said before, I really like Man of Steel. I really like Superman the movie. I like Superman Returns. But there's always something I'm kind of like, ah. It left me wanting something. So I'm going to be hopeful, and this is my number two for right now. Nice plan, by the way. Be hopeful. Yep. And then after...

it comes out and we all see it. We'll just have to email and see where we would have put, now we already officially put this movie. And as I said to you before, Tyler, and through Texas and everything, if this movie does really well, like I'm saying like a billion dollars, James Gunn is directing Justice League. Without a doubt. James Gunn is going to direct all the Superman movies and stuff. I feel like he's going to end up making his, he'll be like the first director to ever maybe do like two superhero trilogies. Oh, that's right. So we have some directors that have done a trilogy.

Gunn being one of them. The guy who did the Ant-Man movies? Yeah, I'm going to make a list while you guys talk. Levi, give us your number one. I think me and James should just say this at the same time. One, two, three. Man of Steel. For me, it's my favorite Superman and my favorite Superman story with my favorite Superman villain. And the movie has a deeply personal meaning for me.

So that could be a large part of it, but I am in that group that if no one's out there defending Man of Steel anymore, then I'm dead. Don't worry, we'll just put you through a Kryptonian revival matrix and you'll come back. There we go. It's my favorite Superman movie. It's my favorite Superman actor. One of my favorite directors. There's a lot for me to love about the movie. Man of Steel, I think, is really great. It doesn't deserve as much hate as it gets. Sure, if you don't like aspects about it, but I feel like the movie definitely doesn't deserve the majority of the hate that it gets.

Exactly. It's very well made. It's got a lot of great talent in it. Henry Cavill is... Yeah, Hans Zimmer's score is fantastic. And we're 12 years later and the special effects are still... Some of the best in all of superhero movies. I still wake up to... I've had this alarm now for 12 years. What are you going to do when you're not saving the world? I wake up. Flight's my alarm. It's made a rotation. It was my alarm. It was my ringtone.

So, and, and, you know, it's, it's got a really great cast. Michael Shannon Zod is such an amazing villain, even for one who believes that he's not the villain of the story. He is absolutely a villain, but a sympathetic one, even at that. As Brad's been saying, can we get a McFarlane of Michael Shannon's Zod? He's been in two movies. You could do a variant of the armor and without the armor. I'd buy both. Yeah, I definitely would. Oh, for sure. Absolutely. It's so good.

I honestly in the, in it, the only controversial bit to me and, and, and not even in a controversial way, I just feel like it's a little bit weaker is the tornado scene, but otherwise I still, I'm okay with what happens, you know, I'm okay with that. And you know, the, the way people talk about the, the truck scene where, where, uh, um clark asks if he should just have let them drown and and paw kent says maybe you know i think people just hear hear him say that and they're automatically like he never like that's not that's not pocket he never would when you watch kevin costner in that scene when you watch him when you listen to him he doesn't believe in what he's saying he doesn't believe he's saying maybe all he's gonna start is is taking care of his son at that moment but he doesn't believe that he should have let them die or anything like that his voice it's so like you see with his voice he's like maybe he's like you can see you in his voice he's uncertain that you should even said that yeah it's in his voice it's in it's in the physical uh body language that he gives like it's just yeah it gets a lot of hate that it does not deserve like i can understand there are things that people don't like and particularly the color and the saturation levels of the movie being a big thing for people which is fine understandable but yeah a lot of the other reasons is is a lot of nitpicking stuff and

really pushing hard at those nitpicks, you know? I'm saving a lot of my thoughts because Tyler and I have talked about recording an episode on Henry Superman. That's our June special. It'll be the three of us. So I'm saving a lot of my thoughts for them, but it's just one of those. It's overhated. A lot of the hate is, I think, forced and regurgitated and directed at Zack Snyder's fans as opposed to the movie itself. All right, Brad, we skipped your number one just because those two had the same. So you're number one.

All right, my number one. It's a three-way tie. And for the process of elimination, you've probably figured out what it is. But my tie is Superman the Movie, The Theatroclubs, Superman II, The Donner Cut, and Man of Steel. Superman the movie, the theatrical cut. I've seen the three-hour cut. I've never seen the special edition for whatever reason. That's weird. I didn't mean to. That's weird. I know, right? I watched the three-hour cut, but not the special edition. It's like 20, 30 minutes of extra footage. But so after seeing Superman 2, I did weird, you know, watch an order. Because at the time, my Hollywood video only had certain films. Certain Superman films. Watch Superman 3 after 2. Liked at the time. Going back to it now, I'm like, probably not. Did I ever watch it again? But then Superman 1, I watched. I liked it. But I thought it wasn't as good as 2.

I felt like it was long, you know, I lacked the action and everything I want to see, like him fighting someone and everything. And for years, I'd mean to rewatch it, because I watched that back in 2009, I'm going to say, right? Then comes 2018. I am recovering from a work-related injury. And I say to myself, you know what? I'm going to pull out my Superman DVD set. The tin set they put out years ago. One of my all-time favorite DVD sets, if not my favorite DVD set. And I say to myself, Brad, it's been about nine, almost ten years. When do you give Superman the movie a rewatch? And at that time, it was like, you know, it's the 80th anniversary of Superman. I'm watching a bunch of Superman stuff. I finally watched his first Superman serial with Kirk Allen. Loved it. Watched the first season of George Reeves' show. Loved it. And then I said, okay, let's return to Superman the movie. No pun intended. Superman return. Ha ha ha ha.

But watching that movie, many years later, and having grown a lot with my tastes in movies and also noticing things and everything, I fell in love with that movie. It had a big change on me, to the point where I will say this right now, Superman the movie, Superman 2, and NSVL are not only my all-time favorite superhero movies, they are definitely within top five favorite movies of all time. but yeah i've been watching this from in the movie i would also learn to pick up a lot of things because since then i like a lot more appreciation for film especially like how they did old special effects and everything all the hard work they put in there everything from like rear projection to all the flying scenes because a lot of people don't know they had an event a lot of new flying techniques for that movie remember no cpi and blue screen probably looked terrible back then they did do a little bit um of green screen there's for one of the flying shots they actually had chris like this his legs were bent down covered in green and they had a fake back

the cape dripped over it for a certain yeah i've heard something about that now i remember but yeah then just watching the movie i was just fell in love it instantly became one of my all-time favorite movies i appreciate all the hard work christopher reeve immediately escalated back to being one of my all-time favorite superman him and henry and yeah just it was an experience and then after that uh i rented the three-hour cut from my local library watched that i actually enjoyed it i thought it was great it's long don't get me wrong it's long it's three hours but i liked a lot of extra stuff they added to it especially of course as a previous mention the vanity scene that scene I don't get why they cut it. It's such a great scene. It could have been such an iconic scene had they kept it in the movie. But yeah, Superman the movie, definitely not first place. Yeah, sorry. First place spot tied in with the others. Now Superman 2, the Richard Donner cut. The only Superman film, the only version of Superman 2, you can get on Blu-ray separately. Because, you know, I have this one collection right here. One from the Superman celebration in 2019.

For whatever reason, you can't buy Superman 2, the theatrical cuts, on Blu-ray separately. For whatever reason, you can do on DVD, but whatever. Oh, sorry, there's other things I forgot to mention about Superman 2. I then watched it at the Superman Celebration in 2018. That was a weird cut they did, where like, it was a three-hour cut, but they trimmed a few things. I thought that was great. And then when they did a theatrical re-release of Superman the movie, not only the 80th anniversary of Superman, but as well as the 40th anniversary of the movie, I saw it in theaters and loved it. But Superman 2, the Richard Donner cut.

This was a film, I want to say it was actually my first director's cut I ever watched. Because I watched it, I want to say back in 2009. Again, for that awesome tin Blu-ray, a DVD set. Can I put that right now without stuff all over? Got to shut off the collection, right guys? First director's cut I ever watched, and I thought it was a superhero movie. As much as I love the lesser cut of Superman 2. Again, the film has a lot of importance to me.

it's still better, you know? Granted, there'll be some inconsistencies and everything, like, for example, Christopher Reeve's bodybuild at the time, because I believe you said they used one of the screen tests for the movie, correct? Yep. And at the time, Chris wasn't as buff as he was then. But it's definitely an interesting look into what if. What could have been had Richard Donner had his way and make Superman 2 the way he did? And Zod, I thought, was a lot better. A lot of the cheesy goofiness from 2, as much as I love it, is gone. Zod feels more like a threat. But one of the other things I really like about it...

is we got rid of the powers Superman and friends never had. I mean, granted, yes, it's Silver Age Superman, and he had a bubble of superpowers, but we didn't have that. We didn't have the cellophane ass or anything like that. And hey, for those who complained about the ending of Man of Steel, at the end of Superman 2, the Donner Cut, you got to see the supervillains survive their fall into the pit of death, even though in the theatrical cut, they died. Yeah, absolutely loved the Donner Cut. That was great. But then we get to Man of Steel. Man of Steel is a film that has a lot of personal attachment to me. For one, as you guys can see,

It was one of the two films at the time that were coming out were the only two films I cared about the most in the world. As much as I loved the MCU, whatever else was coming out at the time, Star Wars and everything, there were two films I was most anticipated for. Like, if I had to choose what two movies to look forward to and nothing else, Man of Steel was one of them. The other being, you know, Godzilla 2014. Man of Steel was my first theatrical Superman movie. I did not see Superman Returns in theaters. I saw it on DVD.

And the more and more I heard about Man of Steel. For one, like, hey, it's Zack Snyder. I like him. So I got him directing and everything. So, you know, a lot of action sequences and everything. I did feel bad. Ren and Ralph did not get the film back of Superman. That is what it is. The fact that this film is going to be the beginning of the new cinematic universe. Great. But then when I watched the movie in theaters, it was one of the very few theatrical experiences I can think of where it had an impression on me. Like a big, big impression on me. For one, as we previously mentioned, absolutely love the score to the point where I have it on CD.

I thought the action sequences were great. It gave me what I wanted to see for the longest time. Superman kicking butt on the big screen with a big budge and everything. Man, it was great. It was awesome. We finally got to see what Superman could do. It was Zack Snyder and his action choreography. It looked great. Absolutely great. Yes, it's got some problems, you know. Yes, it's kind of dark and gritty. Yes, that color palette at times looks ugly. I mean, it could be worse. It could be that... I don't know if you guys remember this. Sometime after Man of Steel, there's this one video, like viral video, that I was complaining about and everything. It's like, oh, Superman looks like a corpse and everything.

And I watched that video and I watched it and I'm like, you just put a filter over that. And then, you know, yes, Superman and Zod caused a lot of disruption and whatnot. But my argument for that is this is not only Superman's first day of truly being Superman everything. He's fighting someone who not only has the same powers as him for the first time, he's fighting someone with military training. Military training. That's why the scene where Jor-El fights Zod in that kind of bugs me. I would have liked it better if Jor-El was like fighting as like scrapping and was sucking and Zod's kind of like just toying with him. And then Jor-El gets like one good hit in and it pisses Zod off. And that's why he reacts and stabs him. Like, cause I just feel like Jor-El's like supposed to be the scientist. Zod, like you just said, the military man who's trained and Jor-El's like fighting and holding his own. I'm like, hmm.

I like that. But yeah, yes, there's destruction on everything, but as I mentioned before, Zod's got military training. I don't believe the whole like, oh, Superman, Zod, they destroyed half the city. Nah, man, half that city was already destroyed by the world engine device, man. And then there's like this one stupid argument that always got under my skin. It was like, why didn't Superman just fly Zod into space? And I'm like, dude, did you watch the movie? He did that. Crash right into Wayne Enterprises, you know, Satellite 2 and everything. But Zod was a villain who was like, you ruined my species' future.

absolutely ruined it. I'm going to take away all these people you love, this whole species, this world. I'm going to take them away from you by hand. And he doesn't care where you landed. He's like, I'm not like one joke. He was like, he's not like Dragon Ball Z either. I'm like, oh, I'll go to this one area of the world where there's like no life and we can fight out that way. No, Zod's like, I don't care about that. I'm going to murder everyone. Everyone. That instant family, dead. But...

And yes, the controversial thing that happened in the end too, where Superman snaps the neck. My philosophy when it comes to Superman and killing is only when it's absolutely positively necessary. Doomsday is a prime example of that. I know Tyler might disagree about this, but during Byrne's run, where he killed the Kryptonian, the pocket dimension Kryptonians, I thought that was justified. Because remember, those guys were pre-crisis. He got pre-crisis fighting post-crisis. Post-crisis is going to lose. He's going to lose badly and everyone's going to die. And did Superman kill Darkseid in Final Crisis? I can't remember.

I don't remember. Final Crisis is weird. I need to revisit it. Yeah. No, Final Crisis was Batman shooting him with the time bullet, the god bullet. Yeah, but then there's this part where Darkseid was not essence, his full form whatever was coming by, and then Superman screamed into the whole machine Brainiac made and destroyed him. It's been quite a few years since I read. Yeah. And as Tyler said, Final Crisis was weird.

Yeah, there's only like rare exceptions where Superman should kill, and I felt like that was justified in everything. But the thing I hate what people said about that scene is like, oh, Superman's a cold-blooded killer. He didn't feel anything about that. The moment he kills Zod, he goes down on his knees, you look in his face, and you see him like on just his face, just reading his emotions on his face. Not only did he just kill someone for the first time, he just essentially killed the only other member of his species that isn't able to pass on everything.

And you see how that emotionally wrecks and destroys him. Granted, I wish I didn't follow up in the later films, but it is what it is. But then once the movie was done, I said to myself, I still remember this to say, this is my favorite modern day superhero film. And you know what? 12 years later, it still is this every day. And then the scene where he drops down, he screams and cries is great. But what pisses me off is the next scene is the hokey scene of him throwing the satellite.

you know i feel like it just undercuts the emotional beat we left on like i feel like that's one of those scenes i just didn't really know where to put it i just think he's hot kind of hot yeah like we get that line which is like uh you just completely killed uh the vibe that we left the last scene on so if you just take that scene out like the transition from is so much better but yeah and then um what else i was gonna say um yeah after that oh one part i really like is near the end where you see Clark when he's a kid. And you see Pa Kent working on his bus, not bus, the car. And you see him, he's got the cape around his neck, he's doing the Superman pose and everything. That to me is like a message of hope. Like, I can't put into words how to describe it, but like, it seems like a hopeful image to me. And then, yeah. I absolutely loved Man of Steel when it came out. As I said, even bought the soundtrack and everything. Soundtrack was great. Oh yeah, yeah. And I'll get to that in a minute too.

But then after that, Man of Steel was also a rarity for me too. Because I rarely see movies twice or more in theaters. Like if you ever asked me how many have I seen twice in theaters, I could probably count on one hand. Maybe with like maybe two extra fingers. And then remember, I've been around for 35 years and I've seen a bunch of movies. But the other important thing about this movie was it was the first time I ever took someone out on a date to see a movie. And a date in general too. Didn't work out, but it was still a good experience for me and everything. And like learning experience doing stuff.

like what to do on the first day or anything and whatnot. But the other big thing is the score, the music. I absolutely love Hans Zimmer. He's arguably my favorite composer, though I'd probably say John Williams is more or so. But when he scored Man of Steel, he was beautiful. Like I said, as I keep on reminding you, you should probably get the vinyl because we have a record player. But the music is beautiful. Like when I first heard, what are you going to do when you're not saving the world in the trailers?

I was like, this is phenomenal. This is the Superman theme I've been waiting for. I absolutely love John Wayne's theme. Absolutely, positively do. I love the music he's done in both Superman 1 and whatever they use for Superman 2, even though he didn't compose that movie. And I love the theme and everything too. But whatever you're going to do for... Tyler, what's it called? Because I'm like stuttering right now. What are you going to do when you're not saving the world? Thank you. It hits me.

Like, for one, I think it'd be a banger wedding march. Like, just, like, imagine how it's, like, a slow beginning and everything. You have, like, you know, all the bridesmaids, the grooms still go by. And it goes, like, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da But one thing that's helped me go through with my social anxieties is Superman. Back in 2018 and 2019, when I went to the Superman celebration, just talking to people there helped me out with those. And might have actually met someone, too, digitally in 2021. Could you imagine that, Tyler? Could you imagine that? Yeah. But again, Superman celebration helped me out with some of my social anxieties. But come 2020, I made a little playlist for myself. It's my inspirational playlist. Like whenever I'm about to do like some big adult thing, like asking out someone, doing a big test or some big task or anything.

I would play Whatever You're Gonna Do, When You're Not Saved in the World, Flight. I feel like there was a third one that's kind of similar, I can't remember. Godzilla, King of the Monsters, the main theme from that, because I love that movie. Plus a scene from My Heroic Vinga. But those songs, in particular, Mass Deals, helped me through a lot. And one of the biggest, biggest things that helped me out was this. When I did my driver's license test back in 2020, yes, it took me a while to get my license, but that's a whole different story for another day. I played that thing. I had it going out in my head. I listened to it.

took that test i mean one big boo-boo but i passed i got my lessons as one of the happiest days ever but the other reason why it's important to me is like a lot of first dates especially like the first girlfriend i ever had and my girlfriend now before i met them i had that music playing to get me that inspiration that drive that push to say hey this is gonna be a good first date and look where i'm at now and then of course i don't have it now because i wore this the thrower went off My Man of Steel Superman shirt is my all-time favorite t-shirt. You can see how worn out is everything, not just by the abs and everything, but just like little flanks and everything. Yeah, like Man of Steel is a movie that had a lot of big impact on me. A lot of positive impact, too, and helped me become a better person, even though some people say like, hey, it sucks, or hey, this side of the fandom is terrible, to which I'm like, kinda. But still, absolutely love Man of Steel.

and Superman the movie and Superman 2 the theatrical cut. It sounds like a long-handed, but you guys saw why they're important and my favorites. Well, it's appreciated, you know. Alright, my number one is the death of Superman. We talked on it earlier. I really like this movie. I think it did a better job telling the death of Superman story. The way they did the Clark and Lois relationship. The line, like Levi talked about the one line earlier, but the one that I like is when she's like, Clark, you need a rest? Get for help. And he's like, I am the Calvary.

You know, like, I am the last line. Get the line from Wonder Woman when he shows up. And she's like, Clark, don't hold back if you do. And, you know, it just, it's a great version of this story. And I'm the one that complains also about how much I hate that Superman's movies and stories only work for his death so many times. That's all they ever want to do. But I really enjoy this movie. I like the scene when he's on the bridge and he stops Doomsday.

He flies down and saves the kid and hands on his table and takes the moment. I really enjoy his whole presence in this movie. I like what you guys talked about earlier. Using the real Justice League, having all those characters and how Doomsday just works his way through all of them. The Bibbo scene, a Bibbo giving the speech is amazing. It's my favorite version of Bibbo. There's a lot that I really like and love in this movie.

yeah it's my number one what did you guys think about how like doomsday was actually kind of influenced by the bps version because doomsday kind of had the whole heat vision well if you pay attention doomsday is made by dark side and it's actually taking from if you go back and watch justice league war when he has superman he's turning superman into oh okay i get you one of his uh parademons and you know batman has to go and help break superman out uh that's how he gets his DNA, and he uses that as part of his way to make... Oh, that's a nice little callback. He sent Doomsday in as the thing to take out, the first line to take out Superman in particular before he can invade. And a lot of people hate that Darkseid created Doomsday in this. I don't mind it because it works for this series. I've also kind of had my own issue with...

doomsday being kryptonian i always like the idea of just doomsday not having a backstory but of course you can't uh you can't do that anymore you have to create backstory for everything because somebody will at least dan jergens got to do it but yeah but it is cool though you think about it because there's a big tie-in between like superman's origin and it's superman's home world and doomsday it's like a nice little connection and there's a reason why he's doing his world comes back to kill him in the end um And I like this movie. It works. I like the Lois and Clark when she throws the rock and everything to try to distract Doomsday. And Clark flies and breaks Doomsday's neck. There's so much I just enjoy in this film.

It's my number one. What do you guys think of Doomsday's design, by the way? Because, like, you know, they kind of do, like, an amalgamation of, like, the classic look and kind of a little bit of New 52. Because, like, he had, like, a little bit of horns, I don't remember, right? Yeah, like, it was, I liked it. I wish, I liked the Doomsday when they go back to having, like, the bones around the eyes and stuff. Oh, yeah, I love that look. And one thing, one thing with Doomsday period that I haven't really liked is each time we see Doomsday, they give him more and more Kryptonian powers. Because he is supposed to be Kryptonian and stuff. Like, I used to joke, like, oh, when Superman fought Doomsday, all I do is just fly him into space. But now Doomsday can fly. Remember, he had a Green Lantern ring at one point. And

It's true. So it just like more and more. He has heat vision. He can fly. He's just becoming more and more powerful. And if you guys remember the one issue after our world's at war, they gave Doomsday. It's like only to my knowledge only appeared once in the comics. Like he kind of had like fire. But like Superman just like faced through it. But like for whatever reason, it never. But all right. Well, we're going to put a pin in it here, fellas. I want to thank Brad, Levi and James, the giant killer for joining us tonight and ranking our Superman movies. I thought it was pretty awesome because.

I liked in the middle how sometimes we were like right on or right behind each other. And then we had some wild cards in there. And then even our top, like we were different. So it was fun. It was a good time. So you guys take care and remember. Look up in the sky.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Krypton Report: All things Superman & DC Comics Podcast?

This episode is 2 hours and 14 minutes long.

When was this Krypton Report: All things Superman & DC Comics Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on May 23, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Krypton Report: All things Superman & DC Comics Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.