In 2002, Ryan Wedding was an Olympic snowboarder at the top of his game. Ryan's style is really gunning and gold. And in less than a minute, it slipped away. But he continued to chase the high. Ryan James Wedding. He controls one of the most violent drug trafficking organizations in this world. I'm Michelle Shepard, and from CBC Podcasts and the Toronto Star, The Most Wanted Olympian. The Most Wanted Olympian. Available now on Spotify.
I'm Josh Cross. And I'm Rabbi Diana Fersco. So what's on the docket for today? Today, I think, is our most personal episode because we are talking about the issue of interfaith marriage and interfaith families, something I've encountered countless times in the past decade, decade and a half that I've been a rabbi. Why do you say this is the most personal?
Well, it's something I've heard so much about from congregants. I've heard from grandparents worried, will my grandchild be Jewish? I've heard from parents of people getting married very, very deeply upset that their child is marrying somebody non-Jewish. And I've heard the complete other side, which is like a lot of anger and frustration with rabbis who won't officiate interfaith marriages and a lot of confusion, I think, about how the reform movement welcomes interfaith families, what our stance is on interfaith marriage in general. And I think it's just a really sensitive but incredibly like urgent.
topic for us to reckon with. Now, there's a running joke in my family that we have an intermarriage because my wife is Sephardi and that's about as far as I get from here. But I have not married a non-Jew and I assume you haven't either. And it's been very interesting to see how this conversation plays out. Last time when...
we spoke about inclusivity, I felt like that was a pretty easy conversation in a lot of ways. And not just easy for us, but easy for the reform movement. Like, this is an obvious value. There's not a lot of controversy about it. You know, maybe we can talk on the edges about how we're being inclusive. But the bottom line is, of course, we are inclusive. It's the core of who we are. It's the right thing to do. It's obvious. This is much, much more complicated because I think it gets at the core anxiety of the Jewish people, which is about continuity. So you have values that are rubbing up against each other. One is the value of inclusion, welcoming, belonging, that we spent an entire episode talking about how important that is to us.
Right. It's germane. It's part of our identity. It's fundamental. But on the other hand, you have this idea that we need to continue our particular people in our particular ways. So it's pretty hard for the reform movement to come out and say something like you should marry Jewish people for multiple reasons. One, because the movement and rabbis actually have very little sway over what Jews do. Right. They do what they want. Two, because it feels inconsistent with our core values of welcoming and belonging. Whereas my kids say it just feels icky. Yeah. And there's an ick factor, I think, for a lot of people there. So.
I think at the end of the day, the reform movement is a movement that centers pragmatism, right? It responds to modernity. It responds to what Jews are doing. There was a, quote, ban on officiating interfaith marriages long ago in the movement. However, at this point, the question for most rabbis in the reform world is not, do you do interfaith weddings? It's, do you do weddings? Because the majority of our people, somewhere around 70%, are now marrying people that aren't Jewish. So the question is moot because the horse is already out of the barn.
Right. So the question then becomes not should Jews marry Jews? Are Jews marrying Jews? We know Jews, in fact, are not marrying Jews. So how do you welcome these families that are choosing to raise their children Jewish, you know, with the commitment, love and support of a non-Jewish parent? How can you make a home for them?
How can you help give them the tools to pass Judaism on, not just to the next generation, but to the generation after that and after that? And that's a question we have for Jewish-Jewish marriages and Jewish-non-Jewish marriages. I got to admit, it's a little hard for me to talk about this because I don't want to feel judgmental. I wound up marrying a Jew. It wasn't my plan, but I fell in love with a Jewish woman. So that worked out for me. But I'm not going to judge anybody. It's a very sensitive subject. Because it's extremely sensitive. Nobody can tell you who to fall in love with. Nobody can tell you what to love or how to love or any of that. And that is a personal thing.
But we're talking about how your personal life interacts with your community. And so I hope that coming out of both of these interviews, we're going to have a better insight at least in how people are attempting to deal with this uncomfortable struggle. You married a Jew. Obviously, you're very happy. Thank God. Is it important to you that your children marry Jews? As anybody who's met them knows, I have literally zero control over my children. I can give them guidance. I can give them my consult.
Gun to my head. Yes, I would prefer that they married a Jew because for me, my experience has been that it has made my life more stable and more. We have an understanding and a foundation on which to build a relationship that goes deeper than just religion. And I think that's something that we've seen in a lot of our conversations is this being bigger than just religion. I can't tell them not to, but I hope that I've given them enough information for them to understand the value in it, for them to understand that by not marrying somebody Jewish, if they fall in love with somebody who's not Jewish, that there is something that they may be choosing to give up. And if they're not giving it up, they may have to do extra work to maintain their own Jewishness, let alone if they were ever to have children. And let me also add on top of that, I feel a little gross saying that. It feels...
bad to say that I want to have blinders or limits and that's part of like what my Jewish tradition is too is I want to be welcoming but it's also important that they feel grounded in something and for me I feel like you can be more grounded If you have the same cultural faith, whatever background on which to build something. When I married my wife, we had so much in common, a common language, even though she's a brilliant French woman and I'm a schlub from Jersey. But because we had a common language on which to base things, we understood things immediately. I knew I was going to marry her on the second night of Rosh Hashanah, less than a year after we started dating. And it was because we had done something Jewish together. And I saw it and went, oh, this works. For me, being Jewish is like the core of the core of the core. And it is important to me that.
It was very important to me to marry somebody Jewish. It's very important to me that my children do the same, although I recognize I have very little control over their choices and over the world entire and the way it's going. But I don't feel uncomfortable. I feel proud that keeping Judaism going is... at the top of my priority list. That's not to say it can't happen or it doesn't happen with interfaith families. Of course, it does. And that's exactly what we're going to talk about in this episode is how to welcome interfaith families with respect and do it well. But I'm a rabbi. I've given my life, my profession, my time, my heart and soul to the Jewish people and preserving our ways and our people.
is kind of the core of who I am. I think the thing that I've come to realize as an adult who, as I've said before, I never went to Hillel, I didn't do any of the youth group or the camp stuff because it was corny to me, that I have a much deeper affinity for those traditions. So I think the place that I would land with my kids is that if you fall in love with somebody who's not Jewish, you have a lot of extra work to do to hang on to the things that really transmit the value in how I brought you up. But I'll love you no matter what. And so who are we talking to today? So we actually have not one, but two guests that I think will offer two different perspectives. The first is a colleague of mine, actually from my class in Israel, Rabbi Bo Shapiro, who is the rabbi in residence at the Skirball Center, and is somebody that young couples of marrying age flock to and has a pretty interesting take, I think, on how to approach intermarriage as a reform rabbi. And the second is Rabbi Lisa Grant, Ph.D. She serves as the director of the rabbinical program at Hebrew Union College, and she was a beloved teacher of mine while I was there. But first, let's get into our conversation with Bo.
who gives us a look into how this works for a rabbi who's on the ground making decisions when Jews and non-Jews come to him looking to get married. Here's our conversation. Rabbi Bo Shapiro, welcome to Reform. Pleasure to be here. Thanks for having me. So this is a very important issue for all of us. It's one that affects almost every Jewish family in the non-Orthodox world. And we were hoping you would start by sharing with us a little bit about how you think about the issue of officiating interfaith marriages. I'd be happy to. And it has changed over the arc of my rabbinate and over the arc of my career. Early on, even from, I think, the end of my time in rabbinical school, my feeling was that
Well, I anticipated that I would not be comfortable officiating at a Jewish wedding ceremonies in which both partners were not Jewish. And then I was ordained and I spent the first decade plus of my rabbinate in an institution where it didn't really matter what I thought. Right. Because we had a policy that the clergy was not free to choose. The then senior rabbi did not officiate at interfaith weddings and did not want a divided shop. And so I never really had to ask myself the question. It was just easy to say, well, I'm not allowed to, and I probably wouldn't do it even if I could. But I never really had to do the work intellectually.
So tell us more about why you thought of yourself as a rabbi who would not officiate or why you were uncomfortable with officiating interfaith marriages. Yeah. Let me start with, and this is in large part what I would often say to couples who came to me, it is not because I don't think a Jew and a non-Jewish should get married. It's not because I don't think a rabbi should marry them. It was completely about me, frankly, and my own issues around feeling like the ceremony had integrity and that I had integrity as a rabbi performing that ceremony. And what that was about for me largely was this sense that as a rabbi,
I'm not a justice of the peace. I only know how to perform a Jewish wedding. And on the meta level, I wasn't sure if it could be a Jewish wedding if both people were not Jewish. And moreover, I always felt like the liturgy that makes up a Jewish wedding ceremony assumes that the people reciting those words are Jews. And that, frankly, to ask someone who is not Jewish to recite those words is offensive, is akin to asking a Jew to go to church and take communion. And so I wasn't comfortable doing that. But then at the same time,
I wasn't really comfortable stripping out all of the Jewish components to the liturgy and to the wedding, which is what I would often get asked to do. Well then, Rabbi, that's fine. We won't say those things. Well, okay, then why am I marrying you? If we're going to take away all the liturgy, then your college roommate should marry you or a justice of peace. So that's what it was really about for me. It wasn't even that I didn't want to do it. It was that I couldn't figure out a way to do it and still feel good about myself and have integrity. So have you figured out a way? I should actually backtrack and say that it's not even that I couldn't figure it out. It's as I said before, I didn't have to. So I thought since I can't do this anyway, I don't really have to figure out a way to do it that feels like it has integrity to me because even if I did, I wouldn't be able to do it. So I didn't have to do that. I'm now in a position where...
I have complete autonomy to do whatever I want. And it was important to me because I do a lot of weddings now. In fact, I do more weddings than I did before. And it was important to me not to just start officiating at intermarriages because it was good for business. It still had to be something that I felt good about. So yeah, I had to figure out a way to do it in a way that feels like it has integrity. I mean, yeah, I think about often my friend and colleague, Zach Shapiro, the other Rabbi Shapiro here in Los Angeles, I think I was still in rabbinical school and he came to speak to our class. And he said something along the lines of, I don't officiate at intermarriages, but I will officiate.
at a ceremony in which one of the parties is not yet Jewish. And he then qualified that by saying that to him, an intermarriage suggests the coming together and weaving together of two disparate and distinctive predictions. And he has no desire to participate in that. A marriage in which one person is Jewish and one person is not, and for whatever reason, either never had a religious identity or had one, but it is no longer something that is particularly significant or relevant in their lives, is a very different situation. I very much agree with that sentiment. It speaks volumes to me.
if someone who is not Jewish, but is not a practicing member of another religious tradition, if they are A, marrying someone who is Jewish, and B, looking for a rabbi to perform that ceremony and have a Jewish wedding, that right there says a lot, right? Because frankly, two Jews decide to get married and they call a rabbi because in many cases, it doesn't occur to them to even call anybody else, right? It's not such a conscious choice. Whereas in the case of a Jew and someone who's not Jewish, it's a choice, right? So they're articulating that they want a Jewish wedding.
and on some level, hopefully, a Jewish home and a Jewish family. And I think that at the end of the day, as a rabbi, I'm in the business of building and creating Jewish families. And so a wedding that I believe will lead to a Jewish family, I think, is something I feel very good about and have a lot of integrity around. That's so fascinating to me. I mean, put some scaffolding in there. So a couple comes to you and says, you know, I'm not Jewish, but he is, and we want you to officiate our wedding.
What kind of requirements do you have of them? Do they have to learn anything? Or what kind of recommendations do you make for the ceremony? How do you talk to them about, like, your limits? You know, I know you won't officiate a wedding, for example, with a priest. Not that they would with you, but, you know, things like that. Like, fill us in on the picture. You know, I have colleagues, I'm sure you do too, right, friends, who, like, I don't know, they have couples, like, sign this affidavit that they're going to, like, raise Jewish children or some kind of whole thing. And, like, at the end of the day, we're taking their word for it. And, frankly, we're taking their word for it that two Jews are going to raise Jewish children in this day and age, right, or how Jewish their children are going to be that they raise. So, you know, I acknowledge full well that, to a certain extent, it's all a
But for me, yeah. One, it's that they are committed to having a Jewish wedding, a Jewish wedding ceremony, right? They're not asking me to stand up there and perform some Unitarian Universalist secular something. I was going to say the same thing. I've gotten the request for like, but will you just do a unity candle? And it's sort of like, well, no. Right. And it's like, no, I'm a rabbi. And this is, again, maybe dancing on the head of a pin, but I'm in California, right? I don't believe that the state of California legally gives me the right to marry anybody and sign any marriage license. They give me that right because I'm a rabbi.
And I think implicit in that is that they're giving you the right to perform Jewish weddings, right? I'm not a justice of the peace. I'm not a judge. It has to be a Jewish wedding in terms of, in a way, aesthetic, and in a way, liturgy, right? Because I still haven't, you know, let go of the notion that I'm not going to ask someone who's not Jewish to say, according to the laws of Moses in Israel, or to say, you know, to say Erosim. It's not something that makes sense, in my opinion.
have someone who's not Jewish say, but does the Sheva Brachot have to be a part of it from my perspective or some version of that? Absolutely. Does it have to be ostensibly a Jewish wedding? Yes. They want me to get up there with Pastor Tim? Like, no. And to your point, I don't know that Pastor Tim would want to get up there with me. Our colleagues across the street have just as much integrity as we do in most cases. So one is that it's a Jewish wedding to me, but frankly, more importantly to me than the ceremony itself is what do they imagine their life to look like and their home to look like and their family to look like? And are they...
hoping, planning, desiring to have a Jewish home. And if they choose to have children, one day a Jewish family and raise Jewish children. You know, I'm under no illusion that some newly engaged couple sitting there has any clue what their life is going to look like with children, despite the fact that they all think they do. So do we. But that's their intent or that that's at least what they can imagine. You know, sometimes a couple say, like, no, you know, we're going to raise this boat. We're going to do this. We're going to do that. That doesn't work for me. But like I said, if my sense is that this couple and this ceremony and my participation in this is going to help promote and create a Jewish family and Jewish children.
Not only do I think that I should do it, I think that I have an obligation to. Right. So I kind of wanted to go back for a minute. Basically, what you've described is for a long time, you worked at a large congregation where there was a policy that all the rabbis did not officiate interfaith weddings. How did that go over with the congregation? Because we know that the majority of our congregants at this point don't marry Jews. So talk us through, was that just like, OK, this is my synagogue? And, you know, how does that play out?
I would say that there was a small portion of the congregation that like 100% supported that. Like, absolutely, Rabbi, you shouldn't be marrying people who aren't Jewish. On the other end of the spectrum, I think there was a relatively small portion who were beside themselves. How could you possibly not do this? And again, knowing the reality of the policy and the situation, thankfully, most of that intimacy was all directed at the senior rabbi and for the rest of us, because I could pretend people could ascribe to me well.
you know, Rabbi Shapiro is so lovely. He would do this if he could, whether I would or not, right? Right. You know, it's nice to not be the boss. And I think the majority either didn't know because it wasn't relevant to them or was sort of resigned to the fact and they just, you know, they knew that was the reality, right? It's a congregation that is, I don't know because it wasn't data that we collected, but I don't think I'm overstating to say it's like at least 30%, maybe 40% intermarried, something like that probably. The fact that none of the clergy there would have officiated those weddings.
I don't know how that makes those folks feel or if they know that. But it had been the reality for so long that at some point people stopped asking, right? Because they knew the answer was no. But it certainly was not without conflict. And look, there's a new senior rabbi who is five weeks on the job. And I guess because it's been five weeks in the high holy days, he hasn't announced it yet, or he won't announce it publicly, but I am positive. I was positive that I can be without having had a conversation with him about it, that that will change. I see that as for the boomer generation, most if not all did not officiate until they did.
And for our generation, it's like the population that's coming to us has so, you know, greatly higher rates of intermarriage that for our generation, it's not like, should we do this? It's more often than not, how do we do this well? You know, so I guess my question is like, what do you think about the future here? Do you think this is a crisis? You know, some sort of continuity crisis where we're not making Jews anymore and this is a real problem and we need to really like encourage aggressively, you know, marrying Jews? Or do you think this is just sort of like the way of the world and something that is part of who we are now?
I think it's both. First of all, I think the how do we do it well is a question that we need to be asking about every single facet of Jewish life. There's too much mediocrity. I don't think that is the same thing as telling Jews that there's something bad about marrying someone who's not Jewish. Absolutely not. But I don't think there's anything wrong with encouraging Jews who care about their Judaism and have strong Jewish identities. And I think that we should be creating meaningful Jewish experiences under the chuppah for Jews, and I'm not being cute, people who aren't Jewish yet, to think about being Jewish.
All right, well, I have one last question I ask everybody we ask to come on. You have 30 seconds. Give me your elevator pitch for Reform Judaism. It's not even for Reform Judaism. It's just for Judaism. I've said for a long time that if I, you know, had a second act or a second life or didn't need to make a living, I think that Judaism just needs a massive ad campaign and marketing campaigns. Really, what would I say to people? Do you want a richer, more meaningful, more beautiful, more connected life filled with purpose, filled with, you know, moments of extraordinary wonder and joy and happiness? We have something for you. I don't think Judaism is...
the best religion in the world. I think it's the best one for me and for those of us in this conversation and a bunch of other people who are out there. But I also think that in a place where so many people are searching for purpose and meaning in their lives, Jews included, by the way, and they're looking everywhere except Judaism, the non-Jews, right? They're looking at SoulCycle. They're looking to yoga. They're looking at the Kabbalah Center. They're looking to Buddhism. They're looking to like, you name it, right? I just want to be on the menu. I want Judaism too.
occur to them. Because the overwhelming majority, we all live in a bubble. The majority, they think Judaism is, they think you can't convert, or if you can, it's really hard, or we don't want you, or it's exclusive, or it's hard, or whatever. And it's a pretty good way to be in the world. Awesome. Well, thank you so much for joining us. Beautiful. Thank you. For our second guest, now that we've seen the view from a rabbi having to make decisions about specific weddings, we wanted to get a feel for the movement view. Next up is our conversation with Rabbi Dr. Lisa Grant, who is the director of the rabbinical program at HUCJIR New York. Have a listen.
We're so thrilled to have you here. It's my absolute joy to be sitting next to a teacher of mine, someone I look up to so much, Rabbi Dr. Lisa Grant. This episode is about interfaith families. We've had an episode more fully about inclusion and the Jewish reform value of inclusivity, but now we're sort of getting down to the heart of the matter. The decision to welcome and embrace interfaith families was a moment of great fanfare in the reform movement. So take us back to that time. How did this happen, that sort of having open doors, welcoming interfaith families became a part of who we are?
Well, I think we can connect the dots, you know, that the first step was really the decision by Rabbi Schindler and the movement to accept Jewish families, whoever their parentage is. And there was ground-up pressure from community members, from parents whose children were getting married to non-Jews, and they wanted them to feel included in the congregation. And that sense of inclusivity, I think, you know, speaks to, you know, one of the core values of Reformed Judaism, which is this notion, you know, that everybody belongs. They did have to think about, you know, what are the ways in which we can help people feel welcome without feeling judged, without feeling lesser than, without... You know, and there were all kinds of questions about, well, can they have any kind of ritual responsibilities? Can they be called up, you know, when their children become bar bat mitzvah? Can they, you know, can they serve on committees? And all of this evolved over time. And it took quite a long time, I would say. I remember there was a student in 2007 who gave her senior sermon about the positive impact of intermarriage. I remember this moment. I was sitting there in the sanctuary at HUC and just on a rhetorical level, like, wow, can that rabbi preach, right? Yes, she did an amazing job and she was terrified.
She said, I don't know how this is going to go over, and that she really took a great risk. And I think that the student body was probably quite mixed about that. Today, if that sermon were given, nobody would give that sermon today because nobody would even think that this is an issue that we have to address because it is a fact of life. It's normative. It's part of who we are as a community that we have figured out some many, many beautiful ways to welcome and include.
the non-Jews who are part of our community. And it's very tricky. You know, what can they do ritually, you know, serving on committees? And it's not, the movement hasn't handed down, you know, rules about that. So a lot of communities make their own decisions. But I will talk about something quite beautiful that we do at our congregation on Yom Kippur. At some point during the service, the rabbi invites up all of the non-Jews in the community who are raising Jewish children for a blessing.
And there's 40, 50 people who come onto the Bema, and it is extraordinarily moving. And the blessing that she offers is filled with gratitude and support for their commitment to creating Jewish families. And so I think, I mean, that's a really beautiful sign of the distance we have traveled since that first decision was made when nobody had any clue what to do to today, where we have a lot of tools and resources and skills for figuring out how to make people welcome without judgment. I mean, this is all great, and I like it, and it's what I want my Judaism to be like. But is it actually helping? Do we have more people living Jewishly now, or do we have some kind of continuity crisis? Okay, so the continuity crisis emerged, or was named that, after the 1990 National Jewish Population Study, which I mentioned before, in which the statistic was 50% of Jews getting married today are intermarrying, and that sent shockwaves throughout the community. Again, I mean, I don't have the statistics off the top of my head, but in the 80s and 90s, the vast majority of couples...
who are intermarrying were not raising their children as Jews, were not affiliating the synagogues. And today, I can't say it's a much higher percentage. And there's all kinds of, I was noodling around trying to find some statistics and didn't come up with anything conclusive because there's a lot of different studies. But certainly, all of the studies that I was looking at show that. a much higher percentage of interfaith families or intermarried families are raising their children as Jewish today to a much greater extent than they were a generation ago. And so in that way, I would say it's working out pretty well. And there's also, there's a percentage of those, even though, and we'll talk about officiating in a moment, I think, but...
there are a small percentage of those families who are raising their children in two religions or where there are elements of a second religion in the family, which, you know, personally, do I like that? I mean, it makes me uncomfortable. I'm not a fan of syncretism, of sort of blending. I think Judaism is rich and deep and wide and has so much to offer that there's plenty to immerse ourselves in for a lifetime in Jewish life and that we should be doing that and encouraging our families to do that. But people come from, you know...
All kinds of different backgrounds and experiences and family traditions are so, so important. And so it's really hard to be judgmental. All we can do is offer the best we can to our communities and create a place where people feel fully accepted, fully, fully belonging and find deep meaning, whether they're a five-year-old or a 50-year-old or whatever age they are, that they find that this is my home. This is the core of my spiritual life, my communal life. And that's the work that we need to do as rabbis and cantors and educators and communal leaders.
But isn't that letting us get away with being lazy? And let me make a finer point on that. You're going to be feisty, huh? Oh, yeah. That's my job. But my question is...
okay, the rabbi that I grew up with never would have done an interfaith marriage, just wouldn't have done it. It's a different time. It's a different generation now. But I can see a world in which Eric Wisnia would have said, okay, now we have to do this because of various things. But I am definitely not going to do this unless this person takes three classes. Unless this, you know, like, again, I bring up Catholics. The Catholics make them go to classes. We make conversion hard for a reason. Should we not also make other things to make sure we're doing the right thing to make sure that somebody's, for lack of a better word, properly vetted to come into our community that we shouldn't demand that people, I don't care if you're too busy. If you're too busy, maybe you're too busy to get married.
It's a legitimate point. I don't agree with it completely. I would say, I mean, yes, if your rabbi were alive today, chances are he would be officiating in intermarriages. There was a tipping point, which I couldn't identify it exactly, but it was somewhere between 10 and 15 years ago where rabbis of my generation, the baby boomer generation, where the great majority of them were not officiating, all of a sudden started to officiate. And many of them gave high holiday sermons telling the congregation why that was happening and why they had made that.
difficult decision. And it's different. I totally see the difference between Jews who are non-believers or Jews who could care less about pretty much anything other than, you know, bagels and lox or maybe not even that, but, you know, who we don't blink an eye. when they come to us, you know, to be married. You know, you're Jewish, fine. You have a Jewish mother, you have a Jewish father, you're fine. No other questions asked. I mean, maybe we should be, you know, stronger-willed with everybody and say, I mean, the Orthodox do this, I mean, for different reasons, but, you know, they have the bride take kala classes, you know, bride classes to learn about family purity and what the mikvah is, you know. Maybe we should have classes for engaged couples. And I have, I'm a Jewish educator. I'm all for education and make as many opportunities available as possible. But co-rucing people into doing that, I think, is...
Not going to win us, friends. So I have one final question, which is definitely the hardest. You have 30 seconds. Give me your pitch for Reformed Judaism. That Reformed Judaism is the Judaism of our time. When it's done well, you can become a part of a deeply rich, Jewishly engaged community where you can bring your full self in terms of, you know, finding anything you want to do around social justice, around Jewish engagement, around ritual life, around community, around...
fun activities for your kids around exploring, you know, whatever, and that you don't have to leave any of yourself at the door. And I think that that's really, really important, that there's no compromise, that you're fully in whoever you are. And I think that that's really beautiful. Really, really appreciate your being here and your wealth of insights and reflections. Well, thank you. This was fun.
We've now talked to two rabbis besides yourself. And I think that the number one thing that I'm certain of is it's infinitely more complicated than we could ever imagine. And it feels like we're in a moment where we're saying it's very dire that Judaism is going to die out. For me, this gets down to the article called The Ever-Dying Jewish People, which basically makes the claim that in every generation, Jews think they will be the last generation of Jews. And so this puts us in like an existential panic. Is our success in assimilation going to turn around and bite us? Have we been too successful?
in joining institutions, you know, culture, et cetera, to the point where we're actually, you know, reducing ourselves, goes the argument. But I think the only question at this point is not if to welcome interfaith families, it's how to welcome interfaith families. I mean, that's the entire point here is anybody who tells you this is something avoidable is just wrong. This is something, as you said before, 70-ish percent of American Jews are doing. So what we need to do is figure out where we want to be.
what we want to address and how to support those Jews so that we're doing our turn in this generation at trying not to lose all the other Jews. And I want to put a finer point on it. It's not just about welcoming people. Right. It's about actually giving them the tools to make sure that they know how to help their families be Jewish. Some of them will convert along the way. Many of them won't. But the question is, are we sort of showing them the Jewish way with enough clarity, with enough urgency, with enough depth, enough value to say, like, not just welcome, you belong, come hang out. But actually, you're an intrinsic part of the future of the Jewish people. And I feel for these families because I feel like there's been a lot of shame historically and stigma and being in an interfaith relationship. But actually, what I've seen time and time again is that interfaith family.
that choose to come to reform synagogues, often the non-Jewish spouse is like should be championed. Here they are doing something that's not of them. That's not of their heritage because either they believe in it or their supportive spouse or they want it for their children, even if they don't have it themselves. And it's not something we need to feel ashamed about at this point. I think the answer is more like this is where we are. Let's go all in on helping these people be a part of the Jewish people in all the ways. I think the way I look at it is I don't care.
If you have an interfaith marriage, you love who you love. But I really hope that we as a people, we as a community can give you enough so that you care if your child has a bar or bat mitzvah. You care if your child feels connected to other Jews. You care if when they see somebody from Chabad on the street, they don't do what I did and tell them I'm not Jewish enough for you. I care about the Jews feeling like Jews and their children also feeling like Jews. And I think whether we're panicked about it.
unnecessarily because it is in every generation. Or if we are at an actual inflection point, what we need to do to challenge ourselves, to challenge our institutions and everyone else to say, give us better tools. I need to work harder. Every institution needs to work harder. Everybody has the best of intentions. But if it's not being effective, we need to also own that and say, how can we teach people to better want to be Jews? I'm going to push back a tiny bit and say this. There are multiple well-funded global institutions that are designed to do exactly that. How are they doing? I think they're doing well. The content.
Is out there. OK. The intention from the Jewish world to welcome families that are young couples that are marrying somebody like there are so many iterations on this idea because we know that that's our population. But it's also incumbent on Jewish people that are marrying non-Jewish people to use the tools and to take the initiative and say like, hey, this is something that I want for me. And at least take that first step in exploring together. But if you've made the greatest TV series that's ever been made and nobody watches it, is it the viewer's fault or is it the person who made the TV series?
Well, it's the viewer's loss because it is the greatest TV show ever made. We're not going to debate that because that's 100% correct. I think it's both. I think that there needs to be a rethink of how we communicate all the things that are value. And I think that's something that the movement lost when it went focused on Judaism is only a religion, as I keep beating this drum the entire time, and say this is all the other value of what it means to be a Jew. Something that has existed before the concept of just a religion, back when we were tribes. This is so much greater than that. And when you've lost the sense of being in a tribe with people.
you don't feel the same connection to transmitting it. And I think that's probably where we need to go, where both on a personal level, we need to take that in and also on an institutional level, work to communicate the value in being a member of our tribe. I'm not sure we're having this conversation in the best way. Not you and I, but I mean as institutions, right? It's set up as this dichotomy between either like you do interfaith marriages or you don't. You're pro or you're con. But that's not real. I think what is real is that it is wonderful when Jews marry other Jews.
That is important to us. It is the reality that most don't anymore in the Reformed world. And so the question becomes, how do we make sure that those families know they belong in a Reformed synagogue and have the tools to contribute to the Jewish people in a way where they realize in a way that feels authentic to them, but also respectful to us so that they'll perpetuate? I would say authentic to them and authentic to us. It's authenticity that goes both ways. There is so much to say that we could sit here and talk about this for another 75 hours and we'd never get to the bottom of it. For me, the final point is that this is a thing that is happening and we all need to find a way to show off what's so awesome about being a Jew. Whether it is building a sukkah or it is davening three times a day if that's your jam or whatever it is, we need to do a better job as all of us communicating why we like this and where the value is so that even those people who aren't Jewish when they come into my shul, they figure it out why we're having a good time. Amen.
So with that, join us next week where we're going to tackle clearly the smallest issue facing the Jewish people, Zionism. I can't wait. So until then, see you next time. Same Jew time, same Jew channel. Reform is a Tablet Studios production. The show is hosted by me, Josh Cross, and Rabbi Diana Fersko, and is produced and edited by me, Quinn Waller, and Leah Dunn. Our executive producer is Courtney Hazlett. For more information, go to tabletmag.com slash reformpodcast or email us at podcasts at tabletmag.com. And don't forget to rate and review us wherever you get your podcasts.
In 2002, Ryan Wedding was an Olympic snowboarder at the top of his game. Ryan's style is really gunning and gold. And in less than a minute, it slipped away. But he continued to chase the high. Ryan James Wedding. He controls one of the most violent drug trafficking organizations in this world. I'm Michelle Shepard, and from CBC Podcasts and the Toronto Star, The Most Wanted Olympian. The Most Wanted Olympian. Available now on Spotify.