Skip to content
Re-Post: Cat Wars (Pete Marra special) episode artwork

Feb 1, 2018 42 min

Re-Post: Cat Wars (Pete Marra special)

from Urban Wildlife Podcast Hosted by Urban Wildlife Podcast

Pete Marra joins us for a special episode to talk about his (and Chris Santella’s) book Cat Wars: The Devastating Consequences of a Cuddly Killer. We originally posted this for his talk last year at the Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia. … Continue reading →

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Re-Post: Cat Wars (Pete Marra special)

0:00 42:57
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hi, podcast listeners. This is Billy. This episode is a repost of one from about a year ago. I have an article coming out in Grid Magazine in a few days, an op-ed arguing that we should keep cats inside, even if that means we end up having to put down some of them that can't be reformed. Ultimately, it saves animal lives and helps keep nature accessible for us and our neighbors. I figured some readers might want to check out this episode. Of course, please disregard the event information in the episode. Pete Mara spoke at the Academy of Natural Sciences last year. Tony and I are hard at work on a literature review episode about outdoor cats and wildlife, one in which we'll dive into the studies about outdoor cats and the evidence for and against TNR. Please stay tuned.

You know, cats are, they're pests or pets, depending upon the situations humans put them in. There's no question about that. They are a domesticated species, and we have to remember that. So when we put them in these situations and they are having an impact on biodiversity, we're leaving them there and we're allowing it. And that's on us.

Welcome back to a special episode of Urban Wildlife Podcast. Yes, indeed. So we're going to talk about Cat Wars. This is a book, a topic, but the book is by Peter Mara and Chris Santella. So the occasion for this podcast episode about Cat Wars is that Pete Mara is going to be talking at the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia, Drexel University, on Thursday, this Thursday, February 23rd, 6.30 p.m. We want everyone listening to this, if you're in the Philadelphia area, to go, well, register first, and then go to the talk. Pete is the, he's written some, he's published articles on this. He and his co-author wrote the book.

Cat Wars, which I've been reading and finding this mix of depressing and energizing. You know, on the podcast, we've talked more than once on different episodes about the importance of keeping cats indoors, you know, and get all our cats on the table here. I myself am allergic to cats. I don't have anything really against them aside from my allergy. I've lived with cats. I've had to comfort a partner while we had to put down cats because they had gotten really old and sick. I know how they can be part of a family. I'm part of a household and no one knows it better than Tony right here. I got my lovely Lola. Lola and Tony looks like this big burly.

He is a big, burly dude. He can look kind of intimidating if you don't know him very well before you know he's a cuddly bear of a man. But when you see him with Lola, you know he's a cuddly man because it's a fuzzy little geriatric cat. Like, rawr! He hops up on his lap. She's seriously like a living teddy bear. Like, she wants to be carried around. I come home, she's like, rawr! And you just pick her up. And she begs to be picked up and just carry her out with you. And she just wants to be in your lap the whole time. And Tony is, I think, a true sense of cat person. I mean, like, when your friend, you know, Mike McGraw, on the podcast, you thought he could use a cat?

What happened? A trash pit one. There you go. He rescued a cat. Yeah, took it off the street. And now it lives with Mike McGraw and his pet cat. What's his cat's name? Walter. Walter. There you go. Because she's named Walter. Because Mike and I are both kind of like a combination of a dude in Big Lebowski. But we're both kind of a lot like Walter. So my point is that we are not cat haters. Arguably, Tony is a cat person who loves cats, rescues cats, gives cats to his friends, but keeps the damn cats indoors. And so this has been a theme earlier in other episodes when we're talking about Cat Tracker. Pops up here and there.

The importance of keeping cats out of the outdoors. The basic concepts are that cats, even though they might be well-fed, are still impulsive predators. They love to hunt and kill things. Tony, tell us about Lola's hunting activities. Yeah, Lola is like, she's tiny. She weighs only a couple pounds. She's mostly hair. And she's like, well, she was really shy until I started feeding her people food. And now she just wants to hang out with everybody. So it's successful. But she used to be really meek and shy. But she's an unbelievable mouser. And I wake up at like four in the morning to her doing like the mouse song.

meowing like a song like meowing you only hear when they have a prey on them and she wakes me up like with a bloody mouse like she's old she's like 13 so I came home one day and there's like bloody puke and I'm like oh no my poor Lola's like puking blood she's gonna die and it was like I gotta clean it up and it was like a mouse he puked up a mouse she killed she's brutal and this is what kills me about these cat fanatics that they have like this whole like it's like the Koch brothers with the like Heartland Institute where they have this like misinformation factory they have these like sites like alley cat allies and these mantras they always say they're like a fed cat doesn't hunt and I'm like wait my cat literally has a giant ball of food. She's so little, I just leave it out for her. She can eat as much as she wants. She can give her treats and people food, whatever. And she slaughters mice. Everybody's, you know, you get cats and you still feed your cat, right? So like, yeah, Gigi's got, Gigi had cats and, you know, she had some chunky cats that, we'd have mice, but they would hammer those house centipedes, they'd hammer the cockroaches. So like, there's a notion that a fed cat doesn't hunt. In fact, it's the opposite, where they're subsidized predators. Exactly. Where a predator that depends on prey items for sustenance generally doesn't kill much more than it can eat in a certain amount of time.

Because it's just going to waste calories catching more things. And also, its population is going to be restricted by the availability of prey. So if it eats the prey down below a certain level of availability, they'll start starving. Yeah, there's an equilibrium. But if a cat is being let out, or you have a feral cat colony and you're feeding the cats, then they're subsidized so they can kill more. Also, feral cat colonies, we'll hear about this, it actually attracts people to dump cats. Right. If everybody knows that's where they take care of those cats, and you can't find anywhere else to take your cat.

Because all the shelters have gone no kill, which is its own kind of problem we touch on, or Pete Talks touches on this interview. Then you're like, okay, well, at least behind the Walmart on Washington Avenue, like people are feeding the cats. I'll dump Fluffy over there. And you promote interactions with these domesticated animals with wildlife because when you leave food out for a cat, you don't just feed cats. You feed foxes, skunks, raccoons, possums. And then they interact with the cats, you know, either directly or, you know, there's lives exchanged at the bowl.

Cats can get rabies. They can give more. Cats do get rabies. They do get rabies. They can give mange and toxoplasmosis to these other animals. And these animals get accustomed to being fed. So you're subsidizing wild predators as well as subsidizing cats. And you just have this horrible mix of things that really sets up a bad situation for your native critters. I mean, I think we're going to hear a lot about birds because they tend to be the bigger conservation focus, rightly so. But the mammal figures are way higher than the birds. And so that's like, it isn't just like, people are real great, we get rid of mice. No, there's a lot of wild mammals that we don't notice in, I'll call them, urban wild areas. We look at the species list for...

let's say the Wissahickon. And you've got everything from like, you've got weasels in there, right? Well, I've never seen one, but yes, they should be there. You've got weasels, you've got shrews, you've got native rodent species, bulls, mice, you've got star-nosed moles in the Wissahickon. You've got some really interesting mammals and all of these are, maybe the moles are underground, but these are still a lot of interesting native wild mammals that are cat target food. And so, you have lots of herps, you have snakes, you have frogs, you have lizards, and then what's mostly the conservation focus and what gets our blood boiling is when we see the cat colonies being maintained in important stopover areas for birds.

so that it isn't even just our wildlife. We're talking about the wildlife for Canada and Central America that's getting taken out by our little ecological traps that we're setting up with these cat colonies. Girls' wildlife are actually doing... better now, but there was this warbler that, I mean, there's other species that are on decline. There's this, there's a dangerous warbler that breeds in the upper Midwest. At one point, it was only breeding in the, in the northern portion of the lower peninsula of Michigan and wintering in the Bahamas. And it was a really low population. And so think about that. Like, they don't come through Philly, but they come through, certainly, they, they have a, they follow river corridors. And they follow, yeah. And so they know this, you know, they make landfall somewhere in Florida maybe. So, you know, you have throw cats in like, you know, the megalopolis of Florida or anywhere between there and, you know, you know, of course like Toledo, because they know they go through that area and Chicago probably, you know, these, it is just one example, you know, this is dangerous species that could like get eaten.

The one thing we didn't cover a whole lot with this interview, actually let's listen to the interview now and then we'll talk about this last part. So here's Pete Mara. I'm talking with me and Tony about his book Cat Wars and the conservation problem of outdoor cats and what we can hopefully do to solve the problem. My name is Pete Mara and I am a scientist. I gotta be really transparent. This is all, we're only doing this because I need to talk to you and take notes so I can win Facebook debates about turtle cats.

Perfect. Okay. That's fine. There can be ulterior motives here. I'm cool with that. So I wrote the book because I don't think most people recognize how significant of an issue it is that we have so many free-roaming cats around the U.S., Canada, and actually globally. It is a tremendous problem, and I wanted to write the book in a way that most people would enjoy reading, but at the same time see how significant this is for wildlife, for human health, and for the cats themselves.

In terms of biodiversity, in the United States, we have calculated that cats probably kill somewhere in the range of 1.3 to 4 billion birds per year. When you compare that to other sources of direct anthropogenic mortality, nothing else even comes close. Collisions with buildings, which was at one time thought to be the primary killer of birds, comes in a far second at about 599 million. Beyond that, the others are almost trivial, but they're important relative to cats. That information, that evidence, that when we pull together all the different sources of information globally and we're able to build those models and really understand what the mortality was, that put up enormous red flags because that's on the heels of already knowing that cats have contributed, if not caused, the extinction of 63 species around the world, reptiles, mammals, and birds. Those are primarily on islands, but not just on islands.

So when you think about the overall impact that cats have had and are having, it would be completely irresponsible for us not to take this much more seriously. They are the second greatest cause of species extinctions on the planet, and that's after rodents. That's a significant issue, and most people just can't appreciate that. They don't understand these issues, and so the purpose of reading and writing the book was to bring all that to bear. The numbers are shocking, and you sort of say, I can't quite believe that, really. How do you get to the aggregate numbers of what cats kill?

So it's actually quite simple, actually, and I would also say that we weren't the first people to estimate this at over a billion. There have been other folks that have come up with those estimates, but they've been kind of swept under the carpet. Richard Alcock came up with an estimate that didn't even include unowned feral cats and came up with an estimate over a billion. So basically what you do is you calculate how many birds are typically killed by owned cats and then by unowned cats. You adjust it based upon the number that they actually bring in, and so you have to really kind of figure out how many they're actually killing. Most of those estimations are based upon the number of...

birds, for example, that a cat will bring home to its owner. And we know that a cat only returns about a third of what they kill. The other thing is they either eat or they kill and they leave them. And that's been demonstrated with some really convincing studies using cat cams and actually studies where they actually followed the cats around almost 24-7. And then basically you need to know and estimate the number of cats. And we think that there are somewhere around 80 million owned cats out there, and roughly 50% to 60% of those, somewhere around that range, go outside and are allowed to hunt. And then there are somewhere between 60 and 100 million unowned cats out there. And because we were being very conservative, we set our estimates at somewhere between 30 million and 80 million. So even when you consider the lowest parts of our model, lowest estimates from our model, like the lowest number of birds that a cat will kill or the lowest number of mammals that a cat will kill, and the lowest number of cats that are on the landscape,

That generates a 1.3 billion estimate. Now, one of the criticisms that we've been getting from the cat advocates, people that don't really understand bird populations, is that, well, estimates are that there's only 10 billion birds out there, and you're telling us that it could be 4 billion that are killed by cats? That's crazy. Well, yeah, that's because there aren't just 10 billion birds out there. The 10 billion estimate of birds, and it varies depending upon where you look to get that estimate, counting the number of birds across the landscape is not a trivial thing to do. And I would argue that we really don't know how many birds are out there. But the important thing to know is that cats are preying on birds throughout the year.

The estimate of, say, 10 billion that's put out by some organizations, that is just the estimate of the breeding census, so how many males and females are in the population in May or June. After they reproduce, that number can double, triple, or quadruple because those birds raise young. They could have two, three broods in a year, and there could be as many as 40 or 45 billion in the population. So you can't just say there's 10 billion birds out there. That number changes throughout the annual cycle as birds reproduce and recruit individual animals into the population, and those numbers change as you go from June to July to August, et cetera, so you're back down to June again next year.

Cats are preying throughout the year on that available population of birds. So when you think about it in those terms, hopefully it's a more reasonable combination of estimates of 1.3 to 4 billion relative to anywhere between 10 and 40 billion or 50 billion birds that might be out there. And is that impactful still? Of course it is. It's horribly impactful. So the number of reptiles that are killed every year is somewhere in the 100 million or so. Mammals, it's higher. It's like 15 billion. Cats certainly prefer mammals. But given the situation, cats are opportunistic predators. And so on island situations where there may be a higher abundance of

of lizards or in certain terrestrial and mainland situations where lizards or snakes might be more available and easier prey, they'll certainly kill those as well. They'll kill anything that moves for the most part. That's what they do. And another point I want to make is that, you know, cats are, they're pests or pets depending upon the situations humans put them in. There's no question about that. They are a domesticated species and we have to remember that. So when we put them in these situations and they are having an impact on biodiversity, we're leaving them there and we're allowing it. And that's on us. Do we know much about how cats might predate other animals in urban settings versus in rural settings or variations based on landscape like that?

Yeah, so I don't know of studies that separate landscape type and predation rates per se, but I will say that in some urban areas, certainly, wildlife isn't as susceptible as in others, so it's not a constant issue, right? Some areas have endangered species, or there are cat colonies along beaches where there might be piping plovers nesting. There's a greater risk there, no question about it. But I'll also say that in some urban settings, people would be surprised at... how important those areas are for wildlife, in particular migratory births during stopover, during spring migration, or there could easily be a small lizard population, a remnant population that remains in an urban area, depending upon where you are. Many urban areas are, thankfully, more forested, and in Washington, D.C., for example. And so you can have really important stopover areas being right in downtown D.C. And so we need to be careful where cats are placed, cat colonies are placed, or where people let their cat out, even in urban suburban settings, because those areas can be really important for wildlife.

So the title Cat Wars doesn't refer to the battle between cats and wildlife. The Cat Wars title really refers to the battles that we've been having at multiple scales and across different groups. So when I published papers on cats and other folks have come out with statements against cats, there is a gigantic and aggressive group of cat advocates out there and so-called animal rights advocates that are very, very aggressive towards anything that might be saying cats don't belong in the landscape or might refer to the need for euthanasia of cats or to enclose cats. It's a very, very aggressive, very, very vocal group. And there are wars there. There are battles that have ensued almost in every county, in every state, every town, every city. When you start looking at how these things are growing and spreading across the U.S. and Canada, it's remarkable. And there's also battles that occur between people that live in neighborhoods, between individuals and their neighbors, because individuals that own cats feel strongly that they should be able to let their cats out. And the fact of the matter is that that cat may be going into some other neighbor's yard where they are really trying to restore their habitat for nature.

and that cat is killing things in their yard, but that individual next door feels strongly that that cat should be let out, and that cow may not have leash law, that cow may not have any enforcement whatsoever. There's wars that are happening even between neighbors over the cat issue. We title the cat wars, you know, mainly because we think it captures the current dilemma that we're in, which is a dilemma that we've been in for over 100 years, and we've known about the consequences of cats, yet we refuse to sort of dig our way out of this. What have you seen work in terms of ways to resolve free-roaming cat problems wildlife? So nothing is working. I wish I could point to success stories in the U.S., but I can't. There's maybe one. Aurora, Colorado has a leash law that has some teeth. But there are no success stories in the U.S. Again, we've known about this for over 100 years, yet the animal rights activists, the cat advocates have really pushed this forward in a way that it makes it very challenging for us now to say that it's not okay to have a cat colony in this area that's really important for biodiversity, whether it's birds or skanks.

And so now, in our book, what we propose is that we're not going to get all cats off the landscape overnight. It's just impossible. It's just not going to happen. But we need to remove cats from areas where they are posing a risk to sensitive wildlife. That has to be a zero-tolerance policy.

And then, likewise, there are probably areas where they're not posing as much of a risk. And in those areas, we probably need to allow cat colonies to occur at least until we can demonstrate, or it is demonstrated, that they are impacting wildlife where the colony is not going extinct. But in those areas where cat colonies persist, because these are invasive, non-native predators, if they're going to exist there, a wildlife professional needs to make the decision about where that colony goes. There needs to be an environmental impact assessment, literally. I mean, it really does. And after that happens, then the colonies need to be managed properly. They need to be counted properly in a statistically defensible way.

They need to be monitored and captured and given booster vaccines so they're not continuing to spread diseases. And on that point, it's also not just about wildlife impacts. The other side of this equation and the other point here, which makes this even more disturbing to me, is the impacts cats are having through the spread of Toxoplasma gondii directly into humans and children and also through the food that we eat. It's having a tremendous impact on the global population in ways that we're now just starting to understand. So going back to your point, for some people, we're never going to be able to convince them. Some cat advocacy groups, we're never going to be able to convince them that cats can't be on the landscape. It's going to be impossible.

And it's going to be a top-down. It's going to require a top-down approach and a regulatory approach once we convince the decision makers. For other people that are more reasonable, my hope is that the book and other arguments will make them see the light that there is a problem here. And I think that the majority of people will see that. And I'm optimistic, honestly, despite the fact that we have very few wins, in part because there's precedent. We did it with dogs. In the 60s and 70s, when I was growing up, dogs used to roam free all over the place. And certainly they do occasionally in certain parts of the U.S. But we learned our lessons from rabies, from dog attacks, from dogs getting hit by cars themselves.

And we started to require leash laws. We started to require licensing. We started to require rabies vaccinations. And it took 10, 20, 30 years, but we got that under control. We need to start treating cats like dogs. Cats are in Philadelphia. They're actually exempted in the regulation. And lots of cities have that exemption. It's just crazy. But the reason that exemption occurs is because of the really strong voice of cat advocacy groups. They've gotten it in there. And on the other side of the coin, bird advocacy groups, wildlife advocacy groups have not been as vocal. We don't have that many out there. We've got the American Bird Conservancy. We've got the Wildlife Society, PETA.

But in a lot of these meetings that take place in different municipalities and in different places around the country, they are not represented as well. And so the cat advocacy groups have pushed this agenda through, and it's created a problem. One of the things I found interesting, just observing, I know you can't necessarily speak for other organizations, but on the animal welfare slash animal rights side of the table, you've got the Humane Society, which interestingly is the one that I see in other fields come out in favor of wildlife. Then you've got PETA, which has its own reputation, but you've got them in opposite sides. It's fascinating. It really is. PETA comes out and says, it is inhumane to put cats back on the landscape. And frankly, they're 100% correct. When you look at what happens to cats on the landscape, whether it's having them go through major surgery through the sterilization process and putting them out within 12 hours of that surgery, no veterinarian worth their salt would recommend that, but that's what happens. They'll often bleed to death, and then they're exposed to getting hit by cars, getting eaten by coyotes, disease.

No organization should be calling that a humane treatment of an animal. It's just not. And that's where PETA comes down on that. It is more humane. It is more caring. It is more thoughtful to actually euthanize an animal than to do that. The U.S. Humane Society is in complete contradiction with its own policies. They've got this wildlife group, and then they've got this policy on cats that makes no sense whatsoever. But the Humane Society has also gone into this no-till realm, which unfortunately is the direction that many shelters have gone in across the United States, that has now resulted in enormous numbers of unintended consequences for wildlife and for domestic.

animals, companion animals. Could you flesh that out a little bit, because this has come up in other discussions I've been having locally. Sure. So a no-kill shelter basically will turn away animals once they've reached their saturation point. They're not going to keep accepting animals because they can't euthanize them. But because these shelters have limited resources, both in space and money, they can only take so many animals. And so when they tell somebody that's made the very difficult decision that they can no longer keep their cat or they can no longer keep their dog, those people are turned away and are facing another difficult decision. What are they going to do with their animal? They have no choice but to figure out what is the thing that they can do. And they see a colony out there.

where cats are being fed, they're going to dump their animal. And that's what we're seeing. People are dumping their animals because they've got no choice. No-kill shelters have, you know, that's just one of the unintended consequences. They also probably have too many animals, and having too many animals also encourages various diseases to emerge. In dogs, it would be something like parvovirus.

I noticed in the park that I work at, there's someone that finally got them to stop feeding on park property. I noticed that there's a red fox that I'll see come out the road at around the same time every day, and that's also the time the person comes to feed. So it seems pretty clear that this fox has been conditioned to know when there's going to be food around. Have you looked into the effect of these cat colonies feeding indirectly other wildlife? Oh, yeah. It's a tremendous issue, in fact, in the book. And one of the issues is rabies, of course, because there's this transfer of rabies from wildlife, especially like raccoons, into cats because they both go to these feeding stations.

When people put out this food, they're often just scattering the food out there. And even if they're putting it in bowls, it gets dispersed. But it attracts things like fox and raccoons and a variety of things that also have rabies. And in Pennsylvania, in the book, we have a map of the rabies distribution in cats. Cats that have been picked up that have rabies. And it's amazing. Every year in Pennsylvania, there are probably between, I don't know, 30 and 50 cases of rabid cats. It's just a matter of time before somebody is going to pick up one of those cats. It's going to be some sort of exchange of mucus, and someone's not going to know. And they're going to come down with rabies, and they're going to die. Once you get rabies symptoms, you die. Every year, we also have people that are exposed to rabies from cats, but they figure it out, and they have to go through post-exposure prophylaxis.

which is not inexpensive and it's not trivial. One of the things that comes up, I'm a birder. I mean, I give it to myself. I mean, I own a pack myself, so I think I should be viewed on both sides of this. And I also think that without even a side, you should just make sound decisions based on, you know, ecological principles and science. But people will say, well, you're biased because you're a birder and you study birds professionally. And since you do as well, how do you address that criticism to people?

So there's nothing wrong with cats. There's nothing wrong with owning cats. As I mentioned earlier, we turn cats into pests or pets. The trick is you have to have an indoor cat. Letting your cat out the door and letting it roam around, that's irresponsible pet ownership. But there are ways to get...

stimulation to your cat, which is what people want because cats need stimulation. They do, just like any pet. With dogs, you know, I have a dog right now. I've owned cats in the past, but they've been indoor cats. And with my dog, I have to bring him to the park or bring him for long walks or throw the ball for him, make sure he gets exercise. He is stimulated. With cats, we can walk cats on leashes. In fact, we're seeing people walk cats on leashes more and more. You're not going to get an aerobic exercise, but the cat will get stimulated. We can build catios, these enclosures where cats will be safe and wildlife will be safe, but they'll still get stimulated. There are ways that we can treat cats.

So they are being fairly treated and wildlife is being fairly treated and the disease risk is lowered. And that's how we need to be thinking about things. Cats are just going to require a little more work than we once thought. Exotic invasive. So the one thing we didn't cover so much in that conversation is something that I want to actually dedicate an entire episode to. So we'll get some folks to really go through literature because we've done this ourselves. You end up with these Facebook battles where people are like, well, trap, neuter, release is better than alternatives. The mantra seems to be that like, oh, trapping and killing cats doesn't work. So TNR does work. And so then what ends up happening is someone, and they always seem to post the same page, I think it's Alley Cat Allies, a list of articles. I mean, I also just keep talking about it because the name is hilarious. So you argue with somebody and you're like, here's this article.

or like all these articles and like a lot of not the only article this is like part of a body of literature which tends to find the same thing yeah and you um you post you know you're posting these like peer-reviewed articles in like conservation biology or you know some other journal you know some highly reputable journal and they're like what about this and you're like it's allies or like someone's like blog post one thing that comes up fairly often is Veterinarian journals. Right. This stuff tends to come out in veterinary journals. And what's the thing about that is that's art research scientists. So I'm curious that they can be in certain fields. I don't want to say that. And almost all of it. They're not population biologists. Right. And almost they're not ecologists. So veterinary, they're obviously from a bias. Veterinarian is someone I would take my cat to if my cat were sick. I would not take my cat to a population biologist or an ecologist if my cat were sick. Similarly, if I want to learn about population dynamics of wild or feral animals.

I'm going to go to the ecologists and the population biologists. We'll get into the specifics. I actually want an episode where we basically just go through the Alley Cat Allies literature page. Because I've done this. In one of Tony's Facebook debates, he got in one of his Facebook words with some cat people. And they posted this page. I'm like, all right, I'll look at it. I couldn't get the full article or something. Something they had to deal with the abstract. But still, it didn't seem to apply. We're talking about one argument I have with somebody. And I said, I'm still waiting for actual peer-reviewed papers on this topic. And I think it was...

in response, someone replied with a list. And her thing is, she'll often say, should we bring it up in the future debates? She's a friend of mine. She'll be like, don't bother to debate Tony. He won't read the papers. And I'm like, I didn't read the papers because you sent me a list within 20 minutes that you didn't curate. Because by doing a Google, by copying and pasting it in the Google search, it came up that it was a list. And the majority of the papers, just by me looking at the abstracts, were irrelevant to the topic. But I'll say, I did read them. And so I'll talk about how they were irrelevant. Well, I just read the ones that were supposedly relevant. Those were garbage.

The basics of the problem in Philadelphia are that a maintained colony, to shrink over time under the TNR model, you have to spay the vast majority of the females in the population. New to the males too, of course, but really the spaying is what really controls the population there. And then you have to limit recruitment. Recruitment is a term that you use in ecology to refer to new individuals coming into a population. And that can be from babies that survive and then grow up. It can be from new animals coming in. And so the problem with the TNR models is that I don't know how the hell they limit recruitment.

I mean, you have to either stop more people from dumping their cats or be there every time someone dumps a cat to grab it and before it can join the population. And I'll, you know, own this as a supposition, but... The presence of these colonies sure seems to draw people in or draw cat owners in to dump their cats. Let me just say this. I can speak to something similar. Yeah. Where when I worked at Kyle's Creek Environmental Center. Yeah. It wasn't even a cat colony where you fed cats. People dumped cats and dogs monthly. And they say, you know, there's like a box meowing outside on a driveway. Yeah. Or a pit bull in a baby carriage because you can't walk because you've been starved. Oh, God. Or that was crazy. The animal control folks who you imagine see stuff like that all the time, they almost cried.

Pete Mayer makes a great point. I think we're going to use it to open the episodes. You've probably already heard him say it twice by now, which is that cats are pets or pests, depending how humans treat them. This isn't about the cats. It's about humans owning our responsibility as the owners, as the supporters, as the companions, depending on your framework, for these animals. That we can treat them with respect and dignity, keep them inside. We can, honestly, if they can't find a home and there's no good way to, no humane way to handle them because throwing them outside to be hit by cars.

eaten by an owl. Whatever is not humane, whereas euthanasia is. Yeah, and I want to talk about that. There's, like, these two prevailing things that you hear, and there's, like, that euthanasia is cruel, and the other thing is kind of like, well, is this nature playing it out? Or, like, how dare we, like, put value on one another if it just, like, let it take its course? We'll discuss that in a minute, but when it comes to euthanasia, if it's an animal rights issue, what you're dealing with is whether or not it's cruel to kill animals. Then, what I don't understand is when you euthanize a cat, or you kill a cat, whatever you want to say, right? Whether you shoot it in a field, right? Or...

Or put it down with anesthetic. Honestly, I'm fine in big areas if they just use a rifle or whatever, because man arrows are intensive. So anyway, if you kill a cat, it stops killing. Right. You save the birds, you save the snakes, you save the mice. Also, the other thing is you save the domestic animals that you kill to feed it, and you also save the chickens, the fish, the fish, the krill or whatever that you're catching in the wild, right? Definitely clean down by catch. Yeah. Right?

or you're raising them in fish farms, and you're feeding them wild-caught fish in the first place. So you're killing all these other animals. Either you let it get killed in the field, you're killing other animals to subsidize it while it's in the field, or you adopt it, get adopted, and you're killing other animals to feed it. So you're killing way more animals by letting this cat live. There is no no-kill option. Yeah, in the field or adopted. You're killing way more animals no matter what. So I don't understand that. And the other thing is, the idea is, why do humans think you have the right to manage animals? Well, they're pollution. They're an entity from somewhere else.

That is somewhere it shouldn't be, and it's causing a hard environment. Thanks to human action. We have a responsibility to deal with that. This isn't like we're managing red-tailed hawks eating squirrels or gray foxes. Careful there, not say red foxes. We'll say gray foxes killing native snakes and frogs. That's stuff that would be happening in this space, whether humans were here or Europeans were here or not. And the animals here in areas of cats weren't previously, right? They evolved.

to deal with the sweet predators that go evolve with them. It didn't evolve to evade cats. And certainly not cats at the population densities that we provide. Right, they're subsidized. We could go on forever, and I think we will. I think, like, sort of the next steps in this as a podcast are I do want to do that sort of, like, review of the literature to sort of put to rest these questions of, like, TNR working, it doesn't. I have been moved to start trying to organize a little bit about this. I can't because I work for the park system. I gotta just let, you know, I gotta...

You can respond to the park situations with the park policy tools that exist, but I'm not. So I'm sort of trying to pull people together to talk about the naturalist, the conservationist, the urban wildlife enthusiast, the public health response to feral cat colonies. And maybe that doesn't mean we ban TNR completely as much as that would make me happy. Maybe that means that we just, we accept what we can work with. And it's a question of moving the maintained colonies or the condos, the feeding away from particularly sensitive areas. So that if you've got, let's say, on Delaware Waterfront, you've got some park where there's a lot of birds stopping over migration.

Can we move the colonies and the care a couple blocks away from the waterfront? Something like that. I think those are the kind of solutions that I would love to see. Is it in a park? Okay. Can we move it a few blocks away from the park? Those kind of things can take them out of the natural areas or the areas that sustain wild animals that are particularly vulnerable to the cats. Put the cats in the back of a strip mall or something instead, you know, and keep them away from the migrating warblers, the five-line skinks in their one little tiny population in Philadelphia, all the interesting wild mammals we might have in our wooded stream quarter parks.

Keep the cats places where they're not going to do the damage. And frankly, let the TNR people do their thing. The other thing we need to talk about is address the notion that there's two sides, that we're bird people, right? We talked about it in the beginning. You are a cat person and a bird person. Right, but what I mean by that is talking about how when they're reintroducing pike and clovers to Barry Islands, sometimes they do things like kill greyhorned owls that live there, right? Or the current war we talked about earlier, they...

kill the euthanized or kill whatever brown-headed cowbirds because they're parasizing their nests and follow them. You've got some unfortunate trade-offs in these situations. Yes, and there's trade-offs. And the goal is to preserve the overall biodiversity of the world. And in our cities, too. Yeah. This is part of what we do in this podcast. We don't want to give up on cities as spaces for biodiversity. If you are listening to this podcast, you're a fan of urban biodiversity. And if you are a fan of urban biodiversity, then it is really hard to be that fan of urban biodiversity and also be a fan of outdoor cats, whether that's outdoor pet cats, whether that's feral cats, dump cats, you name it. If we want people living in cities...

to have this rich experience of biodiversity that we actually can have, we actually indeed can have in cities, which is what we love and what we want to share. You can't have that and also have tons of outdoor cats. This is what moves us to get so involved in this. I'm just going to wind up repeating information about Pete Mara. Pete Mara, again, co-author of Cat Wars, is going to be talking on Thursday, February 23rd at 6.30 p.m. at the Academy Town Square Series. This is at the Academy of Natural Sciences of Drexel University. This is in Center City, Philadelphia, central to everything, right by the parkway. Thank you very much. Thank you.

It's all the signs, but they just couldn't do it.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Urban Wildlife Podcast?

This episode is 42 minutes long.

When was this Urban Wildlife Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on February 1, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Urban Wildlife Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.