BFM 8 and 9.9 of the Business Station. My name is Rich Breadbrie and this of course is Matt Slaint. Today we're asking whether Web3 is a solution to what we perceive as the faults of the current internet or simply the latest upgrade where we repeat the same mistakes. What a light and sunny intro man has given me today.
Thanks very much for that Matt. Hey Rich, yeah you know that's just the kind of positive frame of mind I've been in recently so no I kind of tread a bit lightly around Web3 because I'm aware that it kind of is to technology what comic books are to popular get the slightest character or what reference wrong and you know you get the kind of abuse that's usually reserved for mass murderers as you know an aggrieved army of geeks confronts you for your astounding and astonishing ignorance. But I came across a shortly some new scientist about something that I've been wondering how to tackle for a while and that's the potential of Web3 to reduce our dependence on these kind of big tech companies that a lot of people express they're dislikeful and perhaps to you know undo some of the data harvesting excesses of the web to era. So as ever a quick sideline what do I mean by web2 and web3?
Well web2 or as most of us know it more simply the internet. Broadly speaking web2 is the social web so it's the version of the internet that we've been accustomed to. Well I mean since around 2004 actually it came in in about 1999 but we started sort of using the terminology more around 2004 and it's the idea of sites that you know a base around creating user-generated content. So obviously most people immediately think social media sites, Twitter, Facebook, TikTok, MySpace if we're going further back into history.
But it's actually a lot more than that you know it's e-commerce sites that Amazon where products are rated by the users. It's that power of the crowd you know quite literally in the case of things like crowdfunding. The Democratic Web? Well you know some people even say the performative web which I'm not sure is holy fair but I kind of waver around terms like democratic so yes we you know people talked about web2 technologies democratizing the internet.
This enormous flood of free services that allow people to start blogs, to reconnect with childhood friends online, to find and join these globally distributed communities. And we saw tools like Twitter play an integral part in the Arab Spring uprisings, in the late nortes and the early tweens. But I'm not going to get into you know where things have perceived to have gone wrong with web2 just yet so I'll go into that definition of web3. So web3 or as most of us will know it more simply in the future the internet.
I'm not just trying to be clever or smart, I'll hit by repeating that you know as we explored in the series of metaverse shows in November and December web1, web2, web3 these are all just experience layers but it's terminology that idiots like me use to everyone else it is just the internet you know when it was web1 when it was dial up and AOL and GeoCities that was the internet. It's very different from the web of today but it's still just the internet. So what I want to get into today is looking at how web3 will kind of change the structure of the internet we experience and address some of the issues that a lot of people seem to have with the direction that these kind of social web the web2.0 technologies have gone in. And are we going to be speaking about the metaverse again today?
I'm going to try not to partly because I don't want to make it even more confusing. Some of the subject matter is similar to what we discussed in the metaverse episodes in the sense that this is all technology that is still in the process of being built you know when we talk about web3 what we're really talking about today is decentralization we're talking about blockchains we're talking about sort of crypto and tokens but mainly we're kind of talking about decentralization because decentralization is being pushed as this democratic future of the internet that's why I said you know democratic is kind of a loaded term when we're talking about all of this whereas in web2 we had centralization being pushed as the democratic force so we're kind of having one set of technologies pushed as democratizing and then we're seeing them as being oppressive and we're pushing another set of technologies as being democratizing. So today we'll look at some of the issues surrounding you know the promise versus the reality of the social web era of web2 and whether web3 is a solution to some of those issues or whether it's just going to be you know a different set of technologies but the same kind of traps that we fall into. Okay now let's start with web2.0 and where you think I guess it started to go off the rails a bit.
Yeah I can do that I mean a few years ago pre-pandemic in fact we talked a lot about certainty and uncertainty on the show and how some of that was down to this seeming unaccountability of technology in the companies that operate it. This was the era that people were starting to mainstream talk about surveillance capitalism. We had data breaches at all sorts of web2.0 companies who it seems weren't really taking our privacy and that data security very seriously. On top of that we had these same companies effectively giving away huge tranches of information about us to third parties who paid the money like the Cambridge Analytica scandal which you know I mean it just seems so quaint now but the social web it seemed to become this seething pit of kind of rage and dissatisfaction and discontent.
You know there were people who were hiding behind anonymous accounts and they just you know just blithely send out rape or death threats to other people. We had this sort of emergence of doxing revealing someone's name and address details or as we used to call it when I was a kid the phone book. When I was a kid as well I'll let you in with that. But yeah I mean now we're at this place where everything is public.
Our information is public. We give it away for free. Most of the things like your location even you're taking this snapshot on Instagram or whatever social media and you're checking into places and that kind of stuff. You're literally telling people where you are you know with GPS data.
Yeah but I mean that's one of the issues that I find so interesting about doxing people are so afraid of having their home address revealed. Yeah they put all of this information online whereas 20 or 30 years ago people wouldn't have dreamed of putting that information online but they were happy to have their name their address printed in this book that anyone could just walk into a phone box and look I'm not even going to bother explaining what a phone box is to anyone under the age of 20. You know I mean you're right you know we were seeing the proliferation of disinformation. We were seeing this propaganda this hate speech.
We were seeing videos of hate crimes and atrocities on our social feeds, terroristic acts, all this content that seemed beyond our control and beyond the control of the companies providing the services. You know this is where we saw the social sites really start to invest hard in content moderation both in terms of human moderation and developing machine algorithm based content moderation systems as well. But when COVID happened we pushed a lot of those discussions about our relationship with tech companies to the back of our minds and during that time our dependence actually increased. You know how many people used QR codes for the first time during the pandemic.
Yeah yeah. But just a couple of years later it seems that almost every restaurant and cafe expects you to scan a code and order your food online and when you go into stores you know the retail counter the point of sale is covered in codes for e-wallets that allow us to scan and pay with our phones. Even down at my local wet market you know on a Sunday morning when I go and get my fruit in a morning I'm no longer paying cash it's the touch and go wallet or it's something else to pay. The uncle's the aunties down there completely familiar with this tech you know have no issue with it.
There's maybe one or two people that might take cash and they tend to be few and far between and you can see that they're struggling with business actually. And yeah I mean I had a blockchain changed recently so you know one of our doors jammed and the guy came and I hadn't taken cash out so I said to him oh do you want me to go and get your cash and he's like no just transfer it to me. You know like you said you know we've just kind of gone full circle in this kind of pandemic period we've broken that dependence on cash that we've had for hundreds of years. I mean that is a massive change to the way we conduct our lives and we see that in a lot of other areas you know we went from hating video calls and refusing to make them to hating video calls but spending most of our working day on them.
Rich is laughing because we're doing this as a video call. Yes and I hate them but hey there you go. Exactly because you know it was for a lot of people it was the only way to stay in touch with family friends co-workers during a period where we couldn't see people in person. So we've come through the pandemic as these shell shocked socially inhibited and technology dependent or Tomatons.
You know as you said the people at the wet market struggling with the technology in order to just make the living that they made before the pandemic happened. So a lot of people aren't happy about it and I get that. You know people are deeply uneasy about these things even though they helped us through that difficult time because they've become the norm the standard but nobody actually asked us if we wanted it to be that again like the people you're talking about at the wet market and a lot of these technologies don't feel very social anymore. They're not empowering us they're not making us feel good.
We stare at social media feeds of people living their best lives and we compare those lives to our own even though we know the feeds we're looking at are probably faked. People who make it look like they're permanently on holiday when actually they just took dozens and dozens of shots and clips on the trips they took months before and they're just spreading them out. So as a result you know we create these equally false narratives around our own lives to try and compete. It's like we've all become a like a smaller scale version of that Netflix show Inventing Anna.
You know the fake heiress who charmed to went to New York society and just lied about her life. A lot of us now are a little bit Anna and the social web just seems to amplify that kind of personality and that kind of personality trait. Yeah you haven't mentioned the business model I spoke yet though. Well yeah I mean pretty early on we decided that we didn't want to pay for stuff which wasn't helped by the explosion of you know think pieces about the freemium model and how freemium could also be a democratizing force.
Another reason I don't like this terminology. You know there was this idea that we'd all be able to take free flights around the world if we watched a few ads from our seat while we were in air but very quickly we saw that advertising revenue concentrated around companies like Google and Facebook and there were simply far more freemium products than there were brands to advertise and fund them and even for companies like Facebook and Google who were taking most of that money the ad revenue wasn't enough for them to keep the lights on. So you know I'm not saying that we should blame ourselves for what Big Tech has become. Sorry I said that wrong.
We should blame ourselves for what Big Tech has become. We wanted free and even when it was obvious that the ads weren't going to pay the bills we still refuse to pay. In fact we even started to use plugins that blocked the ads from the sites that we're using them to give us free content. So the social web sort of turned itself into this kind of pretzel in order to make money.
We stopped being customers we turned into the product the customers where the companies that these platforms were selling our information to. The data generated by the content we posted was and still is packaged up and sold and that led to all of these Cambridge analytical level scandals when you know it became known that all those free services where we clicked yes without reading the terms and conditions were painting these incredibly intimate portraits of our lives. Now that's not an excuse. A lot of terms and conditions are set up so that you don't read them but a lot of the dissatisfaction with the social web could have been avoided perhaps if we'd agreed to pay just like we do with everything else in life.
Now even if you do argue that we willingly let ourselves return into a product instead of a customer would we still feel so alienated if the power or the ownership was more distributed? I think this is where it gets a little bit murky and where we'll pick up with web 3 after the break. You know the original web was distributed. People maintained their own sites and servers.
They were in control but with that control came responsibility and also ability. Towards that that transition phase between web 1 and web 2 is where we saw hosting services strengthen their role because up until that point you had to know how to host a website. You had to know you know you either had to have your own server or you had to know how to connect to a server. Suddenly you could start a blog or a social profile without needing to know code.
So web 2.0 is where the internet became easy to use. You know one of the reasons Google became this de facto gateway to the internet is because it had a great product. It had accurate results that put all of the content of this you know information superhigh way as we called it at that time. It put it at your fingertips.
But two decades on it feels less like empowerment and more like a weight because you know you peel back the layers of the technology and you see all this interference and intervention from big companies and governments and people feel as though they're being manipulated by all of the algorithms that they are in control of what they see on the newsfeeds. So there's this general erosion of trust especially amongst old detect users who were kind of skeptical to begin with. So we see rather than democratization we see the potential for some of these technologies to actually alienate and exclude people. You know people who don't have data on their phones, people who don't even have a smartphone, people who don't have cards versus stores that no longer take cash.
And even though it may only be a small percentage of people who are affected by this, it's kind of the antithesis of what the social web claim to represent. Yeah and on that note when we come back can Web3 Breakly Stranglehold or Big Tech or is it simply center a place that with the next generation of big tech monopolies? It's tuned into Matslane here on BFM 89.9 the Business Station. BFM 89.9 the Business Station welcome back to Matslane.
We're talking about Web2 and Web3 today or as Mat puts it the current internet and the future internet. Where do we even start Mat? Well with Web3 I guess with those blockchains and that decentralization because that's kind of the key to the parts of Web3 that we're talking about today. I'm actually making it my mission to become more Web3 literate this year so that I can answer these questions more confidently and competently.
But most people know what blockchain is sort of roughly at least you know people who listen to shows like this or keep perhaps a lazy eye on what's happening in technology in general. I know that that's a minority of people overall which we'll discuss later but blockchain is basically an encrypted ledger a list of transactions that enables transparency and security. Now it can be centralized or decentralized so a lot of governments and financial institutions are looking into or have actually started rolling out centralized blockchains. For example they can make international money transfers pretty much instant because the money isn't moved so much as the ownership is transferred and that transfer or transaction is then recorded on that blockchain.
But when we talk about Web3 especially in the context of reducing our dependence on big companies what we're really talking about is this trend towards decentralization. Which of course brings us to Bitcoin for example. Yeah which we now think of mostly as a form of digital money but actually Bitcoin is was the first decentralized blockchain so it's created back in 2008. How do centralized and decentralized blockchains differ?
Well at the very kind of surface level that we're talking about it's basically an issue of control and ownership. A centralized ledger is owned by an entity that might be an individual or it could be a company or groups of those things whereas a decentralized ledger is distributed it doesn't have a single set of owners copies of that ledger are held on multiple computers and it's this distributed characteristic which slightly counterintuitively actually guarantees that it's secure and accurate. Why do you say counterintuitive? Well I mean for example think for bank so your bank tells you how much is in your bank account right so your trust is actually vested in that bank that institution keeping accurate records and not trying to cheat you.
Now if your bank details were held by a kind of a loose cooperative of individuals you would possibly have less trust in it because you don't know all of those people or those entities you don't necessarily have that trust with them but really a decentralized blockchain is a bit like having hundreds of accountants. That way no one actor actually has the power to manipulate your holdings or steal or alter what you have. It's actually a remarkably simple concept the system is honest because there are so many copies which allows you to see exactly where someone has attempted to manipulate the receipts because they won't match any of the other copies so it effectively breaks the chain. Now today isn't about going into how all of those copies are updated because again not enough time different show.
Now blockchains of course we hear about them in relation to things like NFTs and crypto currencies but they're a lot more than that and they can be used in very simple ways as well as very complex ways. For example this is an example of kind of one of the more simple ones I was talking to someone recently who was previously in government who mentioned the potential of putting things like fishing quotas onto a blockchain which would enable auditors to see a glance who had taken what and when out of the sea. So very simple and straightforward not large in scale because it's a very kind of relatively small number of people that that would kind of relate to. Similarly elections could be carried out using blockchain technology which would be an antidote to the folks who believe that voter fraud is rampant because blockchain would provide a tamper proof receipt of the votes.
Now NFTs we already know in terms of digital artworks but a lot of creative products might find their way onto the blockchain. Music podcasts for example writing, providing content creators with a new way to earn money and get rewarded. And is this the democracy aspect that you were talking about? Well it's democratic in the sense that it's about recording participation and in the case of many of the blockchain technologies being built it's about rewarding participation as well.
And this is the kind of next level of what we see and perhaps the kind of wider use case and this is people building decentralized apps also known as DApps on blockchains or on pterp networks. So again what is a decentralized app so we'll go with something that's quite basic and easy for people to understand. Take an app like Twitter or Facebook. These are examples of centralized apps.
You give your information to them and a private company owns the platform so they're the gatekeepers a decentralized version of Twitter or Facebook would not be owned by a person or entity or a group of people. So for example if you had a D app Twitter clone there would be no moderator to come and step in and delete your content because your content is an entry on the chain is indelible. And DApps can be used in exactly the same kind of scenarios that we use centralized apps now. You can use them for games, for social media, in finance and real estate you can use them for health apps.
They're especially useful in terms of logistics and supply chain etc etc. You can go on and on because they provide records that are trustworthy and transparent. And I think before we go any further you might want to explain to everyone the difference between transparency and privacy. Yeah I mean that's a good point.
So the transactions or interactions are transparent but that doesn't mean that the user has to be. So that doesn't mean that if you're on a decentralized app that all of your information is available for anyone who wants to view it. Now I'm not going to go into this aspect right now because I've already gone off on a bunch of tangents away from the central theme. So are you met?
No not at all. But user activity on blockchains with DApps can be governed by what are called smart contracts. So just go with me on this one. If you want to know more about smart contracts we will talk about them in future shows but you can go and look it up on sites like Investor or PDA.
But essentially the smart contract means that your privacy is maintained. Now that doesn't mean that your privacy is absolute. As we've mentioned before particularly with financial transactions on blockchains forensic accountants can track the movements of assets through the blockchain and they see at what point those are converted into cash like USD via digital wallets because people use email identities to set up the wallets and you can often reverse engineer who actually owns them by following those trails. Now that's just a relatively simple example but the big difference here is that your personal information is not centrally held in a private company server.
Now that's more important than it sounds because it means that you can move from one D app to another. So you can move from one Twitter clone to another Twitter clone simply by taking your information. It's recorded on the blockchain. You simply swap it to the other app.
It's not owned or possessed by the app that you were using before. That's something of course that you can't do with your information when it's held by a company like Twitter or Facebook. And that kind of raises back to the central theme. Will web3 tear down big take?
Honestly, we've been talking about this for about 25 minutes now. No 30 minutes probably. And I can only give you a really poor answer which is who knows. Yeah, I'm sorry.
Half an hour in. I don't know. No, but partly because this goes back to the principles of the original web going back to that web 1.0. In order to use that you had to be extremely tech literate unless you were in the know.
You couldn't find news nets. You couldn't find message boards or anything else on that internet. So web2.0 represented ease of use and these streamlined user interfaces. So we essentially traded ownership for usability.
In web3 we get to take back ownership but we still have some of those same tech issues of complexity. So this is where we've used the example of the of Mastodon before the Twitter clone that was gained in profile if not maybe active users since Elon Musk took over Twitter. Now Mastodon isn't really web3 but it is an example of a decentralized app and it's also kind of hard to use. It's more difficult to find people.
It's difficult to find content. Different Mastodon servers have different codes of conduct for users. Which goes to show you how messy democracy is. So we see that in a lot of these first generation web3 services.
They're kind of techy. They're kind of hard to use and they're kind of glitchy. Which of course are all things that don't matter at all to be. But surely over time that will change as the technology evolves surely.
And that's why I said the answer here is poor because for example if you look at a lot of the decentralized apps right now they're built on the Ethereum blockchain. Chezos is another chain that's gaining prominence. There's a whole bunch of them. If an app is decentralized and not owned, how incentivized is the community to create a simple user experience.
As I said, democracy is messy. So even if the chain or the app allows the community to vote on functionality which is another kind of core principle of a lot of web3 services that the users get to vote on what happens to it. That can also be a recipe for bloat rather than singlessness. You get that situation where Microsoft of the early norties where all of their products had every feature that you could imagine in them.
But you couldn't use any of it. But then if blockchain organizations take on a more central role governing standards, minimum standards for user interfaces, etc. Not only does that run counter to the original principles of web3, it has the potential to elevate those companies to the position of the big tech companies that they were originally supposed to be this alternative to. And I guess that's the final point.
Is there a consumer demand for web3.0? There is but it's still very small. It's going to be hard to get people to move from their Gmail to a decentralized alternative until you can demonstrate that it's frictionless and that the user experience is going to be comparable. I don't think we're at the point or level of dissatisfaction where we turn our backs on the companies that we're currently using.
So overall, I think it's probably too simplistic to look at web3 as an escape from web2.0 or a cure all for what we think has gone wrong. With technology, our reason for using it is generally pretty simple. That it's better than what we used before. And that I think is where we'll see the utility of web3 growing.
I think the debate about decentralization, decentralization, I think that's going to be lost on most people. As primary concern is, does it do the thing and does it do the thing well? So that's where I think we'll see the growth. The openness of web3 allows us to use the technology in different ways.
And if that sounds like a segue into a future episode, that's because it is. Well done. Thank you very much, Matt. Oh, my pleasure.
Of course, that was Matt's point. And if you did miss any of this episode, don't forget you can download it wherever you normally get it from. We recommend the BFM app. It's available at the app.org or Google Play.
And for some other stuff, you can check Matt out on his sub-stack. It is cotchapop.substack.com, correct? Well done. That's correct.
Well there you go. This is me, Matt. It's here at BFM. It's the station.