Welcome to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism, coming to you from the studios of 2SEL 107.3 in Sydney, which sits on Gadigal land of the Eora nation to which we pay our respects. You might also be tuning in across the country courtesy of the Community Radio Network for listening via our podcast. My name is Shane Anderson, thanks for joining us. This week we're going to be taking a closer look at how foreign correspondents have been covering the human rights crisis unfolding in Xinjiang, China.
I say unfolding because while the tensions between the Uigome Muslim ethnic minority and the Chinese state have a long history, in the past few years the situation has deteriorated. The Uigome people are being detained en masse without charge in what's being called reeducation camps. The exact number of people in these camps and what goes on in there is unknown. However, the UN estimates there could be up to 1 million people held there.
At the same time, an increase in policing and surveillance technology has clamped down on everything from where people can go to how they dress and perhaps most importantly who they can communicate with. This combined with various state media propaganda campaigns has made reporting on Xinjiang an exceptional challenge for foreign journalists. An ex-guest, Megha Rajagapalan, has the enriable title of World Correspondent for BuzzFeed, previously based in China. Her article, This is What a 21st Century Police State Looks Like, was based on reporting from Xinjiang and exile communities in Turkey and it won her a 2018 Human Rights Press Award.
We had a chat about some of the challenges of reporting on Xinjiang and how you balance the responsibility of reporting on what's happening with the fact that doing so can put both you and the people you speak to at great personal risk. I started out by asking how she first got into reporting on Xinjiang. So I came to Beijing to work as a journalist first in 2012 and that was with Reuters and sort of in that capacity as a political correspondent with Reuters. I looked at Xinjiang and all of the issues around it kind of on and off for four or five years.
That encompassed all dimensions of the problems there, everything from human rights to the problems with ethnic unrest, terrorist attacks, government policy, economic policy, all that stuff. And I also had backpacks there as a student so I was pretty familiar with a lot of the issues there and I really had a deep affection for the people who live there because of the time I spent there traveling. And after I joined BuzzFeed, I sort of made it my mind that I wanted to do a piece on kind of the human rights situation there. Around like early 2017, we started to hear that things had really deteriorated considerably and there were sort of signals of that happening.
We had heard from people in the exile world. There were kind of some local media reports and things like that but it's just one of those things where you hear about stuff happening. And I just thought access is so bad in Xinjiang, there's not actually that many journalists who cover regularly. And at that time, it's not like people, a lot of people now are taking trips but at that time it wasn't such a big story so they're really only a handful of people that were pretty interested in it.
So I thought if I don't start to look at this then there might not be that many other people who would be willing to take the time and resources to do it. So that was in early 2017, that was sort of how I got started thinking about the kind of human rights measure of the crisis. And then of course when I went, it just turned out to be a lot worse than I could have ever imagined. It was just like the kind of human rights situation has just like visibly deteriorated like the kind of art-sensitive mass surveillance were just everywhere and you could sort of tell how much pressure people were under there.
Could you maybe talk me through just briefly kind of the history relations between Xinjiang and China and then why it's changed so recently? Yeah, sure. Okay, let me think about how far back we come here. Okay, so Xinjiang is basically this massive region in Western China.
It's the North West of China right on the border of Central Asia. The population is about one half dominant Han Chinese minority. So the Han Chinese are the dominant ethnic group in China and the other half is made up mostly of Turkic Muslims. So and the majority of that group is a group called Uighurs which are a Muslim ethnic minority group, majority Muslim.
And I think there's something between like nine and 11 million of them. And it's basically been a part of the people's republic of China since it's founding. So there's been escalating violence and it's been credited to the growing separatist movement or growing terrorism. Right, right.
Okay, so let me start talking about like kind of like why relations? Why the situation now is so bad. So like basically like the kind of the most recent history of a situation like you can take it back pretty much as far as you want. But like I'll start at kind of 2009.
So in 2009 there were these kinds of waves of ethnic riots and it was really bad. It started in a room she was just the capital of the region of Xinjiang. And you know, hundreds of people were killed. A lot of people of Han ethnicity were killed.
And there's still a lot of anger about that period like you know, both from the government as well as the kind of broader population of Han Chinese not just in Xinjiang but sort of all over China. And in response to that there was this kind of huge crackdown. The government arrested hundreds of people I think almost all Uighur. Those people were punished.
A lot of people were even executed. So after that happened, you know, there's sort of lots of stories about how that kind of first wave of the crackdown, you know, the last decade kind of changed people's lives. Like you know, there were a lot more things like checkpoints, you know, a lot more kind of repressive measures taken on Uighurs to sort of start to monitor their lives and things like that. And then after that you get to kind of the 2013-2014 period where there were basically a wave of knife and bomb attacks that the government has blamed on Uighur militants.
Now the government has basically blamed a lot of these attacks on a group that calls E-Tim or the East Turkestan Islamic Movement. So East Turkestan is the name that some Uighurs will use for the region of Xinjiang. It's sort of their name and it sort of civilizes their hope for an independent state, right? For some of these people.
So E-Tim is not a group that has really been sort of acknowledged by any kind of like independent scholarship. Like people just do not agree on whether this group is kind of like even like a cohesive group like where it's based or even if it even exists in that kind of form. But this notion of E-Tim as like a movement that has sort of like brought up here in Xinjiang it sort of belongs to the Chinese government. Okay so then you get to kind of the most recent history which is starts when Chen Chuan Guo who is basically the party boss of Xinjiang.
He takes power in Xinjiang comes to power as a party boss. I believe in 2016 he had come from Tibet before that which is of course another part of China that has historically been under very heavy repression. So when Chen Chuan Guo arrives in Xinjiang he puts into place sort of a whole bunch of new policies. So when I say that I don't need to apply that he's doing this unilaterally or that he has any sort of autonomy over this.
This is clearly something that has been signed off on and probably you know encouraged. But after Chen Chuan Guo took power that's true is that the situation in Xinjiang sort of deteriorated significantly from a human rights perspective. So one of the things that he did just to give you an example. He implemented this tactic that you could call grid style policing which was previously used in Tibet it was it's been used in other parts of China too.
But the notion is that you divide a city up into a grid and for each square of that grid you're going to have a certain amount of kind of police presence. So it could be you know officers it could be these kinds of like mobile police fans it could be little police kiosks. So I mean the result of that is the kind of density of the police presence is like very very striking. It almost looks like you're you know in an occupied territory or in a war zone or something like that.
So that's sort of been one dimension of the crackdown. The second thing that goes along with that heavy handed human policing is obviously you know the surveillance technology which we can talk about further. And the third thing is the kind of growth of the so-called political education centers or basically camps like re-education camps. And the camps did exist before but under Chen Chuan Guo their use of them has expanded like very very significantly which has been documented by things like procurement records and satellite imagery.
I definitely want to talk about surveillance tech but let's just talk about how we know about the situation. So where is this information about the changes coming from? Yeah so this is a really good question. So just to give you kind of a baseline right so there's lots of human rights crises in the world right now unfortunately just take as an example the drug war in the Philippines.
I'm just using this because I happen to cover it. So you know the issues in the Philippines are that basically you have kind of vigilante groups and police doing extra judicial killings just going out into the streets of Vanilla into like very poor neighborhoods and shooting people with impunity and taking their stuff and that sort of thing right. So if you were a person who was trying to find out information about this crisis right whatever role that you might be in you would have everything from like you would have the journalists that are following the police around you have the police themselves that are releasing statements you would have social media you would have the neighbors that are like coming out and taking pictures and taking videos and putting them up on Facebook. You would have Twitter you would have the president's office you would have human rights lawyers you would have civil society you would have court records like sort of all of these sources of information they come together to kind of create our perspective on this crisis and that's kind of how the modern world works right like the world that we live in where we have access to the internet and sort of expect a certain level of access to the internet for lots of different kinds of people around the world.
So in Xinjiang none of that stuff exists almost none of it and that has been really really hard I think for those of us that are seeking to understand this crisis and not just journalists but people like researchers academics you know activists and people like that. So how do we know what we do know okay so basically there's three sources of information. One is I guess interviews and exile accounts a lot of the stuff now all of it has been compiled by journalists. Exiles they take a tremendous risk in speaking to us and you know we are very very grateful for that they're putting themselves and their families at risk but there are also problems with relying almost exclusively on exiles for one thing it's very difficult to corroborate those accounts without being able to go in yourself you have to sort of find other ways to corroborate them you know and the second thing is it's really hard to leave Xinjiang right now if you're a weaker chances are the government has taken back your passport right so like if you don't have your passport you probably can't leave so that means that a lot of the people that we talk to it's on a delay like there are people that sort of got out earlier before things were really bad or there are people that have gotten out more recently but they sort of have the means to just like give huge huge brides to officials and be able to leave which sort of you know it doesn't say anything negative about their story but it does mean that it's sort of a self-selected population it's a certain kind of population that's not necessarily representative of you know what we are that larger are sort of going through.
The second source of information we have is basically official records so that goes to things like government procurement records hiring records some reports in sort of local state controlled media about about the camps and like where the camps aren't sort of stuff like that and their number of researchers including Adrian Zens in Berlin and Guiding Shan Zhang in Canada who have relied on stuff like this to do interesting research and that kind of stuff was very very useful I think sort of until about the middle of this year and then a lot of research sort of started to come out relying on procurement records and stuff like that and then now I've noticed personally that access to those records has become a little bit more difficult like I used to be able to go to those databases and like kind of look stuff up pretty freely and then now it's like a lot of databases have like new requirements like a require like you know a Chinese based cellphone number or a form of ID which may not necessarily you know you might not be able to use like a foreign ID or a passport. So people have agreed on to it is that what you're saying that people have figured out that's where the information is coming from and tried to look that down? Yeah that's what that's exactly what I'm saying the government has figured out that's where the information is coming and I mean my guess is they've issued some kind of order to lock it down. Yeah and then the third thing just very quickly is satellite data so a lot of people now have used satellite data satellite data is great because no one can censor it right like anyone can look at Google Earth Chinese government has no control over what's on Google Earth the one thing that that's done for our understanding of crisis is it's helped us sort of document historically like the growth of these camps and a lot of kind of journalists and researchers have been doing really great work on that but it sort of it helps you prove beyond a doubt that on this camp system it is new it's growing and if it's growing what does that tell you it tells you probably you know not only is it housing a lot of people but you know because of the nature of the growth because these buildings are sort of permanent very sturdy kind of facilities and not sort of tent camps or anything like that it tells you that they have plans to keep putting people in and this issue is not going away anytime soon.
How has what you've seen from you know exile accounts and the satellite data in these records how is that contrasted to what you've been hearing from the state media. So, Seyenia, this is a really interesting question. So basically until August of this year, Seyenia really hadn't said much of anything. So what happened in August of this year?
Basically the UN Commission on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination held a hearing and this was a previously scheduled hearing that they hold for lots of countries not just China and they this time it was for China and to everyone's surprise this committee basically led to some very very sharp criticism at the Chinese government particularly over the Uyur issue. They also raised this number of upwards of a million people being held in these internment camps and that unsurprisingly led to a lot of headlines. It led to like governments, Western governments taking notice. It's sort of in my opinion it sort of lent some kind of credibility and authority to the kind of research on this issue that I think individual journalists and individual academics had sort of been unable to do and I think as a direct result of that panel, Chinese state media sort of came up with this sort of propaganda push and you know it started out by saying well no this isn't happening at all right.
You guys all have this wrong and then now it's sort of morphed into yes you guys still have it wrong but even if you were right this is really for their benefit and these are education centers, they're not concentration camps and basically it's sort of a full-throated defense of the policies there. So does that contrast with the research? I mean sort of in that they're saying that it's not happening at the scale that it's happening and I think the research based on satellite imagery and other sources and certainly based on the witness accounts suggest quite the opposite. Yeah and what about you reporting it as a journalist?
So what are some of the ways that I mean you mentioned earlier that there was like access issues to going to Xinjiang so were you able to actually go there and see any of this? Yeah so Xinjiang is not a place where you need a permit to go as a journalist. There are other parts of China that are like that like Tibet but with Xinjiang you can just fly in you can take the trains and buses and you can drive and whatever you want. But the issue there is that once you get there for the most part if you're a journalist you're probably going to be met by police officers and then followed around by them.
So the result of this is probably not to intimidate you as a foreign journalist but to you know intimidate anybody who wants to cooperate and I should clarify like when I'm speaking about the issues for journalists there I'm talking only about foreign journalists. If you're a local journalist you're probably you're not going to cover this issue at all because first of all there's no incentive for you to do it and like second of all if you try you know the kind of heavy arm of the censorship apparatus would come down to bear upon you. So you know for that reason I'm not even going to discuss kind of what they face up against. But I think for us as foreign journalists because of this kind of issue of being followed and also being detained for several hours which is sort of meant to prevent you from doing your job it really hurts your ability to just go and talk to people there.
Even kind of pre-arranged meetings are difficult if you're being followed certainly like talking to people on the street like ordinary people becomes very very difficult. For me personally I did go. I went it's actually been a while now like because I left China in March but I went a few months before that so I had gone in kind of late fall 2017. I was detained very very briefly I was met by police officers at my hotel but they at that time this wasn't a huge news story you know there weren't a lot of people really talking about it.
Basically they didn't really view me as that much of a threat is my assessment. You know I also don't I don't work for like the New York Times, the Western Journal or CNN which is probably what they perceive as being really threatening. I worked for BuzzFeed so I think probably for some of those reasons they chose not to follow me around. I also you know we also have like little tips and techniques to get around some of the access problems like you know you check in your hotel very late at night you leave super early in the morning so like I think the next morning I left at 4am and just try to walk around for the rest of the day to avoid getting picked up by the police.
Yeah. How do you navigate that the ethics of that like you said that a lot of the parade of being followed by police is mostly to intimidate people who might cooperate with you. So how do you navigate that knowing that you're there to speak to people but doing so puts them at risk. Okay so I'll explain what I did and then I'll talk about some of the broader perspectives on ethics.
So for me like you know at the time that I did that story like I think immediately before like we had heard stories about people who had gone in kind of earlier that year and worked with people like fixers and drivers and stuff and those people had been sent away to camps and at that time we were calling them like re-education centers if we didn't really know what they were I don't think to the extent that we do now and I just remember thinking like I don't want this to happen like I have to avoid this happening and then you know absolutely no blame on the journalists that happened to because I mean there's no way that they could have known that things had gotten that bad because that was sort of very early on but I did know so I sort of came up with this methodology that I was going to go to Turkey first talk to exiles and do sort of the majority of like the substantive interviewing with exiles and then kind of come back and try to corroborate their stories in Xinjiang. So that's sort of what I did. It was honestly still really difficult talking to exiles because one of the things the government does is they punish the families of people that have gone abroad they'll send them to camps or levy other kinds of punishments on them. So of course nobody wants that so I think even people who are abroad at that time were very very reluctant to talk to foreign journalists or really anybody.
But I did manage to do it. I got a bunch of information including I think the location of one of the camps that I wanted to visit you know a bunch of other kind of information from personal stories that I wanted to kind of go to the settings of and try to corroborate when I was in Xinjiang. So then after that I went to Xinjiang and I spent most of that trip looking at kind of different aspects of the kind of mass surveillance architecture and I did talk to a few people but the conversations I had were pretty superficial like when I actually went to visit that camp that I had gotten the location of you know I tried to talk to some people in the area but the thing is like it's very clear like when people see that you are a foreigner they like Uyghurs they really want to talk to you because they want you to know what's going on but they're afraid. So like for instance I was in the small business that was sort of in the vicinity of the camp and I was like trying to talk to the owner and I ended up spending like 30 minutes just sitting there like talking about nothing and then he was like okay let me like walk you out and like I'll give you directions the next place you're going and that was sort of his way of saying like let's go out in the open and talk for like a few minutes you know rather than talk in my place of work which he thought I think he thought was being eavesdropped on.
So you sort of take measures like that. I was not being followed I should know at that time but kind of on the broader ethical issues I mean this is a really hard question because if you take the most precautions if you're only priorities to keep people safe you can't get the information out like that's just reality right and I think it's that kind of thinking that's led other reporters to go to Xinjiang and then talk to people and they'll name the sources in the story and you know sometimes I'll read their stories and be like well what happened to that person like you know if that person appeared in like this very heavily circulated article like aren't they going to get blowback but I mean there's a notion of consent every general sort of makes this decision for themselves like you know do you believe that this person is genuinely consenting to being interviewed and you know put in a kind of American media publication do they know what that means do they know you know what that's what's going to happen to them if that happens right. Can I ask have there been occasions where you've been talking to a source and realized that they're not kind of meeting that requirement that you like maybe they're not consenting they don't understand the scope. Yeah oh my god all the time all the time and that happens in China quite a lot because of the Great Firewall so people in China don't first of all most people don't speak English and second of all even if they did speak English they can't access international media so if you have never read international media how could you possibly know what it means to be quoted in international media.
You don't know like if your local police chief is going to be made aware of that and then end up detaining you like you don't know if you're an SL you don't know if it's going to have blowback on your family necessarily if you're not that familiar with it like I mean I'm a person that airs on the side of caution I tend towards just protecting sources and kind of you know giving up things like real name attribution and stuff like that there are some people that lean the other way and I think they're kind of I don't want to speak for them but they're rationale for that is like the most important thing is like this bigger picture of just getting the story out so like to me like I would rather have a story out but then not name the source even if it's sort of weak in the story because I just feel like it has to be you know harm you know I don't even want to get into a situation where it's even possible that somebody could be arrested like that yeah yeah do you think do you think that foreign journalists reporting on Xinjiang are being dissuaded is there other ways that the state's encouraging silence on this issue for foreign journalists as well as as journalists in China. Absolutely absolutely um so like think about this from I mean it's not all somebody calls you into a dark room and tells you you better shut up about this like I mean there's some of that but it's actually a little bit more I would say it's more insidious than that um you know so think about okay the news industry is not doing well right now okay like budgets are being slashed across the board and if you are going to a place like Xinjiang to report think about the value proposition that you have to give your editor for that okay like first of all it's expensive to get there like the flights are not cheap second of all once you get there you might not even be able to do any work because somebody might be following you you can't necessarily talk to anyone like I have friends that have taken trips to Xinjiang and been so afraid of getting someone into trouble they brought that very very little and that can happen so like would you rather if your journalist who has to cover all of China this huge country this complex country of billion plus people are you going to go to a place where you don't even know if you're going to be able to work or are you going to go somewhere where you know you can achieve a story and bring back something that's going to make your editor happy probably the latter right so that's less true now than it was before just because of the snowball effect and like Xinjiang the issues in Xinjiang have become like this big story that like nobody can ignore but you know even then like if you read closely a lot of the coverage a lot of it has been date lines and places other than China right there's been a lot of good reporting on a Kazakhstan there's been stuff in Turkey um you know there's a reason for that it's because like access in Xinjiang is really bad so that's like one way that they dissuade us the second thing is kind of the standard techniques that they use to dissuade everyone for doing any reporting that they don't like which is basically pressure on the business sides of news organizations and pressure on visas yeah because out is era right closed down their bureau in China that was um that was uh almost ten years ago now let me say seven years from like I have to go back and look but yeah that's right and you you're not reporting in China anymore I'm not I left in March on the garment decline to decline to renew my visa but we're not very we're not clear on the reasoning behind that um I will say like I so when I was in China I was on the board of the foreign correspondence club and um just because I was in that role I was pretty a lot of um the problems that different correspondents are we're having um you know with things like visas and stuff like that and um you know it's a very common experience to get detained in Xinjiang first of all as I've mentioned and then a lot of people also got blowback for coverage that's usually called in colloquial Chinese like being taken out to tea so they'll ask you to go out to tea and um they'll be like well you did a very bad thing you shouldn't have you shouldn't have written this or that so I mean that kind of stuff happens too I actually don't necessarily think that doing that really dissuades anyone from doing anything just because I mean it's a bit of a it's uncomfortable but surely for a journalist you would be thinking okay I must be reporting on the right thing then I think probably yeah probably a lot of people would think about it that way but I mean I think the bigger issues are things like um just like economic pressure and visas yeah yeah and look I you've said you don't want to speculate um other media organizations have speculated on your behalf that it might have had something to do with how high-profile your reports into Xinjiang were so are you still reporting on what's happening now? Yeah I'm certainly trying to I mean I have a couple of stories um sort of in the works although I think they will probably take a while to come out um just because of the there's there's still sort of work to be done on them but um I do think that this is an example of a story where you can garner a certain amount of information without being there obviously it would be better to be there as a journalist but between things like satellite records and um to the exile community which has become you know just a lot more willing to talk to journalists unfortunately I think there's a lot of work that can still be done on it and like I to be honest I've gotten kind of just really emotionally linked to the story like I think once you spend that much time on it it's really impossible not to feel pretty acutely about it and it's not really something that I want to stop reporting on at the end of the day there aren't that many foreign correspondents in the world anymore and that includes China there's not that many right I mean and the ones that are are covering again the whole country so I do think that there's a certain certain amount of responsibility on those of us who have reported on it and you know for those to keep following this issue just because at least to the current date it's not gotten any better and I think it's gonna keep being a pretty urgent thing. That was BuzzFeed World Correspondent Megha Rajakulan talking about what it's like to report on the human rights crisis in Xinjiang from under the dorm of Chinese surveillance and that is all for Fourth Estate this week.
Don't forget to subscribe to our podcast to keep up to date with the latest episodes and while you're there leave us a review. It's one way that you can support both us and community radio at the same time. We'll be back next week with a new episode. In the meantime I'm Shane Anderson thank you for listening.
A safer Ontario means more police than prosecutors making sure my card doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.
That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us. Learn how at ontario.ca. Pay for it by the Government of Ontario.